RLRomain Lallement

Romain Lallement

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Romain Lallement has a total of 44 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Low-n absorber EUV masks: mask manufacturing assessment through process characterization and optimization with early look at EUV Low-NA and High-NA imaging performance

    by Henry H. Kamberian, Jed Rankin, Jinju Beineke, Romain Lallement, Michael Green, Martin Burkhardt, Mohamed Ramadan, Scott Halle, Rajiv Sejpal, Oseo Park, et al.

    Industry has made significant progress advancing EUV Lithography technology for the past several years leading to its full adoption starting at N7 node and volume production through N3 node. To extend EUVL technology well into sub-2nm node regime and beyond, a new High NA EUV platform (Hi-NA) is needed and will be introduced. These new Hi-NA scanner platforms will use anamorphic optics with 0.55NA with EUV illumination incidence angle lower from current scanners arriving light of 6° incidence. At mask level, the combination of EUV light at oblique incidence, absorber thickness, and non-uniform mirror reflectance through incidence angle, creates mask-induced imaging aberrations, known as mask 3D effects (M3D). Additionally, these Hi-NA systems introduce mask related imaging complications such as non-telecentricity, which has shown to cause H-V bias due to shadowing, pattern shift through focus, and image contrast loss due to apodization by the reflective mask coatings. All these factors suggest a need for novel EUV mask absorbers, which will reduce these effects. Of the various novel materials, the low refractive index (low-n) absorber materials, characterized as EUVPSM, have received most attention and acceptance. EUVPSM promises to address mask 3D effects while improving wafer image quality with enhanced contrast. In this work, we have embarked on characterization studies to evaluate a EUV low-n absorber material (EUVPSM), which meets EUV mask fabrication requirements for impending 2nm and below advanced semiconductor device nodes. While a number of low-n materials were considered, through simulation and material evaluation the selection was narrowed to one material, which met thickness, PSM phase angle, and EUV reflectivity targets. Characterization consisted of studying mask manufacturing modules including patterning, post-exposure processing, cleaning, defect inspection and repair. In this study, the material was evaluated for critical patterning performance looking at key CD control metrics such as resolution, uniformity, linearity, proximity and LER/LWR. We also characterized pattern fidelity looking at complex mask designs for 2nm node class and beyond using internally developed advanced mask characterization and optimization methodology emphasizing 2D pattern characterization, including sidewall angle (SWA) assessment of patterned absorber and resultant imaging. Another module studied is the EUV Black-Border patterning process which must improve to meet tightening dimensional, placement and EUV reflectivity controls needed for the Hi-NA regime, especially to enable half-field stitching requirements. With a mask manufacturing process established and characterized, EUVPSM mask lithographic performance was evaluated both to validate the simulation models, and to assess overall EUV printability at Low-NA, where the lithography process and tools are more established. Additionally, an early assessment at Hi-NA conditions is planned to examine critical imaging metrics while comparing the EUVPSM to standard Ta-based binary mask absorber, including early assessment of BB process on both mask and wafer.


  • EUV mask patterning process to enable opaque SRAFS for bright field EUV mask imaging

    by Michael Green, Scott Halle, Mohamed Ramadan, Romain Lallement, Henry H. Kamberian, Martin Burkhardt, Jinju Beineke, Jed Rankin, Chris Progler, Steven McDermott

