Robert Thombley
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Robert Thombley has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Benjamin I. Rosner
University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA
4 shared publications - Judith S. Shaw
Department of Pediatrics, University of Vermont College of Medicine, Burlington, Vermont
2 shared publications - Julia Adler-Milstein
Division of Clinical Informatics and Digital Transformation, Department of Medicine, University of California, San Francisco , San Francisco, CA 94131
2 shared publications - Naomi S. Bardach
Pediatrics, University of California San Francisco, San Francisco, California, USA
2 shared publications - Stephanie E. Rogers
University of California San Francisco San Francisco California USA
2 shared publications - Aaron Alexander Tierney
Division of Research Kaiser Permanente Northern California Pleasanton California USA
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 22 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the American Geriatrics Society
Patient Outcomes Associated With a Composite Measure of 4Ms Care Adherence in the Inpatient Setting
Background: The 4Ms (what matters, medication, mentation, and mobility) is a widely adopted age‐friendly care framework. However, there is no evidence on inpatient 4Ms adherence thresholds associated with improved outcomes. Methods: In a retrospective cross‐sectional analysis, we measured encounter‐level adherence to the 4Ms for inpatients 65+ at the University of California San Francisco between January 1, 2021 and December 31, 2024. Outcomes included 30‐day unplanned readmissions, 30‐day emergency department (ED) visits, length of stay (LOS), and community admissions discharged to a facility. Using fixed effects regression models, we estimated the effect on outcomes of adherence to 100% of 4Ms assessments (what matters, medication, mentation, and mobility screening) plus 25%, 50%, and 75% of shifts with full adherence to 4Ms Act Ons (actions, such as de‐prescribing high‐risk medications, ambulating). We conducted subgroup analyses by age and medical versus surgical admissions. Results: Our study sample included 34,923 inpatient encounters for 22,949 unique patients aged 65+ (mean age 75.3; 49.0% female). We observed lower 30‐day readmissions at Act On adherence of 50% (4.1% reduction; 95% CI: 1.8–6.4) and 25% (1.9%; 0.3–3.6). We also found lower 30 day ED visits at 50% Act On adherence in the overall group (3.3%; 0.9–5.8), and in those 85+ (5.0%; 0.4–9.7). Act On adherence and LOS demonstrated a dose–response‐like relationship, with 1.0 (0.8–1.1), 1.5 (1.3–1.7), and 1.9 (1.6–2.2) day reductions associated with 25%, 50%, and 75% Act On adherence respectively. No associations were observed between Act On adherence and discharge to facility. Conclusions: Higher inpatient adherence to 4Ms care is associated with meaningful reductions in post‐acute care utilization and LOS. Our analyses offer clinical leaders guidance on deploying limited resources to positively influence outcomes. They suggest that fully adherent assessments and 25%–50% of shifts with fully adherent Act Ons represent target thresholds.
- 22 August 2026
- Published by Wiley in Journal of the American Geriatrics Society
Open AccessPatient Outcomes Associated With a Composite Measure of 4Ms Care Adherence in the Inpatient Setting
Background: The 4Ms (what matters, medication, mentation, and mobility) is a widely adopted age‐friendly care framework. However, there is no evidence on inpatient 4Ms adherence thresholds associated with improved outcomes. Methods: In a retrospective cross‐sectional analysis, we measured encounter‐level adherence to the 4Ms for inpatients 65+ at the University of California San Francisco between January 1, 2021 and December 31, 2024. Outcomes included 30‐day unplanned readmissions, 30‐day emergency department (ED) visits, length of stay (LOS), and community admissions discharged to a facility. Using fixed effects regression models, we estimated the effect on outcomes of adherence to 100% of 4Ms assessments (what matters, medication, mentation, and mobility screening) plus 25%, 50%, and 75% of shifts with full adherence to 4Ms Act Ons (actions, such as de‐prescribing high‐risk medications, ambulating). We conducted subgroup analyses by age and medical versus surgical admissions. Results: Our study sample included 34,923 inpatient encounters for 22,949 unique patients aged 65+ (mean age 75.3; 49.0% female). We observed lower 30‐day readmissions at Act On adherence of 50% (4.1% reduction; 95% CI: 1.8–6.4) and 25% (1.9%; 0.3–3.6). We also found lower 30 day ED visits at 50% Act On adherence in the overall group (3.3%; 0.9–5.8), and in those 85+ (5.0%; 0.4–9.7). Act On adherence and LOS demonstrated a dose–response‐like relationship, with 1.0 (0.8–1.1), 1.5 (1.3–1.7), and 1.9 (1.6–2.2) day reductions associated with 25%, 50%, and 75% Act On adherence respectively. No associations were observed between Act On adherence and discharge to facility. Conclusions: Higher inpatient adherence to 4Ms care is associated with meaningful reductions in post‐acute care utilization and LOS. Our analyses offer clinical leaders guidance on deploying limited resources to positively influence outcomes. They suggest that fully adherent assessments and 25%–50% of shifts with fully adherent Act Ons represent target thresholds.
