Jorge García-Macía
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Jorge García-Macía has a total of 228 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Miguel Ferrer
Applied Ecology Group Estación Biológica de Doñana (CSIC) Seville Spain
9 shared publications Vicente Urios
9 shared publications- Virginia Morandini
Applied Ecology Group Estación Biológica de Doñana (CSIC) Seville Spain
8 shared publications - Vicente Urios
Universidad de Alicante
7 shared publications Carlos Torralvo
Fundación MIGRES
6 shared publicationsErnesto Álvarez
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 21 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Direct Killing, Poisoning, and Electrocution Drive High Human-induced Mortality of Raptor Populations in Africa
Raptor populations in Africa are rapidly declining, yet causes of mortality beyond poisoning are insufficiently known for most resident species. Our study aimed to investigate the causes of raptor mortality in Africa. We compiled 1,012 mortality records from 43 raptor species tracked with GPS transmitters in Africa between 2003 and 2026 to identify the main causes of mortality, estimate relative contribution of anthropogenic versus natural causes of mortality, and assess factors associated with mortality. Among 474 mortality records for which a cause of death could be assigned, 66.7% were classified as human-induced, with direct killing (24.4%), poisoning (23.6%), and electrocution (10.1%) being the three most frequently assigned specific causes. Human-induced mortality accounted for 58.8% of assigned mortality causes among migratory raptors (n = 233) and 74.3% among non-migratory raptors (n = 241). Predatory raptors had a higher prevalence of records classified as direct killing than vultures, with higher prevalence in urbanised than in rural landscapes and during the non-breeding season than during breeding or migration. Vultures had a higher prevalence of records classified as poisoning among adults than among immatures and in more rural/protected areas relative to urbanised areas. Among poisoned vultures (n = 103), 40.2% were classified as intentional poisoning. Records classified as electrocution occurred at similar rates in vultures and predatory raptors and were more frequent with greater urbanisation. Our results show the predominantly anthropogenic origin of raptor mortality in Africa, stressing the need for stronger conservation actions to reduce direct killing, poisoning, and electrocution.
- 21 October 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessDirect Killing, Poisoning, and Electrocution Drive High Human-induced Mortality of Raptor Populations in Africa
Raptor populations in Africa are rapidly declining, yet causes of mortality beyond poisoning are insufficiently known for most resident species. Our study aimed to investigate the causes of raptor mortality in Africa. We compiled 1,012 mortality records from 43 raptor species tracked with GPS transmitters in Africa between 2003 and 2026 to identify the main causes of mortality, estimate relative contribution of anthropogenic versus natural causes of mortality, and assess factors associated with mortality. Among 474 mortality records for which a cause of death could be assigned, 66.7% were classified as human-induced, with direct killing (24.4%), poisoning (23.6%), and electrocution (10.1%) being the three most frequently assigned specific causes. Human-induced mortality accounted for 58.8% of assigned mortality causes among migratory raptors (n = 233) and 74.3% among non-migratory raptors (n = 241). Predatory raptors had a higher prevalence of records classified as direct killing than vultures, with higher prevalence in urbanised than in rural landscapes and during the non-breeding season than during breeding or migration. Vultures had a higher prevalence of records classified as poisoning among adults than among immatures and in more rural/protected areas relative to urbanised areas. Among poisoned vultures (n = 103), 40.2% were classified as intentional poisoning. Records classified as electrocution occurred at similar rates in vultures and predatory raptors and were more frequent with greater urbanisation. Our results show the predominantly anthropogenic origin of raptor mortality in Africa, stressing the need for stronger conservation actions to reduce direct killing, poisoning, and electrocution.
- Open Access
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Wiley
Plasma chemistry of wild black kites (Milvus migrans) during fall migration via the Strait of Gibraltar: effects of age, sex, and body conditions
Hematology is increasingly used as a complementary tool in ornithology, particularly in the case of prey birds, because it can provide information on the ecology of individual animals, possible pathologies, body conditions, and behavioral patterns, as they are affected by nutritional status. The plasma biochemistry components can indicate the bird’s physiological situation; for this reason, they are commonly used in clinical settings. However, for its application in ecological studies, reference values from wild populations are needed. Here, we analyzed 11 blood biochemical parameters in black kites (Milvus migrans) captured in southern Spain during their fall migration to Africa. We did not find sex differences in any of them but did find differences in urea and ALP between age classes or in the interactions between age and sex. In addition, the body condition indices of adults were better (lower urea levels and higher BCI) than those of juveniles. In the case of ALP, lower values were found in adults than in juveniles, as we expected due to the conditions of different individuals prior to migration to Africa. We also compared urea levels and a body condition index. Our results demonstrate how blood chemistry reference values from wild populations, complemented with other data collected when handling birds in the field, can provide useful information on the nutritional status of wild birds.
