Ido Shalev
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Ido Shalev has a total of 74 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Florina Uzefovsky
Ben Gurion University in the Negev
17 shared publications - Alal Eran
Computational Health Informatics Program, Boston Children’s Hospital
5 shared publications Alal Eran
3 shared publicationsCarrie Allison
3 shared publicationsTim Dalgleish
3 shared publications- Duncan Edward Astle
University of Cambridge
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavior Research Methods
- Vol. 58 (12)
A practical guide to self-organising maps in psychological research
Identifying shared and distinct profiles, whether of symptoms, personality traits, or cognitive abilities, is essential for understanding psychological phenomena, yet doing so requires navigating interrelated theoretical, conceptual, and technical complexities. First, most psychological phenomena typically exist along continuous spectra rather than discrete categories, complicating the characterisation of inherently heterogeneous constructs. Second, studying individual differences requires balancing population-level generalisation with person-level interpretability, which is critical for applied science and clinical practice. Third, psychological data often contain missing values, non-linear relationships, and high-dimensional patterns that violate standard statistical assumptions. Commonly used approaches for profile detection often fall short of these demands, producing oversimplified or difficult-to-interpret results that are hard to map back to the individual. In contrast, self-organising maps (SOMs) offer a powerful, visual, and intuitive solution that addresses these challenges. Despite growing interest, SOMs remain underutilised in psychology, likely due to a lack of accessible tutorials and clear guidelines tailored to the field. This tutorial introduces SOMs to psychologists without technical backgrounds, emphasising practical implementation. We provide evidence-based recommendations for key methodological decisions, accompanied by annotated R code. Using a dataset of depressive symptoms as an illustrative case, we present a complete workflow covering data preprocessing, map initialisation, parameter optimisation, and interpretation. We further discuss advanced SOM extensions relevant to psychological research and highlight key limitations of the method. By making SOMs accessible, this tutorial supports nuanced, person-centred analyses that preserve the complexity of psychological phenomena.
- 12 November 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Behavior Research Methods
- Vol. 58 (12)
Open AccessA practical guide to self-organising maps in psychological research
Identifying shared and distinct profiles, whether of symptoms, personality traits, or cognitive abilities, is essential for understanding psychological phenomena, yet doing so requires navigating interrelated theoretical, conceptual, and technical complexities. First, most psychological phenomena typically exist along continuous spectra rather than discrete categories, complicating the characterisation of inherently heterogeneous constructs. Second, studying individual differences requires balancing population-level generalisation with person-level interpretability, which is critical for applied science and clinical practice. Third, psychological data often contain missing values, non-linear relationships, and high-dimensional patterns that violate standard statistical assumptions. Commonly used approaches for profile detection often fall short of these demands, producing oversimplified or difficult-to-interpret results that are hard to map back to the individual. In contrast, self-organising maps (SOMs) offer a powerful, visual, and intuitive solution that addresses these challenges. Despite growing interest, SOMs remain underutilised in psychology, likely due to a lack of accessible tutorials and clear guidelines tailored to the field. This tutorial introduces SOMs to psychologists without technical backgrounds, emphasising practical implementation. We provide evidence-based recommendations for key methodological decisions, accompanied by annotated R code. Using a dataset of depressive symptoms as an illustrative case, we present a complete workflow covering data preprocessing, map initialisation, parameter optimisation, and interpretation. We further discuss advanced SOM extensions relevant to psychological research and highlight key limitations of the method. By making SOMs accessible, this tutorial supports nuanced, person-centred analyses that preserve the complexity of psychological phenomena.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Self-harm in autistic and non-autistic people: network structure and prediction of suicidality over time
