Inna Berdnik
Research Subjects
Inna Berdnik has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Михайло Пузирьов
National Academy of the National Guard of Ukraine
2 shared publications - Chernihiv Academy Of The State Penitentiary Service1 shared publication
- Ihor Pylypenko
Prosecutor’s Training Center of Ukraine (Kyiv, Ukraine)
1 shared publication K.A. Berebenets
1 shared publication- S.R. Tahiiev1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Lviv University of Business and Law in Academic Visions
- No. 54
Tools for Protecting Prosecutorial Independence: International Practice in Examining Notifications of Threats to Prosecutorial Independence
This article examines the national legal mechanisms for safeguarding prosecutorial independence as one of the fundamental guarantees of the effective functioning of the prosecution service and the implementation of the rule of law. Particular attention is paid to the mechanism for reviewing notifications of threats to prosecutorial independence, the activities of the Council of Prosecutors of Ukraine, and the analysis of its law enforcement practice. The purpose of the study is to analyse the national instruments for ensuring prosecutorial independence, determine their legal nature, examine the practical application of the mechanism for protecting prosecutorial independence, and formulate the author's approaches to distinguishing the concepts of «influence», «pressure», and «interference» in the professional activities of prosecutors. To achieve this objective, the study employs a combination of general scientific and special legal research methods, including the dialectical method, the formal legal method, the comparative legal method, the systemic-structural method, and the method of generalising judicial and disciplinary practice. The findings demonstrate that prosecutorial independence is a complex legal concept ensured through a system of interrelated legal, organisational, procedural, material, and institutional guarantees. The conclusions confirm that the effectiveness of the mechanism for safeguarding prosecutorial independence depends not only on the legislative establishment of the relevant guarantees but also on the development of consistent law enforcement practice based on uniform criteria for assessing unlawful influence, pressure, and interference.
- 30 April 2026
- Published by Lviv University of Business and Law in Academic Visions
- No. 54
Tools for Protecting Prosecutorial Independence: International Practice in Examining Notifications of Threats to Prosecutorial Independence
This article examines the national legal mechanisms for safeguarding prosecutorial independence as one of the fundamental guarantees of the effective functioning of the prosecution service and the implementation of the rule of law. Particular attention is paid to the mechanism for reviewing notifications of threats to prosecutorial independence, the activities of the Council of Prosecutors of Ukraine, and the analysis of its law enforcement practice. The purpose of the study is to analyse the national instruments for ensuring prosecutorial independence, determine their legal nature, examine the practical application of the mechanism for protecting prosecutorial independence, and formulate the author's approaches to distinguishing the concepts of «influence», «pressure», and «interference» in the professional activities of prosecutors. To achieve this objective, the study employs a combination of general scientific and special legal research methods, including the dialectical method, the formal legal method, the comparative legal method, the systemic-structural method, and the method of generalising judicial and disciplinary practice. The findings demonstrate that prosecutorial independence is a complex legal concept ensured through a system of interrelated legal, organisational, procedural, material, and institutional guarantees. The conclusions confirm that the effectiveness of the mechanism for safeguarding prosecutorial independence depends not only on the legislative establishment of the relevant guarantees but also on the development of consistent law enforcement practice based on uniform criteria for assessing unlawful influence, pressure, and interference.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by National Institute of Justice in The Journal of the National Institute of Justice
- No. 1(76),p. 48-55
Criminal law assessment of attacks against the civilian population during an international armed conflict under the legislation of Ukraine
The criminal law evaluation of violations of the rules and customs of war under Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (hereinafter - the Criminal Code) requires reference to the relevant international treaties that establish such rules, as indicated by the article's provisions. These treaties contain a range of norms outlining prohibitions for parties to international armed conflicts and specifying particular breaches of the laws and customs of war. The breadth of these norms gives rise to practical challenges in applying Article 438 of the Criminal Code, particularly when drafting indictments. Among the most serious breaches of the rules and customs of war is the targeting of the civilian population or individual civilians. Identifying the objective and subjective elements of this act is of significant scholarly interest. Within the framework of international humanitarian law, this violation is formulated in a manner atypical for domestic criminal legislation. Additionally, issues arise in differentiating it from other serious violations of the laws and customs of war and in correlating it with prohibitions and requirements established under international humanitarian law. To clarify the essence of this violation, the study analyzed relevant international treaty norms and their interrelationships. This analysis allowed for identifying objective characteristics that distinguish the violation under study from other similar offenses, such as indiscriminate attacks. The study also examined possible forms of subjective intent with respect to committing such a violation, namely the targeting of the civilian population or individual civilians. Furthermore, judicial practice was reviewed, with particular attention to how charges under Article 438 of the Criminal Code are formulated. The study emphasizes and substantiates the importance of guidance on the commission of serious violations of international agreements when preparing charges in such proceedings.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by National Institute of Justice in The Journal of the National Institute of Justice
- No. 1(76),p. 48-55
Open AccessCriminal law assessment of attacks against the civilian population during an international armed conflict under the legislation of Ukraine
