Sean M. Sultaire
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Sean M. Sultaire has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Joshua J. Millspaugh
Wildlife Biology Program W.A. Franke College of Forestry and Conservation, University of Montana Missoula Montana USA
5 shared publicationsRobert A. Montgomery
Institute of Science and Environment University of Cumbria Ambleside UK
5 shared publicationsPatrick J. Jackson
Nevada Department of Wildlife Reno Nevada USA
4 shared publicationsGary J. Roloff
Affiliation Department of Fisheries and Wildlife, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, United States of America
3 shared publications- Jake Verschuyl
National Council for Air and Stream Improvement
3 shared publications - Andrew J. Kroll
Weyerhaeuser Springfield Oregon USA
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (5) , e71422
First Camera Trap Detection of a Gray Wolf Movement Into Nevada
Following gray wolf (Canis lupus) reintroduction to Yellowstone National Park and central Idaho, USA, in the mid‐1990s, the species range has expanded into western Montana, eastern Oregon, and eastern Washington. By 2011, wolves reached northern California and formed multiple packs within a decade of their arrival in the state. Gray wolf observations have been sporadic, however, in the comparatively open and nonforested ecosystems such as the nearby northern Great Basin. During a broad‐scale, camera‐trapping study, we detected a gray wolf on an unbaited camera trap in northwest Nevada. This observation represents the 2nd confirmed sighting of a gray wolf in the state of Nevada since the 1920s and the first documented camera trap detection for the species in the state. We discuss this observation in the context of historical gray wolf presence in Nevada and the potential for the species to establish in the northern Great Basin.
- 8 May 2025
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 15 (5) , e71422
Open AccessFirst Camera Trap Detection of a Gray Wolf Movement Into Nevada
Following gray wolf (Canis lupus) reintroduction to Yellowstone National Park and central Idaho, USA, in the mid‐1990s, the species range has expanded into western Montana, eastern Oregon, and eastern Washington. By 2011, wolves reached northern California and formed multiple packs within a decade of their arrival in the state. Gray wolf observations have been sporadic, however, in the comparatively open and nonforested ecosystems such as the nearby northern Great Basin. During a broad‐scale, camera‐trapping study, we detected a gray wolf on an unbaited camera trap in northwest Nevada. This observation represents the 2nd confirmed sighting of a gray wolf in the state of Nevada since the 1920s and the first documented camera trap detection for the species in the state. We discuss this observation in the context of historical gray wolf presence in Nevada and the potential for the species to establish in the northern Great Basin.
- 12 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (1) , 161-171
Identifying Factors Mediating the Carnivore Richness–Productivity Relationship Across a Precipitation‐Driven Ecotone
Aim: Primary productivity is an important mechanism influencing the species richness of animal taxa such as mammals. However, the factors that mediate the relationship between carnivore species richness, for example, and productivity are not well understood. We examined whether the relationship between carnivore species richness and primary productivity followed a hump‐shaped relationship and explored potential pathways by which productivity influences carnivore communities.Location: Western Great Basin, USA.Methods: We deployed a camera‐trap grid across a strong precipitation—and the corresponding productivity—gradient and estimated carnivore species richness using a novel application of a multisession community occupancy model. To quantify the relationship between carnivore species richness and productivity, we included the linear and quadratic effects of average annual precipitation as covariates on carnivore species richness. We fit additional community models linking carnivore species richness to vegetation and land cover variables to identify factors that mediate the relationship between carnivore richness and productivity.Results: The linear effect of precipitation on carnivore richness was positive and the quadratic effect was negative, supporting the hump‐shaped relationship where richness declines at the highest levels of productivity. Similarly, carnivore species richness followed a quadratic relationship with vegetation height along the productivity gradient. The relationship between carnivore species richness and proportion tree cover was positive, with limited evidence that open vegetation types in the surrounding landscape increased site‐level richness.Main Conclusions: In addition to supporting the notion that primary productivity has a strong and nonlinear influence on local‐scale carnivore species richness, our results suggest that vegetation structure may be an important mediator of this relationship. Although future changes in precipitation and productivity due to climate change are uncertain, our results indicate that targeting areas of intermediate productivity and vegetation height, such as woodlands, may be key for conserving species‐rich carnivore communities along productivity gradients.
