IMIldar F. Mingazov

Ildar F. Mingazov

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Ildar F. Mingazov has a total of 40 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    CIRCULATORY DISEASES AND DIABETES MELLITUS IN MEDICAL DEATH CERTIFICATES IN A NUMBER OF RUSSIAN REGIONS

    by Ekaterina P. Kakorina, Irina V. Samorodskaya, Oleg V. Zayratyants, Ildar F. Mingazov, Sergey A. Makarov, Elena G. Arefyeva, Olga L. Barbarash, Екатерина Петровна Какорина, Ирина Владимировна Самородская, Олег Вадимович Зайратьянц, et al.

    Highlights The study findings have revealed significant regional differences in determining the underlying cause of death and implementing “statistical guidelines” for completion of medical death certificates, thus necessitating standardization of underlying cause of death coding across all regions of the Russian Federation.   Aim. To assess the incidence of circulatory system diseases (CSD), the combined myocardial infarction (MI) and stroke with diabetes mellitus (DM) in medical death certificates (MDCs) of Moscow, Moscow Region (MR), Novosibirsk Region (NR), and Kemerovo Region (KR); and to discuss the causes of the differences, their significance in clinical practice, and cause–of–death statistics. Methods. MDCs of patients who died in 2023 at the age of 18 years and older from diseases (ICD–10 classes I–XVIII and XXII) were selected from an electronic database in Moscow (90,663), MR (86,934), NR (31,152), and KR (31,416). Results. CSD was indicated as the underlying cause of death (UCD) in 59.8% of cases in Moscow and 44.5% in MR; 57.7% in NR and 43.4% in KR (p < 0.0001), including stroke – 6.9%; 8.0%; 6.5% and 7.6%; and MI – 2.1%; 3.0%; 2.5% and 2.7%, respectively. DM in any part of MDCs was indicated in 3.2%; 6.6%; 4.1% and 7.4%, respectively (of which – DM was indicated in Part II in 92% of MDCs in Moscow, whereas in MR and KR DM was indicated as UCD in more than 70%, and in 67% in NR). The combination of MI and DM in one MDC was registered in 0.1% of all analyzed MDCs in Moscow, in 0.5% in MR; 0.2% in NR and 0.8% in KR. The combination of stroke and DM in MDCs was present in 0.4%; 0.8%; 0.3%, and 1.4%, respectively. Significant regional differences were revealed regarding the use of MDCs entries for the combination of stroke/DM (stroke as a complication of DM was listed in Part I of MDCs in 0.3% of cases in Moscow, in 95.5% in KR) and MI/DM (MI was listed as a fatal complication of DM in 72.6% of MDCs in MR, in 42.9% in NR; in 6.4% in Moscow; and in 93.8% in KR). Conclusions. Significant differences in the frequency of registering cardiovascular diseases (including stroke and MI) and DM in MDCs in Moscow, MR, NR, and KR are related to the specifics of choosing the UCD and filling out the MDCs. These differences subsequently affect mortality rates from various diseases calculated using UCD data. The results obtained require extensive discussion by specialists.

  • The incidence of osteoporosis and its registration as a cause of death in a number of constituent entities of the Russian Federation

    by O.M. Draprina, I.A. Skripnikova, I.V. Samorodskaja, O.V. Zayratyants, E.P. Kakorina, O.L. Barbarash, I.F. Mingazov