- 6 October 2026
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessPlasma chemistry of wild black kites (Milvus migrans) during fall migration via the Strait of Gibraltar: effects of age, sex, and body conditions
Hematology is increasingly used as a complementary tool in ornithology, particularly in the case of prey birds, because it can provide information on the ecology of individual animals, possible pathologies, body conditions, and behavioral patterns, as they are affected by nutritional status. The plasma biochemistry components can indicate the bird’s physiological situation; for this reason, they are commonly used in clinical settings. However, for its application in ecological studies, reference values from wild populations are needed. Here, we analyzed 11 blood biochemical parameters in black kites (Milvus migrans) captured in southern Spain during their fall migration to Africa. We did not find sex differences in any of them but did find differences in urea and ALP between age classes or in the interactions between age and sex. In addition, the body condition indices of adults were better (lower urea levels and higher BCI) than those of juveniles. In the case of ALP, lower values were found in adults than in juveniles, as we expected due to the conditions of different individuals prior to migration to Africa. We also compared urea levels and a body condition index. Our results demonstrate how blood chemistry reference values from wild populations, complemented with other data collected when handling birds in the field, can provide useful information on the nutritional status of wild birds.
- Open Access
- 21 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Uncovering opportunities for a conservation-dependent raptor in Iberia: insights from Species Distribution Modelling
Understanding environmental drivers of species distributions is a central objective in ecology and biogeography, especially to guide further range expansion and inform evidence-based conservation actions for threatened populations. The Mediterranean Osprey ( Pandion haliaetus ) is highly threatened due to the small and fragmented nature of its populations. Consequently, several conservation projects, primarily involving translocations and reintroductions, have been implemented across the region in recent decades. In southern Spain, a reintroduced population currently comprises around 20 territorial pairs distributed in two breeding areas. However, Population Viability Analyses have highlighted the vulnerability of the population, suggesting that its long-term sustainability remains uncertain without additional management measures. Therefore, we used Species Distribution Models (SDMs) to identify suitable habitats and assess opportunities for future population expansion in southern Iberia, with the aim of informing reinforcement projects for the species. We found that occupancy probability increased in coastal or semi-coastal areas with warm and stable temperatures, higher annual precipitation, and greater availability of water bodies —both inland and coastal wetlands. Overall, highest occupancy probabilities were concentrated across southwestern Andalusia. Extensive surfaces of suitable but currently unoccupied habitats were identified, suggesting that habitat availability alone does not explain the recent population stagnation. Instead, we proposed that the spatial isolation of breeding nuclei, together with limited male dispersal, may have constrained further colonisation process. We therefore identified key water-dominated habitats appropriate to increase the distribution range of the species, connect the current breeding nuclei, and to increase the resistance of the population to human impacts and environmental stochasticity.
- 21 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessUncovering opportunities for a conservation-dependent raptor in Iberia: insights from Species Distribution Modelling
Understanding environmental drivers of species distributions is a central objective in ecology and biogeography, especially to guide further range expansion and inform evidence-based conservation actions for threatened populations. The Mediterranean Osprey ( Pandion haliaetus ) is highly threatened due to the small and fragmented nature of its populations. Consequently, several conservation projects, primarily involving translocations and reintroductions, have been implemented across the region in recent decades. In southern Spain, a reintroduced population currently comprises around 20 territorial pairs distributed in two breeding areas. However, Population Viability Analyses have highlighted the vulnerability of the population, suggesting that its long-term sustainability remains uncertain without additional management measures. Therefore, we used Species Distribution Models (SDMs) to identify suitable habitats and assess opportunities for future population expansion in southern Iberia, with the aim of informing reinforcement projects for the species. We found that occupancy probability increased in coastal or semi-coastal areas with warm and stable temperatures, higher annual precipitation, and greater availability of water bodies —both inland and coastal wetlands. Overall, highest occupancy probabilities were concentrated across southwestern Andalusia. Extensive surfaces of suitable but currently unoccupied habitats were identified, suggesting that habitat availability alone does not explain the recent population stagnation. Instead, we proposed that the spatial isolation of breeding nuclei, together with limited male dispersal, may have constrained further colonisation process. We therefore identified key water-dominated habitats appropriate to increase the distribution range of the species, connect the current breeding nuclei, and to increase the resistance of the population to human impacts and environmental stochasticity.
