Elena Ayala-Hurtado
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Elena Ayala-Hurtado has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Christina Ciocca Eller
Harvard University, Cambridge, MA, USA
1 shared publication - Derek Robey
Syracuse University
1 shared publication - Laura Adler
Yale School of Management
1 shared publication - Mari Sanchez
PhD candidate in sociology at Harvard University, United States
1 shared publication - Shira Zilberstein
Duke Institute for Health Innovation, Durham, USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 21 February 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociology of Education
- Vol. 99 (2) , 174-194
“Who Is Anybody to Judge?” Educational Resistance through Recognition
The United States is a “schooled society”: one where formal education is viewed as a primary conduit between American cultural ideals and people's moral worth and social value. Sociologists of education have described resistance against this dominant model through disinvestment from school, particularly among some students from traditionally underrepresented backgrounds. Yet it remains unclear if “school-invested” students also enact resistance and if so, what such resistance entails and means for educational and social inequality. Bringing together the literatures on recognition and educational resistance, we argue that recognition of stigmatized educational groups by school-invested students may serve as an important form of educational resistance. We build this argument by drawing on unique multiwave interview data (n = 168) to investigate college students’ perceptions of college dropouts. We find that although a minority of respondents discursively deploy stigmatizing frames when describing dropouts, more draw on recognition frames to bridge moral and symbolic gaps between college students and particular dropouts. We also find that certain college experiences, particularly exposure to peers with complicated college trajectories, appear to change students’ narratives on dropout over time. We consider the implications of recognition-based resistance and the associated opportunities and limitations concerning inequality.
- 21 February 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociology of Education
- Vol. 99 (2) , 174-194
“Who Is Anybody to Judge?” Educational Resistance through Recognition
The United States is a “schooled society”: one where formal education is viewed as a primary conduit between American cultural ideals and people's moral worth and social value. Sociologists of education have described resistance against this dominant model through disinvestment from school, particularly among some students from traditionally underrepresented backgrounds. Yet it remains unclear if “school-invested” students also enact resistance and if so, what such resistance entails and means for educational and social inequality. Bringing together the literatures on recognition and educational resistance, we argue that recognition of stigmatized educational groups by school-invested students may serve as an important form of educational resistance. We build this argument by drawing on unique multiwave interview data (n = 168) to investigate college students’ perceptions of college dropouts. We find that although a minority of respondents discursively deploy stigmatizing frames when describing dropouts, more draw on recognition frames to bridge moral and symbolic gaps between college students and particular dropouts. We also find that certain college experiences, particularly exposure to peers with complicated college trajectories, appear to change students’ narratives on dropout over time. We consider the implications of recognition-based resistance and the associated opportunities and limitations concerning inequality.
- 26 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Work and Occupations
- Vol. 53 (2) , 343-388
Qualities and Configurations of Insecurity in the United States and Spain
In recent decades, socioeconomic insecurity—encompassing employment precarity and economic instability—has become increasingly widespread. However, insecurity manifests differently across contexts. How do people interpret the insecurity in their own contexts? Drawing on 164 crossnational interviews with young college graduates, most facing insecurity, in the U.S. and Spain, I find that respondents in each national context perceive insecurity as having starkly different qualities. While Spanish respondents perceive insecurity as narrow, unambiguous, and transitory, American respondents perceive it as broad, ambiguous, and recurrent. I develop a framework that illuminates, first, how these perceived qualities of insecurity are underpinned by people's understandings of the structural conditions of insecurity in each context— or “configurations of insecurity”— and second, the consequences of these perceptions. This study examines the meanings ascribed to structural conditions of insecurity, reveals the multidimensionality of perceived insecurity, and develops a framework that elucidates the sources and consequences of those perceptions.
- 26 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Work and Occupations
- Vol. 53 (2) , 343-388
Qualities and Configurations of Insecurity in the United States and Spain
In recent decades, socioeconomic insecurity—encompassing employment precarity and economic instability—has become increasingly widespread. However, insecurity manifests differently across contexts. How do people interpret the insecurity in their own contexts? Drawing on 164 crossnational interviews with young college graduates, most facing insecurity, in the U.S. and Spain, I find that respondents in each national context perceive insecurity as having starkly different qualities. While Spanish respondents perceive insecurity as narrow, unambiguous, and transitory, American respondents perceive it as broad, ambiguous, and recurrent. I develop a framework that illuminates, first, how these perceived qualities of insecurity are underpinned by people's understandings of the structural conditions of insecurity in each context— or “configurations of insecurity”— and second, the consequences of these perceptions. This study examines the meanings ascribed to structural conditions of insecurity, reveals the multidimensionality of perceived insecurity, and develops a framework that elucidates the sources and consequences of those perceptions.