- 12 October 2024
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 52 (1) , 161-171
Identifying Factors Mediating the Carnivore Richness–Productivity Relationship Across a Precipitation‐Driven Ecotone
Aim: Primary productivity is an important mechanism influencing the species richness of animal taxa such as mammals. However, the factors that mediate the relationship between carnivore species richness, for example, and productivity are not well understood. We examined whether the relationship between carnivore species richness and primary productivity followed a hump‐shaped relationship and explored potential pathways by which productivity influences carnivore communities.Location: Western Great Basin, USA.Methods: We deployed a camera‐trap grid across a strong precipitation—and the corresponding productivity—gradient and estimated carnivore species richness using a novel application of a multisession community occupancy model. To quantify the relationship between carnivore species richness and productivity, we included the linear and quadratic effects of average annual precipitation as covariates on carnivore species richness. We fit additional community models linking carnivore species richness to vegetation and land cover variables to identify factors that mediate the relationship between carnivore richness and productivity.Results: The linear effect of precipitation on carnivore richness was positive and the quadratic effect was negative, supporting the hump‐shaped relationship where richness declines at the highest levels of productivity. Similarly, carnivore species richness followed a quadratic relationship with vegetation height along the productivity gradient. The relationship between carnivore species richness and proportion tree cover was positive, with limited evidence that open vegetation types in the surrounding landscape increased site‐level richness.Main Conclusions: In addition to supporting the notion that primary productivity has a strong and nonlinear influence on local‐scale carnivore species richness, our results suggest that vegetation structure may be an important mediator of this relationship. Although future changes in precipitation and productivity due to climate change are uncertain, our results indicate that targeting areas of intermediate productivity and vegetation height, such as woodlands, may be key for conserving species‐rich carnivore communities along productivity gradients.
- 12 February 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Mammalogy
- Vol. 105 (2) , 337-347
Range expansion of a declining forest species, the Western Gray Squirrel (Sciurus griseus), into semiarid woodland
Globally, animals that are range-restricted are frequently becoming species of conservation concern, in part due to competitive exclusion by phylogenetically and ecologically similar species that are more tolerant of human disturbance. However, climate and land use changes to natural landscapes can create pockets of refugia for range-restricted species. Western gray squirrels (Sciurus griseus) are native to the west coast of North America, principally California and western Oregon. Over the past several decades, Western Gray Squirrel populations have declined in human-dominated areas, with increased competition from introduced congeneric species native to eastern North America cited as a primary driver. Despite declines in their established range west of the Pacific Crest in western North America, western gray squirrels are extending their range into the Great Basin, where they were not historically found. Using a network of remote camera traps deployed across the Sierra Nevada–Great Basin ecotone in northwestern Nevada, we detected western gray squirrels across 16 of 100 camera-trapping sites. The majority of detections were located in piñon–juniper woodland, a land cover type not previously occupied by this species. Occupancy modeling revealed that western gray squirrels were equally likely to occur in piñon–juniper woodland compared to mature pine forest that they occupy elsewhere in their range. A species distribution model parameterized with historical gray squirrel observations (pre-1950), indicated increased climatic suitability for the species on the eastern side of the Sierra Nevada in recent decades, which may have facilitated this range expansion. Our findings reveal the potential for species declining in their historical range to colonize novel habitats that become increasingly suitable as a result of human-driven changes to ecosystems.
- 12 February 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Mammalogy
- Vol. 105 (2) , 337-347
Range expansion of a declining forest species, the Western Gray Squirrel (Sciurus griseus), into semiarid woodland
Globally, animals that are range-restricted are frequently becoming species of conservation concern, in part due to competitive exclusion by phylogenetically and ecologically similar species that are more tolerant of human disturbance. However, climate and land use changes to natural landscapes can create pockets of refugia for range-restricted species. Western gray squirrels (Sciurus griseus) are native to the west coast of North America, principally California and western Oregon. Over the past several decades, Western Gray Squirrel populations have declined in human-dominated areas, with increased competition from introduced congeneric species native to eastern North America cited as a primary driver. Despite declines in their established range west of the Pacific Crest in western North America, western gray squirrels are extending their range into the Great Basin, where they were not historically found. Using a network of remote camera traps deployed across the Sierra Nevada–Great Basin ecotone in northwestern Nevada, we detected western gray squirrels across 16 of 100 camera-trapping sites. The majority of detections were located in piñon–juniper woodland, a land cover type not previously occupied by this species. Occupancy modeling revealed that western gray squirrels were equally likely to occur in piñon–juniper woodland compared to mature pine forest that they occupy elsewhere in their range. A species distribution model parameterized with historical gray squirrel observations (pre-1950), indicated increased climatic suitability for the species on the eastern side of the Sierra Nevada in recent decades, which may have facilitated this range expansion. Our findings reveal the potential for species declining in their historical range to colonize novel habitats that become increasingly suitable as a result of human-driven changes to ecosystems.
