Lise Seland Graff
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Lise Seland Graff has a total of 140 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Xavier Levine
NORCE Norwegian Research Centre AS and Bjerknes Centre for Climate Research, Bergen, Norway
14 shared publications - Dörthe Handorf
Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Potsdam, Germany
12 shared publications - Raphael Köhler
Alfred Wegener Institute, Helmholtz Centre for Polar and Marine Research, Potsdam, Germany
12 shared publications - Camille Li
Geophysical Institute and Bjerknes Centre for Climate Research, University of Bergen, Norway
11 shared publications - René Reijer Wijngaard
Department of Physical Geography, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands
11 shared publications - Mats Bentsen
NORCE Norwegian Research Centre Bjerknes Centre for Climate Research Bergen Norway
10 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 4 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Comment on egusphere-2026-5525
Future climate projections are subject to multiple sources of uncertainty. Here, we examine model uncertainty from a storyline perspective using three variable-resolution (VR) models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. We implement the storyline framework by prescribing sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea-ice concentrations (SICs) from models from the coupled model intercomparison project phase six previously deemed representative of contrasting Arctic and Antarctic storylines. We perform experiments with and without polar refinement, resulting in the first storyline-based multi-model experiments with polar refinement. We evaluate whether this framework captures known characteristics of the storylines and generally find good agreement between the VR experiments and storylines for near-surface temperature, reflecting the strong constraint from the lower-boundary forcing. For precipitation and zonal wind, the characteristics are better captured for the Antarctic storyline experiments than the Arctic ones. Nevertheless, the contrasting storyline forcing mostly yields distinct future responses, demonstrating that storyline-based forcing-model selection is a powerful tool for generating contrasting model experiments. We also quantify the influence of the storyline, VR model, and resolution for a wider range of variables. Resolution has the weakest overall impact, while the storyline dominates across most variables in the Antarctic storyline experiments and for low-level tropospheric temperature and near-surface humidity in the Arctic experiments. The model and resolution influence are generally strongest for precipitation and cloud cover. Thus, the choice of lower-boundary forcing and model has a greater influence on future responses than local changes in horizontal resolution.
- 4 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2026-5525
Future climate projections are subject to multiple sources of uncertainty. Here, we examine model uncertainty from a storyline perspective using three variable-resolution (VR) models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. We implement the storyline framework by prescribing sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea-ice concentrations (SICs) from models from the coupled model intercomparison project phase six previously deemed representative of contrasting Arctic and Antarctic storylines. We perform experiments with and without polar refinement, resulting in the first storyline-based multi-model experiments with polar refinement. We evaluate whether this framework captures known characteristics of the storylines and generally find good agreement between the VR experiments and storylines for near-surface temperature, reflecting the strong constraint from the lower-boundary forcing. For precipitation and zonal wind, the characteristics are better captured for the Antarctic storyline experiments than the Arctic ones. Nevertheless, the contrasting storyline forcing mostly yields distinct future responses, demonstrating that storyline-based forcing-model selection is a powerful tool for generating contrasting model experiments. We also quantify the influence of the storyline, VR model, and resolution for a wider range of variables. Resolution has the weakest overall impact, while the storyline dominates across most variables in the Antarctic storyline experiments and for low-level tropospheric temperature and near-surface humidity in the Arctic experiments. The model and resolution influence are generally strongest for precipitation and cloud cover. Thus, the choice of lower-boundary forcing and model has a greater influence on future responses than local changes in horizontal resolution.
