Mary Alison Durand
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Mary Alison Durand has a total of 49 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nicholas Mays
Department of Health Services Research and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London WC1H 9SH, UK
12 shared publications Gerald Wistow
Care Policy and Evaluation Centre, London School of Economics, London, UK
7 shared publications- Agata Pacho
Policy Innovation and Evaluation Research Unit, Department of Health Services Research and Policy, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK
5 shared publications - Lavanya Thana
Department of Health Service Research and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK
5 shared publications - Mustafa Al-Haboubi
Department of Health Services Research and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK
5 shared publications Nick Douglas
Research Fellow, Policy Innovation and Evaluation Research Unit (PIRU), Department of Health Services Research and Policy, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 58-68
The impact and legacy of COVID-19 on community-based multidisciplinary teams organising integrated health and social care for older people with long-term conditions: Findings from the evaluation of the integrated care and support Pioneers
Objectives: The COVID-19 pandemic severely disrupted health and social care (HSC) services in many countries, including England. At the same time, it forced systems to respond innovatively to radically changed circumstances and challenges. This study identifies the impacts and emerging legacy of the pandemic for community-based multidisciplinary teams (MDTs) supporting older people with multiple long-term conditions living in their own homes. Methods: Thirty-eight strategic, operational, and frontline staff involved with MDTs in seven areas in England were interviewed between July 2020 and August 2021, as part of a wider evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers programme. Interview transcripts were analysed thematically. Results: Interviewees described an initial period of pandemic disruption characterised by uncertainty, shifting of priorities and resources within the HSC system towards emergency care, and redeployment of staff away from MDTs. These circumstances required the development of new ways of working with MDT patients/clients and with one another. Remote, mostly virtual, MDT working between professionals was seen by most as a positive adaptation, though some felt that in-person meetings were better for the development of working relationships. Others raised concerns about access to, and quality of, care provided to vulnerable patients remotely, or in person but with a delay. At the local system level, the crisis response lowered barriers to collaboration between organisations, blurred professional roles, increased flexibility in the use of resources, and engendered a stronger sense of local cohesion among a wide range of staff in HSC. Most respondents wished to retain these attributes of the local system permanently. Conclusions: The pandemic’s legacy seemed to accelerate innovations in health and care provision and increased cohesion and closer working relationships. Remote ways of working were perceived to have improved the efficiency of MDT meetings and facilitated involvement of professionals external to MDTs. The implications for patient/client care were more complex. We suggest that the potential impact on inequalities of remote access to, and provision of, care for people served by MDTs will need to be considered if these changes are to be maintained. The resilience of MDTs and the HSC system may be improved by upskilling staff and creating a more flexible workforce capable of working across organisations during future crises.
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 58-68
Open AccessThe impact and legacy of COVID-19 on community-based multidisciplinary teams organising integrated health and social care for older people with long-term conditions: Findings from the evaluation of the integrated care and support Pioneers
Objectives: The COVID-19 pandemic severely disrupted health and social care (HSC) services in many countries, including England. At the same time, it forced systems to respond innovatively to radically changed circumstances and challenges. This study identifies the impacts and emerging legacy of the pandemic for community-based multidisciplinary teams (MDTs) supporting older people with multiple long-term conditions living in their own homes. Methods: Thirty-eight strategic, operational, and frontline staff involved with MDTs in seven areas in England were interviewed between July 2020 and August 2021, as part of a wider evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers programme. Interview transcripts were analysed thematically. Results: Interviewees described an initial period of pandemic disruption characterised by uncertainty, shifting of priorities and resources within the HSC system towards emergency care, and redeployment of staff away from MDTs. These circumstances required the development of new ways of working with MDT patients/clients and with one another. Remote, mostly virtual, MDT working between professionals was seen by most as a positive adaptation, though some felt that in-person meetings were better for the development of working relationships. Others raised concerns about access to, and quality of, care provided to vulnerable patients remotely, or in person but with a delay. At the local system level, the crisis response lowered barriers to collaboration between organisations, blurred professional roles, increased flexibility in the use of resources, and engendered a stronger sense of local cohesion among a wide range of staff in HSC. Most respondents wished to retain these attributes of the local system permanently. Conclusions: The pandemic’s legacy seemed to accelerate innovations in health and care provision and increased cohesion and closer working relationships. Remote ways of working were perceived to have improved the efficiency of MDT meetings and facilitated involvement of professionals external to MDTs. The implications for patient/client care were more complex. We suggest that the potential impact on inequalities of remote access to, and provision of, care for people served by MDTs will need to be considered if these changes are to be maintained. The resilience of MDTs and the HSC system may be improved by upskilling staff and creating a more flexible workforce capable of working across organisations during future crises.