- 17 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (8) , e70546
Global change pressures reduce reproductive performance and increase conservation reliance in a declining steppe raptor
Impacts attributed to global change, such as weather anomalies, land‐use changes and anthropogenic disturbances, often provoke demographic catastrophes mediated by the deterioration of reproductive output, especially in slow‐paced animals, that is top predators, often used as biological indicators of ecosystem networks. In our study, we aimed to disentangle the bioclimatic variables affecting the breeding performance of a declining ground‐nesting raptor in southern Spain, the Montagu's harrier ( Circus pygargus ), a steppe‐specialist species highly affected by climate change and agricultural intensification. We also investigated how conservation measures implemented at nest scale modulated breeding outputs along with environmental variables. Furthermore, we assessed the long‐term viability of the population under different climatic and conservation scenarios. Our analyses suggested that the breeding performance of the population is positively influenced by spring and autumn precipitation, habitat heterogeneity and some conservation measures; on the other hand, it is negatively influenced by human disturbance. Our population viability analysis suggested that nest‐focused conservation measures—for example fences, unharvested buffers—may partially buffer the detrimental effects of weather anomalies. However, local conservation actions may not completely offset population decline in the long term. Policy implications . Our analyses suggest that the species will remain dependent on intensive, multi‐scale conservation actions in the long term, a pattern likely shared by many pseudo‐steppe and farmland birds affected by global change. Beyond nest‐focused conservation actions, integrative broad‐scale policies aiming to mitigate climate change, habitat homogenization and intensification of agronomic systems are essential to ensure the self‐sustainability of the population. In this sense, reforming the Common Agricultural Policy is essential to integrate the conservation of steppe birds into agricultural planning.
- 17 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Ecology
- Vol. 63 (8) , e70546
Global change pressures reduce reproductive performance and increase conservation reliance in a declining steppe raptor
Impacts attributed to global change, such as weather anomalies, land‐use changes and anthropogenic disturbances, often provoke demographic catastrophes mediated by the deterioration of reproductive output, especially in slow‐paced animals, that is top predators, often used as biological indicators of ecosystem networks. In our study, we aimed to disentangle the bioclimatic variables affecting the breeding performance of a declining ground‐nesting raptor in southern Spain, the Montagu's harrier ( Circus pygargus ), a steppe‐specialist species highly affected by climate change and agricultural intensification. We also investigated how conservation measures implemented at nest scale modulated breeding outputs along with environmental variables. Furthermore, we assessed the long‐term viability of the population under different climatic and conservation scenarios. Our analyses suggested that the breeding performance of the population is positively influenced by spring and autumn precipitation, habitat heterogeneity and some conservation measures; on the other hand, it is negatively influenced by human disturbance. Our population viability analysis suggested that nest‐focused conservation measures—for example fences, unharvested buffers—may partially buffer the detrimental effects of weather anomalies. However, local conservation actions may not completely offset population decline in the long term. Policy implications . Our analyses suggest that the species will remain dependent on intensive, multi‐scale conservation actions in the long term, a pattern likely shared by many pseudo‐steppe and farmland birds affected by global change. Beyond nest‐focused conservation actions, integrative broad‐scale policies aiming to mitigate climate change, habitat homogenization and intensification of agronomic systems are essential to ensure the self‐sustainability of the population. In this sense, reforming the Common Agricultural Policy is essential to integrate the conservation of steppe birds into agricultural planning.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Highlighting the relevance of fine-scale collision risk in wind farms: a pre-operational study in southern Spain
Wind energy is key to global decarbonization, yet wind farms can negatively impact wildlife, particularly through collision risk for flying species. Collision Risk Models (CRMs) are therefore a key component of Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs), and have evolved towards increasingly sophisticated frameworks. However, a gap often remains between current scientific knowledge and its application in EIAs, where collision risk is frequently assessed using coarse, wind farm–level metrics based on overall activity patterns. To evaluate the potential bias introduced by such generalized approaches, we conducted an experimental pre-operational study across four wind farms in southern Spain, encompassing 59 turbines. Using fine-scale spatial data collected through targeted field surveys over complete annual cycles during pre-operation phases, we quantified flight activity and collision risk of soaring-gliding birds at the turbine level. Both flight activity and estimated risk were highly heterogeneous among turbines and followed a strongly right-skewed distribution, with a small subset of turbines disproportionately contributing to overall risk. For example, ~80% of risky observations of soaring-gliding birds were concentrated in 26 turbines (44%). Moreover, we found mixed and inconsistent aggregation patterns of flying and risk rates at the wind farm-level: variance partitioning (PERMANOVA framework) indicated that wind farm identity explained a low-to-moderate proportion of the variance, while fine-scale, site-specific factors accounted for a larger share. Despite the local scope of our study and the need for further research to identify the environmental drivers underlying spatial heterogeneity also integrating year-to-year variability, our results highlight the importance of incorporating fine-scale spatial variability into EIAs. Identifying high-risk turbines can improve the ecological realism of collision risk assessments and provide actionable information to guide turbine siting and mitigation measures.
