Aytug Ozaltun Celik
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Aytug Ozaltun Celik has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Esra Bukova Guzel
Dokuz Eylul University
14 shared publications - Amy B. Ellis
University of Georgia
2 shared publications - Semiha Kula Ünver
Dokuz Eylül Üniversitesi
2 shared publications - Anne Waswa
University of Georgia
1 shared publication - Aysun Nüket Elçi̇
Manisa Celal Bayar Üniversitesi, Eğitim Fakültesi, Matematik ve Fen Bilimleri Eğitimi Bölümü, Matematik Eğitimi Anabilim Dalı
1 shared publication - Beste Selin Koca
Department of Mathematics and Science Education, Buca Faculty of Education Dokuz Eylul University Izmir Türkiye
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in School Science and Mathematics
Visual Displays, Actions, and Purposes: Patterns of 12th‐Grade Students' Visual Reasoning in a Circle‐Based Geometric Task
This study examines the visual reasoning reflected in the written solutions of 12th‐grade students in the context of a circle‐based task requiring the creation of visual displays. Students' visual reasoning was analyzed in terms of visual display, visual action, and visual purpose. The dataset consisted of 228 students' written solutions and was analyzed using inductive content analysis. The findings indicate that static geometric structures were more frequently represented than relational visual structures in students' written solutions. Evidence of visual actions varied across action categories, with comparison and equal‐partitioning actions occurring more frequently than quantification and comparisons involving different positions of point P . In terms of the visual purpose component, the written solutions contained evidence of both angle‐determination and generalization purposes, with qualitative generalizations more prevalent than explicit rule construction. The findings generally indicate that the components of visual display, visual action, and visual purpose occurred in different patterns and at different levels of prevalence across students' written solutions. In light of these results, future research should examine students' visual reasoning using complementary forms of evidence, including tasks supported by dynamic geometry software or visually oriented activities targeting different areas of mathematics learning.
- 13 October 2026
- Published by Wiley in School Science and Mathematics
Visual Displays, Actions, and Purposes: Patterns of 12th‐Grade Students' Visual Reasoning in a Circle‐Based Geometric Task
This study examines the visual reasoning reflected in the written solutions of 12th‐grade students in the context of a circle‐based task requiring the creation of visual displays. Students' visual reasoning was analyzed in terms of visual display, visual action, and visual purpose. The dataset consisted of 228 students' written solutions and was analyzed using inductive content analysis. The findings indicate that static geometric structures were more frequently represented than relational visual structures in students' written solutions. Evidence of visual actions varied across action categories, with comparison and equal‐partitioning actions occurring more frequently than quantification and comparisons involving different positions of point P . In terms of the visual purpose component, the written solutions contained evidence of both angle‐determination and generalization purposes, with qualitative generalizations more prevalent than explicit rule construction. The findings generally indicate that the components of visual display, visual action, and visual purpose occurred in different patterns and at different levels of prevalence across students' written solutions. In light of these results, future research should examine students' visual reasoning using complementary forms of evidence, including tasks supported by dynamic geometry software or visually oriented activities targeting different areas of mathematics learning.
- Open Access
- 4 June 2026
- Published by Akademiai Kiado Zrt. in Hungarian Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 16 (2) , 260-274
Preservice mathematics teachers' confidence in teaching algebra: A scale adaptation study
This study aimed to adapt the scale developed by Day and Hurrell (2013) and later adopted by Lau (2021) into Turkish and to assess middle school mathematics teacher candidates' confidence in teaching algebra. We also examined the validity and reliability of the scale and evaluated the candidates' confidence levels. A total of 267 senior preservice mathematics teachers from nineteen universities participated in the study. We collected the data using a nine-item Likert-type questionnaire. During the adaptation process, we translated the scale into Turkish, obtained expert feedback from two mathematics education specialists, revised the items based on their suggestions, and conducted a back-translation through another expert to ensure linguistic accuracy. We performed confirmatory factor analysis, which supported the proposed factor structure and provided evidence of satisfactory psychometric properties, including adequate convergent validity and high internal consistency. The descriptive results showed that preservice teachers reported moderate to high levels of confidence in teaching algebra, although we observed notable individual differences across participants. These variations suggest that teacher education programs may need to provide additional targeted support to strengthen preservice teachers' confidence in teaching algebra. We expect that this valid and reliable instrument will serve as a useful tool for examining confidence across different variables, identifying potential gaps, and improving teacher education programs more effectively.