- Open Access
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 36-47
Frontline staff perspectives on multi-disciplinary team working and the effectiveness of integrated service delivery: Findings from the evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers in England
Objectives: Horizontal integration of health and social care in England is frequently supported by multi-disciplinary (MDT) case management focused on high-risk older people with multiple chronic conditions living in the community. This paper analyses MDT working in two of the 25 areas participating in the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme in England. The analysis aims to understand the experience of frontline staff in such MDTs of working with professionals and staff from multiple sectors, and their perceptions of their roles and the benefits of integrated working. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with a purposive sample of 54 frontline staff from a range of professional backgrounds working in 11 community-based MDTs in two Integrated Care and Support Pioneers. A largely inductively developed coding frame was used to thematically code and guide analysis of verbatim interview transcripts from audio recordings. Findings: Staff conceptualised the team as a cohesive yet ‘porous’ entity, able to evolve a shared sense of purpose to deliver holistic care that helped to level traditional professional hierarchies, enable collective problem-solving and share responsibility for patient care. MDT working was seen as benefiting staff and patients. Despite strong similarities between the MDTs in members’ understandings of the role and purpose of a MDT, each MDT was adapted to its context and the needs of the population served. The process of working through inter-professional tensions seemed to strengthen relationships within the team and enhance its ability to work effectively in the local health and care system. However, without performance or outcome measures, these perceptions were driven by ‘soft’ intelligence alone. Conclusions: Frontline staff accounts of MDT working demonstrate their strong commitment to this way of working, as a mechanism enabling them to deliver more holistic care with perceived benefits to patients.
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 36-47
Open AccessFrontline staff perspectives on multi-disciplinary team working and the effectiveness of integrated service delivery: Findings from the evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers in England
Objectives: Horizontal integration of health and social care in England is frequently supported by multi-disciplinary (MDT) case management focused on high-risk older people with multiple chronic conditions living in the community. This paper analyses MDT working in two of the 25 areas participating in the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme in England. The analysis aims to understand the experience of frontline staff in such MDTs of working with professionals and staff from multiple sectors, and their perceptions of their roles and the benefits of integrated working. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with a purposive sample of 54 frontline staff from a range of professional backgrounds working in 11 community-based MDTs in two Integrated Care and Support Pioneers. A largely inductively developed coding frame was used to thematically code and guide analysis of verbatim interview transcripts from audio recordings. Findings: Staff conceptualised the team as a cohesive yet ‘porous’ entity, able to evolve a shared sense of purpose to deliver holistic care that helped to level traditional professional hierarchies, enable collective problem-solving and share responsibility for patient care. MDT working was seen as benefiting staff and patients. Despite strong similarities between the MDTs in members’ understandings of the role and purpose of a MDT, each MDT was adapted to its context and the needs of the population served. The process of working through inter-professional tensions seemed to strengthen relationships within the team and enhance its ability to work effectively in the local health and care system. However, without performance or outcome measures, these perceptions were driven by ‘soft’ intelligence alone. Conclusions: Frontline staff accounts of MDT working demonstrate their strong commitment to this way of working, as a mechanism enabling them to deliver more holistic care with perceived benefits to patients.
