Sarah A. Brands
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Sarah A. Brands has a total of 161 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jorick S. Vink
Armagh Observatory, College Hill
11 shared publications - P. A. Crowther
Astrophysics Research Cluster, School of Mathematical and Physical Sciences, University of Sheffield , Hicks Building, Hounsfield Road, Sheffield S3 7RH
9 shared publications - Andreas A. C. Sander
Zentrum für Astronomie der Universität Heidelberg
8 shared publications - Calum Hawcroft
Space Telescope Science Institute
7 shared publications - Frank Backs
Institute of Astronomy, KU Leuven
7 shared publications - Hugues Sana
Institute of Astronomy
7 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 10 June 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 710, A166
X-shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context . Our limited understanding of the winds of massive stars hampers our ability to predict their evolution. We currently often rely on mass-loss rate prescriptions that show strong features that lack a firm empirical confirmation, such as the bi-stability jump. This bi-stability jump is a pronounced increase in mass loss in the decreasing temperature regime T eff ~28–21 kK, i.e., spectral types B1-B2. Different prescriptions also give different metallicity dependences; these sometimes include a dependence on effective temperature, luminosity or both, that may also differ among prescriptions. Although recent papers have compared empirical results to prescriptions, a large observational sample of B stars for which the wind has been scrutinised over different metallicity ranges is still lacking. Aims . Through the modelling of both ultraviolet (from the ULLYSES programme) and optical (from the XShootU programme) high-resolution spectra, we determined the stellar and wind parameters, including detailed clumping parameters, of 24 SMC B stars ranging in T eff from 13 to 29 kK. By combining this sample with LMC studies, we compared the wind behaviour of B stars in two different metallicity regimes. We compared our results to common mass-loss rate prescriptions to test features present in these models and their metallicity dependence. Methods . We have used the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and the genetic algorithm code Kiwi-GA to fit the UV and optical spectra simultaneously. This allows us to determine wind properties including clumping behaviour. Results . The moderate to strong metallicity trends present in the mass-loss prescriptions ( Ṁ ∝ Z 0.41–1.4 ) explored here overestimate the empirical metallicity dependence in the B-star regime, which appears very weak. Similarly to a previous study of B supergiants in the LMC, we do not find a sudden increase in mass-loss rate at approximately spectral type B1, but only a weak temperature trend. As in this LMC study, we show that on average around 40% of the wind mass is located in the wind medium between the clumps. Using other studies from this paper series, we compiled a sample of 80+ O and B stars in the SMC and LMC. From a comparison we find a clear difference in O- and B-type metallicity dependence. Conclusions . The apparent lack of a bi-stability jump in the B-star regime and a very weak metallicity dependence for the same stars offers new empirical constraints to theoretical models of line-driven winds. As differences between these models are large (reaching orders of magnitude in parts of parameter space) such constraints are much needed. More studies exploring the mass-loss rates of B stars and cooler objects will be helpful to our understanding of hot star winds.
- 10 June 2026
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 710, A166
Open AccessX-shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context . Our limited understanding of the winds of massive stars hampers our ability to predict their evolution. We currently often rely on mass-loss rate prescriptions that show strong features that lack a firm empirical confirmation, such as the bi-stability jump. This bi-stability jump is a pronounced increase in mass loss in the decreasing temperature regime T eff ~28–21 kK, i.e., spectral types B1-B2. Different prescriptions also give different metallicity dependences; these sometimes include a dependence on effective temperature, luminosity or both, that may also differ among prescriptions. Although recent papers have compared empirical results to prescriptions, a large observational sample of B stars for which the wind has been scrutinised over different metallicity ranges is still lacking. Aims . Through the modelling of both ultraviolet (from the ULLYSES programme) and optical (from the XShootU programme) high-resolution spectra, we determined the stellar and wind parameters, including detailed clumping parameters, of 24 SMC B stars ranging in T eff from 13 to 29 kK. By combining this sample with LMC studies, we compared the wind behaviour of B stars in two different metallicity regimes. We compared our results to common mass-loss rate prescriptions to test features present in these models and their metallicity dependence. Methods . We have used the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and the genetic algorithm code Kiwi-GA to fit the UV and optical spectra simultaneously. This allows us to determine wind properties including clumping behaviour. Results . The moderate to strong metallicity trends present in the mass-loss prescriptions ( Ṁ ∝ Z 0.41–1.4 ) explored here overestimate the empirical metallicity dependence in the B-star regime, which appears very weak. Similarly to a previous study of B supergiants in the LMC, we do not find a sudden increase in mass-loss rate at approximately spectral type B1, but only a weak temperature trend. As in this LMC study, we show that on average around 40% of the wind mass is located in the wind medium between the clumps. Using other studies from this paper series, we compiled a sample of 80+ O and B stars in the SMC and LMC. From a comparison we find a clear difference in O- and B-type metallicity dependence. Conclusions . The apparent lack of a bi-stability jump in the B-star regime and a very weak metallicity dependence for the same stars offers new empirical constraints to theoretical models of line-driven winds. As differences between these models are large (reaching orders of magnitude in parts of parameter space) such constraints are much needed. More studies exploring the mass-loss rates of B stars and cooler objects will be helpful to our understanding of hot star winds.
