Rebecca Ker Loh
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Rebecca Ker Loh has a total of 56 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Nalini Puniamoorthy
Department of Biological Sciences, https://dx.doi.org/37580National University of Singapore, 16 Science Drive 4, Singapore 117558, Singapore
4 shared publications - Darren C. J. Yeo
Department of Biological Sciences, Faculty of Science, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore
3 shared publications - Rudolf Meier
Center for Integrative Biodiversity Discovery, Leibniz Institute for Evolution and Biodiversity Science, Museum fur Naturkunde, Invalidenstrasse 43, 10115 Berlin, Germany
3 shared publications - Sujatha Narayanan Kutty
Tropical Marine Science Institute National University of Singapore Singapore City Singapore
3 shared publications - Ivan Neo
National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore
2 shared publications - Ming Kai Tan
Lee Kong Chian Natural History Museum, Faculty of Science, National University of Singapore, Singapore, Singapore
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology Resources
- Vol. 26 (5) , e70151
Using Metabarcoding Techniques to Map Multiple Dung Beetle‐Vertebrate iDNA Networks in a Southeast Asian Forest
Given the high levels of endemism, diversity, and increasing anthropogenic impacts in tropical regions, studies on species interactions and ecological networks are urgently needed to understand community responses to environmental change. Increasingly, molecular methods are used to monitor biodiversity and identify species interactions. In this study, we developed an optimised DNA metabarcoding protocol to construct quantitative dung beetle‐vertebrate trophic networks in a heterogenous tropical forest. We show that while the highest probability of detection is within 3 h of feeding, vertebrate DNA can still be detected in most beetles after 24 h, including around 50% of beetles with visually empty guts. Using the vertebrate taxa detected from DNA in the gut contents, we constructed dung beetle‐vertebrate networks across 50 forest sites. Our networks displayed high trophic generalism and nestedness. By using group‐specific primers, we documented interactions between dung beetles and multiple vertebrate species, including amphibians, birds, and rare mammals, such as the Sunda slow loris and Sunda pangolin. Our optimised molecular techniques contribute towards the development of new methods for comprehensive biodiversity assessments and ecological network studies that are urgently needed to monitor biodiversity in the hyper‐diverse tropics.
- 9 June 2026
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology Resources
- Vol. 26 (5) , e70151
Open AccessUsing Metabarcoding Techniques to Map Multiple Dung Beetle‐Vertebrate iDNA Networks in a Southeast Asian Forest
Given the high levels of endemism, diversity, and increasing anthropogenic impacts in tropical regions, studies on species interactions and ecological networks are urgently needed to understand community responses to environmental change. Increasingly, molecular methods are used to monitor biodiversity and identify species interactions. In this study, we developed an optimised DNA metabarcoding protocol to construct quantitative dung beetle‐vertebrate trophic networks in a heterogenous tropical forest. We show that while the highest probability of detection is within 3 h of feeding, vertebrate DNA can still be detected in most beetles after 24 h, including around 50% of beetles with visually empty guts. Using the vertebrate taxa detected from DNA in the gut contents, we constructed dung beetle‐vertebrate networks across 50 forest sites. Our networks displayed high trophic generalism and nestedness. By using group‐specific primers, we documented interactions between dung beetles and multiple vertebrate species, including amphibians, birds, and rare mammals, such as the Sunda slow loris and Sunda pangolin. Our optimised molecular techniques contribute towards the development of new methods for comprehensive biodiversity assessments and ecological network studies that are urgently needed to monitor biodiversity in the hyper‐diverse tropics.
