Gregor W. Schuurman
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Gregor W. Schuurman has a total of 109 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Brian W. Miller
U.S. Geological Survey, North Central Climate Adaptation Science Center, Boulder, USA
6 shared publications - David J. Lawrence
Climate Change Response Program National Park Service Fort Collins Colorado USA
5 shared publications - Amber N. Runyon
Climate Change Response Program, U.S. National Park Service
3 shared publications - Amy J. Symstad
U.S. Geological Survey, Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center Hot Springs SD 57747 USA
3 shared publications - Dawn Robin Magness
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Kenai National Wildlife Refuge Soldotna Alaska USA
3 shared publications - Joel H. Reynolds
Solutions Consulting, LLC Fort Collins Colorado USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Human Ecology
- Vol. 55 (3) , 41
How Indigenous Socio-Cultural Systems Resist, Accept, or Direct Ecological Transformation: A Research Agenda
Anthropogenic ecological transformations are challenging conventional environmental management paradigms, as maintaining historical ecological structures and functions becomes increasingly untenable. The resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework offers a strategic tool to navigate these shifts. However, as a product of the dominant socio-cultural system, the RAD framework risks perpetuating the same patterns of thinking that have contributed to unsustainable social-ecological dynamics. Indigenous socio-cultural systems, considered here through the lens of long-term coevolution with their environments, offer valuable empirical models for adaptive responses to environmental change. Such Indigenous socio-cultural responses, grounded in narratives, governance institutions, value systems, and other cultural elements collectively referred to as Indigenous Knowledge (IK), hold relevance for addressing today’s intertwined environmental and social challenges. We provide a targeted review of existing literature at the intersection of IK and the RAD framework, along with a broader conceptual overview of relevant insights across related fields. These reveal contrasting assumptions about Indigenous responses to environmental change, such as consistently resisting to preserve cultural fidelity or uniformly accepting, reflecting deeper cultural, temporal, and ecological complexity. We propose a structured research agenda to investigate Indigenous socio-cultural responses to environmental change through empirical research, theoretical synthesis, hypothesis development, and practical application. This agenda is grounded in comprehensive collaboration, emphasizing shared power and integrating both emic and etic perspectives throughout all stages of research and implementation. By bridging the adaptive dynamics of coevolved social-ecological systems and mainstream management strategies, an IK–RAD framework could enhance the efficacy of responses to global environmental change.
- 22 October 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Human Ecology
- Vol. 55 (3) , 41
Open AccessHow Indigenous Socio-Cultural Systems Resist, Accept, or Direct Ecological Transformation: A Research Agenda
Anthropogenic ecological transformations are challenging conventional environmental management paradigms, as maintaining historical ecological structures and functions becomes increasingly untenable. The resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework offers a strategic tool to navigate these shifts. However, as a product of the dominant socio-cultural system, the RAD framework risks perpetuating the same patterns of thinking that have contributed to unsustainable social-ecological dynamics. Indigenous socio-cultural systems, considered here through the lens of long-term coevolution with their environments, offer valuable empirical models for adaptive responses to environmental change. Such Indigenous socio-cultural responses, grounded in narratives, governance institutions, value systems, and other cultural elements collectively referred to as Indigenous Knowledge (IK), hold relevance for addressing today’s intertwined environmental and social challenges. We provide a targeted review of existing literature at the intersection of IK and the RAD framework, along with a broader conceptual overview of relevant insights across related fields. These reveal contrasting assumptions about Indigenous responses to environmental change, such as consistently resisting to preserve cultural fidelity or uniformly accepting, reflecting deeper cultural, temporal, and ecological complexity. We propose a structured research agenda to investigate Indigenous socio-cultural responses to environmental change through empirical research, theoretical synthesis, hypothesis development, and practical application. This agenda is grounded in comprehensive collaboration, emphasizing shared power and integrating both emic and etic perspectives throughout all stages of research and implementation. By bridging the adaptive dynamics of coevolved social-ecological systems and mainstream management strategies, an IK–RAD framework could enhance the efficacy of responses to global environmental change.
