Benedikt Barthel
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Benedikt Barthel has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Themistoklis P. Sapsis
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
4 shared publications - Beverley J. McKeon
Stanford University
2 shared publications - Bryce E. Harrop
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 3200 Innovation Blvd, K9-24, Richland, United States [US
2 shared publications - L. Ruby Leung
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory
2 shared publications - Shixuan Zhang
Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, PO Box 999, MSIN: K9-24, Richland, United States [US
2 shared publications A. Charalampopoulos
Department of Mechanical Engineering Massachusetts Institute of Technology Cambridge MA USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 January 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 18 (1)
A Probabilistic Framework for Learning Non‐Intrusive Corrections to Long‐Time Climate Simulations From Short‐Time Training Data
Despite advances in high performance computing, accurate numerical simulations of global atmospheric dynamics remain a challenge. The resolution required to fully resolve the vast range scales as well as the strong coupling with—often not fully‐understood—physics renders such simulations computationally infeasible over time horizons relevant for long‐term climate risk assessment. While data‐driven parameterizations have shown some promise of alleviating these obstacles, the scarcity of high‐quality training data and their lack of long‐term stability typically hinders their ability to capture the risk of rare extreme events. In this work we present a general strategy for training variational (probabilistic) neural network models to non‐intrusively correct under‐resolved long‐time simulations of turbulent climate systems. The approach is based on the paradigm introduced by Barthel Sorensen et al. (2024, https://doi.org/10.1029/2023ms004122 ) which involves training a post‐processing correction operator on under‐resolved simulations nudged toward a high‐fidelity reference. Our variational framework enables us to learn the dynamics of the underlying system from very little training data and thus drastically improve the extrapolation capabilities of the previous deterministic state‐of‐the art—even when the statistics of that training data are far from converged. We investigate and compare three recently introduced variational network architectures and illustrate the benefits of our approach on an anisotropic quasi‐geostrophic flow. For this prototype model our approach is able to not only accurately capture global statistics, but also the anistropic regional variation and the statistics of multiple extreme event metrics—demonstrating significant improvement over previously introduced deterministic architectures.
- 8 January 2026
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 18 (1)
Open AccessA Probabilistic Framework for Learning Non‐Intrusive Corrections to Long‐Time Climate Simulations From Short‐Time Training Data
Despite advances in high performance computing, accurate numerical simulations of global atmospheric dynamics remain a challenge. The resolution required to fully resolve the vast range scales as well as the strong coupling with—often not fully‐understood—physics renders such simulations computationally infeasible over time horizons relevant for long‐term climate risk assessment. While data‐driven parameterizations have shown some promise of alleviating these obstacles, the scarcity of high‐quality training data and their lack of long‐term stability typically hinders their ability to capture the risk of rare extreme events. In this work we present a general strategy for training variational (probabilistic) neural network models to non‐intrusively correct under‐resolved long‐time simulations of turbulent climate systems. The approach is based on the paradigm introduced by Barthel Sorensen et al. (2024, https://doi.org/10.1029/2023ms004122 ) which involves training a post‐processing correction operator on under‐resolved simulations nudged toward a high‐fidelity reference. Our variational framework enables us to learn the dynamics of the underlying system from very little training data and thus drastically improve the extrapolation capabilities of the previous deterministic state‐of‐the art—even when the statistics of that training data are far from converged. We investigate and compare three recently introduced variational network architectures and illustrate the benefits of our approach on an anisotropic quasi‐geostrophic flow. For this prototype model our approach is able to not only accurately capture global statistics, but also the anistropic regional variation and the statistics of multiple extreme event metrics—demonstrating significant improvement over previously introduced deterministic architectures.
- Open Access
- 26 March 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 16 (3)
A Non‐Intrusive Machine Learning Framework for Debiasing Long‐Time Coarse Resolution Climate Simulations and Quantifying Rare Events Statistics
Due to the rapidly changing climate, the frequency and severity of extreme weather is expected to increase over the coming decades. As fully‐resolved climate simulations remain computationally intractable, policy makers must rely on coarse‐models to quantify risk for extremes. However, coarse models suffer from inherent bias due to the ignored “sub‐grid” scales. We propose a framework to non‐intrusively debias coarse‐resolution climate predictions using neural‐network (NN) correction operators. Previous efforts have attempted to train such operators using loss functions that match statistics. However, this approach falls short with events that have longer return period than that of the training data, since the reference statistics have not converged. Here, the scope is to formulate a learning method that allows for correction of dynamics and quantification of extreme events with longer return period than the training data. The key obstacle is the chaotic nature of the underlying dynamics. To overcome this challenge, we introduce a dynamical systems approach where the correction operator is trained using reference data and a coarse model simulation nudged toward that reference. The method is demonstrated on debiasing an under‐resolved quasi‐geostrophic model and the Energy Exascale Earth System Model (E3SM). For the former, our method enables the quantification of events that have return period two orders longer than the training data. For the latter, when trained on 8 years of ERA5 data, our approach is able to correct the coarse E3SM output to closely reflect the 36‐year ERA5 statistics for all prognostic variables and significantly reduce their spatial biases.