- 20 April 2026
- Published by Magnolia Press in Zootaxa
- Vol. 5796 (1) , 51-79
Revision of the wingless pygmy grasshopper Potua Bolívar, 1887 (Orthoptera: Tetrigidae) from Southeast Asia
Potua Bolívar, 1887, a genus currently assigned to Xerophyllini (Cladonotinae), requires taxonomic revision because its type species, P. coronata Bolívar, 1887, is poorly defined. It exhibits huge variability in the pronotum among type specimens and longstanding confusion with P. morbillosa (Walker, 1871). To resolve the issue, we performed morphometric analyses and sequenced a fragment of the cytochrome oxidase subunit I (COI) gene to reassess species boundaries. Integrating the morphological and genetic data, we synonymise P. coronata Bolívar, 1887, syn. nov. with P. morbillosa (Walker, 1871) and prove that specimens with different pronotal morphology, previously regarded as intraspecific variations, represent different species. Genetic variations within each morphotype are also very low. Here, we describe three new species—P. bulbosa Muhammad, Adžić & Tan, sp. nov. from the Malay Peninsula; P. kinabalu Muhammad & Tan, sp. nov.; and P. sepilok Tan & Muhammad, sp. nov. from Borneo. We also provide an annotated diagnostic table to distinguish each of the four species from Southeast Asia.
- 20 April 2026
- Published by Magnolia Press in Zootaxa
- Vol. 5796 (1) , 51-79
Revision of the wingless pygmy grasshopper Potua Bolívar, 1887 (Orthoptera: Tetrigidae) from Southeast Asia
Potua Bolívar, 1887, a genus currently assigned to Xerophyllini (Cladonotinae), requires taxonomic revision because its type species, P. coronata Bolívar, 1887, is poorly defined. It exhibits huge variability in the pronotum among type specimens and longstanding confusion with P. morbillosa (Walker, 1871). To resolve the issue, we performed morphometric analyses and sequenced a fragment of the cytochrome oxidase subunit I (COI) gene to reassess species boundaries. Integrating the morphological and genetic data, we synonymise P. coronata Bolívar, 1887, syn. nov. with P. morbillosa (Walker, 1871) and prove that specimens with different pronotal morphology, previously regarded as intraspecific variations, represent different species. Genetic variations within each morphotype are also very low. Here, we describe three new species—P. bulbosa Muhammad, Adžić & Tan, sp. nov. from the Malay Peninsula; P. kinabalu Muhammad & Tan, sp. nov.; and P. sepilok Tan & Muhammad, sp. nov. from Borneo. We also provide an annotated diagnostic table to distinguish each of the four species from Southeast Asia.
- Open Access
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 8 (2) , e70274
Advancing Environmental DNA Applications in Southeast Asia Through Networking, Adaptable Standard Development, and Capacity Building
Environmental DNA (eDNA) has become a transformative tool for biodiversity monitoring and conservation across Southeast Asia, one of the world's most critical biodiversity hotspots. Despite its potential, several factors hinder the adoption and scalability of eDNA tools in the region. In this perspective paper for the special issue “Understanding the Current Use of Environmental DNA in Southeast Asia: Promoting Accessibility through Networking and Capacity Building,” we synthesize our insights as eDNA researchers and end‐users across the region to identify key challenges and highlight opportunities for enhanced regional networking, capacity building, and collaboration. Key challenges we identified include limited resources, the lack of standardized protocols, particularly in the context of metabarcoding, and the lack of training in eDNA data analysis. Hurdles such as outdated infrastructure, expensive reagents and equipment costs, logistical barriers, and limited bioinformatics expertise also persist. Furthermore, initiatives to advance and standardize eDNA methods, protocols, and technologies are often led by the Global North, which may neglect to account for Southeast Asia's distinct ecological landscape and resource challenges. Based on these insights, our key recommendations include the development of regional eDNA laboratories, the creation of adaptable standards that reflect the region's wide range of biodiversity and environmental conditions, investment in eDNA training, and building local bioinformatics expertise. We also highlight major themes such as the need for adaptive standards, regional collaboration, and potentially repurposing COVID‐19 surveillance infrastructure for eDNA studies, demonstrating how existing molecular platforms can be leveraged for biodiversity monitoring. By aligning regional efforts with global standards while addressing local needs, researchers in Southeast Asia can maximize the potential of eDNA for biodiversity conservation and ecological research. Future eDNA research in Southeast Asia will depend on continued innovation, collaboration, and the development of methodologies tailored to the region's unique biodiversity.