    As extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL) technology progresses to support more advanced nodes, mask designs are becoming more complex and difficult for mask makers to produce with the required fidelity. Resolution enhancement techniques (RETs) including mask optical proximity correction (OPC) models and the addition of sub-resolution assist features (SRAFs) are now critical technology enablers. Early adopters of EUVL benefited from the resolution improvement provided by the shorter wavelength. To extend the benefits of EUV to smaller technologies and broader applications, SRAFs are valuable tools to maximize the process window for a variety of critical layers which require both bright and dark field imaging. Regardless of mask tone, because of the short wavelength of EUV radiation, very small SRAFs are required, thus patterning SRAFs for EUVL poses significant mask process challenges. E beam exposure and resist characteristics are key factors for important patterning attributes including minimum resolvable size, line edge roughness (LER), corner rounding (CR), and line end shortening (LES). Patterning dark SRAFs for bright field masks involves an additional challenge of overcoming mechanical forces on these small structures that can cause feature toppling or collapse. In this study, we demonstrate a mask process capable of patterning dark SRAFs on mask at line widths below 25nm (4X). We will discuss patterning solutions including innovations in both the physical mask manufacturing processes as well as mask data preparation techniques, such as mask process correction (MPC). We will utilize advanced characterization techniques to evaluate SRAF pattern fidelity on the mask and its predicted impact on wafer printing performance. A process capable of resolving sufficiently small SRAFs enables an on-wafer analysis to validate whether the predicted lithographic benefits can be demonstrated. Finally, we will review the outlook of continued shrinking mask resolution requirements from both a design value and process implementation perspective. The coming challenges for EUV mask makers include supporting not only ever increasing design complexity, but also the introduction of new mask materials, including phase shift masks (PSMs) as part of the overall RET solution.

  • Impact of high-NA half-field to full-field overlay performance by Monte Carlo simulations

    by Romain J. Lallement, Daniel Schmidt, Richard Johnson, Jack Wong, Christopher Carr, Martin Burkhardt, Jaime Morillo, Allen Gabor

    In an earlier publication, we evaluated simulation methods to explore overlay performance implications when a highNumerical Aperture (high-NA) Extreme Ultra Violet (EUV) exposure is mixed and matched with a 0.33NA EUV full field exposure. The present contribution goes beyond the method description and aims to quantify the overlay performance impact in such a mix and match case, giving insight into the influence of different sets of overlay corrections. To this aim, the Mont Carlo engine has been updated to accommodate overlay corrections with up to 57 parameters. Since high-NA EUV is not yet available, typical overlay correction terms from IBM’s 0.33NA EUV tool have been used to approximate a realistic image placement error fingerprint for our simulations. As a result, we demonstrate the benefit of various overlay correction sets, and the detrimental effect when using different masks for top and bottom half fields. Such information can also help to infer design layout placement decisions to avoid hot spot regions.


  • Open Access

    OVL performance of HighNA stitched fields using Monte Carlo simulations

    by Romain Lallement, Jaime Morillo, Daniel Schmidt, Rick Johnson, Cody Murray, Martin Burkhardt, Allen Gabor

    SPIE Digital Library Proceedings

  • Focus considerations of design pitches and absorber choice for EUV random logic

    by Martin Burkhardt, Zheng G. Chen, Scott Halle, Romain J. Lallement, Stuart A. Sieg, Luciana Meli

    Background: In EUV lithography, the absorber material determines the amplitude and phase of the diffracted orders, which define best focus (BF) and depth of focus (DOF). Control of BF and DOF is needed for mid and high numerical aperture (NA) systems. Aim: Generate recommendations for EUV absorber classes and explain the best focus shifts that occur for bright and dark field mask imaging. Approach: We anchor simulations with experiments using a TaBN absorber, then investigate the BF and DOF for various absorbers using simulation. We use a simple analytical model to show that the analytically predicted diffraction orders behave similarly in magnitude and phase to EMF simulations. Results: We find good prediction for BF experiments and simulations using a very simple resist model, and fair prediction in DOF. We explain the BF shift depending on simple absorber parameters using an analytical model. The exact BF shift needs to be calculated using EMF simulations. Conclusions: Best focus shifts are more pronounced for dark than clear field masks, and more so in attPSM materials than in more binary absorbers. Magnitude and phase of the 0th order plays an important role in BF shifts. We are encouraged to explore low-reflection attPSM materials as mask absorbers.


