R. Edward MinchinJr.
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
R. Edward MinchinJr. has a total of 51 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Yuanxin Zhang
Guangzhou Univ
8 shared publications - Mohammad S. El-Mashaleh
Associate Professor, Dept. of Civil Engineering, Hashemite Univ., P.O. Box 150459, Zarqa 13115, Jordan
4 shared publications - Jiayi Pan
Assistant Professor, Dept. of Construction Management, School of Civil Engineering, Tsinghua Univ., Room 107B, Beijing 100084, China
3 shared publications - Raja Raymond Issa
University of Florida
3 shared publications - Russell C. Walters
Lecturer, Rinker School of Construction Management, Univ. of Florida, 304 Rinker Hall, Gainesville, FL 32611
3 shared publications - Don W. Lewis
Postdoctoral Research Assistant, Dept. of Civil and Coastal Engineering, Univ. of Florida, 365 Weil Hall, Gainesville, FL 32611
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 November 2026
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 18 (4) , 04526043
An Integrated Analysis of Supply Chain Disruptions in Transportation Projects
Recent global disruptions have exposed critical vulnerabilities in construction supply chains (CSC), particularly in transportation infrastructure projects. To provide strategies to manage such risks, this study combines objective performance data from real-world projects with legal case analysis, offering an in-depth empirical lens into how recent macroeconomic and geopolitical shocks have reshaped contractual relationships and dispute dynamics. The research unfolds in three phases. First, a comprehensive literature review was conducted to map the root causes of supply chain (SC) failures and propose strategic mitigation frameworks. Second, legal disputes arising from SC disruptions extracted from LexisNexis were analyzed, focusing on cases that reveal shifts in risk allocation, contractual ambiguities, and dispute resolution outcomes. Third, procurement and performance data from Florida’s transportation projects were analyzed to identify patterns of delay, cost escalation, and scope changes attributable to SC disruptions. This study contributes to the field by integrating legal and engineering perspectives, enabling a deeper understanding of how risk is redistributed in practice, often diverging from intended contractual allocations. By bridging the gap between theory and practice, this research advances the discourse on dispute resolution and risk management in civil infrastructure, providing actionable insights for policymakers, legal professionals, and project managers.
- 1 November 2026
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 18 (4) , 04526043
An Integrated Analysis of Supply Chain Disruptions in Transportation Projects
Recent global disruptions have exposed critical vulnerabilities in construction supply chains (CSC), particularly in transportation infrastructure projects. To provide strategies to manage such risks, this study combines objective performance data from real-world projects with legal case analysis, offering an in-depth empirical lens into how recent macroeconomic and geopolitical shocks have reshaped contractual relationships and dispute dynamics. The research unfolds in three phases. First, a comprehensive literature review was conducted to map the root causes of supply chain (SC) failures and propose strategic mitigation frameworks. Second, legal disputes arising from SC disruptions extracted from LexisNexis were analyzed, focusing on cases that reveal shifts in risk allocation, contractual ambiguities, and dispute resolution outcomes. Third, procurement and performance data from Florida’s transportation projects were analyzed to identify patterns of delay, cost escalation, and scope changes attributable to SC disruptions. This study contributes to the field by integrating legal and engineering perspectives, enabling a deeper understanding of how risk is redistributed in practice, often diverging from intended contractual allocations. By bridging the gap between theory and practice, this research advances the discourse on dispute resolution and risk management in civil infrastructure, providing actionable insights for policymakers, legal professionals, and project managers.
- 6 December 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2677 (5) , 893-906
Statistical Comparison of the Performance of Alternative Contracting Methods in Florida
This study empirically examines the performance of alternative contracting methods using data from 2,721 highway projects gathered from a Florida Department of Transportation database. Contracting methods can significantly influence the cost and time of highway projects, so it is essential to use appropriate contracting methods in highway projects, especially considering the huge current volume of work and great need for more lane miles and new bridges. The most widely used alternative contracting methods in horizontal construction include Design–Build Major, Design–Build Minor, Cost Plus Time, Incentive/Disincentive, Lump Sum, and No Excuse Bonus. These have been devised to overcome shortcomings of the conventional Design–Bid–Build (DBB) method; however, their actual performance in practice has not previously been rigorously studied. To fill this gap, we statistically analyze our sample of highway projects using the Shapiro–Wilk test, Levene’s test, Kruskal–Wallis test, Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney test, and Dunn’s test for unequal sample sizes. Another unique contribution of this research is the analytical techniques employed, which led to more reliable results based on the large quantity of data gathered. We find that some contracting methods performed better than others in each cost category for cost and time, and based on average cost and time savings, but not all were confirmed statistically. All seven contracting methods performed better in achieving time reductions than cost reductions, and all methods were more effective in reducing the cost and time of projects worth less $20 million than those worth over $20 million.