- Open Access
- 17 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Health Affairs Scholar
- Vol. 3 (10) , qxaf184
From 4Ms to 5 domains: ensuring new CMS Age-Friendly hospital measure improves care for older adults
In 2024, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) added a novel Age-Friendly Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (IQR) Measure, composed of 10 attestation statements in 5 domains. The measure is designed to improve care for older adults through promoting care processes and structural capabilities drawn from evidence-based standards included in the 4Ms Framework (What Matters, Medication, Mentation, and Mobility) and operationalized in 3 programs: Geriatric Surgery Verification, Geriatric Emergency Department Accreditation, and the Institute for Healthcare Improvement's Age-Friendly Health System recognition. We highlight synergies and gaps between these programs and the CMS Age-Friendly IQR measure to guide hospital efforts as they prepare for their first attestation in 2026. In addition, we make recommendations to CMS to improve measure validity through better specifications that ensure meaningful impact on care for older adults and to reduce associated reporting burden. Notably, there is little overlap in the outcome measures incorporated into each program. Attending to these considerations is critical to maximize the potential of this new national quality measure to address persistent shortcomings in evidence-based care for older adults.
- 17 September 2025
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Health Affairs Scholar
- Vol. 3 (10) , qxaf184
Open AccessFrom 4Ms to 5 domains: ensuring new CMS Age-Friendly hospital measure improves care for older adults
In 2024, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) added a novel Age-Friendly Hospital Inpatient Quality Reporting (IQR) Measure, composed of 10 attestation statements in 5 domains. The measure is designed to improve care for older adults through promoting care processes and structural capabilities drawn from evidence-based standards included in the 4Ms Framework (What Matters, Medication, Mentation, and Mobility) and operationalized in 3 programs: Geriatric Surgery Verification, Geriatric Emergency Department Accreditation, and the Institute for Healthcare Improvement's Age-Friendly Health System recognition. We highlight synergies and gaps between these programs and the CMS Age-Friendly IQR measure to guide hospital efforts as they prepare for their first attestation in 2026. In addition, we make recommendations to CMS to improve measure validity through better specifications that ensure meaningful impact on care for older adults and to reduce associated reporting burden. Notably, there is little overlap in the outcome measures incorporated into each program. Attending to these considerations is critical to maximize the potential of this new national quality measure to address persistent shortcomings in evidence-based care for older adults.