- 4 June 2026
- Published by Akademiai Kiado Zrt. in Hungarian Educational Research Journal
- Vol. 16 (2) , 260-274
Open AccessPreservice mathematics teachers' confidence in teaching algebra: A scale adaptation study
This study aimed to adapt the scale developed by Day and Hurrell (2013) and later adopted by Lau (2021) into Turkish and to assess middle school mathematics teacher candidates' confidence in teaching algebra. We also examined the validity and reliability of the scale and evaluated the candidates' confidence levels. A total of 267 senior preservice mathematics teachers from nineteen universities participated in the study. We collected the data using a nine-item Likert-type questionnaire. During the adaptation process, we translated the scale into Turkish, obtained expert feedback from two mathematics education specialists, revised the items based on their suggestions, and conducted a back-translation through another expert to ensure linguistic accuracy. We performed confirmatory factor analysis, which supported the proposed factor structure and provided evidence of satisfactory psychometric properties, including adequate convergent validity and high internal consistency. The descriptive results showed that preservice teachers reported moderate to high levels of confidence in teaching algebra, although we observed notable individual differences across participants. These variations suggest that teacher education programs may need to provide additional targeted support to strengthen preservice teachers' confidence in teaching algebra. We expect that this valid and reliable instrument will serve as a useful tool for examining confidence across different variables, identifying potential gaps, and improving teacher education programs more effectively.
- Open Access
- 5 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Education
- Vol. 60 (3)
What Drives Metacognitive‐Identity Profiles for Primary School Teachers? A Latent Profile Analysis and Predictor Roles of Growth Mindset and Demographics
Metacognition involves teachers reflecting on their knowledge and teaching practices and mobilising students' metacognition. Teachers' metacognitive regulation is necessary to promote students' learning and motivation. Additionally, teacher identity is a dynamic process that evolves through social interactions and relationships in the workplace. This study investigates the latent profiles of primary school teachers' metacognitive strategies and identities. It also examines how teacher growth mindset and demographic factors influence the membership prediction in these profiles. The participants of the study consisted of 303 primary school teachers working in various regions of Turkiye. Latent profile analysis (LPA) and ANOVA were used to analyse the data. The results revealed that four distinct profiles best represented the meta‐cognitive organising strategies and teacher identity constructs observed among primary school teachers. Latent profile analysis revealed four distinct teacher profiles: (a) Detached educators: teachers with low metacognition and moderate teacher identity: characterised by moderate professional identity and weak metacognitive regulation strategies, (b) Highly performed teachers: strong metacognition and teacher identity: exhibit a strong teacher identity and metacognitive regulation skills, (c) Balanced profiles: teachers with moderate metacognition and teacher identity: characterised by a balanced distribution in terms of identity and metacognition, (d) Struggling with identity: teachers with low teacher identity but moderate metacognition: exhibit medium level of meta‐cognitive regulation and the lowest level of teacher identity. ANOVA results show that there are significant differences between teachers' identity and meta‐cognitive strategy use according to the profiles.
- 5 July 2025
- Published by Wiley in European Journal of Education
- Vol. 60 (3)
Open AccessWhat Drives Metacognitive‐Identity Profiles for Primary School Teachers? A Latent Profile Analysis and Predictor Roles of Growth Mindset and Demographics
Metacognition involves teachers reflecting on their knowledge and teaching practices and mobilising students' metacognition. Teachers' metacognitive regulation is necessary to promote students' learning and motivation. Additionally, teacher identity is a dynamic process that evolves through social interactions and relationships in the workplace. This study investigates the latent profiles of primary school teachers' metacognitive strategies and identities. It also examines how teacher growth mindset and demographic factors influence the membership prediction in these profiles. The participants of the study consisted of 303 primary school teachers working in various regions of Turkiye. Latent profile analysis (LPA) and ANOVA were used to analyse the data. The results revealed that four distinct profiles best represented the meta‐cognitive organising strategies and teacher identity constructs observed among primary school teachers. Latent profile analysis revealed four distinct teacher profiles: (a) Detached educators: teachers with low metacognition and moderate teacher identity: characterised by moderate professional identity and weak metacognitive regulation strategies, (b) Highly performed teachers: strong metacognition and teacher identity: exhibit a strong teacher identity and metacognitive regulation skills, (c) Balanced profiles: teachers with moderate metacognition and teacher identity: characterised by a balanced distribution in terms of identity and metacognition, (d) Struggling with identity: teachers with low teacher identity but moderate metacognition: exhibit medium level of meta‐cognitive regulation and the lowest level of teacher identity. ANOVA results show that there are significant differences between teachers' identity and meta‐cognitive strategy use according to the profiles.