- 1 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 8 (2) , e70274
Open AccessAdvancing Environmental DNA Applications in Southeast Asia Through Networking, Adaptable Standard Development, and Capacity Building
Environmental DNA (eDNA) has become a transformative tool for biodiversity monitoring and conservation across Southeast Asia, one of the world's most critical biodiversity hotspots. Despite its potential, several factors hinder the adoption and scalability of eDNA tools in the region. In this perspective paper for the special issue “Understanding the Current Use of Environmental DNA in Southeast Asia: Promoting Accessibility through Networking and Capacity Building,” we synthesize our insights as eDNA researchers and end‐users across the region to identify key challenges and highlight opportunities for enhanced regional networking, capacity building, and collaboration. Key challenges we identified include limited resources, the lack of standardized protocols, particularly in the context of metabarcoding, and the lack of training in eDNA data analysis. Hurdles such as outdated infrastructure, expensive reagents and equipment costs, logistical barriers, and limited bioinformatics expertise also persist. Furthermore, initiatives to advance and standardize eDNA methods, protocols, and technologies are often led by the Global North, which may neglect to account for Southeast Asia's distinct ecological landscape and resource challenges. Based on these insights, our key recommendations include the development of regional eDNA laboratories, the creation of adaptable standards that reflect the region's wide range of biodiversity and environmental conditions, investment in eDNA training, and building local bioinformatics expertise. We also highlight major themes such as the need for adaptive standards, regional collaboration, and potentially repurposing COVID‐19 surveillance infrastructure for eDNA studies, demonstrating how existing molecular platforms can be leveraged for biodiversity monitoring. By aligning regional efforts with global standards while addressing local needs, researchers in Southeast Asia can maximize the potential of eDNA for biodiversity conservation and ecological research. Future eDNA research in Southeast Asia will depend on continued innovation, collaboration, and the development of methodologies tailored to the region's unique biodiversity.
- Open Access
- 30 October 2025
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in ZooKeys
- Vol. 1257, 305-326
First DNA barcodes and morphometric analysis of Singaporean Tetrigidae (Orthoptera, Caelifera) support color variations as intraspecific polymorphism through integrative taxonomy
Integrative taxonomy refers to the practice of incorporating multiple lines of evidence, including morphology and genetics, to delineate species. While both morphology and genetic markers, such as the Cytochrome c oxidase subunit I ( COI ), have been widely applied in insect taxonomy, their use remains limited in the taxonomic studies of pygmy grasshoppers (Orthoptera: Tetrigidae). Currently, DNA barcodes for tetrigids, especially from Southeast Asia, remain scarce. This limitation is especially pressing given the extensive color variation documented in pygmy grasshoppers, which has rarely been systematically tested to determine whether such variation represents intraspecific polymorphisms or species differences. Historically, color polymorphism has even led to erroneous species delimitation. In this study, we examined taxa from Singapore previously reported to exhibit color variation and applied an integrative taxonomic framework to investigate whether these morphs represent intraspecific polymorphism or species-level differences. Our analyses combined morphometrics of 22 characters with principal component analyses, and DNA barcoding using short gene fragments of COI and small ribosomal RNA subunit III ( 12S ). We focused on four taxa: two morphospecies of Coptotettix , Loxilobus insidiosus (Bolívar, 1887), and Thoradonta nodulosa (Stål, 1861). DNA barcoding revealed that color morphs are genetically similar, and morphometric analysis likewise showed no distinct clustering. Together, these results indicate that different color morphs indeed represent intraspecific polymorphisms. More importantly, we demonstrate that combining molecular data with morphological evidence offers an effective, integrative framework for resolving taxonomic challenges within tetrigids and highlights the value of integrative approaches for clarifying species boundaries in morphologically variable taxa.