- 6 December 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2677 (5) , 893-906
Statistical Comparison of the Performance of Alternative Contracting Methods in Florida
This study empirically examines the performance of alternative contracting methods using data from 2,721 highway projects gathered from a Florida Department of Transportation database. Contracting methods can significantly influence the cost and time of highway projects, so it is essential to use appropriate contracting methods in highway projects, especially considering the huge current volume of work and great need for more lane miles and new bridges. The most widely used alternative contracting methods in horizontal construction include Design–Build Major, Design–Build Minor, Cost Plus Time, Incentive/Disincentive, Lump Sum, and No Excuse Bonus. These have been devised to overcome shortcomings of the conventional Design–Bid–Build (DBB) method; however, their actual performance in practice has not previously been rigorously studied. To fill this gap, we statistically analyze our sample of highway projects using the Shapiro–Wilk test, Levene’s test, Kruskal–Wallis test, Wilcoxon–Mann–Whitney test, and Dunn’s test for unequal sample sizes. Another unique contribution of this research is the analytical techniques employed, which led to more reliable results based on the large quantity of data gathered. We find that some contracting methods performed better than others in each cost category for cost and time, and based on average cost and time savings, but not all were confirmed statistically. All seven contracting methods performed better in achieving time reductions than cost reductions, and all methods were more effective in reducing the cost and time of projects worth less $20 million than those worth over $20 million.
- 15 March 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2676 (7) , 773-785
Analysis of Constructability Practices in State Departments of Transportation under Organizational Constraints
Designers typically do not base critical design decisions on construction requirements and constraints, and soon realize that their designs could be difficult to build and expensive. Thus, construction expertise needs to be incorporated in the design process through applying constructability concepts at early project stages. With the underlying concept of a construction-driven design, there are many approaches used by transportation agencies in conducting constructability reviews (CRs), but the key is to develop an approach that is consistent and scalable to different ranges of environmental constraints and project delivery methods, while accounting for organizational structure. The objective of this paper is thus to investigate and recommend effective practices in CRs that could be used by Departments of Transportation (DOTs), given their organizational constraints. To achieve this objective, the methodology was divided into two major steps starting with a comprehensive literature review, followed by two case studies of DOTs employing two different constructability programs that align with their organizational policies and constraints: California Department of Transportation and Utah Department of Transportation. Results of the case studies highlight the common themes in their CRs (early involvement of the DOT construction team), whereas the organizational constraints also result in significant differences (CR formality level, and consultants’ and contractors’ involvement). This study thus highlights that there is no one-size-fits-all constructability approach and provides evidence and recommendations, through two different but successful CR processes, on the importance of developing a CR process that aligns with organizational constraints.
- 15 March 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2676 (7) , 773-785
Analysis of Constructability Practices in State Departments of Transportation under Organizational Constraints
Designers typically do not base critical design decisions on construction requirements and constraints, and soon realize that their designs could be difficult to build and expensive. Thus, construction expertise needs to be incorporated in the design process through applying constructability concepts at early project stages. With the underlying concept of a construction-driven design, there are many approaches used by transportation agencies in conducting constructability reviews (CRs), but the key is to develop an approach that is consistent and scalable to different ranges of environmental constraints and project delivery methods, while accounting for organizational structure. The objective of this paper is thus to investigate and recommend effective practices in CRs that could be used by Departments of Transportation (DOTs), given their organizational constraints. To achieve this objective, the methodology was divided into two major steps starting with a comprehensive literature review, followed by two case studies of DOTs employing two different constructability programs that align with their organizational policies and constraints: California Department of Transportation and Utah Department of Transportation. Results of the case studies highlight the common themes in their CRs (early involvement of the DOT construction team), whereas the organizational constraints also result in significant differences (CR formality level, and consultants’ and contractors’ involvement). This study thus highlights that there is no one-size-fits-all constructability approach and provides evidence and recommendations, through two different but successful CR processes, on the importance of developing a CR process that aligns with organizational constraints.