- Open Access
- 19 August 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 700, A186
Evolutionary models for the very massive stars in the R136 cluster of 30 Doradus in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Context. The cluster Radcliffe 136 in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) contains a population of stars in excess of 100 M⊙, including the most massive star known, R136a1. Very massive stars (VMSs) play an influential role in feedback processes and may potentially produce exotic supernova (SN) types and black holes of tens of solar masses. Aims. The evolutionary history and final fate of the three most luminous stars, R136a1, R136a2, and R136a3, continues to be a puzzling issue. We aim to resolve this using dedicated stellar evolution models. Methods. We computed rotating single-star MESA models and applied observationally constrained mass-loss rates during the early evolution and new theoretical Wolf-Rayet-type rates once the surface becomes enriched in helium. We considered various scenarios for internal angular momentum (AM) transport. We produced interpolated model grids and applied a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analysis to compare our models with observations. Results. The nature of SN progenitors strongly depends on mass loss and the AM coupling schemes. We predict no pair-instability and no gamma-ray burst progenitors from our fiducial model grid at LMC metallicity. The onset of Wolf-Rayet-type mass-loss rates on the main sequence leads to a rapid decrease in stellar mass and luminosity. The initially most massive model (800 M⊙) loses mass the most rapidly and becomes less massive than the initially least massive model (100 M⊙) in our grid. This mass turnover implies that the evolutionary history can only be inferred if additional constraints are available. We utilised the surface helium abundance, which poses a conundrum: R136a1, the most luminous star, is less enriched in helium than R136a2 and R136a3. We propose that this can be explained if both R136a2 and R136a3 were initially more massive than R136a1. From a rigorous confrontation of our models to spectroscopically derived observables, we estimate an initial mass of 346 ± 42 M⊙ for R136a1, and ≳500 M⊙ for R136a2 and R136a3. Conclusions. Even though VMSs are only present in the youngest clusters below 2 Myr of age, our study demonstrates the greater strength of their role in local and galaxy evolution. At the LMC metallicity, they will be observable as helium-enriched massive stars after their drastic mass loss, produced via single-star evolution. If the core collapse leads to a SN, it will be of Type Ib/c.
- 19 August 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 700, A186
Open AccessEvolutionary models for the very massive stars in the R136 cluster of 30 Doradus in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Context. The cluster Radcliffe 136 in the Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) contains a population of stars in excess of 100 M⊙, including the most massive star known, R136a1. Very massive stars (VMSs) play an influential role in feedback processes and may potentially produce exotic supernova (SN) types and black holes of tens of solar masses. Aims. The evolutionary history and final fate of the three most luminous stars, R136a1, R136a2, and R136a3, continues to be a puzzling issue. We aim to resolve this using dedicated stellar evolution models. Methods. We computed rotating single-star MESA models and applied observationally constrained mass-loss rates during the early evolution and new theoretical Wolf-Rayet-type rates once the surface becomes enriched in helium. We considered various scenarios for internal angular momentum (AM) transport. We produced interpolated model grids and applied a Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) analysis to compare our models with observations. Results. The nature of SN progenitors strongly depends on mass loss and the AM coupling schemes. We predict no pair-instability and no gamma-ray burst progenitors from our fiducial model grid at LMC metallicity. The onset of Wolf-Rayet-type mass-loss rates on the main sequence leads to a rapid decrease in stellar mass and luminosity. The initially most massive model (800 M⊙) loses mass the most rapidly and becomes less massive than the initially least massive model (100 M⊙) in our grid. This mass turnover implies that the evolutionary history can only be inferred if additional constraints are available. We utilised the surface helium abundance, which poses a conundrum: R136a1, the most luminous star, is less enriched in helium than R136a2 and R136a3. We propose that this can be explained if both R136a2 and R136a3 were initially more massive than R136a1. From a rigorous confrontation of our models to spectroscopically derived observables, we estimate an initial mass of 346 ± 42 M⊙ for R136a1, and ≳500 M⊙ for R136a2 and R136a3. Conclusions. Even though VMSs are only present in the youngest clusters below 2 Myr of age, our study demonstrates the greater strength of their role in local and galaxy evolution. At the LMC metallicity, they will be observable as helium-enriched massive stars after their drastic mass loss, produced via single-star evolution. If the core collapse leads to a SN, it will be of Type Ib/c.