- 30 October 2025
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in ZooKeys
- Vol. 1257, 305-326
Open AccessFirst DNA barcodes and morphometric analysis of Singaporean Tetrigidae (Orthoptera, Caelifera) support color variations as intraspecific polymorphism through integrative taxonomy
Integrative taxonomy refers to the practice of incorporating multiple lines of evidence, including morphology and genetics, to delineate species. While both morphology and genetic markers, such as the Cytochrome c oxidase subunit I ( COI ), have been widely applied in insect taxonomy, their use remains limited in the taxonomic studies of pygmy grasshoppers (Orthoptera: Tetrigidae). Currently, DNA barcodes for tetrigids, especially from Southeast Asia, remain scarce. This limitation is especially pressing given the extensive color variation documented in pygmy grasshoppers, which has rarely been systematically tested to determine whether such variation represents intraspecific polymorphisms or species differences. Historically, color polymorphism has even led to erroneous species delimitation. In this study, we examined taxa from Singapore previously reported to exhibit color variation and applied an integrative taxonomic framework to investigate whether these morphs represent intraspecific polymorphism or species-level differences. Our analyses combined morphometrics of 22 characters with principal component analyses, and DNA barcoding using short gene fragments of COI and small ribosomal RNA subunit III ( 12S ). We focused on four taxa: two morphospecies of Coptotettix , Loxilobus insidiosus (Bolívar, 1887), and Thoradonta nodulosa (Stål, 1861). DNA barcoding revealed that color morphs are genetically similar, and morphometric analysis likewise showed no distinct clustering. Together, these results indicate that different color morphs indeed represent intraspecific polymorphisms. More importantly, we demonstrate that combining molecular data with morphological evidence offers an effective, integrative framework for resolving taxonomic challenges within tetrigids and highlights the value of integrative approaches for clarifying species boundaries in morphologically variable taxa.
- Open Access
- 22 May 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Environmental Management
- Vol. 387, 125777
Physical properties of food waste influence the efficiency of black soldier fly larvae bioconversion via microbial activity
- 22 May 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Environmental Management
- Vol. 387, 125777
Open AccessPhysical properties of food waste influence the efficiency of black soldier fly larvae bioconversion via microbial activity
- Open Access
Evolution under Domestication: Genetic differentiation in black soldier fly ( Hermetia illucens ) populations subjected to recent selective breeding
The black soldier fly (BSF; Hermetia illucens ) is widely utilized in commercial and research applications for waste bioconversion and sustainable protein production. However, prolonged captivity and artificial selection can shape genetic diversity, potentially influencing adaptability and long-term population stability. This study examined how recent selective breeding, genetic drift, and relaxed selection have influenced genetic differentiation in BSF populations over a short timeframe. Using mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase I ( CO1 ) and genome-wide RAD sequencing, population structure, heterozygosity, and selection signatures across eleven BSF populations, including selectively bred, wild-derived, and commercial strains were analysed. Results revealed that rapid genetic shifts have occurred within selectively bred populations (LA to LE) over ∼5 years, driven by artificial selection, subsequent relaxation, and environmental adaptation. The decline in effective population size (Ne) observed post-COVID-19 suggests recent bottlenecks, which may have further contributed to genetic drift and differentiation. While domesticated populations exhibited reduced genetic diversity and signs of inbreeding, wild-type population under short captivity retained higher heterozygosity. Genome-wide analyses further identified adaptive divergence among populations, with balancing selection and selective sweeps shaping genetic variation. Notably, despite shared ancestry, genetic differentiation persisted in selectively bred populations, reinforcing that selection and environmental pressures continue to influence their genomic landscape even after targeted selection was relaxed. These findings underscore the need to monitor genetic diversity in BSF breeding programs to maintain adaptability, enhance resilience, and mitigate risks from artificial selection and population collapse.
