Changkun Cai
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Changkun Cai has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Na Tang
College of Public Administration Huazhong University of Science and Technology Wuhan China
4 shared publications Qiyao Shen
College of Public Administration Huazhong University of Science and Technology Wuhan China
2 shared publications- Zifan Yu
Sun Yat-sen University
2 shared publications Lei Yang
College of Public Administration, Huazhong University of Science and Technology
1 shared publicationLi Cheng
Sichuan Provincial Development and Reform Commission, Chengdu, China
1 shared publicationNan Zhou
Law School, Renmin University of China, Beijing, Haidian, China
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 12 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Review of Policy Research
- Vol. 43 (4) , e70115
Differentiated Institutionalization: How Is a Policy Innovation Institutionalized Within the Bureaucratic Organization?
The efficacy of policy innovation largely rests on its internalization into the institutionalized practices of bureaucratic organizations. Existing research has explored the concept, influencing factors, and process of innovation institutionalization, but thus far, studies have not yet opened the internal “black box” of innovations going into organizations. This study constructs an analytical framework for the institutionalization of a policy innovation based on inhabited institutionalism. Then, this framework is applied to the case study of the Establishing Legal Counsel Systems (ELCS) in CL County, China. The findings show that policy innovation is institutionalized through a pattern of “differentiated institutionalization,” which is comprised of both temporal and structural dimensions. Temporally, innovation institutionalization unfolds through four stages: innovation entry, initial institutionalization, innovation routinization, and continuous evolution. Structurally, the institutionalization of policy innovation is characterized by sequential construction at the management level and variegated coupling at the practice level. These processes result in dynamic quasi‐institutionalization. This study establishes a process perspective for the institutionalization of a policy innovation and attempts to dissolve the tension and boundaries between innovation and institutionalization.
- 12 July 2026
- Published by Wiley in Review of Policy Research
- Vol. 43 (4) , e70115
Differentiated Institutionalization: How Is a Policy Innovation Institutionalized Within the Bureaucratic Organization?
The efficacy of policy innovation largely rests on its internalization into the institutionalized practices of bureaucratic organizations. Existing research has explored the concept, influencing factors, and process of innovation institutionalization, but thus far, studies have not yet opened the internal “black box” of innovations going into organizations. This study constructs an analytical framework for the institutionalization of a policy innovation based on inhabited institutionalism. Then, this framework is applied to the case study of the Establishing Legal Counsel Systems (ELCS) in CL County, China. The findings show that policy innovation is institutionalized through a pattern of “differentiated institutionalization,” which is comprised of both temporal and structural dimensions. Temporally, innovation institutionalization unfolds through four stages: innovation entry, initial institutionalization, innovation routinization, and continuous evolution. Structurally, the institutionalization of policy innovation is characterized by sequential construction at the management level and variegated coupling at the practice level. These processes result in dynamic quasi‐institutionalization. This study establishes a process perspective for the institutionalization of a policy innovation and attempts to dissolve the tension and boundaries between innovation and institutionalization.
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice
- Vol. 28 (3) , 259-314
Orchestrating Regime: A Comparative Analysis of Policies for Tackling Wicked Problems
Wicked problems have become a prominent topic in the fields of public administration and policy research (Rittel and Webber 1973; Roberts 2000; Weber and Khademian 2008). In contrast to tamed and b...
- 12 March 2026
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice
- Vol. 28 (3) , 259-314
Orchestrating Regime: A Comparative Analysis of Policies for Tackling Wicked Problems
Wicked problems have become a prominent topic in the fields of public administration and policy research (Rittel and Webber 1973; Roberts 2000; Weber and Khademian 2008). In contrast to tamed and b...
