Bernadette Somody
Research Subjects
Bernadette Somody has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- István Hoffman
Eötvös Loránd University
3 shared publications - Fruzsina Gárdos-Orosz
HUN-REN CSS Institute for Legal Studies, Budapest, Hungary
2 shared publications - Zoltán Pozsár-Szentmiklósy
Faculty of Law, ELTE Eötvös Loránd University, Budapest, Hungary
2 shared publications - Balázs Tőkey
ELTE Eötvös Loránd University (Budapest)
1 shared publication - Jarosław Kostrubiec
Maria Curie-Skłodowska University (Lublin)
1 shared publication - Katarzyna Hanas
Maria Curie-Skłodowska University in Lublin
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 30 June 2026
- Published by Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawla II in Review of European and Comparative Law
- Vol. 65 (2) , 35-50
Animal Protection: From Property Rights Towards Legal Capacity?
This article examines the evolution of animal protection law from its traditional foundations - anchored in the property-based conception of animals as objects - towards more complex contemporary regulatory models. Through a comparative analysis of European legal systems and the overarching EU and ECHR frameworks, the study explores how administrative, environmental, and criminal law interact in shaping the legal status of animals. Special attention is given to the Hungarian system, highlighting persistent anthropocentric structures and emerging doctrinal tensions. The paper situates these developments within broader debates on vulnerability, equal protection, and the potential constitutional recognition of animals' fundamental rights.
- 30 June 2026
- Published by Katolicki Uniwersytet Lubelski Jana Pawla II in Review of European and Comparative Law
- Vol. 65 (2) , 35-50
Open AccessAnimal Protection: From Property Rights Towards Legal Capacity?
This article examines the evolution of animal protection law from its traditional foundations - anchored in the property-based conception of animals as objects - towards more complex contemporary regulatory models. Through a comparative analysis of European legal systems and the overarching EU and ECHR frameworks, the study explores how administrative, environmental, and criminal law interact in shaping the legal status of animals. Special attention is given to the Hungarian system, highlighting persistent anthropocentric structures and emerging doctrinal tensions. The paper situates these developments within broader debates on vulnerability, equal protection, and the potential constitutional recognition of animals' fundamental rights.
- Open Access
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 35 (1) , 119-135
Challenges and Solutions – New Ways of Children’s Participation in Municipal Decisions in the Light of the Case of the Municipality of Lublin and the Municipality of Budapest
The involvement of children in decision-making poses a challenge for public bodies. Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child protects the right to express their views. However, in administrative decision-making, it is a challenge to enforce this principle, and the involvement of young people, especially children, in local decision-making is a crucial element of education for civic participation. The literature clearly demonstrates that children can express their views quite effectively on local affairs which impact them directly. It can be more significant in new democracies, where education for active participation in public life is even more important than in countries with long-established democratic traditions and institutions. This paper focuses on the analysis of the framework, challenges, and potential solutions for involving children and young people in municipal decision-making processes in Poland and Hungary. It should be noted that both countries belong to the relatively young democracies and have been building their democratic local government systems since the 1990s. The paper analyses the first regulations and solutions on the involvement of young people in local democracy, which were mainly institutionally centred and based on the representation of the children. We seek to demonstrate both the advantages and limitations of these representation-based solutions. Based on the limitations of these tools, new and more deliberative forms have evolved in Poland and Hungary. These developments have been linked to the digitalisation of decision-making processes and the digital environment that surrounds young people. These models, however, have challenges, and even these e-solutions have strong limitations. Another important issue is the analysis of opportunities for the participation of particularly vulnerable groups of children in these initiatives, especially children with disabilities and migrant children. The article also explores the challenges and opportunities associated with their inclusion. An important part of the initiatives discussed is the development of effective solutions. Therefore, the authors focus on the challenges of piloting such tools and institutions. Based on the development of the former solutions, the article formulates policy recommendations aimed at strengthening children’s participation at the local level in new democracies. These recommendations are based on the experiences of the European Youth Capital 2023 project in Lublin and on policies promoting the involvement of children in municipal decision-making in Budapest. In addition, one of the bases of the presentation is a current CLAP (“Children’s Involvement in Local Affairs for Active Participation”) project, which aims to enhance children’s participation based on a piloted in cooperation with local authorities.