- Open Access
- 31 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 13 (11) , e10658
Spatial patterns of reproduction suggest marginal habitat limits continued range expansion of black bears at a forest‐desert ecotone
Investigating spatial patterns of animal occupancy and reproduction in peripheral populations can provide insight into factors that form species range boundaries. Following historical extirpation, American black bears (Ursus americanus) recolonized the western Great Basin in Nevada from the Sierra Nevada during the late 1900s. This range expansion, however, has not continued further into the Great Basin despite the presence of additional habitat. We aimed to quantify whether reduced reproduction toward the range edge contributes to this range boundary. We analyzed black bear detections from 100 camera traps deployed across black bear distribution in western Nevada using a multistate occupancy model that quantified the probability of occupancy and reproduction (i.e., female bears with cubs occupancy) in relation to changes in habitat type and habitat amount toward the range boundary. We detected a strong effect of habitat amount and habitat type on the probability of black bear occupancy and reproduction. At similar levels of landscape‐scale habitat amount (e.g., 50%), estimated probability of occupancy for adult bears in piñon‐juniper woodlands near the range boundary was 0.39, compared to ~1.0 in Sierra Nevada mixed‐conifer forest (i.e., core habitat). Furthermore, estimated probability of cub occupancy, conditional on adult bear occupancy, in landscapes with 50% habitat was 0.32 in Great Basin piñon‐juniper woodlands, compared to 0.92 in Sierra Nevada mixed‐conifer forest. Black bear range in the western Great Basin conforms to the center–periphery hypothesis, with piñon‐juniper woodland at the range edge supporting ecologically marginal habitat for the species compared to habitat in the Sierra Nevada. Further geographic expansion of black bears in the Great Basin may be limited by lower occupancy of reproducing females in piñon‐juniper woodland. Center–periphery range dynamics may be common in large carnivore species, as their dispersal ability allows them to colonize low‐quality habitat near range edges.
- 31 October 2023
- Published by Wiley in Ecology and Evolution
- Vol. 13 (11) , e10658
Open AccessSpatial patterns of reproduction suggest marginal habitat limits continued range expansion of black bears at a forest‐desert ecotone
Investigating spatial patterns of animal occupancy and reproduction in peripheral populations can provide insight into factors that form species range boundaries. Following historical extirpation, American black bears (Ursus americanus) recolonized the western Great Basin in Nevada from the Sierra Nevada during the late 1900s. This range expansion, however, has not continued further into the Great Basin despite the presence of additional habitat. We aimed to quantify whether reduced reproduction toward the range edge contributes to this range boundary. We analyzed black bear detections from 100 camera traps deployed across black bear distribution in western Nevada using a multistate occupancy model that quantified the probability of occupancy and reproduction (i.e., female bears with cubs occupancy) in relation to changes in habitat type and habitat amount toward the range boundary. We detected a strong effect of habitat amount and habitat type on the probability of black bear occupancy and reproduction. At similar levels of landscape‐scale habitat amount (e.g., 50%), estimated probability of occupancy for adult bears in piñon‐juniper woodlands near the range boundary was 0.39, compared to ~1.0 in Sierra Nevada mixed‐conifer forest (i.e., core habitat). Furthermore, estimated probability of cub occupancy, conditional on adult bear occupancy, in landscapes with 50% habitat was 0.32 in Great Basin piñon‐juniper woodlands, compared to 0.92 in Sierra Nevada mixed‐conifer forest. Black bear range in the western Great Basin conforms to the center–periphery hypothesis, with piñon‐juniper woodland at the range edge supporting ecologically marginal habitat for the species compared to habitat in the Sierra Nevada. Further geographic expansion of black bears in the Great Basin may be limited by lower occupancy of reproducing females in piñon‐juniper woodland. Center–periphery range dynamics may be common in large carnivore species, as their dispersal ability allows them to colonize low‐quality habitat near range edges.