- Open Access
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 8 (6) , e70277
Is it assisted migration, conservation translocation, managed relocation, or another term? Best practices for clear communication when using translocation terminology
Translocations referred to as assisted migration, conservation translocation, managed relocation, and similar terms—which involve the intentional movement of organisms or propagative material from one area to another—can be useful for managing species and ecosystems under stress from climate change, invasive species, disease, or habitat loss. Different translocation actions carry different levels of risk, perceptions of which are confounded by translocation terms that have multiple meanings or nuanced differences in how they are used. As translocations are incorporated into policy, these terminological issues may affect decision‐making and associated outcomes. To avoid confusion and misunderstanding, we suggest a set of four best practices whenever using translocation terminology, including: (1) always define translocation terms, (2) use complete definitions that allow for unambiguous interpretations, (3) avoid identifying translocation terms as synonyms, and (4) avoid creating new translocation terms.
- 5 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Science and Practice
- Vol. 8 (6) , e70277
Open AccessIs it assisted migration, conservation translocation, managed relocation, or another term? Best practices for clear communication when using translocation terminology
Translocations referred to as assisted migration, conservation translocation, managed relocation, and similar terms—which involve the intentional movement of organisms or propagative material from one area to another—can be useful for managing species and ecosystems under stress from climate change, invasive species, disease, or habitat loss. Different translocation actions carry different levels of risk, perceptions of which are confounded by translocation terms that have multiple meanings or nuanced differences in how they are used. As translocations are incorporated into policy, these terminological issues may affect decision‐making and associated outcomes. To avoid confusion and misunderstanding, we suggest a set of four best practices whenever using translocation terminology, including: (1) always define translocation terms, (2) use complete definitions that allow for unambiguous interpretations, (3) avoid identifying translocation terms as synonyms, and (4) avoid creating new translocation terms.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by National Park Service
Adapting to Climate Change-Driven Loss of Ecologically Important Species and Processes from Park Ecosystems: A Study of Management Options for Glacier National Park Streams in the Context of National Park Service Policy and Guidance—Public Version
The traditional paradigm in mainstream environmental stewardship assumes a stationary climate in which climatic and ecological change generally occur within bounds (e.g., “natural range of variability”) and managers can conserve ecosystems by preserving their historically co-occurring species, natural communities, and physical and biological processes. For example, 2006 Management Policies, the current NPS management policies document, suggests that by preserving ecosystem components and processes in their natural condition, the NPS will prevent resource degradation and thus avoid any subsequent need for resource restoration. But climate change challenges these long-held assumptions. As local climates become increasingly inhospitable for historically occurring species, managers confront the paradox that maintaining historical (i.e., natural) ecosystem structure and ecological processes may be increasingly difficult with such species. This report examines the NPS policy context for a diversity of potential management responses to this paradox in Glacier National Park, illustrating a type of resource-management challenge that many other parks face. Here, the focus is on a mid- to lower-elevation reach of a lake-connected stream in Glacier National Park that is losing its native top-predator fish species—the bull trout (Salvelinus confluentus)—due to synergistic impacts of (1) climate change (e.g., stream warming and increasingly frequent and long low-flow periods in summer and fall, as well as increasing frequency of rain-on-snow events and associated streambed scour) and (2) the nonnative lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush), which preys on and competes with bull trout. Loss of a top predator in stream ecosystems can cause cascading changes in abundances of other species and in resource flows throughout the aquatic food web and interconnected terrestrial ecosystems. To inform ongoing development of policy and guidance for climate-informed stewardship, this analysis considers potential management strategies developed using the resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework. It considers these strategies against NPS policies to identify where policy is prescriptive, permissive, prohibitory, or unclear, and concludes that current policy—as augmented by the August 2024 Policy Memorandum 24-03 (Managing National Parks in an Era of Climate Change)—recognizes the challenge and instructs managers not to expect park ecosystems to resemble those of the past and to plan and manage for future climatic and associated ecological conditions. Furthermore, NPS policy both expects managers to adapt to climate change “including by proactively resisting, accepting, or directing its impacts” and acknowledges that such actions may entail novel approaches, including substantial interventions or divestment of activities.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by National Park Service
