Grigory E. Volovik
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Grigory E. Volovik has a total of 52 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Frans R. Klinkhamer
Karlsruhe Institute of Technology (KIT)
3 shared publications Volovik G. E
3 shared publications- Jaakko Nissinen
Low Temperature Laboratory, Department of Applied Physics, Aalto University, FI-00076 Aalto, Finland
2 shared publications - Kuang Zhang
Low Temperature Laboratory Aalto University P.O. Box 15100 FI-00076 Aalto Finland
2 shared publications - Yuri N. Obukhov
Nuclear Safety Institute (IBRAE), Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow, Russia
2 shared publications A. G. Kvashnin
Skolkovo Institute of Science and Technology, Moscow, Russia
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 2 July 2026
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 447-458
Proton Decay in de Sitter Environment
- Open Access
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 123 (8) , 509-513
Thermodynamics of Kerr Black Hole: Tsallis–Cirto Composition Law and Entropy Quantization
The processes of splitting and merging of black holes obey the composition law generated by the Tsallis–Cirto $$\delta = 2$$ statistics. The same composition law expresses the full entropy of the Reissner–Nordström black hole via the entropies of its outer and inner horizons. Here we apply this composition law to the thermodynamics of the Kerr black hole. As distinct from Reissner–Nordström black hole, where the full entropy depends only on mass M and does not depend on its charge Q , the entropy of Kerr black hole is the sum of contributions from its mass M and angular momentum J , i.e., $$S(M,J) = S(M,0) + 4\pi \sqrt {J(J + 1)} $$ . Here $$S(M,0)$$ is the entropy of the Schwarzschild black hole. This demonstrates that when the Kerr black hole with $$J \gg 1$$ absorbs or emits a massless particle with spin $${{s}_{z}} = \pm 1{\text{/}}2$$ , its entropy changes by $${\text{|}}\Delta S{\text{|}} = 2\pi $$ . We also considered the quantization of entropy suggested by the toy model, in which the black hole thermodynamics is represented by the ensemble of the Planck-scale black holes—Planckons. The Tsallis–Cirto composition law is also extended to the thermodynamics of Kerr–Newman black hole and Schwarzschild–de Sitter black hole.- 14 April 2026
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 123 (8) , 509-513
Open AccessThermodynamics of Kerr Black Hole: Tsallis–Cirto Composition Law and Entropy Quantization
The processes of splitting and merging of black holes obey the composition law generated by the Tsallis–Cirto $$\delta = 2$$ statistics. The same composition law expresses the full entropy of the Reissner–Nordström black hole via the entropies of its outer and inner horizons. Here we apply this composition law to the thermodynamics of the Kerr black hole. As distinct from Reissner–Nordström black hole, where the full entropy depends only on mass M and does not depend on its charge Q , the entropy of Kerr black hole is the sum of contributions from its mass M and angular momentum J , i.e., $$S(M,J) = S(M,0) + 4\pi \sqrt {J(J + 1)} $$ . Here $$S(M,0)$$ is the entropy of the Schwarzschild black hole. This demonstrates that when the Kerr black hole with $$J \gg 1$$ absorbs or emits a massless particle with spin $${{s}_{z}} = \pm 1{\text{/}}2$$ , its entropy changes by $${\text{|}}\Delta S{\text{|}} = 2\pi $$ . We also considered the quantization of entropy suggested by the toy model, in which the black hole thermodynamics is represented by the ensemble of the Planck-scale black holes—Planckons. The Tsallis–Cirto composition law is also extended to the thermodynamics of Kerr–Newman black hole and Schwarzschild–de Sitter black hole. - 1 September 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics
- Vol. 141 (1-3) , 32-40
Thermodynamics of Black and White Holes in Ensemble of Planckons
The Tsallis-Cirto non-extensive statistics with \(\delta = 2\) describes the processes of splitting and merging of black holes and their thermodynamics [1, 2]. Here we consider a toy model, which matches this generalized statistics and extends it by providing the integer valued entropy of the black hole, SBH(N) = \(N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\). In this model the black hole consists of \(N\) the so-called Planckons—objects with reduced Planck mass \({{m}_{{\text{P}}}} = 1{\text{/}}\sqrt {8\pi G} \) – so that its mass is quantized, \(M = N{{m}_{{\text{P}}}}\). The entropy of each Planckon is zero, but the entropy of black hole with \(N\) Planckons is provided by the \(N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\) degrees of freedom—the correlations between the gravitationally attracted Planckons. This toy model can be extended to a charged Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole, which consists of charged Planckons. Despite the charge, the statistical ensemble of Planckons remains the same, and the RN black hole with \(N\) Planckons has the same entropy as the electrically neutral hole, \({{S}_{{{\text{RNBH}}}}}(N) = N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\). This is supported by the adiabatic process of transformation from the RN to Schwarzschild black hole by varying the fine structure constant. The adiabaticity is violated in the extreme limit, when the gravitational interaction between two Planckons is compensated by the repulsion between their electric charges, and the RN black hole loses stability. The white hole formed by the same \(N\) Planckons has negative entropy, \({{S}_{{{\text{WH}}}}}(N) = - N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\).