GKGünther Knoblich

Günther Knoblich

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Günther Knoblich has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Joint (versus individual) task representations are activated spontaneously and preferentially: evidence from switch cost asymmetry

    by Shaheed Azaad, Kassandra Friebe, Günther Knoblich, Natalie Sebanz

    We routinely face the decision to act either alone or with another person. Research has found that humans exhibit a joint action preference, choosing to coordinate even when it is unnecessary and inefficient. Here, we tested one mechanism that might contribute to this preference: that joint task representations are activated spontaneously and preferentially to individual task representations. To this end, we conducted a secondary (meta)analysis of seven experiments (total N = 288) in which dyads completed a stimulus-response task requiring switching between individual and joint responses. Switch-cost asymmetry between the two trial types revealed that joint task representations were represented preferentially to individual task representations. This held even though participants did not coordinate intentionally, responding together only incidentally when a stimulus cued responses from both. In other words, the task was represented jointly and preferentially activated, spontaneously. Our results add to a body of joint action research indicating that a suite of spontaneous perceptual and cognitive processes automatically prepare us to coordinate with others.

  • Open Access

    The Influence of Robot Autonomy on Sense of Control and Trust Towards a Robot

    by Mateusz Woźniak, Davide De Tommaso, Guenther Knoblich, Agnieszka Wykowska

    Autonomous robots can make decisions that lead to outcomes that are better, equal to, or worse than those requested by a human. However, how the value of these outcomes shapes perceptions of robot autonomy remains underexplored. We conducted four online experiments examining how different forms of robot decision-making autonomy influence human–robot interaction. Participants played a game in which they selected a box for a robot avatar to collect, with each box yielding a specific number of points. Some robots were described as autonomous and could disobey instructions. We compared robots that disobeyed to produce a better outcome for the participant (helpful autonomy) with robots that disobeyed but achieved the same outcome (same-outcome autonomy). Experiments 3 and 4 further distinguished helpful autonomy aimed at avoiding losses from autonomy aimed at obtaining additional gains. Trust was assessed using a post-task trust game. Results showed that helpful autonomy generally increased trust compared to same-outcome autonomy, except when loss avoidance was unreliable. Trust was unrelated to perceived control. Perceived control was higher for same-outcome autonomy in Experiments 1–2, where non-autonomous and random robots were present, but higher for helpful autonomy in Experiments 3–4, indicating that perceived control depends on both robot autonomy and the behavioral context in which it is experienced. Finally, helpful autonomy produced bimodal distributions in ratings of robot cooperativeness and experienced sense of joint agency, suggesting that such behavior can elicit qualitatively different attitudes toward the robot.

  • Open Access

    A Predictive Processing Framework for Joint Action and Communication

    by Giovanni Pezzulo, Günther Knoblich, Domenico Maisto, Francesco Donnarumma, Elisabeth Pacherie, Uri Hasson

    Humans act together to achieve feats they could never achieve alone and communicate to ensure alignment of meaning and understanding across different individuals. Explaining the unique human joint action and communication abilities poses an enormous challenge because it requires a systematic account of how people go beyond their own individual perceptions, thoughts, and needs to achieve joint outcomes and align their understanding. Here, we advance a new unified computational framework for explaining joint action and communication. It builds upon influential predictive processing architectures, extending them from individual cognition to multiagent, interactive settings. We assume that joint action and communication involve using and updating agent-neutral models that enable co-agents to predict collective outcomes of interactions regardless of who achieved them. This contrasts with previous frameworks postulating that agent-specific models predict action outcomes for self and others. We discuss three key claims derived from our framework: 1) Co-agents use agent-neutral predictive frameworks during joint action; 2) Co-agents update agent-neutral models interactively by shaping others’ predictions through verbal and non-verbal communication; and 3) Agent-neutral models enable dynamic role allocation during joint action. We highlight how these three claims stem from our proposal, what evidence currently favors or disfavors them, and what novel experiments could be conducted to test them further. Our agent-neutral predictive processing framework will provide a new perspective for understanding the individual basis of human sociality, which closely links theories of joint action and communication to principles of computational neuroscience.

