Lisa A. Edmonds
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Lisa A. Edmonds has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Marion C. Leaman
Department of Hearing and Speech, University of Kansas Medical Center, Kansas City
5 shared publications Jodi Morgan
Brooks Rehabilitation Aphasia Center, Jacksonville, FL
2 shared publications- Kate Nealon
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, Montclair State University, NJ
2 shared publications Addeo Russell
1 shared publicationAna Rivera
Department of Speech, Language, and Hearing Sciences, University of Florida, Gainesville
1 shared publicationBrent Archer
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, Bowling Green State University, OH
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 4 June 2026
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in Perspectives of the Asha Special Interest Groups
- Vol. 11  (3) , 711-730
Reliability of Perceptual Measurement of Apraxia of Speech Characteristics
Background: Diagnostic accuracy and reliability of acquired apraxia of speech (AOS) in the presence of co-occurring aphasia and/or dysarthria are crucial for appropriate treatment selection and clinical decision making. However, overlapping symptomology and lack of operationalization of AOS assessment methods have contributed to inadequate interrater reliability of perceptual measures differentially diagnostic of AOS. Purpose: This study investigated factors influencing the operationalization of AOS assessment methods, primarily interrater reliability of perceptual characteristics of differentially diagnostic (i.e., phonetic and prosodic errors) measures in order to inform assessment methods in AOS with concomitant aphasia. Method: Forty participants presenting with varying aphasia subtypes and severities and potential motor speech impairment were included. Speech production errors were analyzed by four raters using narrow transcription methods in response to the spoken language subtest stimuli (Naming, Repetition, and Spontaneous Speech subtests) of the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised (WAB-R). Interrater reliability of perceptual measurement of both differentially diagnostic and nondiscriminatory features of AOS were examined when using consistent stimuli (WAB-R), measures (Apraxia of Speech Rating Scale), and trained raters using narrow transcription methods. Results: Both differentially diagnostic as well as nondiscriminatory speech characteristics were shown to demonstrate adequate ( Cicchetti, 1994 ) interrater reliability across a variety of aphasia subtypes and severities in people with and without a diagnosis of AOS. Conclusions: The current work provides preliminary evidence of adequate interrater reliability of perceptual features of AOS using consistent stimuli (WAB-R spoken language stimuli), measures (Apraxia of Speech Rating Scale), and trained raters using narrow transcription. These preliminary results support the consistency and operationalization of assessment methods through the investigation of reliability of perceptual measurements of differentially diagnostic characteristics of AOS in the presence of aphasia.
- 4 June 2026
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in Perspectives of the Asha Special Interest Groups
- Vol. 11  (3) , 711-730
Reliability of Perceptual Measurement of Apraxia of Speech Characteristics
Background: Diagnostic accuracy and reliability of acquired apraxia of speech (AOS) in the presence of co-occurring aphasia and/or dysarthria are crucial for appropriate treatment selection and clinical decision making. However, overlapping symptomology and lack of operationalization of AOS assessment methods have contributed to inadequate interrater reliability of perceptual measures differentially diagnostic of AOS. Purpose: This study investigated factors influencing the operationalization of AOS assessment methods, primarily interrater reliability of perceptual characteristics of differentially diagnostic (i.e., phonetic and prosodic errors) measures in order to inform assessment methods in AOS with concomitant aphasia. Method: Forty participants presenting with varying aphasia subtypes and severities and potential motor speech impairment were included. Speech production errors were analyzed by four raters using narrow transcription methods in response to the spoken language subtest stimuli (Naming, Repetition, and Spontaneous Speech subtests) of the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised (WAB-R). Interrater reliability of perceptual measurement of both differentially diagnostic and nondiscriminatory features of AOS were examined when using consistent stimuli (WAB-R), measures (Apraxia of Speech Rating Scale), and trained raters using narrow transcription methods. Results: Both differentially diagnostic as well as nondiscriminatory speech characteristics were shown to demonstrate adequate ( Cicchetti, 1994 ) interrater reliability across a variety of aphasia subtypes and severities in people with and without a diagnosis of AOS. Conclusions: The current work provides preliminary evidence of adequate interrater reliability of perceptual features of AOS using consistent stimuli (WAB-R spoken language stimuli), measures (Apraxia of Speech Rating Scale), and trained raters using narrow transcription. These preliminary results support the consistency and operationalization of assessment methods through the investigation of reliability of perceptual measurements of differentially diagnostic characteristics of AOS in the presence of aphasia.
