Blair Gallante
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Blair Gallante has a total of 66 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mantu Gupta
Department of Urology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, USA
8 shared publications - William M. Atallah
Department of Urology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, USA
8 shared publications - Ziv Savin
Department of Urology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, New York
8 shared publications - Kavita Gupta
Department of Urology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, USA
7 shared publications - Eve Frangopoulos
Department of Urology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, USA
6 shared publications - Mantu Gupta
Department of Urology, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, New York, USA
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 699
More energy, same results: high energy settings do not improve the efficiency of dual energy lithotripsy during percutaneous nephrolithotomy
- 25 September 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 699
Open AccessMore energy, same results: high energy settings do not improve the efficiency of dual energy lithotripsy during percutaneous nephrolithotomy
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 542
Prevention of ureteral stone migration during percutaneous nephrolithotomy: a randomized controlled trial
Objective With the increasing adoption of totally tubeless percutaneous nephrolithotomy (ttPCNL), prevention of stone fragment migration into the ureter has gained clinical importance. This study aimed to compare the incidence of ureteral fragment migration at the end of PCNL using a 5 Fr open-ended ureteral catheter (5FrUC) versus an occlusion balloon catheter (OBC). Methods In this IRB-approved randomized controlled trial, 108 eligible patients were randomized 1:1 to either the 5FrUC or OBC group and 99 were included in the final analysis. The primary outcome, ureteral fragment migration, was defined as the presence of any stone fragment ≥ 1 mm between the ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) and ureterovesical junction (UVJ), confirmed by ureteroscopy at the conclusion of PCNL. Results Baseline demographics, stone characteristics, and operative parameters were comparable between groups, confirming effective randomization. Ureteral fragments were detected in 10 patients (10%): 7 with a single fragment, 2 with two fragments, and 1 with more than three fragments. The median fragment size was 2 mm (range, 1–4 mm). The incidence of ureteral fragments was significantly higher in the 5FrUC group compared with the OBC group (17% vs. 4%, p = 0.03). Logistic regression analysis demonstrated that OBC use reduced the risk of ureteral fragment migration by approximately 80% compared with 5FrUC (OR = 0.204, 95%CI 0.041–1.001, p = 0.05). Greater total stone burden, larger stone volume, higher Guy’s stone score, and presence of full staghorn calculi were also associated with fragment migration. Conclusion Use of an occlusion balloon catheter significantly reduced ureteral fragment migration compared with a 5 Fr open-ended ureteral catheter, achieving prevention in 96% of cases. Although the clinical impact of residual ureteral fragments remains uncertain, these findings support consideration of OBC use, particularly in ttPCNL procedures.
- 2 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 542
Prevention of ureteral stone migration during percutaneous nephrolithotomy: a randomized controlled trial
Objective With the increasing adoption of totally tubeless percutaneous nephrolithotomy (ttPCNL), prevention of stone fragment migration into the ureter has gained clinical importance. This study aimed to compare the incidence of ureteral fragment migration at the end of PCNL using a 5 Fr open-ended ureteral catheter (5FrUC) versus an occlusion balloon catheter (OBC). Methods In this IRB-approved randomized controlled trial, 108 eligible patients were randomized 1:1 to either the 5FrUC or OBC group and 99 were included in the final analysis. The primary outcome, ureteral fragment migration, was defined as the presence of any stone fragment ≥ 1 mm between the ureteropelvic junction (UPJ) and ureterovesical junction (UVJ), confirmed by ureteroscopy at the conclusion of PCNL. Results Baseline demographics, stone characteristics, and operative parameters were comparable between groups, confirming effective randomization. Ureteral fragments were detected in 10 patients (10%): 7 with a single fragment, 2 with two fragments, and 1 with more than three fragments. The median fragment size was 2 mm (range, 1–4 mm). The incidence of ureteral fragments was significantly higher in the 5FrUC group compared with the OBC group (17% vs. 4%, p = 0.03). Logistic regression analysis demonstrated that OBC use reduced the risk of ureteral fragment migration by approximately 80% compared with 5FrUC (OR = 0.204, 95%CI 0.041–1.001, p = 0.05). Greater total stone burden, larger stone volume, higher Guy’s stone score, and presence of full staghorn calculi were also associated with fragment migration. Conclusion Use of an occlusion balloon catheter significantly reduced ureteral fragment migration compared with a 5 Fr open-ended ureteral catheter, achieving prevention in 96% of cases. Although the clinical impact of residual ureteral fragments remains uncertain, these findings support consideration of OBC use, particularly in ttPCNL procedures.