- 24 June 2026
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 35 (1) , 119-135
Open AccessChallenges and Solutions – New Ways of Children’s Participation in Municipal Decisions in the Light of the Case of the Municipality of Lublin and the Municipality of Budapest
The involvement of children in decision-making poses a challenge for public bodies. Article 12 of the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child protects the right to express their views. However, in administrative decision-making, it is a challenge to enforce this principle, and the involvement of young people, especially children, in local decision-making is a crucial element of education for civic participation. The literature clearly demonstrates that children can express their views quite effectively on local affairs which impact them directly. It can be more significant in new democracies, where education for active participation in public life is even more important than in countries with long-established democratic traditions and institutions. This paper focuses on the analysis of the framework, challenges, and potential solutions for involving children and young people in municipal decision-making processes in Poland and Hungary. It should be noted that both countries belong to the relatively young democracies and have been building their democratic local government systems since the 1990s. The paper analyses the first regulations and solutions on the involvement of young people in local democracy, which were mainly institutionally centred and based on the representation of the children. We seek to demonstrate both the advantages and limitations of these representation-based solutions. Based on the limitations of these tools, new and more deliberative forms have evolved in Poland and Hungary. These developments have been linked to the digitalisation of decision-making processes and the digital environment that surrounds young people. These models, however, have challenges, and even these e-solutions have strong limitations. Another important issue is the analysis of opportunities for the participation of particularly vulnerable groups of children in these initiatives, especially children with disabilities and migrant children. The article also explores the challenges and opportunities associated with their inclusion. An important part of the initiatives discussed is the development of effective solutions. Therefore, the authors focus on the challenges of piloting such tools and institutions. Based on the development of the former solutions, the article formulates policy recommendations aimed at strengthening children’s participation at the local level in new democracies. These recommendations are based on the experiences of the European Youth Capital 2023 project in Lublin and on policies promoting the involvement of children in municipal decision-making in Budapest. In addition, one of the bases of the presentation is a current CLAP (“Children’s Involvement in Local Affairs for Active Participation”) project, which aims to enhance children’s participation based on a piloted in cooperation with local authorities.
- 21 April 2026
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
- p. 137-150
Vannak-e alapjogai az új igénybejelentőknek? A jövő nemzedékek és a természet alapjogi státusza
- 21 April 2026
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
- p. 137-150
Vannak-e alapjogai az új igénybejelentőknek? A jövő nemzedékek és a természet alapjogi státusza
- 21 April 2026
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
- p. 7-29
Az alapjogi jogalanyiság fogalmi rendszere
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
Fogalmi keret az alapjogvédelmi rendszerek alkotmányjogi értékeléséhez
Milyen állapotba került az alapjogvédelem Magyarországon az Alaptörvény hatálybalépése után? Hogyan alakult át az alapjogok érvényesülésének jogi és intézményi feltételrendszere az elmúlt másfél évtizedben? Ezek a változások rosszabb vagy csak másfajta működést eredményeztek? A kötet abból indul ki, hogy ezekre a kérdésekre adható olyan alkotmányjogi válasz, amely tehermentesíthető a legtöbb politikai értékvitától, mégis érdemben képes értékelni a jogvédelmi rendszer állapotát. A könyv az ehhez szükséges fogalmi keret kidolgozására vállalkozik, és az Alaptörvény hatálybalépését követő időszak több meghatározó közjogi fejleményét vizsgálja meg ebben az összefüggésben: az Alaptörvénybe foglalt konkrét jogkorlátozó rendelkezéseket, a különleges jogrendi alapjog-korlátozás gyakorlatát, az alkotmányjogi panasz szerepének átalakulását, valamint az ombudsmani és más jogvédelmi feladatok szervezeti koncentrációját. Az elemzés ezzel alkotmányjogi szempontrendszert kínál az Alaptörvény időszakában kialakult alapjogvédelmi rendszer értékeléséhez, és kiindulópontot adhat annak előrevetített alkotmányos átalakításához is.
- 1 January 2026
- Published by Eötvös Loránd University
Fogalmi keret az alapjogvédelmi rendszerek alkotmányjogi értékeléséhez
Milyen állapotba került az alapjogvédelem Magyarországon az Alaptörvény hatálybalépése után? Hogyan alakult át az alapjogok érvényesülésének jogi és intézményi feltételrendszere az elmúlt másfél évtizedben? Ezek a változások rosszabb vagy csak másfajta működést eredményeztek? A kötet abból indul ki, hogy ezekre a kérdésekre adható olyan alkotmányjogi válasz, amely tehermentesíthető a legtöbb politikai értékvitától, mégis érdemben képes értékelni a jogvédelmi rendszer állapotát. A könyv az ehhez szükséges fogalmi keret kidolgozására vállalkozik, és az Alaptörvény hatálybalépését követő időszak több meghatározó közjogi fejleményét vizsgálja meg ebben az összefüggésben: az Alaptörvénybe foglalt konkrét jogkorlátozó rendelkezéseket, a különleges jogrendi alapjog-korlátozás gyakorlatát, az alkotmányjogi panasz szerepének átalakulását, valamint az ombudsmani és más jogvédelmi feladatok szervezeti koncentrációját. Az elemzés ezzel alkotmányjogi szempontrendszert kínál az Alaptörvény időszakában kialakult alapjogvédelmi rendszer értékeléséhez, és kiindulópontot adhat annak előrevetített alkotmányos átalakításához is.