BackgroundNon-suicidal self-injury (NSSI) is relatively common among autistic people. While studies indicate relationships between NSSI and suicidal thoughts and behaviour (STB), it is unclear whether specific NSSI behaviours co-occur in meaningful ways with differential relevance to STB, and if this differs between autistic and non-autistic people.MethodsTo understand the clinical relevance of specific NSSI behaviours to STB and related constructs, we pooled data from 327 autistic and 260 non-autistic participants from two online surveys. We used network analyses to separately visualise and compare the NSSI networks of autistic and non-autistic people, controlling for age differences between groups. Thereafter, using data provided by autistic people across two time-points one year apart, we examined zero-order correlations and used LASSO regression to assess links between NSSI behaviours at the first time-point and STB-related variables at the second.ResultsOur first analyses revealed differences between autistic and non-autistic people in the co-occurrence of NSSI behaviours and their relationships to STB-related constructs. Three NSSI clusters emerged for autistic people and one for non-autistic people. In both groups, some NSSI behaviours were only indirectly linked to STB via relationships to other NSSI behaviours; cutting and ingesting dangerous substances/sharp objects were most strongly related to suicide attempts. Our second analyses, focusing on autistic people, revealed initial correlations between cutting, self-burning, self-hitting and skin-tearing and STB-related outcomes, although these disappeared after controlling for STB at time-point one. Self-biting, breaking bones and fighting to get hurt remained significant predictors of STB-related outcomes. ConclusionWhile requiring replication in better matched samples, our findings corroborate differences in how autistic and non-autistic people engage in NSSI, as well as differential relevance of specific behaviours to STB. Future research must explore direct and indirect pathways between NSSI behaviours and STB, and the functional needs that different behaviours serve.
- 6 July 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessSelf-harm in autistic and non-autistic people: network structure and prediction of suicidality over time
BackgroundNon-suicidal self-injury (NSSI) is relatively common among autistic people. While studies indicate relationships between NSSI and suicidal thoughts and behaviour (STB), it is unclear whether specific NSSI behaviours co-occur in meaningful ways with differential relevance to STB, and if this differs between autistic and non-autistic people.MethodsTo understand the clinical relevance of specific NSSI behaviours to STB and related constructs, we pooled data from 327 autistic and 260 non-autistic participants from two online surveys. We used network analyses to separately visualise and compare the NSSI networks of autistic and non-autistic people, controlling for age differences between groups. Thereafter, using data provided by autistic people across two time-points one year apart, we examined zero-order correlations and used LASSO regression to assess links between NSSI behaviours at the first time-point and STB-related variables at the second.ResultsOur first analyses revealed differences between autistic and non-autistic people in the co-occurrence of NSSI behaviours and their relationships to STB-related constructs. Three NSSI clusters emerged for autistic people and one for non-autistic people. In both groups, some NSSI behaviours were only indirectly linked to STB via relationships to other NSSI behaviours; cutting and ingesting dangerous substances/sharp objects were most strongly related to suicide attempts. Our second analyses, focusing on autistic people, revealed initial correlations between cutting, self-burning, self-hitting and skin-tearing and STB-related outcomes, although these disappeared after controlling for STB at time-point one. Self-biting, breaking bones and fighting to get hurt remained significant predictors of STB-related outcomes. ConclusionWhile requiring replication in better matched samples, our findings corroborate differences in how autistic and non-autistic people engage in NSSI, as well as differential relevance of specific behaviours to STB. Future research must explore direct and indirect pathways between NSSI behaviours and STB, and the functional needs that different behaviours serve.
