Michael A. Campion
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Michael A. Campion has a total of 32 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Emily D. Campion
University of Iowa
5 shared publications Julia Levashina
3 shared publications- Julia Levashina
Kent State University
2 shared publications Alexis A. Fink
Microsoft Corporation
1 shared publicationAndrew Barsa
1 shared publicationBrian J. Ruggeberg
Aon Consulting
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 5 November 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Applied Psychology
Natural language processing word dictionaries for personnel selection: Achieving explainable, generalizable, and incremental prediction with low impact when passively scoring narrative application information.
- 5 November 2026
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Applied Psychology
Natural language processing word dictionaries for personnel selection: Achieving explainable, generalizable, and incremental prediction with low impact when passively scoring narrative application information.
- Open Access
- 19 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 65 (1) , 235-255
Can Legal and Professional Personnel Selection Principles be Met With Machine Learning (Artificial Intelligence)?
The purpose of this article is primarily to evaluate whether machine learning (a form of artificial intelligence) can meet scientific, professional, and legal principles of personnel selection based on the rapidly accumulating research literature in Human Resource Management (HRM). It does so by addressing a series of questions in terms of what is known in the current research literature on these principles and related topics and by proposing a research agenda for what else needs to be studied. The review shows that there is enough current scientific evidence on the value of ML to support its use. ML tools are able to meet the basic principles of personnel selection and better meet many other very important principles. In addition, ML for personnel selection decisions is not a “black box” and can be understood and explained. It does not increase the legal risks from hiring, although it may require some additional steps in a few jurisdictions. There are uses of ML in selection that most organizations should be considering. Customized procedures will require good data, but generic vendor products may also serve some needs. Additional expertise may be required of HRM professionals, but not necessarily at a high level that would require new staffing or consultant expense. The availability of large language models (LLMs) may render unproctored remote assessments vulnerable to cheating, and all narrative candidate information provided in the future susceptible to AI‐generated text, resulting in more questions than research answers at this stage. The article ends with practical and theoretical implications for the use of ML in selection.
- 19 September 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 65 (1) , 235-255
Open AccessCan Legal and Professional Personnel Selection Principles be Met With Machine Learning (Artificial Intelligence)?
The purpose of this article is primarily to evaluate whether machine learning (a form of artificial intelligence) can meet scientific, professional, and legal principles of personnel selection based on the rapidly accumulating research literature in Human Resource Management (HRM). It does so by addressing a series of questions in terms of what is known in the current research literature on these principles and related topics and by proposing a research agenda for what else needs to be studied. The review shows that there is enough current scientific evidence on the value of ML to support its use. ML tools are able to meet the basic principles of personnel selection and better meet many other very important principles. In addition, ML for personnel selection decisions is not a “black box” and can be understood and explained. It does not increase the legal risks from hiring, although it may require some additional steps in a few jurisdictions. There are uses of ML in selection that most organizations should be considering. Customized procedures will require good data, but generic vendor products may also serve some needs. Additional expertise may be required of HRM professionals, but not necessarily at a high level that would require new staffing or consultant expense. The availability of large language models (LLMs) may render unproctored remote assessments vulnerable to cheating, and all narrative candidate information provided in the future susceptible to AI‐generated text, resulting in more questions than research answers at this stage. The article ends with practical and theoretical implications for the use of ML in selection.
