Sabine Brunswicker
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Sabine Brunswicker has a total of 64 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Adeline Nyamathi
University of California Irvine, USA
3 shared publications - Amir M. Rahmani
University of California, Irvine, Irvine, California, USA
3 shared publications - Cheonkam Jeong
Sue & Bill Gross School of Nursing, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA, United States
3 shared publications - Chet Khay
Amore Senior Living, Laguna Niguel, CA, United States
3 shared publications - Erik Krogh
Smart Forward, Rancho Palos Verdes, CA, United States
3 shared publications - Jocelyn Ludlow
Sue & Bill Gross School of Nursing, University of California Irvine, Irvine, CA, United States
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 28 October 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 28, e85651
Evaluation of Personas and Daily Activity Maps to Inform Clinical Care and Socially Assistive Robot Training and Design for Persons With Dementia: Mixed Methods Study
Background: Over 55 million people worldwide are living with dementia, resulting in significant caregiving demands and caregiver burden. Socially assistive robots (SARs) are increasingly being explored to reduce caregiving workload and improve the quality of life for persons with dementia; however, their effectiveness depends on person-centered design grounded in a comprehensive understanding of the target population. Personas and their corresponding daily activity maps (DAMs) are user-centered design tools that provide a holistic understanding of the personal, medical, emotional, and life trajectory of persons with dementia, enabling SARs to engage in contextually relevant and empathetic interactions. Despite their potential, these tools have not been formally evaluated for dementia care and digital health technology development. Objective: This mixed methods study aimed to explore the perspectives of professional and family caregivers, health care providers, and robot designers on the quality and use of personas and DAMs in clinical practice and digital health design. Methods: Using purposive sampling, 15 stakeholders involved in dementia care or digital health design were interviewed via Zoom (Zoom Communications, Inc) between March and April 2025 to evaluate a subset of persona-DAM pairs using a modified 12-item version of the Persona Perception Scale (PPS), adapted for dementia care contexts, across 5 domains: Credibility, Completeness, Clarity, Willingness to Use, and Empathy. Participants subsequently provided qualitative perspectives through semistructured interviews, reflecting on their ratings and offering suggestions for improvement. Results: Fifteen participants with a median of 9 (IQR 4-15) years of experience in dementia care evaluated 9 persona-DAM pairs. Overall evaluation-level median PPS scores were 4.79 (IQR 4.45, 4.91) for personas and 4.76 (IQR 4.45, 4.94) for DAMs. For both personas and DAMs, the highest-rated domains were Clarity, Credibility, and Willingness to Use (all median 5.00), suggesting stakeholders perceived the tools favorably and were willing to use them. Empathy scores (personas: median 4.67, IQR 4.25-5; DAMs: median 4.83, IQR 4.33-5) highlighted the need for greater cultural, ethnic, and religious representation to foster culturally sensitive interventions. Completeness was the lowest-scoring domain (personas: median 4.50, IQR 3.94-5; DAMs: median 4.38, IQR 4-5), representing the most quantitative improvement suggestions. Qualitative analysis revealed 3 major themes: (1) improving human-robot interaction training through greater knowledge of the personal context of persons with dementia; (2) comprehensive assessment of clinical history and functional capacities as essential for the provision of safe and effective interaction; and (3) perceived design utility: translating person-centered knowledge into actionable tools. Conclusions: This study provides early-stage exploratory evidence that personas and DAMs are perceived as clinically and technically relevant tools for dementia care, complementing existing clinical documentation through a holistic, person-centered view, and serving as human-centered design tools for developing personalized digital health solutions.
