Tamara Mathys
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Tamara Mathys has a total of 36 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Christian Hauck
Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland
12 shared publications Christin Hilbich
Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland
11 shared publications- Martin Hoelzle
Department of Geosciences, University of Fribourg, Fribourg, Switzerland
11 shared publications - Leo C. P. Martin
Aix Marseille Univ, CNRS, IRD, INRAE, CEREGE, Aix-en-Provence, France
9 shared publications - Murataly Duishonakunov
Division of Arts, Humanities and Communication, American University of Central Asia, Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan
9 shared publications Ryskul Usubaliev
Department of Climate, Water and Geoecology, Central Asian Institute for Applied Geosciences (CAIAG), Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan
9 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 6 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-50
Comment on egusphere-2026-2756
Permafrost degradation poses increasing risks to infrastructure in high-mountain regions, yet quantitative and spatially distributed assessments remain scarce in data-limited areas such as Central Asia. This study focuses on a 1,563 km² area in Inner Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, including the Kumtor gold mine and the Arabel plateau. We applied the numerical permafrost model CryoGrid to simulate permafrost thermal conditions and thaw depth across the study area, informed by geophysically derived stratigraphies and assessed against borehole temperatures and ground-based observations. To represent subsurface heterogeneity, surface-type-specific stratigraphies were developed for six landscape classes derived from petrophysical joint inversion of co-located Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Refraction Seismic Tomography (RST) data. Legacy borehole measurements from 1986–1992 were incorporated to provide a multi-decadal validation of ground thermal conditions. The resulting 30 m resolution maps indicate continuous permafrost across the study area, with mean ground temperatures at 5 m depth ranging from −0.1 °C to −6.5 °C and a spatial mean of −2.9 °C. Mean thaw depth at the end of August 2024 is 2.0 m, with surface type exerting a strong control on spatial patterns. Fine-grained and vegetated sediments on the Arabel plateau show comparatively deep thaw, coinciding with thermokarst features and ground subsidence, whereas coarse-blocky debris and rock glaciers exhibit shallow thaw depths. Comparison with ERT-derived thaw depths from 15 profiles shows agreement generally within about 1 m. Simulated ground temperatures show warming trends of 0.20 °C and 0.18 °C per decade at 5 m and 20 m depth since 1975, corresponding to approximately 1 °C warming since the 1980s. These results demonstrate the value of integrating geophysical data and surface-type-specific stratigraphies into modeling studies to represent spatial variability of mountain permafrost in data-scarce regions.
- 6 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-50
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2756
Permafrost degradation poses increasing risks to infrastructure in high-mountain regions, yet quantitative and spatially distributed assessments remain scarce in data-limited areas such as Central Asia. This study focuses on a 1,563 km² area in Inner Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, including the Kumtor gold mine and the Arabel plateau. We applied the numerical permafrost model CryoGrid to simulate permafrost thermal conditions and thaw depth across the study area, informed by geophysically derived stratigraphies and assessed against borehole temperatures and ground-based observations. To represent subsurface heterogeneity, surface-type-specific stratigraphies were developed for six landscape classes derived from petrophysical joint inversion of co-located Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Refraction Seismic Tomography (RST) data. Legacy borehole measurements from 1986–1992 were incorporated to provide a multi-decadal validation of ground thermal conditions. The resulting 30 m resolution maps indicate continuous permafrost across the study area, with mean ground temperatures at 5 m depth ranging from −0.1 °C to −6.5 °C and a spatial mean of −2.9 °C. Mean thaw depth at the end of August 2024 is 2.0 m, with surface type exerting a strong control on spatial patterns. Fine-grained and vegetated sediments on the Arabel plateau show comparatively deep thaw, coinciding with thermokarst features and ground subsidence, whereas coarse-blocky debris and rock glaciers exhibit shallow thaw depths. Comparison with ERT-derived thaw depths from 15 profiles shows agreement generally within about 1 m. Simulated ground temperatures show warming trends of 0.20 °C and 0.18 °C per decade at 5 m and 20 m depth since 1975, corresponding to approximately 1 °C warming since the 1980s. These results demonstrate the value of integrating geophysical data and surface-type-specific stratigraphies into modeling studies to represent spatial variability of mountain permafrost in data-scarce regions.
