JDJoseph Donia

Joseph Donia

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Joseph Donia has a total of 19 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Secondary Use of Health Data in Canada and the European Union: Expectations, Frictions and the Politics of Scale

    by Joseph Donia, Luca Marelli

    In this article, we trace expectations associated with efforts to promote secondary use of health data in Canada and the European Union. In Canada, we focus on initiatives enabling cross‐jurisdictional data access in a highly devolved federal system with parallel commitments to Indigenous data sovereignty. In the EU, we focus on the European Health Data Space, a new regulatory regime intended to facilitate access to health data for clinical care, research, policymaking and innovation across 27 member states. Drawing on a comparative analysis of policy documents and semi‐structured interviews across nine EU member states and four Canadian provinces and one territory, we find that despite institutional differences, secondary use in both jurisdictions is characterised by strikingly similar promissory vocabularies. We argue that these expectations are fundamentally ones of scale: They seek to render health data interoperable, comparable and usable to different ends. At the same time, we document shared frictions: between sovereignty and integration; between access and control; and between private assets and public goods. We understand these as spaces where competing valuations of health data are negotiated. We suggest that secondary use logics are progressively reorienting health systems, with implications for public value, equity and political collectives.

  • Open Access

    Can Canada learn from the European Health Data Space?

    by Joseph Donia, Kimberlyn McGrail, Luca Marelli

    Federal, provincial, and territorial governments in Canada are increasingly committed to promoting health data access and use. The European Union has advanced a bold vision for health data integration with the European Health Data Space (EHDS) Regulation, which entered into force in March 2025. As the first data space to take shape as part of the broader European Strategy for Data, the EHDS establishes a robust regulatory regime for both primary use (clinical care, including electronic health record certification) and secondary use (research, policymaking, and innovation). In this commentary, we outline what Canada can learn from the EHDS policy experience to ensure that debates about health data access and use in Canada remain connected to broader discussions about community rights, accountability, public value, and the practical challenges of integrating data across jurisdictions. In particular, we suggest a more explicit focus on the politics of health data access and use; a value-oriented approach; and situating individual rights in relation to community-oriented governance.

  • Open Access

    Governing the European Health Data Space (EHDS): Ethical and Political Perspectives on the TEHDAS2 Second Public Consultation

    by Luca Marelli, Benedetta Muda, Joseph Donia, Andrea Martani

    This white paper consolidates comments submitted to the TEHDAS2 second public consultation on the TEHDAS2 guidelines (September 2025). TEHDAS2 guidelines provide practical guidance and operational interpretation of key provisions of the European Health Data Space (EHDS) Regulation, aimed at supporting consistent implementation across Member States while allowing for national flexibility. TEHDAS2 guidance addresses core aspects of the secondary use framework of the EHDS, including fee structures, permitted and prohibited uses of health data, metadata cataloguing, data access application and request procedures, enforcement and sanctions, and individual opt-out mechanisms. Across the guidelines, foundational principles such as transparency, proportionality, non-discrimination, due process, competition neutrality, data minimization, and alignment with FAIR principles are emphasized. The guidelines also clarify procedural requirements, including compliance monitoring, verification and assessment workflows, coordination mechanisms, and transparency obligations at both national and EU levels. While the TEHDAS2 guidelines offer valuable operational clarity, our analysis identifies several areas where further specification, harmonization, or clarification would strengthen implementation. These include, among others: the rationale and consistency of fee models and accounting standards; cross-border coordination and enforcement; alignment with GDPR requirements and AI governance; interpretation of allowed purposes and public interest; handling of intellectual property and trade secrets; metadata scalability and resource constraints; differentiation between data and dataset quality; and the practical implementation of opt-out mechanisms, particularly in relation to genetic data, vulnerable populations, and communication strategies.


  • Open Access

    Making data markets: Assetization, valuation, and proxy work in a digital health start-up

    by Joseph Donia, Jennifer Gibson, James A Shaw

    Digital data are increasingly framed as essential resources in health and medicine, implicating diverse actors who work to transform them into different forms of value. In this article we focus on the diverse and contingent valuation practices that shaped an artificial intelligence-enabled ‘smart’ health technology and the data it generated at different moments in time, and the corresponding asset forms that were envisioned, developed, tested, and marketed. We also outline the role of assetization as a contested but essential design and marketing activity, and introduce the notion of proxy work as an intermediary between data generation and assetization, where people, infrastructures, and other material devices are arranged in such a way that data become capable of ‘standing in’ for something else, allowing accountable forms of value to be realized across multiple sites. We conclude with a discussion of the consequences of assetization as a dominant lens through which governments, firms, and other actors increasingly understand the value of digital health data, and the different health-related futures those practices make possible.


  • Open Access

    Algorithmic accountabilities and health systems: A review and sociomaterial approach

    by Joseph Donia

    The perceived importance and difficulty of accounting for algorithms in health systems continues to inform scholarship and practice across diverse fields. While accountability is often framed as a normative good, less clear is exactly what kind of normative work accountability is expected to do, and how it is expected to do it. Drawing on contributions from science and technology studies, and especially sociomaterial perspectives on governance, in this article I review how algorithmic accountability has been conceptualized in the academic and grey literature. I introduce five normative logics characterizing discussions of algorithmic accountability: (1) accountability as verification, (2) accountability as participation, (3) accountability as social licence, (4) accountability as fiduciary duty, and (5) accountability as compliance. I critically engage with the styles of valuation these are predicated upon, including how each configures the algorithm as an object of reference, and discuss the implications of this approach for understanding how health-related worlds are created and sustained, and how they might be otherwise.


  • Lifecycles, pipelines, and value chains: toward a focus on events in responsible artificial intelligence for health

    by Joseph Donia, Lola Oyefeso, Gayathri Embuldeniya, Cari Whyne, David Burns, Philip Boyer, Helen Razmjou, James A. Shaw


  • Open Access

    Ethics and Values in Design: A Structured Review and Theoretical Critique

    by Joseph Donia, James. A. Shaw

    A variety of approaches have appeared in academic literature and in design practice representing “ethics-first” methods. These approaches typically focus on clarifying the normative dimensions of design, or outlining strategies for explicitly incorporating values into design. While this body of literature has developed considerably over the last 20 years, two themes central to the endeavour of ethics and values in design (E + VID) have yet to be systematically discussed in relation to each other: (a) designer agency, and (b) the strength of normative claims informing the design process. To address this gap, we undertook a structured review of leading E + VID approaches and critiques, and classified them according to their positions on normative strength, and views regarding designer agency. We identified 18 distinct approaches and 13 critiques that met the inclusion criteria for our review. Included papers were distributed across the spectrum of views regarding normative strength, and we found that no approaches and only one critique represented a view characteristic of “low” designer agency. We suggest that the absence of “low” designer agency approaches results in the neglect of crucial influences on design as targets of intervention by designers. We conclude with suggestions for future research that might illuminate strategies to achieve ethical design in information mature societies, and argue that without attending to the tensions raised by balancing normatively “strong” visions of the future with limitations imposed on designer agency in corporate-driven design settings, “meaningful” ethical design will continue to encounter challenges in practice.