- 2 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 65-86
Alternative Strategies to Criminal Background Checks for Reducing Risk to Organizations
- 2 August 2025
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 65-86
Alternative Strategies to Criminal Background Checks for Reducing Risk to Organizations
- 20 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Group Processes & Intergroup Relations
Toxic team climate: The causal role of psychopathic personality and lack of teamwork knowledge in dysfunctional team outcomes
We identify the central role of toxic team climate in understanding dysfunctional work teams. We develop and test a model identifying team-level psychopathic personality and teamwork knowledge as proximal contributors to the creation of toxic team climates, which mediates the effects to create dysfunctional team outcomes. We also tested an alternative model that treats teamwork knowledge as a moderator of the relationship between team psychopathy and toxic team climate. Using a four-wave longitudinal design, we evaluated these models in a sample of 508 business students comprising 107 student teams (35 MBA and 72 undergraduate) completing semester-long team projects. Results indicate that (1) teams with relatively higher levels of psychopathy and lower levels of teamwork knowledge were more likely to have toxic team climates, (2) teams with more toxic climates had higher levels of social loafing and interpersonal deviance, and lower team performance and satisfaction, and (3) the effects of psychopathy on dysfunctional outcomes were mediated by toxic team climate, but the effects of teamwork knowledge were not. In addition, teamwork knowledge moderated the relationship between team psychopathy and toxic team climate by reducing its effects. The study yields implications for the management of toxic work teams.
- 20 March 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Group Processes & Intergroup Relations
Toxic team climate: The causal role of psychopathic personality and lack of teamwork knowledge in dysfunctional team outcomes
We identify the central role of toxic team climate in understanding dysfunctional work teams. We develop and test a model identifying team-level psychopathic personality and teamwork knowledge as proximal contributors to the creation of toxic team climates, which mediates the effects to create dysfunctional team outcomes. We also tested an alternative model that treats teamwork knowledge as a moderator of the relationship between team psychopathy and toxic team climate. Using a four-wave longitudinal design, we evaluated these models in a sample of 508 business students comprising 107 student teams (35 MBA and 72 undergraduate) completing semester-long team projects. Results indicate that (1) teams with relatively higher levels of psychopathy and lower levels of teamwork knowledge were more likely to have toxic team climates, (2) teams with more toxic climates had higher levels of social loafing and interpersonal deviance, and lower team performance and satisfaction, and (3) the effects of psychopathy on dysfunctional outcomes were mediated by toxic team climate, but the effects of teamwork knowledge were not. In addition, teamwork knowledge moderated the relationship between team psychopathy and toxic team climate by reducing its effects. The study yields implications for the management of toxic work teams.
- Open Access
- 3 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 64 (4) , 1041-1055
Influence of Proctored Remote Versus Onsite Assessment on Candidate Scores, Assessment Types, Subgroup Differences, and Fairness Reactions
As more organizations move to remote hiring assessments, important questions emerge as to the effects on scores, racioethnic, and gender subgroup differences, and candidate reactions. We compare scores of candidates assessed remotely under proctored conditions ( N = 902) versus onsite ( N = 891) in an actual selection context in the same organization, in the same time period, and on the same cognitive ability tests, case exercises, and structured interviews. Controlling for job, there were no differences for cognitive ability tests or case exercises in the remote environment, but higher scores for structured interviews, leading to a slightly higher total score for all assessments combined and a 5% increase in the overall passing rate. Within groups, Hispanic or Latino candidates performed better on the remote cognitive ability test compared with Hispanic or Latino candidates onsite, while Asian candidates performed better remotely for the case exercise. All subgroups performed better on the remote structured interview compared with their onsite counterparts. No between‐group differences emerged by racioethnicity, but women outperformed men on the remote cognitive ability test compared to onsite. Candidate fairness reactions did not differ by test environment for any assessments or subgroups. We conclude that: (1) remote proctored assessments will not create lower overall passing rates (i.e., fewer candidates for hire); (2) differences in remote assessment scores may depend on the type of assessment, with the greatest positive differences for structured interviews; (3) remote assessments do not disadvantage racioethnic minority candidates or candidates overall; and (4) remote assessments do not reduce candidate fairness reactions.