- 28 October 2026
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 28, e85651
Open AccessEvaluation of Personas and Daily Activity Maps to Inform Clinical Care and Socially Assistive Robot Training and Design for Persons With Dementia: Mixed Methods Study
Background: Over 55 million people worldwide are living with dementia, resulting in significant caregiving demands and caregiver burden. Socially assistive robots (SARs) are increasingly being explored to reduce caregiving workload and improve the quality of life for persons with dementia; however, their effectiveness depends on person-centered design grounded in a comprehensive understanding of the target population. Personas and their corresponding daily activity maps (DAMs) are user-centered design tools that provide a holistic understanding of the personal, medical, emotional, and life trajectory of persons with dementia, enabling SARs to engage in contextually relevant and empathetic interactions. Despite their potential, these tools have not been formally evaluated for dementia care and digital health technology development. Objective: This mixed methods study aimed to explore the perspectives of professional and family caregivers, health care providers, and robot designers on the quality and use of personas and DAMs in clinical practice and digital health design. Methods: Using purposive sampling, 15 stakeholders involved in dementia care or digital health design were interviewed via Zoom (Zoom Communications, Inc) between March and April 2025 to evaluate a subset of persona-DAM pairs using a modified 12-item version of the Persona Perception Scale (PPS), adapted for dementia care contexts, across 5 domains: Credibility, Completeness, Clarity, Willingness to Use, and Empathy. Participants subsequently provided qualitative perspectives through semistructured interviews, reflecting on their ratings and offering suggestions for improvement. Results: Fifteen participants with a median of 9 (IQR 4-15) years of experience in dementia care evaluated 9 persona-DAM pairs. Overall evaluation-level median PPS scores were 4.79 (IQR 4.45, 4.91) for personas and 4.76 (IQR 4.45, 4.94) for DAMs. For both personas and DAMs, the highest-rated domains were Clarity, Credibility, and Willingness to Use (all median 5.00), suggesting stakeholders perceived the tools favorably and were willing to use them. Empathy scores (personas: median 4.67, IQR 4.25-5; DAMs: median 4.83, IQR 4.33-5) highlighted the need for greater cultural, ethnic, and religious representation to foster culturally sensitive interventions. Completeness was the lowest-scoring domain (personas: median 4.50, IQR 3.94-5; DAMs: median 4.38, IQR 4-5), representing the most quantitative improvement suggestions. Qualitative analysis revealed 3 major themes: (1) improving human-robot interaction training through greater knowledge of the personal context of persons with dementia; (2) comprehensive assessment of clinical history and functional capacities as essential for the provision of safe and effective interaction; and (3) perceived design utility: translating person-centered knowledge into actionable tools. Conclusions: This study provides early-stage exploratory evidence that personas and DAMs are perceived as clinically and technically relevant tools for dementia care, complementing existing clinical documentation through a holistic, person-centered view, and serving as human-centered design tools for developing personalized digital health solutions.
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Neurocomputing
- Vol. 664
COVEE: A dataset for cognitive modeling with video, electroencephalography, and eye tracker
- 21 November 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Neurocomputing
- Vol. 664
COVEE: A dataset for cognitive modeling with video, electroencephalography, and eye tracker
- Open Access
- 21 October 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Evaluation of Personas and Daily Activity Maps for Improved Clinical Care and Training Models for Effective Human-Robot Interaction for Persons with Dementia: A Qualitative Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND With over 7.2 million persons with dementia needing healthcare, challenges faced by healthcare are growing. As Social Assistive Robots have been in existence for some time, utilizing realistic and comprehensive personas and their daily activity maps to inform robot designers, and in the long-term, nurse caregivers, about predicting agitation and fall risk is a significant undertaking. However, no studies to date have evaluated these personas and their daily activity maps with expert dementia stakeholders. OBJECTIVE The purpose of this mixed method study was to explore the perspectives of formal and informal dementia caregivers, and robot designers in the use of personas and their daily activity maps to support caregivers in a residential facility in monitoring for agitation and fall risk. METHODS In this study, 15 stakeholders were first administered survey questions for which they subsequently provided perspectives on how to improve their scores if warranted. RESULTS In the quantitative survey, using a modified Persona Perception Scale, the average score for the personas was 4.60 out of 5, while the daily activity maps received