Natasha C. Allard
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Natasha C. Allard has a total of 28 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Heather Orom
Department of Community Health and Health Behavior, University at Buffalo
12 shared publications - Erika A. Waters
Division of Public Health Sciences, Department of Surgery, Washington University in St. Louis
7 shared publications - Jennifer L. Hay
Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA
7 shared publications - Marc T. Kiviniemi
University of Kentucky, Lexington, USA
7 shared publications - Amy McQueen
School of Public Health, Washington University in St. Louis, St. Louis
4 shared publications - Malwina Lewicka
Department of Psychiatry & Behavioral Sciences, Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Cancer Causes & Control
- Vol. 37 (9)
“I never thought to bring them up to the doctor”: examining symptom appraisal, help-seeking behaviors, and diagnostic delays among young adults with cancer
Purpose: Cancer incidence is rising among young adults (20–39 years), and it is one of the top five causes of death for this age group. Young adults often experience longer delays in diagnosis than children and older adults, which negatively impacts survival and quality of life. Communication interventions might help reduce these delays, but understanding the factors driving delays is crucial for developing effective strategies. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 30 young adults diagnosed with cancer to explore factors contributing to delays across three intervals: symptom appraisal, help-seeking, and diagnostic. Interviews were conducted in January and February 2023 and analyzed using template analysis by three independent coders. Results: Most young adults misattributed symptoms to stress, lifestyle, or minor issues, and thus delayed seeking medical evaluation. Many used online information to inform care-seeking decisions but encountered content that minimized symptom severity or offered unclear guidance. Upon seeking care, several young adults had to self-advocate for diagnostic testing after providers initially dismissed their concerns. Conclusion: These patterns highlight potentially modifiable targets for future communication interventions. Strategies to improve young adults’ awareness of potential cancer symptoms, address misconceptions about cancer risk, and promote timely care-seeking are warranted. Efforts should also focus on improving the quality of online symptom information and equipping young adults with tools to communicate more effectively with providers. While systemic changes are also needed, individual-level communication campaigns could help shorten time to diagnosis and improve outcomes for young adults with cancer.
- 22 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Cancer Causes & Control
- Vol. 37 (9)
Open Access“I never thought to bring them up to the doctor”: examining symptom appraisal, help-seeking behaviors, and diagnostic delays among young adults with cancer
Purpose: Cancer incidence is rising among young adults (20–39 years), and it is one of the top five causes of death for this age group. Young adults often experience longer delays in diagnosis than children and older adults, which negatively impacts survival and quality of life. Communication interventions might help reduce these delays, but understanding the factors driving delays is crucial for developing effective strategies. Methods: We conducted semi-structured interviews with 30 young adults diagnosed with cancer to explore factors contributing to delays across three intervals: symptom appraisal, help-seeking, and diagnostic. Interviews were conducted in January and February 2023 and analyzed using template analysis by three independent coders. Results: Most young adults misattributed symptoms to stress, lifestyle, or minor issues, and thus delayed seeking medical evaluation. Many used online information to inform care-seeking decisions but encountered content that minimized symptom severity or offered unclear guidance. Upon seeking care, several young adults had to self-advocate for diagnostic testing after providers initially dismissed their concerns. Conclusion: These patterns highlight potentially modifiable targets for future communication interventions. Strategies to improve young adults’ awareness of potential cancer symptoms, address misconceptions about cancer risk, and promote timely care-seeking are warranted. Efforts should also focus on improving the quality of online symptom information and equipping young adults with tools to communicate more effectively with providers. While systemic changes are also needed, individual-level communication campaigns could help shorten time to diagnosis and improve outcomes for young adults with cancer.