- 10 March 2026
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 35  (2) , 476-499
Improving Language in Individual Conversation-Level Therapy: Group and Individual Results of ECoLoGiC Treatment for People With Moderate and Severe Aphasia
Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate group- and individual-level impact of ECoLoGiC (Expanding Communication and Language Opportunities Generated in Conversation) Treatment (ECoLoGiC-Tx), an aphasia intervention aimed at improving conversational language. In addition, treatment fidelity for the speech-language pathologists (SLPs) who delivered treatment was evaluated, providing feasibility data to optimize successful future field implementation. Method: Ten people with moderate or severe aphasia completed 10 weeks of ECoLoGiC-Tx delivered twice weekly for 1 hr. Testing occurred at pretreatment, posttreatment, and at 6 weeks maintenance. Conversation/monologue samples were collected three times per testing phase. Group results were analyzed using linear mixed models. Individual data were analyzed using effect size and minimal detectable change criteria. Treatment fidelity was analyzed using an established 23-point checklist. Results: Robust results indicate generalization across measure types at group and individual levels. Participants improved their ability to convey meaning in conversation, the primary focus of ECoLoGiC-Tx. They demonstrated an average gain of 11.31 points on the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised (range: −1 to 21.5), and 7/10 participants shifted to a less impaired category of severity (e.g., from severe to moderate aphasia). Group-level change did not occur for reading, sentence construction in a picture task or in monologue, or Grammaticality in conversation/monologue. SLP fidelity was 97.3%. Conclusions: Pilot study findings were replicated, with robust group and individual results. Exceptional improvements occurred for 9/10 participants. Results demonstrate generalization of skills to conversation and reduced aphasia severity for most participants. Deliverability of ECoLoGiC-Tx was evidenced by very high treatment fidelity by practicing SLPs, suggesting good potential for successful field implementation. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.30856571
- 10 March 2026
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 35  (2) , 476-499
Improving Language in Individual Conversation-Level Therapy: Group and Individual Results of ECoLoGiC Treatment for People With Moderate and Severe Aphasia
Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate group- and individual-level impact of ECoLoGiC (Expanding Communication and Language Opportunities Generated in Conversation) Treatment (ECoLoGiC-Tx), an aphasia intervention aimed at improving conversational language. In addition, treatment fidelity for the speech-language pathologists (SLPs) who delivered treatment was evaluated, providing feasibility data to optimize successful future field implementation. Method: Ten people with moderate or severe aphasia completed 10 weeks of ECoLoGiC-Tx delivered twice weekly for 1 hr. Testing occurred at pretreatment, posttreatment, and at 6 weeks maintenance. Conversation/monologue samples were collected three times per testing phase. Group results were analyzed using linear mixed models. Individual data were analyzed using effect size and minimal detectable change criteria. Treatment fidelity was analyzed using an established 23-point checklist. Results: Robust results indicate generalization across measure types at group and individual levels. Participants improved their ability to convey meaning in conversation, the primary focus of ECoLoGiC-Tx. They demonstrated an average gain of 11.31 points on the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised (range: −1 to 21.5), and 7/10 participants shifted to a less impaired category of severity (e.g., from severe to moderate aphasia). Group-level change did not occur for reading, sentence construction in a picture task or in monologue, or Grammaticality in conversation/monologue. SLP fidelity was 97.3%. Conclusions: Pilot study findings were replicated, with robust group and individual results. Exceptional improvements occurred for 9/10 participants. Results demonstrate generalization of skills to conversation and reduced aphasia severity for most participants. Deliverability of ECoLoGiC-Tx was evidenced by very high treatment fidelity by practicing SLPs, suggesting good potential for successful field implementation. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.30856571
- 3 October 2024
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in Perspectives of the Asha Special Interest Groups
- Vol. 9  (5) , 1265-1279
Utilization of Western Aphasia Battery–Revised Spoken Language Subtest Stimuli to Characterize Differentially Diagnostic Characteristics of Acquired Apraxia of Speech
Purpose: There is a need for stimuli that can be used in the assessment of apraxia of speech (AOS) characteristics. AOS often presents with aphasia, and the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised (WAB-R) is administered extensively in clinical practice for the assessment of aphasia. This preliminary study investigated error production of differentially diagnostic characteristics of AOS (phonetic and prosodic errors) in response to existing spoken language subtest stimuli of the WAB-R in individuals with concomitant AOS and aphasia and aphasia only. Method: Ten participants presenting with aphasia and potential motor speech impairment were included. Presence of AOS was determined for five individuals. Speech production errors were analyzed using narrow transcription methods in response to the Naming, Repetition, and Spontaneous Speech subtests of the WAB-R for both AOS and aphasia and aphasia-only groups. Results: Differences in total error production for both phonetic and prosodic errors were reported between the AOS and aphasia and aphasia-only groups. In addition, the phonetic complexity of the stimuli correlated to the phonetic and prosodic error production in both groups. An effect of WAB-R subtest was not reported for either group. Conclusion: The diversity of elicited spoken language production across multiple contexts makes the use of the spoken language subtest stimuli a feasible component of a comprehensive AOS assessment, since AOS is often concomitant with aphasia.