- 22 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Thinking Skills and Creativity
- Vol. 56
A qualitative metasynthesis: Interaction between mathematical modeling and higher order thinking
- 22 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Thinking Skills and Creativity
- Vol. 56
A qualitative metasynthesis: Interaction between mathematical modeling and higher order thinking
- 12 December 2024
- Published by Ogretim Teknolojisi ve Hayat Boyu Ogrenme Dergisi (ITALL) in Öğretim Teknolojisi ve Hayat Boyu Öğrenme Dergisi - Instructional Technology and Lifelong Learning
Expanding on Knowledge of Student Thinking through Mathematics Teachers’ Engagement in Lesson Study
The purpose of this study is to expand on knowledge of student thinking based on the mathematics teachers’ practices in a lesson study process designed for improving teachers’ knowledge of student thinking. The participants of this qualitative case study were three secondary mathematics teachers. The data were gathered from twenty-two hours lessons observations and field notes. By the data analysis, we got nine main components by constant comparison. The main components of knowledge of student thinking were (a) building on students’ mathematical ideas, (b) promoting students’ thinking of mathematics, (c) triggering and considering divergent thoughts, (d) engaging students in mathematical learning, (e) evaluating students’ understanding, (f) motivating students’ learning, (g) considering students’ misconceptions and errors, (h) considering students’ difficulties, and (i) estimating students’ possible ideas and approaches. This study supported the mathematics teachers in developing professional knowledge and also provided to elaborate the content of teachers’ knowledge of student thinking.
- 12 December 2024
- Published by Ogretim Teknolojisi ve Hayat Boyu Ogrenme Dergisi (ITALL) in Öğretim Teknolojisi ve Hayat Boyu Öğrenme Dergisi - Instructional Technology and Lifelong Learning
Expanding on Knowledge of Student Thinking through Mathematics Teachers’ Engagement in Lesson Study
The purpose of this study is to expand on knowledge of student thinking based on the mathematics teachers’ practices in a lesson study process designed for improving teachers’ knowledge of student thinking. The participants of this qualitative case study were three secondary mathematics teachers. The data were gathered from twenty-two hours lessons observations and field notes. By the data analysis, we got nine main components by constant comparison. The main components of knowledge of student thinking were (a) building on students’ mathematical ideas, (b) promoting students’ thinking of mathematics, (c) triggering and considering divergent thoughts, (d) engaging students in mathematical learning, (e) evaluating students’ understanding, (f) motivating students’ learning, (g) considering students’ misconceptions and errors, (h) considering students’ difficulties, and (i) estimating students’ possible ideas and approaches. This study supported the mathematics teachers in developing professional knowledge and also provided to elaborate the content of teachers’ knowledge of student thinking.
- 9 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Mathematics Education Research Journal
- Vol. 37 (4) , 659-686
Supporting a robust understanding of square root for middle school students
- 9 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Mathematics Education Research Journal
- Vol. 37 (4) , 659-686
Supporting a robust understanding of square root for middle school students
- 1 January 2024
- Published by National Council of Teachers of Mathematics in Journal for Research in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 55 (1) , 7-30
Classroom Supports for Generalizing
Generalizing is a critical aspect of mathematics learning, with researchers and policy documents highlighting generalizing as a core mathematical practice. It can also be challenging to foster in class settings, and teachers need access to better resources to teach generalizing, including an understanding of effective forms of instruction. This article proposes Classroom Supports for Generalizing (CSGs), investigating how multiple elements—such as tasks, teacher moves, student interactions, and representations—interact to meaningfully foster student generalizing. Drawing on class video data from a middle school teacher and two high school teachers, we present the CSG Framework, which identifies three categories of supports: Interactions for Generalizing, Structures for Generalizing, and Routines for Generalizing.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by National Council of Teachers of Mathematics in Journal for Research in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 55 (1) , 7-30
Classroom Supports for Generalizing
Generalizing is a critical aspect of mathematics learning, with researchers and policy documents highlighting generalizing as a core mathematical practice. It can also be challenging to foster in class settings, and teachers need access to better resources to teach generalizing, including an understanding of effective forms of instruction. This article proposes Classroom Supports for Generalizing (CSGs), investigating how multiple elements—such as tasks, teacher moves, student interactions, and representations—interact to meaningfully foster student generalizing. Drawing on class video data from a middle school teacher and two high school teachers, we present the CSG Framework, which identifies three categories of supports: Interactions for Generalizing, Structures for Generalizing, and Routines for Generalizing.