- Open Access
- 12 March 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Partnering with Social Media Influencers to Promote Cancer Screening: A Process Evaluation and Practical Guidance for Influencer-Based Health Promotion (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Health communicators and researchers are increasingly exploring partnerships with social media influencers as a strategy to improve the reach and engagement of health messaging. However, practical guidance on how health communicators can identify, recruit, and collaborate with influencers is limited. OBJECTIVE The aim of this paper is to provide a detailed description of how to work with social media influencers to disseminate health messages and to highlight lessons learned that may help others avoid or overcome challenges associated with this communication channel. METHODS We conducted a process evaluation of an Instagram influencer campaign promoting colorectal cancer screening between March and July 2025. We reviewed publicly available guidance on collaborating with social media influencers for health promotion and summarized key recommendations. Using a paid influencer marketing platform, we identified and contacted nano- and micro-influencers (1,000–50,000 followers). Participating influencers created and posted an Instagram Reel and shared it to their Instagram Story. We documented the recruitment process, vetting criteria, negotiations, content review procedures, and engagement metrics and examined associations between influencer characteristics and engagement outcomes. RESULTS We sent 1,907 outreach emails to potential influencers; 72 expressed interest and we negotiated collaboration terms with 52 before finalizing agreements with 22 and receiving Reels from 16 (0.84%). Outreach emails that specified compensation and project details upfront were the most effective strategy (completed posts from 2.0% of outreach emails compared with 0.7% for emails that did not include compensation and 0% for emails sent only after pre-vetting influencers). Recruiting these influencers required approximately 2.5 months of outreach and a paid influencer marketing platform subscription costing $1,647. Influencer payments ranged from $200 to $500 (mean $389). The 16 influencer videos generated 89,764 total views (mean 5,610 per video) and approximately 232 visits to the campaign website. We found no significant associations between influencer payment or follower count and video views or engagement rates. CONCLUSIONS Partnering with influencers to disseminate health messages on social media can result in relatively high engagement with health messages, including among audiences who may not actively seek health information. However, implementing influencer campaigns using a commercial influencer marketing platform required substantial recruitment effort, including large volumes of outreach and lengthy negotiation timelines. In our campaign, fewer than 1% of outreach emails resulted in completed posts. Providing compensation and project expectations in the initial outreach email substantially improved recruitment success. Influencers with relatively fewer followers may generate similar reach and engagement at lower cost, but may be less experienced and require more clarifications and discussions in the negotiation process. Establishing clear expectations for timelines, deliverables, and revisions during negotiation may help prevent delays and improve content quality. The recruitment outcomes, timelines, and cost estimates reported here may help health communicators develop more realistic implementation plans and budgets when considering influencer-based health communication campaigns.
- 12 March 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessPartnering with Social Media Influencers to Promote Cancer Screening: A Process Evaluation and Practical Guidance for Influencer-Based Health Promotion (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Health communicators and researchers are increasingly exploring partnerships with social media influencers as a strategy to improve the reach and engagement of health messaging. However, practical guidance on how health communicators can identify, recruit, and collaborate with influencers is limited. OBJECTIVE The aim of this paper is to provide a detailed description of how to work with social media influencers to disseminate health messages and to highlight lessons learned that may help others avoid or overcome challenges associated with this communication channel. METHODS We conducted a process evaluation of an Instagram influencer campaign promoting colorectal cancer screening between March and July 2025. We reviewed publicly available guidance on collaborating with social media influencers for health promotion and summarized key recommendations. Using a paid influencer marketing platform, we identified and contacted nano- and micro-influencers (1,000–50,000 followers). Participating influencers created and posted an Instagram Reel and shared it to their Instagram Story. We documented the recruitment process, vetting criteria, negotiations, content review procedures, and engagement metrics and examined associations between influencer characteristics and engagement outcomes. RESULTS We sent 1,907 outreach emails to potential influencers; 72 expressed interest and we negotiated collaboration terms with 52 before finalizing agreements with 22 and receiving Reels from 16 (0.84%). Outreach emails that specified compensation and project details upfront were the most effective strategy (completed posts from 2.0% of outreach emails compared with 0.7% for emails that did not include compensation and 0% for emails sent only after pre-vetting influencers). Recruiting these influencers required approximately 2.5 months of outreach and a paid influencer marketing platform subscription costing $1,647. Influencer payments ranged from $200 to $500 (mean $389). The 16 influencer videos generated 89,764 total views (mean 5,610 per video) and approximately 232 visits to the campaign website. We found no significant associations between influencer payment or follower count and video views or engagement rates. CONCLUSIONS Partnering with influencers to disseminate health messages on social media can result in relatively high engagement with health messages, including among audiences who may not actively seek health information. However, implementing influencer campaigns using a commercial influencer marketing platform required substantial recruitment effort, including large volumes of outreach and lengthy negotiation timelines. In our campaign, fewer than 1% of outreach emails resulted in completed posts. Providing compensation and project expectations in the initial outreach email substantially improved recruitment success. Influencers with relatively fewer followers may generate similar reach and engagement at lower cost, but may be less experienced and require more clarifications and discussions in the negotiation process. Establishing clear expectations for timelines, deliverables, and revisions during negotiation may help prevent delays and improve content quality. The recruitment outcomes, timelines, and cost estimates reported here may help health communicators develop more realistic implementation plans and budgets when considering influencer-based health communication campaigns.