- Open Access
- 26 May 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 698, A9
The wind properties of O-type stars at sub-SMC metallicity
Context. Powerful radiation-driven winds heavily influence the evolution and end-of-life products of massive stars. Feedback processes from these winds strongly impact the thermal and dynamical properties of the interstellar medium of their host galaxies. The dependence of mass loss on stellar properties is poorly understood, particularly at low metallicity (Z). Aims. We aim to characterise global, photospheric, and wind properties of hot massive stars in Local Group dwarf galaxies with metal contents below that of the Small Magellanic Cloud and to compare our findings to theories of radiation-driven winds. Methods. We performed quantitative optical and ultraviolet spectroscopy on a sample of 11 O-type stars in nearby dwarf galaxies with Z < 0.2 Z⊙. We used the stellar atmosphere code FASTWIND in combination with the genetic algorithm KIWI-GA to determine the stellar and wind parameters. Clumpy structures present in the wind outflow were assumed to be optically thin. Results. The winds of the sample stars are very weak, with mass loss rates of ∼10−9−10−7 M⊙ yr−1. Such feeble winds can only be constrained if ultraviolet spectra are available. The modified wind momentum as a function of luminosity (L) for stars in this Z regime is in agreement with extrapolations to lower Z of a recently established empirical relation for this quantity as a function of both L and Z. However, theoretical prescriptions do not match our results nor those of other recent analyses at low luminosity (L ≲ 105.2 L⊙) and low Z. In this regime, they predict winds that are stronger by an order of magnitude or more. Conclusions. For our sample stars at Z ∼ 0.14 Z⊙ with masses ∼30−50 M⊙, stellar winds strip only a small amount of mass during the bulk of the main-sequence evolution. However, if the steep dependence of mass loss on luminosity found here also holds for (so far undiscovered) much more massive stars at these metallicities, these more massive stars may suffer (almost) as severely from main-sequence mass stripping as well-known very massive stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud and Milky Way.
- 26 May 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 698, A9
Open AccessThe wind properties of O-type stars at sub-SMC metallicity
Context. Powerful radiation-driven winds heavily influence the evolution and end-of-life products of massive stars. Feedback processes from these winds strongly impact the thermal and dynamical properties of the interstellar medium of their host galaxies. The dependence of mass loss on stellar properties is poorly understood, particularly at low metallicity (Z). Aims. We aim to characterise global, photospheric, and wind properties of hot massive stars in Local Group dwarf galaxies with metal contents below that of the Small Magellanic Cloud and to compare our findings to theories of radiation-driven winds. Methods. We performed quantitative optical and ultraviolet spectroscopy on a sample of 11 O-type stars in nearby dwarf galaxies with Z < 0.2 Z⊙. We used the stellar atmosphere code FASTWIND in combination with the genetic algorithm KIWI-GA to determine the stellar and wind parameters. Clumpy structures present in the wind outflow were assumed to be optically thin. Results. The winds of the sample stars are very weak, with mass loss rates of ∼10−9−10−7 M⊙ yr−1. Such feeble winds can only be constrained if ultraviolet spectra are available. The modified wind momentum as a function of luminosity (L) for stars in this Z regime is in agreement with extrapolations to lower Z of a recently established empirical relation for this quantity as a function of both L and Z. However, theoretical prescriptions do not match our results nor those of other recent analyses at low luminosity (L ≲ 105.2 L⊙) and low Z. In this regime, they predict winds that are stronger by an order of magnitude or more. Conclusions. For our sample stars at Z ∼ 0.14 Z⊙ with masses ∼30−50 M⊙, stellar winds strip only a small amount of mass during the bulk of the main-sequence evolution. However, if the steep dependence of mass loss on luminosity found here also holds for (so far undiscovered) much more massive stars at these metallicities, these more massive stars may suffer (almost) as severely from main-sequence mass stripping as well-known very massive stars in the Large Magellanic Cloud and Milky Way.
- Open Access
- 16 May 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 697, A54
X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. Mass loss governs the evolution of massive stars and shapes the stellar surroundings. To quantify the impact of the stellar winds, we need to know the exact mass-loss rates; however, empirical constraints on the rates are hampered by limited knowledge of their small-scale wind structure, also referred to as ‘wind clumping’. Aims. We aim to improve empirical constraints on the mass loss of massive stars by investigating the clumping properties of their winds, in particular, the relation between stellar parameters and wind structure. Methods. We analysed the optical and ultraviolet spectra of 25 O-type giants and supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud, using the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and a genetic algorithm. We derived the stellar and wind parameters, including detailed clumping properties, such as the amount of clumping, the density of the interclump medium, velocity–porosity of the medium, and wind turbulence. Results. We obtained stellar and wind parameters for 24 of our sample stars and found that the winds are highly clumped, with an average clumping factor of 〈fcl〉 = 33 14, an interclump density factor of 〈fic〉 = 0.2 0.1, and moderate-to-strong velocity-porosity effects of 〈fvel〉 = 0.6 0.2. The scatter around the average values of the wind-structure parameters is large. With the exception of a significant, positive correlation between the interclump density factor and mass loss, we find no dependence of clumping parameters on the mass-loss rate or stellar properties. Conclusions. In the luminosity range we investigate here, the empirical and theoretical mass-loss rates both have a scatter of about 0.5 dex (or a factor 3). Within this uncertainty, the empirical rates and theoretical predictions are in agreement. The origin of the scatter of the empirically inferred mass-loss rates requires further investigation. It is possible that our description of wind clumping is still not sufficient to capture effects of the structured wind, which could contribute to the scatter.