- 6 July 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessHighlighting the relevance of fine-scale collision risk in wind farms: a pre-operational study in southern Spain
Wind energy is key to global decarbonization, yet wind farms can negatively impact wildlife, particularly through collision risk for flying species. Collision Risk Models (CRMs) are therefore a key component of Environmental Impact Assessments (EIAs), and have evolved towards increasingly sophisticated frameworks. However, a gap often remains between current scientific knowledge and its application in EIAs, where collision risk is frequently assessed using coarse, wind farm–level metrics based on overall activity patterns. To evaluate the potential bias introduced by such generalized approaches, we conducted an experimental pre-operational study across four wind farms in southern Spain, encompassing 59 turbines. Using fine-scale spatial data collected through targeted field surveys over complete annual cycles during pre-operation phases, we quantified flight activity and collision risk of soaring-gliding birds at the turbine level. Both flight activity and estimated risk were highly heterogeneous among turbines and followed a strongly right-skewed distribution, with a small subset of turbines disproportionately contributing to overall risk. For example, ~80% of risky observations of soaring-gliding birds were concentrated in 26 turbines (44%). Moreover, we found mixed and inconsistent aggregation patterns of flying and risk rates at the wind farm-level: variance partitioning (PERMANOVA framework) indicated that wind farm identity explained a low-to-moderate proportion of the variance, while fine-scale, site-specific factors accounted for a larger share. Despite the local scope of our study and the need for further research to identify the environmental drivers underlying spatial heterogeneity also integrating year-to-year variability, our results highlight the importance of incorporating fine-scale spatial variability into EIAs. Identifying high-risk turbines can improve the ecological realism of collision risk assessments and provide actionable information to guide turbine siting and mitigation measures.
- Open Access
- 17 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Direct Killing, Poisoning, and Electrocution Drive High Human-induced Mortality of Raptors in Africa
Raptor populations in Africa are rapidly declining, yet causes of mortality are insufficiently known for most resident species understudied beyond poisoning. This study aimed to investigate the causes of raptor mortality on the African continent. We compiled 1012 mortality records from 43 raptor species tracked with GPS transmitters in Africa between 2003 and 2026 to identify the main causes of mortality, estimate the relative contribution of anthropogenic vs natural causes of mortality, and the factors affecting mortality. Human-induced mortality accounted for 58.8% of known mortality in migratory raptors (n = 233) and 74.3% in non-migratory raptors (n = 241). The main causes of known mortality were direct killing (24.4% of 474 records), poisoning (23.6%), and electrocution (10.1%). Predatory raptors were at higher risk of direct killing than vultures, had higher risk in urbanised than rural landscapes, for non-migrants compared to migrants, and during the non-breeding season compared to the breeding and migration seasons. Vultures had a higher risk of poisoning among adults compared to immatures and in more rural/protected areas relative to urbanised areas. Among poisoned vultures (n = 103), 40.2% were poisoned intentionally. Electrocution occurred at similar rates in vultures and predatory raptors, and more frequently with more urbanisation. The proportion of tracked birds for which cause of mortality could be identified increased over time but remained lower for non-migrants compared to migrants. Our results show the predominantly anthropogenic origin of raptor mortality in Africa, stressing the need for stronger conservation actions directed against direct killing, poisoning, and electrocution.