    Osteoporosis in older adults is a common condition associated with hormonal factors, a decline in quality of life, and a risk of death from its complications. Objective. To analyze morbidity indicators and assess the frequency of recording osteoporosis (ICD-10 codes M80–M81) in medical certificates of cause of death in Moscow and the Moscow, Novosibirsk, and Kemerovo regions. Materials and methods. The analysis utilized data for 2023 obtained from regional electronic databases, including: a) the number of osteoporosis cases among the adult population (Federal Statistical Observation Form № 12, «Information on the number of diseases registered in patients residing in the medical organization’s service area»); and b) registered deaths (Record Form № 106u, «Medical Certificate of Cause of Death» (MCCD)). A preliminary study showed that the three-digit ICD-10 codes M80–M81 are recorded in MCCDs only for deaths occurring at age 60 or older; therefore, the analysis was restricted to MCCDs of individuals in this age group. Results. The incidence of osteoporosis with and without pathological fractures (three-digit ICD-10 codes: M80–M81) in four constituent entities of Russia is presented. According to data from Form № 12, the incidence of osteoporosis without pathological fractures in the regions is 3 times lower than in Moscow. M80–M81 codes registered in the MCCDs in those who died from diseases at the age of 60 and older are extremely rare and in 4 regions of Russia were identified in only 185 MCCDs (ranging from a maximum of 0.16% in Moscow to a minimum of 0.016% in the Novosibirsk and Kemerovo regions). The ratio of deceased women to men was 4.3:1. The mean age was 80.7±11.2 years for men and 84.3±7.9 years for women (p<0.0001). Osteoporosis codes were most frequently listed in Part II of the MCCD as contributing causes of death, with the codes M80.8 «Other osteoporosis with pathological fracture» (56.8%) and M80.0 «Postmenopausal osteoporosis with pathological fracture» (18.4%) being predominantly used. When ICD-10 codes M80–M81 were indicated in Part II of the MCCDs, the underlying causes of death were predominantly identified as I67.8 (Other specified cerebrovascular diseases — 56 MCCDs) and I25.5 (ischemic cardiomyopathy). Conclusion. The analysis and comparison with data from other studies suggest low detection and underreporting of osteoporosis cases in Federal Statistical Observation Form № 12. In the Record Form № 106u «Medical Certificate of Cause of Death» codes M80—M81 are extremely rare. The obtained data indicate the need to develop standardized guidelines clarifying the criteria and placement of osteoporosis reporting in the Record Form № 106u «Medical Certificate of Cause of Death», as well as to optimize current statistical reporting and monitoring practices.

  • Open Access

    Nosological structure of causes of death due to cardiovascular diseases in hospitals of five Russian regions

    by S. A. Boytsov, O. V. Zairatyants, I. V. Samorodskaya, E. P. Kakorina, O. L. Barbarash, I. F. Mingazov, E. V. Ivanova, I. V. Antonova, С. А. Бойцов, О. В. Зайратьтянц, et al.

    Aim. To determine whether there are differences in the nosological structure of causes of death among patients who died due to cardiovascular diseases (CVDs) in hospitals across Russian regions, taking into account demographic characteristics. Material and methods . Medical certificate of cause of death (form № 106/u) for patients aged 18 years and older who died in hospitals from DCS (ICD-10 Chapter IX) in 2023 were retrieved from the electronic databases of regional medical information and analytical centers (for Moscow, excluding those issued by federal and departmental medical organizations). Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS 26.0. Results . The mean age of patients who died from CVDs in hospitals in Moscow (76,5±12,8 years) was higher (pConclusion. Significant differences in the nosological structure of causes of death from CVDs were identified between the regions, which require further investigation.

  • Open Access

    Differences in Causes of Death among the Elderly in Four Regions of the Russian Federation: Retrospective Study

    by O. V. Zayratyants, I. V. Samorodskaya, E. P. Kakorina, O. L. Barbarash, I. F. Mingazov, О. В. Зайратьянц, И. В. Самородская, Е. П. Какорина, О. Л. Барабаш, И. Ф. Мингазов

    OBJECTIVE . To identify and discuss the causes of death among the elderly in the four regions of the Russian Federation, using medical death certificate (MDC) data. MATERIALS AND METHODS. A total of 114,402 deaths of people aged 75 years or older from diseases (ICD-10 codes I–XVIII and XXII) were selected from electronic databases of regional medical information and analysis centers in four regions of the Russian Federation for the year 2023. Of these, 45,988 died in Moscow (40.2%), 43,249 in the Moscow region (37.8%), 13,309 in Novosibirsk region (11.6%), and 11,856 in Kemerovo region (10.4%). RESULTS . The structure of the underlying causes of death (OCD) from diseases by ICD-10 classes in 4 regions has significant differences (p < 0.0001). The share of diseases of the circulatory system (DCS) was 71.6% in Moscow, 47.7% in the Moscow region; 70.8% in the Novosibirsk region and 50.9% in the Kemerovo region. The share of deaths from malignant neoplasms (MN) was 18.7% in Moscow; 9.9% in the Moscow region; 14.9% in the Novosibirsk region and 14.1% in the Kemerovo region; diseases of the nervous system — 0.2%; 22.2%; 2.9% and 15.5%, respectively. The fourth rank place in the Moscow region (4.8%) and Kemerovo region (6.2%) was occupied by diseases of the endocrine system (0.2% in Moscow and 1.1% in the Novosibirsk region). The share of acute forms of ischemic heart disease (ICD-10 code groups I21–I24), stroke (I60–I64) and ruptured aneurysm or aortic dissection in the structure of the PPS was 9.7% in Moscow; 12.3% in the Moscow region; 8.8% in the Novosibirsk region and 12.9% in the Kemerovo region. The share of codes probably associated with chronic cognitive impairment and/or dementia (from 3 classes of diseases) accounted for 33.2% in Moscow, 30.8% in the Moscow region, 14.0% in the Novosibirsk region and 26.7% in the Kemerovo region. The CSD codes in any place of the ICD-10 were indicated in 83.0% of cases in Moscow and 85.2% in the Moscow region; in the Novosibirsk region — 85.6%, and in the Kemerovo region — 87.3%, with 98.0% of the MCCs indicating more than one 4-digit ICD-10 code. CONCLUSIONS . Despite significant differences in the structure of causes of the death, chronic pathology predominates in all four regions, with a high proportion of deaths associated with cognitive impairment. The causeof-death statistics for those aged 75 and older are not sufficiently objective, with underdiagnosis of some diseases and overdiagnosis of others, as well as a high frequency of using codes for unspecified causes of death or those not recommended for use in mortality statistics.

