SPS. Blair Payne

S. Blair Payne

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


S. Blair Payne has a total of 32 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Professional Development Literature Across Decades

    by Lisa Didion, Sarah R. Powell, Blair Payne, Marissa Filderman

    Professional development (PD) is a key strategy for improving teacher effectiveness and student outcomes. This review examines trends in PD research over the past four decades, focusing on alignment with Hill et al.’s (2013) five-stage research framework and Desimone’s (2009) high-quality PD components. We included 107 experimental and quasi-experimental studies published between 1986 and 2022 that evaluated teacher outcomes following PD. Despite increased attention to PD, most research remains in early stages and lacks integration of established high-quality components. Greater investment in later-stage, large-scale studies is needed to understand the impact of PD on student outcomes and to guide future policy and practice.

  • Open Access

    Beyond Business-as-Usual: A Meta-Analysis of Active Control Comparisons in Teacher Professional Development

    by Lisa Didion, Derek Rodgers, Blair Payne, Elizabeth Hart

    This meta-analysis examined the impact of professional development (PD) design features on teacher outcomes by comparing PD interventions to active control conditions with planned variations in format, duration, content, and delivery. The study aimed to move beyond business-as-usual (BAU) comparisons to identify which PD features most effectively support teacher learning. Secondary data analyses of the Teacher Outcomes and Professional Development (TOPD) database was conducted. The TOPD database was created using comprehensive search methods of published and unpublished research between 1986 and 2023 and includes 112 randomized controlled and quasi-experimental design studies where PD was the primary intervention for preschool through 12th grade teachers (Authors, 2025a). Meta-analysis and subgroup analyses were conducted to examine the impact of variations in PD features (i.e., format, duration, content, delivery), standardized measures, and research design. PD with active control conditions yielded a significant overall effect on teacher outcomes. Studies using BAU comparisons reported larger effect sizes than those with active control conditions. Researcher-created measures produced significantly larger effects than standardized assessments. Among active control studies, variations in format and duration were most commonly tested and yielded the largest effects. Increasing the number of PD variations did not consistently enhance effectiveness. Findings highlight the limitations of BAU comparisons and highlight the importance of rigorous, feature-specific PD research. Future research should prioritize active control comparisons and intentional variation in PD features to better inform practice and policy.

  • Open Access

    A Synthesis of Mathematics Interventions for High School Students With Mathematics Difficulties

    by S. Blair Payne, Sarah R. Powell, Erica C. Fry

    High school mathematics can have a direct impact on the academic, health, and financial outcomes of students. To understand how to better support students experiencing mathematics difficulty (MD) in Grades 9, 10, 11, and 12 (i.e., high school), we conducted a synthesis of 21 studies in which author teams investigated the efficacy of a mathematics intervention across a total sample of 197 students. Overall, 15 studies demonstrated positive outcomes, with four studies demonstrating no effects and two studies demonstrating mixed results. We identified several instructional strategies used across multiple studies: explicit instruction, use of technology, focus on vocabulary, use of representations, and word-problem instruction. In most studies, researchers used single case designs, and most of the mathematics content focused on early algebraic standards. As such, there is a need for more mathematics intervention research at the high school level.


  • A meta-analysis of the effects of academic interventions on academic and academic anxiety outcomes in secondary students

    by Sarah Fishstrom, Philip Capin, Bethany H. Bhat, Katlynn Dahl-Leonard, Blair Payne, Hsuan-Hui Wang, Jordan Dille, Sharon Vaughn


  • Open Access

    The Efficacy of a Content Area Reading Comprehension Intervention for Students With Disabilities

    by Sharon Vaughn, Jeanne Wanzek, Leticia R. Martinez, Eleanor M. Hancock, Anna-Mari Fall, S. Blair Payne, Sally K. Fluhler

    This pilot study investigated the efficacy of the Promoting Adolescent Comprehension Through Text (PACT) intervention, a social studies content knowledge and reading comprehension set of practices implemented with social studies classes including students with disabilities. Social studies general education teachers were provided with professional development on the PACT and differentiation practices to support students with disabilities in the general education classroom. A total of 28 teachers and 893 students (58 students with disabilities) participated in the study, across 20 U.S. rural and urban middle schools. Effect sizes (ES) ranged from 0.21 to 0.36 on measures of content knowledge acquisition and reading comprehension for students with disabilities in the treatment classes.