- Open Access
Automated Electrical Resistivity Tomography for Continuous Monitoring of Permafrost Dynamics: First Field Application and Validation in Central Asia
Continuous monitoring of permafrost dynamics remains challenging in remote high-mountain environments due to logistical constraints, harsh climatic conditions, and the limited availability of spatially distributed observations. In addition to direct temperature observations in boreholes, Autonomous Electrical Resistivity Tomography (A-ERT) offers significant potential for long-term monitoring by providing high temporal resolution observations of subsurface electrical properties, which are highly sensitive to freeze/thaw processes. This study presents the field validation of a low-power A-ERT system designed for long-term autonomous operation in extreme environments. The system was deployed at a high-altitude permafrost site near the Kumtor gold mine in the Central Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, representing the first application of continuous A-ERT monitoring in the Central Asian mountain ranges. The system operated continuously under harsh environmental conditions with air temperatures as low as −30 °C. Data quality remained consistently high throughout the monitoring period, with less than 1% of measurements removed during filtering, and inversion results with root-mean-square errors generally ranging between 3% and 4%. Time-lapse resistivity observations revealed strong seasonal freeze–thaw dynamics within the active layer and continued seasonal resistivity variations within the underlying permafrost despite permanently frozen conditions. Analysis of depth-dependent resistivity–temperature relationships revealed increasingly pronounced hysteresis behavior below the active layer, indicating that subsurface electrical properties were not controlled solely by temperature. This behavior likely reflects variations in unfrozen water content and pore connectivity within the fine-grained permafrost, where liquid water can persist at sub-zero temperatures. The results demonstrate the capability of the A-ERT system for reliable long-term autonomous monitoring in remote permafrost environments and investigation of coupled thermal and hydrological processes in permafrost systems.
Open AccessAutomated Electrical Resistivity Tomography for Continuous Monitoring of Permafrost Dynamics: First Field Application and Validation in Central Asia
Continuous monitoring of permafrost dynamics remains challenging in remote high-mountain environments due to logistical constraints, harsh climatic conditions, and the limited availability of spatially distributed observations. In addition to direct temperature observations in boreholes, Autonomous Electrical Resistivity Tomography (A-ERT) offers significant potential for long-term monitoring by providing high temporal resolution observations of subsurface electrical properties, which are highly sensitive to freeze/thaw processes. This study presents the field validation of a low-power A-ERT system designed for long-term autonomous operation in extreme environments. The system was deployed at a high-altitude permafrost site near the Kumtor gold mine in the Central Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, representing the first application of continuous A-ERT monitoring in the Central Asian mountain ranges. The system operated continuously under harsh environmental conditions with air temperatures as low as −30 °C. Data quality remained consistently high throughout the monitoring period, with less than 1% of measurements removed during filtering, and inversion results with root-mean-square errors generally ranging between 3% and 4%. Time-lapse resistivity observations revealed strong seasonal freeze–thaw dynamics within the active layer and continued seasonal resistivity variations within the underlying permafrost despite permanently frozen conditions. Analysis of depth-dependent resistivity–temperature relationships revealed increasingly pronounced hysteresis behavior below the active layer, indicating that subsurface electrical properties were not controlled solely by temperature. This behavior likely reflects variations in unfrozen water content and pore connectivity within the fine-grained permafrost, where liquid water can persist at sub-zero temperatures. The results demonstrate the capability of the A-ERT system for reliable long-term autonomous monitoring in remote permafrost environments and investigation of coupled thermal and hydrological processes in permafrost systems.