- Open Access
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 69-81
Evaluating the role of community-based multi-disciplinary teams in integrated health and social care in England: Overview of findings from the Pioneer evaluation and their implications for health and social care integration
Objectives: This paper synthesises the findings of an evaluation of community-based multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs), primarily serving older people with long-term conditions, undertaken as part of a wider evaluation (2015–2022) of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme (2013–2018) in England. The MDT evaluation was undertaken in two contrasting Pioneers with 11 MDTs covering four models of MDT functioning. Methods: The synthesis, set against our conceptual framework of MDT functioning, draws principally on the findings of semi-structured interviews with local strategic level health and care leaders, frontline MDT staff, and patients and their informal carers, observations of MDT meetings, and an online survey of MDT staff. Results: MDTs were seen as an essential means of working towards local health and care integration. While local contexts shaped the precise aims, structure, composition and ways of working of the different MDT models studied, there were strong similarities across the teams in how staff viewed the nature and benefits of MDT working. MDTs were perceived as having the potential to provide more holistic care to patients, speed up access to care, improve access to a wider range of services and enhance care at home. Benefits to staff included better information sharing; reduced duplication of tasks; enhanced collective responsibility and problem-solving, which enriched decision-making; opportunities to learn from, and about, the remits of other professional groups and services; and the erosion of traditional professional hierarchies. However, barriers to MDT working, including the absence of shared patient records, inadequate infrastructure and resources, and concerns about the ability to measure and demonstrate the value of MDT working, were also identified. Patients and their informal carers reported valuing good communication with their health and care providers but often appeared unaware of an MDT’s involvement in planning their care. This suggests there is some distance to travel in terms of how MDTs communicate their roles to those they serve. Conclusions: At the service delivery level, our findings’ implications for policy and practice include the need for greater integration across patient records and data systems, and greater investment in specialist services (e.g., housing) currently absent from MDTs. However, our research also highlighted challenges to evaluating the outcomes of ‘integration’ both as a concept and at the service delivery level. Changes to both the research environment and the approach to evaluation are also warranted.
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 69-81
Open AccessEvaluating the role of community-based multi-disciplinary teams in integrated health and social care in England: Overview of findings from the Pioneer evaluation and their implications for health and social care integration
Objectives: This paper synthesises the findings of an evaluation of community-based multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs), primarily serving older people with long-term conditions, undertaken as part of a wider evaluation (2015–2022) of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme (2013–2018) in England. The MDT evaluation was undertaken in two contrasting Pioneers with 11 MDTs covering four models of MDT functioning. Methods: The synthesis, set against our conceptual framework of MDT functioning, draws principally on the findings of semi-structured interviews with local strategic level health and care leaders, frontline MDT staff, and patients and their informal carers, observations of MDT meetings, and an online survey of MDT staff. Results: MDTs were seen as an essential means of working towards local health and care integration. While local contexts shaped the precise aims, structure, composition and ways of working of the different MDT models studied, there were strong similarities across the teams in how staff viewed the nature and benefits of MDT working. MDTs were perceived as having the potential to provide more holistic care to patients, speed up access to care, improve access to a wider range of services and enhance care at home. Benefits to staff included better information sharing; reduced duplication of tasks; enhanced collective responsibility and problem-solving, which enriched decision-making; opportunities to learn from, and about, the remits of other professional groups and services; and the erosion of traditional professional hierarchies. However, barriers to MDT working, including the absence of shared patient records, inadequate infrastructure and resources, and concerns about the ability to measure and demonstrate the value of MDT working, were also identified. Patients and their informal carers reported valuing good communication with their health and care providers but often appeared unaware of an MDT’s involvement in planning their care. This suggests there is some distance to travel in terms of how MDTs communicate their roles to those they serve. Conclusions: At the service delivery level, our findings’ implications for policy and practice include the need for greater integration across patient records and data systems, and greater investment in specialist services (e.g., housing) currently absent from MDTs. However, our research also highlighted challenges to evaluating the outcomes of ‘integration’ both as a concept and at the service delivery level. Changes to both the research environment and the approach to evaluation are also warranted.
- Open Access
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 48-57
The views of older people on community-based multi-disciplinary team caseloads and informal carers about health and care services in two Integrated Care Pioneer sites in England
Objectives: Community-based multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs) were among the most widely reported health and care integration initiatives in the Integrated Care Pioneers in England. Such MDTs bring together staff from different sectors to co-ordinate and plan care for patients, who are often older, have multiple long-term conditions and risk hospital admission. As part of our evaluation of MDTs in two contrasting Pioneers, we explored MDT patients’ and informal carers’ perspectives on health and care services. As the COVID-19 pandemic started during data collection, we also wanted to understand its impact on patients’ access to services. Methods: We conducted qualitative interviews with 44 patients aged 60 or over, with long-term conditions, and on the caseload of one of 11 participating MDTs. We also undertook qualitative interviews with 15 carers. Interviews took place between November 2019 and March 2021. Interview transcripts were coded in NVivo-12 and analysed thematically. Results: In addition to formal services, patients often relied on informal care. Valued aspects of care included equipment and home modifications that supported independence, timely access to and continuity in care, effective information-sharing, professionals who made them feel that their needs mattered, and having a named contact. Where challenges were experienced (e.g. with accessing professionals, communication, and care quality), patients and carers sometimes felt abandoned. While some patients mentioned being on an MDT caseload, few reported having a care plan. The impacts of caring on informal carers were sometimes considerable. COVID-19 affected patient and carer wellbeing, but the new ways of accessing care generated by the pandemic were valued by some participants. Conclusions: As long as challenges remain, patients and carers are unlikely to perceive care as joined-up and patient-centred. If truly integrated and holistic care is to be provided, barriers (such as the lack of shared patient records) must be addressed. Even where MDTs function primarily to co-ordinate rather than deliver care, they could better communicate their co-ordinating role, and MDT discussion outcomes, including care decisions, to patients. Informal carers’ needs also require greater attention by MDTs.