- 16 May 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 697, A54
Open AccessX-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. Mass loss governs the evolution of massive stars and shapes the stellar surroundings. To quantify the impact of the stellar winds, we need to know the exact mass-loss rates; however, empirical constraints on the rates are hampered by limited knowledge of their small-scale wind structure, also referred to as ‘wind clumping’. Aims. We aim to improve empirical constraints on the mass loss of massive stars by investigating the clumping properties of their winds, in particular, the relation between stellar parameters and wind structure. Methods. We analysed the optical and ultraviolet spectra of 25 O-type giants and supergiants in the Large Magellanic Cloud, using the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and a genetic algorithm. We derived the stellar and wind parameters, including detailed clumping properties, such as the amount of clumping, the density of the interclump medium, velocity–porosity of the medium, and wind turbulence. Results. We obtained stellar and wind parameters for 24 of our sample stars and found that the winds are highly clumped, with an average clumping factor of 〈fcl〉 = 33 14, an interclump density factor of 〈fic〉 = 0.2 0.1, and moderate-to-strong velocity-porosity effects of 〈fvel〉 = 0.6 0.2. The scatter around the average values of the wind-structure parameters is large. With the exception of a significant, positive correlation between the interclump density factor and mass loss, we find no dependence of clumping parameters on the mass-loss rate or stellar properties. Conclusions. In the luminosity range we investigate here, the empirical and theoretical mass-loss rates both have a scatter of about 0.5 dex (or a factor 3). Within this uncertainty, the empirical rates and theoretical predictions are in agreement. The origin of the scatter of the empirically inferred mass-loss rates requires further investigation. It is possible that our description of wind clumping is still not sufficient to capture effects of the structured wind, which could contribute to the scatter.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 695, A198
X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. The proximity and low dust extinction of the Magellanic Clouds provides an ideal environment for metal-poor massive stars to be studied in detail. The Hubble Space Telescope ULLYSES initiative has provided exquisite ultraviolet spectroscopy of a large sample of OB stars in the Magellanic Clouds, and its legacy value has been enhanced through the acquisition of optical VLT/XShooter spectroscopy (XShootU). Aims. We aim to determine the spectral types and physical properties of 122 LMC and 103 SMC OB stars observed via XShootU. Physical parameters are required for these to serve as templates in spectral libraries of metal-poor massive stars. We also aim to identify double-lined binaries and OeBe stars for which analysis requires non-standard treatment. Methods. We have applied a pipeline designed to analyse large spectroscopic samples of hot luminous stars to XShootU spectroscopic datasets, together with grids of synthetic model spectra computed with the non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium atmospheric code FASTWIND at LMC and SMC metallicities. Results. We have determined physical and wind properties of 97 LMC and 77 SMC massive stars, ranging from O2 to B9 subtypes, representing the majority of the XShootU OB sample (OeBe and candidate SB2 systems are excluded). Results are broadly in agreement with previous optical spectroscopic studies, with evolutionary masses spanning 12–117 M⊙ in the LMC and 11–74 M⊙ in the SMC. We have determined a revised Teff-spectral type calibration for Magellanic Cloud stars, identified stars with peculiar radial velocities, and compared wind properties of high luminosity O stars with dense winds, revealing ∼ 0.27 dex higher wind momenta of LMC stars with respect to SMC counterparts. Incorporating the recent empirical metallicity dependence of Z0.22 for wind velocities, this suggests a mass-loss dependence of Z0.5 for luminous O stars. Studies incorporating ultraviolet mass-loss diagnostics are required for OB stars with weak winds and/or low luminosities.
- 21 March 2025
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 695, A198
Open AccessX-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. The proximity and low dust extinction of the Magellanic Clouds provides an ideal environment for metal-poor massive stars to be studied in detail. The Hubble Space Telescope ULLYSES initiative has provided exquisite ultraviolet spectroscopy of a large sample of OB stars in the Magellanic Clouds, and its legacy value has been enhanced through the acquisition of optical VLT/XShooter spectroscopy (XShootU). Aims. We aim to determine the spectral types and physical properties of 122 LMC and 103 SMC OB stars observed via XShootU. Physical parameters are required for these to serve as templates in spectral libraries of metal-poor massive stars. We also aim to identify double-lined binaries and OeBe stars for which analysis requires non-standard treatment. Methods. We have applied a pipeline designed to analyse large spectroscopic samples of hot luminous stars to XShootU spectroscopic datasets, together with grids of synthetic model spectra computed with the non-Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium atmospheric code FASTWIND at LMC and SMC metallicities. Results. We have determined physical and wind properties of 97 LMC and 77 SMC massive stars, ranging from O2 to B9 subtypes, representing the majority of the XShootU OB sample (OeBe and candidate SB2 systems are excluded). Results are broadly in agreement with previous optical spectroscopic studies, with evolutionary masses spanning 12–117 M⊙ in the LMC and 11–74 M⊙ in the SMC. We have determined a revised Teff-spectral type calibration for Magellanic Cloud stars, identified stars with peculiar radial velocities, and compared wind properties of high luminosity O stars with dense winds, revealing ∼ 0.27 dex higher wind momenta of LMC stars with respect to SMC counterparts. Incorporating the recent empirical metallicity dependence of Z0.22 for wind velocities, this suggests a mass-loss dependence of Z0.5 for luminous O stars. Studies incorporating ultraviolet mass-loss diagnostics are required for OB stars with weak winds and/or low luminosities.