  • Open Access

    Chronic coronary artery disease as a cause of death: analysis of medical certificates of cause of death from several regions of the Russian Federation

    by R. N. Shepel, I. V. Samorodskaya, O. V. Zairatyants, E. P. Kakorina, I. F. Mingazov, S. A. Makarov, O. L. Barbarash, O. M. Drapkina

    Aim.  To assess the registration rate of certain chronic coronary artery disease (CAD) types based on medical certificates of cause of death (MCCD) of individuals who died (in hospital and out of hospital) in Moscow, Moscow Oblast, Novosibirsk Oblast, and Kemerovo Oblast. Material and methods.  A total of 240065 MCCDs of individuals aged 18 years or older from diseases (classes I-XVIII and XXII) were included. There were 90663 deaths in Moscow, 86934 in the Moscow Oblast, 31152 in the Novosibirsk Oblast, and 31416 in the Kemerovo Oblast. From all the regional statistical data, cases of chronic CAD registration in any part and line of paragraphs 10 and 22 of the regional statistical data were selected. The registration rate of chronic CAD as the underlying cause of death (UCD) and contributing causes, the proportion of in-hospital deaths, and chronic CAD code use rate were determined. Given the study objective and multiple comparisons, statistical null hypotheses were only proposed for individual variables. The statistical significance of differences in the frequencies of the studied variable was assessed using the χ 2 test, and for quantitative variables in the 4 regions, using univariate analysis of variance. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS 26.0 (IBM Company) and Excel (Microsoft for Microsoft Windows). Results.  As UCD codes, chronic CAD were registered in Moscow in 21,3% of all analyzed MCCDs, in Moscow Oblast — in 20,3%, in Novosibirsk Oblast — in 36,5%, and in Kemerovo Oblast — in 16,1% of cases; in part 2 of MCCDs — in 7,4, 21, 7,3 and 14% of cases, respectively. The contribution of chronic CAD codes to CAD was 89,8% in Moscow, 87,0% in Moscow Region, 93,6% in Novosibirsk Oblast and 83,4% in Kemerovo Oblast, respectively. In less than 2% of all analyzed regions, chronic CAD codes are indicated in combination with codes of acute CAD in different MCCD lines. The proportion of inhospital deaths (with chronic CAD indicated in any part of the MCCD) was 42,9% in Moscow, 29,0% in the Moscow Region, 30,5% in the Novosibirsk Oblast, and 31,6% in the Kemerovo Oblast. Among the MCCDs in which chronic CAD codes were presented as UCD, they were 35,9%, 31,9%, 24,8%, and 18,7%, respectively. In Moscow, I25.5 (35,1%) and I25.8 (62,3%) codes were used to designate UCD in the overwhelming majority of cases, while in the Novosibirsk Oblast and Kemerovo Oblast, code I25.1 was used more often (86,9%) and 73,9%, respectively. Conclusion.  Regional differences in the use of chronic CAD codes in the MCCDs demonstrate a subjective approach to their application as UCD or causes contributing to death. In our view, an expert consensus is needed on the criteria for different chronic CAD types, their selection, and coding as causes of death when registering the MCCD.