- 26 March 2024
- Published by American Geophysical Union (AGU) in Journal of Advances in Modeling Earth Systems
- Vol. 16 (3)
Open AccessA Non‐Intrusive Machine Learning Framework for Debiasing Long‐Time Coarse Resolution Climate Simulations and Quantifying Rare Events Statistics
Due to the rapidly changing climate, the frequency and severity of extreme weather is expected to increase over the coming decades. As fully‐resolved climate simulations remain computationally intractable, policy makers must rely on coarse‐models to quantify risk for extremes. However, coarse models suffer from inherent bias due to the ignored “sub‐grid” scales. We propose a framework to non‐intrusively debias coarse‐resolution climate predictions using neural‐network (NN) correction operators. Previous efforts have attempted to train such operators using loss functions that match statistics. However, this approach falls short with events that have longer return period than that of the training data, since the reference statistics have not converged. Here, the scope is to formulate a learning method that allows for correction of dynamics and quantification of extreme events with longer return period than the training data. The key obstacle is the chaotic nature of the underlying dynamics. To overcome this challenge, we introduce a dynamical systems approach where the correction operator is trained using reference data and a coarse model simulation nudged toward that reference. The method is demonstrated on debiasing an under‐resolved quasi‐geostrophic model and the Energy Exascale Earth System Model (E3SM). For the former, our method enables the quantification of events that have return period two orders longer than the training data. For the latter, when trained on 8 years of ERA5 data, our approach is able to correct the coarse E3SM output to closely reflect the 36‐year ERA5 statistics for all prognostic variables and significantly reduce their spatial biases.
- Open Access
- 22 November 2023
- Published by Wiley
A Machine Learning Bias Correction of Large-scale Environment of Extreme Weather Events in E3SM Atmosphere Model
Large-scale dynamical and thermodynamical processes are common environmental drivers of extreme weather events. However, such large-scale environmental conditions often display systematic biases in climate simulations, posing challenges to evaluating extreme weather events and associated risks in current and future climate. In this paper, a machine learning (ML) approach was employed to bias correct the large-scale wind, temperature, and humidity simulated by the E3SM atmosphere model at $\sim 1^\circ$ resolution. The usefulness of the proposed ML approach for extreme weather analysis was demonstrated with a focus on three extreme weather events, including tropical cyclones (TCs), extratropical cyclones (ETCs), and atmospheric rivers (ARs). We show that the ML model can effectively reduce climate bias in large-scale wind, temperature, and humidity while preserving their responses to imposed climate change perturbations. The bias correction is found to directly improve the water vapor transport associated with ARs, and the representations of thermodynamical flows associated with ETCs. When the bias-corrected large-scale winds are used to drive a synthetic TC track forecast model over the Atlantic basin, the resulting TC track density agrees better with that of the TC track model driven by observed winds. In addition, the ML model insignificantly interferes with the mean climate change signals of large-scale storm environments as well as the occurrence and intensity of three extreme events. This study suggests that the proposed ML approach can be used to improve the downscaling of extreme weather events by providing more realistic large-scale storm environments simulated by low-resolution climate models.- 22 November 2023
- Published by Wiley
Open AccessA Machine Learning Bias Correction of Large-scale Environment of Extreme Weather Events in E3SM Atmosphere Model