- Open Access
X-Shooting ULLYSES: massive stars at low metallicity: XII. The clumped winds of O-type (super)giants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Mass loss governs the evolution of massive stars and shapes the stellar surroundings. To quantify the impact of the stellar winds we need to know the exact mass-loss rates; however, empirical constraints on the rates are hampered by limited knowledge of their small-scale wind structure or 'wind clumping'. We aim to improve empirical constraints on the mass loss of massive stars by investigating the clumping properties of their winds, in particular the relation between stellar parameters and wind structure. We analyse the optical and ultraviolet spectra of 25 O-type (super)giants in the LMC, using the model atmosphere code Fastwind and a genetic algorithm. We derive stellar and wind parameters including detailed clumping properties, such as the amount of clumping, the density of the interclump medium, velocity-porosity of the medium, and wind turbulence. We obtain stellar and wind parameters for 24 of our sample stars and find that the winds are highly clumped, with an average clumping factor of $f_{\rm cl}=33\pm14$, an interclump density factor of $f_{\rm ic}=0.2\pm0.1$, and moderate to strong velocity-porosity effects. The scatter around the average values of the wind-structure parameters is large. With the exception of a significant, positive correlation between the interclump density factor and mass loss, we find no dependence of clumping parameters on either mass-loss rate or stellar properties. In the luminosity range that we investigate, the empirical and theoretical mass-loss rates both have a scatter of about 0.5~dex, or a factor 3. Within this uncertainty, the empirical rates and the theoretical predictions agree. The origin of the scatter of the empirical mass-loss rates requires further investigation. It is possible that our description of wind clumping is still not sufficient to capture effects of the structured wind; this could contribute to the scatter.Open AccessX-Shooting ULLYSES: massive stars at low metallicity: XII. The clumped winds of O-type (super)giants in the Large Magellanic Cloud
Mass loss governs the evolution of massive stars and shapes the stellar surroundings. To quantify the impact of the stellar winds we need to know the exact mass-loss rates; however, empirical constraints on the rates are hampered by limited knowledge of their small-scale wind structure or 'wind clumping'. We aim to improve empirical constraints on the mass loss of massive stars by investigating the clumping properties of their winds, in particular the relation between stellar parameters and wind structure. We analyse the optical and ultraviolet spectra of 25 O-type (super)giants in the LMC, using the model atmosphere code Fastwind and a genetic algorithm. We derive stellar and wind parameters including detailed clumping properties, such as the amount of clumping, the density of the interclump medium, velocity-porosity of the medium, and wind turbulence. We obtain stellar and wind parameters for 24 of our sample stars and find that the winds are highly clumped, with an average clumping factor of $f_{\rm cl}=33\pm14$, an interclump density factor of $f_{\rm ic}=0.2\pm0.1$, and moderate to strong velocity-porosity effects. The scatter around the average values of the wind-structure parameters is large. With the exception of a significant, positive correlation between the interclump density factor and mass loss, we find no dependence of clumping parameters on either mass-loss rate or stellar properties. In the luminosity range that we investigate, the empirical and theoretical mass-loss rates both have a scatter of about 0.5~dex, or a factor 3. Within this uncertainty, the empirical rates and the theoretical predictions agree. The origin of the scatter of the empirical mass-loss rates requires further investigation. It is possible that our description of wind clumping is still not sufficient to capture effects of the structured wind; this could contribute to the scatter. - Open Access
- 4 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A88
X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. Mass loss through a stellar wind is an important physical process that steers the evolution of massive stars and controls the properties of their end-of-life products, such as the supernova type and the mass of compact remnants. To probe its role in stellar evolution over cosmic time, mass loss needs to be studied as function of metallicity. For mass loss to be accurately quantified, the wind structure needs to be established jointly with the characteristics of small-scale inhomogeneities in the outflow, which are known as wind clumping. Aims. We aim to improve empirical estimates of mass loss and wind clumping for hot main-sequence massive stars, study the dependence of both properties on the metal content, and compare the theoretical predictions of mass loss as a function of metallicity to our findings. Methods. Using the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and the genetic algorithm fitting method KIWI-GA, we analyzed the optical and ultraviolet spectra of 13 O-type giant to supergiant stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud galaxy, which has a metallicity of approximately one-fifth of that of the Sun. We quantified the stellar global outflow properties, such as the mass-loss rate and terminal wind velocity, and the wind clumping properties. To probe the role of metallicity, our findings were compared to studies of Galactic and Large Magellanic Cloud samples that were analyzed with similar methods, including the description of clumping. Results. We find significant variations in the wind clumping properties of the target stars, with clumping starting at flow velocities 0.01–0.23 of the terminal wind velocity and reaching clumping factors fcl = 2–30. In the luminosity (log L/L⊙ = 5.0–6.0) and metallicity (Z/Z⊙ = 0.2–1) range we considered, we find that the scaling of the mass loss M˙ with metallicity Z varies with luminosity. At log L/L⊙ = 5.75, we find M˙ ∝ Zm with m = 1.02 ± 0.30, in agreement with pioneering work in the field within the uncertainties. For lower luminosities, however, we obtain a significantly steeper scaling of m > 2. Conclusions. The monotonically decreasing m(L) behavior adds a complexity to the functional description of the mass-loss rate of hot massive stars. Although the trend is present in the predictions, it is much weaker than we found here. However, the luminosity range for which m is significantly larger than previously assumed (at log L/L⊙ ≲ 5.4) is still poorly explored, and more studies are needed to thoroughly map the empirical behavior, in particular, at Galactic metallicity.