The criminal law evaluation of violations of the rules and customs of war under Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (hereinafter - the Criminal Code) requires reference to the relevant international treaties that establish such rules, as indicated by the article's provisions. These treaties contain a range of norms outlining prohibitions for parties to international armed conflicts and specifying particular breaches of the laws and customs of war. The breadth of these norms gives rise to practical challenges in applying Article 438 of the Criminal Code, particularly when drafting indictments. Among the most serious breaches of the rules and customs of war is the targeting of the civilian population or individual civilians. Identifying the objective and subjective elements of this act is of significant scholarly interest. Within the framework of international humanitarian law, this violation is formulated in a manner atypical for domestic criminal legislation. Additionally, issues arise in differentiating it from other serious violations of the laws and customs of war and in correlating it with prohibitions and requirements established under international humanitarian law. To clarify the essence of this violation, the study analyzed relevant international treaty norms and their interrelationships. This analysis allowed for identifying objective characteristics that distinguish the violation under study from other similar offenses, such as indiscriminate attacks. The study also examined possible forms of subjective intent with respect to committing such a violation, namely the targeting of the civilian population or individual civilians. Furthermore, judicial practice was reviewed, with particular attention to how charges under Article 438 of the Criminal Code are formulated. The study emphasizes and substantiates the importance of guidance on the commission of serious violations of international agreements when preparing charges in such proceedings.
- Open Access
- 28 February 2026
- Published by Lviv University of Business and Law in Scientific Notes of Lviv University of Business and Law
- No. 48
INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS FOR THE PROTECTION OF THE INDEPENDENCE OF PROSECUTORS
This article examines the international standards for safeguarding prosecutorial independence as one of the fundamental guarantees of the effective functioning of the prosecution service, the rule of law, and the fair administration of justice. It analyses international legal instruments, recommendations, and documents adopted by the United Nations, the Council of Europe, the Consultative Council of European Prosecutors, the Venice Commission, the International Association of Prosecutors, and other international institutions that define the concept of prosecutorial independence, its guarantees, and mechanisms for its protection. Particular attention is paid to the classification and systematization of international guarantees of prosecutorial independence and their significance for the development of a modern model of the prosecution service. The purpose of the study is to provide a comprehensive analysis of international standards for safeguarding prosecutorial independence, to determine their content, identify their principal guarantees, and assess their role in ensuring the proper functioning of the prosecution service in accordance with the principle of the rule of law. To achieve this objective, the study employs a combination of general scientific and special legal research methods, including the dialectical method, the formal legal method, the comparative legal method, the systemic-structural method, and the method of legal analysis of international instruments. The findings demonstrate that international standards regard prosecutorial independence as an essential institutional guarantee for protecting the public interest, safeguarding human rights, and ensuring the fair administration of justice. The study substantiates that the system of international standards encompasses organisational, procedural, personnel, social, and security guarantees designed to prevent any unlawful influence on the professional activities of prosecutors. It is concluded that international standards provide universal benchmarks for the development of national legislation and for strengthening the institutional independence of the prosecution service.
- 28 February 2026
- Published by Lviv University of Business and Law in Scientific Notes of Lviv University of Business and Law
- No. 48
Open AccessINTERNATIONAL STANDARDS FOR THE PROTECTION OF THE INDEPENDENCE OF PROSECUTORS
This article examines the international standards for safeguarding prosecutorial independence as one of the fundamental guarantees of the effective functioning of the prosecution service, the rule of law, and the fair administration of justice. It analyses international legal instruments, recommendations, and documents adopted by the United Nations, the Council of Europe, the Consultative Council of European Prosecutors, the Venice Commission, the International Association of Prosecutors, and other international institutions that define the concept of prosecutorial independence, its guarantees, and mechanisms for its protection. Particular attention is paid to the classification and systematization of international guarantees of prosecutorial independence and their significance for the development of a modern model of the prosecution service. The purpose of the study is to provide a comprehensive analysis of international standards for safeguarding prosecutorial independence, to determine their content, identify their principal guarantees, and assess their role in ensuring the proper functioning of the prosecution service in accordance with the principle of the rule of law. To achieve this objective, the study employs a combination of general scientific and special legal research methods, including the dialectical method, the formal legal method, the comparative legal method, the systemic-structural method, and the method of legal analysis of international instruments. The findings demonstrate that international standards regard prosecutorial independence as an essential institutional guarantee for protecting the public interest, safeguarding human rights, and ensuring the fair administration of justice. The study substantiates that the system of international standards encompasses organisational, procedural, personnel, social, and security guarantees designed to prevent any unlawful influence on the professional activities of prosecutors. It is concluded that international standards provide universal benchmarks for the development of national legislation and for strengthening the institutional independence of the prosecution service.
