Dorit Barlevy
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Dorit Barlevy has a total of 45 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Gabriel Lázaro-Muñoz
Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, USA
4 shared publications - Stacey Pereira
Center for Medical Ethics and Health Policy Baylor College of Medicine Houston Texas USA
4 shared publications - Rémy A. Furrer
Department of Neurosurgery, Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
3 shared publications - Shai Carmi
Hebrew University of Jerusalem
3 shared publications - Todd Lencz
Northwell, New Hyde Park, NY, USA
3 shared publications - Christopher Thomas Scott
Baylor College of Medicine
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 21 June 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Genetics in Medicine
- Vol. 27 (9) , 101507
Eugenics and polygenic embryo screening: Public, clinician, and patient perceptions of conditions versus traits
- 21 June 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Genetics in Medicine
- Vol. 27 (9) , 101507
Eugenics and polygenic embryo screening: Public, clinician, and patient perceptions of conditions versus traits
- Open Access
- 25 March 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Science and Public Policy
- Vol. 51 (4) , 680-691
Governing with public engagement: an anticipatory approach to human genome editing
In response to calls for public engagement on human genome editing (HGE), which intensified after the 2018 He Jiankui scandal that resulted in the implantation of genetically modified embryos, we detail an anticipatory approach to the governance of HGE. By soliciting multidisciplinary experts’ input on the drivers and uncertainties of HGE development, we developed a set of plausible future scenarios to ascertain publics values—specifically, their hopes and concerns regarding the novel technology and its applications. In turn, we gathered a subset of multidisciplinary experts to propose governance recommendations for HGE that incorporate identified publics’ values. These recommendations include: (1) continued participatory public engagement; (2) international harmonization and transparency of multiple governance levers such as professional and scientific societies, funders, and regulators; and (3) development of a formal whistleblower framework.
- 25 March 2024
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Science and Public Policy
- Vol. 51 (4) , 680-691
Open AccessGoverning with public engagement: an anticipatory approach to human genome editing
In response to calls for public engagement on human genome editing (HGE), which intensified after the 2018 He Jiankui scandal that resulted in the implantation of genetically modified embryos, we detail an anticipatory approach to the governance of HGE. By soliciting multidisciplinary experts’ input on the drivers and uncertainties of HGE development, we developed a set of plausible future scenarios to ascertain publics values—specifically, their hopes and concerns regarding the novel technology and its applications. In turn, we gathered a subset of multidisciplinary experts to propose governance recommendations for HGE that incorporate identified publics’ values. These recommendations include: (1) continued participatory public engagement; (2) international harmonization and transparency of multiple governance levers such as professional and scientific societies, funders, and regulators; and (3) development of a formal whistleblower framework.
- 12 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics
- Vol. 41 (5) , 1221-1231
Patient interest in and clinician reservations on polygenic embryo screening: a qualitative study of stakeholder perspectives
Purpose We explored and compared perspectives of reproductive endocrinology and infertility specialists (REIs) and in vitro fertilization (IVF) patients regarding polygenic embryo screening (PES), a new type of preimplantation screening that estimates the genetic chances of developing polygenic conditions and traits in the future. Methods Qualitative thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with US-based REIs and IVF patients. Results Clinicians and patients often held favorable views of screening embryos for physical or psychiatric conditions, though clinicians tended to temper their positive attitudes with specific caveats. Clinicians also expressed negative views about screening embryos for traits more frequently than patients, who generally held more positive views. Most clinicians were either unwilling to discuss or offer PES to patients or were willing to do so only under certain circumstances, while many patients expressed interest in PES. Both stakeholder groups envisioned multiple potential benefits or uses of PES and raised multiple potential, interrelated concerns about PES. Conclusion A gap exists between clinician and patient attitudes toward PES; clinicians generally maintained reservations about such screening and patients indicated interest in it. Clinicians and patients sometimes imagined using PES to prepare for the birth of a predisposed or “affected” individual—a rationale that is often associated with prenatal testing. Many clinicians and patients held different attitudes depending on what is specifically screened, despite the sometimes blurry distinction between conditions and traits. Considerations raised by clinicians and patients may help guide professional societies in developing guidelines to navigate the uncertain terrain of PES.