- Open Access
- 4 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Review of "Quantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models"
Future climate projections are subject to multiple sources of uncertainty. Here, we examine model uncertainty from a storyline perspective using three variable-resolution (VR) models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. We implement the storyline framework by prescribing sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea-ice concentrations (SICs) from models from the coupled model intercomparison project phase six previously deemed representative of contrasting Arctic and Antarctic storylines. We perform experiments with and without polar refinement, resulting in the first storyline-based multi-model experiments with polar refinement. We evaluate whether this framework captures known characteristics of the storylines and generally find good agreement between the VR experiments and storylines for near-surface temperature, reflecting the strong constraint from the lower-boundary forcing. For precipitation and zonal wind, the characteristics are better captured for the Antarctic storyline experiments than the Arctic ones. Nevertheless, the contrasting storyline forcing mostly yields distinct future responses, demonstrating that storyline-based forcing-model selection is a powerful tool for generating contrasting model experiments. We also quantify the influence of the storyline, VR model, and resolution for a wider range of variables. Resolution has the weakest overall impact, while the storyline dominates across most variables in the Antarctic storyline experiments and for low-level tropospheric temperature and near-surface humidity in the Arctic experiments. The model and resolution influence are generally strongest for precipitation and cloud cover. Thus, the choice of lower-boundary forcing and model has a greater influence on future responses than local changes in horizontal resolution.
- 4 November 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessReview of "Quantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models"
Future climate projections are subject to multiple sources of uncertainty. Here, we examine model uncertainty from a storyline perspective using three variable-resolution (VR) models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. We implement the storyline framework by prescribing sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea-ice concentrations (SICs) from models from the coupled model intercomparison project phase six previously deemed representative of contrasting Arctic and Antarctic storylines. We perform experiments with and without polar refinement, resulting in the first storyline-based multi-model experiments with polar refinement. We evaluate whether this framework captures known characteristics of the storylines and generally find good agreement between the VR experiments and storylines for near-surface temperature, reflecting the strong constraint from the lower-boundary forcing. For precipitation and zonal wind, the characteristics are better captured for the Antarctic storyline experiments than the Arctic ones. Nevertheless, the contrasting storyline forcing mostly yields distinct future responses, demonstrating that storyline-based forcing-model selection is a powerful tool for generating contrasting model experiments. We also quantify the influence of the storyline, VR model, and resolution for a wider range of variables. Resolution has the weakest overall impact, while the storyline dominates across most variables in the Antarctic storyline experiments and for low-level tropospheric temperature and near-surface humidity in the Arctic experiments. The model and resolution influence are generally strongest for precipitation and cloud cover. Thus, the choice of lower-boundary forcing and model has a greater influence on future responses than local changes in horizontal resolution.
- Open Access
- 23 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Supplementary material to "Quantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models"
- 23 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSupplementary material to "Quantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models"
- Open Access
- 23 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Quantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models
Future climate projections are subject to multiple sources of uncertainty. Here, we examine model uncertainty from a storyline perspective using three variable-resolution (VR) models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. We implement the storyline framework by prescribing sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea-ice concentrations (SICs) from models from the coupled model intercomparison project phase six previously deemed representative of contrasting Arctic and Antarctic storylines. We perform experiments with and without polar refinement, resulting in the first storyline-based multi-model experiments with polar refinement. We evaluate whether this framework captures known characteristics of the storylines and generally find good agreement between the VR experiments and storylines for near-surface temperature, reflecting the strong constraint from the lower-boundary forcing. For precipitation and zonal wind, the characteristics are better captured for the Antarctic storyline experiments than the Arctic ones. Nevertheless, the contrasting storyline forcing mostly yields distinct future responses, demonstrating that storyline-based forcing-model selection is a powerful tool for generating contrasting model experiments. We also quantify the influence of the storyline, VR model, and resolution for a wider range of variables. Resolution has the weakest overall impact, while the storyline dominates across most variables in the Antarctic storyline experiments and for low-level tropospheric temperature and near-surface humidity in the Arctic experiments. The model and resolution influence are generally strongest for precipitation and cloud cover. Thus, the choice of lower-boundary forcing and model has a greater influence on future responses than local changes in horizontal resolution.