- 30 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Psychology
- Vol. 31 (8) , 3210-3226
Effects of affective states on colorectal cancer screening health message persuasion depend on whether people avoid cancer information
People frequently defensively avoid information about threatening health conditions. We tested whether, consistent with a mood-as-a-resource hypothesis, inducing high arousal positive mood (vs high arousal negative or neutral mood) would decrease colorectal cancer (CRC) information avoidance among people who avoid cancer information and are non-adherent to CRC screening. In a pilot study ( N = 265), we successfully identified video clips that induced positive, neutral, or negative emotions in individuals who either do or do not tend to avoid CRC information. In the main study ( N = 337), avoidance moderated the effects of affect induction on screening intentions; whereas avoiders’ screening intentions tended to be stronger after the neutral affect induction than after either the positive or negative affect induction, the pattern was the opposite for non-avoiders. Messages targeting avoiders might be more effective if they do not employ emotional appeals—including fear appeals or even gain framing if it evokes high arousal positive affect.
- 30 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Health Psychology
- Vol. 31 (8) , 3210-3226
Effects of affective states on colorectal cancer screening health message persuasion depend on whether people avoid cancer information
People frequently defensively avoid information about threatening health conditions. We tested whether, consistent with a mood-as-a-resource hypothesis, inducing high arousal positive mood (vs high arousal negative or neutral mood) would decrease colorectal cancer (CRC) information avoidance among people who avoid cancer information and are non-adherent to CRC screening. In a pilot study ( N = 265), we successfully identified video clips that induced positive, neutral, or negative emotions in individuals who either do or do not tend to avoid CRC information. In the main study ( N = 337), avoidance moderated the effects of affect induction on screening intentions; whereas avoiders’ screening intentions tended to be stronger after the neutral affect induction than after either the positive or negative affect induction, the pattern was the opposite for non-avoiders. Messages targeting avoiders might be more effective if they do not employ emotional appeals—including fear appeals or even gain framing if it evokes high arousal positive affect.
- 28 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Behavioral Medicine
- Vol. 49 (1) , 43-56
Intention and affective responses to colorectal cancer screening messages among people who do and do not avoid colorectal cancer information
We conducted a preregistered experiment testing the comparative efficacy of five common communication strategies (fear, disgust, values affirmation/gain frame, disrupt-then-reframe, or self-efficacy) in people who do and do not avoid colorectal cancer (CRC) information. Participants (N = 274; 45–74 years, not CRC screening adherent, no history of CRC, 49% CRC information avoiders) were randomly assigned to view one of five brief CRC screening intervention videos or an attentional control video, after which they completed assessments of affect and screening intentions followed by manipulation checks. Participants who watched the fear, disgust, disrupt-then-reframe and self-efficacy videos, rather than the control video, had stronger intentions to talk to a doctor about screening and those who watched fear and self-efficacy videos had stronger intentions to be screened. Video effects on intentions did not vary between avoiders and nonavoiders, but affective responses did. Nonavoiders reported more positive affect if they viewed CRC videos rather than the control video, but the trend reversed for avoiders. There were indirect effects of avoidance on intentions through positive affect. Depressed positive affect in response to threatening information may be part of an avoidance affective signature that could undermine motivation to engage in health behaviors such as cancer screening.