- 4 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A88
Open AccessX-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. Mass loss through a stellar wind is an important physical process that steers the evolution of massive stars and controls the properties of their end-of-life products, such as the supernova type and the mass of compact remnants. To probe its role in stellar evolution over cosmic time, mass loss needs to be studied as function of metallicity. For mass loss to be accurately quantified, the wind structure needs to be established jointly with the characteristics of small-scale inhomogeneities in the outflow, which are known as wind clumping. Aims. We aim to improve empirical estimates of mass loss and wind clumping for hot main-sequence massive stars, study the dependence of both properties on the metal content, and compare the theoretical predictions of mass loss as a function of metallicity to our findings. Methods. Using the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and the genetic algorithm fitting method KIWI-GA, we analyzed the optical and ultraviolet spectra of 13 O-type giant to supergiant stars in the Small Magellanic Cloud galaxy, which has a metallicity of approximately one-fifth of that of the Sun. We quantified the stellar global outflow properties, such as the mass-loss rate and terminal wind velocity, and the wind clumping properties. To probe the role of metallicity, our findings were compared to studies of Galactic and Large Magellanic Cloud samples that were analyzed with similar methods, including the description of clumping. Results. We find significant variations in the wind clumping properties of the target stars, with clumping starting at flow velocities 0.01–0.23 of the terminal wind velocity and reaching clumping factors fcl = 2–30. In the luminosity (log L/L⊙ = 5.0–6.0) and metallicity (Z/Z⊙ = 0.2–1) range we considered, we find that the scaling of the mass loss M˙ with metallicity Z varies with luminosity. At log L/L⊙ = 5.75, we find M˙ ∝ Zm with m = 1.02 ± 0.30, in agreement with pioneering work in the field within the uncertainties. For lower luminosities, however, we obtain a significantly steeper scaling of m > 2. Conclusions. The monotonically decreasing m(L) behavior adds a complexity to the functional description of the mass-loss rate of hot massive stars. Although the trend is present in the predictions, it is much weaker than we found here. However, the luminosity range for which m is significantly larger than previously assumed (at log L/L⊙ ≲ 5.4) is still poorly explored, and more studies are needed to thoroughly map the empirical behavior, in particular, at Galactic metallicity.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A91
X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive Stars at low metallicity
Context. Current implementations of mass loss for hot, massive stars in stellar evolution models usually include a sharp increase in mass loss when blue supergiants become cooler than Teff ∼ 20 − 22 kK. Such a drastic mass-loss jump has traditionally been motivated by the potential presence of a so-called bistability ionisation effect, which may occur for line-driven winds in this temperature region due to recombination of important line-driving ions. Aims. We perform quantitative spectroscopy using UV (ULLYSES program) and optical (XShootU collaboration) data for 17 OB-supergiant stars in the LMC (covering the range Teff ∼ 14 − 32 kK), deriving absolute constraints on global stellar, wind, and clumping parameters. We examine whether there are any empirical signs of a mass-loss jump in the investigated region, and we study the clumped nature of the wind. Methods. We used a combination of the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and the genetic algorithm (GA) code Kiwi-GA to fit synthetic spectra of a multitude of diagnostic spectral lines in the optical and UV. Results. We find an almost monotonic decrease of mass-loss rate with effective temperature, with no signs of any upward mass loss jump anywhere in the examined region. Standard theoretical comparison models, which include a strong bistability jump thus severely overpredict the empirical mass-loss rates on the cool side of the predicted jump. Another key result is that across our sample we find that on average about 40% of the total wind mass seems to reside in the more diluted medium in between dense clumps. Conclusions. Our derived mass-loss rates suggest that for applications such as stellar evolution one should not include a drastic bistability jump in mass loss for stars in the temperature and luminosity region investigated here. The derived high values of interclump density further suggest that the common assumption of an effectively void interclump medium (applied in the vast majority of spectroscopic studies of hot star winds) is not generally valid in this parameter regime.
- 4 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A91
Open AccessX-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive Stars at low metallicity
Context. Current implementations of mass loss for hot, massive stars in stellar evolution models usually include a sharp increase in mass loss when blue supergiants become cooler than Teff ∼ 20 − 22 kK. Such a drastic mass-loss jump has traditionally been motivated by the potential presence of a so-called bistability ionisation effect, which may occur for line-driven winds in this temperature region due to recombination of important line-driving ions. Aims. We perform quantitative spectroscopy using UV (ULLYSES program) and optical (XShootU collaboration) data for 17 OB-supergiant stars in the LMC (covering the range Teff ∼ 14 − 32 kK), deriving absolute constraints on global stellar, wind, and clumping parameters. We examine whether there are any empirical signs of a mass-loss jump in the investigated region, and we study the clumped nature of the wind. Methods. We used a combination of the model atmosphere code FASTWIND and the genetic algorithm (GA) code Kiwi-GA to fit synthetic spectra of a multitude of diagnostic spectral lines in the optical and UV. Results. We find an almost monotonic decrease of mass-loss rate with effective temperature, with no signs of any upward mass loss jump anywhere in the examined region. Standard theoretical comparison models, which include a strong bistability jump thus severely overpredict the empirical mass-loss rates on the cool side of the predicted jump. Another key result is that across our sample we find that on average about 40% of the total wind mass seems to reside in the more diluted medium in between dense clumps. Conclusions. Our derived mass-loss rates suggest that for applications such as stellar evolution one should not include a drastic bistability jump in mass loss for stars in the temperature and luminosity region investigated here. The derived high values of interclump density further suggest that the common assumption of an effectively void interclump medium (applied in the vast majority of spectroscopic studies of hot star winds) is not generally valid in this parameter regime.
