KGKarin Geffert

Karin Geffert

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Karin Geffert has a total of 35 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • "There Is No One Truth": A Qualitative Analysis of Advisory Committees in COVID-19 Policy-Making in Germany

    by Elisa Braun, Kerstin Sell, Evelien de Hoop, Karin Geffert

    Background: The COVID-19 pandemic posed an unprecedented public health challenge, causing over one hundred thousand deaths in Germany alone. As elsewhere, policy-makers in Germany sought expert advice to navigate uncertainty and urgency, including through ad hoc advisory committees. We aimed to identify committees operating between 2021-2023, assess their composition, and analyse their work processes with a particular focus on structures, expert deliberations and evidence use. Methods: We conducted a systematic document analysis of government documents and semi-structured interviews with committee members in April/May 2024. We identified documents (parliamentary inquiries and freedom of information requests) through systematic searches in digital government archives; and purposively sampled experts from identified committee member lists. Documents were analysed using abridged content analysis, and interview transcripts were analysed using codebook thematic analysis. Results: We screened 984 documents, analysed 43 documents, and conducted 12 interviews. Ultimately, we identified six ad hoc advisory committees which met our inclusion criteria. These committees advised the German national government and the state governments of Bavaria, North Rhine-Westphalia, Rhineland-Palatinate, Schleswig-Holstein, and Thuringia. These were dominated by academic experts, especially from bio-medical disciplines. Structure of the advisory process: Consultations were direct (in person/online meeting) or indirect (written reports). Direct consultations typically included short presentations/input, followed by discussions to reach a consensus opinion. Expert deliberations drew on expert opinion, reports, pre-prints, and peer-reviewed studies. Multi-disciplinary exchange was valued but faced time constraints; opinions differed on whether a successful multi-disciplinary exchange was achieved. Reflections: Committee members were aware of the limits of their advisory role but occasionally struggled with the political nature of the work. Conclusion: German policy-makers continued to involve ad hoc advisory committees after the first year of the pandemic. Where it was achieved and meaningful, multidisciplinary work was perceived as valuable. Political decisions deviating from expert advice required justification under certain circumstances.

  • Open Access

    Assessing governance structures for climate-resilient and sustainable health systems: development of the PHONIC framework

    by Karin Geffert, Annkathrin von der Haar, Marie Jung, Melvine Anyango Otieno, Eva Rehfuess, Alexandra Schneider, Maike Voss, Isabelle von Polenz, Franziska Matthies-Wiesler

    The consequences of climate change have detrimental effects on human health. The establishment of functional governance structures is considered crucial for addressing health challenges, as such structures provide the foundation for coordinated and coherent action. At present, no standardised and internationally applicable approach exists for assessing and benchmarking governance structures for climate and health at national level. Therefore, the objective of this study was to develop the PHONIC framework, a tool designed to assess governance structures for climate-resilient and sustainable health systems. We followed a four-step approach: First, we selected a methodology, originally designed for assessing food environment policies, and assessed its applicability to governance structures for health and climate change. This methodology comprises five key stages, as well as a set of indicators and a catalogue of good practice examples. Second, we identified and adapted existing indicators, through online consultations with international experts, and collated good practice examples for the assessment of governance structures for climate-resilient and sustainable health systems. Third, we piloted the framework with national expert groups in two countries, Germany and Kenya. Finally, we evaluated the PHONIC framework's application and revised the methodology based on the findings from the pilot phase. The final PHONIC framework includes a set of ten indicators across three thematic areas: three indicators focused on governance, four on policy development, and three on cross-sectoral collaboration. In addition, we compiled a catalogue of good practice examples for climate-resilient and sustainable health systems, currently comprising 47 examples from 32 countries. The piloting revealed opportunities, such as the participatory process, but also challenges regarding the narrow focus on health systems. The PHONIC framework, with its participatory and adaptable approach, enables the benchmarking and comprehensive analysis of the strengths and weaknesses of governance structures for climate-resilient and sustainable health systems at country level. The potential of the framework could be expanded by including international experts from a broader geographic scope and systematic searches for good practice examples. Decision makers in the health sector can use the outcomes of the PHONIC framework to identify the most relevant areas and actions for improvement of their climate change and health governance.


  • Early and young child feeding in South Africa: expert assessment of public policy using food-EPI

    by Peter Delobelle, Nicole Holliday, Carmen Klinger, Zandile June-Rose Mchiza, Peter Von Philipsborn, Karin Geffert, Olufunke Alaba

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Public health in Germany: structures, dynamics, and ways forward

    by Hajo Zeeb, Julika Loss, Dagmar Starke, Thomas Altgeld, Susanne Moebus, Karin Geffert, Ansgar Gerhardus