  • Exploring the stochastics cliff: understanding the impact of LER/LWR to stochastic defectivity and yield

    by Jennifer Church, Graham Jensen, Romain Lallement, Andrew Cross, Luciana Meli

    EUV materials and processes are constantly evolving and maturing, making sub-30nm pitch single-exposure yield feasible. In this paper, the link between LER and stochastic defectivity is explored at a deeper level, as we probe the possibility of nucleating stochastic failures with programmed LER structures at 30 nm pitch using CDSEM, optical inspection and electrical yield data. First, we characterize LER post-develop and post-etch using unbiased LER measurements. Second, we study the defectivity and optical characteristics of programmed LER pattern post hard mask open using optical inspection. Finally, this data is compared to electrical yield to understand yield as a function of LER and defectivity.


  • Fundamental characterization of stochastic variation for improved single-expose extreme ultraviolet patterning at aggressive pitch

    by Jennifer Church, Luciana Meli, Jing Guo, Martin Burkhardt, Chris A. Mack, Anuja De Silva, Karen E. Petrillo, Mary A. Breton, Ravi K. Bonam, Romain Lallement, et al.

    Background: With aggressive scaling of single-expose (SE) extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography to the sub-7-nm node, stochastic variations play a prominent role in defining the lithographic process window (PW). Fluctuations in photon shot noise, absorption, and subsequent chemical reactions can lead to stochastic failure, directly impacting electrical yield. Aim: Fundamental characterization of the mode and magnitude of these variations is required to define the threshold for failure. Approach: A complementary series of techniques is enlisted to probe the nature and modulation of stochastic variation in SE EUV patterning. Unbiased line edge roughness (LER), local critical dimension uniformity (LCDU), and defect inspection techniques are employed to monitor the frequency of stochastic variations leading to failures in line/space (L/S) and via patterning. Results: When characterizing different resists and illumination conditions, there is no change in unbiased LER or via LCDU with increasing critical dimension (CD). Stochastic defect density is correlated with CD for both L/S and via arrays, and there is a strong correlation with L/S electrical yield data. Conclusions: Traditional 3σ LER and via LCDU measurements are not sensitive enough to define and improve PW. For PW centering and yield improvement, stochastic defect inspection is a necessity.


  • EUVL mask process development and verification using advanced modeling and characterization techniques

    by Michael Green, Romain Lallement, Mohamed Ramadan, Derren Dunn, Henry Kamberian, Stuart Sieg, Young Ham, Chris Progler

    Mask technology is key to enabling the progression of advanced IC technology nodes into the realm beyond 7nm node logic. In particular, extreme ultraviolet lithography (EUVL) relies heavily on the mask in order to achieve adequate process window (PW) and final yields. In the EUVL environment, mask process development and verification becomes increasingly more difficult and costly. The mask manufacture costs are driven by multiple factors including significantly more expensive mask blanks and increased ebeam write times. Wafer verification of mask process improvements is very difficult with the relatively low number of early adopters of EUVL and high cost associated with processing non-product wafers with that technology. It is therefore useful for mask manufacturers and wafer lithographers to collaborate to develop low cost mask process screening techniques as a precursor to committing valuable EUV exposure time for final verification. Previously, we demonstrated that by utilizing a toolkit of mask and wafer analytical techniques known as advanced mask characterization and optimization (AMCO) [2], we were able to predict wafer defectivity on 1D and 2D metal structures and optimize a mask process to enable 30nm pitch interconnect in a single exposure step using EUVL [1]. In this study, we use similar methodology to develop a mask process for beyond 7nm node logic contact and via layers. These structures pose a different set of challenges than the metal layer. Contact hole area loss, corner rounding (CR), and mask process-induced x-y error on asymmetric holes must be optimized to deliver the required capability. Additionally, sub-resolution assist features (SRAFs) become relevant at this node. Resolving these on the mask is critical. Here, we describe the development of a mask process to overcome these challenges. We use advanced modeling techniques including AMCO to characterize the process improvements and predict wafer performance. Mask process improvements that are characterized include both physical mask process components as well as write data optimization techniques, i.e. mask process correction (MPC).