- 2 October 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Forest Ecology and Management
- Vol. 549
Using high-throughput sequencing to investigate summer truffle consumption by chipmunks in relation to retention forestry
- 2 October 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Forest Ecology and Management
- Vol. 549
Using high-throughput sequencing to investigate summer truffle consumption by chipmunks in relation to retention forestry
- 3 January 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Wildlife Management
- Vol. 87 (3)
Black bear density and habitat use variation at the Sierra Nevada‐Great Basin Desert transition
In the first 2 decades of the twenty‐first century, American black bear (Ursus americanus) populations rebounded with range expansions into areas where the species was previously extirpated. While there are a number of factors that limit range expansion, habitat quality and availability are among the most important. Such factors may be particularly important in western Nevada, USA, at the transition zone of the Sierra Nevada and the Great Basin Desert. We deployed a multi‐faceted data collection system including motion‐sensitive cameras, noninvasive hair sampling and genotyping, and global positioning system (GPS) tracking. We analyzed data using spatial capture‐recapture to estimate population density and dynamic occupancy models to estimate habitat use. Black bear habitat use and density were substantially higher in the Sierra Nevada than the Great Basin Desert and had strong positive relationships with the presence of conifer land cover in the transition zone. The average black bear density was >4 times higher in the mixed‐conifer forests of the Sierra Nevada (12.4 bears/100 km2) than in desert mountain ranges with piñon (Pinus monophylla)‐juniper (Juniperus spp.) woodland (2.7 bears/100 km2). The low‐elevation shrub and grassland portions of the study area had even lower estimated black bear density (0.6 bears/100 km2) and probability of use (0.03, 95% CI = 0.00–0.09). Across these spatially variable configurations in black bear density, we estimated the population size to be 418 individuals (95% CI = 239–740). Declining density towards the range edge, coupled with a relatively stable range of black bears in Nevada observed since 2000, suggests that further species range expansion into the western Great Basin may be limited by habitat quality and availability.
- 3 January 2023
- Published by Wiley in The Journal of Wildlife Management
- Vol. 87 (3)
Black bear density and habitat use variation at the Sierra Nevada‐Great Basin Desert transition
In the first 2 decades of the twenty‐first century, American black bear (Ursus americanus) populations rebounded with range expansions into areas where the species was previously extirpated. While there are a number of factors that limit range expansion, habitat quality and availability are among the most important. Such factors may be particularly important in western Nevada, USA, at the transition zone of the Sierra Nevada and the Great Basin Desert. We deployed a multi‐faceted data collection system including motion‐sensitive cameras, noninvasive hair sampling and genotyping, and global positioning system (GPS) tracking. We analyzed data using spatial capture‐recapture to estimate population density and dynamic occupancy models to estimate habitat use. Black bear habitat use and density were substantially higher in the Sierra Nevada than the Great Basin Desert and had strong positive relationships with the presence of conifer land cover in the transition zone. The average black bear density was >4 times higher in the mixed‐conifer forests of the Sierra Nevada (12.4 bears/100 km2) than in desert mountain ranges with piñon (Pinus monophylla)‐juniper (Juniperus spp.) woodland (2.7 bears/100 km2). The low‐elevation shrub and grassland portions of the study area had even lower estimated black bear density (0.6 bears/100 km2) and probability of use (0.03, 95% CI = 0.00–0.09). Across these spatially variable configurations in black bear density, we estimated the population size to be 418 individuals (95% CI = 239–740). Declining density towards the range edge, coupled with a relatively stable range of black bears in Nevada observed since 2000, suggests that further species range expansion into the western Great Basin may be limited by habitat quality and availability.
- Open Access
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Wildlife Biology
- Vol. 2023 (2)
The influence of fine‐scale topography on detection of a mammal assemblage at camera traps in a mountainous landscape
Changes in topography, such as terrain elevation and slope, are an important source of landscape complexity influencing the ecology of animals, particularly in mountainous landscapes. In such landscapes animals navigate changes in elevation and slope in their daily movement. Despite the importance of topographic variation, studies of animal ecology in mountainous landscapes tend not to explicitly consider those effects on species detection. We deployed a broad‐extent, coarse resolution camera‐trapping system across a landscape with considerable complexity and quantified the influence of topographic variables on detection probability conditional on occurrence for multiple mammal species. Specifically, we examined the fine‐scale effects of terrain steepness and topographic position (i.e. ridges, mid‐slopes or valleys) on detection probability for 14 mammal species at camera‐traps. We found that detection probability increased on gently sloping terrain for six species and decreased on the steepest slopes sampled for three of these species and three additional species. Among four other mammal species, detection probability changed according to local topographic position though the directionality of these responses varied among these species. Several species, primarily meso‐carnivores as well as larger‐bodied species, like mule deer and black bears, were more detectable on gentle slopes than flat terrain. This pattern suggests that many species may use moderately steep terrain for the resources or heterogeneity they provide. Topographic position had comparatively less effect on species detection probabilities, suggesting that this variable does not have a strong effect on fine‐scale space use of animal species in mountainous regions. These relationships suggest that researchers should consider local terrain when siting camera traps in mountainous landscapes and analyzing survey data from such landscapes. Studies that compare the detection of mammal species at cameras deployed in close proximity will improve our understanding of fine‐scale topographic effects on mammal movement and detection.
