Robbie Clark
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Robbie Clark has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jacqueline Thompson
School of Psychological Science, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1TU, UK
3 shared publications - Marcus Robert Munafo
Vice Chancellor's Office University of Bath Bath UK
3 shared publications - Katie Drax
School of Psychological Science, University of Bristol, Bristol, BS8 1TU, UK
2 shared publications - Robert T. Thibault
Coalition for Aligning Science, Chevy Chase, Maryland
2 shared publications - Aoife O'MAhony
School of Public Health, University College Cork, Cork, Ireland
1 shared publication - Charlotte Rebecca Pennington
School of Psychology, College of Health and Life Sciences, Aston University
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 March 2022
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
- Vol. 28 (1) , 1-9
Correcting statistical misinformation about scientific findings in the media: Causation versus correlation.
Although retractions significantly reduce the number of references people make to misinformation, retracted information nevertheless persists in memory, continuing to influence reasoning. One hundred and twenty-nine lay participants completed an adaptation on the traditional continued influence paradigm, which set out to identify whether it is possible to debunk a piece of common statistical misinformation: inappropriate causal inference based on a correlation. We hypothesized that participants in the correction condition would make fewer causal inferences (misinformation) and more correlational inferences (correction) than those in the no-correction condition. Additional secondary hypotheses were that the number of references made to the misinformation and correction would be moderated by the level of trust in science and scientists, and the amount of television that participants watch. Although the secondary hypotheses were not supported, the data strongly supported the primary hypotheses. This study provides evidence for the efficacy of corrections about misinformation where correlational evidence has been inappropriately reported as causal. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
- 1 March 2022
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied
- Vol. 28 (1) , 1-9
Correcting statistical misinformation about scientific findings in the media: Causation versus correlation.
Although retractions significantly reduce the number of references people make to misinformation, retracted information nevertheless persists in memory, continuing to influence reasoning. One hundred and twenty-nine lay participants completed an adaptation on the traditional continued influence paradigm, which set out to identify whether it is possible to debunk a piece of common statistical misinformation: inappropriate causal inference based on a correlation. We hypothesized that participants in the correction condition would make fewer causal inferences (misinformation) and more correlational inferences (correction) than those in the no-correction condition. Additional secondary hypotheses were that the number of references made to the misinformation and correction would be moderated by the level of trust in science and scientists, and the amount of television that participants watch. Although the secondary hypotheses were not supported, the data strongly supported the primary hypotheses. This study provides evidence for the efficacy of corrections about misinformation where correlational evidence has been inappropriately reported as causal. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2022 APA, all rights reserved).
- Open Access
Discrepancy review: A feasibility study of a novel peer review intervention to reduce undisclosed discrepancies between registrations and publications
Background: Undisclosed discrepancies often exist between study registrations and their associated publications. Discrepancies can increase risk of bias, and when undisclosed, they disguise this increased risk of bias from readers. To remedy this issue, we developed an intervention called discrepancy review . We provided journals with peer reviewers specifically assigned to check for undisclosed discrepancies between registrations and manuscripts submitted to journals. Objectives: We aimed to (1) evaluate the feasibility of incorporating discrepancy review as a regular practice at scientific journals and the feasibility of conducting a trial on discrepancy review; (2) explore the benefits and time required to incorporate discrepancy review as a regular practice at scientific journals; and (3) refine the discrepancy review process. Method: We performed discrepancy review on 18 manuscripts submitted to Nicotine and Tobacco Research and 3 manuscripts submitted to the European Journal of Personality . We iteratively refined the discrepancy review process based on feedback from discrepancy reviewers, editors, and authors. We then assessed whether revised manuscripts addressed recommendations from discrepancy reviewers and identified potential outcome measures for use in a future trial of discrepancy review. Results: Registrations were generally too imprecise to be effectively evaluated by our original discrepancy review process so we developed a simplified, semi-structured process. Authors addressed the majority of discrepancy reviewer comments and there was no opposition to running a trial from authors, editors, or discrepancy reviewers. Clinical trial registrations were more precise but less comprehensive than registrations on the Open Science Framework, suggesting they should be evaluated in separate trials. Outcome measures for a trial of discrepancy review on clinical trial registration could include the presence of primary or secondary outcome discrepancies and whether publications that are not the primary report from a clinical trial registration are clearly described as such. Outcome measures for a trial on Open Science Framework registrations could include assessments of whether registrations are permanent, as well as an overarching subjective assessment of the impact of discrepancies. Conclusion: We found that discrepancy review could feasibly be introduced as a regular practice at journals interested in this process. A full trial of discrepancy review would be needed to evaluate its impact on reducing undisclosed discrepancies.