- Open Access
- 28 March 2024
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 33 (1) , 263-278
The Concept of Legal Capacity in Private Law and Constitutional Law
The Concept of Legal Capacity in Private Law and Constitutional Law
- 28 March 2024
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 33 (1) , 263-278
Open AccessThe Concept of Legal Capacity in Private Law and Constitutional Law
The Concept of Legal Capacity in Private Law and Constitutional Law
- Open Access
- 31 December 2023
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 32 (5) , 385-405
Conceptualizing the Legal Capacity to Fundamental Rights
While the capacity to have rights has been a question since people started creating states and law, having the capacity to exercise fundamental rights is a contemporary legal issue. The article focuses on the legal capacity to fundamental rights and presents an innovative proposal for the legal doctrine related to the concept of the normative constitution of fundamental rights. The authors argue that protecting fundamental rights is incomplete if uncertainties exist regarding these rights’ subjects. Due to the complexity of the problem and the relevance of the “judge-made law”, the article offers a new methodological tool: instead of building a pre-set, abstractly defined comprehensive concept, concept mapping is advocated for conceptualizing the legal capacity to fundamental rights. The concept map is an organic and beneficial way to collect and structure the interrelated factors determining legal capacity. It can be a decision-support tool for judges in fundamental right-related cases to bring well-grounded decisions. As a starting point, the authors argue that an autonomous dogmatic category of legal capacity to fundamental rights is crucial for effectively protecting rights. To support this point, the complex theoretical background (the concept of person, personality, rights and fundamental rights) is reviewed. The authors point out that existing approaches do not give an unambiguous answer to what entity and how far can be the holder of what fundamental right. The article concludes with a methodological proposal of conceptualizing by mapping to maximize the effect of knowledge on factors that influence judicial decisions in this regard.
- 31 December 2023
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 32 (5) , 385-405
Open AccessConceptualizing the Legal Capacity to Fundamental Rights
While the capacity to have rights has been a question since people started creating states and law, having the capacity to exercise fundamental rights is a contemporary legal issue. The article focuses on the legal capacity to fundamental rights and presents an innovative proposal for the legal doctrine related to the concept of the normative constitution of fundamental rights. The authors argue that protecting fundamental rights is incomplete if uncertainties exist regarding these rights’ subjects. Due to the complexity of the problem and the relevance of the “judge-made law”, the article offers a new methodological tool: instead of building a pre-set, abstractly defined comprehensive concept, concept mapping is advocated for conceptualizing the legal capacity to fundamental rights. The concept map is an organic and beneficial way to collect and structure the interrelated factors determining legal capacity. It can be a decision-support tool for judges in fundamental right-related cases to bring well-grounded decisions. As a starting point, the authors argue that an autonomous dogmatic category of legal capacity to fundamental rights is crucial for effectively protecting rights. To support this point, the complex theoretical background (the concept of person, personality, rights and fundamental rights) is reviewed. The authors point out that existing approaches do not give an unambiguous answer to what entity and how far can be the holder of what fundamental right. The article concludes with a methodological proposal of conceptualizing by mapping to maximize the effect of knowledge on factors that influence judicial decisions in this regard.
- Open Access
- 16 September 2021
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 30 (3) , 109-118
Animal Protection in Hungary: A Multilayer System Based on an Administrative Approach
Animal protection has a long tradition in the Hungarian legal system. It can be interpreted as a multi-layer model, but the major approach of animal protection has an administrative nature. Originally, animal protection was interpreted as protecting farm animals as resources. Even though new layers have been evolved, the agricultural-administrative approach remained. The second layer is based on the protection of health and healthy nature. Animals are even protected as part of the natural environment and ecosystem and their protection is part of securing the biodiversity in Hungary. Although animal cruelty is a criminal offense in Hungary, the penal law approach is consistent with administrative law as it is based on the institutional protection of the fundamental right to health and a healthy environment. The law acknowledges that animals are capable of feeling, of suffering. However, animal protection stems from the state’s objective – subjectless – duty to protect the environment and humans’ living conditions. Its ultimate aim is to protect humans.
- 16 September 2021
- Published by Maria Curie-Sklodowska University in Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
- Vol. 30 (3) , 109-118
Open AccessAnimal Protection in Hungary: A Multilayer System Based on an Administrative Approach
Animal protection has a long tradition in the Hungarian legal system. It can be interpreted as a multi-layer model, but the major approach of animal protection has an administrative nature. Originally, animal protection was interpreted as protecting farm animals as resources. Even though new layers have been evolved, the agricultural-administrative approach remained. The second layer is based on the protection of health and healthy nature. Animals are even protected as part of the natural environment and ecosystem and their protection is part of securing the biodiversity in Hungary. Although animal cruelty is a criminal offense in Hungary, the penal law approach is consistent with administrative law as it is based on the institutional protection of the fundamental right to health and a healthy environment. The law acknowledges that animals are capable of feeling, of suffering. However, animal protection stems from the state’s objective – subjectless – duty to protect the environment and humans’ living conditions. Its ultimate aim is to protect humans.