Caroline A. B. Redhead
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Caroline A. B. Redhead has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Lucy Frith
Centre for Social Ethics and Policy, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
6 shared publications Anna Chiumento
School of Social and Political Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK
3 shared publicationsHeather Draper
Warwick Medical School, The University of Warwick, Warwick, UK
3 shared publications- Catherine Bowden
Centre for Social Ethics and Policy, Division of Law, School of Social Sciences, The Faculty of Humanities, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
2 shared publications Lucy Frith
Centre for Social Ethics and Policy, Department of Law, The University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
2 shared publications- Marie Fox
University of Liverpool, Liverpool, L697WZ, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 18 March 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (3) , 233-256
Conceptualising ‘my data’: Going beyond data security to build trustworthy governance of health data sharing
Despite strong support for health research in the UK, many people currently opt not to share their health data because they do not trust that their data will be handled appropriately. This lack of trust is widely acknowledged but what is missing from the literature is a theoretical understanding of what underlies this lack of trust. This article presents an original, empirically-based account of the source of this lack of trust based on interviews conducted with those who were unwilling to share their GP data with NHS Digital’s General Practice Data for Planning and Research (GPDPR) programme. The participants told us that they did not feel the data was being treated as ‘my data’. In this article, we explore what this concept means to our participants and argue that those responsible for sharing health data need to demonstrate commitment to patients’ values and interests as well as data security.
- 18 March 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Medical Law International
- Vol. 26 (3) , 233-256
Open AccessConceptualising ‘my data’: Going beyond data security to build trustworthy governance of health data sharing
Despite strong support for health research in the UK, many people currently opt not to share their health data because they do not trust that their data will be handled appropriately. This lack of trust is widely acknowledged but what is missing from the literature is a theoretical understanding of what underlies this lack of trust. This article presents an original, empirically-based account of the source of this lack of trust based on interviews conducted with those who were unwilling to share their GP data with NHS Digital’s General Practice Data for Planning and Research (GPDPR) programme. The participants told us that they did not feel the data was being treated as ‘my data’. In this article, we explore what this concept means to our participants and argue that those responsible for sharing health data need to demonstrate commitment to patients’ values and interests as well as data security.
- Open Access
- 2 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 382, 118354
Relational dynamite: Engagements with kinship at the interface of donor conception and DNA testing
- 2 July 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Social Science & Medicine
- Vol. 382, 118354
Open AccessRelational dynamite: Engagements with kinship at the interface of donor conception and DNA testing
- Open Access
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Human Fertility
- Vol. 28 (1) , 2493252
Warnock and its contested legacy in relation to donor conceived families: the case for regulatory reform
A generation on from the Warnock Report, the regulatory system it proposed remains largely intact, despite significant changes in the fertility sector, legal culture and wider society. In this article, we trace Warnock's legacy, focusing on the context of gamete donor conception. Drawing on illustrative examples from the ConnectedDNA research project, we analyse two aspects of Warnock's proposals - its recommendation that gamete donors should be anonymous and its key assumption that only the 'triad' of donor, recipient(s) and donor-conceived people have an interest in receiving information about each other. The jettisoning of donor anonymity coupled with a questioning of Warnock's assumptions about the meaning of 'family', illustrate the challenges inherent in a key Warnock objective: to 'future proof' fertility law. Both the global market in gametes and embryos and the accessibility of Direct-to-Consumer Genetic Testing (DTCGT) technologies were wholly unforeseen by Warnock. Similarly, contemporary understandings of donation, families, kinship and relatedness exist in tension with Warnock's original assumptions and, thus, with the principles underpinning the legislative framework. Given this, we recommend three specific reforms to the regulation of donor conception: (1) an urgent review and reformulation of information-sharing provisions, particularly with regard to donor-siblings; (2) an expansion of counselling and support provisions for those affected by donor conception; and (3) the effective imposition of a global ten-family limit. More generally, we suggest that piecemeal and ad hoc reforms to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 have often appeared contradictory and have failed to grapple with the global nature of fertility practice. Thus, we conclude by arguing that a comprehensive review of the legislative framework is needed to create a system of legal governance which meets the needs of the donor conceived community and remains fit for purpose in the twenty-first century.