- Open Access
- 16 June 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Modifying Empathic Disequilibrium Through a Brief Mindfulness-Based Meditation Training
Whether a person feels overwhelmed by others' emotions or remains detached from them may depend not on how much empathy they have, but on the balance between the cognitive and emotional components of empathy. An imbalance between emotional and cognitive empathy, termed empathic disequilibrium, has consistently distinguished clinical from non-clinical groups across a range of conditions, independent of overall empathy levels. Given these links, empathic disequilibrium may be experienced by some as distressing, yet whether it is malleable and what mechanisms may underlie such change remains untested. Building on the view that empathic disequilibrium acts as a form of emotion dysregulation in interpersonal contexts, and on its links to emotional reactivity, this study tested whether a brief mindfulness intervention can modify empathic disequilibrium. A total of 157 psychology students were assigned to ten days of daily, 10 minute guided mindfulness training (n = 89) or to a control group involving emotion regulation lessons and daily mood ratings (n = 68). Empathic disequilibrium and emotional reactivity were assessed at baseline and post-intervention using validated self-report measures. Compared with the control group, mindfulness training reduced both forms of empathic disequilibrium. Contrary to our hypothesis, this reduction was not mediated by changes in emotional reactivity, even though reactivity itself decreased. Complementary Bayesian and propensity-score sensitivity analyses supported the robustness of these effects. These findings provide the first evidence that empathic disequilibrium is modifiable in the general population, and suggest that mechanisms beyond emotional reactivity sustain this interpersonal imbalance.
- 16 June 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessModifying Empathic Disequilibrium Through a Brief Mindfulness-Based Meditation Training
Whether a person feels overwhelmed by others' emotions or remains detached from them may depend not on how much empathy they have, but on the balance between the cognitive and emotional components of empathy. An imbalance between emotional and cognitive empathy, termed empathic disequilibrium, has consistently distinguished clinical from non-clinical groups across a range of conditions, independent of overall empathy levels. Given these links, empathic disequilibrium may be experienced by some as distressing, yet whether it is malleable and what mechanisms may underlie such change remains untested. Building on the view that empathic disequilibrium acts as a form of emotion dysregulation in interpersonal contexts, and on its links to emotional reactivity, this study tested whether a brief mindfulness intervention can modify empathic disequilibrium. A total of 157 psychology students were assigned to ten days of daily, 10 minute guided mindfulness training (n = 89) or to a control group involving emotion regulation lessons and daily mood ratings (n = 68). Empathic disequilibrium and emotional reactivity were assessed at baseline and post-intervention using validated self-report measures. Compared with the control group, mindfulness training reduced both forms of empathic disequilibrium. Contrary to our hypothesis, this reduction was not mediated by changes in emotional reactivity, even though reactivity itself decreased. Complementary Bayesian and propensity-score sensitivity analyses supported the robustness of these effects. These findings provide the first evidence that empathic disequilibrium is modifiable in the general population, and suggest that mechanisms beyond emotional reactivity sustain this interpersonal imbalance.
- Open Access
- 30 May 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
A Practical Guide to Self-Organising Maps in Psychological Research
Identifying shared and distinct profiles, whether in symptom combinations, personality traits, or cognitive abilities, is essential for understanding psychological phenomena, yet doing so requires navigating interrelated theoretical, conceptual, and technical complexities. First, psychological phenomena typically exist along continuous spectra rather than discrete categories, complicating the characterisation of inherently heterogeneous constructs. Second, studying individual differences requires balancing population-level generalisation with person-level interpretability, which is critical for applied science. Third, psychological data often contain missing values, non-linear relationships, and high-dimensional patterns that violate standard statistical assumptions. Commonly used approaches for profile detection fail to address these complexities simultaneously, typically producing oversimplified or difficult-to-interpret results that obscure person-centred patterns. In contrast, Self-Organising Maps (SOMs) offer a powerful, visual, and intuitive solution that addresses these challenges. Despite growing interest, SOMs remain underutilised in psychology, potentially due to a lack of accessible tutorials and clear guidelines tailored to the field. This tutorial introduces SOMs to psychologists without technical backgrounds, emphasising practical implementation. We provide evidence-based guidance for key methodological decisions, accompanied by annotated R code. Using a dataset of depressive symptoms as an illustrative case, we present a complete workflow covering data preprocessing, map initialisation, parameter optimisation, and interpretation. We further discuss advanced SOM extensions relevant to psychological research and highlight key limitations of the method. By providing clear guidance, this tutorial facilitates the adoption of SOMs, advancing nuanced, person-centred analyses that preserve the complexity of psychological phenomena.