- Open Access
- 13 June 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
The Trainee Digital Growth Chart: Development of Electronic Health Record Audit Log Based Information Gathering Benchmarks and an Observation Cohort Study on Pediatric Hospital Medicine Resident Information Gathering Activities (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Information gathering is the foundational skill of clinical reasoning. However, residents and attending physicians have no objective insights into the competencies of residents in developing skills in information gathering in the electronic health record (EHR). The EHR audit logs, time stamped records of user activities, can provide a wealth of information about how residents gather information about patients at the time of admissions and throughout daily rounding. OBJECTIVE In this study, our goals were to: 1. Understand and delineate attending physician expectations of residents’ EHR-based information gathering activities at different stages of residency, 2. Develop a system, referred to as the Trainee Digital Growth Chart (a.k.a Growth Chart), using the EHR audit logs to audit and feed back information gathering performance to residents and their attending physicians, and 3. Pilot the Growth Chart among pediatric residents on pediatric hospital medicine (PHM) rotations to understand whether audit and feedback data on EHR-based information gathering is helpful in supporting resident learning and assessment. METHODS We convened a focus group of PHM attending physicians to establish information gathering benchmarks for residents at each stage of their training. Residents and attendings were involved in the co-design of an information gathering performance electronic dashboard called the Trainee Digital Growth Chart. This dashboard was piloted in an observational cohort study among PHM residents and attending physicians during the 2023-24 academic year. RESULTS Considerable variability was observed as focus group attendings established training-stage specific benchmarks. During the pilot, resident and attending logged into the Growth Chart to observe performance at moderate to high rates. However, despite their involvement in its co-design, most participants did not find great value in the Growth Chart. However, as an intervention, viewing prior Growth Chart information gathering performance had a positive impact on future information gathering performance among first year residents on daily rounds when that performance was also discussed with an attending physician. CONCLUSIONS Information gathering is at the foundation of clinical reasoning. However, no competency-based benchmarks for information gathering in the EHR exist. Opportunities to leverage the EHR audit logs exist to feed back performance information to trainees, thereby influencing future information gathering behaviors. This is particularly powerful when done early in training before habits become formed, and when done in conjunction with verbal review with an attending physician. Such tools must find their way into routine clinical workflows and be capable of providing real time or near real time feedback before perceived educational value will be realized. Nevertheless, these approaches have broad potential to scale across specialties and allied health disciplines.
- 13 June 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessThe Trainee Digital Growth Chart: Development of Electronic Health Record Audit Log Based Information Gathering Benchmarks and an Observation Cohort Study on Pediatric Hospital Medicine Resident Information Gathering Activities (Preprint)
BACKGROUND Information gathering is the foundational skill of clinical reasoning. However, residents and attending physicians have no objective insights into the competencies of residents in developing skills in information gathering in the electronic health record (EHR). The EHR audit logs, time stamped records of user activities, can provide a wealth of information about how residents gather information about patients at the time of admissions and throughout daily rounding. OBJECTIVE In this study, our goals were to: 1. Understand and delineate attending physician expectations of residents’ EHR-based information gathering activities at different stages of residency, 2. Develop a system, referred to as the Trainee Digital Growth Chart (a.k.a Growth Chart), using the EHR audit logs to audit and feed back information gathering performance to residents and their attending physicians, and 3. Pilot the Growth Chart among pediatric residents on pediatric hospital medicine (PHM) rotations to understand whether audit and feedback data on EHR-based information gathering is helpful in supporting resident learning and assessment. METHODS We convened a focus group of PHM attending physicians to establish information gathering benchmarks for residents at each stage of their training. Residents and attendings were involved in the co-design of an information gathering performance electronic dashboard called the Trainee Digital Growth Chart. This dashboard was piloted in an observational cohort study among PHM residents and attending physicians during the 2023-24 academic year. RESULTS Considerable variability was observed as focus group attendings established training-stage specific benchmarks. During the pilot, resident and attending logged into the Growth Chart to observe performance at moderate to high rates. However, despite their involvement in its co-design, most participants did not find great value in the Growth Chart. However, as an intervention, viewing prior Growth Chart information gathering performance had a positive impact on future information gathering performance