- 1 September 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Physics
- Vol. 141 (1-3) , 32-40
Thermodynamics of Black and White Holes in Ensemble of Planckons
The Tsallis-Cirto non-extensive statistics with \(\delta = 2\) describes the processes of splitting and merging of black holes and their thermodynamics [1, 2]. Here we consider a toy model, which matches this generalized statistics and extends it by providing the integer valued entropy of the black hole, SBH(N) = \(N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\). In this model the black hole consists of \(N\) the so-called Planckons—objects with reduced Planck mass \({{m}_{{\text{P}}}} = 1{\text{/}}\sqrt {8\pi G} \) – so that its mass is quantized, \(M = N{{m}_{{\text{P}}}}\). The entropy of each Planckon is zero, but the entropy of black hole with \(N\) Planckons is provided by the \(N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\) degrees of freedom—the correlations between the gravitationally attracted Planckons. This toy model can be extended to a charged Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole, which consists of charged Planckons. Despite the charge, the statistical ensemble of Planckons remains the same, and the RN black hole with \(N\) Planckons has the same entropy as the electrically neutral hole, \({{S}_{{{\text{RNBH}}}}}(N) = N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\). This is supported by the adiabatic process of transformation from the RN to Schwarzschild black hole by varying the fine structure constant. The adiabaticity is violated in the extreme limit, when the gravitational interaction between two Planckons is compensated by the repulsion between their electric charges, and the RN black hole loses stability. The white hole formed by the same \(N\) Planckons has negative entropy, \({{S}_{{{\text{WH}}}}}(N) = - N(N - 1){\text{/}}2\).- Open Access
- 25 August 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 122 (5) , 276-281
Extended Tsallis–Cirto Entropy for Black and White Holes
In black hole thermodynamics, entropy is non-extensive. This entropy obeys the composition rule which coincides with the composition rule in the non-extensive Tsallis–Cirto $$\delta = 2$$ statistics. Here we extend this approach to the thermodynamics of white holes. The entropy of the white hole is negative as follows from the rate of macroscopic quantum tunneling from black hole to white hole. The white hole entropy is with the minus sign the entropy of the black hole with the same mass, S WH(M) = –S BH(M). This reflects the anti-symmetry with respect to time reversal, at which the shift vector in the Arnowitt–Deser–Misner formalism changes sign. This symmetry allows one to extend the Tsallis–Cirto entropy by adding a minus sign to the Tsallis–Cirto formula applied to white hole. As a result, the composition rule remains the same, with the only difference being that instead of entropy it contains the entropy modulus. The same non-extensive composition rule is obtained for the entropy of the Reissner–Nordström black hole. This entropy is formed by the positive entropy of the outer horizon and the negative entropy of the inner horizon. The model of the black hole formed by black hole atoms with Planck-scale mass is also extended to include the negative entropy of white holes.- 25 August 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 122 (5) , 276-281
Open AccessExtended Tsallis–Cirto Entropy for Black and White Holes
In black hole thermodynamics, entropy is non-extensive. This entropy obeys the composition rule which coincides with the composition rule in the non-extensive Tsallis–Cirto $$\delta = 2$$ statistics. Here we extend this approach to the thermodynamics of white holes. The entropy of the white hole is negative as follows from the rate of macroscopic quantum tunneling from black hole to white hole. The white hole entropy is with the minus sign the entropy of the black hole with the same mass, S WH(M) = –S BH(M). This reflects the anti-symmetry with respect to time reversal, at which the shift vector in the Arnowitt–Deser–Misner formalism changes sign. This symmetry allows one to extend the Tsallis–Cirto entropy by adding a minus sign to the Tsallis–Cirto formula applied to white hole. As a result, the composition rule remains the same, with the only difference being that instead of entropy it contains the entropy modulus. The same non-extensive composition rule is obtained for the entropy of the Reissner–Nordström black hole. This entropy is formed by the positive entropy of the outer horizon and the negative entropy of the inner horizon. The model of the black hole formed by black hole atoms with Planck-scale mass is also extended to include the negative entropy of white holes. - Open Access