an average score of 4.54. Individual scores on the subscales of Credibility, Completeness, Clarity, Empathy, and Willingness to Use, for both personas and daily activity maps, ranged from 4.23 to 4.75. In the qualitative analysis, three major themes emerged: 1) Improving human-robot interaction training through greater knowledge of the personal context of persons with dementia; 2) Comprehensive assessment of clinical history and functional capacities as essential for provision of safe and effective interaction for persons with dementia; and 3) Recommendations for improving the clarity and usefulness of the design of personas and their daily activity maps. CONCLUSIONS The evaluation of personas and daily activity maps represents a promising avenue for improving the care of persons with dementia, particularly in relation to managing agitation and reducing fall risks. As the global burden of dementia continues to grow, innovative approaches like the use of personas and their daily activity maps may play an important role in enhancing the quality of care for individuals living with dementia. CLINICALTRIAL N/A INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT RR2-10.2196/55761
- 21 October 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessEvaluation of Personas and Daily Activity Maps for Improved Clinical Care and Training Models for Effective Human-Robot Interaction for Persons with Dementia: A Qualitative Study (Preprint)
BACKGROUND With over 7.2 million persons with dementia needing healthcare, challenges faced by healthcare are growing. As Social Assistive Robots have been in existence for some time, utilizing realistic and comprehensive personas and their daily activity maps to inform robot designers, and in the long-term, nurse caregivers, about predicting agitation and fall risk is a significant undertaking. However, no studies to date have evaluated these personas and their daily activity maps with expert dementia stakeholders. OBJECTIVE The purpose of this mixed method study was to explore the perspectives of formal and informal dementia caregivers, and robot designers in the use of personas and their daily activity maps to support caregivers in a residential facility in monitoring for agitation and fall risk. METHODS In this study, 15 stakeholders were first administered survey questions for which they subsequently provided perspectives on how to improve their scores if warranted. RESULTS In the quantitative survey, using a modified Persona Perception Scale, the average score for the personas was 4.60 out of 5, while the daily activity maps received an average score of 4.54. Individual scores on the subscales of Credibility, Completeness, Clarity, Empathy, and Willingness to Use, for both personas and daily activity maps, ranged from 4.23 to 4.75. In the qualitative analysis, three major themes emerged: 1) Improving human-robot interaction training through greater knowledge of the personal context of persons with dementia; 2) Comprehensive assessment of clinical history and functional capacities as essential for provision of safe and effective interaction for persons with dementia; and 3) Recommendations for improving the clarity and usefulness of the design of personas and their daily activity maps. CONCLUSIONS The evaluation of personas and daily activity maps represents a promising avenue for improving the care of persons with dementia, particularly in relation to managing agitation and reducing fall risks. As the global burden of dementia continues to grow, innovative approaches like the use of personas and their daily activity maps may play an important role in enhancing the quality of care for individuals living with dementia. CLINICALTRIAL N/A INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT RR2-10.2196/55761
- Open Access
- 19 June 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in Proceedings of the ACM on Software Engineering
- Vol. 2 (FSE) , 1824-1846
Towards Understanding Fine-Grained Programming Mistakes and Fixing Patterns in Data Science
Programming is an essential activity in data science (DS). Unlike regular software developers, DS programmers often use Jupyter notebooks instead of conventional IDEs. Moreover, DS programmers focus on statistics, data analytics, and modeling rather than writing production-ready code following best practices in software engineering. Thus, in order to provide effective tool support to improve their productivity, it is important to understand what kinds of errors they make and how they fix them. Previous studies have analyzed DS code from public code-sharing platforms such as GitHub and Kaggle. However, they only accounted for code changes committed to the version history, omitting many programming mistakes that are resolved before code commits. To bridge the gap, we present an in-depth analysis of the fine-grained logs of a DS competition, which includes 390 Jupyter Notebooks written by participants over six weeks. In addition, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 10 DS programmers from different domains to understand the reasons behind their programming mistakes. We identified several unique programming mistakes and fix patterns that had not been reported before, highlighting opportunities for designing new tool support for DS programming.