- 30 May 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessA Practical Guide to Self-Organising Maps in Psychological Research
Identifying shared and distinct profiles, whether in symptom combinations, personality traits, or cognitive abilities, is essential for understanding psychological phenomena, yet doing so requires navigating interrelated theoretical, conceptual, and technical complexities. First, psychological phenomena typically exist along continuous spectra rather than discrete categories, complicating the characterisation of inherently heterogeneous constructs. Second, studying individual differences requires balancing population-level generalisation with person-level interpretability, which is critical for applied science. Third, psychological data often contain missing values, non-linear relationships, and high-dimensional patterns that violate standard statistical assumptions. Commonly used approaches for profile detection fail to address these complexities simultaneously, typically producing oversimplified or difficult-to-interpret results that obscure person-centred patterns. In contrast, Self-Organising Maps (SOMs) offer a powerful, visual, and intuitive solution that addresses these challenges. Despite growing interest, SOMs remain underutilised in psychology, potentially due to a lack of accessible tutorials and clear guidelines tailored to the field. This tutorial introduces SOMs to psychologists without technical backgrounds, emphasising practical implementation. We provide evidence-based guidance for key methodological decisions, accompanied by annotated R code. Using a dataset of depressive symptoms as an illustrative case, we present a complete workflow covering data preprocessing, map initialisation, parameter optimisation, and interpretation. We further discuss advanced SOM extensions relevant to psychological research and highlight key limitations of the method. By providing clear guidance, this tutorial facilitates the adoption of SOMs, advancing nuanced, person-centred analyses that preserve the complexity of psychological phenomena.
- Open Access
- 18 April 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Eating Disorders
- Vol. 14 (1)
Feeling more than understanding: empathic disequilibrium and emotional reactivity in eating psychopathology
Background: Emotional dysregulation is a core feature of eating disorders, yet research has predominantly focused on intra personal emotion processes rather than inter personal emotional mechanisms. Empathy comprises affective empathy (AE; feeling others’ emotions) and cognitive empathy (CE; understanding others’ emotions), with recent research suggesting that empathic disequilibrium—imbalances between AE and CE—may contribute to psychopathology. We hypothesized that empathic disequilibrium characterized by AE-dominance underlies emotional difficulties in eating disorders through heightened emotional reactivity. Methods: We conducted a two-phase investigation. Study 1 examined empathy and eating disorder symptoms in 345 undergraduate students using the Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI) and Eating Disorder Examination Questionnaire (EDE-Q). Study 2 replicated findings in 835 participants (including 103 with eating disorder diagnoses) and tested emotional reactivity as a mediator using the Emotional Reactivity Scale (ERS). Results: Both studies demonstrated consistent associations between empathic disequilibrium characterized by AE-dominance and eating disorder pathology (Study 1) and diagnosis (Study 2), with CE being unrelated to eating disorder symptoms. Mediation analyses revealed that emotional reactivity mediated the relationship between empathic disequilibrium and eating disorder symptoms, with sensitivity analyses supporting pathway robustness. Conclusions: This study provides first comprehensive evidence that empathic disequilibrium, rather than specific empathic deficits, represents a potential risk factor for eating psychopathology. AE-dominance appears to create emotional hyper-arousal when encountering others’ emotions, which may be regulated using disordered eating behaviours. These findings challenge traditional empathy approaches in psychopathology and highlight the importance of interpersonal emotional processes in eating disorder conceptualization and treatment, opening new therapeutic avenues targeting both intrapersonal and interpersonal emotional functioning.