- Open Access
- 8 September 2024
- Published by The Dnipropetrovsk State University of Internal Affairs in Naukovyy Visnyk Dnipropetrovs'kogo Derzhavnogo Universytety Vnutrishnikh Sprav
- No. 1
DOCTRINAL FRAMEWORK OF DEVELOPING A SAFE-ORIENTED DIMENSION OF THE FUNCTIONING OF PRISONS OF THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE OF UKRAINE
The author's analysis of the conceptual apparatus in the field of penitentiary security is carried out in the article. Author's definitions of such concepts as: "security in the penitentiary system", "danger in the process of execution / serving sentences in places of detention of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine", "penitentiary threat", "personal security during execution / serving sentences", "right of convicts", "for personal safety".
- 8 September 2024
- Published by The Dnipropetrovsk State University of Internal Affairs in Naukovyy Visnyk Dnipropetrovs'kogo Derzhavnogo Universytety Vnutrishnikh Sprav
- No. 1
Open AccessDOCTRINAL FRAMEWORK OF DEVELOPING A SAFE-ORIENTED DIMENSION OF THE FUNCTIONING OF PRISONS OF THE MINISTRY OF JUSTICE OF UKRAINE
The author's analysis of the conceptual apparatus in the field of penitentiary security is carried out in the article. Author's definitions of such concepts as: "security in the penitentiary system", "danger in the process of execution / serving sentences in places of detention of the Ministry of Justice of Ukraine", "penitentiary threat", "personal security during execution / serving sentences", "right of convicts", "for personal safety".
- Open Access
- 11 May 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 545-552
The civilian population as an object of attack during an international armed conflict: a criminal-legal assessment under the national legislation of Ukraine
The criminal law assessment of each violation of the rules and customs of war under Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (hereinafter referred to as the Criminal Code of Ukraine) requires reference to international treaties establishing such rules. This is indicated by the disposition of this article. In turn, international treaties have a list of provisions that contain instructions on prohibitions for parties to international armed conflicts and on specific violations of the rules and customs of war. This list is quite wide, due to which problems arise during the practical application of Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, in particular, when formulating an indictment. Serious violations of the rules and customs of war include, in particular, turning the civilian population or individual civilians into targets of attack. Establishing objective and subjective signs of this act is of scientific interest. In the norms of international humanitarian law, this violation is formulated atypically for domestic criminal legislation. In addition, there are issues of differentiation with other serious violations of the rules and customs of war, correlation with prohibitions and requirements established in the norms of international humanitarian law. In order to clarify the essence of this violation, the norms of international treaties, which are part of international humanitarian law, as well as their interrelationship, were analyzed. This made it possible to draw conclusions about the objective features by which it is possible to distinguish the analyzed violation from other homogeneous violations, for example, from committing attacks of an indiscriminate nature. Possible variants of a subjective attitude to the commission of such a violation as the transformation of the civilian population or individual civilians into an object of attack are also defined. In addition, examples from judicial practice were considered with an emphasis on ways of formulating charges under Art. 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. The importance of instructions for the commission of a serious violation of an international agreement during the formulation of charges in such proceedings is emphasized and substantiated. Prospects for further research on issues related to the criminal-legal assessment of attacks on the civilian population in the context of an international armed conflict are outlined. Кримінально-правова оцінка кожного порушення правил та звичаїв війни за ст. 438 Кримінального кодексу України (далі - КК України) вимагає звернення до міжнародних договорів, що встановлюють такі правила. На це вказує диспозиція статті. У свою чергу, міжнародні договори передбачають перелік положень, у яких містяться вказівки на заборони для сторін міжнародних збройних конфліктів та на конкретні порушення правил та звичаїв війни. Цей перелік досить широкий, у зв'язку з чим виникають проблеми під час практичного застосування ст. 438 КК України, зокрема, при формулюванні обвинувачення. До серйозних порушень правил та звичаїв війни віднесено, зокрема, перетворення цивільного населення або окремих цивільних осіб на об'єкт нападу. Встановлення об'єктивних і суб'єктивних ознак цього діяння викликає науковий інтерес. У положеннях міжнародного гуманітарного права це порушення сформульовано нетипово для вітчизняного кримінального законодавства. Крім того, постають питання розмежування з іншими серйозними порушеннями правил та звичаїв війни, співвідношення з заборонами і вимогами, закріпленими в нормах міжнародного гуманітарного права. Задля з'ясування сутності цього порушення було, зокрема, проаналізовано норми міжнародних договорів, що є частиною міжнародного гуманітарного права, у тому числі в їх взаємозв'язку. Це дозволило зробити висновки щодо об'єктивних ознак, за якими можна відрізнити аналізоване порушення від інших однорідних порушень, наприклад, від учинення нападів не- вибіркового характеру. Також були визначені можливі варіанти суб'єктивного ставлення до вчинення перетворення цивільного населення або окремих цивільних осіб на об'єкт нападу з боку суб'єкта цього порушення. Крім того, розглянуто приклади з судової практики з акцентом на способи формулювання обвинувачення за ст. 438 КК України. Підкреслено і обґрунтовано важливість вказівок на вчинення серйозного порушення міжнародного...