Adapting to Climate Change-Driven Loss of Ecologically Important Species and Processes from Park Ecosystems: A Study of Management Options for Glacier National Park Streams in the Context of National Park Service Policy and Guidance—Public Version
The traditional paradigm in mainstream environmental stewardship assumes a stationary climate in which climatic and ecological change generally occur within bounds (e.g., “natural range of variability”) and managers can conserve ecosystems by preserving their historically co-occurring species, natural communities, and physical and biological processes. For example, 2006 Management Policies, the current NPS management policies document, suggests that by preserving ecosystem components and processes in their natural condition, the NPS will prevent resource degradation and thus avoid any subsequent need for resource restoration. But climate change challenges these long-held assumptions. As local climates become increasingly inhospitable for historically occurring species, managers confront the paradox that maintaining historical (i.e., natural) ecosystem structure and ecological processes may be increasingly difficult with such species. This report examines the NPS policy context for a diversity of potential management responses to this paradox in Glacier National Park, illustrating a type of resource-management challenge that many other parks face. Here, the focus is on a mid- to lower-elevation reach of a lake-connected stream in Glacier National Park that is losing its native top-predator fish species—the bull trout (Salvelinus confluentus)—due to synergistic impacts of (1) climate change (e.g., stream warming and increasingly frequent and long low-flow periods in summer and fall, as well as increasing frequency of rain-on-snow events and associated streambed scour) and (2) the nonnative lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush), which preys on and competes with bull trout. Loss of a top predator in stream ecosystems can cause cascading changes in abundances of other species and in resource flows throughout the aquatic food web and interconnected terrestrial ecosystems. To inform ongoing development of policy and guidance for climate-informed stewardship, this analysis considers potential management strategies developed using the resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework. It considers these strategies against NPS policies to identify where policy is prescriptive, permissive, prohibitory, or unclear, and concludes that current policy—as augmented by the August 2024 Policy Memorandum 24-03 (Managing National Parks in an Era of Climate Change)—recognizes the challenge and instructs managers not to expect park ecosystems to resemble those of the past and to plan and manage for future climatic and associated ecological conditions. Furthermore, NPS policy both expects managers to adapt to climate change “including by proactively resisting, accepting, or directing its impacts” and acknowledges that such actions may entail novel approaches, including substantial interventions or divestment of activities.
- Open Access
- 12 June 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
- Vol. 76 (10) , 1203-1211
Applying the resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework to wildlife health management
Wildlife diseases can have substantial impacts on wildlife populations as well as on human and domestic animal health and well-being. Although many agencies and stakeholders share a goal of supporting wildlife health, reducing wildlife disease burden is complicated by a scarcity of effective interventions for wildlife, competition for funds, and conflicting priorities. As a result, agencies are unlikely to avoid the impacts of wildlife diseases in all contexts and need to evaluate where resisting disease is most feasible and beneficial. The resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework is a tool that assists natural resource managers in exploring and communicating about management interventions, including in situations where resisting ecological changes may not be possible. In the present article, we discuss how the RAD framework could be adapted to wildlife disease contexts to address several outstanding challenges in wildlife health management.
- 12 June 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
- Vol. 76 (10) , 1203-1211
Open AccessApplying the resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework to wildlife health management
Wildlife diseases can have substantial impacts on wildlife populations as well as on human and domestic animal health and well-being. Although many agencies and stakeholders share a goal of supporting wildlife health, reducing wildlife disease burden is complicated by a scarcity of effective interventions for wildlife, competition for funds, and conflicting priorities. As a result, agencies are unlikely to avoid the impacts of wildlife diseases in all contexts and need to evaluate where resisting disease is most feasible and beneficial. The resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework is a tool that assists natural resource managers in exploring and communicating about management interventions, including in situations where resisting ecological changes may not be possible. In the present article, we discuss how the RAD framework could be adapted to wildlife disease contexts to address several outstanding challenges in wildlife health management.