- 19 June 2025
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM) in Proceedings of the ACM on Software Engineering
- Vol. 2 (FSE) , 1824-1846
Open AccessTowards Understanding Fine-Grained Programming Mistakes and Fixing Patterns in Data Science
Programming is an essential activity in data science (DS). Unlike regular software developers, DS programmers often use Jupyter notebooks instead of conventional IDEs. Moreover, DS programmers focus on statistics, data analytics, and modeling rather than writing production-ready code following best practices in software engineering. Thus, in order to provide effective tool support to improve their productivity, it is important to understand what kinds of errors they make and how they fix them. Previous studies have analyzed DS code from public code-sharing platforms such as GitHub and Kaggle. However, they only accounted for code changes committed to the version history, omitting many programming mistakes that are resolved before code commits. To bridge the gap, we present an in-depth analysis of the fine-grained logs of a DS competition, which includes 390 Jupyter Notebooks written by participants over six weeks. In addition, we conducted semi-structured interviews with 10 DS programmers from different domains to understand the reasons behind their programming mistakes. We identified several unique programming mistakes and fix patterns that had not been reported before, highlighting opportunities for designing new tool support for DS programming.
- Open Access
SAFE-TAXI: A Hierarchical Multi-UAS Safe Auto-Taxiing Framework with Runtime Safety Assurance and Conflict Resolution
We present a hierarchical safe auto-taxiing framework to enhance the automated ground operations of multiple unmanned aircraft systems (multi-UAS). The auto-taxiing problem becomes particularly challenging due to (i) unknown disturbances, such as crosswind affecting the aircraft dynamics, (ii) taxiway incursions due to unplanned obstacles, and (iii) spatiotemporal conflicts at the intersections between multiple entry points in the taxiway. To address these issues, we propose a hierarchical framework, i.e., SAFE-TAXI, combining centralized spatiotemporal planning with decentralized MPC-CBF-based control to safely navigate the aircraft through the taxiway while avoiding intersection conflicts and unplanned obstacles (e.g., other aircraft or ground vehicles). Our proposed framework decouples the auto-taxiing problem temporally into conflict resolution and motion planning, respectively. Conflict resolution is handled in a centralized manner by computing conflict-aware reference trajectories for each aircraft. In contrast, safety assurance from unplanned obstacles is handled by an MPC-CBF-based controller implemented in a decentralized manner. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed framework through numerical simulations and experimentally validate it using Night Vapor, a small-scale fixed-wing test platform.
Open AccessSAFE-TAXI: A Hierarchical Multi-UAS Safe Auto-Taxiing Framework with Runtime Safety Assurance and Conflict Resolution
We present a hierarchical safe auto-taxiing framework to enhance the automated ground operations of multiple unmanned aircraft systems (multi-UAS). The auto-taxiing problem becomes particularly challenging due to (i) unknown disturbances, such as crosswind affecting the aircraft dynamics, (ii) taxiway incursions due to unplanned obstacles, and (iii) spatiotemporal conflicts at the intersections between multiple entry points in the taxiway. To address these issues, we propose a hierarchical framework, i.e., SAFE-TAXI, combining centralized spatiotemporal planning with decentralized MPC-CBF-based control to safely navigate the aircraft through the taxiway while avoiding intersection conflicts and unplanned obstacles (e.g., other aircraft or ground vehicles). Our proposed framework decouples the auto-taxiing problem temporally into conflict resolution and motion planning, respectively. Conflict resolution is handled in a centralized manner by computing conflict-aware reference trajectories for each aircraft. In contrast, safety assurance from unplanned obstacles is handled by an MPC-CBF-based controller implemented in a decentralized manner. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed framework through numerical simulations and experimentally validate it using Night Vapor, a small-scale fixed-wing test platform.