Open AccessDiscrepancy review: A feasibility study of a novel peer review intervention to reduce undisclosed discrepancies between registrations and publications
Background: Undisclosed discrepancies often exist between study registrations and their associated publications. Discrepancies can increase risk of bias, and when undisclosed, they disguise this increased risk of bias from readers. To remedy this issue, we developed an intervention called discrepancy review . We provided journals with peer reviewers specifically assigned to check for undisclosed discrepancies between registrations and manuscripts submitted to journals. Objectives: We aimed to (1) evaluate the feasibility of incorporating discrepancy review as a regular practice at scientific journals and the feasibility of conducting a trial on discrepancy review; (2) explore the benefits and time required to incorporate discrepancy review as a regular practice at scientific journals; and (3) refine the discrepancy review process. Method: We performed discrepancy review on 18 manuscripts submitted to Nicotine and Tobacco Research and 3 manuscripts submitted to the European Journal of Personality . We iteratively refined the discrepancy review process based on feedback from discrepancy reviewers, editors, and authors. We then assessed whether revised manuscripts addressed recommendations from discrepancy reviewers and identified potential outcome measures for use in a future trial of discrepancy review. Results: Registrations were generally too imprecise to be effectively evaluated by our original discrepancy review process so we developed a simplified, semi-structured process. Authors addressed the majority of discrepancy reviewer comments and there was no opposition to running a trial from authors, editors, or discrepancy reviewers. Clinical trial registrations were more precise but less comprehensive than registrations on the Open Science Framework, suggesting they should be evaluated in separate trials. Outcome measures for a trial of discrepancy review on clinical trial registration could include the presence of primary or secondary outcome discrepancies and whether publications that are not the primary report from a clinical trial registration are clearly described as such. Outcome measures for a trial on Open Science Framework registrations could include assessments of whether registrations are permanent, as well as an overarching subjective assessment of the impact of discrepancies. Conclusion: We found that discrepancy review could feasibly be introduced as a regular practice at journals interested in this process. A full trial of discrepancy review would be needed to evaluate its impact on reducing undisclosed discrepancies.
- Open Access
- 14 September 2021
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Wellcome Open Research
- Vol. 6, 231
Evaluating Registered Reports Funding Partnerships: a feasibility study
Background: We studied a novel initiative – Registered Reports Funding Partnerships (RRFPs) – whereby research funders and journals partner in order to integrate their procedures for funding applications and Registered Reports submissions into one process. We investigated the feasibility of conducting a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of the impact of RRFPs on (1) research quality and (2) the efficiency of the research process, from funding to publication. Methods: We conducted 32 semi-structured interviews and follow-up questionnaires with stakeholders (funders, editors, authors, and reviewers) across six different RRFPs. Results: A RCT of RRFPs appears to be feasible in principle. The partnership concept seems worthwhile to pursue further and is adaptable to the needs of various funders and publishers, and across disciplines. Three primary outcomes of interest should be measurable, and participant randomisation could conceivably be done in a number of ways. In practice, however, the current volume of submissions going through existing partnerships is too low to support a full trial. Conclusions: Although a RCT of RRFPs is conceptually feasible, it will only be possible if organisations are willing to form new partnerships, scale up existing ones, and incorporate a trial (i.e., randomisation) into these partnerships.
- 14 September 2021
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in Wellcome Open Research
- Vol. 6, 231
Open AccessEvaluating Registered Reports Funding Partnerships: a feasibility study
Background: We studied a novel initiative – Registered Reports Funding Partnerships (RRFPs) – whereby research funders and journals partner in order to integrate their procedures for funding applications and Registered Reports submissions into one process. We investigated the feasibility of conducting a randomised controlled trial (RCT) of the impact of RRFPs on (1) research quality and (2) the efficiency of the research process, from funding to publication. Methods: We conducted 32 semi-structured interviews and follow-up questionnaires with stakeholders (funders, editors, authors, and reviewers) across six different RRFPs. Results: A RCT of RRFPs appears to be feasible in principle. The partnership concept seems worthwhile to pursue further and is adaptable to the needs of various funders and publishers, and across disciplines. Three primary outcomes of interest should be measurable, and participant randomisation could conceivably be done in a number of ways. In practice, however, the current volume of submissions going through existing partnerships is too low to support a full trial. Conclusions: Although a RCT of RRFPs is conceptually feasible, it will only be possible if organisations are willing to form new partnerships, scale up existing ones, and incorporate a trial (i.e., randomisation) into these partnerships.