- 3 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 64 (4) , 1041-1055
Open AccessInfluence of Proctored Remote Versus Onsite Assessment on Candidate Scores, Assessment Types, Subgroup Differences, and Fairness Reactions
As more organizations move to remote hiring assessments, important questions emerge as to the effects on scores, racioethnic, and gender subgroup differences, and candidate reactions. We compare scores of candidates assessed remotely under proctored conditions ( N = 902) versus onsite ( N = 891) in an actual selection context in the same organization, in the same time period, and on the same cognitive ability tests, case exercises, and structured interviews. Controlling for job, there were no differences for cognitive ability tests or case exercises in the remote environment, but higher scores for structured interviews, leading to a slightly higher total score for all assessments combined and a 5% increase in the overall passing rate. Within groups, Hispanic or Latino candidates performed better on the remote cognitive ability test compared with Hispanic or Latino candidates onsite, while Asian candidates performed better remotely for the case exercise. All subgroups performed better on the remote structured interview compared with their onsite counterparts. No between‐group differences emerged by racioethnicity, but women outperformed men on the remote cognitive ability test compared to onsite. Candidate fairness reactions did not differ by test environment for any assessments or subgroups. We conclude that: (1) remote proctored assessments will not create lower overall passing rates (i.e., fewer candidates for hire); (2) differences in remote assessment scores may depend on the type of assessment, with the greatest positive differences for structured interviews; (3) remote assessments do not disadvantage racioethnic minority candidates or candidates overall; and (4) remote assessments do not reduce candidate fairness reactions.
- Open Access
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 64 (3) , 879-899
Using Practice Employment Tests in Recruitment and Selection to Equalize Preparation Opportunities
Human resources (HR) managers struggle to manage the adverse impact‐validity tradeoff where some of the most predictive and affordable hiring procedures, such as mental ability tests, often result in lower hiring rates for racioethnic minority subgroups of candidates, thus creating legal risks due to anti‐discrimination laws. In this study, we examine whether employer‐sponsored practice testing will reduce subgroup differences in test performance by offering an equalizing preparation opportunity framework based on the tenant of access, including access to information and opportunities to perform. In a large diverse sample in an operational selection context (Npractice test = 29,626; Nactual test = 18,408; Nboth = 5078), we found that candidates who took the practice test scored higher on the actual tests than those who did not. All candidates benefitted by receiving an accurate estimate of passing the actual test and increasing their likelihood of applying. Further, racioethnic minorities realized greater score gains than racial non‐minorities, thereby reducing subgroup mean differences and subsequent adverse impact. The results were supportive for all major racioethnic minority subgroups (Asians, Blacks or African Americans, and Hispanics), and effect sizes were meaningfully large. Finally, we examined differences in other preparation tactics (e.g., gaining additional experience, using study guides) and found that racioethnic minorities were likely to use some tactics more than racioethnic non‐minorities, but not the most predictive tactics. We conclude that HR managers should consider equalizing preparation opportunities, specifically practice testing, to help address the adverse impact‐validity tradeoff by reducing impact without abandoning valid employment tests.
- 5 February 2025
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 64 (3) , 879-899
Open AccessUsing Practice Employment Tests in Recruitment and Selection to Equalize Preparation Opportunities
Human resources (HR) managers struggle to manage the adverse impact‐validity tradeoff where some of the most predictive and affordable hiring procedures, such as mental ability tests, often result in lower hiring rates for racioethnic minority subgroups of candidates, thus creating legal risks due to anti‐discrimination laws. In this study, we examine whether employer‐sponsored practice testing will reduce subgroup differences in test performance by offering an equalizing preparation opportunity framework based on the tenant of access, including access to information and opportunities to perform. In a large diverse sample in an operational selection context (Npractice test = 29,626; Nactual test = 18,408; Nboth = 5078), we found that candidates who took the practice test scored higher on the actual tests than those who did not. All candidates benefitted by receiving an accurate estimate of passing the actual test and increasing their likelihood of applying. Further, racioethnic minorities realized greater score gains than racial non‐minorities, thereby reducing subgroup mean differences and subsequent adverse impact. The results were supportive for all major racioethnic minority subgroups (Asians, Blacks or African Americans, and Hispanics), and effect sizes were meaningfully large. Finally, we examined differences in other preparation tactics (e.g., gaining additional experience, using study guides) and found that racioethnic minorities were likely to use some tactics more than racioethnic non‐minorities, but not the most predictive tactics. We conclude that HR managers should consider equalizing preparation opportunities, specifically practice testing, to help address the adverse impact‐validity tradeoff by reducing impact without abandoning valid employment tests.