  • Open Access

    Do Individual and Joint Action Goals Modulate Imitative Response Tendencies?

    by Maximilian Marschner, Günther Knoblich, David Dignath

    Coordinated social interaction requires people to control their tendencies to imitate each other’s actions. Previous research suggests that imitative response tendencies become modulated by the goals to which one’s own and others’ actions are individually or jointly directed. However, an open question is how different levels of goal representation (ranging from higher-level goals that specify joint or individual action outcomes to lower-level goals encoding own and others’ movement features) interact and shape imitative congruency effects during social interactions. To address this gap, we conducted two online experiments, in which participants selected one of two action targets in turn with a virtual co-actor to achieve either individual or joint task goals. We manipulated imitative congruency between both task partners’ task contributions regarding their individual action goals as well as their lower-level movement goals. Our results showed that participants’ task performance was driven by imitative congruency between their own and their partner’s individual action goals, which modulated effects of imitative congruency between their own and their partner’s low-level movement goals. Interestingly, these imitation effects were found to be present regardless of instructing participants to work towards individual or joint task goals. While supporting goal-directed theories of imitation, our findings suggest that modulations of imitative response tendencies may stem from domain-general action planning and control processes that operate across social and non-social task settings, and that instructions to pursue joint rather than individual task goals exert only limited influence on imitative action tendencies in interactive task contexts.


  • Open Access

    Do Individual and Joint Action Goals Modulate Imitative Response Tendencies?

    by Maximilian Marschner, Günther Knoblich, David Dignath

    Coordinated social interaction requires people to control their tendencies to imitate each other’s actions. Previous research suggests that imitative response tendencies become modulated by the goals to which one’s own and others’ actions are individually or jointly directed. However, an open question is how different levels of goal representation (ranging from higher-level goals that specify joint or individual action outcomes to lower-level goals encoding own and others’ movement features) interact and shape imitative congruency effects during social interactions. In two experiments we manipulated imitative congruency between individual action goals and lower-level movement goals of two co-actors that either worked towards individual or joint task goals. Overall, participants’ task performance was driven by imitative congruency between co-actors’ individual action goals which modulated effects of imitative congruency between co-actors’ low-level movement goals. These imitation effects were found to be present regardless of instructing participants to work towards individual or joint task goals. We discuss how these findings support goal-directed theories of imitation and why co-actors’ individual action goals rather than their joint task goals seem to dominate the control of imitative response tendencies in social interactions.

  • Prescribing Agreement Improves Judgments and Decisions

    by Pavel V. Voinov, Günther Knoblich

    We investigated whether prescribing agreement improves the quality of judgments and decisions. Participants were first asked to provide judgments or decisions individually. Then, they either revised their initial judgments and decisions based on a partners' response, or they provided a joint judgment agreed upon with their partner. In the latter condition, we allowed for a minimal communication protocol restricted to acceptance and rejection responses to each other's proposals. In the Agreement condition, participants improved both in a cognitive (Experiment 1a) and a perceptual decision task (Experiment 1b). The cognitive task agreement allowed participants to improve above the level of accuracy achieved with revision. Surprisingly, the prescribing agreement improved the quality of the initial independent decisions. In a judgment task (Experiment 2), the prescribing agreement led to more accurate judgments because partners weighed each other's judgments more equally than in the Revision condition where they gave higher weight to their own judgments. We conclude that prescribing agreement reduces egocentric discounting bias and motivates individuals to be more accurate. These results not only demonstrate that collective benefits in judgment and decision making can be accrued without verbal communication but also suggest potential limitations of this approach.


  • Open Access

    The influence of robot autonomy on sense of control and trust towards a robot

    by Mateusz M Wozniak, Davide De Tommaso, Günther Knoblich, Agnieszka Wykowska

    We conducted four online experiments in which we investigated how different types of autonomy influence sense of control and trust. Participants played a game in which they selected which box should be collected by a robot avatar. Each box contained a certain number of points. Participants were told that some robots have artificial intelligence and that these robots might collect different boxes than selected by the participants. At the end of the experiment, participants played a trust game with each robot. We compared a situation in which a robot disobeys participants’ commands in order to benefit the participant by obtaining more points (helpful autonomy) versus when it disobeys, but acquires the same payoff (same-outcome autonomy). Moreover, in Experiments 3 and 4 we compared two types of helpful autonomy: autonomy to avoid loss and autonomy to obtain extra gain. We found that helpful autonomy led to higher trust than same-outcome autonomy, except when it helped to avoid loss, but did so unreliably (Experiment 4). Second, trust was unrelated to the perceived sense of control over autonomous robots. Finally, participants reported experiencing more sense of control over robots with same-outcome than helpful autonomy in Experiments 1-2, where the behavior of autonomous robots could be compared with that of robots that had no autonomy or behaved randomly. However, this relation was reversed in Experiments 3-4, where these control conditions were absent, showing that sense of control can be modulated by robot's perceived autonomy, but also exposure to different types of other robots’ behavior.