- 23 September 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2026, 1-40
Open AccessQuantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models
Future climate projections are subject to multiple sources of uncertainty. Here, we examine model uncertainty from a storyline perspective using three variable-resolution (VR) models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. We implement the storyline framework by prescribing sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea-ice concentrations (SICs) from models from the coupled model intercomparison project phase six previously deemed representative of contrasting Arctic and Antarctic storylines. We perform experiments with and without polar refinement, resulting in the first storyline-based multi-model experiments with polar refinement. We evaluate whether this framework captures known characteristics of the storylines and generally find good agreement between the VR experiments and storylines for near-surface temperature, reflecting the strong constraint from the lower-boundary forcing. For precipitation and zonal wind, the characteristics are better captured for the Antarctic storyline experiments than the Arctic ones. Nevertheless, the contrasting storyline forcing mostly yields distinct future responses, demonstrating that storyline-based forcing-model selection is a powerful tool for generating contrasting model experiments. We also quantify the influence of the storyline, VR model, and resolution for a wider range of variables. Resolution has the weakest overall impact, while the storyline dominates across most variables in the Antarctic storyline experiments and for low-level tropospheric temperature and near-surface humidity in the Arctic experiments. The model and resolution influence are generally strongest for precipitation and cloud cover. Thus, the choice of lower-boundary forcing and model has a greater influence on future responses than local changes in horizontal resolution.
- Open Access
- 4 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 152 (778)
A multimodel intercomparison study of variable‐resolution global models with grid refinement over the Arctic and Antarctic
The polar regions are undergoing profound changes, but climate models still struggle to accurately represent key polar climate processes. Exploring how increased horizontal resolution affects model biases in the polar regions and lower latitudes, we performed a coordinated set of global model simulations for the recent past with grid refinement in the polar regions, with the finest resolution implemented poleward of 60°. We employed three state‐of‐the‐art models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. The result is the first coordinated multimodel ensemble with variable‐resolution models with refinement over the polar regions. This work documents the common experiment protocol and presents the first results, focusing on temperature, zonal wind, and turbulent surface fluxes. The experiments were configured with fully coupled atmosphere and land components and prescribed sea‐surface temperatures and sea‐ice concentrations. Forcings for greenhouse gases and aerosols were based on the historical experiment from the sixth phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project. We find that the influence of the refinement, assessed by comparing simulations with refined and uniform resolution, can vary considerably across models, hemispheres, and seasons. The most consistent improvements occur in wintertime upper‐tropospheric high‐latitude temperature, leading to improved Equator‐to‐Pole temperature contrasts and zonal wind in both hemispheres. Though all models underestimate the Arctic winter near‐surface temperature compared with the fifth generation of the European Center for Medium‐Rrange Forecasts Reanalysis, validation against Arctic and Antarctic in‐situ measurements reveals modest improvements in the refined experiments, with the measured values being better represented in the Arctic compared with the Antarctic and in summer compared with winter.
- 4 May 2026
- Published by Wiley in Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society
- Vol. 152 (778)
Open AccessA multimodel intercomparison study of variable‐resolution global models with grid refinement over the Arctic and Antarctic
The polar regions are undergoing profound changes, but climate models still struggle to accurately represent key polar climate processes. Exploring how increased horizontal resolution affects model biases in the polar regions and lower latitudes, we performed a coordinated set of global model simulations for the recent past with grid refinement in the polar regions, with the finest resolution implemented poleward of 60°. We employed three state‐of‐the‐art models: the Community Earth System Model, the Icosahedral Nonhydrostatic model, and the Model for Prediction Across Scales. The result is the first coordinated multimodel ensemble with variable‐resolution models with refinement over the polar regions. This work documents the common experiment protocol and presents the first results, focusing on temperature, zonal wind, and turbulent surface fluxes. The experiments were configured with fully coupled atmosphere and land components and prescribed sea‐surface temperatures and sea‐ice concentrations. Forcings for greenhouse gases and aerosols