  • Open Access

    Features of natural population movement in the Siberian Federal District during the coronavirus pandemic

    by M. I. Voevoda, V. M. Chernyshev, I. F. Mingazov

    The pandemic of a new corona virus infection (NCVI) has worsened the already unfavorable demographic situation in the Russian Federation. Aim of the study was to assess the changes in the demographic situation in the country and the Siberian Federal District and the causes contributing to them. Material and methods. Statistical data of the Ministry of Health of the Russian Federation, Rosstat, regional ministries of health of subjects belonging to the Siberian Federal District, and literature on the problems of demography were used. The following methods were used: analytical, historical, statistical, including statistical observation, summary and grouping of materials, absolute and relative statistical values, sampling. Results and discussion. The pandemic period of the new coronavirus infection in RF and SFD is characterized by a substantial increase in the mortality rate, which became the maximum in the newest history of Russia, i.e. since 1991. The structure of the main causes of death has changed. Diseases of the circulatory system, neoplasms, diseases of the digestive organs and external causes, accounted for 76.6 % of all causes in 2019, in 2021 they accounted for only 60.1 %, with NCVI taking second place among causes of death (19.1 %). The birth rate remains at a low level, and in 2021 was 9.6 per 1000 population, which is 16.5 % lower than in 2017, due to which the natural decline in population has significantly increased (to –6.3 in Russia and to –7.0 per 1000 population in SFD) and the average life expectancy has decreased. Conclusions. All of the foregoing points to the ineffectiveness of measures to prevent and forestall the adverse effects of the pandemic, which is practically inevitable in the case of new, poorly studied infectious diseases. The measures taken to organize medical care to the population in the conditions of the pandemic have not been adequate. This is evidenced by the higher rates of total mortality of the population, compared to the probable ones (caused by the increase in mortality from NCVI), a significant increase in natural population decline and a reduction in life expectancy.


  • Open Access

    On the main problems of healthcare in the Russian Federation and measures to eliminate them

    by V.M. Chernyshev, O.V. Strelchenko, I.F. Mingazov, Novosibirsk Siberian District Medical Center Of Fmba Of Russia

    О главных проблемах здравоохранения Российской Федерации и мерах по их устранению

  • Open Access

    Rural healthcare of Russia. Status, problems, prospects

    by V. M. Chernyshev, M. I. Voevoda, O. V. Strelchenko, I. F. Mingazov

    The transformations of domestic healthcare carried out in the last three decades have not led to the planned results, and in some areas the consequences have turned out to be negative. Rural healthcare suffered the most significantly. The aim of the study was based on the analysis of the situation in the rural health care of the country to propose measures to improve it. Material and methods. The statistical data of the Ministry of Health of Russia, Rosstat, Central Research Institute of Organization and Informatization of Healthcare, as well as data on the Siberian Federal District for the period from 1990 to 2020 were used. Scientific publications on the problem under consideration have been studied. Results and their discussion. The course taken in the early 90s of the last century towards the commercialization of medicine remains. So for the period from 2005 to 2018 in the structure of the country’s medical personnel, the number of people employed in the public sector decreased from 93.6 to 86.8 % (by 237 000), whereas in private medical organizations it increased by 2.3 times. In 2020, 38.4 % of medical organizations were already private. The most significant changes have occurred in rural healthcare. The number of paramedic and obstetric stations decreased by 21.1 %, the provision of beds in hospitals is 2 times lower than the national average, and doctors are 3 times fewer than in cities. In the age structure, the share of doctors over the age of 60 increased from 13.5 % (2017) to 18.1 % (2020). The implementation of the programs “Zemsky Doctor” and “Zemsky paramedic” did not lead to an increase in the provision of medical workers in rural areas. Today, medical care is geographically available only to 49 % of villagers, for 40 % it is difficult to access, and 9 % is practically inaccessible (2 % of respondents could not answer the question). This has led to the fact that the average life expectancy of the villagers is 1.5 years lower than that of the townspeople, and the total mortality is 1.2 % higher than the national average. Conclusion. The problem of accessibility of medical care to the rural population has worsened in the last three decades. The implemented programs aimed at improving its accessibility and quality, including for rural residents, have not led to a significant positive result.


  • Health of the economically active population the Russian Federation and the Siberian Federal District. Social and economic aspects

    by V.M. Chernyshev, Novosibirsk State Medical University, O.V. Strelchenko, I.F. Mingazov, Novosibirsk Siberian District Medical Center Of Fmba Of Russia