- 28 December 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Behavioral Medicine
- Vol. 49 (1) , 43-56
Intention and affective responses to colorectal cancer screening messages among people who do and do not avoid colorectal cancer information
We conducted a preregistered experiment testing the comparative efficacy of five common communication strategies (fear, disgust, values affirmation/gain frame, disrupt-then-reframe, or self-efficacy) in people who do and do not avoid colorectal cancer (CRC) information. Participants (N = 274; 45–74 years, not CRC screening adherent, no history of CRC, 49% CRC information avoiders) were randomly assigned to view one of five brief CRC screening intervention videos or an attentional control video, after which they completed assessments of affect and screening intentions followed by manipulation checks. Participants who watched the fear, disgust, disrupt-then-reframe and self-efficacy videos, rather than the control video, had stronger intentions to talk to a doctor about screening and those who watched fear and self-efficacy videos had stronger intentions to be screened. Video effects on intentions did not vary between avoiders and nonavoiders, but affective responses did. Nonavoiders reported more positive affect if they viewed CRC videos rather than the control video, but the trend reversed for avoiders. There were indirect effects of avoidance on intentions through positive affect. Depressed positive affect in response to threatening information may be part of an avoidance affective signature that could undermine motivation to engage in health behaviors such as cancer screening.
- 20 November 2025
- Published by American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) in Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention
- Vol. 35 (3) , 389-397
Challenges in Achieving US Population Awareness of Alcohol as a Carcinogen: Identifying Predictors of Continued Lack of Awareness after Educational Video Exposure
Background: Alcohol use increases the risk of seven cancers, including breast and colorectal cancers. Awareness of this is low in the US population (34%), which impedes risk reduction efforts, support for alcohol regulation policies, and physician and family communication about this topic. Efforts to improve awareness of the cancer risks of alcohol will require multiple approaches, including the use of educational messages tailored to audience needs. There is a lack of evidence about how existing messaging influences awareness and characteristics associated with awareness that could guide future messaging. Methods: We recruited a nationally representative sample of N = 827 US adults aged ≥21 who reported alcohol use in the past month and were unaware that alcohol increases cancer risk. Participants viewed a publicly available educational video on this topic and subsequently reported cancer risk awareness. Results: After video exposure, 70% of participants reported awareness. Post-video awareness was lower among heavier drinkers, those with a cancer history, those with no family cancer history, and those who tend to avoid health information, perceive low cancer controllability, or feel cancer information overload. Those who reported inaccurate beliefs at baseline (responding “no” to the question of whether cancer can result from too much alcohol) reported lower awareness than those who initially reported that they “didn’t know” whether alcohol increased cancer risk. Conclusions: These findings provide groundwork to guide the development of adaptations to available alcohol and cancer risk messaging. Impact: Educational messages tailored to audience needs can help inform all sectors of the US public about the cancer harms of alcohol. See related In the Spotlight, p. 367
- 20 November 2025
- Published by American Association for Cancer Research (AACR) in Cancer Epidemiology, Biomarkers & Prevention
- Vol. 35 (3) , 389-397
Challenges in Achieving US Population Awareness of Alcohol as a Carcinogen: Identifying Predictors of Continued Lack of Awareness after Educational Video Exposure
Background: Alcohol use increases the risk of seven cancers, including breast and colorectal cancers. Awareness of this is low in the US population (34%), which impedes risk reduction efforts, support for alcohol regulation policies, and physician and family communication about this topic. Efforts to improve awareness of the cancer risks of alcohol will require multiple approaches, including the use of educational messages tailored to audience needs. There is a lack of evidence about how existing messaging influences awareness and characteristics associated with awareness that could guide future messaging. Methods: We recruited a nationally representative sample of N = 827 US adults aged ≥21 who reported alcohol use in the past month and were unaware that alcohol increases cancer risk. Participants viewed a publicly available educational video on this topic and subsequently reported cancer risk awareness. Results: After video exposure, 70% of participants reported awareness. Post-video awareness was lower among heavier drinkers, those with a cancer history, those with no family cancer history, and those who tend to avoid health information, perceive low cancer controllability, or feel cancer information overload. Those who reported inaccurate beliefs at baseline (responding “no” to the question of whether cancer can result from too much alcohol) reported lower awareness than those who initially reported that they “didn’t know” whether alcohol increased cancer risk. Conclusions: These findings provide groundwork to guide the development of adaptations to available alcohol and cancer risk messaging. Impact: Educational messages tailored to audience needs can help inform all sectors of the US public about the cancer harms of alcohol. See related In the Spotlight, p. 367