- Open Access
- 27 August 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Automated Electrical Resistivity Tomography for Continuous Monitoring of Permafrost Dynamics: First Field Application and Validation in Central Asia
Continuous monitoring of permafrost dynamics remains challenging in remote high-mountain environments due to logistical constraints, harsh climatic conditions, and the limited availability of spatially distributed observations. In addition to direct temperature observations in boreholes, Autonomous Electrical Resistivity Tomography (A-ERT) offers significant potential for long-term monitoring by providing high temporal resolution observations of subsurface electrical properties, which is highly sensitive to freeze/thaw processes. This study presents the field validation of a low-power A-ERT system designed for long-term autonomous operation in extreme environments. The system was deployed at a high-altitude permafrost site near the Kumtor gold mine in the Central Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, representing the first application of continuous A-ERT monitoring in the Central Asian mountain ranges. The system operated continuously under harsh environmental conditions with air temperatures as low as −30 °C. Data quality remained consistently high throughout the monitoring period, with less than 1% of measurements removed during filtering, and inversion results with root-mean-square errors generally ranging between 3% and 4%. Time-lapse resistivity observations revealed strong seasonal freeze–thaw dynamics within the active layer and continued seasonal resistivity variations within the underlying permafrost despite permanently frozen conditions. Analysis of depth-dependent resistivity–temperature relationships revealed increasingly pronounced hysteresis behavior below the active layer, indicating that subsurface electrical properties were not controlled solely by temperature. This behavior likely reflects variations in unfrozen water content and pore connectivity within the fine-grained permafrost, where liquid water can persist at sub-zero temperatures. The results demonstrate the capability of the A-ERT system for reliable long-term autonomous monitoring in remote permafrost environments and investigation of coupled thermal and hydrological processes in permafrost systems.
- 27 August 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessAutomated Electrical Resistivity Tomography for Continuous Monitoring of Permafrost Dynamics: First Field Application and Validation in Central Asia
Continuous monitoring of permafrost dynamics remains challenging in remote high-mountain environments due to logistical constraints, harsh climatic conditions, and the limited availability of spatially distributed observations. In addition to direct temperature observations in boreholes, Autonomous Electrical Resistivity Tomography (A-ERT) offers significant potential for long-term monitoring by providing high temporal resolution observations of subsurface electrical properties, which is highly sensitive to freeze/thaw processes. This study presents the field validation of a low-power A-ERT system designed for long-term autonomous operation in extreme environments. The system was deployed at a high-altitude permafrost site near the Kumtor gold mine in the Central Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, representing the first application of continuous A-ERT monitoring in the Central Asian mountain ranges. The system operated continuously under harsh environmental conditions with air temperatures as low as −30 °C. Data quality remained consistently high throughout the monitoring period, with less than 1% of measurements removed during filtering, and inversion results with root-mean-square errors generally ranging between 3% and 4%. Time-lapse resistivity observations revealed strong seasonal freeze–thaw dynamics within the active layer and continued seasonal resistivity variations within the underlying permafrost despite permanently frozen conditions. Analysis of depth-dependent resistivity–temperature relationships revealed increasingly pronounced hysteresis behavior below the active layer, indicating that subsurface electrical properties were not controlled solely by temperature. This behavior likely reflects variations in unfrozen water content and pore connectivity within the fine-grained permafrost, where liquid water can persist at sub-zero temperatures. The results demonstrate the capability of the A-ERT system for reliable long-term autonomous monitoring in remote permafrost environments and investigation of coupled thermal and hydrological processes in permafrost systems.
- Open Access
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-50
Comment on egusphere-2026-2756
Permafrost degradation poses increasing risks to infrastructure in high-mountain regions, yet quantitative and spatially distributed assessments remain scarce in data-limited areas such as Central Asia. This study focuses on a 1,563 km² area in Inner Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, including the Kumtor gold mine and the Arabel plateau. We applied the numerical permafrost model CryoGrid to simulate permafrost thermal conditions and thaw depth across the study area, informed by geophysically derived stratigraphies and assessed against borehole temperatures and ground-based observations. To represent subsurface heterogeneity, surface-type-specific stratigraphies were developed for six landscape classes derived from petrophysical joint inversion of co-located Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Refraction Seismic Tomography (RST) data. Legacy borehole measurements from 1986–1992 were incorporated to provide a multi-decadal validation of ground thermal conditions. The resulting 30 m resolution maps indicate continuous permafrost across the study area, with mean ground temperatures at 5 m depth ranging from −0.1 °C to −6.5 °C and a spatial mean of −2.9 °C. Mean thaw depth at the end of August 2024 is 2.0 m, with surface type exerting a strong control on spatial patterns. Fine-grained and vegetated sediments on the Arabel plateau show comparatively deep thaw, coinciding with thermokarst features and ground subsidence, whereas coarse-blocky debris and rock glaciers exhibit shallow thaw depths. Comparison with ERT-derived thaw depths from 15 profiles shows agreement generally within about 1 m. Simulated ground temperatures show warming trends of 0.20 °C and 0.18 °C per decade at 5 m and 20 m depth since 1975, corresponding to approximately 1 °C warming since the 1980s. These results demonstrate the value of integrating geophysical data and surface-type-specific stratigraphies into modeling studies to represent spatial variability of mountain permafrost in data-scarce regions.