- Open Access
Estimating the prevalence of discrepancies between study registrations and publications: A systematic review and meta-analyses
Objectives: Prospectively registering study plans in a permanent time-stamped and publicly accessible document is becoming more common across disciplines and aims to reduce risk of bias and make risk of bias transparent. Selective reporting persists, however, when researchers deviate from their registered plans without disclosure. This systematic review aimed to estimate the prevalence of undisclosed discrepancies between prospectively registered study plans and their associated publication. We further aimed to identify the research disciplines where these discrepancies have been observed, whether interventions to reduce discrepancies have been conducted, and gaps in the literature. Design: Systematic review and meta-analyses. Data sources: Scopus and Web of Knowledge, published up to 15 December 2019. Eligibility criteria: Articles that included quantitative data about discrepancies between registrations or study protocols and their associated publications. Data extraction and synthesis: Each included article was independently coded by two reviewers using a coding form designed for this review (osf.io/728ys). We used random-effects meta-analyses to synthesize the results. Results: We reviewed k = 89 articles, which included k = 70 that reported on primary outcome discrepancies from n = 6314 studies and, k = 22 that reported on secondary outcome discrepancies from n = 1436 studies. Meta-analyses indicated that between 29% to 37% (95% confidence interval) of studies contained at least one primary outcome discrepancy and between 50% to 75% (95% confidence interval) contained at least one secondary outcome discrepancy. Almost all articles assessed clinical literature, and there was considerable heterogeneity. We identified only one article that attempted to correct discrepancies. Conclusions: Many articles did not include information on whether discrepancies were disclosed, which version of a registration they compared publications to, and whether the registration was prospective. Thus, our estimates represent discrepancies broadly, rather than our target of undisclosed discrepancies between prospectively registered study plans and their associated publications. Discrepancies are common and reduce the trustworthiness of medical research. Interventions to reduce discrepancies could prove valuable. Registration: osf.io/ktmdg . Protocol amendments are listed in Supplementary Material A.
Open AccessEstimating the prevalence of discrepancies between study registrations and publications: A systematic review and meta-analyses
Objectives: Prospectively registering study plans in a permanent time-stamped and publicly accessible document is becoming more common across disciplines and aims to reduce risk of bias and make risk of bias transparent. Selective reporting persists, however, when researchers deviate from their registered plans without disclosure. This systematic review aimed to estimate the prevalence of undisclosed discrepancies between prospectively registered study plans and their associated publication. We further aimed to identify the research disciplines where these discrepancies have been observed, whether interventions to reduce discrepancies have been conducted, and gaps in the literature. Design: Systematic review and meta-analyses. Data sources: Scopus and Web of Knowledge, published up to 15 December 2019. Eligibility criteria: Articles that included quantitative data about discrepancies between registrations or study protocols and their associated publications. Data extraction and synthesis: Each included article was independently coded by two reviewers using a coding form designed for this review (osf.io/728ys). We used random-effects meta-analyses to synthesize the results. Results: We reviewed k = 89 articles, which included k = 70 that reported on primary outcome discrepancies from n = 6314 studies and, k = 22 that reported on secondary outcome discrepancies from n = 1436 studies. Meta-analyses indicated that between 29% to 37% (95% confidence interval) of studies contained at least one primary outcome discrepancy and between 50% to 75% (95% confidence interval) contained at least one secondary outcome discrepancy. Almost all articles assessed clinical literature, and there was considerable heterogeneity. We identified only one article that attempted to correct discrepancies. Conclusions: Many articles did not include information on whether discrepancies were disclosed, which version of a registration they compared publications to, and whether the registration was prospective. Thus, our estimates represent discrepancies broadly, rather than our target of undisclosed discrepancies between prospectively registered study plans and their associated publications. Discrepancies are common and reduce the trustworthiness of medical research. Interventions to reduce discrepancies could prove valuable. Registration: osf.io/ktmdg . Protocol amendments are listed in Supplementary Material A.