Jennifer Macklin
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Jennifer Macklin has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Jim Curtis
Monash University, Behaviour Works Australia, Australia
3 shared publicationsLiam Smith
Monash University, Behaviour Works Australia, Australia
2 shared publications- Liam Smith
BehaviourWorks Australia, Monash Sustainable Development Institute, Monash University, Clayton, Australia
2 shared publications Stefan Kaufman
2 shared publications- Stefan Kaufman
Monash University
2 shared publications Amy Gullickson
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Systematic, quality appraisal of household recycling influences research finds evidence is mostly insufficient
Research on recycling behaviour and its influences can play a key role in supporting public policy efforts to mitigate the negative effects of waste generation and landfilling. However, recent reviews have raised concerns about the quality of research on recycling behaviour. Despite this, no previous reviews have conducted quality appraisals to judge the extent and impact of quality issues. This is partly due to the difficulty of applying validated quality appraisal tools developed for intervention reviews in the health and medicine fields to behaviour influence reviews in environment and sustainability fields. This update of a previous systematic review aims to fill this gap by developing and piloting a novel quality appraisal framework, specifically tailored to the needs of interdisciplinary reviews of the influences on recycling and other pre-environmental behaviours. Application of the novel framework to a set of 118 recycling papers highlighted a substantial lack of causal evidence and weak construct validity of measured ‘behaviour’. These quality issues undermine the ability of individual studies and the body of literature as a whole to firstly, draw strong conclusions about what factors have causal influence on real-world recycling behaviour in broad populations of interest, and secondly, therefore, to guide interventions to improve recycling outcomes. To improve future research, this review identifies instances of better practice to increase the quality of evidence and the field’s confidence in what influences household recycling, and potentially, other pro-environmental behaviour.
- 14 April 2026
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessSystematic, quality appraisal of household recycling influences research finds evidence is mostly insufficient
Research on recycling behaviour and its influences can play a key role in supporting public policy efforts to mitigate the negative effects of waste generation and landfilling. However, recent reviews have raised concerns about the quality of research on recycling behaviour. Despite this, no previous reviews have conducted quality appraisals to judge the extent and impact of quality issues. This is partly due to the difficulty of applying validated quality appraisal tools developed for intervention reviews in the health and medicine fields to behaviour influence reviews in environment and sustainability fields. This update of a previous systematic review aims to fill this gap by developing and piloting a novel quality appraisal framework, specifically tailored to the needs of interdisciplinary reviews of the influences on recycling and other pre-environmental behaviours. Application of the novel framework to a set of 118 recycling papers highlighted a substantial lack of causal evidence and weak construct validity of measured ‘behaviour’. These quality issues undermine the ability of individual studies and the body of literature as a whole to firstly, draw strong conclusions about what factors have causal influence on real-world recycling behaviour in broad populations of interest, and secondly, therefore, to guide interventions to improve recycling outcomes. To improve future research, this review identifies instances of better practice to increase the quality of evidence and the field’s confidence in what influences household recycling, and potentially, other pro-environmental behaviour.
- Open Access
- 23 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Waste Management
- Vol. 194, 318-341
Quality appraisal of household recycling influences research found evidence was mostly insufficient for drawing conclusions
- 23 January 2025
- Published by Elsevier in Waste Management
- Vol. 194, 318-341
Open AccessQuality appraisal of household recycling influences research found evidence was mostly insufficient for drawing conclusions
- Open Access
- 21 February 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Cleaner and Responsible Consumption
- Vol. 12
Consuming responsibly: Prioritising responsible consumption behaviours in Australia
- 21 February 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Cleaner and Responsible Consumption
- Vol. 12
Open AccessConsuming responsibly: Prioritising responsible consumption behaviours in Australia
- 30 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 179-204
Blending Design and Behavioural Science in Three Linked Public Policy Experiments Towards a Circular Economy
- 30 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 179-204
Blending Design and Behavioural Science in Three Linked Public Policy Experiments Towards a Circular Economy
- Open Access
- 15 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Circular Economy and Sustainability
- Vol. 4 (1) , 387-412
How Do We Change What We Cannot Describe? A Comprehensive Framework of User Behaviours in a Materials’ Circular Economy
A circular economy is critical to addressing current unsustainable resource extraction, consumption and waste. Research has hitherto focused predominantly on the supply-side, particularly design, production and circular business models. However, the demand-side is essential in realising benefits from upstream activities. While circular consumption research is emerging, a clear and comprehensive picture of user behaviours required in a circular economy is still lacking. To address this, the research adopted a transdisciplinary integration approach, engaging over 100 Australian circular economy stakeholders from the public, private, research and civil sectors. The output of the research integration was a comprehensive Framework of User Circular Behaviours, containing 59 distinct user behaviours, clearly labelled, categorised and defined. The Framework organises user behaviours according to three phases of product interaction (get, use, pass on), and more specifically by their function in a circular economy. A preliminary model of the inter-relationships between these user behaviours and up- and downstream circular activities was also produced. The Framework contributes to existing circular consumer literature in three ways: it provides both greater breadth and depth of behaviours than existing models; it clarifies when performance of the behaviours can be considered circular; and includes precise definitions to provide clarity and enable consistency in terminology. The Framework has many benefits. It can enable translation between different stakeholders, connect research on production/business models with research on consumers/users and be utilised to organise and accumulate evidence of barriers and enablers of these behaviours and the interventions that work to change them.