- 3 October 2024
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in Perspectives of the Asha Special Interest Groups
- Vol. 9  (5) , 1265-1279
Utilization of Western Aphasia Battery–Revised Spoken Language Subtest Stimuli to Characterize Differentially Diagnostic Characteristics of Acquired Apraxia of Speech
Purpose: There is a need for stimuli that can be used in the assessment of apraxia of speech (AOS) characteristics. AOS often presents with aphasia, and the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised (WAB-R) is administered extensively in clinical practice for the assessment of aphasia. This preliminary study investigated error production of differentially diagnostic characteristics of AOS (phonetic and prosodic errors) in response to existing spoken language subtest stimuli of the WAB-R in individuals with concomitant AOS and aphasia and aphasia only. Method: Ten participants presenting with aphasia and potential motor speech impairment were included. Presence of AOS was determined for five individuals. Speech production errors were analyzed using narrow transcription methods in response to the Naming, Repetition, and Spontaneous Speech subtests of the WAB-R for both AOS and aphasia and aphasia-only groups. Results: Differences in total error production for both phonetic and prosodic errors were reported between the AOS and aphasia and aphasia-only groups. In addition, the phonetic complexity of the stimuli correlated to the phonetic and prosodic error production in both groups. An effect of WAB-R subtest was not reported for either group. Conclusion: The diversity of elicited spoken language production across multiple contexts makes the use of the spoken language subtest stimuli a feasible component of a comprehensive AOS assessment, since AOS is often concomitant with aphasia.
- 3 January 2024
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 33  (1) , 153-172
Pilot Results for ECoLoGiC-Tx: A New Conversation-Level Intervention Improving Language in People With Moderate to Severe Aphasia
Purpose: This study reports pilot data for a novel intervention, ECoLoGiC-Tx, delivered to four people with moderate to severe aphasia. ECoLoGiC-Tx addresses language and communication in unstructured, participant-led conversation. The speech-language pathologist (SLP) uses a framework to choose turns that facilitate a social interaction. When communication breakdown occurs, the SLP implements a least-to-most hierarchy to maximize the people with aphasia's (PWA's) independence in self-repair. ECoLoGiC-Tx draws its theoretical underpinnings from conversation analysis and theories of rehabilitation, including principles of complexity, neuroplasticity, and learning. Method: Four PWA attended 60-min sessions twice weekly for 10 weeks. Assessment occurred at pretreatment, posttreatment, and 6-week maintenance. Outcomes included established discourse measures for conversation and monologue, tests of language and functional communication, and patient-/family-reported outcome measures (P/FROMs). Discourse samples were collected three times per assessment. Interrater reliability and fidelity for assessment and treatment procedures are reported. Results: Participants presented with Broca's aphasia (one moderate, one severe) or conduction aphasia (one moderate, one severe). Each demonstrated improvements in discourse, test batteries, and P/FROMs. They all demonstrated reduced aphasia severity measured by the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised at posttreatment or maintenance. Change in conversation and monologue was robust for three participants, but was mixed for one person (P1: moderate Broca's aphasia). P/FROMs indicated improvement at posttreatment and maintenance for all participants. Most treatment gains were maintained at 6-week follow-up. Conclusions: This study provides promising results for ECoLoGiC-Tx to improve language function of people with chronic moderate to severe aphasia. Generalization occurred to tests, functional communication, spontaneous conversation, and structured monologue tasks.