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 48-57
Open AccessThe views of older people on community-based multi-disciplinary team caseloads and informal carers about health and care services in two Integrated Care Pioneer sites in England
Objectives: Community-based multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs) were among the most widely reported health and care integration initiatives in the Integrated Care Pioneers in England. Such MDTs bring together staff from different sectors to co-ordinate and plan care for patients, who are often older, have multiple long-term conditions and risk hospital admission. As part of our evaluation of MDTs in two contrasting Pioneers, we explored MDT patients’ and informal carers’ perspectives on health and care services. As the COVID-19 pandemic started during data collection, we also wanted to understand its impact on patients’ access to services. Methods: We conducted qualitative interviews with 44 patients aged 60 or over, with long-term conditions, and on the caseload of one of 11 participating MDTs. We also undertook qualitative interviews with 15 carers. Interviews took place between November 2019 and March 2021. Interview transcripts were coded in NVivo-12 and analysed thematically. Results: In addition to formal services, patients often relied on informal care. Valued aspects of care included equipment and home modifications that supported independence, timely access to and continuity in care, effective information-sharing, professionals who made them feel that their needs mattered, and having a named contact. Where challenges were experienced (e.g. with accessing professionals, communication, and care quality), patients and carers sometimes felt abandoned. While some patients mentioned being on an MDT caseload, few reported having a care plan. The impacts of caring on informal carers were sometimes considerable. COVID-19 affected patient and carer wellbeing, but the new ways of accessing care generated by the pandemic were valued by some participants. Conclusions: As long as challenges remain, patients and carers are unlikely to perceive care as joined-up and patient-centred. If truly integrated and holistic care is to be provided, barriers (such as the lack of shared patient records) must be addressed. Even where MDTs function primarily to co-ordinate rather than deliver care, they could better communicate their co-ordinating role, and MDT discussion outcomes, including care decisions, to patients. Informal carers’ needs also require greater attention by MDTs.
- Open Access
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 11-24
Evaluating health and social care integration in England’s Pioneer programme: The challenges of undertaking research in service delivery and research regulatory systems that are not fit for purpose
Objectives: Better integrated health and social or long-term care is high on government policy agendas in many countries. In England, successive pilot programmes, with related national evaluations, have been introduced to better integrate care to meet the needs of people requiring multi-agency help. However, researchers evaluating such programmes both in England and internationally face a daunting number of challenges produced by service delivery and research regulatory systems. This paper analyses the challenges encountered in seeking to undertake a prospective quasi-experimental evaluation of the impacts of community based multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs) on patient experience and outcomes, as part of a wider evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers programme. The paper also identifies a number of general lessons for research commissioners, study site participants, and those tasked with undertaking such evaluative research. Methods: We reviewed our research activities and timelines from the start of the evaluation. We created a narrative history - using reports to the funder, applications to research and ethics regulatory bodies and correspondence with Pioneer sites, regulatory bodies and data providers - to describe the challenges faced and our approaches to attempting to mitigate them. Results: We experienced four key challenges: (1) unrealistic commissioner research specifications; (2) negotiating with and recruiting multiple organisations and services at potential study sites; (3) navigating research ethics and governance systems; and (4) recruiting participants for primary data collection and obtaining (with their consent) their linked routine service use data. The first two challenges resulted from the lack of shared understanding of evaluation feasibility and constraints between local health and care system actors and national level commissioners of evaluation, plus no clear incentive for local sites to participate. The third and fourth challenges were the product of multiple, protracted, and unnecessarily risk-averse research approval processes which affected both the nature and quantity of the data we could collect. Conclusions: We recommend that major changes are made to the regulation of policy research to enable more robust evaluation to take place and that disproportionately high levels of risk aversion in approval processes for non-interventional, low-risk studies are addressed. In addition, the evaluation commissioning process needs to be far better informed at an early stage about which elements in programmes can feasibly be evaluated before research specifications are advertised.