were based on the historical experiment from the sixth phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project. We find that the influence of the refinement, assessed by comparing simulations with refined and uniform resolution, can vary considerably across models, hemispheres, and seasons. The most consistent improvements occur in wintertime upper‐tropospheric high‐latitude temperature, leading to improved Equator‐to‐Pole temperature contrasts and zonal wind in both hemispheres. Though all models underestimate the Arctic winter near‐surface temperature compared with the fifth generation of the European Center for Medium‐Rrange Forecasts Reanalysis, validation against Arctic and Antarctic in‐situ measurements reveals modest improvements in the refined experiments, with the measured values being better represented in the Arctic compared with the Antarctic and in summer compared with winter.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Same model, different answers? Structural uncertainty in Arctic climate change across downscaling approaches, forcings, and scenarios
High-resolution climate change projections are essential for assessing Arctic climate impacts and extreme events. Such projections are commonly obtained through statistical downscaling, dynamical downscaling, regional refinement of global climate models (GCMs), or other emerging high-resolution modelling frameworks. While dynamical methods allow physically consistent regional projections based on global forcing, they remain computationally expensive, limiting the number of GCMs and scenarios that can be explored. As a result, structural uncertainty associated with modelling strategy, choice of driving GCM, and emission scenario is often insufficiently quantified, particularly for Arctic climate change signals. A key challenge is that systematic comparisons of climate change signal patterns across different high-resolution modelling approaches are rare. This is partly because few modelling systems allow consistent simulations in global, regionally refined, and limited-area configurations using the same model physics. Consequently, it remains unclear to what extent differences in projected Arctic climate change arise from large-scale forcing versus the downscaling framework itself.Here, we address this gap using the ICON (ICOsahedral Nonhydrostatic) modelling system in three complementary configurations: a global setup with uniform coarse resolution (~53 km), a globally variable-resolution configuration with enhanced Arctic resolution (~13 km) and coarse resolution elsewhere (~53 km), and an Arctic high-resolution limited-area mode (~11 km). Control and scenario simulations are available for multiple driving GCMs and emission pathways, enabling a targeted, storyline-based assessment of structural uncertainty, focusing on physically consistent responses to prescribed large-scale forcings. This experimental design allows us to disentangle uncertainties related to (i) the downscaling approach, (ii) the choice of large-scale forcing, and (iii) the emission scenario, while keeping model formulation consistent. We analyse Arctic climate change signals for near-surface air temperature and precipitation, focusing on seasonal mean responses. Pattern-based, multi-simulation comparisons are used to assess agreement and differences across simulations at both pan-Arctic and regional scales. This allows us to identify aspects of Arctic climate change that are robust across downscaling strategies, as well as regions where projected responses are particularly sensitive to model configuration or large-scale forcing, highlighting areas of enhanced structural uncertainty. Our results provide guidance for interpreting high-resolution Arctic climate projections and support targeted model selection for impact-oriented studies and regional climate assessments.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessSame model, different answers? Structural uncertainty in Arctic climate change across downscaling approaches, forcings, and scenarios
High-resolution climate change projections are essential for assessing Arctic climate impacts and extreme events. Such projections are commonly obtained through statistical downscaling, dynamical downscaling, regional refinement of global climate models (GCMs), or other emerging high-resolution modelling frameworks. While dynamical methods allow physically consistent regional projections based on global forcing, they remain computationally expensive, limiting the number of GCMs and scenarios that can be explored. As a result, structural uncertainty associated with modelling strategy, choice of driving GCM, and emission scenario is often insufficiently quantified, particularly for Arctic climate change signals. A key challenge is that systematic comparisons of climate change signal patterns across different high-resolution modelling approaches are rare. This is partly because few modelling systems allow consistent simulations in global, regionally refined, and limited-area configurations using the same model physics. Consequently, it remains unclear to what extent differences in projected Arctic climate change arise from large-scale forcing versus the downscaling framework itself.Here, we address this gap using the ICON (ICOsahedral Nonhydrostatic) modelling system in three complementary configurations: a global