- 11 May 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 545-552
Open AccessThe civilian population as an object of attack during an international armed conflict: a criminal-legal assessment under the national legislation of Ukraine
The criminal law assessment of each violation of the rules and customs of war under Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine (hereinafter referred to as the Criminal Code of Ukraine) requires reference to international treaties establishing such rules. This is indicated by the disposition of this article. In turn, international treaties have a list of provisions that contain instructions on prohibitions for parties to international armed conflicts and on specific violations of the rules and customs of war. This list is quite wide, due to which problems arise during the practical application of Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine, in particular, when formulating an indictment. Serious violations of the rules and customs of war include, in particular, turning the civilian population or individual civilians into targets of attack. Establishing objective and subjective signs of this act is of scientific interest. In the norms of international humanitarian law, this violation is formulated atypically for domestic criminal legislation. In addition, there are issues of differentiation with other serious violations of the rules and customs of war, correlation with prohibitions and requirements established in the norms of international humanitarian law. In order to clarify the essence of this violation, the norms of international treaties, which are part of international humanitarian law, as well as their interrelationship, were analyzed. This made it possible to draw conclusions about the objective features by which it is possible to distinguish the analyzed violation from other homogeneous violations, for example, from committing attacks of an indiscriminate nature. Possible variants of a subjective attitude to the commission of such a violation as the transformation of the civilian population or individual civilians into an object of attack are also defined. In addition, examples from judicial practice were considered with an emphasis on ways of formulating charges under Art. 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. The importance of instructions for the commission of a serious violation of an international agreement during the formulation of charges in such proceedings is emphasized and substantiated. Prospects for further research on issues related to the criminal-legal assessment of attacks on the civilian population in the context of an international armed conflict are outlined. Кримінально-правова оцінка кожного порушення правил та звичаїв війни за ст. 438 Кримінального кодексу України (далі - КК України) вимагає звернення до міжнародних договорів, що встановлюють такі правила. На це вказує диспозиція статті. У свою чергу, міжнародні договори передбачають перелік положень, у яких містяться вказівки на заборони для сторін міжнародних збройних конфліктів та на конкретні порушення правил та звичаїв війни. Цей перелік досить широкий, у зв'язку з чим виникають проблеми під час практичного застосування ст. 438 КК України, зокрема, при формулюванні обвинувачення. До серйозних порушень правил та звичаїв війни віднесено, зокрема, перетворення цивільного населення або окремих цивільних осіб на об'єкт нападу. Встановлення об'єктивних і суб'єктивних ознак цього діяння викликає науковий інтерес. У положеннях міжнародного гуманітарного права це порушення сформульовано нетипово для вітчизняного кримінального законодавства. Крім того, постають питання розмежування з іншими серйозними порушеннями правил та звичаїв війни, співвідношення з заборонами і вимогами, закріпленими в нормах міжнародного гуманітарного права. Задля з'ясування сутності цього порушення було, зокрема, проаналізовано норми міжнародних договорів, що є частиною міжнародного гуманітарного права, у тому числі в їх взаємозв'язку. Це дозволило зробити висновки щодо об'єктивних ознак, за якими можна відрізнити аналізоване порушення від інших однорідних порушень, наприклад, від учинення нападів не- вибіркового характеру. Також були визначені можливі варіанти суб'єктивного ставлення до вчинення перетворення цивільного населення або окремих цивільних осіб на об'єкт нападу з боку суб'єкта цього порушення. Крім того, розглянуто приклади з судової практики з акцентом на способи формулювання обвинувачення за ст. 438 КК України. Підкреслено і обґрунтовано важливість вказівок на вчинення серйозного порушення міжнародного...