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Wildlife Biology
- Vol. 2023 (2)
Open AccessThe influence of fine‐scale topography on detection of a mammal assemblage at camera traps in a mountainous landscape
Changes in topography, such as terrain elevation and slope, are an important source of landscape complexity influencing the ecology of animals, particularly in mountainous landscapes. In such landscapes animals navigate changes in elevation and slope in their daily movement. Despite the importance of topographic variation, studies of animal ecology in mountainous landscapes tend not to explicitly consider those effects on species detection. We deployed a broad‐extent, coarse resolution camera‐trapping system across a landscape with considerable complexity and quantified the influence of topographic variables on detection probability conditional on occurrence for multiple mammal species. Specifically, we examined the fine‐scale effects of terrain steepness and topographic position (i.e. ridges, mid‐slopes or valleys) on detection probability for 14 mammal species at camera‐traps. We found that detection probability increased on gently sloping terrain for six species and decreased on the steepest slopes sampled for three of these species and three additional species. Among four other mammal species, detection probability changed according to local topographic position though the directionality of these responses varied among these species. Several species, primarily meso‐carnivores as well as larger‐bodied species, like mule deer and black bears, were more detectable on gentle slopes than flat terrain. This pattern suggests that many species may use moderately steep terrain for the resources or heterogeneity they provide. Topographic position had comparatively less effect on species detection probabilities, suggesting that this variable does not have a strong effect on fine‐scale space use of animal species in mountainous regions. These relationships suggest that researchers should consider local terrain when siting camera traps in mountainous landscapes and analyzing survey data from such landscapes. Studies that compare the detection of mammal species at cameras deployed in close proximity will improve our understanding of fine‐scale topographic effects on mammal movement and detection.
- Open Access
- 31 August 2022
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 17 (8) , e0273630
Short-term responses of small mammal diversity to varying stand-scale patterns of retention tree patches
Retention forestry is a common practice for biodiversity conservation in forests managed for wood production. Retention forestry often leaves unharvested patches of trees that vary in size and spatial pattern but experiments evaluating the effects of different retention patch configurations at a constant level of retention are lacking for many regions and taxonomic groups. We implemented an experimental study in clearcut conifer stands with retention across the U.S. Pacific Northwest region. The study consisted of five stand-level (11–55 ha) experimental treatments each replicated 10 times within a randomized complete block design, resulting in 50 treated stands. Retained tree density was comparable across treatments but size, number, and location (upland or riparian) of patches within stands varied among the five treatments. Within experimental treatments, we measured small mammal (<1kg) species and functional trait (i.e., body size, diet, activity stratum) richness in retention patches, surrounding harvested portions of stands, and nearby unharvested stands. We evaluated species and functional trait richness by treatment using generalized linear mixed-effects models and species-specific responses to retention placement using a community occupancy model. We obtained repeat captures of 21 species of small mammals but found limited evidence of a treatment effect on species richness, and no differences in functional trait richness. Species richness was highest where all retained trees were aggregated into one patch placed adjacent to a forested riparian buffer (mean = 6.6 species, 95% CI = 5.7–7.5), and lowest in the treatment containing one retention patch in the upland portion of a harvested stand (mean = 4.7 species, 95% CI = 3.8–5.6). Furthermore, estimates of species richness within retention patches of harvested stands (i.e., not considering species in harvested areas) did not differ among treatments, indicating that the slightly elevated species richness in riparian-associated retention results from 1–2 species in these patches that do not occur in adjacent harvested portions of each treated stand. Patch occupancy of several species was higher in riparian patches than harvested portions of the treated stands, and fewer species had higher occupancy in upland patches compared to harvested portions of treated stands. Our results indicated that at retention densities currently required in Oregon and Washington, the location of retention patches had a small influence on stand-scale measures of small mammal diversity, but local increases in species richness may be obtained by retaining trees adjacent to riparian buffers.