setup with uniform coarse resolution (~53 km), a globally variable-resolution configuration with enhanced Arctic resolution (~13 km) and coarse resolution elsewhere (~53 km), and an Arctic high-resolution limited-area mode (~11 km). Control and scenario simulations are available for multiple driving GCMs and emission pathways, enabling a targeted, storyline-based assessment of structural uncertainty, focusing on physically consistent responses to prescribed large-scale forcings. This experimental design allows us to disentangle uncertainties related to (i) the downscaling approach, (ii) the choice of large-scale forcing, and (iii) the emission scenario, while keeping model formulation consistent. We analyse Arctic climate change signals for near-surface air temperature and precipitation, focusing on seasonal mean responses. Pattern-based, multi-simulation comparisons are used to assess agreement and differences across simulations at both pan-Arctic and regional scales. This allows us to identify aspects of Arctic climate change that are robust across downscaling strategies, as well as regions where projected responses are particularly sensitive to model configuration or large-scale forcing, highlighting areas of enhanced structural uncertainty. Our results provide guidance for interpreting high-resolution Arctic climate projections and support targeted model selection for impact-oriented studies and regional climate assessments.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Quantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models
Here, we use three variable-resolution, global models to explore storylines of future Arctic and Antarctic climate change previously derived by Levine et al. (2024; 10.5194/esd-15-1161-2024) and Williams et al. (2024; 10.1175/JCLI-D-23-0122.1). The models are the Community Earth System Model (CESM), the ICOsahedral Nonhydrostatic model (ICON), and the Model for Prediction Across Scales (MPAS). The pair of Arctic storylines examined represent 1) weak Arctic amplification combined with strong SST warming in the Barents-Kara Seas and 2) strong Arctic amplification combined with weak SST warming in the Barents-Kara Seas. Over Antarctica, the storylines explored are 1) high Southern Hemisphere (SH) sea-ice loss combined with a shorter delay in SH vortex breakdown, and 2) low SH sea-ice loss combined with a longer delay in SH vortex breakdown. Sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea ice concentrations (SICs) from CMIP6 models that are representative of these storylines were provided to the variable-resolution models to perform a number of AMIP-style experiments. We performed experiments for the recent past and for the future with uniform and refined horizontal resolution over the polar regions. The result is a novel and comprehensive set of experiments based on three different variable-resolution models (CESM, ICON, MPAS), two different SST and SIC forcing fields for the Arctic and two for the Antarctic (from 4 different CMIP6 models), two different resolutions (refined and unrefined), and two different time periods (recent past and future). We use this experiment set to explore the extent to which results from the variable-resolution experiments resemble the CMIP6 models that have been selected to represent the storylines that the SSTs and SICs are taken from, focusing on near-surface temperature, precipitation, and 850-hPa zonal wind. Furthermore, we quantify the influence of the storyline model, the influence of the variable-resolution model, and the influence of the resolution on the future responses. Results show that the influence of the storyline and the variable-resolution model is larger than the influence of the resolution for all variables and seasons in both the Arctic and Antarctic. In the Antarctic, the storyline influence moreover tends to be larger than the model influence, meaning that the model differences are smaller than the differences associated with the phase of the remote drivers (high/low SH sea-ice loss & short/longshort SH vortex breakdown delay). While we find similar results for near-surface temperature in the Arctic, the storyline and model influence are more comparable for precipitation and zonal wind. Overall, our results suggest that for the large-scale climate change responses considered here, careful selection and sampling of storyline drivers and model structural uncertainty is more critical than increased horizontal resolution in the polar regions.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessQuantifying future Arctic and Antarctic climate change from a storyline perspective using global variable-resolution models