- Open Access
- 11 May 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 649-654
Provocation of a crime: analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights and the Supreme Court
The article is devoted to law-making acts of the judicial branch of power on the example of judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter - ECHR) and the Supreme Court (hereinafter - SC) on determining the presence or absence of provocation of a crime by law enforcement agencies or persons involved by them. The choice of these courts is justified by the authors from the point of view that the resolution of legal issues by the ECHR and the SC is of significant importance for criminal proceedings - the performance of procedural actions, and the adoption of procedural decisions by pre-trial investigation bodies, prosecutors, and courts of first instance and appeal. The authors of the study focus on how the ECHR and the Supreme Court define provocation of a crime, citing, in particular, examples from Teixeira de Castro v. Portugal, Ramanauskas v. Lithuania, Malinas v. Lithuania, Milinene v. Lithuania, Sequeira v. Portugal, Furcht v. Germany, Chokhonelidze v. Georgia, and others. The provisions of these judgments, along with the provisions of the procedural legislation of Ukraine, are considered in the article as objective factors, compliance with which should indicate the legitimacy of law enforcement agencies. At the same time, focusing on the provocation of a crime, the authors emphasise that the recognition of law enforcement agencies' actions as provocative also depends on the subjectivity of the court's position based on the assessment of evidence provided by the parties to criminal proceedings. It is established that the subjectivity of the ECHR and the SC is of a different nature. In particular, the consistency and coherence of the ECHR's position on provocation of a crime has been consistent and unchanged since 1998, while the SC has adopted diametrically opposite legal opinions in a short period of time. The authors come to the conclusion that the activities of courts, which are legally obliged to establish justice, to observe the principles of criminal proceedings such as the rule of law and legal certainty, in terms of changing approaches to the assessment of evidence should be strictly regulated at the legislative level. Стаття присвячена правотворчим актам судової гілки влади на прикладі рішень Європейського суду з прав людини (далі - ЄСПЛ) та Верховного Суду (далі - ВС) з питань визначення наявності чи відсутності провокації вчинення злочину з боку правоохоронних органів чи осіб, що залучаються ними. Вибір вказаних судів авторами обґрунтовано з точки зору того, що вирішення ЄСПЛ та ВС правових питань має істотне значення для кримінального провадження - вчинення процесуальних дій, прийняття процесуальних рішень - органами досудового розслідування, прокурорами судами першої та апеляційної інстанції. Автори дослідження зупиняють свою увагу на об'єктивних ознаках провокації злочину, наведених у рішеннях ЄСПЛ та ВС та, зокрема, наводять приклади зі справ Тейксейра де Кастро проти Португалії, Раманаускас проти Литви, Малінінас проти Литви, Мілінене проти Литви, Секвейра проти Португалії, Фурхт проти Німеччини, Чохонелідзе проти Грузії та ін. Положення вказаних рішень поряд з приписами процесуального законодавства України розглядаються у статті як об'єктивні чинники, дотримання яких має свідчити про правомірність правоохоронних органів. Поряд з цим, зосереджуючи увагу на провокації злочину, автори наголошують, що визнання дій правоохоронних органів провокаційними залежить також і від суб'єктивності позиції суду, заснованій на оцінці наданих сторонами кримінального провадження доказів. Встановлено, що суб'єктивізм ЄСПЛ та ВС має різний характер. Зокрема, сталість та узгодженість позицій ЄСПЛ щодо провокації злочину є послідовною та незмінною починаючи з 1998 року, тоді як ВС за невеликий проміжок часу ухвалив діаметрально протилежні правові висновки. Автори приходять до висновку, що діяльність судів, на яких законом покладено обов'язок утвердження справедливості, дотримання таких засад кримінального провадження як верховенства права, правова визначеність, у частині зміни підходів до оцінки доказів має буди суворо регламентована на законодавчому рівні.
- 11 May 2024
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 2,p. 649-654
Open AccessProvocation of a crime: analysis of the case law of the European Court of Human Rights and the Supreme Court
The article is devoted to law-making acts of the judicial branch of power on the example of judgments of the European Court of Human Rights (hereinafter - ECHR) and the Supreme Court (hereinafter - SC) on determining the presence or absence of provocation of a crime by law enforcement agencies or persons involved by them. The choice of these courts is justified by the authors from the point of view that the resolution of legal issues by the ECHR and the SC is of significant importance for criminal proceedings - the performance of procedural actions, and the adoption of procedural decisions by pre-trial investigation bodies, prosecutors, and courts of first instance and appeal. The authors of the study focus on how the ECHR and the Supreme Court define provocation of a crime, citing, in particular, examples from Teixeira de Castro v. Portugal, Ramanauskas v. Lithuania, Malinas v. Lithuania, Milinene v. Lithuania, Sequeira v. Portugal, Furcht v. Germany, Chokhonelidze v. Georgia, and others. The provisions of these judgments, along with the provisions of the procedural legislation of Ukraine, are considered in the article as objective factors, compliance with which should indicate the legitimacy of law enforcement agencies. At the same time, focusing on the provocation of a crime, the authors emphasise that the recognition of law enforcement agencies' actions as provocative also depends on the subjectivity of the court's position based on the assessment of evidence provided by the parties to criminal proceedings. It is established that the subjectivity of the ECHR and the SC is of a different nature. In particular, the consistency and coherence of the ECHR's position on provocation of a crime has been consistent and unchanged since 1998, while the SC has adopted diametrically opposite legal opinions in a short period of time. The authors come to the conclusion that the activities of courts, which are legally obliged to establish justice, to observe