Large-scale dynamical and thermodynamical processes are common environmental drivers of extreme weather events. However, such large-scale environmental conditions often display systematic biases in climate simulations, posing challenges to evaluating extreme weather events and associated risks in current and future climate. In this paper, a machine learning (ML) approach was employed to bias correct the large-scale wind, temperature, and humidity simulated by the E3SM atmosphere model at $\sim 1^\circ$ resolution. The usefulness of the proposed ML approach for extreme weather analysis was demonstrated with a focus on three extreme weather events, including tropical cyclones (TCs), extratropical cyclones (ETCs), and atmospheric rivers (ARs). We show that the ML model can effectively reduce climate bias in large-scale wind, temperature, and humidity while preserving their responses to imposed climate change perturbations. The bias correction is found to directly improve the water vapor transport associated with ARs, and the representations of thermodynamical flows associated with ETCs. When the bias-corrected large-scale winds are used to drive a synthetic TC track forecast model over the Atlantic basin, the resulting TC track density agrees better with that of the TC track model driven by observed winds. In addition, the ML model insignificantly interferes with the mean climate change signals of large-scale storm environments as well as the occurrence and intensity of three extreme events. This study suggests that the proposed ML approach can be used to improve the downscaling of extreme weather events by providing more realistic large-scale storm environments simulated by low-resolution climate models. - 1 November 2023
- Published by American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) in AIAA Journal
- Vol. 61 (11) , 4879-4896
Harnessing Instability Mechanisms in Airfoil Flow for Data-Driven Forecasting of Extreme Events
For certain Reynolds numbers, airfoils are subject to sporadic high-amplitude fluctuations in the aerodynamic forces. These extreme excursions may be seen as prototypical of the kind of unsteady and intermittent dynamics relevant to the flow around airfoils and wings in a variety of real-world applications. Here we investigate the instability mechanisms at the heart of these extreme events, and how they may be harnessed for efficient data-driven forecasting. Through a wavelet and spectral analysis of the pressure and vorticity, we find that the extreme events arise due to the instability of a specific frequency component distinct from the vortex shedding mode. During these events, this extreme event frequency draws energy from the energetically dominant vortex shedding flow and undergoes an abrupt transfer of energy from small to large scales. We propose a preprocessing algorithm to extract this extreme event frequency from the surface pressure data, which in conjunction with an extreme event-tailored loss function, allows us to avoid the commonly used long short-term memory architecture in favor of a simple feed-forward network—a significant reduction in cost over the previous state-of-the-art. Our model requires only three pressure sensors, and it is robust to their location—showing promise for the use of our model in dynamically varying applications. Finally, we show that relying solely on the statistics of the pressure and drag data for optimal sensor placement fails to improve model prediction over uniform or random sensor placement.
- 1 November 2023
- Published by American Institute of Aeronautics and Astronautics (AIAA) in AIAA Journal
- Vol. 61 (11) , 4879-4896
Harnessing Instability Mechanisms in Airfoil Flow for Data-Driven Forecasting of Extreme Events
For certain Reynolds numbers, airfoils are subject to sporadic high-amplitude fluctuations in the aerodynamic forces. These extreme excursions may be seen as prototypical of the kind of unsteady and intermittent dynamics relevant to the flow around airfoils and wings in a variety of real-world applications. Here we investigate the instability mechanisms at the heart of these extreme events, and how they may be harnessed for efficient data-driven forecasting. Through a wavelet and spectral analysis of the pressure and vorticity, we find that the extreme events arise due to the instability of a specific frequency component distinct from the vortex shedding mode. During these events, this extreme event frequency draws energy from the energetically dominant vortex shedding flow and undergoes an abrupt transfer of energy from small to large scales. We propose a preprocessing algorithm to extract this extreme event frequency from the surface pressure data, which in conjunction with an extreme event-tailored loss function, allows us to avoid the commonly used long short-term memory architecture in favor of a simple feed-forward network—a significant reduction in cost over the previous state-of-the-art. Our model requires only three pressure sensors, and it is robust to their location—showing promise for the use of our model in dynamically varying applications. Finally, we show that relying solely on the statistics of the pressure and drag data for optimal sensor placement fails to improve model prediction over uniform or random sensor placement.