- Open Access
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 39 (4) , e70062
Clarifying the role of the resist–accept–direct framework in supporting resource management planning processes
- 20 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Conservation Biology
- Vol. 39 (4) , e70062
Open AccessClarifying the role of the resist–accept–direct framework in supporting resource management planning processes
- 1 January 2025
- Published by National Park Service
Adapting to climate change-driven loss of ecologically important species and processes from park ecosystems: A study of management options for Glacier National Park streams in the context of National Park Service policy and guidance
The traditional paradigm in mainstream environmental stewardship assumes a stationary climate in which climatic and ecological change generally occur within bounds (e.g., “natural range of variability”) and managers can conserve ecosystems by preserving their historically co-occurring species, natural communities, and physical and biological processes. For example, 2006 Management Policies, the current NPS management policies document, suggests that by preserving ecosystem components and processes in their natural condition, the NPS will prevent resource degradation and thus avoid any subsequent need for resource restoration. But climate change challenges these long-held assumptions. As local climates become increasingly inhospitable for historically occurring species, managers confront the paradox that maintaining historical (i.e., natural) ecosystem structure and ecological processes may be increasingly difficult with such species. This report examines the NPS policy context for a diversity of potential management responses to this paradox in Glacier National Park, illustrating a type of resource-management challenge that many other parks face. Here, the focus is on a mid- to lower-elevation reach of a lake-connected stream in Glacier National Park that is losing its native top-predator fish species—the bull trout (Salvelinus confluentus)—due to synergistic impacts of (1) climate change (e.g., stream warming and increasingly frequent and long low-flow periods in summer and fall, as well as increasing frequency of rain-on-snow events and associated streambed scour) and (2) the nonnative lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush), which preys on and competes with bull trout. Loss of a top predator in stream ecosystems can cause cascading changes in abundances of other species and in resource flows throughout the aquatic food web and interconnected terrestrial ecosystems. To inform ongoing development of policy and guidance for climate-informed stewardship, this analysis considers potential management strategies developed using the resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework. It considers these strategies against NPS policies to identify where policy is prescriptive, permissive, prohibitory, or unclear, and concludes that current policy—as augmented by the August-2024 Policy Memorandum 24-03 (Managing National Parks in an Era of Climate Change)—recognizes the challenge and instructs managers not to expect park ecosystems to resemble those of the past and to plan and manage for future climatic and associated ecological conditions. Furthermore, NPS policy both expects managers to adapt to climate change “including by proactively resisting, accepting, or directing its impacts” and acknowledges that such actions may entail novel approaches, including substantial interventions or divestment of activities.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by National Park Service
Adapting to climate change-driven loss of ecologically important species and processes from park ecosystems: A study of management options for Glacier National Park streams in the context of National Park Service policy and guidance
The traditional paradigm in mainstream environmental stewardship assumes a stationary climate in which climatic and ecological change generally occur within bounds (e.g., “natural range of variability”) and managers can conserve ecosystems by preserving their historically co-occurring species, natural communities, and physical and biological processes. For example, 2006 Management Policies, the current NPS management policies document, suggests that by preserving ecosystem components and processes in their natural condition, the NPS will prevent resource degradation and thus avoid any subsequent need for resource restoration. But climate change challenges these long-held assumptions. As local climates become increasingly inhospitable for historically occurring species, managers confront the paradox that maintaining historical (i.e., natural) ecosystem structure and ecological processes may be increasingly difficult with such species. This report examines the NPS policy context for a diversity of potential management responses to this paradox in Glacier National Park, illustrating a type of resource-management challenge that many other parks face. Here, the focus is on a mid- to lower-elevation reach of a lake-connected stream in Glacier National Park that is losing its native top-predator fish species—the bull trout (Salvelinus confluentus)—due to synergistic impacts of (1) climate change (e.g., stream warming and increasingly frequent and long low-flow periods in summer and fall, as well as increasing frequency of rain-on-snow events and associated streambed scour) and (2) the nonnative lake trout (Salvelinus namaycush), which preys on and competes with bull trout. Loss of a top predator in stream ecosystems can cause cascading changes in abundances of other species and in resource flows throughout the aquatic food web and interconnected terrestrial ecosystems. To inform ongoing development of policy and guidance for climate-informed stewardship, this analysis considers potential management strategies developed using the resist–accept–direct (RAD) framework. It considers these strategies against NPS policies to identify where policy is prescriptive, permissive, prohibitory, or unclear, and concludes that current policy—as augmented by the August-2024 Policy Memorandum 24-03 (Managing National Parks in an Era of Climate Change)—recognizes the challenge and instructs managers not to expect park ecosystems to resemble those of the past and to plan and manage for future climatic and associated ecological conditions. Furthermore, NPS policy both expects managers to adapt to climate change “including by proactively resisting, accepting, or directing its impacts” and acknowledges that such actions may entail novel approaches, including substantial interventions or divestment of activities.