- 26 October 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Substance Use & Misuse
- Vol. 61 (5) , 774-778
Assessing Public Opinion for Very Low Nicotine Policies: Using Open-Ended Responses to Evaluate Quantitative Survey Data and Better Inform Communication Strategies
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced plans to establish a maximum allowable nicotine level in cigarettes. Understanding public views on very low nicotine cigarettes (VLNC) is important for policymaking and message development. To provide more reliable insights than those drawn from closed-ended survey items alone, we compared policy preference results from the full survey sample with those from respondents whose open-ended justifications logically aligned with their forced-choice policy selection, treating this alignment as a proxy for more considered opinions. Our sample of US adults (N = 519) was recruited using the crowdsourcing tool, Prime Panels. We asked participants to choose which nicotine policy they would prefer, ranging from policies banning all levels of nicotine to allowing all levels of nicotine. Following that response, participants wrote a justification for their choice. We coded the open-ended responses and constructed a "thoughtfulness" variable; a thoughtful response meant the open-ended response logically matched that participants' policy choice. We used Chi-square tests of independence to analyze policy choice stratified by thoughtfulness and smoking status. Thoughtfulness of response was significantly associated with smoking status (p < .001); current smokers had the lowest proportion of thoughtful responses (53.3%, n = 88), former smokers had the highest proportion (79.1%, n = 72), and never smokers were more intermediate (66.7%, n = 178). The proportion of current smokers supporting no nicotine/VLNC drops to 23% in the thoughtful sub-sample (n = 88) from 39% (n = 77) in the unthoughtful sub-sample (p = .024). To accurately understand smoker opinions on potential VLNC policies for informed policymaking and education/communication efforts, structured interviews or short answer questions may be warranted. VLNC policy support among current smokers may be lower than previously thought based on analyses among only those who likely deliberated and thought about their policy choice, and communication strategies could be better guided by recognizing that true support among smokers may be more limited than earlier surveys suggested.
- 26 October 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Substance Use & Misuse
- Vol. 61 (5) , 774-778
Assessing Public Opinion for Very Low Nicotine Policies: Using Open-Ended Responses to Evaluate Quantitative Survey Data and Better Inform Communication Strategies
The US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) announced plans to establish a maximum allowable nicotine level in cigarettes. Understanding public views on very low nicotine cigarettes (VLNC) is important for policymaking and message development. To provide more reliable insights than those drawn from closed-ended survey items alone, we compared policy preference results from the full survey sample with those from respondents whose open-ended justifications logically aligned with their forced-choice policy selection, treating this alignment as a proxy for more considered opinions. Our sample of US adults (N = 519) was recruited using the crowdsourcing tool, Prime Panels. We asked participants to choose which nicotine policy they would prefer, ranging from policies banning all levels of nicotine to allowing all levels of nicotine. Following that response, participants wrote a justification for their choice. We coded the open-ended responses and constructed a "thoughtfulness" variable; a thoughtful response meant the open-ended response logically matched that participants' policy choice. We used Chi-square tests of independence to analyze policy choice stratified by thoughtfulness and smoking status. Thoughtfulness of response was significantly associated with smoking status (p < .001); current smokers had the lowest proportion of thoughtful responses (53.3%, n = 88), former smokers had the highest proportion (79.1%, n = 72), and never smokers were more intermediate (66.7%, n = 178). The proportion of current smokers supporting no nicotine/VLNC drops to 23% in the thoughtful sub-sample (n = 88) from 39% (n = 77) in the unthoughtful sub-sample (p = .024). To accurately understand smoker opinions on potential VLNC policies for informed policymaking and education/communication efforts, structured interviews or short answer questions may be warranted. VLNC policy support among current smokers may be lower than previously thought based on analyses among only those who likely deliberated and thought about their policy choice, and communication strategies could be better guided by recognizing that true support among smokers may be more limited than earlier surveys suggested.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease
- Vol. 108 (1) , 421-427
Information avoidance is associated with lower willingness to be screened for dementia