- Open Access
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 236
Correction: Who still needs multiple access sites in the era of ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL?
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 236
Open AccessCorrection: Who still needs multiple access sites in the era of ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL?
- 17 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 105
Who still needs multiple access sites in the era of ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL?
Introduction Multiaccess PCNL, typically performed for large complex renal stones, is associated with higher complication rates. Newer techniques like ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL may reduce the need for multiple tracts and related morbidity. This study aims to identify contemporary preoperative predictors for multiple access tracts during ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL. Methods We analyzed our most recent 250 patients undergoing US-guided supine PCNL (and ECIRS when indicated) with at least one year follow-up using logistic regression models and sensitivity analyses to find preoperative factors associated with the likelihood of requiring multiple access tracts. Results Seventeen patients (7%) had a multiaccess procedure, with the lower pole as the most common first access site (59%), followed by upper pole (35%) and interpolar (6%). Fourteen patients had two access sites, two had three, and just one had four. On univariable analysis, multiple stones, higher stone burden, upper pole stones, interpolar stones, and a higher Guy’s Stone Score were associated with likelihood of requiring multiple accesses. On multivariable analysis, stone burden remained the only significant predictor (OR = 1.038, 95% CI: 1.010–1.066, p = 0.007). A burden > 34.5 mm was found to be the optimal size cutoff. Among 36 full staghorn cases, 6 (17%) required multiple accesses. In non-staghorn patients, upper pole stones were the strongest predictor (OR = 5.056, 95% CI: 1.272–20.099, p = 0.021). Conclusion In the era of ECIRS, US-guidance, and supine position, only 7% of patients require multiaccess PCNL. Total linear stone burden, upper pole stones and number of calyces are key risk factors, highlighting the value of preoperative identification for optimized surgical planning and outcomes.
- 17 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 44  (1) , 105
Who still needs multiple access sites in the era of ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL?
Introduction Multiaccess PCNL, typically performed for large complex renal stones, is associated with higher complication rates. Newer techniques like ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL may reduce the need for multiple tracts and related morbidity. This study aims to identify contemporary preoperative predictors for multiple access tracts during ECIRS and US-guided supine PCNL. Methods We analyzed our most recent 250 patients undergoing US-guided supine PCNL (and ECIRS when indicated) with at least one year follow-up using logistic regression models and sensitivity analyses to find preoperative factors associated with the likelihood of requiring multiple access tracts. Results Seventeen patients (7%) had a multiaccess procedure, with the lower pole as the most common first access site (59%), followed by upper pole (35%) and interpolar (6%). Fourteen patients had two access sites, two had three, and just one had four. On univariable analysis, multiple stones, higher stone burden, upper pole stones, interpolar stones, and a higher Guy’s Stone Score were associated with likelihood of requiring multiple accesses. On multivariable analysis, stone burden remained the only significant predictor (OR = 1.038, 95% CI: 1.010–1.066, p = 0.007). A burden > 34.5 mm was found to be the optimal size cutoff. Among 36 full staghorn cases, 6 (17%) required multiple accesses. In non-staghorn patients, upper pole stones were the strongest predictor (OR = 5.056, 95% CI: 1.272–20.099, p = 0.021). Conclusion In the era of ECIRS, US-guidance, and supine position, only 7% of patients require multiaccess PCNL. Total linear stone burden, upper pole stones and number of calyces are key risk factors, highlighting the value of preoperative identification for optimized surgical planning and outcomes.
- 11 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Urolithiasis
- Vol. 53  (1) , 1-9
Do elevated intrarenal pressures during mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy increase postoperative pain??