- 28 January 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 7 (1) , 013905
Variational formulation of resolvent analysis
The conceptual picture underlying resolvent analysis is that the nonlinear term in the Navier-Stokes equations acts as an intrinsic forcing to the linear dynamics, a description inspired by control theory. The inverse of the linear operator, defined as the resolvent, is interpreted as a transfer function between the forcing and the velocity response. From a theoretical point of view this is an attractive approach since it allows for the vast mathematical machinery of control theory to be brought to bear on the problem. However, from a practical point of view, this is not always advantageous. The inversion of the linear operator inherent in the control theoretic definition obscures the physical interpretation of the governing equations and is prohibitive to analytical manipulation, and for large systems it leads to significant computational cost and memory requirements. In this work we suggest an alternative, inverse-free, definition of the resolvent basis based on an extension of the Courant–Fischer–Weyl min-max principle in which resolvent modes are defined as stationary points of a constrained variational problem. This definition leads to a straightforward approach to approximate the resolvent (response) modes of complex flows as expansions in any arbitrary basis. The proposed method avoids matrix inversions and requires only the spectral decomposition of a matrix of significantly reduced size as compared to the original system. To illustrate this method and the advantages of the variational formulation we present three examples. First, we consider streamwise constant fluctuations in turbulent channel flow where an asymptotic analysis allows us to derive closed form expressions for the optimal resolvent mode. Second, to illustrate the cost-saving potential and investigate the limits of the proposed method, we apply our method to both a two-dimensional, three-component equilibrium solution in Couette flow and, finally, to a streamwise developing turbulent boundary layer. For these larger systems we achieve a model reduction of up to two orders of magnitude. Such savings have the potential to open up RA to the investigation of larger domains and more complex flow configurations.
- 28 January 2022
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Fluids
- Vol. 7 (1) , 013905
Variational formulation of resolvent analysis
The conceptual picture underlying resolvent analysis is that the nonlinear term in the Navier-Stokes equations acts as an intrinsic forcing to the linear dynamics, a description inspired by control theory. The inverse of the linear operator, defined as the resolvent, is interpreted as a transfer function between the forcing and the velocity response. From a theoretical point of view this is an attractive approach since it allows for the vast mathematical machinery of control theory to be brought to bear on the problem. However, from a practical point of view, this is not always advantageous. The inversion of the linear operator inherent in the control theoretic definition obscures the physical interpretation of the governing equations and is prohibitive to analytical manipulation, and for large systems it leads to significant computational cost and memory requirements. In this work we suggest an alternative, inverse-free, definition of the resolvent basis based on an extension of the Courant–Fischer–Weyl min-max principle in which resolvent modes are defined as stationary points of a constrained variational problem. This definition leads to a straightforward approach to approximate the resolvent (response) modes of complex flows as expansions in any arbitrary basis. The proposed method avoids matrix inversions and requires only the spectral decomposition of a matrix of significantly reduced size as compared to the original system. To illustrate this method and the advantages of the variational formulation we present three examples. First, we consider streamwise constant fluctuations in turbulent channel flow where an asymptotic analysis allows us to derive closed form expressions for the optimal resolvent mode. Second, to illustrate the cost-saving potential and investigate the limits of the proposed method, we apply our method to both a two-dimensional, three-component equilibrium solution in Couette flow and, finally, to a streamwise developing turbulent boundary layer. For these larger systems we achieve a model reduction of up to two orders of magnitude. Such savings have the potential to open up RA to the investigation of larger domains and more complex flow configurations.
- Open Access
A Variational Formulation of Resolvent Analysis
The conceptual picture underlying resolvent analysis(RA) is that the nonlinear term in the Navier-Stokes(NS) equations provides an intrinsic forcing to the linear dynamics, a description inspired by control theory. The inverse of the linear operator, defined as the resolvent, is interpreted as a transfer function between the forcing and the velocity response. This inversion obscures the physical interpretation of the governing equations and is prohibitive to analytical manipulation, and for large systems leads to significant computational cost and memory requirements. In this work we suggest an alternative, inverse free, definition of the resolvent basis based on an extension of the Courant-Fischer-Weyl min-max principle in which resolvent modes are defined as stationary points of a constrained variational problem. This leads to a straightforward approach to approximate the resolvent (response) modes of complex flows as expansions in any basis. The proposed method avoids matrix inversions and requires only the spectral decomposition of a matrix of significantly reduced size as compared to the original system. To illustrate this method and the advantages of the variational formulation we present three examples. First, we consider streamwise constant fluctuations in turbulent channel flow where an asymptotic analysis allows us to derive closed form expressions for the optimal resolvent modes. Second, to illustrate the cost saving potential, and investigate the limits, of the proposed method we apply our method to both a 2-dimensional, 3-component equilibrium solution in Couette flow and, finally, to a streamwise developing turbulent boundary layer. For these larger systems we achieve a model reduction of up to two orders of magnitude. Such savings have the potential to open RA to the investigation of larger domains and more complex flow configurations.