- 19 May 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Human Fertility
- Vol. 28 (1) , 2493252
Open AccessWarnock and its contested legacy in relation to donor conceived families: the case for regulatory reform
A generation on from the Warnock Report, the regulatory system it proposed remains largely intact, despite significant changes in the fertility sector, legal culture and wider society. In this article, we trace Warnock's legacy, focusing on the context of gamete donor conception. Drawing on illustrative examples from the ConnectedDNA research project, we analyse two aspects of Warnock's proposals - its recommendation that gamete donors should be anonymous and its key assumption that only the 'triad' of donor, recipient(s) and donor-conceived people have an interest in receiving information about each other. The jettisoning of donor anonymity coupled with a questioning of Warnock's assumptions about the meaning of 'family', illustrate the challenges inherent in a key Warnock objective: to 'future proof' fertility law. Both the global market in gametes and embryos and the accessibility of Direct-to-Consumer Genetic Testing (DTCGT) technologies were wholly unforeseen by Warnock. Similarly, contemporary understandings of donation, families, kinship and relatedness exist in tension with Warnock's original assumptions and, thus, with the principles underpinning the legislative framework. Given this, we recommend three specific reforms to the regulation of donor conception: (1) an urgent review and reformulation of information-sharing provisions, particularly with regard to donor-siblings; (2) an expansion of counselling and support provisions for those affected by donor conception; and (3) the effective imposition of a global ten-family limit. More generally, we suggest that piecemeal and ad hoc reforms to the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990 have often appeared contradictory and have failed to grapple with the global nature of fertility practice. Thus, we conclude by arguing that a comprehensive review of the legislative framework is needed to create a system of legal governance which meets the needs of the donor conceived community and remains fit for purpose in the twenty-first century.
- Open Access
- 10 December 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 33 (1)
Unlocking the promise of UK health data: considering the case for a charitable GP data trust
The UK National Health Service general practice (GP) patient data constitute a rich research resource, but collecting, managing, and sharing patient data present challenges. In May 2021, to address these challenges, substantial changes to the system for processing pseudonymized GP patient data in England were announced. As part of an opt-out process, patient consent to sharing GP data was deemed to have been given. However, when over a million people quickly acted to opt out of the new system, the process was paused, and an engagement exercise commenced, whose aim was to inform a re-designed programme addressing patient concerns. In this article, we present and discuss the findings of the General Practice Data Trust pilot study, which has investigated people’s reasons for opting out of sharing their data, and, looking for practical solutions to their concerns, has discussed with participants the concept of a ‘data trust’ to manage the sharing of patient data. Making a conceptual argument for the use of the (relatively new) charitable incorporated organization as a governance model for a GP data trust, we demonstrate how this could address patients’ concerns and represent a more attractive means of stewarding GP data for research and service planning purposes.
- 10 December 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 33 (1)
Open AccessUnlocking the promise of UK health data: considering the case for a charitable GP data trust
The UK National Health Service general practice (GP) patient data constitute a rich research resource, but collecting, managing, and sharing patient data present challenges. In May 2021, to address these challenges, substantial changes to the system for processing pseudonymized GP patient data in England were announced. As part of an opt-out process, patient consent to sharing GP data was deemed to have been given. However, when over a million people quickly acted to opt out of the new system, the process was paused, and an engagement exercise commenced, whose aim was to inform a re-designed programme addressing patient concerns. In this article, we present and discuss the findings of the General Practice Data Trust pilot study, which has investigated people’s reasons for opting out of sharing their data, and, looking for practical solutions to their concerns, has discussed with participants the concept of a ‘data trust’ to manage the sharing of patient data. Making a conceptual argument for the use of the (relatively new) charitable incorporated organization as a governance model for a GP data trust, we demonstrate how this could address patients’ concerns and represent a more attractive means of stewarding GP data for research and service planning purposes.
- Open Access
- 27 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 32 (4) , 505-529
Donor conception, direct-to-consumer genetic testing, choices, and procedural justice: an argument for reform of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990
In this article, using theories of procedural justice and ‘slow violence’, we consider potential reform of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990. Our theoretical discussion is underpinned by findings from the ConnecteDNA project, exploring how people affected by donor conception experience direct-to-consumer genetic testing (DTCGT). The negative impacts of DTCGT, especially shock discoveries about the circumstances of someone’s conception in adulthood, are linked to donor anonymity, and how its continued protection is experienced as a barrier to the rights and agency of donor-conceived people. We focus on two key issues relating to the donor information access process set out in section 31ZA of the 1990 Act. The first is that it excludes certain cohorts of donor-conceived people, creating inequalities of access to donor information. The second is the impact of the use of DTCGT to search for that information. We discuss what a procedurally just process of law reform would look like, concluding that, whatever (prospective) approach to donor anonymity is taken, the donor information access process should be the same for all donor-conceived people. We thus argue that, even were the status quo to be maintained, reform of the donor information access process with retrospective effect would be required.
