Kimberly Arellano Carmona
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Kimberly Arellano Carmona has a total of 4 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- A. Susana Ramirez
University of California Merced
2 shared publications - Deepti Chittamuru
Department of Public Health, School of Social Sciences, Humanities, and Arts, University of California
2 shared publications - Richard L. Kravitz
UC Davis Division of General Medicine and Bioethics, Sacramento, California (R.L.K.)
2 shared publications - Steven Ramondt
Donor Studies, Department of Donor Medicine Research Sanquin Research Amsterdam The Netherlands
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 19 August 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 24 (8) , e36322
Health Information Seeking From an Intelligent Web-Based Symptom Checker: Cross-sectional Questionnaire Study
Background: The ever-growing amount of health information available on the web is increasing the demand for tools providing personalized and actionable health information. Such tools include symptom checkers that provide users with a potential diagnosis after responding to a set of probes about their symptoms. Although the potential for their utility is great, little is known about such tools’ actual use and effects. Objective: We aimed to understand who uses a web-based artificial intelligence–powered symptom checker and its purposes, how they evaluate the experience of the web-based interview and quality of the information, what they intend to do with the recommendation, and predictors of future use. Methods: Cross-sectional survey of web-based health information seekers following the completion of a symptom checker visit (N=2437). Measures of comprehensibility, confidence, usefulness, health-related anxiety, empowerment, and intention to use in the future were assessed. ANOVAs and the Wilcoxon rank sum test examined mean outcome differences in racial, ethnic, and sex groups. The relationship between perceptions of the symptom checker and intention to follow recommended actions was assessed using multilevel logistic regression. Results: Buoy users were well-educated (1384/1704, 81.22% college or higher), primarily White (1227/1693, 72.47%), and female (2069/2437, 84.89%). Most had insurance (1449/1630, 88.89%), a regular health care provider (1307/1709, 76.48%), and reported good health (1000/1703, 58.72%). Three types of symptoms—pain (855/2437, 35.08%), gynecological issues (293/2437, 12.02%), and masses or lumps (204/2437, 8.37%)—accounted for almost half (1352/2437, 55.48%) of site visits. Buoy’s top three primary recommendations split across less-serious triage categories: primary care physician in 2 weeks (754/2141, 35.22%), self-treatment (452/2141, 21.11%), and primary care in 1 to 2 days (373/2141, 17.42%). Common diagnoses were musculoskeletal (303/2437, 12.43%), gynecological (304/2437, 12.47%) and skin conditions (297/2437, 12.19%), and infectious diseases (300/2437, 12.31%). Users generally reported high confidence in Buoy, found it useful and easy to understand, and said that Buoy made them feel less anxious and more empowered to seek medical help. Users for whom Buoy recommended “Waiting/Watching” or “Self-Treatment” had strongest intentions to comply, whereas those advised to seek primary care had weaker intentions. Compared with White users, Latino and Black users had significantly more confidence in Buoy (P<.05), and the former also found it significantly more useful (P<.05). Latino (odds ratio 1.96, 95% CI 1.22-3.25) and Black (odds ratio 2.37, 95% CI 1.57-3.66) users also had stronger intentions to discuss recommendations with a provider than White users. Conclusions: Results demonstrate the potential utility of a web-based health information tool to empower people to seek care and reduce health-related anxiety. However, despite encouraging results suggesting the tool may fulfill unmet health information needs among women and Black and Latino adults, analyses of the user base illustrate persistent second-level digital divide effects.