- 17 June 2026
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Open AccessDirect Killing, Poisoning, and Electrocution Drive High Human-induced Mortality of Raptors in Africa
Raptor populations in Africa are rapidly declining, yet causes of mortality are insufficiently known for most resident species understudied beyond poisoning. This study aimed to investigate the causes of raptor mortality on the African continent. We compiled 1012 mortality records from 43 raptor species tracked with GPS transmitters in Africa between 2003 and 2026 to identify the main causes of mortality, estimate the relative contribution of anthropogenic vs natural causes of mortality, and the factors affecting mortality. Human-induced mortality accounted for 58.8% of known mortality in migratory raptors (n = 233) and 74.3% in non-migratory raptors (n = 241). The main causes of known mortality were direct killing (24.4% of 474 records), poisoning (23.6%), and electrocution (10.1%). Predatory raptors were at higher risk of direct killing than vultures, had higher risk in urbanised than rural landscapes, for non-migrants compared to migrants, and during the non-breeding season compared to the breeding and migration seasons. Vultures had a higher risk of poisoning among adults compared to immatures and in more rural/protected areas relative to urbanised areas. Among poisoned vultures (n = 103), 40.2% were poisoned intentionally. Electrocution occurred at similar rates in vultures and predatory raptors, and more frequently with more urbanisation. The proportion of tracked birds for which cause of mortality could be identified increased over time but remained lower for non-migrants compared to migrants. Our results show the predominantly anthropogenic origin of raptor mortality in Africa, stressing the need for stronger conservation actions directed against direct killing, poisoning, and electrocution.
- Open Access
- 21 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 316
From reintroduction to extinction risk: Past, present and future of the newly established population of ospreys in southern Iberia
- 21 February 2026
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 316
Open AccessFrom reintroduction to extinction risk: Past, present and future of the newly established population of ospreys in southern Iberia
- Open Access
Regulation of the Dependence Period in Booted Eagles: Effects of Nutritional Condition
The post-fledging dependence period is a crucial stage in the development of altricial birds that may influence their future performance and fitness. This period is regulated by parental investment, in terms of food provisioning and protection, and the young’s demands associated with their development and physical condition. We examined post-fledging dependence regulation in 21 Booted Eagle (Hieraaetus pennatus) nestlings in southern Spain. We compared the dependence timing among juvenile birds from different territories. Here, we analyzed the blood plasma chemistry of nestlings in southern Spain and compared blood biochemistry parameters, including urea levels and a body condition index with the hatching date. Urea levels showed a stronger negative relationship with the length of dependence period than with the hatching date or body condition index. Our results support that better nourished nestlings attain independence later than those in an inferior condition, highlighting the potential of urea levels as a reliable indicator of nestling status. In this study, we describe the concentrations of selected chemical parameters in the plasma of free-living Booted Eagle nestlings, including chemical parameters that have been shown to be related to nutritional condition. Young with a better nutritional condition started dispersal later. Blood parameters can be used as a very useful complementary technique when approaching ecological issues. Early dispersal onset seems to be controlled by endogenous factors that are evolutionarily selected since it should provide inherent benefits in terms of future fitness.
Open AccessRegulation of the Dependence Period in Booted Eagles: Effects of Nutritional Condition
The post-fledging dependence period is a crucial stage in the development of altricial birds that may influence their future performance and fitness. This period is regulated by parental investment, in terms of food provisioning and protection, and the young’s demands associated with their development and physical condition. We examined post-fledging dependence regulation in 21 Booted Eagle (Hieraaetus pennatus) nestlings in southern Spain. We compared the dependence timing among juvenile birds from different territories. Here, we analyzed the blood plasma chemistry of nestlings in southern Spain and compared blood biochemistry parameters, including urea levels and a body condition index with the hatching date. Urea levels showed a stronger negative relationship with the length of dependence period than with the hatching date or body condition index. Our results support that better nourished nestlings attain independence later than those in an inferior condition, highlighting the potential of urea levels as a reliable indicator of nestling status. In this study, we describe the concentrations of selected chemical parameters in the plasma of free-living Booted Eagle nestlings, including chemical parameters that have been shown to be related to nutritional condition. Young with a better nutritional condition started dispersal later. Blood parameters can be used as a very useful complementary technique when approaching ecological issues. Early dispersal onset seems to be controlled by endogenous factors that are evolutionarily selected since it should provide inherent benefits in terms of future fitness.