- 27 July 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 32 (4) , 505-529
Open AccessDonor conception, direct-to-consumer genetic testing, choices, and procedural justice: an argument for reform of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990
In this article, using theories of procedural justice and ‘slow violence’, we consider potential reform of the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act 1990. Our theoretical discussion is underpinned by findings from the ConnecteDNA project, exploring how people affected by donor conception experience direct-to-consumer genetic testing (DTCGT). The negative impacts of DTCGT, especially shock discoveries about the circumstances of someone’s conception in adulthood, are linked to donor anonymity, and how its continued protection is experienced as a barrier to the rights and agency of donor-conceived people. We focus on two key issues relating to the donor information access process set out in section 31ZA of the 1990 Act. The first is that it excludes certain cohorts of donor-conceived people, creating inequalities of access to donor information. The second is the impact of the use of DTCGT to search for that information. We discuss what a procedurally just process of law reform would look like, concluding that, whatever (prospective) approach to donor anonymity is taken, the donor information access process should be the same for all donor-conceived people. We thus argue that, even were the status quo to be maintained, reform of the donor information access process with retrospective effect would be required.
- Open Access
- 28 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1-15
Using symbiotic empirical ethics to explore the significance of relationships to clinical ethics: findings from the Reset Ethics research project
Background: At the beginning of the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic, many non-Covid healthcare services were suspended. In April 2020, the Department of Health in England mandated that non-Covid services should resume, alongside the continuing pandemic response. This ‘resetting’ of healthcare services created a unique context in which it became critical to consider how ethical considerations did (and should) underpin decisions about integrating infection control measures into routine healthcare practices. We draw on data collected as part of the ‘NHS Reset Ethics’ project, which explored the everyday ethical challenges of resetting England’s NHS maternity and paediatrics services during the pandemic. Methods: Healthcare professionals and members of the public participated in interviews and focus group discussions. The qualitative methods are reported in detail elsewhere. The focus of this article is our use of Frith’s symbiotic empirical ethics methodology to work from our empirical findings towards the normative suggestion that clinical ethics should explicitly attend to the importance of relationships in clinical practice. This methodology uses a five-step approach to refine and develop ethical theory based on a naturalist account of ethics that sees practice and theory as symbiotically related. Results: The Reset project data showed that changed working practices caused ethical challenges for healthcare professionals, and that infection prevention and control measures represented harmful barriers to the experience of receiving and offering care. For healthcare professionals, offering care as part of a relational interaction was an ethically important dimension of healthcare delivery. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that foregrounding the importance of relationships across a hospital community will better promote the ethically important multi-directional expression of caring between healthcare professionals, patients, and their families. We offer two suggestions for making progress towards such a relational approach. First, that there is a change of emphasis in clinical ethics practice to explicitly acknowledge the importance of the relationships (including with their healthcare team) within which the patient is held. Second, that organisational decision-making should take into account the moral significance afforded to caring relationships by healthcare professionals, and the role such relationships can play in the negotiation of ethical challenges.
- 28 May 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 25 (1) , 1-15
Open AccessUsing symbiotic empirical ethics to explore the significance of relationships to clinical ethics: findings from the Reset Ethics research project
Background: At the beginning of the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic, many non-Covid healthcare services were suspended. In April 2020, the Department of Health in England mandated that non-Covid services should resume, alongside the continuing pandemic response. This ‘resetting’ of healthcare services created a unique context in which it became critical to consider how ethical considerations did (and should) underpin decisions about integrating infection control measures into routine healthcare practices. We draw on data collected as part of the ‘NHS Reset Ethics’ project, which explored the everyday ethical challenges of resetting England’s NHS maternity and paediatrics services during the pandemic. Methods: Healthcare professionals and members of the public participated in interviews and focus group discussions. The qualitative methods are reported in detail elsewhere. The focus of this article is our use of Frith’s symbiotic empirical ethics methodology to work from our empirical findings towards the normative suggestion that clinical ethics should explicitly attend to the importance of relationships in clinical practice. This methodology uses a five-step approach to refine and develop ethical theory based on a naturalist account of ethics that sees practice and theory as symbiotically related. Results: The Reset project data showed that changed working practices caused ethical challenges for healthcare professionals, and that infection prevention and control measures represented harmful barriers to the experience of receiving and offering care. For healthcare professionals, offering care as part of a relational interaction was an ethically important dimension of healthcare delivery. Conclusions: Our findings suggest that foregrounding the importance of relationships across a hospital community will better promote the ethically important multi-directional expression of caring between healthcare professionals, patients, and their families. We offer two suggestions for making progress towards such a relational approach. First, that there is a change of emphasis in clinical ethics practice to explicitly acknowledge the importance of the relationships (including with their healthcare team) within which the patient is held. Second, that organisational decision-making should take into account the moral significance afforded to caring relationships by healthcare professionals, and the role such relationships can play in the negotiation of ethical challenges.