Introduction High intrarenal pressures (IRP) during mini-PCNL have been postulated to result in increased postoperative pain but no studies have evaluated this to our knowledge. We sought to determine if there is a correlation between IRP and immediate postoperative pain when using different tract sizes. Methods Patients were enrolled and assigned for standard (s-PCNL, 24fr), suctioning-mini (sm-PCNL, 16fr) and non-suctioning-mini (nsm-PCNL, 17.5fr) PCNLs. IRP was measured continuously with a novel technique of real-time monitoring using a 0.014 single-use pressure-sensing COMET™ guidewire. Postoperative pain was documented at the PACU using the VAS pain score. Correlation tests were used to evaluate the association between maximal IRP or tract size and postoperative pain. Results The study cohort consisted of 30 patients with 10 patients in each group. The median age was 59 and the median stone volume was 438 mm3. None of the patients were pre-stented. Baseline characteristics were comparable across the groups. The median average IRP of the entire cohort was 7 mmHg (IQR 5–11), and the median maximal pressure was 50 mmHg (IQR 30–66). There were no IRP differences between the groups (p = 0.67 for average; p = 0.35 for maximal). Average and maximal VAS pain scores were not different between the tract size groups (p = 0.09 and p = 0.17, respectively), and no significant association was found between maximal IRP and pain scores. Conclusion The IRP range during PCNL is relatively low, regardless of the tract size. There was no association between the level of maximal IRP and postoperative pain. Our findings provide new in-vivo evidence challenging the commonly cited 30 mmHg IRP threshold and support its reevaluation, given the lack of strong clinical validation.
- 11 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Urolithiasis
- Vol. 53  (1) , 1-9
Do elevated intrarenal pressures during mini percutaneous nephrolithotomy increase postoperative pain??
Introduction High intrarenal pressures (IRP) during mini-PCNL have been postulated to result in increased postoperative pain but no studies have evaluated this to our knowledge. We sought to determine if there is a correlation between IRP and immediate postoperative pain when using different tract sizes. Methods Patients were enrolled and assigned for standard (s-PCNL, 24fr), suctioning-mini (sm-PCNL, 16fr) and non-suctioning-mini (nsm-PCNL, 17.5fr) PCNLs. IRP was measured continuously with a novel technique of real-time monitoring using a 0.014 single-use pressure-sensing COMET™ guidewire. Postoperative pain was documented at the PACU using the VAS pain score. Correlation tests were used to evaluate the association between maximal IRP or tract size and postoperative pain. Results The study cohort consisted of 30 patients with 10 patients in each group. The median age was 59 and the median stone volume was 438 mm3. None of the patients were pre-stented. Baseline characteristics were comparable across the groups. The median average IRP of the entire cohort was 7 mmHg (IQR 5–11), and the median maximal pressure was 50 mmHg (IQR 30–66). There were no IRP differences between the groups (p = 0.67 for average; p = 0.35 for maximal). Average and maximal VAS pain scores were not different between the tract size groups (p = 0.09 and p = 0.17, respectively), and no significant association was found between maximal IRP and pain scores. Conclusion The IRP range during PCNL is relatively low, regardless of the tract size. There was no association between the level of maximal IRP and postoperative pain. Our findings provide new in-vivo evidence challenging the commonly cited 30 mmHg IRP threshold and support its reevaluation, given the lack of strong clinical validation.
- 3 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 43  (1) , 1-9
Should percutaneous nephrolithotomy be performed in patients with severe chronic kidney disease? A closer look at renal function outcomes
- 3 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 43  (1) , 1-9
Should percutaneous nephrolithotomy be performed in patients with severe chronic kidney disease? A closer look at renal function outcomes
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 43  (1) , 1-10
World-wide variation in percutaneous nephrolithotomy practices: evaluation based on training, experience, and region
Introduction : Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) has undergone numerous technological innovations recently that make it even less invasive, but global adoption of these innovations remains unclear. This study sought to compare the effect of region and education on the penetrance of recent advances in PCNL worldwide. Methods An anonymous 32-item survey was developed and distributed via the Endourological Society’s Twitter/X account in November 2023. The survey collected data on participants’ geographic region, PCNL volume, fellowship training, and PCNL practices. Descriptive statistics were calculated, and chi-square or Fisher’s exact tests were used for comparisons. Results Responses were received from 160 PCNL providers worldwide. Respondents were categorized by geography, fellowship training, and procedural volume. Spinal anesthesia was more commonly used by Asian providers (31%, p = 0.001), while supine positioning was notably more common in Europe (76%, p = 0.001). Asian providers favored pneumatic energy (63%), while North American and European providers more frequently used dual energy lithotripters (31–72%) and hemostatic tract agents (p < 0.001). High-volume providers and those with more post-fellowship experience tended to use smaller sheaths, including mini-PCNL. Postoperative imaging practices also varied by region and fellowship-training status. Conclusion PCNL practices vary significantly worldwide, influenced by regional, economic, and experiential factors. Our survey indicates a significant shift in practices with 41% of providers using supine position and over 50% doing tubeless PCNL. However, ultrasound access has been slow to gain widespread use with 73% still using predominantly fluoroscopy, similar to prior studies. Further randomized studies are needed to establish the clinical effectiveness of new technologies and to drive standardization of care across geographic and economic barriers.
