Nadja Schaetz
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Nadja Schaetz has a total of 45 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Juliane A. Lischka
Universität Hamburg
6 shared publications Laura Laugwitz
3 shared publications- Alexa Robertson
Stockholm University
2 shared publications Anna Schjøtt
Roskilde University, Denmark
2 shared publications- Laura Laugwitz
Department of Social Sciences, University of Hamburg
2 shared publications - Agustin Ferrari Braun
University of Amsterdam, Netherlands
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 August 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly
- Vol. 103 (4) , 1487-1508
The Trouble With Catching Up: Problematizing the “AI Gap” and its Global Inequities in Journalism
The “artificial intelligence (AI) gap” in journalism describes a divide between newsrooms equipped to innovate and benefit from AI and those left behind. Rather than an objective condition, this study examines this gap as a discursive construction, drawing on articulation theory. Using the JournalismAI Academy for Small Newsrooms as a case study, we combine ethnographic observation with interviews conducted in 2022 to 2023 and 2025. Findings demonstrate how technological lag is articulated as a problem and AI investment as its solution, a linkage stabilized through assumptions of inevitable, linear technological progress—legitimizing particular ways of thinking about and acting on AI.
- 25 August 2026
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly
- Vol. 103 (4) , 1487-1508
Open AccessThe Trouble With Catching Up: Problematizing the “AI Gap” and its Global Inequities in Journalism
The “artificial intelligence (AI) gap” in journalism describes a divide between newsrooms equipped to innovate and benefit from AI and those left behind. Rather than an objective condition, this study examines this gap as a discursive construction, drawing on articulation theory. Using the JournalismAI Academy for Small Newsrooms as a case study, we combine ethnographic observation with interviews conducted in 2022 to 2023 and 2025. Findings demonstrate how technological lag is articulated as a problem and AI investment as its solution, a linkage stabilized through assumptions of inevitable, linear technological progress—legitimizing particular ways of thinking about and acting on AI.
- Open Access
- 26 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Information, Communication & Society
- Vol. 29 (12) , 1-19
Taming AI: how AI courses for journalists shape the global appropriation of AI
- 26 January 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Information, Communication & Society
- Vol. 29 (12) , 1-19
Open AccessTaming AI: how AI courses for journalists shape the global appropriation of AI
- Open Access
- 18 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
What is Data? A Conceptual and Empirical Inquiry of the Facets of Data in News Organizations
While journalism research increasingly engages with the applications of artificial intelligence (AI), it often overlooks the foundational layer that enables AI itself: data. This study conceptualizes ‘data’ in journalism, a field profoundly shaped by data-intensive practices. Integrating perspectives from Science and Technology Studies (STS), infrastructure studies, and journalism practice, this study traces how data is embedded in news organizations. Following a Laswellian framework, we describe: What is datafied (subjects), who produces and processes data (actors), where data circulates (spaces), how data is composed (constructions), and why data is valued (values). To illustrate these facets, we construct a Patchwork News Outlet, which is a composite case that synthesizes empirical insights from six news organizations from five countries, identifying common data practices and points of divergence. Findings reveal that data practices span from the ubiquitous use of data, to selective engagement with data-driven strategies, and strategic resistance to datafication. We offer not one but five definitions of data, each grounded in a specific theoretical stream and derived from an analysis across the Lasswellian framework’s dimensions: data (1) as a socially constructed artifact shaped by power structures, biases, and strategic interests; (2) as an infrastructural entity embedded in socio-technical systems; (3) as resource for news stories; (4) as machine-readable input optimized for computational processing; and (5) as empirical representations of audience transactions and editorial practices, embedded with biases and contested value. Alongside its conceptual contribution, we introduce a systematic framework for locating research foci across intersecting dimensions of data in journalism.