- 18 April 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Eating Disorders
- Vol. 14 (1)
Open AccessFeeling more than understanding: empathic disequilibrium and emotional reactivity in eating psychopathology
Background: Emotional dysregulation is a core feature of eating disorders, yet research has predominantly focused on intra personal emotion processes rather than inter personal emotional mechanisms. Empathy comprises affective empathy (AE; feeling others’ emotions) and cognitive empathy (CE; understanding others’ emotions), with recent research suggesting that empathic disequilibrium—imbalances between AE and CE—may contribute to psychopathology. We hypothesized that empathic disequilibrium characterized by AE-dominance underlies emotional difficulties in eating disorders through heightened emotional reactivity. Methods: We conducted a two-phase investigation. Study 1 examined empathy and eating disorder symptoms in 345 undergraduate students using the Interpersonal Reactivity Index (IRI) and Eating Disorder Examination Questionnaire (EDE-Q). Study 2 replicated findings in 835 participants (including 103 with eating disorder diagnoses) and tested emotional reactivity as a mediator using the Emotional Reactivity Scale (ERS). Results: Both studies demonstrated consistent associations between empathic disequilibrium characterized by AE-dominance and eating disorder pathology (Study 1) and diagnosis (Study 2), with CE being unrelated to eating disorder symptoms. Mediation analyses revealed that emotional reactivity mediated the relationship between empathic disequilibrium and eating disorder symptoms, with sensitivity analyses supporting pathway robustness. Conclusions: This study provides first comprehensive evidence that empathic disequilibrium, rather than specific empathic deficits, represents a potential risk factor for eating psychopathology. AE-dominance appears to create emotional hyper-arousal when encountering others’ emotions, which may be regulated using disordered eating behaviours. These findings challenge traditional empathy approaches in psychopathology and highlight the importance of interpersonal emotional processes in eating disorder conceptualization and treatment, opening new therapeutic avenues targeting both intrapersonal and interpersonal emotional functioning.
- Open Access
- 17 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Mapping mental ill-health and health within a large, representative UK school-based sample of adolescents
To support effective healthcare, frameworks are needed that capture the real-world complexity of youth mental health. We applied unsupervised machine learning (Growing Hierarchical Self-Organizing Map; GHSOM) to data from a representative sample of over 26,000 adolescents (11-14 years) from 85 UK schools. Input features included anxiety, depression, conduct, hyperactivity, interpersonal challenges, and markers of mental well-being. GHSOM represents mental health hierarchically, from narrow to broader profiles and, at the highest hierarchical level, eight reproducible profiles were identified. Profiles ranged from flourishing adolescents to those with widespread social-emotional and behavioural difficulties and low mental well-being. Other profiles showed moderate well-being despite minimal symptoms, or focal patterns of internalising or externalising. Regarding sex, females were more likely to experience patterns of anxiety and depression, while males displayed more depression, behavioural, and socialization challenges. Overall, this study offers a data-driven, multidimensional framework for organising youth mental health and informing intervention and healthcare.
- 17 January 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in PsyArXiv
Open AccessMapping mental ill-health and health within a large, representative UK school-based sample of adolescents
To support effective healthcare, frameworks are needed that capture the real-world complexity of youth mental health. We applied unsupervised machine learning (Growing Hierarchical Self-Organizing Map; GHSOM) to data from a representative sample of over 26,000 adolescents (11-14 years) from 85 UK schools. Input features included anxiety, depression, conduct, hyperactivity, interpersonal challenges, and markers of mental well-being. GHSOM represents mental health hierarchically, from narrow to broader profiles and, at the highest hierarchical level, eight reproducible profiles were identified. Profiles ranged from flourishing adolescents to those with widespread social-emotional and behavioural difficulties and low mental well-being. Other profiles showed moderate well-being despite minimal symptoms, or focal patterns of internalising or externalising. Regarding sex, females were more likely to experience patterns of anxiety and depression, while males displayed more depression, behavioural, and socialization challenges. Overall, this study offers a data-driven, multidimensional framework for organising youth mental health and informing intervention and healthcare.