- Open Access
- 25 October 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Using symbiotic empirical ethics to explore the significance of relationships to clinical ethics: findings from the Reset Ethics research project
Background At the beginning of the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic, many non-Covid healthcare services were suspended. In April 2020, the Department of Health in England mandated that non-Covid services should resume, alongside the continuing pandemic response. This ‘resetting’ of healthcare services created a unique context in which it became critical to consider how ethical considerations did (and should) underpin decisions about integrating infection control measures into routine healthcare practices. We draw on data collected as part of the ‘NHS Reset Ethics’ project, which explored the everyday ethical challenges of resetting England’s NHS maternity and paediatrics services during the pandemic.Methods Healthcare professionals and members of the public participated in interviews and focus group discussions. The qualitative methods are reported in detail elsewhere [Chiumento, et al. 2023, forthcoming]. The focus of this article is our use of Frith’s symbiotic empirical ethics methodology to work from our empirical findings towards the normative suggestion that clinical ethics should explicitly attend to the importance of relationships in clinical practice. This methodology uses a five-step approach to refine and develop ethical theory based on a naturalist account of ethics that sees practice and theory as symbiotically related.Results The Reset project data showed that changed working practices caused ethical challenges for healthcare professionals, and that infection prevention and control measures represented harmful barriers to the experience of receiving and offering care. For healthcare professionals, offering care as part of a relational interaction was an ethically important dimension of healthcare delivery.Conclusions Our findings suggest that foregrounding the importance of relationships across a hospital community will better promote the ethically important multi-directional expression of caring between healthcare professionals, patients, and their families. We offer two suggestions for making progress towards such a relational approach. First, that there is a change of emphasis in clinical ethics practice to explicitly acknowledge the importance of the relationships (including with their healthcare team) within which the patient is held. Second, that organisational decision-making should take into account the moral significance afforded to caring relationships by healthcare professionals, and the role such relationships can play in the negotiation of ethical challenges.
- 25 October 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessUsing symbiotic empirical ethics to explore the significance of relationships to clinical ethics: findings from the Reset Ethics research project
Background At the beginning of the coronavirus (Covid-19) pandemic, many non-Covid healthcare services were suspended. In April 2020, the Department of Health in England mandated that non-Covid services should resume, alongside the continuing pandemic response. This ‘resetting’ of healthcare services created a unique context in which it became critical to consider how ethical considerations did (and should) underpin decisions about integrating infection control measures into routine healthcare practices. We draw on data collected as part of the ‘NHS Reset Ethics’ project, which explored the everyday ethical challenges of resetting England’s NHS maternity and paediatrics services during the pandemic.Methods Healthcare professionals and members of the public participated in interviews and focus group discussions. The qualitative methods are reported in detail elsewhere [Chiumento, et al. 2023, forthcoming]. The focus of this article is our use of Frith’s symbiotic empirical ethics methodology to work from our empirical findings towards the normative suggestion that clinical ethics should explicitly attend to the importance of relationships in clinical practice. This methodology uses a five-step approach to refine and develop ethical theory based on a naturalist account of ethics that sees practice and theory as symbiotically related.Results The Reset project data showed that changed working practices caused ethical challenges for healthcare professionals, and that infection prevention and control measures represented harmful barriers to the experience of receiving and offering care. For healthcare professionals, offering care as part of a relational interaction was an ethically important dimension of healthcare delivery.Conclusions Our findings suggest that foregrounding the importance of relationships across a hospital community will better promote the ethically important multi-directional expression of caring between healthcare professionals, patients, and their families. We offer two suggestions for making progress towards such a relational approach. First, that there is a change of emphasis in clinical ethics practice to explicitly acknowledge the importance of the relationships (including with their healthcare team) within which the patient is held. Second, that organisational decision-making should take into account the moral significance afforded to caring relationships by healthcare professionals, and the role such relationships can play in the negotiation of ethical challenges.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal of Law, Policy and The Family
- Vol. 37 (1)
Facial kinship verification and searching for genetic origins in gamete/embryo donor conception—an overview of potential legal and ethical issues
The aim of Facial Kinship Verification (FKV) technologies is to determine, by comparing images of their faces, whether two people are related genetically. FKV is developing rapidly, and it could be used to search for genetic relatives in a variety of ways and settings, such as searching for missing children or unknown parents. In this article, we focus on one area where this technology might have significant implications, the searching for gamete (egg and sperm) and embryo donor(s) by donor-conceived people. In many jurisdictions, donor-conceived people do not have access to information about their donor’s identity, and laws differ significantly in this area. We offer an initial overview of the legal and related ethical issues raised by FKV in this context, and touch on other areas where it might be used to find genetic relatives, as a starting point for further analysis and research.