Open AccessA Variational Formulation of Resolvent Analysis
The conceptual picture underlying resolvent analysis(RA) is that the nonlinear term in the Navier-Stokes(NS) equations provides an intrinsic forcing to the linear dynamics, a description inspired by control theory. The inverse of the linear operator, defined as the resolvent, is interpreted as a transfer function between the forcing and the velocity response. This inversion obscures the physical interpretation of the governing equations and is prohibitive to analytical manipulation, and for large systems leads to significant computational cost and memory requirements. In this work we suggest an alternative, inverse free, definition of the resolvent basis based on an extension of the Courant-Fischer-Weyl min-max principle in which resolvent modes are defined as stationary points of a constrained variational problem. This leads to a straightforward approach to approximate the resolvent (response) modes of complex flows as expansions in any basis. The proposed method avoids matrix inversions and requires only the spectral decomposition of a matrix of significantly reduced size as compared to the original system. To illustrate this method and the advantages of the variational formulation we present three examples. First, we consider streamwise constant fluctuations in turbulent channel flow where an asymptotic analysis allows us to derive closed form expressions for the optimal resolvent modes. Second, to illustrate the cost saving potential, and investigate the limits, of the proposed method we apply our method to both a 2-dimensional, 3-component equilibrium solution in Couette flow and, finally, to a streamwise developing turbulent boundary layer. For these larger systems we achieve a model reduction of up to two orders of magnitude. Such savings have the potential to open RA to the investigation of larger domains and more complex flow configurations.
- 4 August 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 924, A9
Closing the loop: nonlinear Taylor vortex flow through the lens of resolvent analysis
We present an optimization-based method to efficiently calculate accurate nonlinear models of Taylor vortex flow. Through the resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 658, 2010, pp. 336–382), we model these Taylor vortex solutions by treating the nonlinearity not as an inherent part of the governing equations but rather as a triadic constraint which must be satisfied by the model solution. We exploit the low-rank linear dynamics to calculate an efficient basis, the coefficients of which are calculated through an optimization problem to minimize the triadic consistency of the solution with itself as well as the input mean flow. Our approach constitutes, what is to our knowledge, the first fully nonlinear and self-sustaining, resolvent-based model in the literature. Our results compare favourably with the direct numerical simulation (DNS) of Taylor–Couette flow at up to five times the critical Reynolds number. Additionally, we find that as the Reynolds number increases, the flow undergoes a fundamental transition from a classical weakly nonlinear regime, where the forcing cascade is strictly down scale, to a fully nonlinear regime characterized by the emergence of an inverse (up scale) forcing cascade. Triadic contributions from the inverse and traditional cascade destructively interfere implying that the accurate modelling of a certain Fourier mode requires knowledge of its immediate harmonic and sub-harmonic. We show analytically that this is a direct consequence of the structure of the quadratic nonlinearity of the Navier–Stokes equations formulated in Fourier space. Finally, using our model as an initial condition to a higher Reynolds number DNS significantly reduces the time to convergence.
- 4 August 2021
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Journal of Fluid Mechanics
- Vol. 924, A9
Closing the loop: nonlinear Taylor vortex flow through the lens of resolvent analysis
We present an optimization-based method to efficiently calculate accurate nonlinear models of Taylor vortex flow. Through the resolvent formulation of McKeon & Sharma (J. Fluid Mech., vol. 658, 2010, pp. 336–382), we model these Taylor vortex solutions by treating the nonlinearity not as an inherent part of the governing equations but rather as a triadic constraint which must be satisfied by the model solution. We exploit the low-rank linear dynamics to calculate an efficient basis, the coefficients of which are calculated through an optimization problem to minimize the triadic consistency of the solution with itself as well as the input mean flow. Our approach constitutes, what is to our knowledge, the first fully nonlinear and self-sustaining, resolvent-based model in the literature. Our results compare favourably with the direct numerical simulation (DNS) of Taylor–Couette flow at up to five times the critical Reynolds number. Additionally, we find that as the Reynolds number increases, the flow undergoes a fundamental transition from a classical weakly nonlinear regime, where the forcing cascade is strictly down scale, to a fully nonlinear regime characterized by the emergence of an inverse (up scale) forcing cascade. Triadic contributions from the inverse and traditional cascade destructively interfere implying that the accurate modelling of a certain Fourier mode requires knowledge of its immediate harmonic and sub-harmonic. We show analytically that this is a direct consequence of the structure of the quadratic nonlinearity of the Navier–Stokes equations formulated in Fourier space. Finally, using our model as an initial condition to a higher Reynolds number DNS significantly reduces the time to convergence.