- Open Access
- 13 January 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Lack of Avoidance Behavior in Wind Farms by Young Spanish Imperial Eagles
Wind farms are known to trigger avoidance behaviour leading to habitat loss in some raptors. The recovery of the Spanish imperial eagle, Aquila adalberti, in Cadiz, a Spanish province with a high density of wind farms, is of concern. Macro-displacement was studied by comparing juvenile density between wind farms and control areas. Meso-displacement was studied comparing actual density in each 200 m interval of distance around turbines against a random distribution, assuming no-avoidance, controlling for the influence of other environmental factors. We found no evidence of avoidance at macro scale. At meso scale, using density method, we did not find any evidence supporting eagle avoidance behaviour. The study of avoidance behaviours is an ongoing topic that can help to improve conservation and management decisions, especially for species sensitive to the presence of wind farms and other threatening infrastructures in their habitats.
- 13 January 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessLack of Avoidance Behavior in Wind Farms by Young Spanish Imperial Eagles
Wind farms are known to trigger avoidance behaviour leading to habitat loss in some raptors. The recovery of the Spanish imperial eagle, Aquila adalberti, in Cadiz, a Spanish province with a high density of wind farms, is of concern. Macro-displacement was studied by comparing juvenile density between wind farms and control areas. Meso-displacement was studied comparing actual density in each 200 m interval of distance around turbines against a random distribution, assuming no-avoidance, controlling for the influence of other environmental factors. We found no evidence of avoidance at macro scale. At meso scale, using density method, we did not find any evidence supporting eagle avoidance behaviour. The study of avoidance behaviours is an ongoing topic that can help to improve conservation and management decisions, especially for species sensitive to the presence of wind farms and other threatening infrastructures in their habitats.
- Open Access
How Accurate Are Population Predictions? Wind Farms and Egyptian Vultures as a Case Study
It is clear that scientists’ predictions must be rigorous and based on scientific evidence, but, even more, it is crucial to review scientific predictions after a reasonable time. However, predictions of published PVAs have rarely been contrasted with real populations’ trends over time. This is worrisome because this is the only way to keep learning and improve our ability to make more accurate predictions. In addition, conservation efforts can shift the initial predictions for the viability of threatened populations; thus, the evaluation of initial predictions becomes required over time. This is the case of the Egyptian vulture in Spain, where trajectories of real populations over the years differ from large-scale predictions. Its extinction in the Iberian Peninsula—due to mortality in wind farms, among other causes—was predicted by 2020, according to published viability analyses; yet, 14 years after this publication, not only did it not happen, but its national (and European) population remains stable and is even slightly increasing (+2.6%). These differences between predicted and observed trajectories of populations show the limitations of the simulations as a conservation tool and offer the opportunity to evaluate the used PVAs and the shortcomings that affected the assessment of the real trajectory of the species. With only four years of data available to simulate and generate 100-year predictions, along with the distribution and variance of mortality rates by collision in wind farms and an overestimation the number of pairs in risk areas, a clear relationship was assumed between predicted risk according to distances and the actual recorded mortality at wind farms, even though it is known that these are not closely related.
Open AccessHow Accurate Are Population Predictions? Wind Farms and Egyptian Vultures as a Case Study
It is clear that scientists’ predictions must be rigorous and based on scientific evidence, but, even more, it is crucial to review scientific predictions after a reasonable time. However, predictions of published PVAs have rarely been contrasted with real populations’ trends over time. This is worrisome because this is the only way to keep learning and improve our ability to make more accurate predictions. In addition, conservation efforts can shift the initial predictions for the viability of threatened populations; thus, the evaluation of initial predictions becomes required over time. This is the case of the Egyptian vulture in Spain, where trajectories of real populations over the years differ from large-scale predictions. Its extinction in the Iberian Peninsula—due to mortality in wind farms, among other causes—was predicted by 2020, according to published viability analyses; yet, 14 years after this publication, not only did it not happen, but its national (and European) population remains stable and is even slightly increasing (+2.6%). These differences between predicted and observed trajectories of populations show the limitations of the simulations as a conservation tool and offer the opportunity to evaluate the used PVAs and the shortcomings that affected the assessment of the real trajectory of the species. With only four years of data available to simulate and generate 100-year predictions, along with the distribution and variance of mortality rates by collision in wind farms and an overestimation the number of pairs in risk areas, a clear relationship was assumed between predicted risk according to distances and the actual recorded mortality at wind farms, even though it is known that these are not closely related.