- 31 August 2022
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 17 (8) , e0273630
Open AccessShort-term responses of small mammal diversity to varying stand-scale patterns of retention tree patches
Retention forestry is a common practice for biodiversity conservation in forests managed for wood production. Retention forestry often leaves unharvested patches of trees that vary in size and spatial pattern but experiments evaluating the effects of different retention patch configurations at a constant level of retention are lacking for many regions and taxonomic groups. We implemented an experimental study in clearcut conifer stands with retention across the U.S. Pacific Northwest region. The study consisted of five stand-level (11–55 ha) experimental treatments each replicated 10 times within a randomized complete block design, resulting in 50 treated stands. Retained tree density was comparable across treatments but size, number, and location (upland or riparian) of patches within stands varied among the five treatments. Within experimental treatments, we measured small mammal (<1kg) species and functional trait (i.e., body size, diet, activity stratum) richness in retention patches, surrounding harvested portions of stands, and nearby unharvested stands. We evaluated species and functional trait richness by treatment using generalized linear mixed-effects models and species-specific responses to retention placement using a community occupancy model. We obtained repeat captures of 21 species of small mammals but found limited evidence of a treatment effect on species richness, and no differences in functional trait richness. Species richness was highest where all retained trees were aggregated into one patch placed adjacent to a forested riparian buffer (mean = 6.6 species, 95% CI = 5.7–7.5), and lowest in the treatment containing one retention patch in the upland portion of a harvested stand (mean = 4.7 species, 95% CI = 3.8–5.6). Furthermore, estimates of species richness within retention patches of harvested stands (i.e., not considering species in harvested areas) did not differ among treatments, indicating that the slightly elevated species richness in riparian-associated retention results from 1–2 species in these patches that do not occur in adjacent harvested portions of each treated stand. Patch occupancy of several species was higher in riparian patches than harvested portions of the treated stands, and fewer species had higher occupancy in upland patches compared to harvested portions of treated stands. Our results indicated that at retention densities currently required in Oregon and Washington, the location of retention patches had a small influence on stand-scale measures of small mammal diversity, but local increases in species richness may be obtained by retaining trees adjacent to riparian buffers.
- 18 November 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 49 (1) , 66-78
Spatial variation in bioclimatic relationships for a snow‐adapted species along a discontinuous southern range boundary
Aim: Variation in the relationship between variables across space, known as spatial non‐stationarity, is a common phenomenon in ecology. Species distribution models (SDMs), however, typically assume stationarity in species–environment relationships across space. Spatial non‐stationarity may be particularly apparent in populations along range boundaries where species are actively adapting to changes in climate, and geographically isolated areas where isolation can facilitate adaptation. We used data collected from the southern range boundary of a winter‐adapted mammal to evaluate spatially varying environmental relationships in a region with a geographically isolated population.Taxon: Lepus americanus.Location: Laurentian Great Lakes region, USA.Methods: We surveyed 320 sites for snowshoe hares near their regional southern range boundary. We related snowshoe hare occurrence to short‐term climate variables (snow cover duration, maximum temperature and their interaction) with a spatially explicit model that allowed the effect of climate variables on snowshoe hare occurrence to vary spatially.Results: We found highest support for an SDM that incorporated geographic barriers when estimating spatial effects, in addition to spatially varying effects of maximum temperate, snow cover duration and their interaction. Hares were more likely to occupy sites with longer snow cover duration but the influence of temperature was more variable. Increasing temperature in northern portions of our study area had a positive influence on hare occurrence, but exhibited a negative relationship along the southern range boundary.Main Conclusions: We provide a robust evaluation of stationarity assumptions in bioclimatic relationships and highlight spatially variable relationships between a cold‐adapted species and short‐term climate variables across a range boundary. However, spatial non‐stationarity was not most apparent across dispersal barriers but coincided with differences in the relationship between climate variables across space. Our study provides evidence that the distribution of a winter‐adapted species is strongly constrained by snow cover, but prevailing temperature modulates the strength of this relationship across space.