- 12 March 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Assisted Reproduction and Genetics
- Vol. 41 (5) , 1221-1231
Patient interest in and clinician reservations on polygenic embryo screening: a qualitative study of stakeholder perspectives
Purpose We explored and compared perspectives of reproductive endocrinology and infertility specialists (REIs) and in vitro fertilization (IVF) patients regarding polygenic embryo screening (PES), a new type of preimplantation screening that estimates the genetic chances of developing polygenic conditions and traits in the future. Methods Qualitative thematic analysis of semi-structured interviews with US-based REIs and IVF patients. Results Clinicians and patients often held favorable views of screening embryos for physical or psychiatric conditions, though clinicians tended to temper their positive attitudes with specific caveats. Clinicians also expressed negative views about screening embryos for traits more frequently than patients, who generally held more positive views. Most clinicians were either unwilling to discuss or offer PES to patients or were willing to do so only under certain circumstances, while many patients expressed interest in PES. Both stakeholder groups envisioned multiple potential benefits or uses of PES and raised multiple potential, interrelated concerns about PES. Conclusion A gap exists between clinician and patient attitudes toward PES; clinicians generally maintained reservations about such screening and patients indicated interest in it. Clinicians and patients sometimes imagined using PES to prepare for the birth of a predisposed or “affected” individual—a rationale that is often associated with prenatal testing. Many clinicians and patients held different attitudes depending on what is specifically screened, despite the sometimes blurry distinction between conditions and traits. Considerations raised by clinicians and patients may help guide professional societies in developing guidelines to navigate the uncertain terrain of PES.
- Open Access
Polygenic Embryo Screening: High Approval Despite Substantial Concerns from the U.S. Public
Polygenic embryo screening (PES) is a novel – yet commercially available – technology that can compute genetic likelihood estimates of polygenic conditions (e.g., diabetes, depression) and traits (e.g., height, cognitive ability) in embryos. Patients undergoing in vitro fertilization (IVF) can use these polygenic scores to select which embryos to transfer for implantation with the goal of having a child. We conducted a survey of the U.S. public to examine attitudes toward PES encompassing acceptance, interest, potential uses, and concerns (n=1435). Our results indicate 72% public approval for PES, with 82% expressing some interest in using PES if already undergoing IVF. Approval for using PES for embryo selection is notably high for physical health (77%) and psychiatric conditions (72%). In contrast, there is minority approval for embryo selection based on PES for behavioral traits (36%) and physical traits (30%). Nevertheless, concerns about PES leading to false expectations, eugenic practices, and stigma are pronounced (54-55% find them “very” to “extremely” concerning). In a second sample of participants (n=192), presenting concerns at survey onset (vs. end) reduced approval (−28%) by mostly increasing ambivalence (+24%), and only slightly increasing disapproval (+4%). Given its commercial availability, practical limitations, and ethical concerns among physicians, patients, geneticists, bioethicists, and legal scholars, it is notable that there is such high public approval and interest in using PES. Understanding these attitudes is essential for informing policymakers, healthcare professionals, and researchers about the public’s perspectives on this novel biotechnology and debate about the role of medicine in regulating the use of PES.
Open AccessPolygenic Embryo Screening: High Approval Despite Substantial Concerns from the U.S. Public
Polygenic embryo screening (PES) is a novel – yet commercially available – technology that can compute genetic likelihood estimates of polygenic conditions (e.g., diabetes, depression) and traits (e.g., height, cognitive ability) in embryos. Patients undergoing in vitro fertilization (IVF) can use these polygenic scores to select which embryos to transfer for implantation with the goal of having a child. We conducted a survey of the U.S. public to examine attitudes toward PES encompassing acceptance, interest, potential uses, and concerns (n=1435). Our results indicate 72% public approval for PES, with 82% expressing some interest in using PES if already undergoing IVF. Approval for using PES for embryo selection is notably high for physical health (77%) and psychiatric conditions (72%). In contrast, there is minority approval for embryo selection based on PES for behavioral traits (36%) and physical traits (30%). Nevertheless, concerns about PES leading to false expectations, eugenic practices, and stigma are pronounced (54-55% find them “very” to “extremely” concerning). In a second sample of participants (n=192), presenting concerns at survey onset (vs. end) reduced approval (−28%) by mostly increasing ambivalence (+24%), and only slightly increasing disapproval (+4%). Given its commercial availability, practical limitations, and ethical concerns among physicians, patients, geneticists, bioethicists, and legal scholars, it is notable that there is such high public approval and interest in using PES. Understanding these attitudes is essential for informing policymakers, healthcare professionals, and researchers about the public’s perspectives on this novel biotechnology and debate about the role of medicine in regulating the use of PES.