- 3 January 2024
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 33  (1) , 153-172
Pilot Results for ECoLoGiC-Tx: A New Conversation-Level Intervention Improving Language in People With Moderate to Severe Aphasia
Purpose: This study reports pilot data for a novel intervention, ECoLoGiC-Tx, delivered to four people with moderate to severe aphasia. ECoLoGiC-Tx addresses language and communication in unstructured, participant-led conversation. The speech-language pathologist (SLP) uses a framework to choose turns that facilitate a social interaction. When communication breakdown occurs, the SLP implements a least-to-most hierarchy to maximize the people with aphasia's (PWA's) independence in self-repair. ECoLoGiC-Tx draws its theoretical underpinnings from conversation analysis and theories of rehabilitation, including principles of complexity, neuroplasticity, and learning. Method: Four PWA attended 60-min sessions twice weekly for 10 weeks. Assessment occurred at pretreatment, posttreatment, and 6-week maintenance. Outcomes included established discourse measures for conversation and monologue, tests of language and functional communication, and patient-/family-reported outcome measures (P/FROMs). Discourse samples were collected three times per assessment. Interrater reliability and fidelity for assessment and treatment procedures are reported. Results: Participants presented with Broca's aphasia (one moderate, one severe) or conduction aphasia (one moderate, one severe). Each demonstrated improvements in discourse, test batteries, and P/FROMs. They all demonstrated reduced aphasia severity measured by the Western Aphasia Battery–Revised at posttreatment or maintenance. Change in conversation and monologue was robust for three participants, but was mixed for one person (P1: moderate Broca's aphasia). P/FROMs indicated improvement at posttreatment and maintenance for all participants. Most treatment gains were maintained at 6-week follow-up. Conclusions: This study provides promising results for ECoLoGiC-Tx to improve language function of people with chronic moderate to severe aphasia. Generalization occurred to tests, functional communication, spontaneous conversation, and structured monologue tasks.
- 5 December 2023
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- p. 1-16
Handwritten and Typed Discourse in People With Aphasia: Reference Data for Sequential Picture Description and Comparison of Performance Across Modality
Purpose: Writing can be completed by hand or by typing. Increasingly, functional and social activities are completed in the virtual domain, which often requires discourse level writing. Yet, there is a shortage of research on discourse writing in aphasia. The purpose of this study was to provide preliminary reference data for a sequential picture description task in writing by hand and typing for people with aphasia. Additionally, we examined individual modality differences when comparing handwritten and typed discourse. Method: Fifteen people with mild–moderate aphasia participated in this study. They completed a sequential picture description task in handwriting and in typing. Discourse samples were coded for Correct Information Units (CIUs) and Complete Utterances. Measures of productivity were also evaluated (e.g., Total Words, Total Utterances). Participants completed a computer use questionnaire regarding their current and premorbid typing and computer use. Results: Preliminary reference data are reported. No significant differences were found at the group level for the measures evaluated. At the individual level, there was evidence of a modality effect for seven participants who demonstrated differences in the proportion of CIUs. Conclusions: Although preliminary, these findings suggest that, at the group level, the handwritten and typed discourse produced by people with mild–moderate aphasia is similar. However, at the individual level, there is potential for modality differences. Consistent patterns of premorbid computer use, difficulty ratings, and individual differences in writing modes were not identified for the participants who demonstrated a modality effect. However, there was preliminary evidence that poststroke handedness may contribute to modality differences exhibited by some participants, which should be explored in future research. Additionally, these reference data are preliminary and further research is required from a more heterogeneous group of people with aphasia and to better establish assessment practices for discourse writing.