- 3 July 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The China Quarterly
- Vol. 263, 666-684
Constructing Consent: How Grassroots Governments Reshape the State–Peasant Relationship in the Xi Era
After the rural tax and fee reform in China in the 2000s, the increased administrative nature of rural governance weakened state–peasant connections, rendering local cadres’ traditional societal-oriented consent strategies ineffective. To gain peasants’ consent to state policies and reconnect with them, grassroots officials adopted a more complex, covert and naturalized strategy for constructing consent, integrating it into peasants’ daily lives. This study uses the “rural construction” initiative in Chuxi county, China, as a case study to explore the construction of consent. The findings indicate that constructing peasant consent is a process of continuous interaction between the individual actor and social structures. In the regularization phase, grassroots officials use institutional practices to facilitate consent, including winning the hearts and minds of villagers, solving “thought” problems, shaping behavioural norms and cultivating lower-level agents. In the mobilization phase, when consent is needed, grassroots officials flexibly adapt the pre-established institutional elements to elicit specific consent. They do this by fostering an atmosphere of consent, employing divide-and-rule tactics, and contextualizing rules. The study concludes that the party-state is building a broader form of peasant consent in the Xi era, which extends beyond consent to policies.
- 3 July 2025
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The China Quarterly
- Vol. 263, 666-684
Constructing Consent: How Grassroots Governments Reshape the State–Peasant Relationship in the Xi Era
After the rural tax and fee reform in China in the 2000s, the increased administrative nature of rural governance weakened state–peasant connections, rendering local cadres’ traditional societal-oriented consent strategies ineffective. To gain peasants’ consent to state policies and reconnect with them, grassroots officials adopted a more complex, covert and naturalized strategy for constructing consent, integrating it into peasants’ daily lives. This study uses the “rural construction” initiative in Chuxi county, China, as a case study to explore the construction of consent. The findings indicate that constructing peasant consent is a process of continuous interaction between the individual actor and social structures. In the regularization phase, grassroots officials use institutional practices to facilitate consent, including winning the hearts and minds of villagers, solving “thought” problems, shaping behavioural norms and cultivating lower-level agents. In the mobilization phase, when consent is needed, grassroots officials flexibly adapt the pre-established institutional elements to elicit specific consent. They do this by fostering an atmosphere of consent, employing divide-and-rule tactics, and contextualizing rules. The study concludes that the party-state is building a broader form of peasant consent in the Xi era, which extends beyond consent to policies.
- 3 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (2) , 99-129
From Policy Adoption to Practice: Comparative Analysis of Innovation Institutionalization Paths
As a vital part of a “democratic laboratory”, policy innovation in local government plays a significant role in policy learning and the improvement of governance capacity (Volden 2006). Existing re...
- 3 March 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice
- Vol. 26 (2) , 99-129
From Policy Adoption to Practice: Comparative Analysis of Innovation Institutionalization Paths
As a vital part of a “democratic laboratory”, policy innovation in local government plays a significant role in policy learning and the improvement of governance capacity (Volden 2006). Existing re...
- 23 February 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The China Quarterly
- Vol. 254, 412-428
Bringing the Party Back into the Community: Restructuring Grassroots Governance in Shenzhen
While burgeoning research on China's state–society relations has paid attention to the Party, little is known about how the Party interacts with diverse actors and involves itself at the grassroots level in a specific region. This article delineates Party-advancement strategies at the community level in Shenzhen since 2013. To reclaim its leading role at the grassroots level, the Party opted for “Party–government disaggregation” by framing community governance as a Party-building affair, separating the government's affairs from those of the Party and “kicking” the government out of the community. Under the rubric of “reshaping Party–mass relations,” the Party penetrated deep into the community by innovating a “centre-periphery” organizational system, absorbing community elites in a top-down way and using a “service delivery taking the lead” method in a reciprocal exchange. In the end, the Party-governance structure, in which Party–mass relations are at the core, was reframed in the communities.