- 18 November 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Biogeography
- Vol. 49 (1) , 66-78
Spatial variation in bioclimatic relationships for a snow‐adapted species along a discontinuous southern range boundary
Aim: Variation in the relationship between variables across space, known as spatial non‐stationarity, is a common phenomenon in ecology. Species distribution models (SDMs), however, typically assume stationarity in species–environment relationships across space. Spatial non‐stationarity may be particularly apparent in populations along range boundaries where species are actively adapting to changes in climate, and geographically isolated areas where isolation can facilitate adaptation. We used data collected from the southern range boundary of a winter‐adapted mammal to evaluate spatially varying environmental relationships in a region with a geographically isolated population.Taxon: Lepus americanus.Location: Laurentian Great Lakes region, USA.Methods: We surveyed 320 sites for snowshoe hares near their regional southern range boundary. We related snowshoe hare occurrence to short‐term climate variables (snow cover duration, maximum temperature and their interaction) with a spatially explicit model that allowed the effect of climate variables on snowshoe hare occurrence to vary spatially.Results: We found highest support for an SDM that incorporated geographic barriers when estimating spatial effects, in addition to spatially varying effects of maximum temperate, snow cover duration and their interaction. Hares were more likely to occupy sites with longer snow cover duration but the influence of temperature was more variable. Increasing temperature in northern portions of our study area had a positive influence on hare occurrence, but exhibited a negative relationship along the southern range boundary.Main Conclusions: We provide a robust evaluation of stationarity assumptions in bioclimatic relationships and highlight spatially variable relationships between a cold‐adapted species and short‐term climate variables across a range boundary. However, spatial non‐stationarity was not most apparent across dispersal barriers but coincided with differences in the relationship between climate variables across space. Our study provides evidence that the distribution of a winter‐adapted species is strongly constrained by snow cover, but prevailing temperature modulates the strength of this relationship across space.
- Open Access
Effects of varying retention tree patterns on ground beetle (Coleoptera: Carabidae) taxonomic and functional diversity
Managing forests intensively for timber production can homogenize forest structure and, in turn, alter species richness and functional composition of native species communities. Retention forestry, the practice of retaining structural elements during timber harvest, can increase species diversity in recently harvested forests, but its effect on functional trait diversity is less understood. We used a broad‐scale, replicated experiment to evaluate the effect of five tree retention patterns on species and functional trait diversity of ground beetles (Family: Carabidae) within early‐seral production forests in the Pacific Northwest, USA. We found no evidence for differences in carabid species or functional trait richness among treatments when considering species present in retention patches and adjacent clear‐cuts. However, we found evidence for lower taxonomic and functional trait variation between carabid communities present in retention patches and those present in clear‐cut areas of stands when retention was allocated to several small patches. Lower levels of functional trait variation in stands with several small patches were due to specialized predators found less often in small retention patches than in aggregated or riparian retention patches. Our findings indicate that relative to single large or riparian‐associated patches, small retention patches functioned similarly to clear‐cuts within harvested forests and several small patches did not increase species or functional trait richness. At current levels of retention in the region, allocation of trees to a single upland patch or split between riparian and upland patches can increase variation in ground beetle taxonomic and functional composition within harvested forests.
Open AccessEffects of varying retention tree patterns on ground beetle (Coleoptera: Carabidae) taxonomic and functional diversity
Managing forests intensively for timber production can homogenize forest structure and, in turn, alter species richness and functional composition of native species communities. Retention forestry, the practice of retaining structural elements during timber harvest, can increase species diversity in recently harvested forests, but its effect on functional trait diversity is less understood. We used a broad‐scale, replicated experiment to evaluate the effect of five tree retention patterns on species and functional trait diversity of ground beetles (Family: Carabidae) within early‐seral production forests in the Pacific Northwest, USA. We found no evidence for differences in carabid species or functional trait richness among treatments when considering species present in retention patches and adjacent clear‐cuts. However, we found evidence for lower taxonomic and functional trait variation between carabid communities present in retention patches and those present in clear‐cut areas of stands when retention was allocated to several small patches. Lower levels of functional trait variation in stands with several small patches were due to specialized predators found less often in small retention patches than in aggregated or riparian retention patches. Our findings indicate that relative to single large or riparian‐associated patches, small retention patches functioned similarly to clear‐cuts within harvested forests and several small patches did not increase species or functional trait richness. At current levels of retention in the region, allocation of trees to a single upland patch or split between riparian and upland patches can increase variation in ground beetle taxonomic and functional composition within harvested forests.