- 5 December 2023
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- p. 1-16
Handwritten and Typed Discourse in People With Aphasia: Reference Data for Sequential Picture Description and Comparison of Performance Across Modality
Purpose: Writing can be completed by hand or by typing. Increasingly, functional and social activities are completed in the virtual domain, which often requires discourse level writing. Yet, there is a shortage of research on discourse writing in aphasia. The purpose of this study was to provide preliminary reference data for a sequential picture description task in writing by hand and typing for people with aphasia. Additionally, we examined individual modality differences when comparing handwritten and typed discourse. Method: Fifteen people with mild–moderate aphasia participated in this study. They completed a sequential picture description task in handwriting and in typing. Discourse samples were coded for Correct Information Units (CIUs) and Complete Utterances. Measures of productivity were also evaluated (e.g., Total Words, Total Utterances). Participants completed a computer use questionnaire regarding their current and premorbid typing and computer use. Results: Preliminary reference data are reported. No significant differences were found at the group level for the measures evaluated. At the individual level, there was evidence of a modality effect for seven participants who demonstrated differences in the proportion of CIUs. Conclusions: Although preliminary, these findings suggest that, at the group level, the handwritten and typed discourse produced by people with mild–moderate aphasia is similar. However, at the individual level, there is potential for modality differences. Consistent patterns of premorbid computer use, difficulty ratings, and individual differences in writing modes were not identified for the participants who demonstrated a modality effect. However, there was preliminary evidence that poststroke handedness may contribute to modality differences exhibited by some participants, which should be explored in future research. Additionally, these reference data are preliminary and further research is required from a more heterogeneous group of people with aphasia and to better establish assessment practices for discourse writing.
- Top Cited Papers
- 10 July 2023
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 32  (4) , 1413-1430
Analyzing Language in the Picnic Scene Picture and in Conversation: The Type of Discourse Sample We Choose Influences Findings in People With Aphasia
Purpose: People with aphasia express that improved conversational discourse is a primary rehabilitation goal. Discourse is usually assessed using monologue, such as a picture description task, but research shows that language in monologue varies from language in everyday conversation. Consequently, we investigated the relationship of language in unstructured conversation and in the picnic scene picture because it is a part of the most often used aphasia battery (Western Aphasia Battery–Revised) and thus is frequently used to inform therapy. Second, because previous research suggests people with severe aphasia may not demonstrate language production variability between types of monologue-level discourse, we evaluated the relationship of severity and the difference in scores between conversation and the picnic scene task. Method: Thirty-four people with mild-to-severe aphasia described the picnic scene and provided a conversation sample. We measured language production and communicative success using seven measures with established psychometrics in conversation/monologue. We conducted correlations to answer the research questions. Results: Correlations were moderate and weaker for the measures in the two conditions. A strong negative relationship was demonstrated between aphasia severity and global coherence. All other relationships were moderate and weaker for the remaining measures when correlated with aphasia severity (also negative). Conclusions: Results are consistent with other studies indicating that language varies in different types of discourse. We conclude that for accurate, meaningful assessment, discourse sampling needs to include the specific type of discourse the individual wishes to address in therapy, because discourse samples and their findings are not interchangeable.
- 10 July 2023
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 32  (4) , 1413-1430
Top Cited PapersAnalyzing Language in the Picnic Scene Picture and in Conversation: The Type of Discourse Sample We Choose Influences Findings in People With Aphasia
Purpose: People with aphasia express that improved conversational discourse is a primary rehabilitation goal. Discourse is usually assessed using monologue, such as a picture description task, but research shows that language in monologue varies from language in everyday conversation. Consequently, we investigated the relationship of language in unstructured conversation and in the picnic scene picture because it is a part of the most often used aphasia battery (Western Aphasia Battery–Revised) and thus is frequently used to inform therapy. Second, because previous research suggests people with severe aphasia may not demonstrate language production variability between types of monologue-level discourse, we evaluated the relationship of severity and the difference in scores between conversation and the picnic scene task. Method: Thirty-four people with mild-to-severe aphasia described the picnic scene and provided a conversation sample. We measured language production and communicative success using seven measures with established psychometrics in conversation/monologue. We conducted correlations to answer the research questions. Results: Correlations were moderate and weaker for the measures in the two conditions. A strong negative relationship was demonstrated between aphasia severity and global coherence. All other relationships were moderate and weaker for the remaining measures when correlated with aphasia severity (also negative). Conclusions: Results are consistent with other studies indicating that language varies in different types of discourse. We conclude that for accurate, meaningful assessment, discourse sampling needs to include the specific type of discourse the individual wishes to address in therapy, because discourse samples and their findings are not interchangeable.
