Lisa Giombini
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Lisa Giombini has a total of 2 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Chiara Palazzolo
Universidad Francisco de Vitoria Faculty of Education and Psychology, Virtue and Values Education Centre https://dx.doi.org/16447 Madrid Spain
2 shared publications - Alessandro Bertinetto
Department of Philosophy and Education Sciences, University of Turin
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 29 May 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 10 (3) , 66
Practices of Presence: Performing Arts and Philosophical Inquiry
Over the past few decades, performance theory has flourished into a dynamic interdisciplinary discourse, drawing insights from fields such as anthropology, sociology, linguistics, psychoanalysis, political theory, cultural studies, and feminism
- 29 May 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 10 (3) , 66
Open AccessPractices of Presence: Performing Arts and Philosophical Inquiry
Over the past few decades, performance theory has flourished into a dynamic interdisciplinary discourse, drawing insights from fields such as anthropology, sociology, linguistics, psychoanalysis, political theory, cultural studies, and feminism
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in The Philosophical Forum
- Vol. 56 (3) , 67-75
Beyond Art. Classical Music as a Cultural Profession
What is the future of classical music? The outlook appears bleak; without concerted intervention, there may be very few people left to either perform or appreciate it in the near future. What actions can be taken, and who should spearhead them? While governmental and cultural institutions are expected to do their part by allocating resources for classical music education and performances, this paper argues that performers, as cultural agents, also have a pivotal role to play in preserving a practice with profound cultural and societal significance. Therefore, beyond their technical and musical prowess, musicians must also cultivate additional skills, including critical and reflective capabilities. This reimagining of the performer's role necessitates a broader ethical reassessment of classical music as a professional pursuit. Over centuries, music has evolved from mere craftsmanship to a refined art form. Now, it stands at a juncture where it must redefine itself as a cultural profession to reclaim its relevance in contemporary and future societies. The survival of classical music rests on its ability to make this shift.
- 1 March 2025
- Published by Wiley in The Philosophical Forum
- Vol. 56 (3) , 67-75
Beyond Art. Classical Music as a Cultural Profession
What is the future of classical music? The outlook appears bleak; without concerted intervention, there may be very few people left to either perform or appreciate it in the near future. What actions can be taken, and who should spearhead them? While governmental and cultural institutions are expected to do their part by allocating resources for classical music education and performances, this paper argues that performers, as cultural agents, also have a pivotal role to play in preserving a practice with profound cultural and societal significance. Therefore, beyond their technical and musical prowess, musicians must also cultivate additional skills, including critical and reflective capabilities. This reimagining of the performer's role necessitates a broader ethical reassessment of classical music as a professional pursuit. Over centuries, music has evolved from mere craftsmanship to a refined art form. Now, it stands at a juncture where it must redefine itself as a cultural profession to reclaim its relevance in contemporary and future societies. The survival of classical music rests on its ability to make this shift.
- Open Access
- 31 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 10 (1) , 18
Music Criticism Reconsidered: Bias, Expertise, and the Language of Sound
Despite its growing prominence on social and media platforms, scholarly engagement with music criticism today remains unexpectedly limited, especially when compared to the extensive attention devoted to visual and literary criticism. This article seeks to revitalize the discourse by confronting the biases that have long undermined the credibility of music critics in the eyes of both musicians and the public. Inspired by the myth of King Midas—punished by Apollo for his “misguided” musical judgment—the discussion investigates the persistent critiques leveled at music critics, such as accusations of arbitrariness, inadequacy, and irrelevance. Central to this analysis are key questions: how can critics establish authority when their judgments are often shaped by prevailing cultural trends, what expertise distinguishes them from the average listener, and how do they articulate music’s ephemeral essence in words? To address these questions, the article examines the critic’s role through the lenses of journalism, musicology, and criticism itself, highlighting the tension between objectivity and subjectivity and identifying the distinctive skills necessary for effective critique.