- 1 September 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 43  (1) , 1-10
World-wide variation in percutaneous nephrolithotomy practices: evaluation based on training, experience, and region
Introduction : Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) has undergone numerous technological innovations recently that make it even less invasive, but global adoption of these innovations remains unclear. This study sought to compare the effect of region and education on the penetrance of recent advances in PCNL worldwide. Methods An anonymous 32-item survey was developed and distributed via the Endourological Society’s Twitter/X account in November 2023. The survey collected data on participants’ geographic region, PCNL volume, fellowship training, and PCNL practices. Descriptive statistics were calculated, and chi-square or Fisher’s exact tests were used for comparisons. Results Responses were received from 160 PCNL providers worldwide. Respondents were categorized by geography, fellowship training, and procedural volume. Spinal anesthesia was more commonly used by Asian providers (31%, p = 0.001), while supine positioning was notably more common in Europe (76%, p = 0.001). Asian providers favored pneumatic energy (63%), while North American and European providers more frequently used dual energy lithotripters (31–72%) and hemostatic tract agents (p < 0.001). High-volume providers and those with more post-fellowship experience tended to use smaller sheaths, including mini-PCNL. Postoperative imaging practices also varied by region and fellowship-training status. Conclusion PCNL practices vary significantly worldwide, influenced by regional, economic, and experiential factors. Our survey indicates a significant shift in practices with 41% of providers using supine position and over 50% doing tubeless PCNL. However, ultrasound access has been slow to gain widespread use with 73% still using predominantly fluoroscopy, similar to prior studies. Further randomized studies are needed to establish the clinical effectiveness of new technologies and to drive standardization of care across geographic and economic barriers.
- 7 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 43  (1) , 1-7
Evaluation of a fluoroscopy-free, ureteral access sheath-free, and stent-free approach to retrograde intrarenal surgery
Purpose We sought to evaluate the safety and efficacy of an approach attempting no fluoroscopy (F), ureteral sheaths (US), or stents (S) during retrograde intrarenal surgery (NoFUSS-RIRS) and to compare it to conventional RIRS (C-RIRS). Methods We prospectively collected data on the first 75 NoFUSS-RIRS procedures in patients with 5–20 mm renal stones and compared them to a cohort of 75 prior patients undergoing C-RIRS which involved fluoroscopy and stent placement. Baseline characteristics, safety outcomes (including Clavien-Dindo complications, ED visits, and readmissions), and CT-determined stone-free rates were compared. Secondary outcomes included the incidence of fluoroscopy and stent utilization. Results The NoFUSS protocol was successfully implemented in over 90% of patients, with no cases requiring fluoroscopy or ureteral sheaths and only 9.3% requiring a stent. There were no significant differences in baseline or stone characteristics between groups. Median operating room time was significantly shorter in the NoFUSS-RIRS group (46 vs. 64 min, p < 0.001). There were no differences in complications (6.7% vs. 6.7%), ED visits (5.3% vs. 5.3%), or readmissions (2.7% vs. 2.7%) between NoFUSS-RIRS and C-RIRS groups, all p = 1. There were no significant differences in CT-based stone-free rates across all residual fragment (RF) categories including zero RF (NoFUSS-RIRS: 82.7% vs. C-RIRS: 72.7%, p = 0.199), RF < 3 mm, and RF ≥ 3 mm. Conclusions A NoFUSS-RIRS protocol offers similar stone-free rates compared to C-RIRS with no increase in safety-related outcomes. Moreover, operative costs and radiation exposure to patients and operating room staff can be significantly reduced.