- Open Access
- 4 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A89
X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. With the aim of understanding massive stars and their feedback in the early epochs of our Universe, the ULLYSES and XShootU collaborations collected the biggest homogeneous dataset of high-quality hot star spectra at low metallicity. Within the rich “zoo” of massive star stellar types, B supergiants (BSGs) represent an important connection between the main sequence and more extreme evolutionary stages. Additionally, lying toward the cool end of the hot star regime, determining their wind properties is crucial to gauging our expectations on the evolution and feedback of massive stars as, for instance, they are implicated in the bi-stability jump phenomenon. Aims. Here, we undertake a detailed analysis of a representative sample of 18 Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) BSGs within the ULLYSES dataset. Our UV and optical analysis samples early- and late-type BSGs (from B0 to B8), covering the bi-stability jump region. Our aim is to evaluate their evolutionary status and verify what their wind properties say about the bi-stability jump at a low-metallicity environment. Methods. We used the stellar atmosphere code CMFGEN to model the UV and optical spectra of the sample BSGs as well as photometry in different bands. The optical range encodes photospheric properties, while the wind information resides mostly in the UV. Further, we compare our results with different evolutionary models, with previous determinations in the literature of OB stars, and with diverging mass-loss prescriptions at the bi-stability jump. Additionally, for the first time we provide BSG models in the SMC including X-rays. Results. Our analysis yielded the following main results: (i) From a single-stellar evolution perspective, the evolutionary status of early BSGs appear less clear than late BSGs, which are agree reasonably well with H-shell burning models. (ii) Ultraviolet analysis shows evidence that the BSGs contain X-rays in their atmospheres, for which we provide constraints. In general, higher X-ray luminosity (close to the standard log(LX/L) ~ −7) is favored for early BSGs, despite associated degeneracies. For later-type BSGs, lower values are preferred, log(LX/L) ~ −8.5. (iii) The obtained mass-loss rates suggest neither a jump nor an unperturbed monotonic decrease with temperature. Instead, a rather constant trend appears to happen, which is at odds with the increase found for Galactic BSGs. (iv) The wind velocity behavior with temperature shows a sharp drop at ~19 kK, very similar to the bi-stability jump observed for Galactic stars.
- 4 December 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 692, A89
Open AccessX-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive stars at low metallicity
Context. With the aim of understanding massive stars and their feedback in the early epochs of our Universe, the ULLYSES and XShootU collaborations collected the biggest homogeneous dataset of high-quality hot star spectra at low metallicity. Within the rich “zoo” of massive star stellar types, B supergiants (BSGs) represent an important connection between the main sequence and more extreme evolutionary stages. Additionally, lying toward the cool end of the hot star regime, determining their wind properties is crucial to gauging our expectations on the evolution and feedback of massive stars as, for instance, they are implicated in the bi-stability jump phenomenon. Aims. Here, we undertake a detailed analysis of a representative sample of 18 Small Magellanic Cloud (SMC) BSGs within the ULLYSES dataset. Our UV and optical analysis samples early- and late-type BSGs (from B0 to B8), covering the bi-stability jump region. Our aim is to evaluate their evolutionary status and verify what their wind properties say about the bi-stability jump at a low-metallicity environment. Methods. We used the stellar atmosphere code CMFGEN to model the UV and optical spectra of the sample BSGs as well as photometry in different bands. The optical range encodes photospheric properties, while the wind information resides mostly in the UV. Further, we compare our results with different evolutionary models, with previous determinations in the literature of OB stars, and with diverging mass-loss prescriptions at the bi-stability jump. Additionally, for the first time we provide BSG models in the SMC including X-rays. Results. Our analysis yielded the following main results: (i) From a single-stellar evolution perspective, the evolutionary status of early BSGs appear less clear than late BSGs, which are agree reasonably well with H-shell burning models. (ii) Ultraviolet analysis shows evidence that the BSGs contain X-rays in their atmospheres, for which we provide constraints. In general, higher X-ray luminosity (close to the standard log(LX/L) ~ −7) is favored for early BSGs, despite associated degeneracies. For later-type BSGs, lower values are preferred, log(LX/L) ~ −8.5. (iii) The obtained mass-loss rates suggest neither a jump nor an unperturbed monotonic decrease with temperature. Instead, a rather constant trend appears to happen, which is at odds with the increase found for Galactic BSGs. (iv) The wind velocity behavior with temperature shows a sharp drop at ~19 kK, very similar to the bi-stability jump observed for Galactic stars.