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 11-24
Open AccessEvaluating health and social care integration in England’s Pioneer programme: The challenges of undertaking research in service delivery and research regulatory systems that are not fit for purpose
Objectives: Better integrated health and social or long-term care is high on government policy agendas in many countries. In England, successive pilot programmes, with related national evaluations, have been introduced to better integrate care to meet the needs of people requiring multi-agency help. However, researchers evaluating such programmes both in England and internationally face a daunting number of challenges produced by service delivery and research regulatory systems. This paper analyses the challenges encountered in seeking to undertake a prospective quasi-experimental evaluation of the impacts of community based multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs) on patient experience and outcomes, as part of a wider evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneers programme. The paper also identifies a number of general lessons for research commissioners, study site participants, and those tasked with undertaking such evaluative research. Methods: We reviewed our research activities and timelines from the start of the evaluation. We created a narrative history - using reports to the funder, applications to research and ethics regulatory bodies and correspondence with Pioneer sites, regulatory bodies and data providers - to describe the challenges faced and our approaches to attempting to mitigate them. Results: We experienced four key challenges: (1) unrealistic commissioner research specifications; (2) negotiating with and recruiting multiple organisations and services at potential study sites; (3) navigating research ethics and governance systems; and (4) recruiting participants for primary data collection and obtaining (with their consent) their linked routine service use data. The first two challenges resulted from the lack of shared understanding of evaluation feasibility and constraints between local health and care system actors and national level commissioners of evaluation, plus no clear incentive for local sites to participate. The third and fourth challenges were the product of multiple, protracted, and unnecessarily risk-averse research approval processes which affected both the nature and quantity of the data we could collect. Conclusions: We recommend that major changes are made to the regulation of policy research to enable more robust evaluation to take place and that disproportionately high levels of risk aversion in approval processes for non-interventional, low-risk studies are addressed. In addition, the evaluation commissioning process needs to be far better informed at an early stage about which elements in programmes can feasibly be evaluated before research specifications are advertised.
- Open Access
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 25-35
The role and functions of community-based multidisciplinary teams in two integrated care and support Pioneers: Perspectives from local system leaders
Objectives: Central government has been promoting closer integration between the National Health Service (NHS) and local government social services in England for more than five decades. Improved coordination between primary, hospital, community health and social services has been advocated as a cost-effective response to growing care needs in an ageing population. This paper concentrates on one of the principal local care coordination mechanisms: community-based multidisciplinary teams (MDTs) involving NHS and social services staff. It reports local leaders’ perceptions of MDTs’ current and future contributions to more coordinated care and support systems in two integrated care Pioneer sites. Methods: Thirty-two qualitative semi-structured interviews with 25 local system leaders and operational managers in two contrasting Integrated Care and Support Pioneer areas were conducted between October 2018 and April 2021, as part of a wider evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme. Eight of those interviews took place after the start of the COVID-19 pandemic and between lockdowns. Interviews were analysed thematically. Results: Local leaders in both areas broadly shared a vision of integrated care in which MDTs were essential mechanisms for coordinating improvements in health and wellbeing, especially for older people who are frail, experience falls and have long-term health conditions. Organisational differences between and within sites influenced local decisions about the purpose and structure of MDTs, but, despite such variations, interviewees identified similar challenges to implementation. Staff turnover, often linked to funding uncertainties, and the lack of shared information systems, were among the most frequent operational challenges noted. System leaders valued national policy frameworks as potential enablers of integrated care but also recognised the role of local contexts in shaping local implementation decisions. Interviewees highlighted benefits emerging from multidisciplinary working, including its potential to deliver more holistic care, fewer instances of work duplication, speedier access to care and enhanced home care provision. However, they were concerned such benefits were not always captured by commonly used performance indicators and thus the value of MDTs could be under-estimated. Conclusions: Local contextual variables and local understandings of these variables appeared to be the main influences on variations in local responses to national expectations of improvements in care integration. Local leaders in both areas broadly shared a vision of integrated care in which MDTs provided essential mechanisms for securing interdependent improvements in both the health and wellbeing of local populations and improvements in workforce job satisfaction.