- 7 July 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in World Journal of Urology
- Vol. 43  (1) , 1-7
Evaluation of a fluoroscopy-free, ureteral access sheath-free, and stent-free approach to retrograde intrarenal surgery
Purpose We sought to evaluate the safety and efficacy of an approach attempting no fluoroscopy (F), ureteral sheaths (US), or stents (S) during retrograde intrarenal surgery (NoFUSS-RIRS) and to compare it to conventional RIRS (C-RIRS). Methods We prospectively collected data on the first 75 NoFUSS-RIRS procedures in patients with 5–20 mm renal stones and compared them to a cohort of 75 prior patients undergoing C-RIRS which involved fluoroscopy and stent placement. Baseline characteristics, safety outcomes (including Clavien-Dindo complications, ED visits, and readmissions), and CT-determined stone-free rates were compared. Secondary outcomes included the incidence of fluoroscopy and stent utilization. Results The NoFUSS protocol was successfully implemented in over 90% of patients, with no cases requiring fluoroscopy or ureteral sheaths and only 9.3% requiring a stent. There were no significant differences in baseline or stone characteristics between groups. Median operating room time was significantly shorter in the NoFUSS-RIRS group (46 vs. 64 min, p < 0.001). There were no differences in complications (6.7% vs. 6.7%), ED visits (5.3% vs. 5.3%), or readmissions (2.7% vs. 2.7%) between NoFUSS-RIRS and C-RIRS groups, all p = 1. There were no significant differences in CT-based stone-free rates across all residual fragment (RF) categories including zero RF (NoFUSS-RIRS: 82.7% vs. C-RIRS: 72.7%, p = 0.199), RF < 3 mm, and RF ≥ 3 mm. Conclusions A NoFUSS-RIRS protocol offers similar stone-free rates compared to C-RIRS with no increase in safety-related outcomes. Moreover, operative costs and radiation exposure to patients and operating room staff can be significantly reduced.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Endourology
- Vol. 38  (9) , 929-935
Extreme Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy: A Case Series of Procedures Requiring Five or More Access Tracts
Introduction: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) remains the gold standard treatment for patients with complete staghorn stones, for which multiple access tracts may be required. In this study, we describe a series of patients undergoing PCNL with a minimum of five dilated access tracts. Materials and Methods: We performed a multi-institutional retrospective review of 10 patients with complete staghorn stones who underwent PCNL requiring five or more access tracts. We recorded patient demographics, stone characteristics postoperative complications, and stone-free rates (SFRs). The primary endpoint was any postoperative complication. Secondary endpoints included SFR, operative time, and length of stay. SFR was defined as absence of stones or residual fragments 3 . Seven patients (70%) experienced postoperative complications, ranging from Clavien II to IVa. Three patients (30%) required blood transfusions. Median operative time was 312 minutes ranging from 180 to 560 minutes. Five patients (50%) were stone-free after the initial procedure. Of those with residual fragments, 4 (40%) required reoperation to be rendered stone-free. Median length of stay was 2.5 days, with a range of 1–6 days. Conclusion: To our knowledge, this is the largest series of patients undergoing PCNL with five or more access tracts reported to date. This study confirms that PCNL with five or more tracts is feasible and relatively safe, albeit with a high rate of complications in the immediate postoperative period.
- 1 September 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Endourology
- Vol. 38  (9) , 929-935
Extreme Percutaneous Nephrolithotomy: A Case Series of Procedures Requiring Five or More Access Tracts
Introduction: Percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) remains the gold standard treatment for patients with complete staghorn stones, for which multiple access tracts may be required. In this study, we describe a series of patients undergoing PCNL with a minimum of five dilated access tracts. Materials and Methods: We performed a multi-institutional retrospective review of 10 patients with complete staghorn stones who underwent PCNL requiring five or more access tracts. We recorded patient demographics, stone characteristics postoperative complications, and stone-free rates (SFRs). The primary endpoint was any postoperative complication. Secondary endpoints included SFR, operative time, and length of stay. SFR was defined as absence of stones or residual fragments 3 . Seven patients (70%) experienced postoperative complications, ranging from Clavien II to IVa. Three patients (30%) required blood transfusions. Median operative time was 312 minutes ranging from 180 to 560 minutes. Five patients (50%) were stone-free after the initial procedure. Of those with residual fragments, 4 (40%) required reoperation to be rendered stone-free. Median length of stay was 2.5 days, with a range of 1–6 days. Conclusion: To our knowledge, this is the largest series of patients undergoing PCNL with five or more access tracts reported to date. This study confirms that PCNL with five or more tracts is feasible and relatively safe, albeit with a high rate of complications in the immediate postoperative period.