- 18 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessWhat is Data? A Conceptual and Empirical Inquiry of the Facets of Data in News Organizations
While journalism research increasingly engages with the applications of artificial intelligence (AI), it often overlooks the foundational layer that enables AI itself: data. This study conceptualizes ‘data’ in journalism, a field profoundly shaped by data-intensive practices. Integrating perspectives from Science and Technology Studies (STS), infrastructure studies, and journalism practice, this study traces how data is embedded in news organizations. Following a Laswellian framework, we describe: What is datafied (subjects), who produces and processes data (actors), where data circulates (spaces), how data is composed (constructions), and why data is valued (values). To illustrate these facets, we construct a Patchwork News Outlet, which is a composite case that synthesizes empirical insights from six news organizations from five countries, identifying common data practices and points of divergence. Findings reveal that data practices span from the ubiquitous use of data, to selective engagement with data-driven strategies, and strategic resistance to datafication. We offer not one but five definitions of data, each grounded in a specific theoretical stream and derived from an analysis across the Lasswellian framework’s dimensions: data (1) as a socially constructed artifact shaped by power structures, biases, and strategic interests; (2) as an infrastructural entity embedded in socio-technical systems; (3) as resource for news stories; (4) as machine-readable input optimized for computational processing; and (5) as empirical representations of audience transactions and editorial practices, embedded with biases and contested value. Alongside its conceptual contribution, we introduce a systematic framework for locating research foci across intersecting dimensions of data in journalism.
- Open Access
- 4 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
ChatGPT as a news recommender system: Measuring source types and diversity across different interfaces
This study examines to what extent ChatGPT’s responses to news-seeking prompts reflectexposure diversity in news sources, paying particular attention to whether publishers with licensingagreements are systematically privileged in outputs. Based on a quantitative content analysiscomparing responses from ChatGPT’s web interface and API, the findings indicate that while themodel offers a range of sources, exposure diversity remains limited and context dependent.Although no clear or consistent patterns were observed in the use of traditional journalistic outlets,there was a general tendency towards a greater inclusion of digital-born and hyper-partisan newssites under conditions of prompting for diversity. Results further show discrepancies between theAPI and web interface outputs that reveal significant structural variation in how the model curatesinformation: while the web interface produced results more aligned with mainstream popularitymeasures and showed a higher presence of outlets with licensing agreements, the API tendedtoward encyclopedic and lesser-known sources. Implications for publishers and users arediscussed.
- 4 November 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessChatGPT as a news recommender system: Measuring source types and diversity across different interfaces
This study examines to what extent ChatGPT’s responses to news-seeking prompts reflectexposure diversity in news sources, paying particular attention to whether publishers with licensingagreements are systematically privileged in outputs. Based on a quantitative content analysiscomparing responses from ChatGPT’s web interface and API, the findings indicate that while themodel offers a range of sources, exposure diversity remains limited and context dependent.Although no clear or consistent patterns were observed in the use of traditional journalistic outlets,there was a general tendency towards a greater inclusion of digital-born and hyper-partisan newssites under conditions of prompting for diversity. Results further show discrepancies between theAPI and web interface outputs that reveal significant structural variation in how the model curatesinformation: while the web interface produced results more aligned with mainstream popularitymeasures and showed a higher presence of outlets with licensing agreements, the API tendedtoward encyclopedic and lesser-known sources. Implications for publishers and users arediscussed.
- Open Access
- 24 October 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Recommender Systems
- Vol. 5 (1) , 1-26
From Good Intentions to Meaningful Impact: A Design Justice Approach for News Recommendation
News recommender systems are increasingly positioned as tools for enhancing public discourse, yet their design often reflects narrow commercial or technological goals and overlooks systemic inequalities. This paper introduces a design justice framework to critically examine how these systems encode, enact and reinforce power at multiple levels. Drawing on prior design justice work, we analyze news recommendation processes from an interdisciplinary perspective across micro (values), meso (networks of expertise), and macro (problem scopes) levels. We argue that while efforts to incorporate fairness and diversity into algorithms are important, they are insufficient without confronting the structural dynamics that shape design decisions. In response, we provide a set of actionable strategies to help researchers and practitioners implement design justice in news recommendation processes, shifting the focus from intentions to real-world impact. These strategies offer guidance for evaluating how systems distribute risks and benefits across different social contexts. Rather than proposing a perfect solution, we use design justice as an orientation, acknowledging that justice is iterative and contextual, and that design processes must balance ideals with practical constraints. Our contribution is a conceptual bridge between communication and computer science that enables a more just approach to news recommendation.