- Open Access
- 25 October 2022
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 31  (5S) , 2378-2394
Two-Year Longitudinal Evaluation of Community Aphasia Center Participation on Linguistic, Functional Communication, and Quality of Life Measures Across People With a Range of Aphasia Presentations
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate potential changes on a hierarchy of language tasks and measures of functional communication and quality of life in a group of people with aphasia (PWA) who attended a community aphasia center for 2 years. A secondary purpose was to determine whether there were any predictors of change. Method: Twenty-seven PWA who attended Brooks Rehabilitation Aphasia Center (BRAC) were evaluated on an aphasia battery, confrontation naming, and structured discourse in addition to completing self-reported measures of functional communication and quality of life at three time points: before attending BRAC and after 1 ( N = 27) and 2 ( N = 20) years of BRAC participation. Twenty-six communication partners who communicated regularly with the PWA completed a questionnaire about their functional communication at the same time points. A mixed linear model was conducted for all dependent variables to determine change over time. Tau-b correlations were conducted between demographic and aphasia-related variables and difference scores for outcome measures that exhibited significant improvements. Results: At 1-year testing, significant improvements were observed on the aphasia battery, object and action naming, and all self- and communication partner–reported measures. At 2-year testing, all improvements were maintained except for the self-reported measure of functional communication. Structured discourse showed increases in average number of words, percentage of meaningful words and utterances, and efficiency of meaningful word production after 2 years. No significant correlations were observed between predictor variables and difference scores. Conclusions: Participation in aphasia centers can result in significant changes in language, functional communication, and quality of life in people with chronic aphasia. These findings support the importance of aphasia centers in the continuum of care for PWA. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.21313689
- 25 October 2022
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 31  (5S) , 2378-2394
Open AccessTwo-Year Longitudinal Evaluation of Community Aphasia Center Participation on Linguistic, Functional Communication, and Quality of Life Measures Across People With a Range of Aphasia Presentations
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to evaluate potential changes on a hierarchy of language tasks and measures of functional communication and quality of life in a group of people with aphasia (PWA) who attended a community aphasia center for 2 years. A secondary purpose was to determine whether there were any predictors of change. Method: Twenty-seven PWA who attended Brooks Rehabilitation Aphasia Center (BRAC) were evaluated on an aphasia battery, confrontation naming, and structured discourse in addition to completing self-reported measures of functional communication and quality of life at three time points: before attending BRAC and after 1 ( N = 27) and 2 ( N = 20) years of BRAC participation. Twenty-six communication partners who communicated regularly with the PWA completed a questionnaire about their functional communication at the same time points. A mixed linear model was conducted for all dependent variables to determine change over time. Tau-b correlations were conducted between demographic and aphasia-related variables and difference scores for outcome measures that exhibited significant improvements. Results: At 1-year testing, significant improvements were observed on the aphasia battery, object and action naming, and all self- and communication partner–reported measures. At 2-year testing, all improvements were maintained except for the self-reported measure of functional communication. Structured discourse showed increases in average number of words, percentage of meaningful words and utterances, and efficiency of meaningful word production after 2 years. No significant correlations were observed between predictor variables and difference scores. Conclusions: Participation in aphasia centers can result in significant changes in language, functional communication, and quality of life in people with chronic aphasia. These findings support the importance of aphasia centers in the continuum of care for PWA. Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.21313689
- 18 January 2022
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 31  (1) , 322-341
Toward Empowering Conversational Agency in Aphasia: Understanding Mechanisms of Topic Initiation in People With and Without Aphasia
Purpose: This study examined topic initiation (TI) in conversations involving people with aphasia (PWA), matched people without aphasia (M-PWoA), and speech-language pathologists who were their conversation partners (SLP-Ps). For each speaker type, we analyzed patterns of distribution of typical mechanisms of TI and patterns of simultaneous use of multiple TI mechanisms. Lastly, we examined associations between use of simultaneous TI mechanisms and communicative success.Method: Twenty PWA and 20 M-PWoA each participated in two conversations with SLP-Ps. Conversation samples were analyzed for TI locations and mechanisms, with results tallied for each speaker type following a published typology. A measure of communicative success was applied to TI utterances. Rank-order correlations were conducted to evaluate the patterns of distribution of the TI mechanisms between speaker types and the patterns of multiple mechanism usage between speaker