- 21 October 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2676 (3) , 142-159
Constructability Reviews Utilization Practices for Traditional and Alternative Project Delivery Methods Across State Transportation Agencies
State Transportation Agencies (STAs) recognized that to enhance the quality of construction documents, a review process must be incorporated into project planning, design, and procurement to evaluate projects for constructability. The benefits promised by constructability reviews (CRs) encouraged STAs to adopt it as part of their operations. This approach soon evolved into a structured process, recognized by researchers and practitioners as, the constructability review process (CRP). A significant component to the CRP success is to involve experienced construction personnel in CRs during the design phase; a major limitation of the traditional design-bid-build (DBB) delivery method. To overcome this limitation, more emphasis is being placed towards alternative project delivery methods (APDMs). As such, design–build (DB) and construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC) are among the APDMs most utilized by STAs to deliver transportation projects. Although extensive research has investigated CRs under DBB projects, research on CRs implementation under APDMs is remarkably absent. This study examines CRs utilization and staffing practices adopted by STAs across DBB, DB, and CM/GC projects. The results of this study were drawn utilizing data collected through a national survey questionnaire and interviews with selected STAs. The study found that CRs are initiated and implemented at proportionally similar phases across DBB, DB, and CM/GC projects. Investigation of staffing needs revealed that although the agency holds the executive role in implementation of CRs on DBB projects, their role shifts on DB projects to become more administrative. The agency continues to be involved in CRs under CM/GC projects, along with their allocated design consultant, in conjunction with the GC. The results of this study are anticipated to provide STAs with guidance for CRs utilization on DBB, DB and CM/GC projects.
- 21 October 2021
- Published by SAGE Publications in Transportation Research Record: Journal of the Transportation Research Board
- Vol. 2676 (3) , 142-159
Constructability Reviews Utilization Practices for Traditional and Alternative Project Delivery Methods Across State Transportation Agencies
State Transportation Agencies (STAs) recognized that to enhance the quality of construction documents, a review process must be incorporated into project planning, design, and procurement to evaluate projects for constructability. The benefits promised by constructability reviews (CRs) encouraged STAs to adopt it as part of their operations. This approach soon evolved into a structured process, recognized by researchers and practitioners as, the constructability review process (CRP). A significant component to the CRP success is to involve experienced construction personnel in CRs during the design phase; a major limitation of the traditional design-bid-build (DBB) delivery method. To overcome this limitation, more emphasis is being placed towards alternative project delivery methods (APDMs). As such, design–build (DB) and construction manager/general contractor (CM/GC) are among the APDMs most utilized by STAs to deliver transportation projects. Although extensive research has investigated CRs under DBB projects, research on CRs implementation under APDMs is remarkably absent. This study examines CRs utilization and staffing practices adopted by STAs across DBB, DB, and CM/GC projects. The results of this study were drawn utilizing data collected through a national survey questionnaire and interviews with selected STAs. The study found that CRs are initiated and implemented at proportionally similar phases across DBB, DB, and CM/GC projects. Investigation of staffing needs revealed that although the agency holds the executive role in implementation of CRs on DBB projects, their role shifts on DB projects to become more administrative. The agency continues to be involved in CRs under CM/GC projects, along with their allocated design consultant, in conjunction with the GC. The results of this study are anticipated to provide STAs with guidance for CRs utilization on DBB, DB and CM/GC projects.
- 1 November 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 10 (4)
Answers to Questions of Ethics by Highway Contractors
In serving as an expert witness in a construction injury case, the lead author was confronted with the ethics of a contractor lending a piece of heavy construction equipment to another contractor when personnel of the lending contractor knew that there were unsafe features on the piece of equipment. In teaching a course in methods and management of highway construction, the same researcher was also confronted with the question about whether to teach students that those common unethical practices listed in construction textbooks are actually unethical activities, and so should be avoided. As construction projects become increasingly complex and more directly impact the standard of living enjoyed by the populous, ethical conduct is of paramount importance in the construction industry. This study was carried out to investigate and analyze the current state of ethical conduct in the highway construction industry by posing ethical dilemmas to members of the Florida transportation construction industry. A total of 61 telephone interviews were conducted, each consisting of six questions containing specific ethical situations. Two questions concerned unethical professional practices in the construction industry, bid shopping, and bid peddling. Other questions were based on hypothetical ethical dilemmas possibly faced by contractors that could result in severe legal consequences. The data collected via telephone interviews in this study were more reliable than other studies using questionnaires, as confusion about questions was resolved immediately. The average of over 23 years of experience of the interviewees in this study add to the credibility of the results. In addition, as only a few previous studies quantitatively analyzed the data acquired, this study employed a statistical method for data analysis. This paper makes the unique contribution of reporting on the responses of 61 current highway and bridge construction contractors to questions of an ethical nature, while incorporating a rigorous statistical analysis to the data. Overall, the results indicated that Florida transportation builders uphold a high level of ethical standard in their professional practice, at least in the areas in question, despite a minor deviation in one case.