- Open Access
- 12 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 14 (9) , e70044
Range‐wide population genomic structure of the Karner blue butterfly, Plebejus ( Lycaeides ) samuelis
The Karner blue butterfly, Plebejus ( Lycaeides ) samuelis , is an endangered North American climate change‐vulnerable species that has undergone substantial historical habitat loss and population decline. To better understand the species' genetic status and support Karner blue conservation, we sampled 116 individuals from 22 localities across the species' geographical range in Wisconsin (WI), Michigan (MI), Indiana (IN), and New York (NY). Using genomic analysis, we found that these samples were divided into three major geographic groups, NY, WI, and MI‐IN, with populations in WI and MI‐IN each further divided into three subgroups. A high level of inbreeding was revealed by inbreeding coefficients above 10% in almost all populations in our study. However, strong correlation between F ST and geographical distance suggested that genetic divergence between populations increases with distance, such that introducing individuals from more distant populations may be a useful strategy for increasing population‐level diversity and preserving the species. We also found that Karner blue populations had lower genetic diversity than closely related species and had more alleles that were present only at low frequencies (<5%) in other species. Some of these alleles may negatively impact individual fitness and may have become prevalent in Karner blue populations due to inbreeding. Finally, analysis of these possibly deleterious alleles in the context of predicted three‐dimensional structures of proteins revealed potential molecular mechanisms behind population declines, providing insights for conservation. This rich new range‐wide understanding of the species' population genomic structure can contextualize past extirpations and help conserve and even enhance Karner blue genetic diversity.
- 12 September 2024
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 14 (9) , e70044
Open AccessRange‐wide population genomic structure of the Karner blue butterfly, Plebejus ( Lycaeides ) samuelis
The Karner blue butterfly, Plebejus ( Lycaeides ) samuelis , is an endangered North American climate change‐vulnerable species that has undergone substantial historical habitat loss and population decline. To better understand the species' genetic status and support Karner blue conservation, we sampled 116 individuals from 22 localities across the species' geographical range in Wisconsin (WI), Michigan (MI), Indiana (IN), and New York (NY). Using genomic analysis, we found that these samples were divided into three major geographic groups, NY, WI, and MI‐IN, with populations in WI and MI‐IN each further divided into three subgroups. A high level of inbreeding was revealed by inbreeding coefficients above 10% in almost all populations in our study. However, strong correlation between F ST and geographical distance suggested that genetic divergence between populations increases with distance, such that introducing individuals from more distant populations may be a useful strategy for increasing population‐level diversity and preserving the species. We also found that Karner blue populations had lower genetic diversity than closely related species and had more alleles that were present only at low frequencies (<5%) in other species. Some of these alleles may negatively impact individual fitness and may have become prevalent in Karner blue populations due to inbreeding. Finally, analysis of these possibly deleterious alleles in the context of predicted three‐dimensional structures of proteins revealed potential molecular mechanisms behind population declines, providing insights for conservation. This rich new range‐wide understanding of the species' population genomic structure can contextualize past extirpations and help conserve and even enhance Karner blue genetic diversity.
- Open Access
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Society & Natural Resources
- Vol. 38 (3) , 293-298
Accurately Characterizing Climate Change Scenario Planning in the U.S. National Park Service: Comment on Murphy et al. 2023
Murphy et al. (2023) assess adoption of climate change scenario planning (CC SP) in a subset of US federal public land management agencies, with a focus on the US Forest Service. However, by broadl...
- 4 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Society & Natural Resources
- Vol. 38 (3) , 293-298
Open AccessAccurately Characterizing Climate Change Scenario Planning in the U.S. National Park Service: Comment on Murphy et al. 2023
Murphy et al. (2023) assess adoption of climate change scenario planning (CC SP) in a subset of US federal public land management agencies, with a focus on the US Forest Service. However, by broadl...