Here, we use three variable-resolution, global models to explore storylines of future Arctic and Antarctic climate change previously derived by Levine et al. (2024; 10.5194/esd-15-1161-2024) and Williams et al. (2024; 10.1175/JCLI-D-23-0122.1). The models are the Community Earth System Model (CESM), the ICOsahedral Nonhydrostatic model (ICON), and the Model for Prediction Across Scales (MPAS). The pair of Arctic storylines examined represent 1) weak Arctic amplification combined with strong SST warming in the Barents-Kara Seas and 2) strong Arctic amplification combined with weak SST warming in the Barents-Kara Seas. Over Antarctica, the storylines explored are 1) high Southern Hemisphere (SH) sea-ice loss combined with a shorter delay in SH vortex breakdown, and 2) low SH sea-ice loss combined with a longer delay in SH vortex breakdown. Sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and sea ice concentrations (SICs) from CMIP6 models that are representative of these storylines were provided to the variable-resolution models to perform a number of AMIP-style experiments. We performed experiments for the recent past and for the future with uniform and refined horizontal resolution over the polar regions. The result is a novel and comprehensive set of experiments based on three different variable-resolution models (CESM, ICON, MPAS), two different SST and SIC forcing fields for the Arctic and two for the Antarctic (from 4 different CMIP6 models), two different resolutions (refined and unrefined), and two different time periods (recent past and future). We use this experiment set to explore the extent to which results from the variable-resolution experiments resemble the CMIP6 models that have been selected to represent the storylines that the SSTs and SICs are taken from, focusing on near-surface temperature, precipitation, and 850-hPa zonal wind. Furthermore, we quantify the influence of the storyline model, the influence of the variable-resolution model, and the influence of the resolution on the future responses. Results show that the influence of the storyline and the variable-resolution model is larger than the influence of the resolution for all variables and seasons in both the Arctic and Antarctic. In the Antarctic, the storyline influence moreover tends to be larger than the model influence, meaning that the model differences are smaller than the differences associated with the phase of the remote drivers (high/low SH sea-ice loss & short/longshort SH vortex breakdown delay). While we find similar results for near-surface temperature in the Arctic, the storyline and model influence are more comparable for precipitation and zonal wind. Overall, our results suggest that for the large-scale climate change responses considered here, careful selection and sampling of storyline drivers and model structural uncertainty is more critical than increased horizontal resolution in the polar regions.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Nordic precipitation trends and North Atlantic circulation patterns in CMIP6 models
Recent observed trends indicate increasing future precipitation in Northern Europe, yet CMIP6 models show substantial spread in sign and magnitude of both historical and future precipitation trends in the region. This large model spread highlights the difficulty in accurately modelling regional precipitation in global climate models, and the low confidence in future precipitation trends. In this study, we evaluate recent historical winter precipitation trends in selected models of the CMIP6 ensemble by validating the models against reanalysis and observations, and examining how the trends are influenced by sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and the large-scale atmospheric circulation, particularly the North Atlantic storm track. We consider data from CMIP6 historical and AMIP experiments, the latter using prescribed observed SST and sea ice concentration. Additionally, we include a complimentary set of AMIP-style experiments with the Norwegian Earth System Model (NorESM2) where we explore the effect of different time-evolving SST fields. Results show that models yield consistent precipitation patterns, which enables an assessment of the role of North Atlantic SST in shaping Nordic precipitation trends, when averaging over multiple ensemble members. Differences in Nordic precipitation trends are tied to differences in the North Atlantic SST pattern evolution, with consistent changes in latent heat flux, atmospheric baroclinicity and lower tropospheric zonal wind patterns. Particularly, differences in SST in the North Atlantic warming hole and along the eastern US coast and close to Svalbard, the latter related to rapid warming from Arctic sea ice loss, can influence the precipitation trends. Employing the relationship between North Atlantic SST and precipitation trends in the Nordic region, we can better understand the large precipitation spread among climate models, and thus increase confidence in both historical and future precipitation in the models. Furthermore, while the majority of CMIP6 models provide just a single ensemble member for the AMIP experiment, our results demonstrate that using multiple ensemble members for the AMIP experiments is essential to account for internal variability and to achieve robust results.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessNordic precipitation trends and North Atlantic circulation patterns in CMIP6 models
