Silke Westphale
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Silke Westphale has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Joy Backhaus
Institute of Medical Teaching and Medical Education Research University Hospital Würzburg Würzburg Germany
1 shared publication- Joy Backhaus
Institute of Medical Teaching and Medical Education Research, University Hospital Würzburg, Würzburg, Germany
1 shared publication - Rauf Aliyev
Institute of Medical Teaching and Medical Education Research, University Hospital Würzburg, Josef-Schneider-Str. 2/D6, Würzburg, 97080, Germany, +49 931 201 55210, +49 931 201 655213
1 shared publication - Sarah Koenig
University Hospital Würzburg, Institute of Medical Teaching and Medical Education Research, Würzburg, Germany
1 shared publication - Sarah König
Institute of Medical Teaching and Medical Education Research, University Hospital Würzburg, Würzburg, Germany
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 16 June 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Medical Education
- Vol. 12 (1) , e75516
Comparing the Weighted Gain Score and a Rasch-Based Approach for Estimating Learning Outcomes in Medical Education: Quantitative Study
Background: Pretest-posttest designs are widely used to estimate learning gain in studies evaluating educational interventions in medical education. The Weighted Gain Score (WGS) was proposed to reduce bias associated with differences in baseline performance. Objective: This study evaluated the statistical and inferential properties of the WGS by comparing it to Rasch Learning Gain (RLG) across 3 datasets. Methods: The WGS implements a weighting coefficient that includes the parameter µ, which linearly rescales the difference between pretest and posttest percentage scores. We examined the effect of varying µ (30, 50, and 70) on learning gain calculations and compared the results with those obtained using RLG. The following three datasets were analyzed: (1) a small illustrative dataset demonstrating the mathematical behavior of the WGS, (2) an empirical dataset from a previous educational evaluation study, and (3) a randomly generated binomial dataset designed to examine the metric under larger sample conditions. Results: Changing the parameter µ in the WGS affected the magnitude of the calculated learning gains: lower µ-values produced larger gain estimates, whereas higher µ-values produced smaller estimates. Despite these differences in scale, the WGS and RLG correlated strongly in both the empirical dataset ( r =0.93; P <.001) and the simulated dataset ( r =0.92; P <.001); variation in µ did not alter the inferential results. Both methods identified the same interaction effect in the empirical dataset. Conclusions: The WGS produced results highly consistent with those of RLG while requiring substantially lower computational complexity. The metric can be applied to both small and large datasets and allows µ to function as an adjustment coefficient for calibrating learning gain estimates across cohorts without altering inferential conclusions.
- 16 June 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Medical Education
- Vol. 12 (1) , e75516
Open AccessComparing the Weighted Gain Score and a Rasch-Based Approach for Estimating Learning Outcomes in Medical Education: Quantitative Study
Background: Pretest-posttest designs are widely used to estimate learning gain in studies evaluating educational interventions in medical education. The Weighted Gain Score (WGS) was proposed to reduce bias associated with differences in baseline performance. Objective: This study evaluated the statistical and inferential properties of the WGS by comparing it to Rasch Learning Gain (RLG) across 3 datasets. Methods: The WGS implements a weighting coefficient that includes the parameter µ, which linearly rescales the difference between pretest and posttest percentage scores. We examined the effect of varying µ (30, 50, and 70) on learning gain calculations and compared the results with those obtained using RLG. The following three datasets were analyzed: (1) a small illustrative dataset demonstrating the mathematical behavior of the WGS, (2) an empirical dataset from a previous educational evaluation study, and (3) a randomly generated binomial dataset designed to examine the metric under larger sample conditions. Results: Changing the parameter µ in the WGS affected the magnitude of the calculated learning gains: lower µ-values produced larger gain estimates, whereas higher µ-values produced smaller estimates. Despite these differences in scale, the WGS and RLG correlated strongly in both the empirical dataset ( r =0.93; P <.001) and the simulated dataset ( r =0.92; P <.001); variation in µ did not alter the inferential results. Both methods identified the same interaction effect in the empirical dataset. Conclusions: The WGS produced results highly consistent with those of RLG while requiring substantially lower computational complexity. The metric can be applied to both small and large datasets and allows µ to function as an adjustment coefficient for calibrating learning gain estimates across cohorts without altering inferential conclusions.
- Open Access
- 12 November 2021
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 56 (3) , 312-320
Quantifying teaching quality in medical education: The impact of learning gain calculation
Background: Student performance is a mirror of teaching quality. The pre‐/post‐test design allows a pragmatic approach to comparing the effects of interventions. However, the calculation of current knowledge gain scores introduces varying degrees of distortion. Here we present a new metric employing a linear weighting coefficient to reduce skewness on outcome interpretation. Methods: We compared and contrasted a number of common scores (raw and relative gain scores) with our new method on two datasets, one simulated and the other empirical from a previous intervention study ( n = 180) employing a pre‐/post‐test design. Results: The outcomes of the common scores were clearly different, demonstrating a significant dependency on pre‐test scores. Only the new metric revealed a linear relationship to the knowledge baseline, was less skewed on the upper or lower extremes, and proved well suited to allow the calculation of negative learning gains. Employing the empirical dataset, the new method also confirmed the interaction effect of teaching formats with specific subgroups of learner characteristics. Conclusion: This work introduces a new weighted metric enabling meaningful comparisons between interventions based on a linear transformation. This method will form the basis to intertwine the calculation of test performance closely with the outcome of learning as an important factor reflecting teaching quality and efficacy. Its regular use can improve the transparency of teaching activities and outcomes, contribute to forming rounded judgements of students' acquisition of knowledge and skills and enable valuable feedforward to develop and enhance curricular concepts.
- 12 November 2021
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 56 (3) , 312-320
Open AccessQuantifying teaching quality in medical education: The impact of learning gain calculation
Background: Student performance is a mirror of teaching quality. The pre‐/post‐test design allows a pragmatic approach to comparing the effects of interventions. However, the calculation of current knowledge gain scores introduces varying degrees of distortion. Here we present a new metric employing a linear weighting coefficient to reduce skewness on outcome interpretation. Methods: We compared and contrasted a number of common scores (raw and relative gain scores) with our new method on two datasets, one simulated and the other empirical from a previous intervention study ( n = 180) employing a pre‐/post‐test design. Results: The outcomes of the common scores were clearly different, demonstrating a significant dependency on pre‐test scores. Only the new metric revealed a linear relationship to the knowledge baseline, was less skewed on the upper or lower extremes, and proved well suited to allow the calculation of negative learning gains. Employing the empirical dataset, the new method also confirmed the interaction effect of teaching formats with specific subgroups of learner characteristics. Conclusion: This work introduces a new weighted metric enabling meaningful comparisons between interventions based on a linear transformation. This method will form the basis to intertwine the calculation of test performance closely with the outcome of learning as an important factor reflecting teaching quality and efficacy. Its regular use can improve the transparency of teaching activities and outcomes, contribute to forming rounded judgements of students' acquisition of knowledge and skills and enable valuable feedforward to develop and enhance curricular concepts.