  • Open Access

    Me or We? Action-Outcome Learning in Synchronous Joint Action

    by Maximilian Marschner, David Dignath, Günther Knoblich

    Goal-directed behaviour requires mental representations that encode instrumental relationships between actions and their outcomes. The present study investigated how people acquire representations of joint actions where co-actors perform synchronized action contributions to produce joint outcomes in the environment. Adapting an experimental procedure to assess individual action-outcome learning, we tested whether co-acting individuals link jointly produced action outcomes to individual-level features of their own action contributions or to group-level features of their joint action contributions instead. In a learning phase, pairs of participants produced musical chords by synchronizing individual key press responses. In a subsequent test phase, the previously produced chords were presented as imperative stimuli requiring forced-choice responses by both pair members. Stimulus-response mappings were systematically manipulated to be either compatible or incompatible with the individual and joint action-outcome mappings of the preceding learning phase. Only joint but not individual compatibility was found to modulate participants’ performance in the test phase. Yet, opposite to predictions of associative accounts of action-outcome learning, jointly incompatible mappings between learning and test phase resulted in better performance. We discuss a possible explanation of this finding proposing that pairs’ group-level learning experience modulated how participants encoded ambiguous task instructions in the test phase. Our findings inform current debates on the mechanistic nature of action-outcome learning and provide novel evidence that planning and control of joint actions is supported by dedicated mental representations encoding group-level features of joint actions.

  • Open Access

    Identifying with an avatar face changes perceptual representation of one’s real face

    by Mateusz M Wozniak, Kassandra Friebe, Günther Knoblich, Lara Maister

    Cognitive processing of images of one’s face is special: they attract attention and people are faster and more accurate to detect and recognize them. Moreover, recent studies found that similar effects can also be observed for images of unknown faces that have been associated with the self, i.e. for avatar faces. What remains unexplored is whether identifying with an avatar face changes the mental representation of one’s real face. In order to investigate this issue we conducted three experiments in which we asked participants to create associations with previously-unfamiliar faces, in a brief learning session. One face was associated with the concept ‘self’, and one with the concept ‘stranger’. We then presented participants with images of morphs between their real faces, self-associated unfamiliar faces (avatar faces), and stranger-associated unfamiliar faces. The participants’ task was to judge which of these identities each presented morph was most similar. Based on these responses we calculated the points of subjective equivalence (PSE) between each face. We discovered that when participants did the task in which they self-identified with an avatar face the PSE between their real face and a stranger-associated face was shifted towards the stranger-associated face. These results suggest that identifying with an avatar face changes the mental representation of one’s real face making it more similar to a stranger-associated face.


  • Open Access

    Biases in cultural transmission of information about a minimal ingroup

    by Mateusz M Wozniak, Mathieu Charbonneau, Günther Knoblich

    Group membership and our beliefs about the groups we belong to are the building blocks of our social and cultural identity. In this study we investigated whether transmission of information about how often different personality traits occur in an ingroup and outgroup results in distinct patterns of cultural evolution. Participants transmitted information about the occurrence of positive, negative and neutral traits to other participants of the study in linear transmission chains. First, we found a general tendency for the percentage of occurrence of all traits to decrease across generations. However, our control experiment revealed that this general decrease was not specific to transmission of information about traits, but represented a low-level response bias. Critically, this decrease across generations was smaller when participants were transmitting information about ingroup than outgroup traits, but only for positive and neutral traits. No significant difference emerged for negative traits. Together, the results show that minimal group membership can selectively bias transmission of information about ingroup and outgroup. We propose that this comes as a result of two processes: an ingroup-positivity bias and higher motivation to accurately transmit ingroup-related information. Overall, the current study provides an example of how examining mechanisms of cultural transmission can elucidate our understanding of processes of formation and evolution of social-cultural identity.