- 2 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior
- Vol. 165
Trust through words: The systemize-empathize-effect of language in task-oriented conversational agents
- 2 December 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Computers in Human Behavior
- Vol. 165
Trust through words: The systemize-empathize-effect of language in task-oriented conversational agents
- Open Access
- 4 October 2024
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Research Protocols
- Vol. 13 (1) , e55761
Establishing the Foundations of Emotional Intelligence in Care Companion Robots to Mitigate Agitation Among High-Risk Patients With Dementia: Protocol for an Empathetic Patient-Robot Interaction Study
Background: An estimated 6.7 million persons are living with dementia in the United States, a number expected to double by 2060. Persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia are 4 to 5 times more likely to fall than those without dementia, due to agitation and unsteady gait. Socially assistive robots fail to address the changing emotional states associated with agitation, and it is unclear how emotional states change, how they impact agitation and gait over time, and how social robots can best respond by showing empathy. Objective: This study aims to design and validate a foundational model of emotional intelligence for empathetic patient-robot interaction that mitigates agitation among those at the highest risk: persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia. Methods: A design science approach will be adopted to (1) collect and store granular, personal, and chronological data using Personicle (an open-source software platform developed to automatically collect data from phones and other devices), incorporating real-time visual, audio, and physiological sensing technologies in a simulation laboratory and at board and care facilities; (2) develop statistical models to understand and forecast the emotional state, agitation level, and gait pattern of persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia in real time using machine learning and artificial intelligence and Personicle; (3) design and test an empathy-focused conversation model, focused on storytelling; and (4) test and evaluate this model for a care companion robot (CCR) in the community. Results: The study was funded in October 2023. For aim 1, architecture development for Personicle data collection began with a search for existing open-source data in January 2024. A community advisory board was formed and met in December 2023 to provide feedback on the use of CCRs and provide personal stories. Full institutional review board approval was received in March 2024 to place cameras and CCRs at the sites. In March 2024, atomic marker development was begun. For aim 2, after a review of open-source data on patients with dementia, the development of an emotional classifier was begun. Data labeling was started in April 2024 and completed in June 2024 with ongoing validation. Moreover, the team established a baseline multimodal model trained and validated on healthy-person data sets, using transformer architecture in a semisupervised manner, and later retrained on the labeled data set of patients experiencing moderate to severe dementia. In April 2024, empathy alignment of large language models was initiated using prompt engineering and reinforcement learning. Conclusions: This innovative caregiving approach is designed to recognize the signs of agitation and, upon recognition, intervene with empathetic verbal communication. This proposal has the potential to have a significant impact on an emerging field of computational dementia science by reducing unnecessary agitation and falls of persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia, while reducing caregiver burden. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): PRR1-10.2196/55761
- 4 October 2024
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Research Protocols
- Vol. 13 (1) , e55761
Open AccessEstablishing the Foundations of Emotional Intelligence in Care Companion Robots to Mitigate Agitation Among High-Risk Patients With Dementia: Protocol for an Empathetic Patient-Robot Interaction Study
Background: An estimated 6.7 million persons are living with dementia in the United States, a number expected to double by 2060. Persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia are 4 to 5 times more likely to fall than those without dementia, due to agitation and unsteady gait. Socially assistive robots fail to address the changing emotional states associated with agitation, and it is unclear how emotional states change, how they impact agitation and gait over time, and how social robots can best respond by showing empathy. Objective: This study aims to design and validate a foundational model of emotional intelligence for empathetic patient-robot interaction that mitigates agitation among those at the highest risk: persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia. Methods: A design science approach will be adopted to (1) collect and store granular, personal, and chronological data using Personicle (an open-source software platform developed to automatically collect data from phones and other devices), incorporating real-time visual, audio, and physiological sensing technologies in a simulation laboratory and at board and care facilities; (2) develop statistical models to understand and forecast the emotional state, agitation level, and gait pattern of persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia in real time using machine learning and artificial intelligence and Personicle; (3) design and test an empathy-focused conversation