Open AccessEvolution under Domestication: Genetic differentiation in black soldier fly ( Hermetia illucens ) populations subjected to recent selective breeding
The black soldier fly (BSF; Hermetia illucens ) is widely utilized in commercial and research applications for waste bioconversion and sustainable protein production. However, prolonged captivity and artificial selection can shape genetic diversity, potentially influencing adaptability and long-term population stability. This study examined how recent selective breeding, genetic drift, and relaxed selection have influenced genetic differentiation in BSF populations over a short timeframe. Using mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase I ( CO1 ) and genome-wide RAD sequencing, population structure, heterozygosity, and selection signatures across eleven BSF populations, including selectively bred, wild-derived, and commercial strains were analysed. Results revealed that rapid genetic shifts have occurred within selectively bred populations (LA to LE) over ∼5 years, driven by artificial selection, subsequent relaxation, and environmental adaptation. The decline in effective population size (Ne) observed post-COVID-19 suggests recent bottlenecks, which may have further contributed to genetic drift and differentiation. While domesticated populations exhibited reduced genetic diversity and signs of inbreeding, wild-type population under short captivity retained higher heterozygosity. Genome-wide analyses further identified adaptive divergence among populations, with balancing selection and selective sweeps shaping genetic variation. Notably, despite shared ancestry, genetic differentiation persisted in selectively bred populations, reinforcing that selection and environmental pressures continue to influence their genomic landscape even after targeted selection was relaxed. These findings underscore the need to monitor genetic diversity in BSF breeding programs to maintain adaptability, enhance resilience, and mitigate risks from artificial selection and population collapse.
- Open Access
- 7 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (2) , 264-281
Toward eDNA‐based bioassessment of freshwater reservoirs with small volumes of water: Robust molecular protocols
Bioassessment of freshwater quality with eDNA is a powerful alternative to traditional methods involving collecting, sorting, and identifying metazoan taxa with morphology (e.g., macroinvertebrates). Particularly attractive for routine monitoring would be an eDNA method that uses a remote‐controlled boat for collecting small volumes of water without filtration in order to simplify sampling. Such a method would not likely capture eDNA signals for all metazoan species, but may nevertheless allow for cost‐effective, and frequent monitoring of water quality, which is important for tropical waterbodies that require year‐round surveillance. We here optimize a molecular protocol for capturing metazoan signatures based on eDNA obtained from 15 ml of water. To test the robustness of the method, we used samples from two tropical reservoirs with known differences in water quality to optimize molecular procedures so that they yield repeatable results. Each reservoir was sampled at three sites (“biological replicates”) and each water sample was subsampled twice before extracting the eDNA using ethanol precipitation for both subsamples (“technical replicates”). We then tested how much DNA (0.1 ng to 15 ng) and how many PCR cycles (25 or 35) minimized the variance of the metazoan eDNA signal between biological and technical replicates. For this purpose, we amplified a 313 bp COI minibarcode using a universal metazoan primer pair. We found that regardless of template amounts or PCR cycle numbers, the eDNA signatures for both reservoirs were distinct because only 17 of 59 mOTUs (mainly planktonic crustaceans and rotifers) were shared. We also found that template amounts between 0.5 and 15 ng yielded overall similar results, but the use of 35 PCR cycles significantly depressed the number of detected species (p‐value < 0.05). Fortunately, the differences between the detected metazoan community of the reservoirs were so strong that all biological and technical replicates could be assigned unambiguously to their source reservoir although the variance between technical replicates remained high for all PCR experiments (Bray‐Curtis dissimilarity: 5%–20%; Jaccard distance: 10%–40%).