the principles of criminal proceedings such as the rule of law and legal certainty, in terms of changing approaches to the assessment of evidence should be strictly regulated at the legislative level. Стаття присвячена правотворчим актам судової гілки влади на прикладі рішень Європейського суду з прав людини (далі - ЄСПЛ) та Верховного Суду (далі - ВС) з питань визначення наявності чи відсутності провокації вчинення злочину з боку правоохоронних органів чи осіб, що залучаються ними. Вибір вказаних судів авторами обґрунтовано з точки зору того, що вирішення ЄСПЛ та ВС правових питань має істотне значення для кримінального провадження - вчинення процесуальних дій, прийняття процесуальних рішень - органами досудового розслідування, прокурорами судами першої та апеляційної інстанції. Автори дослідження зупиняють свою увагу на об'єктивних ознаках провокації злочину, наведених у рішеннях ЄСПЛ та ВС та, зокрема, наводять приклади зі справ Тейксейра де Кастро проти Португалії, Раманаускас проти Литви, Малінінас проти Литви, Мілінене проти Литви, Секвейра проти Португалії, Фурхт проти Німеччини, Чохонелідзе проти Грузії та ін. Положення вказаних рішень поряд з приписами процесуального законодавства України розглядаються у статті як об'єктивні чинники, дотримання яких має свідчити про правомірність правоохоронних органів. Поряд з цим, зосереджуючи увагу на провокації злочину, автори наголошують, що визнання дій правоохоронних органів провокаційними залежить також і від суб'єктивності позиції суду, заснованій на оцінці наданих сторонами кримінального провадження доказів. Встановлено, що суб'єктивізм ЄСПЛ та ВС має різний характер. Зокрема, сталість та узгодженість позицій ЄСПЛ щодо провокації злочину є послідовною та незмінною починаючи з 1998 року, тоді як ВС за невеликий проміжок часу ухвалив діаметрально протилежні правові висновки. Автори приходять до висновку, що діяльність судів, на яких законом покладено обов'язок утвердження справедливості, дотримання таких засад кримінального провадження як верховенства права, правова визначеність, у частині зміни підходів до оцінки доказів має буди суворо регламентована на законодавчому рівні.
- Open Access
- 17 November 2023
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 5,p. 465-469
On the peculiarities of investigating criminal offenses related to illicit trafficking in narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors in modern conditions
The article examines the peculiarities of carrying out certain procedural actions during the investigation of criminal offenses related to the illegal circulation of narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors, in modern conditions. The author states that in today's conditions, against the background of global informatization of society and the active introduction of the latest technologies in all spheres of human life, the forms of sale of narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors are also changing. Criminals, using the assets of modern technologies, constantly improve their criminal activities, change directions of interaction with the aim of committing offenses. In Ukraine, as well as in the world in general, drug crime is actively carried out through smartphones and the Internet using messengers and special applications for the distribution of psychoactive substances, narcotic drugs and their analogues. The author researched the peculiarities of ensuring the prosecutor fulfills the tasks of criminal proceedings during the investigation of criminal offenses in the sphere of trafficking in narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors: the prosecutor's exercise of powers aimed at ensuring the completeness and comprehensiveness of the investigation of the circumstances of the criminal offense and the correct application of the norms of the criminal law, and as well as the specifics of conducting investigative actions in criminal proceedings on the facts of trafficking in narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors. The author concludes that the effectiveness of pre-trial investigation in criminal proceedings on the facts of illegal sale of substances excluded from free circulation using the Internet and other telecommunication technologies is complicated by the need to identify the user under a pseudonym.
- 17 November 2023
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 5,p. 465-469
Open AccessOn the peculiarities of investigating criminal offenses related to illicit trafficking in narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors in modern conditions
The article examines the peculiarities of carrying out certain procedural actions during the investigation of criminal offenses related to the illegal circulation of narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors, in modern conditions. The author states that in today's conditions, against the background of global informatization of society and the active introduction of the latest technologies in all spheres of human life, the forms of sale of narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors are also changing. Criminals, using the assets of modern technologies, constantly improve their criminal activities, change directions of interaction with the aim of committing offenses. In Ukraine, as well as in the world in general, drug crime is actively carried out through smartphones and the Internet using messengers and special applications for the distribution of psychoactive substances, narcotic drugs and their analogues. The author researched the peculiarities of ensuring the prosecutor fulfills the tasks of criminal proceedings during the investigation of criminal offenses in the sphere of trafficking in narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors: the prosecutor's exercise of powers aimed at ensuring the completeness and comprehensiveness of the investigation of the circumstances of the criminal offense and the correct application of the norms of the criminal law, and as well as the specifics of conducting investigative actions in criminal proceedings on the facts of trafficking in narcotic drugs, psychotropic substances, their analogues or precursors. The author concludes that the effectiveness of pre-trial investigation in criminal proceedings on the facts of illegal sale of substances excluded from free circulation using the Internet and other telecommunication technologies is complicated by the need to identify the user under a pseudonym.