Recent observed trends indicate increasing future precipitation in Northern Europe, yet CMIP6 models show substantial spread in sign and magnitude of both historical and future precipitation trends in the region. This large model spread highlights the difficulty in accurately modelling regional precipitation in global climate models, and the low confidence in future precipitation trends. In this study, we evaluate recent historical winter precipitation trends in selected models of the CMIP6 ensemble by validating the models against reanalysis and observations, and examining how the trends are influenced by sea surface temperatures (SSTs) and the large-scale atmospheric circulation, particularly the North Atlantic storm track. We consider data from CMIP6 historical and AMIP experiments, the latter using prescribed observed SST and sea ice concentration. Additionally, we include a complimentary set of AMIP-style experiments with the Norwegian Earth System Model (NorESM2) where we explore the effect of different time-evolving SST fields. Results show that models yield consistent precipitation patterns, which enables an assessment of the role of North Atlantic SST in shaping Nordic precipitation trends, when averaging over multiple ensemble members. Differences in Nordic precipitation trends are tied to differences in the North Atlantic SST pattern evolution, with consistent changes in latent heat flux, atmospheric baroclinicity and lower tropospheric zonal wind patterns. Particularly, differences in SST in the North Atlantic warming hole and along the eastern US coast and close to Svalbard, the latter related to rapid warming from Arctic sea ice loss, can influence the precipitation trends. Employing the relationship between North Atlantic SST and precipitation trends in the Nordic region, we can better understand the large precipitation spread among climate models, and thus increase confidence in both historical and future precipitation in the models. Furthermore, while the majority of CMIP6 models provide just a single ensemble member for the AMIP experiment, our results demonstrate that using multiple ensemble members for the AMIP experiments is essential to account for internal variability and to achieve robust results.
- Open Access
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Stockholm University Press in Tellus
- Vol. 78 (1) , 1-21
Selecting CMIP6 Models for Future Arctic Storylines Using a Novel Performance Score
Storylines are physically plausible scenarios of future climate change, statistically derived from an ensemble of climate model projections and organized according to the magnitude of projected changes in two or more remote drivers that strongly influence the spatial pattern of the climate response. Here, we provide novel insights into the Arctic storylines identified by Levine et al. (2024), where Barents-Kara Sea warming and lower-tropospheric Arctic warming during the extended summer season (May–October) were remote drivers, as we identify a set of models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project phase 6 to represent the storylines. We do this by first identifying models that are similar to these storylines in terms of each remote driver response and quantifying this similarity. Second, we evaluate the model’s performance in terms of a simple performance score based on the mean normalized root-mean-square error for multiple climate variables of importance for the storylines. The normalized values vary between 0 and 1 for all variables, allowing them to exert a comparable influence on the score. The advantage of the score is that it provides an easily implementable and interpretable way of identifying models that are characterized by large errors relative to the rest of the ensemble. Finally, we combine the similarity estimate and the score to select models to represent the storylines. We focus on the Arctic during the extended summer season for which the storylines were designed, but also consider other seasons and regions. Through this exercise, we also document the methodology, benefits, and limitations of the score.
- 31 December 2025
- Published by Stockholm University Press in Tellus
- Vol. 78 (1) , 1-21
Open AccessSelecting CMIP6 Models for Future Arctic Storylines Using a Novel Performance Score
Storylines are physically plausible scenarios of future climate change, statistically derived from an ensemble of climate model projections and organized according to the magnitude of projected changes in two or more remote drivers that strongly influence the spatial pattern of the climate response. Here, we provide novel insights into the Arctic storylines identified by Levine et al. (2024), where Barents-Kara Sea warming and lower-tropospheric Arctic warming during the extended summer season (May–October) were remote drivers, as we identify a set of models from the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project phase 6 to represent the storylines. We do this by first identifying models that are similar to these storylines in terms of each remote driver response and quantifying this similarity. Second, we evaluate the model’s performance in terms of a simple performance score based on the mean normalized root-mean-square error for multiple climate variables of importance for the storylines. The normalized values vary between 0 and 1 for all variables, allowing them to exert a comparable influence on the score. The advantage of the score is that it provides an easily implementable and interpretable way of identifying models that are characterized by large errors relative to the rest of the ensemble. Finally, we combine the similarity estimate and the score to select models to represent the storylines. We focus on the Arctic during the extended summer season for which the storylines were designed, but also consider other seasons and regions. Through this exercise, we also document the methodology, benefits, and limitations of the score.