- Open Access
- 2 October 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 690, A113
Properties of intermediate- to high-mass stars in the young cluster M17
Context. The outcome of the formation of massive stars is an important anchor point in the formation and evolution process of these stars. It provides insight into the physics of the assembly process, and sets the conditions for stellar evolution. For massive stars, the outcome of formation is rarely observed because the processes involved unfold deep down in highly extincted molecular clouds. Aims. We characterize a population of highly reddened stars in the very young massive star-forming region M17. The group of 18 O4.5 to B9 stars constitutes one of the best samples of almost zero-age main-sequence (ZAMS) high- and intermediate-mass stars. Their properties allow us to identify the empirical location of the ZAMS of massive stars, and the rotation and mass-loss rate of stars close to or at the onset of core-hydrogen burning. Methods. We performed quantitative spectroscopic modeling of a uniform set of over 100 spectral features in optical VLT/X-shooter spectra using the nonlocal thermal equilibrium stellar atmosphere code FASTWIND and a fitting approach based on a genetic algorithm, KIWI-GA. The spectral energy distributions of photometric observations were used to determine the line-of-sight extinction. From a comparison of their positions in the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram with MIST evolutionary tracks, we inferred the stellar masses and ages. Results. We find an age of 0.4−0.2+0.6 Myr for our sample, however we also identify a strong relation between the age and the mass of the stars. All sources are highly reddened, with AV ranging from 3.6 to 10.6 mag. The sample can be subdivided into two groups. Stars more massive than 10 M⊙ have reached the ZAMS. Their projected ZAMS spin rate distribution extends to 0.3 of the critical velocity; their mass-loss rates agree with those of other main-sequence O and early-B stars. Stars with a mass in the range 3 < M/M⊙ < 7 are still on the pre-main sequence (PMS), and some of them have circumstellar disks. Evolving their υ sin i to the ZAMS assuming angular momentum conservation yields values up to ~0.6 υcrit. For PMS stars without disks, we find tentative mass-loss rates up to 10−8.5 M⊙ yr−1. The total-to-selective extinction RV is higher for PMS stars with disks than for the remainder of the sample. Conclusions. We constrain the empirical location of the ZAMS for massive (10 < M/M⊙ < 50) stars and find it to agree with its location in MIST evolutionary tracks. The ZAMS rotation rates for intermediate-mass stars are twice as high as for massive stars, suggesting that the angular momentum gain processes differ between the two groups. The relation between the age and mass of the stars suggests a lag in the formation of more massive stars relative to lower mass stars. Taking the derived mass-loss rates at face value, stellar winds are already initiated in the PMS phase. The PMS-star winds are found to be substantially more powerful than indicated by predictions for line-driven outflows.
- 2 October 2024
- Published by EDP Sciences in Astronomy & Astrophysics
- Vol. 690, A113
Open AccessProperties of intermediate- to high-mass stars in the young cluster M17
Context. The outcome of the formation of massive stars is an important anchor point in the formation and evolution process of these stars. It provides insight into the physics of the assembly process, and sets the conditions for stellar evolution. For massive stars, the outcome of formation is rarely observed because the processes involved unfold deep down in highly extincted molecular clouds. Aims. We characterize a population of highly reddened stars in the very young massive star-forming region M17. The group of 18 O4.5 to B9 stars constitutes one of the best samples of almost zero-age main-sequence (ZAMS) high- and intermediate-mass stars. Their properties allow us to identify the empirical location of the ZAMS of massive stars, and the rotation and mass-loss rate of stars close to or at the onset of core-hydrogen burning. Methods. We performed quantitative spectroscopic modeling of a uniform set of over 100 spectral features in optical VLT/X-shooter spectra using the nonlocal thermal equilibrium stellar atmosphere code FASTWIND and a fitting approach based on a genetic algorithm, KIWI-GA. The spectral energy distributions of photometric observations were used to determine the line-of-sight extinction. From a comparison of their positions in the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram with MIST evolutionary tracks, we inferred the stellar masses and ages. Results. We find an age of 0.4−0.2+0.6 Myr for our sample, however we also identify a strong relation between the age and the mass of the stars. All sources are highly reddened, with AV ranging from 3.6 to 10.6 mag. The sample can be subdivided into two groups. Stars more massive than 10 M⊙ have reached the ZAMS. Their projected ZAMS spin rate distribution extends to 0.3 of the critical velocity; their mass-loss rates agree with those of other main-sequence O and early-B stars. Stars with a mass in the range 3 < M/M⊙ < 7 are still on the pre-main sequence (PMS), and some of them have circumstellar disks. Evolving their υ sin i to the ZAMS assuming angular momentum conservation yields values up to ~0.6 υcrit. For PMS stars without disks, we find tentative mass-loss rates up to 10−8.5 M⊙ yr−1. The total-to-selective extinction RV is higher for PMS stars with disks than for the remainder of the sample. Conclusions. We constrain the empirical location of the ZAMS for massive (10 < M/M⊙ < 50) stars and find it to agree with its location in MIST evolutionary tracks. The ZAMS rotation rates for intermediate-mass stars are twice as high as for massive stars, suggesting that the angular momentum gain processes differ between the two groups. The relation between the age and mass of the stars suggests a lag in the formation of more massive stars relative to lower mass stars. Taking the derived mass-loss rates at face value, stellar winds are already initiated in the PMS phase. The PMS-star winds are found to be substantially more powerful than indicated by predictions for line-driven outflows.