- 15 August 2023
- Published by Academy Of The State Penitentiary Servise in Scientific journal Criminal and Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow
- Vol. 2022 (2) , 7-20
VICTIMOLOGY PREVENTION OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
The article is devoted to the peculiarities of victimological prevention of domestic violence. An analysis of the factors determining the dynamics of criminal offenses related to domestic violence was carried out. The authors identify certain reasons for the low effectiveness of various victimological prevention measures related to the lack of understanding of the origins of such behavior. The authors also emphasize the need to increase the professionalism and responsibility of law enforcement agents in domestic violence proceedings, which will allow for proper risk assessment, as well as to exclude victim-blaming and secondary victimization. Knowledge of patterns and causes of victim behavior will allow these subjects to provide effective professional victimological counseling, develop preventive measures, and choose effective means of influencing the individual in order to prevent victimization. In turn, this will stimulate the resolution of intra-family problems, provide a professional response to the victim’s scenario, and provide an opportunity to develop rehabilitation programs for working with the family as a whole: both with the aggressor and with the victim. The specified areas in their totality form a system of successful individual victimological prevention of domestic violence. The authors came to the conclusion that when implementing individual victimological prevention of domestic violence, it is very important to have an understanding of models of victim behavior, methods of implementation and translation of learned victim norms. Victimological counseling is gaining relevance as a way of providing necessary, decent and sufficient help to victims of domestic violence. It is noted that individual victimological prevention measures will not be fully effective without such factors preventing victim behavior as unconscious attitudes. Therefore, any process of reintegration and readaptation of the victims should include psychotherapeutic counseling, preferably both on the part of the aggressor and the victim to understand the patterns of behavior that cause violence. Key words: individual victimhood, domestic violence, victimological prevention, victimization, the person of the criminal, the victim of a criminal offense.
- 15 August 2023
- Published by Academy Of The State Penitentiary Servise in Scientific journal Criminal and Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow
- Vol. 2022 (2) , 7-20
VICTIMOLOGY PREVENTION OF DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
The article is devoted to the peculiarities of victimological prevention of domestic violence. An analysis of the factors determining the dynamics of criminal offenses related to domestic violence was carried out. The authors identify certain reasons for the low effectiveness of various victimological prevention measures related to the lack of understanding of the origins of such behavior. The authors also emphasize the need to increase the professionalism and responsibility of law enforcement agents in domestic violence proceedings, which will allow for proper risk assessment, as well as to exclude victim-blaming and secondary victimization. Knowledge of patterns and causes of victim behavior will allow these subjects to provide effective professional victimological counseling, develop preventive measures, and choose effective means of influencing the individual in order to prevent victimization. In turn, this will stimulate the resolution of intra-family problems, provide a professional response to the victim’s scenario, and provide an opportunity to develop rehabilitation programs for working with the family as a whole: both with the aggressor and with the victim. The specified areas in their totality form a system of successful individual victimological prevention of domestic violence. The authors came to the conclusion that when implementing individual victimological prevention of domestic violence, it is very important to have an understanding of models of victim behavior, methods of implementation and translation of learned victim norms. Victimological counseling is gaining relevance as a way of providing necessary, decent and sufficient help to victims of domestic violence. It is noted that individual victimological prevention measures will not be fully effective without such factors preventing victim behavior as unconscious attitudes. Therefore, any process of reintegration and readaptation of the victims should include psychotherapeutic counseling, preferably both on the part of the aggressor and the victim to understand the patterns of behavior that cause violence. Key words: individual victimhood, domestic violence, victimological prevention, victimization, the person of the criminal, the victim of a criminal offense.
- Open Access
- 18 February 2023
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 6,p. 373-378
To the issue of qualification of sexual violence in the conditions of international armed conflict
The article examines the peculiarities of the qualification of sexual violence as war crimes, using the norms of international and national law. The author states that the study of sexual violence, its consequences for society, as well as taking measures toprevent it through criminal legal means remains relevant for almost all countries of the world. The issues of qualification acquire special importance during investigation of sexual violence acts took place in the context of an armed conflict.It is proved that the issues of qualification of sexual violence committed during an armed conflict should be investigated taking with the provisions of the Rome Statute and Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Such an approach will provide thepotential possibility for blaming guilty persons to international criminal responsibility.The lion’s share of this article is devoted to the defining the common and mandatory signs of composition for all crimes related to sexual violence: the objective elements (actus reus) and mental elements (mens rea). The author takes into account thegeneral rules of qualification of crimes and clarifies the peculiarities of the qualification algorithm for the combatants who committed sexual violence against the civilian population during the armed conflict.The author comes to the conclusion that sexual violence committed by a combatant in the conditions of an armed conflict is covered by the concept of “other violations of the laws and customs of war, which are provided for by international treaties, thebinding consent of which was given by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine”. Such actions must be qualified under Part 1 and/or Part 2 of Art. 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine and norms of international humanitarian law according to the general qualificationrules of criminal offenses.