  • The Development of a Coaching Model: Challenges and Implications for Intervention Research

    by Jade Wexler, Alexandra Shelton, Elizabeth Swanson, S. Blair Payne, Robin Sayers, Tara Johnston, Erin K. Hogan, Kristabel Stark

    Instructional coaching is one way to support teachers’ implementation of evidence-based practices, but gaps exist in knowledge about effective coaching interventions to support teacher learning at the secondary level. In this article, we first introduce an adaptive intervention model (AIM) for coaching, AIM Coaching, a coaching model designed for middle school instructional leaders to use to support teachers as they implement evidence-based literacy instructional practices across a Tier 1 school-wide literacy model. We also describe the theory of change that guided our work, a description of the accompanying professional development instructional leaders received, and the literacy practices that are linked to the model for the purpose of this work. Second, we describe the challenges we encountered and decisions we made during the development process, solutions that addressed those challenges, and implications of those solutions.


  • Open Access

    Implementation Fidelity Data Collection Methods: Comparing the Codability of Audio versus Video Recordings

    by Elizabeth Swanson, Blair Payne, Erin Hogan, Jade Wexler

    Implementation fidelity data, critical for understanding how interventions are delivered, can be gathered using various methods, with in-person observations being the traditional gold standard. However, due to high costs and logistical challenges associated with this form of data collection, researchers are increasingly turning to audio and video recordings. This paper compares the effectiveness of using audio and video recordings to capture fidelity data by describing the level of agreement between coders using each method and exploring whether agreement varied by objective (e.g., whether instructional components were delivered) and subjective components of instructional fidelity (e.g., instructional quality). The results suggest coding fidelity data captured by either audio or video recordings is feasible and effective, with an overall agreement rate exceeding 80%. However, accuracy varies according to the fidelity construct being measured. Results indicate a high level of agreement across coders using audio and video recordings for objective items, but video recordings facilitated coding of subjective items including instructional quality and student-teacher interactions. This study offers insights into the practical implications of capturing fidelity data through audio or video recordings and provides guidance on how to optimize fidelity coding of intervention implementation through both formats.

  • Open Access

    A Synthesis of Academic Interventions for High School Students With Behavioral and Learning Difficulties

    by S. Blair Payne, Na Young Yoon

    Many students who experience behavioral difficulties (BD) also experience learning difficulties (LD) in school; however, little research exists on how to support the academic achievement of students with co-occurring BD/LD. Even less research exists for students who experience these co-occurring difficulties at the high school or secondary level. The goal of this synthesis was to explore the effects of academic interventions on the academic outcomes (i.e., reading, mathematics, and writing) of high school students with co-occurring BD/LD. A total of nine single-case design studies met criteria for this synthesis, including two dissertations. Four studies examined mathematics outcomes, four studies assessed reading outcomes, and two studies targeted spelling outcomes, with one study examining both mathematics and spelling. The calculated Tau-U effect sizes ranged from 0.54 to 1.0 across studies. Implications for research and practice are discussed with the goal of contributing to the small body of research on secondary-age students with co-occurring BD/LD.


  • A literature review: Mathematics vocabulary intervention for students with mathematics difficulty

    by Danielle O. Lariviere, Tessa L. Arsenault, S. Blair Payne

    This paper details a literature review of mathematics vocabulary intervention studies for students with mathematics difficulty. The primary aim was to identify instructional practices that support mathematics vocabulary development. We conducted a database search to identify mathematics intervention studies either focused exclusively on vocabulary or with an embedded vocabulary component. Ultimately, 13 studies with participants from kindergarten to Grade 8 were included in the review. The majority of included studies had dual foci on vocabulary and other mathematics content, including whole number computation, word problem solving, fractions, algebra, or geometry. All studies that measured mathematics vocabulary performance indicated positive student outcomes. In addition, multiple studies indicated positive effects on measures of other mathematics content beyond mathematics vocabulary knowledge. We noted six instructional practices across studies that bolstered the mathematics vocabulary performance of students with mathematics difficulty. From most to least common, these practices included formal vocabulary use, explicit instruction, use of representations, repeated exposures, pre‐teaching, and graphic organizers. Implications are addressed for both researchers and practitioners.


  • An Exploration of Middle School Literacy Coaching: A Study of Teachers and Instructional Coaches

    by Alexandra Shelton, Elizabeth Swanson, Jade Wexler, S. Blair Payne, Erin Hogan

    Secondary teachers benefit from ongoing coaching to support their implementation of evidence-based literacy practices across content areas. However, several factors may facilitate or impede literacy coaching at the secondary level. We conducted an exploratory survey study to investigate 141 middle school teachers’ and 64 instructional coaches’ experiences with and perceptions of literacy coaching. Both quantitative and qualitative analyses were used. Findings of the teacher survey revealed that, while most teachers had a literacy coach in their school, many did not receive coaching. In addition, many teachers identified the need for coaching related to providing literacy support to students with disabilities. Meanwhile, findings of the coach survey revealed that many instructional coaches do not provide literacy coaching. However, most coaches reported needing support related to incorporating literacy practices into various content areas. Practical implications and areas for future research related to secondary literacy coaching are discussed.