- 1 May 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Organization Science
- Vol. 34 (3) , 1051-1072
Cultivating a Leadership Pipeline: Using a Real Options Lens to Understand Executives’ Strategic Staffing Decisions
This paper adapts real options theory to explain how executives create and maintain real options portfolios within leadership pipelines. Hypotheses flowing from our theorizing predict that executives often make seemingly risky staffing decisions for leaders who occupy stepping-stone positions. Focusing on their option (future potential) rather than project (current productivity) value, executives laterally transfer leaders in stepping-stone positions frequently, despite it resulting in lower short-term job performance, but often promote these leaders at lower levels of performance and sooner. Once leaders are promoted to destination positions where they may stay indefinitely, executives tend to transfer high-performing leaders more often but not when they are still improving the effectiveness of their current unit. We present evidence suggesting that executives make these decisions to improve other units and maintain a flexible system, possibly recapturing previous investments in developing those leaders. We provide empirical support for our hypotheses using eight years of data in a large retail organization (n = 25,004) where executives overseeing thousands of units made internal mobility decisions. These findings refine real options theory, show that it explains these phenomena better than existing theories, and provide important and immediately usable practical implications for executives. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2022.1608 .
- 1 May 2023
- Published by Institute for Operations Research and the Management Sciences (INFORMS) in Organization Science
- Vol. 34 (3) , 1051-1072
Cultivating a Leadership Pipeline: Using a Real Options Lens to Understand Executives’ Strategic Staffing Decisions
This paper adapts real options theory to explain how executives create and maintain real options portfolios within leadership pipelines. Hypotheses flowing from our theorizing predict that executives often make seemingly risky staffing decisions for leaders who occupy stepping-stone positions. Focusing on their option (future potential) rather than project (current productivity) value, executives laterally transfer leaders in stepping-stone positions frequently, despite it resulting in lower short-term job performance, but often promote these leaders at lower levels of performance and sooner. Once leaders are promoted to destination positions where they may stay indefinitely, executives tend to transfer high-performing leaders more often but not when they are still improving the effectiveness of their current unit. We present evidence suggesting that executives make these decisions to improve other units and maintain a flexible system, possibly recapturing previous investments in developing those leaders. We provide empirical support for our hypotheses using eight years of data in a large retail organization (n = 25,004) where executives overseeing thousands of units made internal mobility decisions. These findings refine real options theory, show that it explains these phenomena better than existing theories, and provide important and immediately usable practical implications for executives. Supplemental Material: The online appendix is available at https://doi.org/10.1287/orsc.2022.1608 .
- Open Access
- 13 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 61 (1) , 91-116
Assessing job crafting competencies to predict tradeoffs between competing outcomes
We introduce the job crafting competency construct and apply it to predict tradeoffs between competing outcomes that are inherent in job crafting, like performance and well‐being or engagement and withdrawal. Job crafting competencies are the clusters of individual knowledge, skills, and abilities that are necessary to achieve personal objectives through effective job crafting problem‐solving. We create a framework of job crafting competencies consisting of comprehensive/simplistic heuristic information use and approach/avoidance problem‐solving skills. In Study 1, we operationalize competencies as profiles demonstrated through an aptitude‐oriented assessment that predicts differences in outcomes. Five distinct profiles emerged in a sample of 174 workers. The high‐volume analytic problem‐solving profile was associated with higher performance and strain, while the ambivalent acquiescence profile was associated with lower performance and strain. The practical problem‐solving profile minimized tradeoffs between performance and strain. Rapid problem‐solving and low‐volume analytic problem‐solving profiles were variants in between these other patterns. Study 2 used a survey of 323 workers to support the uniqueness of the five competencies, and their relationships with approach/avoidance job crafting, engagement, and withdrawal. The research identifies a new job crafting individual difference (job crafting competencies) to delineate outcomes and tradeoffs according to unique competency profiles.