Background: Fear of developing Alzheimer's disease and other dementias could motivate defensive responses to dementia information, including public health messaging, and reduce willingness to undergo screening or diagnostic testing for the disease. Objective: We sought to assess the pervasiveness of dementia information avoidance and test whether it is associated with lower willingness to be screened for dementia. We also tested whether lower generalized self-efficacy is associated with higher dementia information avoidance, as the former might be a point of intervention for decreasing defensive information avoidance. Methods: Survey respondents (N = 285 recruited from Prolific; 34.7% ≥ 60 years old) answered questions about tendencies to avoid information about dementia, generalized self-efficacy, willingness to be screened for dementia, perceived risk for and worry about developing dementia, perceived preventability of dementia and dementia knowledge. Results: Nearly half of respondents believed they were somewhat (43.2%) or very (6.7%) likely to get dementia in their lifetimes. About a quarter were moderately (16.8%) or extremely (8.4%) worried about getting dementia. Although willingness to be screened was high (91.9%), there was a subgroup of respondents (9.5%) who tended to avoid dementia information and this was associated with being less likely to be willing to be screened for dementia (b = -0.40, 95% CI = -0.55, −0.25, p < 0.001). Having lower generalized self-efficacy was associated with greater dementia information avoidance (b = -0.31, 95% CI = -0.45, −0.17, p < 0.001). Conclusions: Communication about dementia risk and prevention might include strategies for enhancing agency beliefs, such as self-efficacy, in order to reduce the potential for defensive avoidance.
- 10 September 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Alzheimer’s Disease
- Vol. 108 (1) , 421-427
Information avoidance is associated with lower willingness to be screened for dementia
Background: Fear of developing Alzheimer's disease and other dementias could motivate defensive responses to dementia information, including public health messaging, and reduce willingness to undergo screening or diagnostic testing for the disease. Objective: We sought to assess the pervasiveness of dementia information avoidance and test whether it is associated with lower willingness to be screened for dementia. We also tested whether lower generalized self-efficacy is associated with higher dementia information avoidance, as the former might be a point of intervention for decreasing defensive information avoidance. Methods: Survey respondents (N = 285 recruited from Prolific; 34.7% ≥ 60 years old) answered questions about tendencies to avoid information about dementia, generalized self-efficacy, willingness to be screened for dementia, perceived risk for and worry about developing dementia, perceived preventability of dementia and dementia knowledge. Results: Nearly half of respondents believed they were somewhat (43.2%) or very (6.7%) likely to get dementia in their lifetimes. About a quarter were moderately (16.8%) or extremely (8.4%) worried about getting dementia. Although willingness to be screened was high (91.9%), there was a subgroup of respondents (9.5%) who tended to avoid dementia information and this was associated with being less likely to be willing to be screened for dementia (b = -0.40, 95% CI = -0.55, −0.25, p < 0.001). Having lower generalized self-efficacy was associated with greater dementia information avoidance (b = -0.31, 95% CI = -0.45, −0.17, p < 0.001). Conclusions: Communication about dementia risk and prevention might include strategies for enhancing agency beliefs, such as self-efficacy, in order to reduce the potential for defensive avoidance.
- 28 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Health Psychology
- Vol. 30 (1)
Reducing information avoidance: The effectiveness of humour, cute animals and coping messages
Objectives: Guided by the hedonic surplus/mood‐as‐resource hypotheses, we sought to identify message components that prevent health information avoidance by inducing hedonic psychological states. Design: Two experimental studies. Methods: Participants, age 45–75, recruited from the online survey platform, Prolific (Study 1 N = 288, Study 2 N = 505), completed a survey of their colorectal cancer (CRC) information avoidance tendency and demographics. They were reinvited to participate in a study where they were randomized to view one of four types of images: humorous comics, cute animals, coping messages or streetscapes images (control condition). To assess CRC information avoidance behaviour after viewing the stimuli, participants choose whether to be directed to a website to complete a CRC risk calculator (Study 1), or whether to view a CRC information video or a video about foot care (Study 2). Using logistic regression, we regressed each outcome variable on interactions between self‐reported CRC information avoidance tendency and experimental condition. We then used the PROCESS macro to test if mood mediated these interaction effects. Results: In Study 1, to the degree participants reported CRC information avoidance tendency, viewing humorous comics compared to control images increased their odds of choosing to view the risk calculator (OR = 5.26, p = .02). The same was true in Study 2 for choosing to watch the video about CRC vs. foot care (OR = 2.42, p = .04). Effects were not mediated through mood and there were no effects for the cute animals or coping messages. Conclusions: Using humour at the outset of a health message may increase reach to people who otherwise avoid CRC or other health messaging.