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 25-35
Open AccessThe role and functions of community-based multidisciplinary teams in two integrated care and support Pioneers: Perspectives from local system leaders
Objectives: Central government has been promoting closer integration between the National Health Service (NHS) and local government social services in England for more than five decades. Improved coordination between primary, hospital, community health and social services has been advocated as a cost-effective response to growing care needs in an ageing population. This paper concentrates on one of the principal local care coordination mechanisms: community-based multidisciplinary teams (MDTs) involving NHS and social services staff. It reports local leaders’ perceptions of MDTs’ current and future contributions to more coordinated care and support systems in two integrated care Pioneer sites. Methods: Thirty-two qualitative semi-structured interviews with 25 local system leaders and operational managers in two contrasting Integrated Care and Support Pioneer areas were conducted between October 2018 and April 2021, as part of a wider evaluation of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme. Eight of those interviews took place after the start of the COVID-19 pandemic and between lockdowns. Interviews were analysed thematically. Results: Local leaders in both areas broadly shared a vision of integrated care in which MDTs were essential mechanisms for coordinating improvements in health and wellbeing, especially for older people who are frail, experience falls and have long-term health conditions. Organisational differences between and within sites influenced local decisions about the purpose and structure of MDTs, but, despite such variations, interviewees identified similar challenges to implementation. Staff turnover, often linked to funding uncertainties, and the lack of shared information systems, were among the most frequent operational challenges noted. System leaders valued national policy frameworks as potential enablers of integrated care but also recognised the role of local contexts in shaping local implementation decisions. Interviewees highlighted benefits emerging from multidisciplinary working, including its potential to deliver more holistic care, fewer instances of work duplication, speedier access to care and enhanced home care provision. However, they were concerned such benefits were not always captured by commonly used performance indicators and thus the value of MDTs could be under-estimated. Conclusions: Local contextual variables and local understandings of these variables appeared to be the main influences on variations in local responses to national expectations of improvements in care integration. Local leaders in both areas broadly shared a vision of integrated care in which MDTs provided essential mechanisms for securing interdependent improvements in both the health and wellbeing of local populations and improvements in workforce job satisfaction.
- Open Access
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 1-10
Evaluating the role of community-based multi-disciplinary teams in England’s Pioneer integrated health and social care programme: Setting the scene
This paper introduces an evaluation of community-based, integrated health and social care multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs), primarily serving older people with long-term conditions, undertaken as part of the wider evaluation (2015-2022) of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme in England (2013-2018). To explain the context within which the MDT evaluation was undertaken, we first outline a brief history of health and social care integration policy in England, describe the Pioneer Programme and the requirements of the national ‘longer-term’ evaluation of the Pioneers. We then explain our rationale for focusing on MDTs, describe our conceptual framework of MDT functioning and provide a brief description of the evaluation design and methods, highlighting four overarching challenges we faced in undertaking it. We then briefly describe the individual papers that constitute the current supplement.
- 19 July 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Services Research & Policy
- Vol. 30 (1_suppl) , 1-10
Open AccessEvaluating the role of community-based multi-disciplinary teams in England’s Pioneer integrated health and social care programme: Setting the scene
This paper introduces an evaluation of community-based, integrated health and social care multi-disciplinary teams (MDTs), primarily serving older people with long-term conditions, undertaken as part of the wider evaluation (2015-2022) of the Integrated Care and Support Pioneer Programme in England (2013-2018). To explain the context within which the MDT evaluation was undertaken, we first outline a brief history of health and social care integration policy in England, describe the Pioneer Programme and the requirements of the national ‘longer-term’ evaluation of the Pioneers. We then explain our rationale for focusing on MDTs, describe our conceptual framework of MDT functioning and provide a brief description of the evaluation design and methods, highlighting four overarching challenges we faced in undertaking it. We then briefly describe the individual papers that constitute the current supplement.
- Open Access
- 29 October 2021
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 21 (4)
Integrated Care in England – what can we Learn from a Decade of National Pilot Programmes?