- 7 December 2022
- Published by Wiley in Environmental DNA
- Vol. 5 (2) , 264-281
Open AccessToward eDNA‐based bioassessment of freshwater reservoirs with small volumes of water: Robust molecular protocols
Bioassessment of freshwater quality with eDNA is a powerful alternative to traditional methods involving collecting, sorting, and identifying metazoan taxa with morphology (e.g., macroinvertebrates). Particularly attractive for routine monitoring would be an eDNA method that uses a remote‐controlled boat for collecting small volumes of water without filtration in order to simplify sampling. Such a method would not likely capture eDNA signals for all metazoan species, but may nevertheless allow for cost‐effective, and frequent monitoring of water quality, which is important for tropical waterbodies that require year‐round surveillance. We here optimize a molecular protocol for capturing metazoan signatures based on eDNA obtained from 15 ml of water. To test the robustness of the method, we used samples from two tropical reservoirs with known differences in water quality to optimize molecular procedures so that they yield repeatable results. Each reservoir was sampled at three sites (“biological replicates”) and each water sample was subsampled twice before extracting the eDNA using ethanol precipitation for both subsamples (“technical replicates”). We then tested how much DNA (0.1 ng to 15 ng) and how many PCR cycles (25 or 35) minimized the variance of the metazoan eDNA signal between biological and technical replicates. For this purpose, we amplified a 313 bp COI minibarcode using a universal metazoan primer pair. We found that regardless of template amounts or PCR cycle numbers, the eDNA signatures for both reservoirs were distinct because only 17 of 59 mOTUs (mainly planktonic crustaceans and rotifers) were shared. We also found that template amounts between 0.5 and 15 ng yielded overall similar results, but the use of 35 PCR cycles significantly depressed the number of detected species (p‐value < 0.05). Fortunately, the differences between the detected metazoan community of the reservoirs were so strong that all biological and technical replicates could be assigned unambiguously to their source reservoir although the variance between technical replicates remained high for all PCR experiments (Bray‐Curtis dissimilarity: 5%–20%; Jaccard distance: 10%–40%).
- Open Access
Network analysis with either Illumina or MinION reveals that detecting vertebrate species requires metabarcoding of iDNA from a diverse fly community
Metabarcoding of vertebrate DNA obtained from invertebrates (iDNA) has been used to survey vertebrate communities, but we here show that it can also be used to study species interactions between invertebrates and vertebrates in a spatial context. We sampled the dung and carrion fly community of a swamp forest remnant along a disturbance gradient (10 sites: 80-310m from a road). Approximately, 60% of the baited 407 flies yield 294 vertebrate identifications based on two COI fragments and 16S sequenced with Illumina and/or MinION. A bipartite network analysis finds no specialization in the interaction between flies and vertebrate species, but a spatial analysis revealed that surprisingly 18 of the 20 vertebrate species can be detected within 150m of the road. We show that the fly community sourced for iDNA was unexpectedly rich (24 species, 3 families) and carried DNA for mammals, birds, and reptiles. They included common and rare ground-dwelling (e.g., wild boar, Sunda pangolin), and arboreal species (e.g., long-tailed macaque, Raffles’ banded langur) as well as small bodied vertebrates (skinks, rats). All of our results were obtained with a new, greatly simplified iDNA protocol that eliminates DNA extraction by obtaining template directly through dissolving feces and regurgitates from individual flies with water. Lastly, we show that MinION- and Illumina-based metabarcoding yield similar results. Overall, flies from several families (calliphorids, muscids and sarcophagids) should be used in iDNA surveys because we show that uncommon fly species carry the signal for several vertebrate species that are otherwise difficult to detect with iDNA.
Open AccessNetwork analysis with either Illumina or MinION reveals that detecting vertebrate species requires metabarcoding of iDNA from a diverse fly community
Metabarcoding of vertebrate DNA obtained from invertebrates (iDNA) has been used to survey vertebrate communities, but we here show that it can also be used to study species interactions between invertebrates and vertebrates in a spatial context. We sampled the dung and carrion fly community of a swamp forest remnant along a disturbance gradient (10 sites: 80-310m from a road). Approximately, 60% of the baited 407 flies yield 294 vertebrate identifications based on two COI fragments and 16S sequenced with Illumina and/or MinION. A bipartite network analysis finds no specialization in the interaction between flies and vertebrate species, but a spatial analysis revealed that surprisingly 18 of the 20 vertebrate species can be detected within 150m of the road. We show that the fly community sourced for iDNA was unexpectedly rich (24 species, 3 families) and carried DNA for mammals, birds, and reptiles. They included common and rare ground-dwelling (e.g., wild boar, Sunda pangolin), and arboreal species (e.g., long-tailed macaque, Raffles’ banded langur) as well as small bodied vertebrates (skinks, rats). All of our results were obtained with a new, greatly simplified iDNA protocol that eliminates DNA extraction by obtaining template directly through dissolving feces and regurgitates from individual flies with water. Lastly, we show that MinION- and Illumina-based metabarcoding yield similar results. Overall, flies from several families (calliphorids, muscids and sarcophagids) should be used in iDNA surveys because we show that uncommon fly species carry the signal for several vertebrate species that are otherwise difficult to detect with iDNA.