types. Descriptive analysis was conducted to provide additional insight to the TI behaviors of each speaker type and to evaluate the relationship between multiple TI mechanisms and communicative success.Results: All speaker types used cohesion most often to achieve TI. PWA used an abrupt method of TI (noncoherent TI) more often than other speaker types. A single mechanism of TI was used most often by all speaker types, except for SLP-Ps when they were in conversations with PWA. In this case, SLP-Ps most often used two or more layered mechanisms of TI. SLP-Ps also used a highly salient TI mechanism with greater frequency when speaking with PWA than observed between other speaker types. When PWA layered mechanisms of TI, they appeared to be more likely to achieve better communicative success.Conclusions: Specific, teachable behaviors such as favoring certain TI mechanisms and using multiple TI mechanisms may improve communicative success during TI for PWA. Furthermore, findings suggest that SLP-Ps modify their TI behaviors when speaking to PWA.Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.17699423
- 18 January 2022
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 31  (1) , 322-341
Toward Empowering Conversational Agency in Aphasia: Understanding Mechanisms of Topic Initiation in People With and Without Aphasia
Purpose: This study examined topic initiation (TI) in conversations involving people with aphasia (PWA), matched people without aphasia (M-PWoA), and speech-language pathologists who were their conversation partners (SLP-Ps). For each speaker type, we analyzed patterns of distribution of typical mechanisms of TI and patterns of simultaneous use of multiple TI mechanisms. Lastly, we examined associations between use of simultaneous TI mechanisms and communicative success.Method: Twenty PWA and 20 M-PWoA each participated in two conversations with SLP-Ps. Conversation samples were analyzed for TI locations and mechanisms, with results tallied for each speaker type following a published typology. A measure of communicative success was applied to TI utterances. Rank-order correlations were conducted to evaluate the patterns of distribution of the TI mechanisms between speaker types and the patterns of multiple mechanism usage between speaker types. Descriptive analysis was conducted to provide additional insight to the TI behaviors of each speaker type and to evaluate the relationship between multiple TI mechanisms and communicative success.Results: All speaker types used cohesion most often to achieve TI. PWA used an abrupt method of TI (noncoherent TI) more often than other speaker types. A single mechanism of TI was used most often by all speaker types, except for SLP-Ps when they were in conversations with PWA. In this case, SLP-Ps most often used two or more layered mechanisms of TI. SLP-Ps also used a highly salient TI mechanism with greater frequency when speaking with PWA than observed between other speaker types. When PWA layered mechanisms of TI, they appeared to be more likely to achieve better communicative success.Conclusions: Specific, teachable behaviors such as favoring certain TI mechanisms and using multiple TI mechanisms may improve communicative success during TI for PWA. Furthermore, findings suggest that SLP-Ps modify their TI behaviors when speaking to PWA.Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.17699423
- 11 March 2019
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 28  (1S) , 359-372
Conversation in Aphasia Across Communication Partners: Exploring Stability of Microlinguistic Measures and Communicative Success
Purpose: The aim of this study was to determine if people with aphasia demonstrate differences in microlinguistic skills and communicative success in unstructured, nontherapeutic conversations with a home communication partner (Home-P) as compared to a speech-language pathologist communication partner (SLP-P).Method: Eight persons with aphasia participated in 2 unstructured, nontherapeutic 15-minute conversations, 1 each with an unfamiliar SLP-P and a Home-P. Utterance-level analysis evaluated communicative success. Two narrow measures of lexical relevance and sentence frame were used to evaluate independent clauses. Two broad lexical and morphosyntactic measures were used to evaluate elliptical and dependent clauses and to evaluate independent clauses for errors beyond lexical relevance and sentence frame (such as phonological and morphosyntactic errors). Utterances were further evaluated for presence of behaviors indicating lexical retrieval difficulty (pauses, repetitions, and false starts) and for referential cohesion.Results: No statistical differences occurred for communicative success or for any of the microlinguistic measures between the SLP-P and Home-P conversation conditions. Four measures (2 of lexical retrieval and 1 each of communicative success and grammaticality) showed high correlations across the 2 conversation samples. Individuals showed variation of no more than 10 percentage points between the 2 conversation conditions for 46 of 56 data points. Variation greater than 10 percentage points tended to occur for the measure of referential cohesion and primarily for 1 participant.Conclusions: Preliminary findings suggest that these microlinguistic measures and communicative success have potential for reliable comparison across Home-P and SLP-P conversations, with the possible exception of referential cohesion. However, further research is needed with a larger, more diverse sample. These findings suggest future assessment and treatment implications for clinical and research needs.Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.7616312
- 11 March 2019
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 28  (1S) , 359-372