- 24 October 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in ACM Transactions on Recommender Systems
- Vol. 5 (1) , 1-26
Open AccessFrom Good Intentions to Meaningful Impact: A Design Justice Approach for News Recommendation
News recommender systems are increasingly positioned as tools for enhancing public discourse, yet their design often reflects narrow commercial or technological goals and overlooks systemic inequalities. This paper introduces a design justice framework to critically examine how these systems encode, enact and reinforce power at multiple levels. Drawing on prior design justice work, we analyze news recommendation processes from an interdisciplinary perspective across micro (values), meso (networks of expertise), and macro (problem scopes) levels. We argue that while efforts to incorporate fairness and diversity into algorithms are important, they are insufficient without confronting the structural dynamics that shape design decisions. In response, we provide a set of actionable strategies to help researchers and practitioners implement design justice in news recommendation processes, shifting the focus from intentions to real-world impact. These strategies offer guidance for evaluating how systems distribute risks and benefits across different social contexts. Rather than proposing a perfect solution, we use design justice as an orientation, acknowledging that justice is iterative and contextual, and that design processes must balance ideals with practical constraints. Our contribution is a conceptual bridge between communication and computer science that enables a more just approach to news recommendation.
- 5 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 27 (6) , 1818-1837
The logics of innovation. Institutional logics and isomorphic pressures in public service media innovation labs in the age of artificial intelligence
This study explores how Public Service Media (PSM) innovation laboratories navigate a complex institutional environment that simultaneously constrains and demands innovation. Drawing on the concepts of isomorphic pressures and institutional logics, the study investigates strategies used by PSM innovation labs to innovate within institutional constraints. Based on interviews with editorial technologists from three PSM innovation labs in Germany, we identify five institutional logics that enable innovation despite strong normative and coercive pressures: the logics of agility, efficiency, public service, audience, and interdisciplinary collaboration. These logics function as adaptive mechanisms that enable PSM innovation labs to balance the demands of innovation with adherence to norms, regulations, and limited resources. Our findings illustrate how PSMs can manage institutional complexity and sustain innovation within constrained operational environments. Hence, this study offers a dynamic view of isomorphism, where conformity and agency coexist, and where innovation can emerge from within institutional boundaries rather than in opposition to them.
- 5 June 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 27 (6) , 1818-1837
The logics of innovation. Institutional logics and isomorphic pressures in public service media innovation labs in the age of artificial intelligence
This study explores how Public Service Media (PSM) innovation laboratories navigate a complex institutional environment that simultaneously constrains and demands innovation. Drawing on the concepts of isomorphic pressures and institutional logics, the study investigates strategies used by PSM innovation labs to innovate within institutional constraints. Based on interviews with editorial technologists from three PSM innovation labs in Germany, we identify five institutional logics that enable innovation despite strong normative and coercive pressures: the logics of agility, efficiency, public service, audience, and interdisciplinary collaboration. These logics function as adaptive mechanisms that enable PSM innovation labs to balance the demands of innovation with adherence to norms, regulations, and limited resources. Our findings illustrate how PSMs can manage institutional complexity and sustain innovation within constrained operational environments. Hence, this study offers a dynamic view of isomorphism, where conformity and agency coexist, and where innovation can emerge from within institutional boundaries rather than in opposition to them.
- Open Access
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Digital Journalism
- Vol. 14 (2) , 220-237
AI Hype and its Function: An Ethnographic Study of the Local News AI Initiative of the Associated Press
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Digital Journalism
- Vol. 14 (2) , 220-237
Open AccessAI Hype and its Function: An Ethnographic Study of the Local News AI Initiative of the Associated Press
- Open Access
- 28 August 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in New Media & Society
- Vol. 27 (3) , 1360-1377
Algorithm dependency in platformized news use
Previous research has highlighted the ambiguous experience of algorithmic news curation whereby people are simultaneously comfortable with algorithms, but also concerned about the underlying data collection practices. The present article builds on media dependency theory and news-finds-me (NFM) perceptions to explore this tension. Empirically, we analyze original survey data from six European countries (Germany, Sweden, France, Greece, Poland, and Italy, n = 2,899) to investigate how young Europeans’ privacy concerns and attitudes toward algorithms affect NFM. We find that a more positive attitude toward algorithms and more privacy concerns are related to stronger NFM. The study highlights power asymmetries in platformized news use and suggests that the ambivalent experiences might be a result of algorithm dependency , whereby individuals rely on algorithms in platformized news use to meet their information needs, despite accompanying risks and concerns.