- 13 May 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 121 (10) , 766-770
First Law of de Sitter Thermodynamics
The de Sitter state has a special symmetry: it is homogeneous, and its curvature is constant in space. Since all the points in the de Sitter space are equivalent, this state is described by local thermodynamics. This state has the local temperature $$T = H{\text{/}}\pi $$ (which is twice the Gibbons–Hawking temperature), the local entropy density, the local energy density, and the local gravitational degrees of freedom including the scalar curvature $$\mathcal{R}$$ and the effective gravitational coupling K. On the other hand, there is the cosmological horizon, which can also be characterized by the thermodynamic relations. We consider the connections between the local thermodynamics and the thermodynamics of the cosmological horizon. In particular, there is the holographic connection between the entropy density integrated over the Hubble volume and the Gibbons–Hawking entropy of the horizon, $${{S}_{{{\text{volume}}}}} = {{S}_{{{\text{horizon}}}}} = A{\text{/}}4G$$ . We also consider the first law of thermodynamics in these two approaches. In the local thermodynamics, on the one hand, the first law is valid for an arbitrary volume $$V$$ of de Sitter space. On the other hand, the first law is also applicable to the thermodynamics of the horizon. In both cases, the temperature is the same. This consideration is extended to the contracting de Sitter with its negative entropy, $${{S}_{{{\text{volume}}}}} = {{S}_{{{\text{horizon}}}}} = - A{\text{/}}4G$$ .- 13 May 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 121 (10) , 766-770
Open AccessFirst Law of de Sitter Thermodynamics
The de Sitter state has a special symmetry: it is homogeneous, and its curvature is constant in space. Since all the points in the de Sitter space are equivalent, this state is described by local thermodynamics. This state has the local temperature $$T = H{\text{/}}\pi $$ (which is twice the Gibbons–Hawking temperature), the local entropy density, the local energy density, and the local gravitational degrees of freedom including the scalar curvature $$\mathcal{R}$$ and the effective gravitational coupling K. On the other hand, there is the cosmological horizon, which can also be characterized by the thermodynamic relations. We consider the connections between the local thermodynamics and the thermodynamics of the cosmological horizon. In particular, there is the holographic connection between the entropy density integrated over the Hubble volume and the Gibbons–Hawking entropy of the horizon, $${{S}_{{{\text{volume}}}}} = {{S}_{{{\text{horizon}}}}} = A{\text{/}}4G$$ . We also consider the first law of thermodynamics in these two approaches. In the local thermodynamics, on the one hand, the first law is valid for an arbitrary volume $$V$$ of de Sitter space. On the other hand, the first law is also applicable to the thermodynamics of the horizon. In both cases, the temperature is the same. This consideration is extended to the contracting de Sitter with its negative entropy, $${{S}_{{{\text{volume}}}}} = {{S}_{{{\text{horizon}}}}} = - A{\text{/}}4G$$ . - Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 121 (4) , 243-248
Tsallis–Cirto Entropy of a Black Hole and a Black Hole Atom
The quantum tunneling processes related to the black hole determine the black hole thermodynamics. The Hawking temperature is determined by the quantum tunneling processes of emission of particles from the black hole. On the other hand, the Bekenstein–Hawking entropy of the black hole is obtained by consideration of the macroscopic quantum tunneling processes of splitting of black hole to the smaller black holes. These tunneling processes also determine the composition rule for the black hole entropy, which coincides with the composition rule for the non-extensive Tsallis–Cirto $$\delta = 2$$ entropy. This composition rule suggests that the mass spectrum of the black hole is equidistant, $$M = N{{M}_{0}}$$ . Here, N is an integer number and M 0 = $$\sqrt 2 {{m}_{{\text{P}}}}$$ is the mass quantum expressed via the reduced Planck mass $${{m}_{{\text{P}}}}$$ . The Bekenstein–Hawking entropy of the black hole with mass $$M = N{{M}_{0}}$$ is $${{S}_{{{\text{BH}}}}}(N) = {{N}^{2}}$$ .- 10 February 2025
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 121 (4) , 243-248