- 18 February 2023
- Published by Uzhhorod National University in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
- No. 6,p. 373-378
Open AccessTo the issue of qualification of sexual violence in the conditions of international armed conflict
The article examines the peculiarities of the qualification of sexual violence as war crimes, using the norms of international and national law. The author states that the study of sexual violence, its consequences for society, as well as taking measures toprevent it through criminal legal means remains relevant for almost all countries of the world. The issues of qualification acquire special importance during investigation of sexual violence acts took place in the context of an armed conflict.It is proved that the issues of qualification of sexual violence committed during an armed conflict should be investigated taking with the provisions of the Rome Statute and Article 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine. Such an approach will provide thepotential possibility for blaming guilty persons to international criminal responsibility.The lion’s share of this article is devoted to the defining the common and mandatory signs of composition for all crimes related to sexual violence: the objective elements (actus reus) and mental elements (mens rea). The author takes into account thegeneral rules of qualification of crimes and clarifies the peculiarities of the qualification algorithm for the combatants who committed sexual violence against the civilian population during the armed conflict.The author comes to the conclusion that sexual violence committed by a combatant in the conditions of an armed conflict is covered by the concept of “other violations of the laws and customs of war, which are provided for by international treaties, thebinding consent of which was given by the Verkhovna Rada of Ukraine”. Such actions must be qualified under Part 1 and/or Part 2 of Art. 438 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine and norms of international humanitarian law according to the general qualificationrules of criminal offenses.
- 2 September 2022
- Published by Academy Of The State Penitentiary Servise in Scientific journal Criminal and Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow
- Vol. 2022 (1) , 7-17
INTERNATIONAL PRINCIPLES OF CRIMINAL AND LEGAL PROTECTION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY OBJECTS
The article is devoted to issues of international legal principles in the field of implementation and protection of intellectual property objects in the aspect of influence on the processes of law enforcement and law-making in the field of criminal law of domestic legal systems. It is determined that the following are important for the criminal protection of intellectual property rights: the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS Agreement), the Convention on Cybercrime, the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, the Hague Agreement Concerning the International Registration of Industrial Designs, the Lisbon Agreement for the Protection of Appellations of Origin and their International Registration to them, and others. The relevance of this issue is due to the fact that, taking into account the processes of globalization of the world economy, as well as the process of integration of the legal systems of the countries of the world, the study of the international principles of criminal and legal protection of intellectual property is of great importance at the current stage of Ukraine’s development. The author determines that the concept of “intellectual property” should be understood as a type of property as a generic concept. Based on the analysis of the norms of international acts on the criminal protection of intellectual property rights, a number of problems have been identified that must be resolved in legislation, as well as legal science and practice. These problems include: 1) the problem of determining in which sections of the criminal codes the norms establishing criminal liability for infringement of intellectual property rights should be located. It is proposed to combine the norms establishing criminal liability for infringement of intellectual property rights into one section “Criminal offenses against intellectual property” in the Criminal Code of Ukraine; 2) the problem of determining which objects of intellectual property should be protected by the norms of criminal law. Key words: criminal liability, intellectual property, criminal legal protection, World Intellectual Property Organization, European Union.
- 2 September 2022
- Published by Academy Of The State Penitentiary Servise in Scientific journal Criminal and Executive System: Yesterday. Today. Tomorrow
- Vol. 2022 (1) , 7-17
INTERNATIONAL PRINCIPLES OF CRIMINAL AND LEGAL PROTECTION OF INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY OBJECTS
The article is devoted to issues of international legal principles in the field of implementation and protection of intellectual property objects in the aspect of influence on the processes of law enforcement and law-making in the field of criminal law of domestic legal systems. It is determined that the following are important for the criminal protection of intellectual property rights: the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS Agreement), the Convention on Cybercrime, the Paris Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property, the Berne Convention for the Protection of Literary and Artistic Works, the Hague Agreement Concerning the International Registration of Industrial Designs, the Lisbon Agreement for the Protection of Appellations of Origin and their International Registration to them, and others. The relevance of this issue is due to the fact that, taking into account the processes of globalization of the world economy, as well as the process of integration of the legal systems of the countries of the world, the study of the international principles of criminal and legal protection of intellectual property is of great importance at the current stage of Ukraine’s development. The author determines that the concept of “intellectual property” should be understood as a type of property as a generic concept. Based on the analysis of the norms of international acts on the criminal protection of intellectual property rights, a number of problems have been identified that must be resolved in legislation, as well as legal science and practice. These problems include: 1) the problem of determining in which sections of the criminal codes the norms establishing criminal liability for infringement of intellectual property rights should be located. It is proposed to combine the norms establishing criminal liability for infringement of intellectual property rights into one section “Criminal offenses against intellectual property” in the Criminal Code of Ukraine; 2) the problem of determining which objects of intellectual property should be protected by the norms of criminal law. Key words: criminal liability, intellectual property, criminal legal protection, World Intellectual Property Organization, European Union.