- 28 August 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in New Media & Society
- Vol. 27 (3) , 1360-1377
Open AccessAlgorithm dependency in platformized news use
Previous research has highlighted the ambiguous experience of algorithmic news curation whereby people are simultaneously comfortable with algorithms, but also concerned about the underlying data collection practices. The present article builds on media dependency theory and news-finds-me (NFM) perceptions to explore this tension. Empirically, we analyze original survey data from six European countries (Germany, Sweden, France, Greece, Poland, and Italy, n = 2,899) to investigate how young Europeans’ privacy concerns and attitudes toward algorithms affect NFM. We find that a more positive attitude toward algorithms and more privacy concerns are related to stronger NFM. The study highlights power asymmetries in platformized news use and suggests that the ambivalent experiences might be a result of algorithm dependency , whereby individuals rely on algorithms in platformized news use to meet their information needs, despite accompanying risks and concerns.
- 26 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Digital Journalism
- Vol. 13 (4) , 677-695
Datafication of Journalism: How Data Elites and Epistemic Infrastructures Change News Organizations
- 26 July 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Digital Journalism
- Vol. 13 (4) , 677-695
Datafication of Journalism: How Data Elites and Epistemic Infrastructures Change News Organizations
- Open Access
- 15 May 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 25 (5) , 1148-1166
Solving journalism with data: Silicon Valley’s influence on the Fourth Estate
The historically ambiguous relationship between journalism and Big Tech can be traced back to the late 20th century, when news organizations started to recognize the potential of the Internet as a distribution platform. While a growing body of literature is concerned with power asymmetries between Big Tech and journalism, the role of place in shaping the layered histories of journalism remains underexplored. This study uses a framework of place—conceptualized as material and geographic, a setting for action and lived experiences carrying the legacies of their past, and a site of accumulating histories of cultural meaning and power ( Usher, 2019 )—to examine how Silicon Valley and Fourth Estate ideals converge. Empirically, the study analyzes job advertisements of four US and UK print-legacy news outlets serving as a window into shifting expectations, skills, and values that news organizations seek in their employees, reflecting broader trends in journalism. Findings show that journalism draws on Silicon Valley ideals, merging datasolutionism with Fourth Estate narratives of audience access. Some news organizations are not only tech-oriented but frame themselves as tech companies with a Fourth Estate mission. While both Silicon Valley and Fourth Estate narratives promote ideals of equal power distribution, findings indicate the reinforcement of hegemonic power structures in the news industry. We conclude that the influence of Silicon Valley on journalism is one of consolidating power through location, action, and cultural meaning, as news organizations construct datasolutionism as a pivotal novel layer to achieve long-standing Fourth Estate ideals. This analysis contributes to our understanding of the historical context and evolving nature of the relationship between journalism and Big Tech, highlighting the significance of place in shaping the dynamics between these two increasingly intertwined industries.
- 15 May 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 25 (5) , 1148-1166
Open AccessSolving journalism with data: Silicon Valley’s influence on the Fourth Estate
The historically ambiguous relationship between journalism and Big Tech can be traced back to the late 20th century, when news organizations started to recognize the potential of the Internet as a distribution platform. While a growing body of literature is concerned with power asymmetries between Big Tech and journalism, the role of place in shaping the layered histories of journalism remains underexplored. This study uses a framework of place—conceptualized as material and geographic, a setting for action and lived experiences carrying the legacies of their past, and a site of accumulating histories of cultural meaning and power ( Usher, 2019 )—to examine how Silicon Valley and Fourth Estate ideals converge. Empirically, the study analyzes job advertisements of four US and UK print-legacy news outlets serving as a window into shifting expectations, skills, and values that news organizations seek in their employees, reflecting broader trends in journalism. Findings show that journalism draws on Silicon Valley ideals, merging datasolutionism with Fourth Estate narratives of audience access. Some news organizations are not only tech-oriented but frame themselves as tech companies with a Fourth Estate mission. While both Silicon Valley and Fourth Estate narratives promote ideals of equal power distribution, findings indicate the reinforcement of hegemonic power structures in the news industry. We conclude that the influence of Silicon Valley on journalism is one of consolidating power through location, action, and cultural meaning, as news organizations construct datasolutionism as a pivotal novel layer to achieve long-standing Fourth Estate ideals. This analysis contributes to our understanding of the historical context and evolving nature of the relationship between journalism and Big Tech, highlighting the significance of place in shaping the dynamics between these two increasingly intertwined industries.