Open AccessTsallis–Cirto Entropy of a Black Hole and a Black Hole Atom
The quantum tunneling processes related to the black hole determine the black hole thermodynamics. The Hawking temperature is determined by the quantum tunneling processes of emission of particles from the black hole. On the other hand, the Bekenstein–Hawking entropy of the black hole is obtained by consideration of the macroscopic quantum tunneling processes of splitting of black hole to the smaller black holes. These tunneling processes also determine the composition rule for the black hole entropy, which coincides with the composition rule for the non-extensive Tsallis–Cirto $$\delta = 2$$ entropy. This composition rule suggests that the mass spectrum of the black hole is equidistant, $$M = N{{M}_{0}}$$ . Here, N is an integer number and M 0 = $$\sqrt 2 {{m}_{{\text{P}}}}$$ is the mass quantum expressed via the reduced Planck mass $${{m}_{{\text{P}}}}$$ . The Bekenstein–Hawking entropy of the black hole with mass $$M = N{{M}_{0}}$$ is $${{S}_{{{\text{BH}}}}}(N) = {{N}^{2}}$$ . - 15 November 2024
- Published by The Russian Academy of Sciences in Pisʹma v žurnal êksperimentalʹnoj i teoretičeskoj fiziki
- Vol. 120 (9-10) , 659-660
Schwinger vs Unruh
Schwinger vs Unruh Schwinger vs Unruh
- 15 November 2024
- Published by The Russian Academy of Sciences in Pisʹma v žurnal êksperimentalʹnoj i teoretičeskoj fiziki
- Vol. 120 (9-10) , 659-660
Schwinger vs Unruh
Schwinger vs Unruh Schwinger vs Unruh
- Open Access
- 29 October 2024
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 120 (9) , 631-635
Schwinger versus Unruh (Brief Review)
It is shown that the temperatures which characterise the Unruh effect, the Gibbons–Hawking radiation from the de Sitter cosmological horizon and the Hawking radiation from the black hole horizon acquire the extra factor 2 compared with their traditional values. The reason for that is the coherence of different processes. The combination of the coherent processes also allows us to make the connection between the Schwinger pair production and the Unruh effect.
- 29 October 2024
- Published by Pleiades Publishing Ltd in JETP Letters
- Vol. 120 (9) , 631-635
Open AccessSchwinger versus Unruh (Brief Review)
It is shown that the temperatures which characterise the Unruh effect, the Gibbons–Hawking radiation from the de Sitter cosmological horizon and the Hawking radiation from the black hole horizon acquire the extra factor 2 compared with their traditional values. The reason for that is the coherence of different processes. The combination of the coherent processes also allows us to make the connection between the Schwinger pair production and the Unruh effect.
- Open Access
Discrete Z4 Symmetry in Quantum Gravity
We consider the discrete symmetry , which takes place in the scenario of quantum gravity where the gravitational tetrads emerge as the order parameter—the vacuum expectation value of the bilinear combination of fermionic operators. Under this symmetry operation, , the emerging tetrads are multiplied by the imaginary unit, . The existence of such symmetry and the spontaneous breaking of this symmetry are also supported by the consideration of the symmetry breaking scheme in the topological superfluid 3He-B. The order parameter in 3He-B is also the bilinear combination of the fermionic operators. This order parameter is the analog of the tetrad field, but it has complex values. The -symmetry operation changes the phase of the complex order parameter by , which corresponds to the discrete symmetry in quantum gravity. We also considered the alternative scenario of the breaking of this symmetry, in which the -operation changes sign of the scalar curvature, , and thus the Einstein–Hilbert action violates the -symmetry. In the alternative scenario of symmetry breaking, the gravitational coupling plays the role of the order parameter, which changes sign under -transformation.Open AccessDiscrete Z4 Symmetry in Quantum Gravity
We consider the discrete symmetry , which takes place in the scenario of quantum gravity where the gravitational tetrads emerge as the order parameter—the vacuum expectation value of the bilinear combination of fermionic operators. Under this symmetry operation, , the emerging tetrads are multiplied by the imaginary unit, . The existence of such symmetry and the spontaneous breaking of this symmetry are also supported by the consideration of the symmetry breaking scheme in the topological superfluid 3He-B. The order parameter in 3He-B is also the bilinear combination of the fermionic operators. This order parameter is the analog of the tetrad field, but it has complex values. The -symmetry operation changes the phase of the complex order parameter by , which corresponds to the discrete symmetry in quantum gravity. We also considered the alternative scenario of the breaking of this symmetry, in which the -operation changes sign of the scalar curvature, , and thus the Einstein–Hilbert action violates the -symmetry. In the alternative scenario of symmetry breaking, the gravitational coupling plays the role of the order parameter, which changes sign under -transformation. - Top Cited PapersOpen Access