Conversation in Aphasia Across Communication Partners: Exploring Stability of Microlinguistic Measures and Communicative Success
Purpose: The aim of this study was to determine if people with aphasia demonstrate differences in microlinguistic skills and communicative success in unstructured, nontherapeutic conversations with a home communication partner (Home-P) as compared to a speech-language pathologist communication partner (SLP-P).Method: Eight persons with aphasia participated in 2 unstructured, nontherapeutic 15-minute conversations, 1 each with an unfamiliar SLP-P and a Home-P. Utterance-level analysis evaluated communicative success. Two narrow measures of lexical relevance and sentence frame were used to evaluate independent clauses. Two broad lexical and morphosyntactic measures were used to evaluate elliptical and dependent clauses and to evaluate independent clauses for errors beyond lexical relevance and sentence frame (such as phonological and morphosyntactic errors). Utterances were further evaluated for presence of behaviors indicating lexical retrieval difficulty (pauses, repetitions, and false starts) and for referential cohesion.Results: No statistical differences occurred for communicative success or for any of the microlinguistic measures between the SLP-P and Home-P conversation conditions. Four measures (2 of lexical retrieval and 1 each of communicative success and grammaticality) showed high correlations across the 2 conversation samples. Individuals showed variation of no more than 10 percentage points between the 2 conversation conditions for 46 of 56 data points. Variation greater than 10 percentage points tended to occur for the measure of referential cohesion and primarily for 1 participant.Conclusions: Preliminary findings suggest that these microlinguistic measures and communicative success have potential for reliable comparison across Home-P and SLP-P conversations, with the possible exception of referential cohesion. However, further research is needed with a larger, more diverse sample. These findings suggest future assessment and treatment implications for clinical and research needs.Supplemental Material: https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.7616312
- 6 February 2018
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 27  (1) , 52-70
Evaluation of Language Predictors of Main Concept Production in Spanish/English Bilingual Discourse Using Nicholas and Brookshire Stimuli
Purpose A conceptual framework of bilingual aphasia assessment requires an understanding of the variables that influence discourse in bilingual speakers. This study aimed to determine predictors of main concept (MC) production, a measure of discourse completeness, as well as the effect of language dominance on MCs. Method The Nicholas and Brookshire (1993) picture stimuli were used to elicit English and Spanish discourse in 83 young bilinguals. Participant-reported variables (e.g., proficiency self-ratings) and measured language variables (e.g., correct information units [CIUs] in discourse) were entered into regressions to determine potential MC predictors. A repeated-measures analysis of variance evaluated MCs within and across dominance groups categorized by speaking self-ratings. Results Measured language variables (number of CIUs, naming accuracy) were most predictive of MCs. The participant-reported variable most associated with MC production was self-rating of speaking proficiency. Spanish- and English-dominant groups produced more MCs in their dominant language; the balanced group produced more English MCs. Between-groups differences were observed. Conclusions Two measures related to lexical retrieval (CIUs and naming) were most predictive of MC production across languages. Participant ratings of speaking proficiency were also highly correlated to MCs. They also accurately reflected dominance, though balanced bilinguals overestimated their Spanish abilities. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.5708605
- 6 February 2018
- Published by American Speech Language Hearing Association in American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology
- Vol. 27  (1) , 52-70
Evaluation of Language Predictors of Main Concept Production in Spanish/English Bilingual Discourse Using Nicholas and Brookshire Stimuli
Purpose A conceptual framework of bilingual aphasia assessment requires an understanding of the variables that influence discourse in bilingual speakers. This study aimed to determine predictors of main concept (MC) production, a measure of discourse completeness, as well as the effect of language dominance on MCs. Method The Nicholas and Brookshire (1993) picture stimuli were used to elicit English and Spanish discourse in 83 young bilinguals. Participant-reported variables (e.g., proficiency self-ratings) and measured language variables (e.g., correct information units [CIUs] in discourse) were entered into regressions to determine potential MC predictors. A repeated-measures analysis of variance evaluated MCs within and across dominance groups categorized by speaking self-ratings. Results Measured language variables (number of CIUs, naming accuracy) were most predictive of MCs. The participant-reported variable most associated with MC production was self-rating of speaking proficiency. Spanish- and English-dominant groups produced more MCs in their dominant language; the balanced group produced more English MCs. Between-groups differences were observed. Conclusions Two measures related to lexical retrieval (CIUs and naming) were most predictive of MC production across languages. Participant ratings of speaking proficiency were also highly correlated to MCs. They also accurately reflected dominance, though balanced bilinguals overestimated their Spanish abilities. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.5708605