- 23 February 2023
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The China Quarterly
- Vol. 254, 412-428
Bringing the Party Back into the Community: Restructuring Grassroots Governance in Shenzhen
While burgeoning research on China's state–society relations has paid attention to the Party, little is known about how the Party interacts with diverse actors and involves itself at the grassroots level in a specific region. This article delineates Party-advancement strategies at the community level in Shenzhen since 2013. To reclaim its leading role at the grassroots level, the Party opted for “Party–government disaggregation” by framing community governance as a Party-building affair, separating the government's affairs from those of the Party and “kicking” the government out of the community. Under the rubric of “reshaping Party–mass relations,” the Party penetrated deep into the community by innovating a “centre-periphery” organizational system, absorbing community elites in a top-down way and using a “service delivery taking the lead” method in a reciprocal exchange. In the end, the Party-governance structure, in which Party–mass relations are at the core, was reframed in the communities.
- 19 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Public Management Journal
- Vol. 26 (2) , 240-257
Through the mist: how institution-knowledge bricoleurs make sense of a crisis
As society faces more crises, it is critical for leaders, especially at the local level, to make decisions and intervene before reaching the tipping point. This often requires collective sensemaking across boundaries, but most studies focus on the challenges. This article asks how decision makers make timely decisions. It presents an institutions-process framework and analyzes the process and mechanism in the case of the response of E-Zhong City—just over an hour’s drive from Wuhan City in Hubei Province—to COVID-19 in the “Golden Seven Days” of 2020. Decision makers achieved timely decisions by exploiting all possible political opportunities and institutional tools, maximizing the diversity of the information available, and using multiple discourses and frameworks to enhance personal crisis awareness and achieve collective sensemaking across boundaries. This article defines the mechanism as bricolage and defines these decision makers as institution-knowledge bricoleurs. The concept of institution-knowledge bricoleurs extends the study of crisis decision making and the relationship between institutions and sensemaking.
- 19 January 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Public Management Journal
- Vol. 26 (2) , 240-257
Through the mist: how institution-knowledge bricoleurs make sense of a crisis
As society faces more crises, it is critical for leaders, especially at the local level, to make decisions and intervene before reaching the tipping point. This often requires collective sensemaking across boundaries, but most studies focus on the challenges. This article asks how decision makers make timely decisions. It presents an institutions-process framework and analyzes the process and mechanism in the case of the response of E-Zhong City—just over an hour’s drive from Wuhan City in Hubei Province—to COVID-19 in the “Golden Seven Days” of 2020. Decision makers achieved timely decisions by exploiting all possible political opportunities and institutional tools, maximizing the diversity of the information available, and using multiple discourses and frameworks to enhance personal crisis awareness and achieve collective sensemaking across boundaries. This article defines the mechanism as bricolage and defines these decision makers as institution-knowledge bricoleurs. The concept of institution-knowledge bricoleurs extends the study of crisis decision making and the relationship between institutions and sensemaking.
- 29 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration
- Vol. 101 (4) , 1526-1548
Meet all changes with constancy: The dynamic adaptation process of county governments in China
As their task environments become more unstable, public organizations must build their adaptive capacities. Treating the organization as a problem‐solving system, we constructed an institution‐process framework to analyze how China's local governments use processes and mechanisms to adapt to the task turbulence from higher‐up governments. Based on the experiences of three Chinese counties in dealing with the Targeted Poverty Alleviation task, we found that they built an institutionalized adaptation process that included attention allocation, decision‐making system construction, and boundary work in a turbulent task environment. These processes were embedded in specific institutional structures. We define this institutionalized adaptation process as dynamic conservatism. In this adaptation mode, China's local governments rarely observe and manage the environment; instead, they integrate their existing structural and stable elements to cope with the task turbulence generated by higher‐level governments.
- 29 November 2022
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration
- Vol. 101 (4) , 1526-1548
Meet all changes with constancy: The dynamic adaptation process of county governments in China
As their task environments become more unstable, public organizations must build their adaptive capacities. Treating the organization as a problem‐solving system, we constructed an institution‐process framework to analyze how China's local governments use processes and mechanisms to adapt to the task turbulence from higher‐up governments. Based on the experiences of three Chinese counties in dealing with the Targeted Poverty Alleviation task, we found that they built an institutionalized adaptation process that included attention allocation, decision‐making system construction, and boundary work in a turbulent task environment. These processes were embedded in specific institutional structures. We define this institutionalized adaptation process as dynamic conservatism. In this adaptation mode, China's local governments rarely observe and manage the environment; instead, they integrate their existing structural and stable elements to cope with the task turbulence generated by higher‐level governments.