among first year residents on daily rounds when that performance was also discussed with an attending physician. CONCLUSIONS Information gathering is at the foundation of clinical reasoning. However, no competency-based benchmarks for information gathering in the EHR exist. Opportunities to leverage the EHR audit logs exist to feed back performance information to trainees, thereby influencing future information gathering behaviors. This is particularly powerful when done early in training before habits become formed, and when done in conjunction with verbal review with an attending physician. Such tools must find their way into routine clinical workflows and be capable of providing real time or near real time feedback before perceived educational value will be realized. Nevertheless, these approaches have broad potential to scale across specialties and allied health disciplines.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in INQUIRY: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing
- Vol. 62
4 Steps to 4Ms: A Navigation Guide for a Hospital-Based Composite Measure of 4Ms Care and the Implications for Outcomes Assessment
The 4Ms Framework is the foundation of the Age-Friendly Health System (AFHS) movement. While the framework is based on standalone evidence for each M, there is limited evidence about the impact on outcomes when practiced as a set. A composite measure capturing adherence to the many care processes that comprise the 4Ms is a necessary but complex component of closing the evidence gap. We offer a navigation guide that addresses key considerations for developing a hospital-based composite measure of 4Ms care. The Institute for Healthcare Improvement operationalizes the 4Ms Framework as a minimum set of Assessment and Act On care processes. In developing a composite measure of inpatient 4Ms adherence, we offer a 4 step framework with associated discussion of considerations related to composite measure type (eg, continuous, dichotomous), and synchrony within and across the Ms containing these care processes. Using real-world electronic health record data capturing care process adherence in the 4Ms implementation at a large academic hospital, we illustrate the considerations, and report the implications for sample size and composite measure scoring. We also present our selected composite measure—a dichotomous measure delineating 4Ms care when all encounter-level processes (those needing to be done only once during the hospital encounter) are followed and all day- and shift-level processes are followed for at least 50% of hospital days. While there is no single, standard approach to create a 4Ms composite at this early stage of the AFHS movement, as organizations develop their measure(s), our guide and the considerations we suggest should serve to inform this process and support progress toward meaningful measurement.
- 1 January 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in INQUIRY: The Journal of Health Care Organization, Provision, and Financing
- Vol. 62
Open Access4 Steps to 4Ms: A Navigation Guide for a Hospital-Based Composite Measure of 4Ms Care and the Implications for Outcomes Assessment
The 4Ms Framework is the foundation of the Age-Friendly Health System (AFHS) movement. While the framework is based on standalone evidence for each M, there is limited evidence about the impact on outcomes when practiced as a set. A composite measure capturing adherence to the many care processes that comprise the 4Ms is a necessary but complex component of closing the evidence gap. We offer a navigation guide that addresses key considerations for developing a hospital-based composite measure of 4Ms care. The Institute for Healthcare Improvement operationalizes the 4Ms Framework as a minimum set of Assessment and Act On care processes. In developing a composite measure of inpatient 4Ms adherence, we offer a 4 step framework with associated discussion of considerations related to composite measure type (eg, continuous, dichotomous), and synchrony within and across the Ms containing these care processes. Using real-world electronic health record data capturing care process adherence in the 4Ms implementation at a large academic hospital, we illustrate the considerations, and report the implications for sample size and composite measure scoring. We also present our selected composite measure—a dichotomous measure delineating 4Ms care when all encounter-level processes (those needing to be done only once during the hospital encounter) are followed and all day- and shift-level processes are followed for at least 50% of hospital days. While there is no single, standard approach to create a 4Ms composite at this early stage of the AFHS movement, as organizations develop their measure(s), our guide and the considerations we suggest should serve to inform this process and support progress toward meaningful measurement.
- Open Access
- 1 May 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Academic Pediatrics
- Vol. 22 (4) , 640-646
Weekend Versus Weekday Asthma-Related Emergency Department Utilization
- 1 May 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Academic Pediatrics
- Vol. 22 (4) , 640-646
Open AccessWeekend Versus Weekday Asthma-Related Emergency Department Utilization
- 23 March 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Academic Pediatrics
- Vol. 22 (3) , S125-S132
Follow-Up After Asthma Emergency Department Visits and Its Relationship With Subsequent Asthma-Related Utilization
- 23 March 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Academic Pediatrics
- Vol. 22 (3) , S125-S132
Follow-Up After Asthma Emergency Department Visits and Its Relationship With Subsequent Asthma-Related Utilization