- 28 August 2024
- Published by Wiley in British Journal of Health Psychology
- Vol. 30 (1)
Reducing information avoidance: The effectiveness of humour, cute animals and coping messages
Objectives: Guided by the hedonic surplus/mood‐as‐resource hypotheses, we sought to identify message components that prevent health information avoidance by inducing hedonic psychological states. Design: Two experimental studies. Methods: Participants, age 45–75, recruited from the online survey platform, Prolific (Study 1 N = 288, Study 2 N = 505), completed a survey of their colorectal cancer (CRC) information avoidance tendency and demographics. They were reinvited to participate in a study where they were randomized to view one of four types of images: humorous comics, cute animals, coping messages or streetscapes images (control condition). To assess CRC information avoidance behaviour after viewing the stimuli, participants choose whether to be directed to a website to complete a CRC risk calculator (Study 1), or whether to view a CRC information video or a video about foot care (Study 2). Using logistic regression, we regressed each outcome variable on interactions between self‐reported CRC information avoidance tendency and experimental condition. We then used the PROCESS macro to test if mood mediated these interaction effects. Results: In Study 1, to the degree participants reported CRC information avoidance tendency, viewing humorous comics compared to control images increased their odds of choosing to view the risk calculator (OR = 5.26, p = .02). The same was true in Study 2 for choosing to watch the video about CRC vs. foot care (OR = 2.42, p = .04). Effects were not mediated through mood and there were no effects for the cute animals or coping messages. Conclusions: Using humour at the outset of a health message may increase reach to people who otherwise avoid CRC or other health messaging.
- 9 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Behavioral Medicine
- Vol. 47 (3) , 504-514
Colorectal cancer information avoidance is associated with screening adherence
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the fourth most common cancer among U.S. men and women and the second deadliest. Effective screening modalities can either prevent CRC or find it earlier, but fewer than two thirds of U.S. adults are adherent to CRC screening guidelines. We tested whether people who defensively avoid CRC information have lower adherence to CRC screening recommendations and weaker intentions for being screened and whether CRC information avoidance adds predictive ability beyond known determinants of screening. Participants, aged 45–75 years, completed a survey about known structural determinants of CRC screening (healthcare coverage, healthcare use, provider recommendation), CRC information avoidance tendencies, and screening behavior (n = 887) and intentions (n = 425). Models were tested with multivariable regression and structural equation modeling (SEM). To the extent that participants avoided CRC information, they had lower odds of being adherent to CRC screening guidelines (OR = 0.55) and if non-adherent, less likely to intend to be screened (b=-0.50). In the SEM model, avoidance was negatively associated with each known structural determinant of screening and with lower screening adherence (ps < 0.01). Fit was significantly worse for nested SEM models when avoidance was not included, (i.e., the paths to avoidance were fixed to zero). Information avoidance was associated with screening behavior and other known structural determinants of screening adherence, potentially compounding its influence. Novel strategies are needed to reach avoiders, including health communication messaging that disrupts avoidance and interventions external to the healthcare system, with which avoiders are less engaged.
- 9 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Behavioral Medicine
- Vol. 47 (3) , 504-514
Colorectal cancer information avoidance is associated with screening adherence
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the fourth most common cancer among U.S. men and women and the second deadliest. Effective screening modalities can either prevent CRC or find it earlier, but fewer than two thirds of U.S. adults are adherent to CRC screening guidelines. We tested whether people who defensively avoid CRC information have lower adherence to CRC screening recommendations and weaker intentions for being screened and whether CRC information avoidance adds predictive ability beyond known determinants of screening. Participants, aged 45–75 years, completed a survey about known structural determinants of CRC screening (healthcare coverage, healthcare use, provider recommendation), CRC information avoidance tendencies, and screening behavior (n = 887) and intentions (n = 425). Models were tested with multivariable regression and structural equation modeling (SEM). To the extent that participants avoided CRC information, they had lower odds of being adherent to CRC screening guidelines (OR = 0.55) and if non-adherent, less likely to intend to be screened (b=-0.50). In the SEM model, avoidance was negatively associated with each known structural determinant of screening and with lower screening adherence (ps < 0.01). Fit was significantly worse for nested SEM models when avoidance was not included, (i.e., the paths to avoidance were fixed to zero). Information avoidance was associated with screening behavior and other known structural determinants of screening adherence, potentially compounding its influence. Novel strategies are needed to reach avoiders, including health communication messaging that disrupts avoidance and interventions external to the healthcare system, with which avoiders are less engaged.