- Open Access
- 1 April 2023
- Published by Modestum Ltd in International Electronic Journal of Mathematics Education
- Vol. 18 (2) , em0737
Supporting novice mathematics teachers: The impact of an e-mentoring and video-based professional development program on teachers’ noticing skills
This paper focuses on e-mentoring of novice mathematics teachers as professional development, and reports findings of the e-mentoring practices enriched with videos to improve noticing skills of novice teachers. A single group pre- and post-test study was conducted with the participation of 17 mentees, novice middle school mathematics teachers. Participants’ noticing skills were assessed through a whole-class teaching video shown to them before and after the intervention. The responses of the teachers to the video assessment were analyzed considering attending, interpreting and decision-making dimensions of noticing. The results revealed that the e-mentoring program improved the novice mathematics teachers’ noticing skills significantly in all dimensions.
- 1 April 2023
- Published by Modestum Ltd in International Electronic Journal of Mathematics Education
- Vol. 18 (2) , em0737
Open AccessSupporting novice mathematics teachers: The impact of an e-mentoring and video-based professional development program on teachers’ noticing skills
This paper focuses on e-mentoring of novice mathematics teachers as professional development, and reports findings of the e-mentoring practices enriched with videos to improve noticing skills of novice teachers. A single group pre- and post-test study was conducted with the participation of 17 mentees, novice middle school mathematics teachers. Participants’ noticing skills were assessed through a whole-class teaching video shown to them before and after the intervention. The responses of the teachers to the video assessment were analyzed considering attending, interpreting and decision-making dimensions of noticing. The results revealed that the e-mentoring program improved the novice mathematics teachers’ noticing skills significantly in all dimensions.
- Open Access
- 21 March 2022
- Published by Journal of Pedagogical Research in Journal of Pedagogical Research
- Vol. 6 (1) , 231-244
A preservice middle school mathematics teacher s knowledge of student thinking about line graphs
Interpreting statistical graphs and making inferences based on the graphs are a precursor for formal statistical inferences. To support student inferences, both teachers and future teachers should have adequate knowledge regarding students’ thinking on graphs as well as their potential misinterpretations and difficulties in interpreting graphs. In this qualitative case study, I examined a preservice middle school mathematics teacher’s knowledge of student thinking about interpretation of line graphs. During her practicum course, preservice teacher planned a lesson to teach creating and interpreting line graphs. I first interviewed with her on the lesson plan and then observed her teaching the subject. The data indicated that the preservice mathematics teacher’s actions regarding knowledge of student thinking before and during the lesson supported the students in interpreting graphs beyond reading. Preservice and in-service teachers with more knowledge of student thinking would provide teaching practices to support students’ learning of statistical graphs. I thus suggest that a curriculum may be designed for improving preservice mathematics teachers’ knowledge of student thinking about statistical concepts and informal statistical inferences.
- 21 March 2022
- Published by Journal of Pedagogical Research in Journal of Pedagogical Research
- Vol. 6 (1) , 231-244
Open AccessA preservice middle school mathematics teacher s knowledge of student thinking about line graphs
Interpreting statistical graphs and making inferences based on the graphs are a precursor for formal statistical inferences. To support student inferences, both teachers and future teachers should have adequate knowledge regarding students’ thinking on graphs as well as their potential misinterpretations and difficulties in interpreting graphs. In this qualitative case study, I examined a preservice middle school mathematics teacher’s knowledge of student thinking about interpretation of line graphs. During her practicum course, preservice teacher planned a lesson to teach creating and interpreting line graphs. I first interviewed with her on the lesson plan and then observed her teaching the subject. The data indicated that the preservice mathematics teacher’s actions regarding knowledge of student thinking before and during the lesson supported the students in interpreting graphs beyond reading. Preservice and in-service teachers with more knowledge of student thinking would provide teaching practices to support students’ learning of statistical graphs. I thus suggest that a curriculum may be designed for improving preservice mathematics teachers’ knowledge of student thinking about statistical concepts and informal statistical inferences.