- 19 August 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in Journal of Medical Internet Research
- Vol. 24 (8) , e36322
Open AccessHealth Information Seeking From an Intelligent Web-Based Symptom Checker: Cross-sectional Questionnaire Study
Background: The ever-growing amount of health information available on the web is increasing the demand for tools providing personalized and actionable health information. Such tools include symptom checkers that provide users with a potential diagnosis after responding to a set of probes about their symptoms. Although the potential for their utility is great, little is known about such tools’ actual use and effects. Objective: We aimed to understand who uses a web-based artificial intelligence–powered symptom checker and its purposes, how they evaluate the experience of the web-based interview and quality of the information, what they intend to do with the recommendation, and predictors of future use. Methods: Cross-sectional survey of web-based health information seekers following the completion of a symptom checker visit (N=2437). Measures of comprehensibility, confidence, usefulness, health-related anxiety, empowerment, and intention to use in the future were assessed. ANOVAs and the Wilcoxon rank sum test examined mean outcome differences in racial, ethnic, and sex groups. The relationship between perceptions of the symptom checker and intention to follow recommended actions was assessed using multilevel logistic regression. Results: Buoy users were well-educated (1384/1704, 81.22% college or higher), primarily White (1227/1693, 72.47%), and female (2069/2437, 84.89%). Most had insurance (1449/1630, 88.89%), a regular health care provider (1307/1709, 76.48%), and reported good health (1000/1703, 58.72%). Three types of symptoms—pain (855/2437, 35.08%), gynecological issues (293/2437, 12.02%), and masses or lumps (204/2437, 8.37%)—accounted for almost half (1352/2437, 55.48%) of site visits. Buoy’s top three primary recommendations split across less-serious triage categories: primary care physician in 2 weeks (754/2141, 35.22%), self-treatment (452/2141, 21.11%), and primary care in 1 to 2 days (373/2141, 17.42%). Common diagnoses were musculoskeletal (303/2437, 12.43%), gynecological (304/2437, 12.47%) and skin conditions (297/2437, 12.19%), and infectious diseases (300/2437, 12.31%). Users generally reported high confidence in Buoy, found it useful and easy to understand, and said that Buoy made them feel less anxious and more empowered to seek medical help. Users for whom Buoy recommended “Waiting/Watching” or “Self-Treatment” had strongest intentions to comply, whereas those advised to seek primary care had weaker intentions. Compared with White users, Latino and Black users had significantly more confidence in Buoy (P<.05), and the former also found it significantly more useful (P<.05). Latino (odds ratio 1.96, 95% CI 1.22-3.25) and Black (odds ratio 2.37, 95% CI 1.57-3.66) users also had stronger intentions to discuss recommendations with a provider than White users. Conclusions: Results demonstrate the potential utility of a web-based health information tool to empower people to seek care and reduce health-related anxiety. However, despite encouraging results suggesting the tool may fulfill unmet health information needs among women and Black and Latino adults, analyses of the user base illustrate persistent second-level digital divide effects.
- Open Access
- 17 January 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Beyond Dr. Google: Health information seeking from an intelligent online symptom checker among the general population (Preprint)
BACKGROUND The internet is an increasingly important source for health information, but information quality varies substantially. Disparities in one’s ability to identify reliable information and to make sense of such contribute to negative psychosocial outcomes and aggravate digital divide-related health disparities. The ever-growing amounts of health information available online are increasing demand for tools that provide personalized and actionable health information. Such tools include symptom checkers, which provide users with a potential diagnosis after responding to a set of probes about their symptoms. Although the potential for their utility is great, little is known about actual usage and effects of such tools. OBJECTIVE We sought to understand who is using an online AI-powered symptom checker and for what purposes; how they evaluate the experiences of online information seeking and the interactive interview and the quality of the information, and what they intend to do with the recommendation. METHODS Cross-sectional survey of online health information seekers immediately following completion of symptom checker visit (N=2,437). Symptoms and diagnoses were coded using CDC’s National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. RESULTS Buoy users were well-educated (81% some college or more), mostly white (72%) and female (85%). Most had insurance (89%), a regular healthcare provider (76%), and reported good health (59%). Just three types of symptoms – pain (35%), gynecological issues (13%), and masses or lumps (8%) – accounted for 55% of site visits. Buoy’s primary recommendation was more evenly split across the less-serious triage categories: Primary Care Doctor in 2 weeks (35%), Self-Treatment (21%), and Primary Care in 1-2 days (17%) as the top three recommendations received by Buoy. Common diagnoses were musculoskeletal (12%), gynecological (12%), and skin conditions (12%), and infectious diseases (12%). Users generally reported high levels of confidence in Buoy (Mean (SD)=3.47(0.97)), found it useful (Mean (SD)=4.18(0.81)), easy to understand (Mean (SD)=4.64(0.53)), and said Buoy made them feel less anxious (Mean (SD)=3.60(1.05)) and more empowered to seek medical help (Mean (SD)=3.75(0.96)). Users had strong intention to follow recommended action: 76% intended to follow Buoy’s recommendations, while 66% intended to discuss Buoy’s advice with a physician. Users for whom Buoy recommended “Waiting/Watching” (Mean (SD)=4.38 (0.90)), or “Self-Treatment” (Mean (SD)=4.33 (0.93)), had the strongest intentions to comply, whereas those who were advised to seek primary care had weaker intentions. CONCLUSIONS Results demonstrate the potential utility of an online health in formation tool to empower people to seek appropriate care and reduce health-related anxiety. An interactive symptom checker might provide more personalized and potentially reliable medical information compared to other forms of online health information seeking. Yet despite encouraging results suggesting that the online tool may fill unmet health information needs among women, African Americans, and Latinos, analyses of the user base illustrate persistent second-level digital-divide effects.