- 2 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Risk Research
- Vol. 26 (12) , 1370-1382
I don’t know my child’s asthma risk: evidence against satisficing as an explanation for ‘don’t know’ responses
Several studies suggest that 'don't know' (DK) responses to risk perception items may represent meaningful expressions of uncertainty about disease risk. However, researchers are often discouraged from including a DK response option in survey items due to concerns about respondents overusing it to minimize cognitive effort-a phenomenon often referred to as satisficing. Our objective was to investigate whether patterns of DK responses to risk perception survey items were consistent with satisficing behavior. We conducted a secondary analysis of survey data from 814 parents and guardians (hereafter caregivers) of children with asthma. Caregivers answered 18 items assessing their perceived risk of their child experiencing two types of poor asthma outcomes: asthma exacerbation, and low asthma control. We examined differences in the frequency and distribution of DK responses across all 18 items and by type of risk perception item (i.e. 2 vs. 5 response options, absolute vs. comparative risk). We found that 32% (n = 548) of respondents marked DK at least once. Of the 266 caregivers who provided any DK response, most did so for only 1 or 2 items (51.9%, n = 138), and only 6% (n = 15) answered DK to more than half of the items. Using random coefficient Poisson models, we found more DK responding for dichotomous absolute (30.1%) than ordinal absolute items (5.3%), b = 1.72, p<.001. We also found fewer DK responses to the ordinal absolute items than the comparative items (8.2%), b=-0.49, p<.001. Using Chi-square tests, we found that inattentive responding was not associated with responding DK. Our findings suggest that satisficing is unlikely to completely explain DK responding to perceived risk survey items. Researchers who exclude DK response options from risk perception survey items may obtain an incomplete understanding of their study sample's beliefs about risk.
- 2 December 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Risk Research
- Vol. 26 (12) , 1370-1382
I don’t know my child’s asthma risk: evidence against satisficing as an explanation for ‘don’t know’ responses
Several studies suggest that 'don't know' (DK) responses to risk perception items may represent meaningful expressions of uncertainty about disease risk. However, researchers are often discouraged from including a DK response option in survey items due to concerns about respondents overusing it to minimize cognitive effort-a phenomenon often referred to as satisficing. Our objective was to investigate whether patterns of DK responses to risk perception survey items were consistent with satisficing behavior. We conducted a secondary analysis of survey data from 814 parents and guardians (hereafter caregivers) of children with asthma. Caregivers answered 18 items assessing their perceived risk of their child experiencing two types of poor asthma outcomes: asthma exacerbation, and low asthma control. We examined differences in the frequency and distribution of DK responses across all 18 items and by type of risk perception item (i.e. 2 vs. 5 response options, absolute vs. comparative risk). We found that 32% (n = 548) of respondents marked DK at least once. Of the 266 caregivers who provided any DK response, most did so for only 1 or 2 items (51.9%, n = 138), and only 6% (n = 15) answered DK to more than half of the items. Using random coefficient Poisson models, we found more DK responding for dichotomous absolute (30.1%) than ordinal absolute items (5.3%), b = 1.72, p<.001. We also found fewer DK responses to the ordinal absolute items than the comparative items (8.2%), b=-0.49, p<.001. Using Chi-square tests, we found that inattentive responding was not associated with responding DK. Our findings suggest that satisficing is unlikely to completely explain DK responding to perceived risk survey items. Researchers who exclude DK response options from risk perception survey items may obtain an incomplete understanding of their study sample's beliefs about risk.