SGSarah Gardezi

Sarah Gardezi

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Sarah Gardezi has a total of 35 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Dialoguing educational challenges: Understanding early school leaving and underachievement

    by Sarah Gardezi, Joe O'HAra, Gerry McNamara, Aideen Cassidy, Martin Brown, Michael McNamara

  • Open Access

    The quiet struggle: How vulnerable youth succeed with the right support

    by Sarah Gardezi, Martin Brown, Aideen Cassidy, Gerry McNamara, Joe O'HAra, Michael McNamara

    Educational inequality remains a pervasive and deeply entrenched global issue, with youth from vulnerable and marginalised backgrounds disproportionately affected. Despite the significant challenges that hinder the academic progress of many young people, often reinforcing cycles of social exclusion and economic vulnerability, some students demonstrate the capacity to excel academically, effectively defying the odds. This study seeks to examine the key structural and interpersonal factors that enable such students to achieve positive educational trajectories. Adopting a qualitative narrative research design, the research draws on two sets of semi‐structured interviews with both young people from vulnerable backgrounds and adults who played a role in their educational success ( n = 16). Findings identify four broad categories of factors shaping student success: (1) personal attributes such as resilience, intrinsic motivation, clear goals and a strong sense of purpose; (2) parental expectations and support; (3) teachers' emotional support, involvement and constructive feedback and (4) peer support. Of these, two factors emerged as consistently significant across all cases. First, parental expectations, underpinned by trust in their child's abilities and a high valuation of education, proved essential. Second, the depth and longevity of student–teacher relationships were crucial, with teachers' emotional investment, trust and sustained support providing enduring sources of motivation and encouragement. These insights have important implications for schools, teacher education and policy development. Schools should foster inclusive, high‐expectations cultures with long‐term mentoring and structured peer integration promoting cross‐cultural interaction. Teacher education, in initial and continuing training, should include socio‐emotional learning and pedagogical strategies for non‐native language learners. Context and implications: Rationale for the study: Previous research has typically examined either the perspectives of disadvantaged young people or those of professionals supporting them, often focusing on barriers and deficits. This study brings together both viewpoints to identify the key factors, relationships and supports that enable successful outcomes for young people in contexts where early school leaving is prevalent. Why the new findings matter: Our findings suggest that educational success among disadvantaged young people is shaped by interconnected support systems rather than individual effort alone. Strong parental belief in education and meaningful teacher–student relationships are central to resilience, reinforced by academic, social and community supports that enabled positive educational outcomes. Implications for practitioners and policymakers: Schools need to prioritise mentoring, inclusive cultures and structured cross‐cultural peer activities to strengthen belonging and aspiration. Teacher education and professional development should embed socio‐emotional learning, strategies for supporting multilingual learners and approaches that sustain high expectations in disadvantaged contexts. Policymakers should sustain and strengthen financial supports that enable disadvantaged students to access higher education, ensuring they keep pace with rising participation costs. Increased investment in schools serving disadvantaged communities is also needed to support meaningful family engagement and strengthen home–school relationships that foster resilience and educational success.


  • The trajectories of second-level inspection in Ireland from 1980 to 2016

    by Mary O'DOherty, Gerry McNamara, Sarah Gardezi, Martin Brown

    In this paper, we aim to provide an historical account of the development of the Irish Inspectorate in second-level schools in Ireland, from the 1980s to 2016. The Inspectorate holds a very particu...

  • Open Access

    The problem of early school leaving—socioeconomic causes and potential solutions: a systematic literature review

    by Sarah Gardezi, Gerry McNamara, Joe O'HAra, Martin Brown, Aideen Cassidy, Michael McNamara

    Early School Leaving (ESL), defined within the European Union policy space as individuals aged 18–24 who leave the education system without attaining upper secondary qualifications, affects approximately 3.1 million young people annually across EU. The repercussions of ESL are profound, such as diminishing tax revenues, increasing reliance on social services, and perpetuating cycles of poverty and poor health. Through a systematic literature review of 80 peer-reviewed papers published between 2003 and 2023, the purpose of this paper is to examine the socioeconomic causes of ESL. These causes include factors such as parental level of education and occupation, poverty leading to educational disadvantage, and lack of educational motivation. They also include factors related to schooling, such as school segregation, unsuitable curricula, teacher attitudes and expectations, and inflexible pathways through education and training. The findings reveal the complex interplay between socioeconomic status and educational outcomes. The discussion, while highlighting the interaction of social determinants contributing to underachievement and ESL, also outlines policy measures and interventions designed to counteract ESL's impact, emphasizing a joined-up approach to tackle these challenges. The paper concludes with specific recommendations for policymakers and practitioners aimed at reducing ESL and enhancing educational equity across Europe and beyond.


  • Open Access

    Early School Leaving by Design—Prevention, Intervention and Compensation—A Policy Analysis of Early School Leaving and Underachievement Interventions in Europe

    by Martin Brown, Joe O’hara, Sarah Gardezi, Gerry McNamara, John O’hara, Geraldine French, Grainne McKenna, Aideen Cassidy, Anne Rowan, Michael McNamara

    The purpose of this paper is to provide a comparative policy analysis of successful strategies that have been implemented across European countries to address early school leaving (ESL) and academic underachievement. Employing a transformative and multidimensional approach, the study examines systemic and local interventions that integrate cognitive and socio-emotional dimensions of learning. Using Eurostat data to categorise countries based on their ESL reduction progress, the analysis evaluates legislative frameworks, policy initiatives, and educational practices through the prevention, intervention, and compensation model. The findings identify common themes such as the expansion of early childhood education and care (ECEC), enhancement of guidance and counselling services, targeted support for socio-economically disadvantaged groups, inclusive policies for marginalised populations including Roma communities, and the development of vocational and second-chance education pathways. The paper highlights the critical importance of coherent and scalable policy design to reduce educational inequalities and contribute to achieving European Union ESL reduction targets by 2030. It advances policy discourse by emphasising the essential need for balanced preventive and compensatory measures to improve educational outcomes and to foster social inclusion across varied national contexts.