- Open Access
Towards environmental DNA-based bioassessment of freshwater reservoirs with small volumes of water: robust molecular protocols
Bioassessment of freshwater quality via eDNA is rapidly developing into a powerful alternative to traditional methods involving collecting, sorting, and identifying macroinvertebrates based on morphology. Particularly attractive would be methods that can use remote-controlled boats for sampling because it would allow for cost-effective, and frequent monitoring at multiple sites. The latter will be particularly important for tropical reservoirs that require year-around surveillance. We here optimize molecular protocols for capturing reservoir-specific differences in metazoan communities based on small water volumes (15 mL). The optimization is based on samples from two freshwater reservoirs with very different water qualities (“reservoir signal”). Each reservoir was sampled at three sites (“biological replicates”). For each water sample, the DNA was extracted twice (“technical replicates”). We then tested how much DNA template (0.1 ng to 15 ng) and how many PCR cycles (25 or 35) minimized variance between technical replicates. We find that 15 mL is sufficient for capturing the reservoir signal regardless of sampling time, template amounts, or PCR cycle numbers. Indeed, extrapolation from our results suggests that <1 mL would be sufficient because only 17 of 59 metazoan mOTUs (mainly planktonic crustaceans and rotifers) detected with a 313bp COI minibarcode were shared. We find that the use of 35 PCR cycles significantly lowered the number of detected species and that template amounts <0.5 ng yielded somewhat higher variance between technical replicates. Despite extensive trials, the variance between technical replicates remained high (Bray-Curtis: 5–20%; Jaccard: 10–40%) and we predict that it will be difficult to reduce this variance further. However, the overall reservoir differences are so strong that all biological and technical replicates can be correctly assigned.
Open AccessTowards environmental DNA-based bioassessment of freshwater reservoirs with small volumes of water: robust molecular protocols
Bioassessment of freshwater quality via eDNA is rapidly developing into a powerful alternative to traditional methods involving collecting, sorting, and identifying macroinvertebrates based on morphology. Particularly attractive would be methods that can use remote-controlled boats for sampling because it would allow for cost-effective, and frequent monitoring at multiple sites. The latter will be particularly important for tropical reservoirs that require year-around surveillance. We here optimize molecular protocols for capturing reservoir-specific differences in metazoan communities based on small water volumes (15 mL). The optimization is based on samples from two freshwater reservoirs with very different water qualities (“reservoir signal”). Each reservoir was sampled at three sites (“biological replicates”). For each water sample, the DNA was extracted twice (“technical replicates”). We then tested how much DNA template (0.1 ng to 15 ng) and how many PCR cycles (25 or 35) minimized variance between technical replicates. We find that 15 mL is sufficient for capturing the reservoir signal regardless of sampling time, template amounts, or PCR cycle numbers. Indeed, extrapolation from our results suggests that <1 mL would be sufficient because only 17 of 59 metazoan mOTUs (mainly planktonic crustaceans and rotifers) detected with a 313bp COI minibarcode were shared. We find that the use of 35 PCR cycles significantly lowered the number of detected species and that template amounts <0.5 ng yielded somewhat higher variance between technical replicates. Despite extensive trials, the variance between technical replicates remained high (Bray-Curtis: 5–20%; Jaccard: 10–40%) and we predict that it will be difficult to reduce this variance further. However, the overall reservoir differences are so strong that all biological and technical replicates can be correctly assigned.