For more than a decade the English NHS has pursued integrated care through three national pilot programmes. The independent evaluators of these programmes here identify several common themes that inform the development of integrated care. The three pilot programmes shared the aim of better coordination between hospital and community-based health services and between health and social care. Each programme recruited local pilot sites that designed specific interventions to support inter-professional and inter-organisational collaboration. The pilots were highly heterogenous and results varied both within and between the three programmes. While staff were generally positive about their achievements, pilots had mixed success especially in reducing unplanned hospital admissions. Common facilitators to achieving pilots’ objectives included effective senior leadership and shared values, simple interventions and additional funding. Barriers included short timescales, poor professional engagement, information and data sharing problems, and conflicts with changing national policy. There was little stable or shared understanding of what ‘integrated care’ meant resulting in different practices and priorities. An increasing focus on reducing unplanned hospital use among national sponsors created a mismatch in expectations between local and national actors. Pilots in all three national programmes made some headway against their objectives but were limited in their impact on unplanned hospital admissions.
- 29 October 2021
- Published by Ubiquity Press, Ltd. in International Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 21 (4)
Open AccessIntegrated Care in England – what can we Learn from a Decade of National Pilot Programmes?
For more than a decade the English NHS has pursued integrated care through three national pilot programmes. The independent evaluators of these programmes here identify several common themes that inform the development of integrated care. The three pilot programmes shared the aim of better coordination between hospital and community-based health services and between health and social care. Each programme recruited local pilot sites that designed specific interventions to support inter-professional and inter-organisational collaboration. The pilots were highly heterogenous and results varied both within and between the three programmes. While staff were generally positive about their achievements, pilots had mixed success especially in reducing unplanned hospital admissions. Common facilitators to achieving pilots’ objectives included effective senior leadership and shared values, simple interventions and additional funding. Barriers included short timescales, poor professional engagement, information and data sharing problems, and conflicts with changing national policy. There was little stable or shared understanding of what ‘integrated care’ meant resulting in different practices and priorities. An increasing focus on reducing unplanned hospital use among national sponsors created a mismatch in expectations between local and national actors. Pilots in all three national programmes made some headway against their objectives but were limited in their impact on unplanned hospital admissions.
- Open Access
- 12 July 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-10
Comparison of the impact of two national health and social care integration programmes on emergency hospital admissions
Background: Policy-makers expect that integration of health and social care will improve user and carer experience and reduce avoidable hospital use. We evaluate the impact on emergency hospital admissions of two large nationally-initiated service integration programmes in England: the Pioneer (November 2013 to March 2018) and Vanguard (January 2015 to March 2018) programmes. The latter had far greater financial and expert support from central agencies. Methods: Of the 206 Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) in England, 51(25%) were involved in the Pioneer programme only, 22(11%) were involved in the Vanguard programme only and 13(6%) were involved in both programmes. We used quasi-experimental methods to compare monthly counts of emergency admissions between four groups of CCGs, before and after the introduction of the two programmes. Results: CCGs involved in the programmes had higher monthly hospital emergency admission rates than non-participants prior to their introduction [7.9 (95% CI:7.8–8.1) versus 7.5 (CI:7.4–7.6) per 1000 population]. From 2013 to 2018, there was a 12% (95% CI:9.5–13.6%) increase in emergency admissions in CCGs not involved in either programme while emergency admissions in CCGs in the Pioneer and Vanguard programmes increased by 6.4% (95% CI: 3.8–9.0%) and 8.8% (95% CI:4.5–13.1%), respectively. CCGs involved in both initiatives experienced a smaller increase of 3.5% (95% CI:-0.3–7.2%). The slowdown largely occurred in the final year of both programmes. Conclusions: Health and social care integration programmes can mitigate but not prevent rises in emergency admissions over the longer-term. Greater financial and expert support from national agencies and involvement in multiple integration initiatives can have cumulative effects.