- Open Access
Divergence Between Clinician and Patient Perspectives on Polygenic Embryo Screening: A Qualitative Study
Structured Objective: To explore and compare the perspectives of clinicians and patients on polygenic embryo screening. Design: Qualitative. Subjects: Fifty-three participants: 27 reproductive endocrinology and infertility specialists and 26 patients currently undergoing in vitro fertilization or had done so within the last five years. Main Outcome Measures: Qualitative thematic analysis of interview transcripts. Results: Both clinicians and patients often held favorable views of screening embryos for physical or psychiatric conditions, though clinicians tended to temper their positive attitudes with specific caveats. Clinicians also expressed negative views about screening embryos for traits more often than patients, who generally held more positive views. Most clinicians were either unwilling to discuss or offer polygenic embryo screening to patients or were willing to do so only under certain circumstances, while many patients expressed interest in polygenic embryo screening. Both sets of stakeholders envisioned multiple potential benefits or uses of polygenic embryo screening; the most common included selection and/or prioritization of embryos, receipt of more information about embryos, and preparation for the birth of a predisposed or “affected” child. Both sets of stakeholders also raised multiple potential, interrelated concerns about polygenic embryo screening. The most common concerns among both sets of stakeholders included the potential for different types of “biases” – most often in relation to selection of embryos with preferred genetic chances of traits –, the probabilistic nature of polygenic embryo screening that can complicate patient counseling and/or lead to excessive cycles of in vitro fertilization, and a lack of data from long-term prospective studies supporting the clinical use of polygenic embryo screening. Conclusion: Despite patients’ interest in polygenic embryo screening, clinicians feel such screening is premature for clinical application. Though now embryos can be screened for their genetic chances of developing polygenic conditions and traits, many clinicians and patients maintain different attitudes depending on what is specifically screened, despite the blurry distinction between conditions and traits. Considerations raised by these stakeholders may help guide professional societies as they consider developing guidelines to navigate the uncertain terrain of polygenic embryo screening, which is already commercially available. Funding Statement: This study was supported by the National Institutes of Health’s Human Genome Research Institute [R01HG011711]. Disclosure Statement: SC is a paid consultant at MyHeritage. Attestation Statement: Data regarding any of the subjects in the study has not been previously published unless specified. Data will be made available to the editors of the journal for review or query upon request. Data Sharing Statement: Appendices 1 and 2 will be available as supplemental materials upon publication. De-identified coded transcript excerpts will be made available upon reasonable request to the corresponding author. Capsule: Clinician and patient perspectives on polygenic embryo screening both diverge and overlap, inviting greater reflection on concepts of condition severity and health for the development of professional guidelines.
Open AccessDivergence Between Clinician and Patient Perspectives on Polygenic Embryo Screening: A Qualitative Study
Structured Objective: To explore and compare the perspectives of clinicians and patients on polygenic embryo screening. Design: Qualitative. Subjects: Fifty-three participants: 27 reproductive endocrinology and infertility specialists and 26 patients currently undergoing in vitro fertilization or had done so within the last five years. Main Outcome Measures: Qualitative thematic analysis of interview transcripts. Results: Both clinicians and patients often held favorable views of screening embryos for physical or psychiatric conditions, though clinicians tended to temper their positive attitudes with specific caveats. Clinicians also expressed negative views about screening embryos for traits more often than patients, who generally held more positive views. Most clinicians were either unwilling to discuss or offer polygenic embryo screening to patients or were willing to do so only under certain circumstances, while many patients expressed interest in polygenic embryo screening. Both sets of stakeholders envisioned multiple potential benefits or uses of polygenic embryo screening; the most common included selection and/or prioritization of embryos, receipt of more information about embryos, and preparation for the birth of a predisposed or “affected” child. Both sets of stakeholders also raised multiple potential, interrelated concerns about polygenic embryo screening. The most common concerns among both sets of stakeholders included the potential for different types of “biases” – most often in relation to selection of embryos with preferred genetic chances of traits –, the probabilistic nature of polygenic embryo screening that can complicate patient counseling and/or lead to excessive cycles of in vitro fertilization, and a lack of data from long-term prospective studies supporting the clinical use of polygenic embryo screening. Conclusion: Despite patients’ interest in polygenic embryo screening, clinicians feel such screening is premature for clinical application. Though now embryos can be screened for their genetic chances of developing polygenic conditions and traits, many clinicians and patients maintain different attitudes depending on what is specifically screened, despite the blurry distinction between conditions and traits. Considerations raised by these stakeholders may help guide professional societies as they consider developing guidelines to navigate the uncertain terrain of polygenic embryo screening, which is already commercially available. Funding Statement: This study was supported by the National Institutes of Health’s Human Genome Research Institute [R01HG011711]. Disclosure Statement: SC is a paid consultant at MyHeritage. Attestation Statement: Data regarding any of the subjects in the study has not been previously published unless specified. Data will be made available to the editors of the journal for review or query upon request. Data Sharing Statement: Appendices 1 and 2 will be available as supplemental materials upon publication. De-identified coded transcript excerpts will be made available upon reasonable request to the corresponding author. Capsule: Clinician and patient perspectives on polygenic embryo screening both diverge and overlap, inviting greater reflection on concepts of condition severity and health for the development of professional guidelines.