- 1 January 2023
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal of Law, Policy and The Family
- Vol. 37 (1)
Facial kinship verification and searching for genetic origins in gamete/embryo donor conception—an overview of potential legal and ethical issues
The aim of Facial Kinship Verification (FKV) technologies is to determine, by comparing images of their faces, whether two people are related genetically. FKV is developing rapidly, and it could be used to search for genetic relatives in a variety of ways and settings, such as searching for missing children or unknown parents. In this article, we focus on one area where this technology might have significant implications, the searching for gamete (egg and sperm) and embryo donor(s) by donor-conceived people. In many jurisdictions, donor-conceived people do not have access to information about their donor’s identity, and laws differ significantly in this area. We offer an initial overview of the legal and related ethical issues raised by FKV in this context, and touch on other areas where it might be used to find genetic relatives, as a starting point for further analysis and research.
- Open Access
- 26 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 31 (1) , 83-108
RELATIONSHIPS, RIGHTS, AND RESPONSIBILITIES: (RE)VIEWING THE NHS CONSTITUTION FOR THE POST-PANDEMIC ‘NEW NORMAL’
Action needs to be taken to map out the fairest way to meet the needs of all NHS stakeholders in the post-pandemic ‘new normal’. In this article, we review the NHS Constitution, looking at it from a relational perspective and suggesting that it offers a useful starting point for such a project, but that new ways of thinking are required to accommodate the significant changes the pandemic has made to the fabric of the NHS. These new ways of thinking should encompass concepts of solidarity, care, and (reciprocal) responsibility, grounded in an acceptance of the importance of relationships in society. To this end, we explore and emphasise the importance of our interconnections as NHS stakeholders and ‘re-view’ the NHS Constitution from a relational perspective, concentrating on the rights and responsibilities it describes for patients and the public as NHS stakeholders. We argue that the NHS Constitution, of which most stakeholders are probably unaware, can be used as a tool to engage us, and to catalyse conversation about how our responsibilities as NHS stakeholders should change in the post-pandemic ‘new normal’.
- 26 August 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Medical Law Review
- Vol. 31 (1) , 83-108
Open AccessRELATIONSHIPS, RIGHTS, AND RESPONSIBILITIES: (RE)VIEWING THE NHS CONSTITUTION FOR THE POST-PANDEMIC ‘NEW NORMAL’
Action needs to be taken to map out the fairest way to meet the needs of all NHS stakeholders in the post-pandemic ‘new normal’. In this article, we review the NHS Constitution, looking at it from a relational perspective and suggesting that it offers a useful starting point for such a project, but that new ways of thinking are required to accommodate the significant changes the pandemic has made to the fabric of the NHS. These new ways of thinking should encompass concepts of solidarity, care, and (reciprocal) responsibility, grounded in an acceptance of the importance of relationships in society. To this end, we explore and emphasise the importance of our interconnections as NHS stakeholders and ‘re-view’ the NHS Constitution from a relational perspective, concentrating on the rights and responsibilities it describes for patients and the public as NHS stakeholders. We argue that the NHS Constitution, of which most stakeholders are probably unaware, can be used as a tool to engage us, and to catalyse conversation about how our responsibilities as NHS stakeholders should change in the post-pandemic ‘new normal’.
- Open Access
- 27 July 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 21 (8) , 34-37
Neither ‘Crisis Light’ nor ‘Business as Usual’: Considering the Distinctive Ethical Issues Raised by the Contingency and Reset Phases of a Pandemic
We have been researching the distinctive ethical issues raised by what we have called “the reset period,” when non-Covid services resumed alongside the continuing pandemic in the UK. In this commen...
- 27 July 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 21 (8) , 34-37
Open AccessNeither ‘Crisis Light’ nor ‘Business as Usual’: Considering the Distinctive Ethical Issues Raised by the Contingency and Reset Phases of a Pandemic
We have been researching the distinctive ethical issues raised by what we have called “the reset period,” when non-Covid services resumed alongside the continuing pandemic in the UK. In this commen...