- 3 August 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-50
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-2756
Permafrost degradation poses increasing risks to infrastructure in high-mountain regions, yet quantitative and spatially distributed assessments remain scarce in data-limited areas such as Central Asia. This study focuses on a 1,563 km² area in Inner Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, including the Kumtor gold mine and the Arabel plateau. We applied the numerical permafrost model CryoGrid to simulate permafrost thermal conditions and thaw depth across the study area, informed by geophysically derived stratigraphies and assessed against borehole temperatures and ground-based observations. To represent subsurface heterogeneity, surface-type-specific stratigraphies were developed for six landscape classes derived from petrophysical joint inversion of co-located Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Refraction Seismic Tomography (RST) data. Legacy borehole measurements from 1986–1992 were incorporated to provide a multi-decadal validation of ground thermal conditions. The resulting 30 m resolution maps indicate continuous permafrost across the study area, with mean ground temperatures at 5 m depth ranging from −0.1 °C to −6.5 °C and a spatial mean of −2.9 °C. Mean thaw depth at the end of August 2024 is 2.0 m, with surface type exerting a strong control on spatial patterns. Fine-grained and vegetated sediments on the Arabel plateau show comparatively deep thaw, coinciding with thermokarst features and ground subsidence, whereas coarse-blocky debris and rock glaciers exhibit shallow thaw depths. Comparison with ERT-derived thaw depths from 15 profiles shows agreement generally within about 1 m. Simulated ground temperatures show warming trends of 0.20 °C and 0.18 °C per decade at 5 m and 20 m depth since 1975, corresponding to approximately 1 °C warming since the 1980s. These results demonstrate the value of integrating geophysical data and surface-type-specific stratigraphies into modeling studies to represent spatial variability of mountain permafrost in data-scarce regions.
- Open Access
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-50
Mapping permafrost distribution and thaw depths in the Inner Tien Shan: A CryoGrid-based modeling approach integrating geophysical data
Permafrost degradation poses increasing risks to infrastructure in high-mountain regions, yet quantitative and spatially distributed assessments remain scarce in data-limited areas such as Central Asia. This study focuses on a 1,563 km² area in Inner Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, including the Kumtor gold mine and the Arabel plateau. We applied the numerical permafrost model CryoGrid to simulate permafrost thermal conditions and thaw depth across the study area, informed by geophysically derived stratigraphies and assessed against borehole temperatures and ground-based observations. To represent subsurface heterogeneity, surface-type-specific stratigraphies were developed for six landscape classes derived from petrophysical joint inversion of co-located Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Refraction Seismic Tomography (RST) data. Legacy borehole measurements from 1986–1992 were incorporated to provide a multi-decadal validation of ground thermal conditions. The resulting 30 m resolution maps indicate continuous permafrost across the study area, with mean ground temperatures at 5 m depth ranging from −0.1 °C to −6.5 °C and a spatial mean of −2.9 °C. Mean thaw depth at the end of August 2024 is 2.0 m, with surface type exerting a strong control on spatial patterns. Fine-grained and vegetated sediments on the Arabel plateau show comparatively deep thaw, coinciding with thermokarst features and ground subsidence, whereas coarse-blocky debris and rock glaciers exhibit shallow thaw depths. Comparison with ERT-derived thaw depths from 15 profiles shows agreement generally within about 1 m. Simulated ground temperatures show warming trends of 0.20 °C and 0.18 °C per decade at 5 m and 20 m depth since 1975, corresponding to approximately 1 °C warming since the 1980s. These results demonstrate the value of integrating geophysical data and surface-type-specific stratigraphies into modeling studies to represent spatial variability of mountain permafrost in data-scarce regions.
