HOHanna Ostapenko

Hanna Ostapenko

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Hanna Ostapenko has a total of 1 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Providing legal certainty in Ukraine: actual status and routs for the implementation

    by Hanna Zinovyivna Ostapenko

    The article analyzes legal certainty principle as the requirement of the rule of law and discusses the application of this principle in Ukraine with the aim to introduce practical solutions and improve its implementation. The difficulties to sustain legal certainty caused by reforms in different spheres of legal practice and crucial sociopolitical situation formed the necessity of prompt legal changes that resulted in setting out new legislation as a response to existing demands. The common solution in this situation is the improvement of the legislation by making changes, introduction of the new legal act or amendments to the existing one. However, what is seen as evident and only solution is not the best in some cases. Legal certainty principle is the element of the rule of law, that provides stability, predictability, and sustainability in application of the legal norms, results in effectiveness of its application, allows the participants to make decisions about their actions based on the understanding whether their behaviour is legally allowed or not and of the consequences of their actions. The legal basis of the application of this principle is the article 8 of the Constitution of Ukraine, although the principle itself is not specifically named there. Some of the elements of legal certainty are embodied into Ukrainian legislation. The common situation of application of this principle is legal uncertainty, the level of which in Ukraine is rather high based on the number of the judgments that refer to legal certainty. Ukrainian legal doctrine proposes the immediate change in legislation as the solution to improve legal certainty. However, in some cases the immediate and fast changes of the legislation can cause uncertainties themselves. The examples of the changes to the important legal acts such as The Judiciary System Act and The Enforcement Authority Act show that they suffered severe changes including complete replacement in a short period of time impacting a lot of people. It is argued that the changes must be justified and the legal act very well prepared and drafted. The idea to expand legal regulation is not always the best solution as there should be a certain level of discretion left to meet the needs of the changing environment and specific circumstances. One of the fields that can contribute to the improvement of legal certainty is the unified judiciary application of legal acts that form a legal practice and can balance the absence of legal certainty of legislation if this is the case. Another suggestion made in the article that proper administration can play an immense role in improving legal certainty. This can be done by ambiguity of administration practice and the examples are shown in the article to prove this position. Key words: legal certainty, legal principle, rule of law, judicial practice

  • Open Access

    Role of Legal Certainty in Providing Economic Security: Ukraine’s Experience

    by Hanna Ostapenko

    Economic security is an element of the national security of the country. Even though regulation of economic security implies developing economic sectors or preventing threats, legal principles are not usually considered. The article analyzes how legal certainty as a principle forms a favorable environment, produces reliability, and encourages market players to realize their economic and entrepreneurial initiatives, provided that the country ensures a high level of it. A plurality of the elements of legal certainty makes the influence of the principle of legal certainty on the economic situation diverse and merely realized. It is proposed to divide these elements into two groups in the article. The first one consists of predictability, consistency, and stability. The second one incorporates the mechanisms, mostly legally provided, that prevent the violation of legal certainty. Further examples of court decisions and government acts show negative implications for economic security the violation of legal certainty can lead to. The stability that arises from legal certainty can help market players build their plans and calculate positive risks. Legal certainty contributes to the attraction of investments since profitability depends on the stability of legal regulation. Legitimate expectations are the components of the principle of legal certainty; they rely on the time an entrepreneur makes their business plans. Thus, the reliability that arises from respect to legitimate expectations plays a crucial role in long-term business planning. Immediate changes, the lack of enforcement caused by sudden changes in previously made decisions, and inconsistency in market management lead to a harmful economic effect on legitimate expectations.


  • Open Access

    The Role of Legal Certainty Principle in Provision of Access to Justice in Ukraine in Wartime

    by Hanna Ostapenko

    Background: The paper offers the analysis of implementation of legal certainty principle and access to justice in Ukraine. Both are regarded in connection to the rule of law principle; their coordination is shown in cases when the application of rule of law is required to patch the holes of imperfect judicial system facing the challenges of the ongoing war. Methods: The methods of legal reasoning and analysis are used to present the main approaches to legal certainty principle as well as to the access to justice. Additionally, with the help of comparative method their meaning and influence on the legal practice are established. The method of analogy is used to predict the possible solutions in order to improve access to justice in Ukraine. Results and Conclusions: Legal certainty is an element of the rule of law, it provides predictability in legal regulation, the clarity of legal norms, and demands the propriate way of legal acts enforcement as well as prohibits retroactivity. It challenges respect to the legitimate expectations and provides stability in legal regulation. The improvement in the application of the right to access to justice is beneficial for the legal certainty and vice versa. When legal certainty is violated due to the gap in legislation, unclarity of legal norms or controversy of legislative provisions and violated rights of the claimant could be restored, if the right of access to court is fully guaranteed. It is stated that res judicata, a requirement for legal certainty is a demand that is also common to access to justice.


  • Would architecture be a creative industry in Ukraine?

    by Hanna Ostapenko

    Keywords: creative industry, architectural creation, architectural solution, architect,authors rights of architect Thearticle is devoted to analysis of the legal position of architect has in relations with theclient. Architecture is regarded as a creative industry in Ukraine, therefore the attentionpayed to protection of intellectual property rights in this sphere is important. Theidea implemented in architectural model should be protected according to the protectionof copyright. The industry remains creative until the level of creativeness is highin this economic sector and the number of people involved in production due to the effectivenessand demand for the product is increasing or remains constant. The resultof art and of the architecture is not only the object of property, owned by a client, butalso a piece of art protected as creation under copyright. The subject of such rights isan architect. The legal status of architect in Ukraine is provided by the right to supervisionduring the building process, demand of sighing a final act completing the construction,which means, the building is lead astray without breaking authors copyright.Other special rights are provided such as a right to make a photo of the objectbefore destroying it.Despite regarding architecture objects as protected by copyright the draft law isadopted in the first reading that limits the rights and influence of architect has in theprocess of building. The draft law proposes an option for architect to transfer rights,being apart from the process of building. This can cause a situation when the buildingwill be constructively changed, the creation will be changed without the authors participation.If this proposal will be implemented, the level of the creativeness in architecturewould decrease and even lost. So, the total sphere risks losing the status ofbeing creative. It is underlined that respect to the copyright in architecture is necessaryto the industry and its development. In particular. such rights of the architect asa subject of intellectual property law will be under threat: the freedom of creativity,the right to the inviolability of the work, economic rights. Another thing which is ofconcern is the responsibility of the architect. The removal of the architect during theconstruction process poses a risk of absence of the culprit in case of deformation or destructionof the object, caused by a structural defect or defect of the project.

  • LEGAL CERTAINTY IN THE ASPECT OF LOCAL GOVERNMENT

    by Taras Shevchenko national University of Kyiv, H. Ostapenko

    The article addresses the analyses of adherence to the legal certainty principle while the local government exercises its powers, which are enlarged during the reform of decentralization. It is stated that while the powers belonged to state government, the adherence of the legal certainty principle was found as very important to protect citizens from unpredictable and unequal treatment. So as soon as the powers were handed over to local government the protection of legal certainty principle still remains actual. Legal certainty requires clarity and legibility of legal provisions, limitation of discretive powers, promulgation and publication of legal acts in advance etc. These elements must be adhered realizing local powers. One of the elements legal certainty requires is protection of the legitimate expectations of citizens. A number of court decisions which are analyzed in the article prove that breaking of legitimate expectations happens frequently. Emphasis is made on preventing such practices and on the need to respect legal certainty as a mandatory requirement of the rule of law. The necessity of observance of the requirements of legal certainty at promulgation of acts by local self-government bodies and making the citizens know about them is determined.