- 15 July 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Circular Economy and Sustainability
- Vol. 4 (1) , 387-412
Open AccessHow Do We Change What We Cannot Describe? A Comprehensive Framework of User Behaviours in a Materials’ Circular Economy
A circular economy is critical to addressing current unsustainable resource extraction, consumption and waste. Research has hitherto focused predominantly on the supply-side, particularly design, production and circular business models. However, the demand-side is essential in realising benefits from upstream activities. While circular consumption research is emerging, a clear and comprehensive picture of user behaviours required in a circular economy is still lacking. To address this, the research adopted a transdisciplinary integration approach, engaging over 100 Australian circular economy stakeholders from the public, private, research and civil sectors. The output of the research integration was a comprehensive Framework of User Circular Behaviours, containing 59 distinct user behaviours, clearly labelled, categorised and defined. The Framework organises user behaviours according to three phases of product interaction (get, use, pass on), and more specifically by their function in a circular economy. A preliminary model of the inter-relationships between these user behaviours and up- and downstream circular activities was also produced. The Framework contributes to existing circular consumer literature in three ways: it provides both greater breadth and depth of behaviours than existing models; it clarifies when performance of the behaviours can be considered circular; and includes precise definitions to provide clarity and enable consistency in terminology. The Framework has many benefits. It can enable translation between different stakeholders, connect research on production/business models with research on consumers/users and be utilised to organise and accumulate evidence of barriers and enablers of these behaviours and the interventions that work to change them.
- Open Access
- 28 April 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Resources, Conservation & Recycling Advances
- Vol. 18
Interdisciplinary, systematic review found influences on household recycling behaviour are many and multifaceted, requiring a multi-level approach
- 28 April 2023
- Published by Elsevier in Resources, Conservation & Recycling Advances
- Vol. 18
Open AccessInterdisciplinary, systematic review found influences on household recycling behaviour are many and multifaceted, requiring a multi-level approach
- Open Access
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
How do we change what we can’t describe? A comprehensive Framework of User Behaviours in a materials circular economy.
Transitioning to a circular economy is critical in reducing current unsustainable levels of resource extraction, consumption and throughput to waste generation. The circular economy literature to date has predominantly focused on the supply-side, particularly the design, production and supply of products and materials through circular business models. However, the ‘use’ stage of the value chain is critical in realising the benefits of upstream activities. While research on the role of circular consumption is beginning to emerge, there does not yet exist a clear and comprehensive picture of the set of behaviours that are required or desired of users in a circular economy. The lack of such a framework is an important gap to fill. To address this, the research adopted a collaborative, transdisciplinary approach engaging with a wide range of Australian circular economy stakeholders from across the public, private, research and civil society sectors. A comprehensive Framework of User Circular Behaviours was co-produced, contained 59 distinct user behaviours, clearly labelled and defined. Behaviours are organised according to their phase in user interaction with a product, and by their function in a circular economy. A comparison with existing models of user-consumer behaviour reveals both the greater breadth and depth of the Framework. In addition, a preliminary model of the inter-relationships between these User behaviours, and up- and downstream circular activities is provided. The benefits of new Framework are many. It can provide clarity to future discussions of User behaviours, be utilised to organise and accumulate evidence of barriers and enablers of these behaviours, and the interventions that work to change them, and be a foundation for connecting research on production/business models with researcher on consumers/users.
- 15 December 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessHow do we change what we can’t describe? A comprehensive Framework of User Behaviours in a materials circular economy.