Thermodynamics and Decay of de Sitter Vacuum
We discuss the consequences of the unique symmetry of de Sitter spacetime. This symmetry leads to the specific thermodynamic properties of the de Sitter vacuum, which produces a thermal bath for matter. de Sitter spacetime is invariant under the modified translations, , where H is the Hubble parameter. For , this symmetry corresponds to the conventional invariance of Minkowski spacetime under translations . Due to this symmetry, all the comoving observers at any point of the de Sitter space perceive the de Sitter environment as the thermal bath with temperature , which is twice as large as the Gibbons–Hawking temperature of the cosmological horizon. This temperature does not violate de Sitter symmetry and, thus, does not require the preferred reference frame, as distinct from the thermal state of matter, which violates de Sitter symmetry. This leads to the heat exchange between gravity and matter and to the instability of the de Sitter state towards the creation of matter, its further heating, and finally the decay of the de Sitter state. The temperature determines different processes in the de Sitter environment that are not possible in the Minkowski vacuum, such as the process of ionization of an atom in the de Sitter environment. This temperature also determines the local entropy of the de Sitter vacuum state, and this allows us to calculate the total entropy of the volume inside the cosmological horizon. The result reproduces the Gibbons–Hawking area law, which is attributed to the cosmological horizon, , where . This supports the holographic properties of the cosmological event horizon. We extend the consideration of the local thermodynamics of the de Sitter state using the gravity. In this thermodynamics, the Ricci scalar curvature and the effective gravitational coupling K are thermodynamically conjugate variables. The holographic connection between the bulk entropy of the Hubble volume and the surface entropy of the cosmological horizon remains the same but with the gravitational coupling . Such a connection takes place only in the spacetime, where there is a special symmetry due to which the variables K and have the same dimensionality. We also consider the lessons from de Sitter symmetry for the thermodynamics of black and white holes.Top Cited PapersOpen AccessThermodynamics and Decay of de Sitter Vacuum
We discuss the consequences of the unique symmetry of de Sitter spacetime. This symmetry leads to the specific thermodynamic properties of the de Sitter vacuum, which produces a thermal bath for matter. de Sitter spacetime is invariant under the modified translations, , where H is the Hubble parameter. For , this symmetry corresponds to the conventional invariance of Minkowski spacetime under translations . Due to this symmetry, all the comoving observers at any point of the de Sitter space perceive the de Sitter environment as the thermal bath with temperature , which is twice as large as the Gibbons–Hawking temperature of the cosmological horizon. This temperature does not violate de Sitter symmetry and, thus, does not require the preferred reference frame, as distinct from the thermal state of matter, which violates de Sitter symmetry. This leads to the heat exchange between gravity and matter and to the instability of the de Sitter state towards the creation of matter, its further heating, and finally the decay of the de Sitter state. The temperature determines different processes in the de Sitter environment that are not possible in the Minkowski vacuum, such as the process of ionization of an atom in the de Sitter environment. This temperature also determines the local entropy of the de Sitter vacuum state, and this allows us to calculate the total entropy of the volume inside the cosmological horizon. The result reproduces the Gibbons–Hawking area law, which is attributed to the cosmological horizon, , where . This supports the holographic properties of the cosmological event horizon. We extend the consideration of the local thermodynamics of the de Sitter state using the gravity. In this thermodynamics, the Ricci scalar curvature and the effective gravitational coupling K are thermodynamically conjugate variables. The holographic connection between the bulk entropy of the Hubble volume and the surface entropy of the cosmological horizon remains the same but with the gravitational coupling . Such a connection takes place only in the spacetime, where there is a special symmetry due to which the variables K and have the same dimensionality. We also consider the lessons from de Sitter symmetry for the thermodynamics of black and white holes.