- 13 August 2021
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 61 (1) , 91-116
Open AccessAssessing job crafting competencies to predict tradeoffs between competing outcomes
We introduce the job crafting competency construct and apply it to predict tradeoffs between competing outcomes that are inherent in job crafting, like performance and well‐being or engagement and withdrawal. Job crafting competencies are the clusters of individual knowledge, skills, and abilities that are necessary to achieve personal objectives through effective job crafting problem‐solving. We create a framework of job crafting competencies consisting of comprehensive/simplistic heuristic information use and approach/avoidance problem‐solving skills. In Study 1, we operationalize competencies as profiles demonstrated through an aptitude‐oriented assessment that predicts differences in outcomes. Five distinct profiles emerged in a sample of 174 workers. The high‐volume analytic problem‐solving profile was associated with higher performance and strain, while the ambivalent acquiescence profile was associated with lower performance and strain. The practical problem‐solving profile minimized tradeoffs between performance and strain. Rapid problem‐solving and low‐volume analytic problem‐solving profiles were variants in between these other patterns. Study 2 used a survey of 323 workers to support the uniqueness of the five competencies, and their relationships with approach/avoidance job crafting, engagement, and withdrawal. The research identifies a new job crafting individual difference (job crafting competencies) to delineate outcomes and tradeoffs according to unique competency profiles.
- 26 August 2019
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 59 (3) , 291-306
Competency modeling: A theoretical and empirical examination of the strategy dissemination process
One of the most important functions of a competency model is to translate organizational strategy into employee behavior. Yet, virtually no theoretical attempts to elucidate this process exist, and no empirical evidence has been offered demonstrating that it occurs. Drawing on the strategic management literature, we develop a conceptual framework delineating this process. We theorize that structurally distributed knowledge, attention, and behavior results in coalitions of individuals at different hierarchical levels (top managers vs employees) developing different dominant logics. These differences across levels in habituated modes of processing information and conceptualizing roles impact the initial importance assigned to competencies that are added to the model as an organization's strategy evolves. However, over time, competency models enable top managers to drive their dominant logic downward through the organization. As the importance of certain competencies is reinforced through performance management, schemata of high‐performers shift, becoming better aligned with those of top managers'. Using data from focus groups, surveys, and archives collected at two points in time (6 years apart) capturing change in the strategy of an organization of professional jobs in the U.S. government (n= 218), results were supportive. We then use our model to generate an agenda of research questions and topics to enhance competency modeling scholarship.
- 26 August 2019
- Published by Wiley in Human Resource Management
- Vol. 59 (3) , 291-306
Competency modeling: A theoretical and empirical examination of the strategy dissemination process
One of the most important functions of a competency model is to translate organizational strategy into employee behavior. Yet, virtually no theoretical attempts to elucidate this process exist, and no empirical evidence has been offered demonstrating that it occurs. Drawing on the strategic management literature, we develop a conceptual framework delineating this process. We theorize that structurally distributed knowledge, attention, and behavior results in coalitions of individuals at different hierarchical levels (top managers vs employees) developing different dominant logics. These differences across levels in habituated modes of processing information and conceptualizing roles impact the initial importance assigned to competencies that are added to the model as an organization's strategy evolves. However, over time, competency models enable top managers to drive their dominant logic downward through the organization. As the importance of certain competencies is reinforced through performance management, schemata of high‐performers shift, becoming better aligned with those of top managers'. Using data from focus groups, surveys, and archives collected at two points in time (6 years apart) capturing change in the strategy of an organization of professional jobs in the U.S. government (n= 218), results were supportive. We then use our model to generate an agenda of research questions and topics to enhance competency modeling scholarship.