model, focused on storytelling; and (4) test and evaluate this model for a care companion robot (CCR) in the community. Results: The study was funded in October 2023. For aim 1, architecture development for Personicle data collection began with a search for existing open-source data in January 2024. A community advisory board was formed and met in December 2023 to provide feedback on the use of CCRs and provide personal stories. Full institutional review board approval was received in March 2024 to place cameras and CCRs at the sites. In March 2024, atomic marker development was begun. For aim 2, after a review of open-source data on patients with dementia, the development of an emotional classifier was begun. Data labeling was started in April 2024 and completed in June 2024 with ongoing validation. Moreover, the team established a baseline multimodal model trained and validated on healthy-person data sets, using transformer architecture in a semisupervised manner, and later retrained on the labeled data set of patients experiencing moderate to severe dementia. In April 2024, empathy alignment of large language models was initiated using prompt engineering and reinforcement learning. Conclusions: This innovative caregiving approach is designed to recognize the signs of agitation and, upon recognition, intervene with empathetic verbal communication. This proposal has the potential to have a significant impact on an emerging field of computational dementia science by reducing unnecessary agitation and falls of persons experiencing moderate to severe dementia, while reducing caregiver burden. International Registered Report Identifier (IRRID): PRR1-10.2196/55761
- Open Access
Learning Nudges for Conditional Cooperation: A Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning Model
The public goods game describes a social dilemma in which a large proportion of agents act as conditional cooperators (CC): they only act cooperatively if they see others acting cooperatively because they satisfice with the social norm to be in line with what others are doing instead of optimizing cooperation. CCs are guided by aspiration-based reinforcement learning guided by past experiences of interactions with others and satisficing aspirations. In many real-world settings, reinforcing social norms do not emerge. In this paper, we propose that an optimizing reinforcement agent can facilitate cooperation through nudges, i.e. indirect mechanisms for cooperation to happen. The agent's goal is to motivate CCs into cooperation through its own actions to create social norms that signal that others are cooperating. We introduce a multi-agent reinforcement learning model for public goods games, with 3 CC learning agents using aspirational reinforcement learning and 1 nudging agent using deep reinforcement learning to learn nudges that optimize cooperation. For our nudging agent, we model two distinct reward functions, one maximizing the total game return (sum DRL) and one maximizing the number of cooperative contributions contributions higher than a proportional threshold (prop DRL). Our results show that our aspiration-based RL model for CC agents is consistent with empirically observed CC behavior. Games combining 3 CC RL agents and one nudging RL agent outperform the baseline consisting of 4 CC RL agents only. The sum DRL nudging agent increases the total sum of contributions by 8.22% and the total proportion of cooperative contributions by 12.42%, while the prop nudging DRL increases the total sum of contributions by 8.85% and the total proportion of cooperative contributions by 14.87%. Our findings advance the literature on public goods games and reinforcement learning.
Open AccessLearning Nudges for Conditional Cooperation: A Multi-Agent Reinforcement Learning Model
The public goods game describes a social dilemma in which a large proportion of agents act as conditional cooperators (CC): they only act cooperatively if they see others acting cooperatively because they satisfice with the social norm to be in line with what others are doing instead of optimizing cooperation. CCs are guided by aspiration-based reinforcement learning guided by past experiences of interactions with others and satisficing aspirations. In many real-world settings, reinforcing social norms do not emerge. In this paper, we propose that an optimizing reinforcement agent can facilitate cooperation through nudges, i.e. indirect mechanisms for cooperation to happen. The agent's goal is to motivate CCs into cooperation through its own actions to create social norms that signal that others are cooperating. We introduce a multi-agent reinforcement learning model for public goods games, with 3 CC learning agents using aspirational reinforcement learning and 1 nudging agent using deep reinforcement learning to learn nudges that optimize cooperation. For our nudging agent, we model two distinct reward functions, one maximizing the total game return (sum DRL) and one maximizing the number of cooperative contributions contributions higher than a proportional threshold (prop DRL). Our results show that our aspiration-based RL model for CC agents is consistent with empirically observed CC behavior. Games combining 3 CC RL agents and one nudging RL agent outperform the baseline consisting of 4 CC RL agents only. The sum DRL nudging agent increases the total sum of contributions by 8.22% and the total proportion of cooperative contributions by 12.42%, while the prop nudging DRL increases the total sum of contributions by 8.85% and the total proportion of cooperative contributions by 14.87%. Our findings advance the literature on public goods games and reinforcement learning.