- Open Access
- 10 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 16 (5) , 1671-1698
Sensitivity of winter Arctic amplification in NorESM2
While Arctic amplification is a robust feature of both observed and projected climate change, projections of Arctic climate change are characterized by substantial uncertainty. To better understand the drivers of this uncertainty, we performed a coordinated set of fully coupled experiments with the second version of the Norwegian Earth System Model (NorESM2), in which selected processes of key importance for the Arctic climate have been modified. They include improved representation of (1) mixed-phase clouds, (2) eddy processes in the upper ocean, (3) Greenland ice sheet coupling, (4) snow on sea ice processes, and (5) ozone chemistry. For each modification, we carried out sensitivity experiments following the protocols for the historical simulation of the sixth phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) and a future high-emissions scenario (ssp585). This results in an ensemble of modified historical and ssp585 experiments. The sensitivity experiments all demonstrate enhanced future Arctic warming compared to the unmodified historical and ssp585 experiments. Moreover, the amplitude of the additional warming varies considerably, with the difference between the experiment with the strongest and weakest Arctic mean warming reaching ∼ 9 K during the winter season by the end of the 21st century. The warming signal is dominated by a relatively uniform Arctic warming, which, according to the CMIP6 ssp585 long-term extension, starts to equilibrate during the 22nd century. Surface temperature decomposition shows that winter warming is primarily driven by an enhanced greenhouse effect due to increased cloud cover, near-surface humidity, and the resulting increase in downwelling longwave radiation. The temperature response is most pronounced in the sea ice retreat regions, with the greatest variability between experiments occurring on the Atlantic side. We also identify an emergent constraint, linking changes in Arctic surface temperatures to changes in ocean heat fluxes and sea ice area. This highlights the importance of correctly representing (contemporary) Northern Hemisphere (NH) sea ice when assessing future projected Arctic warming.
- 10 October 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Dynamics
- Vol. 16 (5) , 1671-1698
Open AccessSensitivity of winter Arctic amplification in NorESM2
While Arctic amplification is a robust feature of both observed and projected climate change, projections of Arctic climate change are characterized by substantial uncertainty. To better understand the drivers of this uncertainty, we performed a coordinated set of fully coupled experiments with the second version of the Norwegian Earth System Model (NorESM2), in which selected processes of key importance for the Arctic climate have been modified. They include improved representation of (1) mixed-phase clouds, (2) eddy processes in the upper ocean, (3) Greenland ice sheet coupling, (4) snow on sea ice processes, and (5) ozone chemistry. For each modification, we carried out sensitivity experiments following the protocols for the historical simulation of the sixth phase of the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6) and a future high-emissions scenario (ssp585). This results in an ensemble of modified historical and ssp585 experiments. The sensitivity experiments all demonstrate enhanced future Arctic warming compared to the unmodified historical and ssp585 experiments. Moreover, the amplitude of the additional warming varies considerably, with the difference between the experiment with the strongest and weakest Arctic mean warming reaching ∼ 9 K during the winter season by the end of the 21st century. The warming signal is dominated by a relatively uniform Arctic warming, which, according to the CMIP6 ssp585 long-term extension, starts to equilibrate during the 22nd century. Surface temperature decomposition shows that winter warming is primarily driven by an enhanced greenhouse effect due to increased cloud cover, near-surface humidity, and the resulting increase in downwelling longwave radiation. The temperature response is most pronounced in the sea ice retreat regions, with the greatest variability between experiments occurring on the Atlantic side. We also identify an emergent constraint, linking changes in Arctic surface temperatures to changes in ocean heat fluxes and sea ice area. This highlights the importance of correctly representing (contemporary) Northern Hemisphere (NH) sea ice when assessing future projected Arctic warming.