- Open Access
- 1 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Autism in Adulthood
- Vol. 7 (6) , 724-738
Empathic Disequilibrium as a Predictor of Nonsuicidal Self-Injury in Autistic and Nonautistic People
Background: Nonsuicidal self-injury (NSSI) affects many autistic individuals, and has been linked to suicidality in this group. It has been closely linked to difficulties with intrapersonal emotion regulation, but a role of interpersonal emotion regulation processes in NSSI has been underexplored. Empathic disequilibrium is a state of imbalance between a person’s cognitive empathy (CE) and emotional empathy (EE). We recently found that autistic people exhibit heightened EE relative to CE, consistent with their firsthand reports of hypersensitivity to the emotions of others. Because this kind of empathic imbalance is associated with hyperarousal and emotional reactivity, we hypothesized that it might increase the risk of NSSI, which often occurs as a means of trying to regulate overwhelming or distressing emotions. Methods: We measured CE, EE, emotional reactivity, and NSSI behaviors in 304 autistic and 289 nonautistic participants, and used polynomial regression with response surface analysis to examine empathic disequilibrium as a predictor of emotional reactivity and engagement in NSSI. Results: Replicating previous research, individuals with an autism diagnosis were more likely to show a pattern of EE-dominance (OR = 4.51 [2.66, 7.63], p < 0.001), although they did not differ significantly in overall empathy levels. While empathic disequilibrium was associated with NSSI in autistic and nonautistic people, the nature of these pathways differed between groups. In autistic people, empathic disequilibrium toward EE-dominance was associated with a higher incidence of NSSI through emotional reactivity. In contrast, for nonautistic individuals, the incidence of NSSI was associated with overall empathy and, when accounting for emotional reactivity, with empathic disequilibrium toward CE dominance. Conclusions: While future studies should investigate the direction of relationships with longitudinal designs, these findings highlight different mechanisms for NSSI in autistic and nonautistic people. They corroborate growing evidence that the relative imbalance between empathic abilities may be relevant for meaningful outcomes, such as psychopathology.
- 1 December 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Autism in Adulthood
- Vol. 7 (6) , 724-738
Open AccessEmpathic Disequilibrium as a Predictor of Nonsuicidal Self-Injury in Autistic and Nonautistic People
Background: Nonsuicidal self-injury (NSSI) affects many autistic individuals, and has been linked to suicidality in this group. It has been closely linked to difficulties with intrapersonal emotion regulation, but a role of interpersonal emotion regulation processes in NSSI has been underexplored. Empathic disequilibrium is a state of imbalance between a person’s cognitive empathy (CE) and emotional empathy (EE). We recently found that autistic people exhibit heightened EE relative to CE, consistent with their firsthand reports of hypersensitivity to the emotions of others. Because this kind of empathic imbalance is associated with hyperarousal and emotional reactivity, we hypothesized that it might increase the risk of NSSI, which often occurs as a means of trying to regulate overwhelming or distressing emotions. Methods: We measured CE, EE, emotional reactivity, and NSSI behaviors in 304 autistic and 289 nonautistic participants, and used polynomial regression with response surface analysis to examine empathic disequilibrium as a predictor of emotional reactivity and engagement in NSSI. Results: Replicating previous research, individuals with an autism diagnosis were more likely to show a pattern of EE-dominance (OR = 4.51 [2.66, 7.63], p < 0.001), although they did not differ significantly in overall empathy levels. While empathic disequilibrium was associated with NSSI in autistic and nonautistic people, the nature of these pathways differed between groups. In autistic people, empathic disequilibrium toward EE-dominance was associated with a higher incidence of NSSI through emotional reactivity. In contrast, for nonautistic individuals, the incidence of NSSI was associated with overall empathy and, when accounting for emotional reactivity, with empathic disequilibrium toward CE dominance. Conclusions: While future studies should investigate the direction of relationships with longitudinal designs, these findings highlight different mechanisms for NSSI in autistic and nonautistic people. They corroborate growing evidence that the relative imbalance between empathic abilities may be relevant for meaningful outcomes, such as psychopathology.