- 1 November 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) in Journal of Legal Affairs and Dispute Resolution in Engineering and Construction
- Vol. 10 (4)
Answers to Questions of Ethics by Highway Contractors
In serving as an expert witness in a construction injury case, the lead author was confronted with the ethics of a contractor lending a piece of heavy construction equipment to another contractor when personnel of the lending contractor knew that there were unsafe features on the piece of equipment. In teaching a course in methods and management of highway construction, the same researcher was also confronted with the question about whether to teach students that those common unethical practices listed in construction textbooks are actually unethical activities, and so should be avoided. As construction projects become increasingly complex and more directly impact the standard of living enjoyed by the populous, ethical conduct is of paramount importance in the construction industry. This study was carried out to investigate and analyze the current state of ethical conduct in the highway construction industry by posing ethical dilemmas to members of the Florida transportation construction industry. A total of 61 telephone interviews were conducted, each consisting of six questions containing specific ethical situations. Two questions concerned unethical professional practices in the construction industry, bid shopping, and bid peddling. Other questions were based on hypothetical ethical dilemmas possibly faced by contractors that could result in severe legal consequences. The data collected via telephone interviews in this study were more reliable than other studies using questionnaires, as confusion about questions was resolved immediately. The average of over 23 years of experience of the interviewees in this study add to the credibility of the results. In addition, as only a few previous studies quantitatively analyzed the data acquired, this study employed a statistical method for data analysis. This paper makes the unique contribution of reporting on the responses of 61 current highway and bridge construction contractors to questions of an ethical nature, while incorporating a rigorous statistical analysis to the data. Overall, the results indicated that Florida transportation builders uphold a high level of ethical standard in their professional practice, at least in the areas in question, despite a minor deviation in one case.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 294-304
Monitoring the Financial Trends of Construction Firms in Korea, Japan, and the United States by Using Bankruptcy Prediction Model
The construction industry is a large part of the world economy and thus is susceptible to macroeconomic shifts and prone to fluctuations in economic health due to the effects of financial risk factors. Reports show that unlike those in the Japanese market, many architecture, engineering and construction (AEC) companies in Korea and the U.S. have either failed or experienced financial distress. Understanding and evaluating financial management indicators are an important part of maintaining fiscal well-being and avoiding corporate ruin. Construction experts are now also concerned about consequences that follow a recession, like the labor deficit. To date no prediction models have been able to accurately predict the next recession following the 2008 recession caused by subprime lending. However, maintaining financial strength is always an encouraged business practice that contributes to avoiding financial hardship including bankruptcy. The Altman Z-score is a bankruptcy prediction model based on multivariate discriminant analysis and used for data investigation. In this study, financial ratios are derived from the financial statements of construction companies and compared among three countries: Korea, Japan, and the U.S. Financial statements are an important area to study because they are a reflection of a company’s management style, culture, and social structure. This study seeks to reveal the similarities and differences in the financial indicators of companies. The findings of the research from financial ratios will provide better understanding of construction companies from different countries while offering insight into proper financial management.
- 29 March 2018
- Published by American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)
- p. 294-304
Monitoring the Financial Trends of Construction Firms in Korea, Japan, and the United States by Using Bankruptcy Prediction Model
The construction industry is a large part of the world economy and thus is susceptible to macroeconomic shifts and prone to fluctuations in economic health due to the effects of financial risk factors. Reports show that unlike those in the Japanese market, many architecture, engineering and construction (AEC) companies in Korea and the U.S. have either failed or experienced financial distress. Understanding and evaluating financial management indicators are an important part of maintaining fiscal well-being and avoiding corporate ruin. Construction experts are now also concerned about consequences that follow a recession, like the labor deficit. To date no prediction models have been able to accurately predict the next recession following the 2008 recession caused by subprime lending. However, maintaining financial strength is always an encouraged business practice that contributes to avoiding financial hardship including bankruptcy. The Altman Z-score is a bankruptcy prediction model based on multivariate discriminant analysis and used for data investigation. In this study, financial ratios are derived from the financial statements of construction companies and compared among three countries: Korea, Japan, and the U.S. Financial statements are an important area to study because they are a reflection of a company’s management style, culture, and social structure. This study seeks to reveal the similarities and differences in the financial indicators of companies. The findings of the research from financial ratios will provide better understanding of construction companies from different countries while offering insight into proper financial management.