- 31 January 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 10 (1) , 18
Open AccessMusic Criticism Reconsidered: Bias, Expertise, and the Language of Sound
Despite its growing prominence on social and media platforms, scholarly engagement with music criticism today remains unexpectedly limited, especially when compared to the extensive attention devoted to visual and literary criticism. This article seeks to revitalize the discourse by confronting the biases that have long undermined the credibility of music critics in the eyes of both musicians and the public. Inspired by the myth of King Midas—punished by Apollo for his “misguided” musical judgment—the discussion investigates the persistent critiques leveled at music critics, such as accusations of arbitrariness, inadequacy, and irrelevance. Central to this analysis are key questions: how can critics establish authority when their judgments are often shaped by prevailing cultural trends, what expertise distinguishes them from the average listener, and how do they articulate music’s ephemeral essence in words? To address these questions, the article examines the critic’s role through the lenses of journalism, musicology, and criticism itself, highlighting the tension between objectivity and subjectivity and identifying the distinctive skills necessary for effective critique.
- 2 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Moral Education
- p. 1-16
Classical music as ethical practice: A professional perspective
- 2 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Moral Education
- p. 1-16
Classical music as ethical practice: A professional perspective
- 19 October 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Culture and Dialogue
- Vol. 9 (1) , 31-62
Music, Ontology and the Need for History: A Critical Discussion
Although an ontological approach to musical works has dominated analytic aesthetics for almost fifty years, criticisms have recently started to spread in the philosophical literature. Contestants blame mainstream musical ontology for lacking historical awareness, questioning the cogency of metaphysical proposals that are substantially essentialist with regard to our musical concepts. My aim in this paper is to address this accusation by engaging the historicist critics in a sustained debate. I argue that even if the arguments based on history and sociology turn out to be accurate, this may not be enough of a reason to abandon the ontological project altogether. Ontology and history do not necessarily clash. Moreover, historical-sociological examinations do not fulfil our philosophical interest in music. I conclude by making a plea to “historical ontology,” a perspective that does not reject ontology but closely connects it to the dialectic between historical research and aesthetic interest.
- 19 October 2021
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Culture and Dialogue
- Vol. 9 (1) , 31-62
Music, Ontology and the Need for History: A Critical Discussion
Although an ontological approach to musical works has dominated analytic aesthetics for almost fifty years, criticisms have recently started to spread in the philosophical literature. Contestants blame mainstream musical ontology for lacking historical awareness, questioning the cogency of metaphysical proposals that are substantially essentialist with regard to our musical concepts. My aim in this paper is to address this accusation by engaging the historicist critics in a sustained debate. I argue that even if the arguments based on history and sociology turn out to be accurate, this may not be enough of a reason to abandon the ontological project altogether. Ontology and history do not necessarily clash. Moreover, historical-sociological examinations do not fulfil our philosophical interest in music. I conclude by making a plea to “historical ontology,” a perspective that does not reject ontology but closely connects it to the dialectic between historical research and aesthetic interest.
- 23 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Studies in Conservation
- Vol. 67 (1-2) , 100-108
Respect in Conservation Ethics: A Philosophical Inquiry
International conservation codes ask practitioners to treat historical objects and buildings with ‘respect’. What does this mean? The question has received comparatively little theoretical treatment in conservation literature. Taking a philosophical stance on the issue, this paper suggests that we cannot grasp how respect delineates ethical obligations for professionals in the field if we do not unearth the sources of these obligations, i.e. what counts as respectful behaviour and to whom respect is owed in the first place. Questioning the widespread understanding of respect as ‘preservation of the object’s integrity’, it proposes a model in which respect is interpreted as a form of preservation of meaning. On this model, respect is directed not so much to the artefact itself, but to the person, community, or culture that take interest in it, those for whom the object is especially meaningful.
- 23 June 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Studies in Conservation
- Vol. 67 (1-2) , 100-108
Respect in Conservation Ethics: A Philosophical Inquiry
International conservation codes ask practitioners to treat historical objects and buildings with ‘respect’. What does this mean? The question has received comparatively little theoretical treatment in conservation literature. Taking a philosophical stance on the issue, this paper suggests that we cannot grasp how respect delineates ethical obligations for professionals in the field if we do not unearth the sources of these obligations, i.e. what counts as respectful behaviour and to whom respect is owed in the first place. Questioning the widespread understanding of respect as ‘preservation of the object’s integrity’, it proposes a model in which respect is interpreted as a form of preservation of meaning. On this model, respect is directed not so much to the artefact itself, but to the person, community, or culture that take interest in it, those for whom the object is especially meaningful.