- Open Access
- 22 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Trends in Cognitive Sciences
- Vol. 30 (7) , 585-598
Empathic disequilibrium: theoretical implications and clinical relevance
- 22 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Trends in Cognitive Sciences
- Vol. 30 (7) , 585-598
Open AccessEmpathic disequilibrium: theoretical implications and clinical relevance
- Open Access
- 11 June 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
- Vol. 34 (11) , 3655-3664
Change in empathic disequilibrium across childhood and associations with socioemotional difficulties
Empathy, a socioemotional capacity with emotional and cognitive components, develops from infancy onward. An imbalance between these components, termed empathic disequilibrium, is related to socioemotional difficulties in adulthood, but how empathic disequilibrium changes across development and whether these changes relate to socioemotional difficulties, remain to be discovered. This study investigated changes in empathic disequilibrium with age in children aged 3 to 12 years and its associations with socioemotional outcomes. 303 children from the general population were assessed at three timepoints, four months apart. Parent-reported measures of cognitive and emotional empathy, along with socioemotional outcomes (conduct and emotional problems, callous-unemotional traits, and prosocial behavior), were analyzed. Considering within and between participant variability in age, we characterized empathic disequilibrium development, and examined whether socioemotional outcomes at the last timepoint moderated this trajectory. Empathic disequilibrium typically shifted from emotional-empathy dominance at age 3 years to equilibrium between ages 4.7 and 6.9. Afterwards, a trend toward cognitive-empathy dominance emerged, which declined during early adolescence. Children with socioemotional difficulties at the final timepoint showed distinct developmental patterns of empathic disequilibrium. Specifically, children with high emotional problems, callous-unemotional traits, and low prosocial behavior were less likely to achieve empathic equilibrium by age 12, with those showing high conduct problems reaching equilibrium later than their peers. This study illustrates how empathic disequilibrium develops from early childhood to adolescence and its links with socioemotional outcomes. These findings suggest that tracking empathic disequilibrium could help identify children who may benefit from tailored interventions.
- 11 June 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in European Child & Adolescent Psychiatry
- Vol. 34 (11) , 3655-3664
Open AccessChange in empathic disequilibrium across childhood and associations with socioemotional difficulties
Empathy, a socioemotional capacity with emotional and cognitive components, develops from infancy onward. An imbalance between these components, termed empathic disequilibrium, is related to socioemotional difficulties in adulthood, but how empathic disequilibrium changes across development and whether these changes relate to socioemotional difficulties, remain to be discovered. This study investigated changes in empathic disequilibrium with age in children aged 3 to 12 years and its associations with socioemotional outcomes. 303 children from the general population were assessed at three timepoints, four months apart. Parent-reported measures of cognitive and emotional empathy, along with socioemotional outcomes (conduct and emotional problems, callous-unemotional traits, and prosocial behavior), were analyzed. Considering within and between participant variability in age, we characterized empathic disequilibrium development, and examined whether socioemotional outcomes at the last timepoint moderated this trajectory. Empathic disequilibrium typically shifted from emotional-empathy dominance at age 3 years to equilibrium between ages 4.7 and 6.9. Afterwards, a trend toward cognitive-empathy dominance emerged, which declined during early adolescence. Children with socioemotional difficulties at the final timepoint showed distinct developmental patterns of empathic disequilibrium. Specifically, children with high emotional problems, callous-unemotional traits, and low prosocial behavior were less likely to achieve empathic equilibrium by age 12, with those showing high conduct problems reaching equilibrium later than their peers. This study illustrates how empathic disequilibrium develops from early childhood to adolescence and its links with socioemotional outcomes. These findings suggest that tracking empathic disequilibrium could help identify children who may benefit from tailored interventions.
- Open Access
- 9 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Brain and Neuroscience Advances
- Vol. 9
‘How does it make you feel?’ Reclaiming subjectivity in neuroscience
- 9 May 2025
- Published by SAGE Publications in Brain and Neuroscience Advances
- Vol. 9
Open Access‘How does it make you feel?’ Reclaiming subjectivity in neuroscience