- 31 December 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Industrial and Corporate Change
- Vol. 32 (1) , 234-261
The microstructure of modularity in design: a design motif view
In their seminal theory on modularity in design, Baldwin and Clark (2000, Design Rules: The Power of Modularity. MIT Press) focus on the macro-level: They show that modularity limits the degree to which changes propagate throughout a complex system, as constituted by how interdependencies among all parts pattern into a nested design structure with shared parts at the top transmitting functionalities via central parts down to the bottom. In this paper, we shift the focus to the microlevel structures of interdependencies that reflect the local decisions of designers with limited rationality. Such decisions relate to five fundamental types of interdependence structures among three parts: the design motifs. Following Baldwin and Clark (2000, Design Rules: The Power of Modularity. MIT Press), we assume that value-seeking designers weigh costs and benefits when creating motifs. We develop a new design motif theory to understand the sources of macro-level modularity. We empirically explore this theory using a sample of more than 20,000 design structures of a complex software. We observe a stable, recurring design motif signature: high-value design motifs occur more frequently than low -alue ones because of each motif’s idiosyncratic microstructure. The common resource motif occurs most frequently because of its low costs and benefits for reliability in design. The sequential loop motif holds a critical role: it offers unique benefits for innovating system functionalities, but when placed in the center, it inflates the propagation of changes. This explains why central rather than shared parts are a potential source of innovation at the expense of modularity. These findings contribute to the research and practice of modularity in design.
- 31 December 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Industrial and Corporate Change
- Vol. 32 (1) , 234-261
The microstructure of modularity in design: a design motif view
In their seminal theory on modularity in design, Baldwin and Clark (2000, Design Rules: The Power of Modularity. MIT Press) focus on the macro-level: They show that modularity limits the degree to which changes propagate throughout a complex system, as constituted by how interdependencies among all parts pattern into a nested design structure with shared parts at the top transmitting functionalities via central parts down to the bottom. In this paper, we shift the focus to the microlevel structures of interdependencies that reflect the local decisions of designers with limited rationality. Such decisions relate to five fundamental types of interdependence structures among three parts: the design motifs. Following Baldwin and Clark (2000, Design Rules: The Power of Modularity. MIT Press), we assume that value-seeking designers weigh costs and benefits when creating motifs. We develop a new design motif theory to understand the sources of macro-level modularity. We empirically explore this theory using a sample of more than 20,000 design structures of a complex software. We observe a stable, recurring design motif signature: high-value design motifs occur more frequently than low -alue ones because of each motif’s idiosyncratic microstructure. The common resource motif occurs most frequently because of its low costs and benefits for reliability in design. The sequential loop motif holds a critical role: it offers unique benefits for innovating system functionalities, but when placed in the center, it inflates the propagation of changes. This explains why central rather than shared parts are a potential source of innovation at the expense of modularity. These findings contribute to the research and practice of modularity in design.
- 1 August 2020
- Published by Academy of Management in Academy of Management Proceedings
- Vol. 2020 (1) , 21853
The Microstructure of Complex Design Architectures: A Theory of Design Network Motifs
- 1 August 2020
- Published by Academy of Management in Academy of Management Proceedings
- Vol. 2020 (1) , 21853
The Microstructure of Complex Design Architectures: A Theory of Design Network Motifs