- Open Access
- 24 February 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Administrative Science Quarterly
- Vol. 70 (2) , 496-537
A Little Help from My Friends? Navigating the Tension Between Social Capital and Meritocracy in the Job Search
Job seekers often rely on help from social ties in the search for employment. Yet the job search is characterized by meritocratic ideals according to which candidates should be selected based on their qualifications, not their connections. How do people justify the use of connections given the conflicting cultural logics of social capital and meritocracy? We conduct an inductive analysis of 56 interviews with young Spaniards experiencing a difficult labor market and identify a novel process of justification, situational alignment, that reconciles these conflicting logics. Respondents justified situations in which connections provided assistance as legitimate when they perceived alignment among the job seeker, job, and type of help that connections provided. Respondents deemed illegitimate the situations in which these were not aligned. These justifications allowed respondents to embrace the social capital logic’s prescription to use connections, while upholding the meritocratic principle that jobs be awarded based on qualifications. We further find that situations involving close ties were more readily justified than those involving distant others. We test this inductively derived process using a survey experiment with 1,536 young Spaniards. This study demonstrates that perceptions of merit are situated, and advances the understanding of social capital by identifying a novel process of justification that contributes to labor market inequality.
- 24 February 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Administrative Science Quarterly
- Vol. 70 (2) , 496-537
Open AccessA Little Help from My Friends? Navigating the Tension Between Social Capital and Meritocracy in the Job Search
Job seekers often rely on help from social ties in the search for employment. Yet the job search is characterized by meritocratic ideals according to which candidates should be selected based on their qualifications, not their connections. How do people justify the use of connections given the conflicting cultural logics of social capital and meritocracy? We conduct an inductive analysis of 56 interviews with young Spaniards experiencing a difficult labor market and identify a novel process of justification, situational alignment, that reconciles these conflicting logics. Respondents justified situations in which connections provided assistance as legitimate when they perceived alignment among the job seeker, job, and type of help that connections provided. Respondents deemed illegitimate the situations in which these were not aligned. These justifications allowed respondents to embrace the social capital logic’s prescription to use connections, while upholding the meritocratic principle that jobs be awarded based on qualifications. We further find that situations involving close ties were more readily justified than those involving distant others. We test this inductively derived process using a survey experiment with 1,536 young Spaniards. This study demonstrates that perceptions of merit are situated, and advances the understanding of social capital by identifying a novel process of justification that contributes to labor market inequality.
- 10 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociology of Education
- Vol. 98 (1) , 27-43
The Expectational Liminality of Insecure College Graduates
Graduating from college is widely associated with social and personal advancement, yet many young graduates are not experiencing these benefits. Drawing on 127 interviews with college graduates in the United States and Spain who face employment precarity or economic instability, this study asks: How do these graduates understand their social positions and worth? How does the institution of higher education shape these understandings? The data demonstrate that respondents in both countries largely describe themselves as stalled or stuck. I argue that these are perceptions of “expectational liminality” stemming from the disjuncture between respondents’ expectations and their experiences as college graduates. In addition, I show how three narratives describing the professional/financial success, life course progression, and internal transformation expected of graduates shape respondents’ sense of expectational liminality. I discuss the effects of higher education on graduates’ self-perceptions in uncertain contexts and the relevance of expectational liminality to other contexts where there are disjunctures between expectations and reality.
- 10 November 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Sociology of Education
- Vol. 98 (1) , 27-43
The Expectational Liminality of Insecure College Graduates
Graduating from college is widely associated with social and personal advancement, yet many young graduates are not experiencing these benefits. Drawing on 127 interviews with college graduates in the United States and Spain who face employment precarity or economic instability, this study asks: How do these graduates understand their social positions and worth? How does the institution of higher education shape these understandings? The data demonstrate that respondents in both countries largely describe themselves as stalled or stuck. I argue that these are perceptions of “expectational liminality” stemming from the disjuncture between respondents’ expectations and their experiences as college graduates. In addition, I show how three narratives describing the professional/financial success, life course progression, and internal transformation expected of graduates shape respondents’ sense of expectational liminality. I discuss the effects of higher education on graduates’ self-perceptions in uncertain contexts and the relevance of expectational liminality to other contexts where there are disjunctures between expectations and reality.