Transitioning to a circular economy is critical in reducing current unsustainable levels of resource extraction, consumption and throughput to waste generation. The circular economy literature to date has predominantly focused on the supply-side, particularly the design, production and supply of products and materials through circular business models. However, the ‘use’ stage of the value chain is critical in realising the benefits of upstream activities. While research on the role of circular consumption is beginning to emerge, there does not yet exist a clear and comprehensive picture of the set of behaviours that are required or desired of users in a circular economy. The lack of such a framework is an important gap to fill. To address this, the research adopted a collaborative, transdisciplinary approach engaging with a wide range of Australian circular economy stakeholders from across the public, private, research and civil society sectors. A comprehensive Framework of User Circular Behaviours was co-produced, contained 59 distinct user behaviours, clearly labelled and defined. Behaviours are organised according to their phase in user interaction with a product, and by their function in a circular economy. A comparison with existing models of user-consumer behaviour reveals both the greater breadth and depth of the Framework. In addition, a preliminary model of the inter-relationships between these User behaviours, and up- and downstream circular activities is provided. The benefits of new Framework are many. It can provide clarity to future discussions of User behaviours, be utilised to organise and accumulate evidence of barriers and enablers of these behaviours, and the interventions that work to change them, and be a foundation for connecting research on production/business models with researcher on consumers/users.
- Open Access
- 18 July 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Interdisciplinary, systematic review found influences on household recycling behaviour are many and multifaceted, requiring a multi-level approach.
Recycling is a common policy response to problems of waste, particularly in developed countries. Understanding what influences whether and how well people recycle is important for optimising recycling outcomes. Behaviour is complex, and understanding it fully requires drawing on insights from many disciplines. However past reviews of recycling behaviour research have revealed that the field is currently fragmented into single discipline endeavours, and highly concentrated around psychological approaches. The objective of this paper was to conduct a systematic review of current published knowledge from a wide range of disciplines on what influences households recycling behaviour. The resulting factors were systematically synthesised to produce a comprehensive multi-level hierarchy of potentially influencing factors. The process also revealed potential directions for future research to improve the field’s understanding of the influences on recycling behaviour, and the ability to develop more effective interventions that address waste and recycling issues.
- 18 July 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessInterdisciplinary, systematic review found influences on household recycling behaviour are many and multifaceted, requiring a multi-level approach.
Recycling is a common policy response to problems of waste, particularly in developed countries. Understanding what influences whether and how well people recycle is important for optimising recycling outcomes. Behaviour is complex, and understanding it fully requires drawing on insights from many disciplines. However past reviews of recycling behaviour research have revealed that the field is currently fragmented into single discipline endeavours, and highly concentrated around psychological approaches. The objective of this paper was to conduct a systematic review of current published knowledge from a wide range of disciplines on what influences households recycling behaviour. The resulting factors were systematically synthesised to produce a comprehensive multi-level hierarchy of potentially influencing factors. The process also revealed potential directions for future research to improve the field’s understanding of the influences on recycling behaviour, and the ability to develop more effective interventions that address waste and recycling issues.
- Open Access
- 15 February 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
What does it mean for an evaluation to be ‘valid’? A critical synthesis of evaluation literature.
Validity is both a critical foundation for, and widely contested concept in the field of program evaluation. Given the wide and divergent treatment of the term, this article sought to enhance the field’s understanding and application of validity by systematically identifying, collating and integrating existing conceptions of validity. A critical interpretive synthesis approach was taken to combine the best elements of systematic literature searching with integrative review. We found that conceptions of validity could be roughly collated into three categories pertaining to the evaluation research, evaluative judgement and reporting, and beyond the evaluation proper. The result was a wide-ranging map of validity concepts against the various stages of the evaluation process. This made clear several gaps in the validity thinking, resulting in the development of comprehensive but not yet complete framework that weaves together related aspects identified into a cohesive whole. It is our hope that this initial iteration of a cohesive validity framework will be the starting point for a cooperative effort to improve professional evaluation practice.
- 15 February 2022
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessWhat does it mean for an evaluation to be ‘valid’? A critical synthesis of evaluation literature.
Validity is both a critical foundation for, and widely contested concept in the field of program evaluation. Given the wide and divergent treatment of the term, this article sought to enhance the field’s understanding and application of validity by systematically identifying, collating and integrating existing conceptions of validity. A critical interpretive synthesis approach was taken to combine the best elements of systematic literature searching with integrative review. We found that conceptions of validity could be roughly collated into three categories pertaining to the evaluation research, evaluative judgement and reporting, and beyond the evaluation proper. The result was a wide-ranging map of validity concepts against the various stages of the evaluation process. This made clear several gaps in the validity thinking, resulting in the development of comprehensive but not yet complete framework that weaves together related aspects identified into a cohesive whole. It is our hope that this initial iteration of a cohesive validity framework will be the starting point for a cooperative effort to improve professional evaluation practice.