- 27 July 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-50
Open AccessMapping permafrost distribution and thaw depths in the Inner Tien Shan: A CryoGrid-based modeling approach integrating geophysical data
Permafrost degradation poses increasing risks to infrastructure in high-mountain regions, yet quantitative and spatially distributed assessments remain scarce in data-limited areas such as Central Asia. This study focuses on a 1,563 km² area in Inner Tien Shan, Kyrgyzstan, including the Kumtor gold mine and the Arabel plateau. We applied the numerical permafrost model CryoGrid to simulate permafrost thermal conditions and thaw depth across the study area, informed by geophysically derived stratigraphies and assessed against borehole temperatures and ground-based observations. To represent subsurface heterogeneity, surface-type-specific stratigraphies were developed for six landscape classes derived from petrophysical joint inversion of co-located Electrical Resistivity Tomography (ERT) and Refraction Seismic Tomography (RST) data. Legacy borehole measurements from 1986–1992 were incorporated to provide a multi-decadal validation of ground thermal conditions. The resulting 30 m resolution maps indicate continuous permafrost across the study area, with mean ground temperatures at 5 m depth ranging from −0.1 °C to −6.5 °C and a spatial mean of −2.9 °C. Mean thaw depth at the end of August 2024 is 2.0 m, with surface type exerting a strong control on spatial patterns. Fine-grained and vegetated sediments on the Arabel plateau show comparatively deep thaw, coinciding with thermokarst features and ground subsidence, whereas coarse-blocky debris and rock glaciers exhibit shallow thaw depths. Comparison with ERT-derived thaw depths from 15 profiles shows agreement generally within about 1 m. Simulated ground temperatures show warming trends of 0.20 °C and 0.18 °C per decade at 5 m and 20 m depth since 1975, corresponding to approximately 1 °C warming since the 1980s. These results demonstrate the value of integrating geophysical data and surface-type-specific stratigraphies into modeling studies to represent spatial variability of mountain permafrost in data-scarce regions.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-52
Reply on RC1
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- p. 1-52
Open AccessReply on RC1
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Reply on RC2
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Open AccessReply on RC2
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Reply on RC3
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- 14 March 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Open AccessReply on RC3
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- Open Access
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Comment on egusphere-2024-2795
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- 8 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2795
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- Open Access
- 26 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Comment on egusphere-2024-2795
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.
- 26 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-52
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-2795
In the Central Asian Tien Shan and Pamir mountain ranges, permafrost is extensive, but in-situ data on permafrost remains scarce. Quantitative analysis of permafrost's subsurface components—ice, water, air, and rock—is vital for not only discerning the impact of climate change on increased slope instability due to permafrost degradation, but also for understanding its role as a potential water resource in high-altitude environments. Recent studies have employed a Petrophysical Joint Inversion (PJI) approach combining geoelectrical and seismic refraction data to model the subsurface's four phases (fractions of air, water, ice, and rock). However, most of these studies primarily rely on Archie’s law, which has limitations in coarse blocky substrates typical of mountainous terrains. Recognizing this limitation, the electrical Geometric Mean (PJI-GM) model may be used as an alternative implementation within the PJI. In this study, we assess the suitability of using the PJI-GM model across an extensive geophysical dataset comprising 22 profiles in Central Asia (Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan). Our goals are to (i) address the existing data gap concerning mountain permafrost and ground ice contents in the Tien Shan and Pamir of Central Asia and (ii) evaluate the performance of the GM model in comparison to Archie's law within the PJI framework across the different landforms at remote sites. The findings reveal that the ground ice content is more specific to landform types than to the different geographic regions surveyed, with rock glaciers exhibiting the highest mean ice contents (38–60 %), followed by moraines (18–40 %), talus slopes (20–40 %), and fine-grained sediments (0–20 %). The PJI-GM model performed especially well for ice-rich landforms such as rock glaciers, accurately reflecting high ice contents with minimal variability between model runs. The quality of a model result was hereby assessed by comparing a multitude of different model runs with different sets of inversion parameters and petrophysical variables using a clustering approach. This research provides one of the first comprehensive (geophysical) in-situ datasets on permafrost on various landforms and sites in Central Asia, highlighting the potential of the PJI-GM model as a more suitable alternative to Archie’s law, particularly for rock glaciers and other ice-rich landforms. These findings significantly advance our understanding of permafrost in the Tien Shan and Pamir and serve as a baseline dataset for future modeling studies.