- 17 January 2022
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessBeyond Dr. Google: Health information seeking from an intelligent online symptom checker among the general population (Preprint)
BACKGROUND The internet is an increasingly important source for health information, but information quality varies substantially. Disparities in one’s ability to identify reliable information and to make sense of such contribute to negative psychosocial outcomes and aggravate digital divide-related health disparities. The ever-growing amounts of health information available online are increasing demand for tools that provide personalized and actionable health information. Such tools include symptom checkers, which provide users with a potential diagnosis after responding to a set of probes about their symptoms. Although the potential for their utility is great, little is known about actual usage and effects of such tools. OBJECTIVE We sought to understand who is using an online AI-powered symptom checker and for what purposes; how they evaluate the experiences of online information seeking and the interactive interview and the quality of the information, and what they intend to do with the recommendation. METHODS Cross-sectional survey of online health information seekers immediately following completion of symptom checker visit (N=2,437). Symptoms and diagnoses were coded using CDC’s National Ambulatory Medical Care Survey. RESULTS Buoy users were well-educated (81% some college or more), mostly white (72%) and female (85%). Most had insurance (89%), a regular healthcare provider (76%), and reported good health (59%). Just three types of symptoms – pain (35%), gynecological issues (13%), and masses or lumps (8%) – accounted for 55% of site visits. Buoy’s primary recommendation was more evenly split across the less-serious triage categories: Primary Care Doctor in 2 weeks (35%), Self-Treatment (21%), and Primary Care in 1-2 days (17%) as the top three recommendations received by Buoy. Common diagnoses were musculoskeletal (12%), gynecological (12%), and skin conditions (12%), and infectious diseases (12%). Users generally reported high levels of confidence in Buoy (Mean (SD)=3.47(0.97)), found it useful (Mean (SD)=4.18(0.81)), easy to understand (Mean (SD)=4.64(0.53)), and said Buoy made them feel less anxious (Mean (SD)=3.60(1.05)) and more empowered to seek medical help (Mean (SD)=3.75(0.96)). Users had strong intention to follow recommended action: 76% intended to follow Buoy’s recommendations, while 66% intended to discuss Buoy’s advice with a physician. Users for whom Buoy recommended “Waiting/Watching” (Mean (SD)=4.38 (0.90)), or “Self-Treatment” (Mean (SD)=4.33 (0.93)), had the strongest intentions to comply, whereas those who were advised to seek primary care had weaker intentions. CONCLUSIONS Results demonstrate the potential utility of an online health in formation tool to empower people to seek appropriate care and reduce health-related anxiety. An interactive symptom checker might provide more personalized and potentially reliable medical information compared to other forms of online health information seeking. Yet despite encouraging results suggesting that the online tool may fill unmet health information needs among women, African Americans, and Latinos, analyses of the user base illustrate persistent second-level digital-divide effects.