- 1 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Endourology
- Vol. 38  (8) , 843-851
Evaluation of the Current Status of Artificial Intelligence for Endourology Patient Education: A Blind Comparison of ChatGPT and Google Bard Against Traditional Information Resources
Introduction: Artificial intelligence (AI) platforms such as ChatGPT and Bard are increasingly utilized to answer patient health care questions. We present the first study to blindly evaluate AI-generated responses to common endourology patient questions against official patient education materials. Methods: Thirty-two questions and answers spanning kidney stones, ureteral stents, benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), and upper tract urothelial carcinoma were extracted from official Urology Care Foundation (UCF) patient education documents. The same questions were input into ChatGPT 4.0 and Bard, limiting responses to within ±10% of the word count of the corresponding UCF response to ensure fair comparison. Six endourologists blindly evaluated responses from each platform using Likert scales for accuracy, clarity, comprehensiveness, and patient utility. Reviewers identified which response they believed was not AI generated. Finally, Flesch–Kincaid Reading Grade Level formulas assessed the readability of each platform response. Ratings were compared using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and chi-square tests. Results: ChatGPT responses were rated the highest across all categories, including accuracy, comprehensiveness, clarity, and patient utility, while UCF answers were consistently scored the lowest, all p < 0.01. A subanalysis revealed that this trend was consistent across question categories (i.e., kidney stones, BPH, etc.). However, AI-generated responses were more likely to be classified at an advanced reading level, while UCF responses showed improved readability (college or higher reading level: ChatGPT = 100%, Bard = 66%, and UCF = 19%), p < 0.001. When asked to identify which answer was not AI generated, 54.2% of responses indicated ChatGPT, 26.6% indicated Bard, and only 19.3% correctly identified it as the UCF response. Conclusions: In a blind evaluation, AI-generated responses from ChatGPT and Bard surpassed the quality of official patient education materials in endourology, suggesting that current AI platforms are already a reliable resource for basic urologic care information. AI-generated responses do, however, tend to require a higher reading level, which may limit their applicability to a broader audience.
- 1 August 2024
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Endourology
- Vol. 38  (8) , 843-851
Evaluation of the Current Status of Artificial Intelligence for Endourology Patient Education: A Blind Comparison of ChatGPT and Google Bard Against Traditional Information Resources
Introduction: Artificial intelligence (AI) platforms such as ChatGPT and Bard are increasingly utilized to answer patient health care questions. We present the first study to blindly evaluate AI-generated responses to common endourology patient questions against official patient education materials. Methods: Thirty-two questions and answers spanning kidney stones, ureteral stents, benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), and upper tract urothelial carcinoma were extracted from official Urology Care Foundation (UCF) patient education documents. The same questions were input into ChatGPT 4.0 and Bard, limiting responses to within ±10% of the word count of the corresponding UCF response to ensure fair comparison. Six endourologists blindly evaluated responses from each platform using Likert scales for accuracy, clarity, comprehensiveness, and patient utility. Reviewers identified which response they believed was not AI generated. Finally, Flesch–Kincaid Reading Grade Level formulas assessed the readability of each platform response. Ratings were compared using analysis of variance (ANOVA) and chi-square tests. Results: ChatGPT responses were rated the highest across all categories, including accuracy, comprehensiveness, clarity, and patient utility, while UCF answers were consistently scored the lowest, all p < 0.01. A subanalysis revealed that this trend was consistent across question categories (i.e., kidney stones, BPH, etc.). However, AI-generated responses were more likely to be classified at an advanced reading level, while UCF responses showed improved readability (college or higher reading level: ChatGPT = 100%, Bard = 66%, and UCF = 19%), p < 0.001. When asked to identify which answer was not AI generated, 54.2% of responses indicated ChatGPT, 26.6% indicated Bard, and only 19.3% correctly identified it as the UCF response. Conclusions: In a blind evaluation, AI-generated responses from ChatGPT and Bard surpassed the quality of official patient education materials in endourology, suggesting that current AI platforms are already a reliable resource for basic urologic care information. AI-generated responses do, however, tend to require a higher reading level, which may limit their applicability to a broader audience.