  • Open Access

    The role of the public health service in the implementation of heat health action plans for climate change adaptation in Germany: A qualitative study

    by Karin Geffert, Stephan Voss, Eva Rehfuess, Bernd Rechel

    Background: In response to climate change-induced increases in heat periods, the WHO recommends the implementation of heat health action plans (HHAPs). In Germany, HHAPs are implemented neither comprehensively nor nationwide. Several recommendations have identified the public health service (PHS) at municipal and federal state levels as a key actor regarding to heat and health. Therefore, this study aimed at assessing the role of the PHS in implementing HHAPs at municipal and federal state levels in Germany. Methods: We conducted a policy document analysis to assess the legal basis for the work of the PHS in the 16 federal states in Germany. Furthermore, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 16 experts from within and outside the PHS to explore their perceptions of the PHS in the implementation of HHAPs. The interviews were analysed using reflective thematic analysis. Results: The policy document analysis revealed that heat is not mentioned in any of the federal states’ regulatory frameworks for the PHS, while tasks related to environment and health are addressed, but tend to remain vague. The interviews confirmed that there is currently no clearly defined role for the PHS in implementing HHAPs in Germany and that the actual role primarily depends on the local setting. Main barriers and facilitators could be assigned to three levels (individual, organizational and political), and two overarching contextual factors (awareness of the need for adaptation and existence of other public health emergencies) influenced the implementation of HHAPs across all levels. At the individual level, motivation, knowledge and competencies, and previous experience were possible barriers or enablers. At the organizational level, administrative structures, financial and human resources, leadership and networks were barriers or facilitators, while at the political level they included legislation and political decisions. Conclusions: The PHS could and should be a relevant actor for implementing measures addressing health and climate change locally, in particular because of its focus on vulnerable populations. However, our findings suggest that the legal basis in the federal states of Germany is insufficient. Tailored approaches are needed to overcome barriers such as rigid, non-agile administrative structures and competing priorities, while taking advantage of facilitators such as awareness of relevant actors.


  • Evidenzbasierung für Umwelt und Gesundheit - Grundlagen und Ausblicke für Forschung und Praxis

    by Karin Geffert, Claudia Hornberg

    Zusammenfassung: Der Artikel beschreibt die Bedeutung von umweltbedingten Gesundheitsrisiken und -chancen im Bereich Public Health und betont die Notwendigkeit, wissenschaftliche Erkenntnisse systematisch in die Bewertung und das Management dieser einzubeziehen. Diskutiert werden verschiedene Umweltverständnisse aus Public Health-Sicht, Nutzung von Evidenz und Herausforderungen bei der Evidenzbasierung von Maßnahmen für Umwelt und Gesundheit.

  • Open Access

    Reach and public health implications of proposed new food marketing regulation in Germany: an updated analysis

    by Anna Leibinger, Nicole Holliday, Oliver Huizinga, Carmen Klinger, Elochukwu Okanmelu, Karin Geffert, Eva Rehfuess, Peter von Philipsborn

    Advertising for unhealthy foods adversely affects children’s food preferences and intake. The German government published plans to restrict such advertising in February 2023 and has revised them several times since. We assess the reach of the current draft from June 2023, and discuss its public health implications. We show that across 22 product categories covered by the current draft law, the median share of products permitted for marketing to children stands at 55%, with an interquartile range of 11–73%. Resistance from industry groups and from within government poses hurdles and leaves the prospects of the legislation uncertain.


  • Open Access

    Nutrition Policies in Germany: A Systematic Assessment with the Food Environment Policy Index (Food-EPI)

    by Peter von Philipsborn, Karin Geffert, Carmen Klinger, Antje Hebestreit, Jan Stratil, Eva Rehfuess, for the PEN Consortium

    Objective To systematically assess Germany’s nutrition policies, to benchmark them against international best practices, and to identify priority policy actions to improve population-level nutrition in Germany. Design We applied the Food Environment Policy Index (Food-EPI), a methodological framework developed by the INFORMAS network. Qualitative content analysis of laws, directives and other documents formed the basis of a multi-staged, structured consultation process. Setting Germany. Participants The expert consultation process included 55 experts from academia, public administration, and civil society. Results Germany lags behind international best practices in several key policy areas. For 18 policy indicators, the degree of implementation compared to international best practices was rated as very low, for 21 as low, for 8 as intermediate, and for none as high. In particular, indicators on food taxation, regulation of food marketing, and retail and food service sector policies were rated as very low to low. Identified priority actions included the binding implementation of nutrition standards for schools and kindergartens, a reform of the value added tax on foods and beverages, a sugar-sweetened beverage tax and stricter regulation of food marketing directed at children. Conclusions The results show that Germany makes insufficient use of the potential of evidence-informed health-promoting nutrition policies. Adopting international best practices in key policy areas could help to reduce the burden of nutrition-related chronic disease and related inequalities in nutrition and health in Germany. Implementation of relevant policies requires political leadership, a broad societal dialogue, and evidence-informed advocacy by civil society, including the scientific community.


  • Open Access

    How are social determinants of health represented in German medical education?: a qualitative content analysis of key-curricular documents

    by Franziska Hommes, Simon Drees, Karin Geffert, Peter von Philipsborn, Jan M Stratil

    Objective The WHO Commission on Social Determinants of Health (SDH) has called for a health workforce trained in recognising, understanding and acting on the SDH. However, little is known about how current medical education prepares graduates for this challenge. This study analyses the extent to which the German medical education incorporates content on SDH. Design Following a published protocol, in 2018, we conducted a qualitative and quantitative content analysis of three key document groups, defining and guiding what medical schools are expected to teach and what medical students are expected to know when graduating in Germany. We developed the coding system in a mixed inductive and deductive approach based on key WHO documents. Setting Medical schools and the medical education system in Germany. Results Important gaps exist in the representation of SDH in medical education in Germany. Between 3% and 27% of the analysed document-elements made reference to SDH and only 0%–3% of those document elements made explicit references to SDH. While some aspects were covered widely (eg, topics of occupational health, early childhood development and hygiene), other topics such as health inequalities or determinants outside of the healthcare system were not or hardly represented. Conclusions A stronger and more explicit representation of SDH in German medical education is needed to prepare the new health workforce for current and future challenges in our globalised world and for medical schools to be socially accountable.