- 1 January 2024
- Published by National Park Service
Climate change adaptation practices and possibilities considered by the National Park Service Alaska Leadership Council in 2019: Summary of an ALC exercise (technical assistance request 10860)
Profound climate change-driven environmental changes observed in Alaska prompted the National Park Service’s Alaska Leadership Council (ALC) to dedicate a half-day of their September 2019 meeting to understanding and addressing key climate change vulnerabilities. The session aimed to introduce participants to the Resist-Accept-Direct (RAD) framework—an emerging framing tool for exploring the “universe” of potential adaptation actions—and to initiate broader discussion regarding current and potential future adaptation actions in each of Alaska’s national parks. Participating superintendents were asked to both identify ongoing actions in their parks in response to climate change and brainstorm potential future actions. This report summarizes and analyzes their responses. To gauge the extent to which participants were exploring the full adaptation decision space and to better understand how to apply the RAD framework, actions were further classified as reflecting one of the three RAD categories: resistance, acceptance, or directing of change. Roughly half of all submissions were adaptation actions. Of these adaptation actions, nearly a third were subsistence-related, reflecting the importance of subsistence in the Alaska region. Most adaptation actions were focused on resisting climate change impacts on resources, assets, and people. The exercise clarified the need to understand what constitutes an adaptation action. For example, a decision to support or conduct a research project is different than a decision to use that research to take adaptive action. More importantly, the exercise showed that evaluating the degree to which participants explored the full adaptation decision space—i.e., by classifying each action under the RAD framework—requires that the motivating intention or goal of the action be clearly articulated. For example, “plant(ing) vegetation after disturbance” can be a resistance or a directing-change action depending on whether the motivation is to (a) plant historically occurring species in historically occurring proportions to restore pre-disturbance conditions or to (b) favor species adapted to emerging and projected conditions. This important lesson in RAD framework application underscores the need to request a higher degree of specificity about the motivations behind potential actions in adaptation planning processes. This report documents the ALC’s thinking on climate change adaptation at one point (snapshot) in time. It shows that many of the adaptation actions identified by participants focused on resisting climate change impacts, empowers assessment of the evolution of adaptation action by the NPS ALC, helps to clarify how best to use the RAD framework, and, ideally, prompts further discussion and adaptation action in Alaska.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by National Park Service
Climate change adaptation practices and possibilities considered by the National Park Service Alaska Leadership Council in 2019: Summary of an ALC exercise (technical assistance request 10860)
Profound climate change-driven environmental changes observed in Alaska prompted the National Park Service’s Alaska Leadership Council (ALC) to dedicate a half-day of their September 2019 meeting to understanding and addressing key climate change vulnerabilities. The session aimed to introduce participants to the Resist-Accept-Direct (RAD) framework—an emerging framing tool for exploring the “universe” of potential adaptation actions—and to initiate broader discussion regarding current and potential future adaptation actions in each of Alaska’s national parks. Participating superintendents were asked to both identify ongoing actions in their parks in response to climate change and brainstorm potential future actions. This report summarizes and analyzes their responses. To gauge the extent to which participants were exploring the full adaptation decision space and to better understand how to apply the RAD framework, actions were further classified as reflecting one of the three RAD categories: resistance, acceptance, or directing of change. Roughly half of all submissions were adaptation actions. Of these adaptation actions, nearly a third were subsistence-related, reflecting the importance of subsistence in the Alaska region. Most adaptation actions were focused on resisting climate change impacts on resources, assets, and people. The exercise clarified the need to understand what constitutes an adaptation action. For example, a decision to support or conduct a research project is different than a decision to use that research to take adaptive action. More importantly, the exercise showed that evaluating the degree to which participants explored the full adaptation decision space—i.e., by classifying each action under the RAD framework—requires that the motivating intention or goal of the action be clearly articulated. For example, “plant(ing) vegetation after disturbance” can be a resistance or a directing-change action depending on whether the motivation is to (a) plant historically occurring species in historically occurring proportions to restore pre-disturbance conditions or to (b) favor species adapted to emerging and projected conditions. This important lesson in RAD framework application underscores the need to request a higher degree of specificity about the motivations behind potential actions in adaptation planning processes. This report documents the ALC’s thinking on climate change adaptation at one point (snapshot) in time. It shows that many of the adaptation actions identified by participants focused on resisting climate change impacts, empowers assessment of the evolution of adaptation action by the NPS ALC, helps to clarify how best to use the RAD framework, and, ideally, prompts further discussion and adaptation action in Alaska.
- Open Access
- 29 September 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 286
Scenario-Based Decision Analysis: Integrated scenario planning and structured decision making for resource management under climate change
- 29 September 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Biological Conservation
- Vol. 286
Open AccessScenario-Based Decision Analysis: Integrated scenario planning and structured decision making for resource management under climate change