- 12 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration and Development
- Vol. 42 (1) , 55-71
Do visiting monks give better sermons? “Street‐level bureaucrats from higher‐up” in targeted poverty alleviation in China
In those countries lacking democratic institutions and with weak professional bureaucracy and low governance capacity at the rural grassroots level, do different types of street‐level bureaucrats (SLBs) exist? If so, how do they work? To answer these questions, this article constructs an institution‐practice framework to understand the different types of SLBs. Based on fieldwork in three Chinese counties concerning their implementation of the Targeted Poverty Alleviation Policy, we found that the street‐level bureaucracy from higher‐up is the key to addressing China’s inadequate street‐level governance capacity. The organizational structure, mechanisms, and strategies of SLBs from higher‐up are differ from other types of SLBs. The institutional arrangements of the SLBs from higher‐up are campaign‐style and informal; their institutional mechanisms are mainly idea loading and carrying, and policy learning; their motivation is politicalized, that is, they are politically committed and incentivized; they are also coping, but they are entrepreneurs. The SLBs from higher‐up expands our understanding of the street‐level bureaucracy as it relates to institutional embeddedness, diversified types, and escaping the trap of street‐level governance capacity limitations.
- 12 January 2022
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration and Development
- Vol. 42 (1) , 55-71
Do visiting monks give better sermons? “Street‐level bureaucrats from higher‐up” in targeted poverty alleviation in China
In those countries lacking democratic institutions and with weak professional bureaucracy and low governance capacity at the rural grassroots level, do different types of street‐level bureaucrats (SLBs) exist? If so, how do they work? To answer these questions, this article constructs an institution‐practice framework to understand the different types of SLBs. Based on fieldwork in three Chinese counties concerning their implementation of the Targeted Poverty Alleviation Policy, we found that the street‐level bureaucracy from higher‐up is the key to addressing China’s inadequate street‐level governance capacity. The organizational structure, mechanisms, and strategies of SLBs from higher‐up are differ from other types of SLBs. The institutional arrangements of the SLBs from higher‐up are campaign‐style and informal; their institutional mechanisms are mainly idea loading and carrying, and policy learning; their motivation is politicalized, that is, they are politically committed and incentivized; they are also coping, but they are entrepreneurs. The SLBs from higher‐up expands our understanding of the street‐level bureaucracy as it relates to institutional embeddedness, diversified types, and escaping the trap of street‐level governance capacity limitations.
- 10 December 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Asian Public Policy
- Vol. 13 (1) , 60-78
Making collective policy entrepreneurship work: the case of China’s post-disaster reconstruction
A lower-level bureaucrat with limited political capital is unlikely to become a policy entrepreneur capable of integrating resources and seizing policy opportunities. This paper presents a case study of a group of officials who enabled collective policy entrepreneurship by combining social acuity, problem reframing, common interests, lack of resources, and complementary capabilities. Facing internal and external pressures, to further their shared goals, these policy actors adopted entrepreneurial strategies such as work innovation, resource integration, and issue promotion, to continuously influence change and innovation.
- 10 December 2019
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Asian Public Policy
- Vol. 13 (1) , 60-78
Making collective policy entrepreneurship work: the case of China’s post-disaster reconstruction
A lower-level bureaucrat with limited political capital is unlikely to become a policy entrepreneur capable of integrating resources and seizing policy opportunities. This paper presents a case study of a group of officials who enabled collective policy entrepreneurship by combining social acuity, problem reframing, common interests, lack of resources, and complementary capabilities. Facing internal and external pressures, to further their shared goals, these policy actors adopted entrepreneurial strategies such as work innovation, resource integration, and issue promotion, to continuously influence change and innovation.