- 12 July 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Health Services Research
- Vol. 21 (1) , 1-10
Open AccessComparison of the impact of two national health and social care integration programmes on emergency hospital admissions
Background: Policy-makers expect that integration of health and social care will improve user and carer experience and reduce avoidable hospital use. We evaluate the impact on emergency hospital admissions of two large nationally-initiated service integration programmes in England: the Pioneer (November 2013 to March 2018) and Vanguard (January 2015 to March 2018) programmes. The latter had far greater financial and expert support from central agencies. Methods: Of the 206 Clinical Commissioning Groups (CCGs) in England, 51(25%) were involved in the Pioneer programme only, 22(11%) were involved in the Vanguard programme only and 13(6%) were involved in both programmes. We used quasi-experimental methods to compare monthly counts of emergency admissions between four groups of CCGs, before and after the introduction of the two programmes. Results: CCGs involved in the programmes had higher monthly hospital emergency admission rates than non-participants prior to their introduction [7.9 (95% CI:7.8–8.1) versus 7.5 (CI:7.4–7.6) per 1000 population]. From 2013 to 2018, there was a 12% (95% CI:9.5–13.6%) increase in emergency admissions in CCGs not involved in either programme while emergency admissions in CCGs in the Pioneer and Vanguard programmes increased by 6.4% (95% CI: 3.8–9.0%) and 8.8% (95% CI:4.5–13.1%), respectively. CCGs involved in both initiatives experienced a smaller increase of 3.5% (95% CI:-0.3–7.2%). The slowdown largely occurred in the final year of both programmes. Conclusions: Health and social care integration programmes can mitigate but not prevent rises in emergency admissions over the longer-term. Greater financial and expert support from national agencies and involvement in multiple integration initiatives can have cumulative effects.
- Open Access
- 18 October 2019
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 28 (1) , 14-26
Can health and social care integration make long-term progress? Findings from key informant surveys of the integration Pioneers in England
Purpose: All areas in England are expected by National Health Service (NHS) England to develop integrated care systems (ICSs) by April 2021. ICSs bring together primary, secondary and community health services, and involve local authorities and the voluntary sector. ICSs build on previous pilots, including the Integrated Care Pioneers in 25 areas from November 2013 to March 2018. This analysis tracks the Pioneers’ self-reported progress, and the facilitators and barriers to improve service coordination over three years, longer than previous evaluations in England. The paper aims to discuss these issues. Design/methodology/approach: Annual online key informant (KI) surveys, 2016–2018, are used for this study. Findings: By the fourth year of the programme (2017), KIs had shifted from reporting plans to implementation of a wide range of initiatives. In 2018, informants reported fewer “significant” barriers to change than previously. While some progress in achieving local integration objectives was evident, it was also clear that progress can take considerable time. In parallel, there appears to have been a move away from aspects of personalised care associated with user control, perhaps in part because the emphasis of national objectives has shifted towards establishing large-scale ICSs with a particular focus on organisational fragmentation within the NHS. Research limitations/implications: Because these are self-reports of changes, they cannot be objectively verified. Later stages of the evaluation will look at changes in outcomes and user experiences. Originality/value: The current study shows clearly that the benefits of integrating health and social care are unlikely to be apparent for several years, and expectations of policy makers to see rapid improvements in care and outcomes are likely to be unrealistic.
- 18 October 2019
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Journal of Integrated Care
- Vol. 28 (1) , 14-26
Open AccessCan health and social care integration make long-term progress? Findings from key informant surveys of the integration Pioneers in England
Purpose: All areas in England are expected by National Health Service (NHS) England to develop integrated care systems (ICSs) by April 2021. ICSs bring together primary, secondary and community health services, and involve local authorities and the voluntary sector. ICSs build on previous pilots, including the Integrated Care Pioneers in 25 areas from November 2013 to March 2018. This analysis tracks the Pioneers’ self-reported progress, and the facilitators and barriers to improve service coordination over three years, longer than previous evaluations in England. The paper aims to discuss these issues. Design/methodology/approach: Annual online key informant (KI) surveys, 2016–2018, are used for this study. Findings: By the fourth year of the programme (2017), KIs had shifted from reporting plans to implementation of a wide range of initiatives. In 2018, informants reported fewer “significant” barriers to change than previously. While some progress in achieving local integration objectives was evident, it was also clear that progress can take considerable time. In parallel, there appears to have been a move away from aspects of personalised care associated with user control, perhaps in part because the emphasis of national objectives has shifted towards establishing large-scale ICSs with a particular focus on organisational fragmentation within the NHS. Research limitations/implications: Because these are self-reports of changes, they cannot be objectively verified. Later stages of the evaluation will look at changes in outcomes and user experiences. Originality/value: The current study shows clearly that the benefits of integrating health and social care are unlikely to be apparent for several years, and expectations of policy makers to see rapid improvements in care and outcomes are likely to be unrealistic.