  • Open Access

    Effective practices for reducing underachievement and early school leaving: insights from successful learning environments

    by Sarah Gardezi, Aideen Cassidy, Gerry McNamara, Joe O’hAra, Martin Brown


  • Assessing the Role of Diversity in Higher Education Institutions

    by Sarah Gardezi, Gerry McNamara, Joe O'HAra, Martin Brown

    This study examines the role of diversity in higher education, exploring its benefits, challenges, and institutional strategies for fostering inclusive learning environments. Through a systematic literature review, it highlights how diversity enhances cognitive, social, and academic development while driving institutional innovation. It critically analyses barriers such as systemic biases, exclusion, and stereotyping and assesses the effectiveness of diversity, equity, and inclusion policies. The study emphasises the role of intersectionality in shaping student and faculty experiences and advocates for professional development to enhance cultural competence. Additionally, it examines the potential of data analytics and AI in reducing bias and improving representation. By shifting the discourse from compliance to transformative institutional commitment, this research offers insights for academics, policymakers, and university leaders seeking evidence-based diversity strategies that foster equity, belonging, and academic excellence.


  • Open Access

    Does school inspection lead to school improvement? A case study

    by Mary O’DOherty, Gerry McNamara, Sarah Gardezi, Martin Brown

    This study examines the role of school inspections in driving improvement within an initially a low-performing secondary school in Ireland over a 15-year period. Through a longitudinal case study, the research investigates the impact of three inspection cycles on school development. The study draws on a thematic review of literature to contextualise the evolving functions, roles, and frameworks of the Irish Inspectorate from 1996 to the present, a period marked by significant changes in inspection practices. Nineteen semi-structured interviews with stakeholders provide qualitative insights, which are analysed alongside the literature to understand the dynamics at play in the school's improvement journey. Findings suggest that despite Ireland's low-stakes inspection system, strong trust in the expertise of inspectors, the respected position of the inspectorate, and alignment between the inspection findings and the school's internal self-evaluation were instrumental in fostering acceptance of the initial critical report. This acceptance by school leadership, extended gradually to the entire school and underscores inspection as a potent catalyst for sustainable school improvement. The study concludes that, under specific conditions, school inspection can indeed serve as a highly effective mechanism for long-term educational improvement.


  • Preparing teachers for diversity: how are teacher education systems responding to cultural diversity – the case of Austria and Ireland

    by Barbara Herzog-Punzenberger, Martin Brown, Herbert Altrichter, Sarah Gardezi

    The paper begins with an overview of migration-related diversity in Austria and Ireland, both countries with high levels of cultural, linguistic and religious diversity in schools. Research in Europe indicates that migration produces a new context for teaching, for which many teachers do not feel sufficiently prepared. Hence, teacher education is at stake and rarely looked at systematically in migration-related research in education. Therefore, in this article secondary teacher education courses are analysed to ascertain how higher education institutions in these two countries are preparing secondary teachers for culturally responsive teaching. After describing the methodology used to examine the Initial Teacher Education curricula of the two countries an analysis of the research findings is provided. It turns out that relevant courses in the compulsory sections of the curricula are largely missing in both countries. Finally, based on an analysis of the literature and research findings, a discussion of the consequences for teacher education together with recommendations for improvement are formulated. It provides countries with a foundational discourse to equip student teachers with the necessary skills to embed cultural responsivity into their classrooms upon completion of their apprenticeship for teaching.

  • Open Access

    Exploring the multifaceted nature of school inspectors' power dynamics: A comparative analysis of four quality assurance systems

    by Sarah Gardezi, Gerry McNamara, Martin Brown, Joe O'HAra

    This research critically explores the role of school inspectors in driving improvements across diverse educational settings, focusing on the nuanced dynamics of their influence on school leaders' attitudes towards feedback. The study employs French and Raven's ‘The Bases of Social Powers’ framework to investigate the various forms of power wielded by school inspectors. The examination encompasses inspection regimes with varied approaches, ranging from high‐stakes to low‐stakes, each conferring different degrees of authority on school inspectors. Conducted in four jurisdictions—Dubai, Ireland, New Zealand and Pakistan—each characterised by distinct school quality assurance systems, the research aims to provide readers, including academicians, policy makers, quality assurance personnel and school leaders, with examples of current practices and models. Through interviews with school leaders and inspectors, the findings reveal that leaders' perceptions of inspectors' powers influence both their attitudes towards inspectors and their responses to feedback. The six bases of power—reward, coercive, legitimate, referent, expert and informational—as postulated in French and Raven's framework—are identified in the school leaders' responses and highlighted in the structural dynamics of the inspection systems under study, though at varying degrees. Notably, all forms of power hold value in influencing school leaders and driving changes in their practices. While the first three focus on regulating and evaluating school operations, the latter three foster change by inspiring and guiding school leaders. The findings underscore the need for a balanced integration of these power bases in school inspection systems, tailored to the unique contexts of every country. By shedding light on the interplay between power dynamics and school leaders' responsiveness to feedback, this research contributes valuable insights to inform the development and refinement of school inspection systems. The ultimate goal is to maximise the impact of inspections and enhance the efficacy of quality assurance systems in promoting positive change and improvement within diverse educational environments.