- Open Access
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Russell Sage Foundation in RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences
- Vol. 10 (5) , 118-140
The Self in Action: Narrating Agentic Moments
This article develops a cultural and contextual approach to studying agency that attends to variation in how people narrate their experiences. Drawing on the large-scale, nationally representative American Voices Project data, the article uses computational methods to test patterns in agentic expression and qualitative methods to examine how respondents narrate agency and passivity as they describe their lives. This analysis captures agentic moments, widespread narratives through which people emphasize their agentic selfhood as they recount specific situations. Moreover, individuals use narrative moves—such as shifting their focus and drawing on subtypes of agency—to craft agentic moments despite constraints. We argue that narratives of agency are variable, situational, and often co-occurring with narrative passivity, which enables people to narrate themselves as agentic even in challenging situations.
- 20 August 2024
- Published by Russell Sage Foundation in RSF: The Russell Sage Foundation Journal of the Social Sciences
- Vol. 10 (5) , 118-140
Open AccessThe Self in Action: Narrating Agentic Moments
This article develops a cultural and contextual approach to studying agency that attends to variation in how people narrate their experiences. Drawing on the large-scale, nationally representative American Voices Project data, the article uses computational methods to test patterns in agentic expression and qualitative methods to examine how respondents narrate agency and passivity as they describe their lives. This analysis captures agentic moments, widespread narratives through which people emphasize their agentic selfhood as they recount specific situations. Moreover, individuals use narrative moves—such as shifting their focus and drawing on subtypes of agency—to craft agentic moments despite constraints. We argue that narratives of agency are variable, situational, and often co-occurring with narrative passivity, which enables people to narrate themselves as agentic even in challenging situations.
- 30 June 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Work and Occupations
- Vol. 49 (1) , 45-78
Narrative Continuity/Rupture: Projected Professional Futures amid Pervasive Employment Precarity
As working conditions change worldwide, employment precarity is increasing, including for groups for whom such conditions are unexpected. This study investigates how members of one such group—educationally advantaged young adults—describe their professional futures in a context of unprecedented employment precarity where their expected trajectories are no longer easily achievable. Using 75 interviews with young university graduates in Madrid, Spain, I find that most young graduates drew on a long-standing cultural narrative, which I call the “achievement narrative,” to imagine future stable employment. Simultaneously, most denounced this narrative as fraudulent. To explain this finding, I draw on the concept of hysteresis: the mismatch between beliefs that are dependent on the past conditions that produced them and the available opportunities in the present. I argue that hysteresis can extend into future projections; projected futures can be guided by beliefs based on past conditions more than by lived experiences in the present. Further, I argue that the achievement narrative itself reinforces hysteresis in future projections due to its resonance and institutional support. The paper offers new insights into projected futures and employment precarity by analyzing the future projections of a privileged cohort facing unexpected precarity, further develops the concept of hysteresis, and extends the study of cultural narratives.
- 30 June 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Work and Occupations
- Vol. 49 (1) , 45-78
Narrative Continuity/Rupture: Projected Professional Futures amid Pervasive Employment Precarity
As working conditions change worldwide, employment precarity is increasing, including for groups for whom such conditions are unexpected. This study investigates how members of one such group—educationally advantaged young adults—describe their professional futures in a context of unprecedented employment precarity where their expected trajectories are no longer easily achievable. Using 75 interviews with young university graduates in Madrid, Spain, I find that most young graduates drew on a long-standing cultural narrative, which I call the “achievement narrative,” to imagine future stable employment. Simultaneously, most denounced this narrative as fraudulent. To explain this finding, I draw on the concept of hysteresis: the mismatch between beliefs that are dependent on the past conditions that produced them and the available opportunities in the present. I argue that hysteresis can extend into future projections; projected futures can be guided by beliefs based on past conditions more than by lived experiences in the present. Further, I argue that the achievement narrative itself reinforces hysteresis in future projections due to its resonance and institutional support. The paper offers new insights into projected futures and employment precarity by analyzing the future projections of a privileged cohort facing unexpected precarity, further develops the concept of hysteresis, and extends the study of cultural narratives.