- Open Access
- 21 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 24 (1) , 1-12
Researching the future: scenarios to explore the future of human genome editing
Background: Forward-looking, democratically oriented governance is needed to ensure that human genome editing serves rather than undercuts public values. Scientific, policy, and ethics communities have recognized this necessity but have demonstrated limited understanding of how to fulfill it. The field of bioethics has long attempted to grapple with the unintended consequences of emerging technologies, but too often such foresight has lacked adequate scientific grounding, overemphasized regulation to the exclusion of examining underlying values, and failed to adequately engage the public. Methods: This research investigates the application of scenario planning, a tool developed in the high-stakes, uncertainty-ridden world of corporate strategy, for the equally high-stakes and uncertain world of the governance of emerging technologies. The scenario planning methodology is non-predictive, looking instead at a spread of plausible futures which diverge in their implications for different communities’ needs, cares, and desires. Results: In this article we share how the scenario development process can further understandings of the complex and dynamic systems which generate and shape new biomedical technologies and provide opportunities to re-examine and re-think questions of governance, ethics and values. We detail the results of a year-long scenario planning study that engaged experts from the biological sciences, bioethics, social sciences, law, policy, private industry, and civic organizations to articulate alternative futures of human genome editing. Conclusions: Through sharing and critiquing our methodological approach and results of this study, we advance understandings of anticipatory methods deployed in bioethics, demonstrating how this approach provides unique insights and helps to derive better research questions and policy strategies.
- 21 September 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Medical Ethics
- Vol. 24 (1) , 1-12
Open AccessResearching the future: scenarios to explore the future of human genome editing
Background: Forward-looking, democratically oriented governance is needed to ensure that human genome editing serves rather than undercuts public values. Scientific, policy, and ethics communities have recognized this necessity but have demonstrated limited understanding of how to fulfill it. The field of bioethics has long attempted to grapple with the unintended consequences of emerging technologies, but too often such foresight has lacked adequate scientific grounding, overemphasized regulation to the exclusion of examining underlying values, and failed to adequately engage the public. Methods: This research investigates the application of scenario planning, a tool developed in the high-stakes, uncertainty-ridden world of corporate strategy, for the equally high-stakes and uncertain world of the governance of emerging technologies. The scenario planning methodology is non-predictive, looking instead at a spread of plausible futures which diverge in their implications for different communities’ needs, cares, and desires. Results: In this article we share how the scenario development process can further understandings of the complex and dynamic systems which generate and shape new biomedical technologies and provide opportunities to re-examine and re-think questions of governance, ethics and values. We detail the results of a year-long scenario planning study that engaged experts from the biological sciences, bioethics, social sciences, law, policy, private industry, and civic organizations to articulate alternative futures of human genome editing. Conclusions: Through sharing and critiquing our methodological approach and results of this study, we advance understandings of anticipatory methods deployed in bioethics, demonstrating how this approach provides unique insights and helps to derive better research questions and policy strategies.
- 20 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 23 (7) , 53-55
Curiosity and Uncertainty Resolution: Inflating the Perceived Utility of Genetic Information
- 20 June 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 23 (7) , 53-55
Curiosity and Uncertainty Resolution: Inflating the Perceived Utility of Genetic Information
- 28 January 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 22 (2) , 42-45
Capacities and Limitations of Using Polygenic Risk Scores for Reproductive Decision Making
In their article “Implementing Expanded Prenatal Genetic Testing: Should Parents Have Access to Any and All Fetal Genetic Information?” Bayefsky and Berkman (2022) briefly mention that: “[s]ome are...
- 28 January 2022
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 22 (2) , 42-45
Capacities and Limitations of Using Polygenic Risk Scores for Reproductive Decision Making
In their article “Implementing Expanded Prenatal Genetic Testing: Should Parents Have Access to Any and All Fetal Genetic Information?” Bayefsky and Berkman (2022) briefly mention that: “[s]ome are...
- 28 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 22 (1) , 46-48
How Ethics Can Better Anticipate the Consequences of Emerging Biotechnologies
Ankeny et al.’s “Developing a Reflexive, Anticipatory, and Deliberative Approach to Unanticipated Discoveries: Ethical Lessons from iBlastoids” (Ankeny et al. 2022) cites several places in the lite...
- 28 December 2021
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 22 (1) , 46-48
How Ethics Can Better Anticipate the Consequences of Emerging Biotechnologies
Ankeny et al.’s “Developing a Reflexive, Anticipatory, and Deliberative Approach to Unanticipated Discoveries: Ethical Lessons from iBlastoids” (Ankeny et al. 2022) cites several places in the lite...