Wolfgang Suttrop
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Wolfgang Suttrop has a total of 435 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Matthias Willensdorfer
Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik
10 shared publications - Hartmut Zohm
Max-Planck-Institut für Plasmaphysik
8 shared publications - Mike Dunne
Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics
8 shared publications - Andrew Kirk
UKAEA (United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority)
7 shared publications - Rachael M. McDermott
Max Planck Institute for Plasma Physics, 85748 Garching, Germany
7 shared publications - Carlos Paz-Soldan
Columbia University in the City of New York
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 August 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 68 (8) , 085044
Uncertainties of magnetic equilibrium reconstructions
Uncertainties of quantities of magnetic equilibrium reconstructions are essential for the validation and quantification of estimated plasma parameters and their uncertainties. The uncertainties of a few equilibrium quantities can be evaluated analytically. A Monte-Carlo method is proposed to estimate the uncertainty of any equilibrium quantity. The Monte-Carlo method was verified using analytic formulas for the uncertainty of some equilibrium quantities and applied to various scalar, profile, flux-surface averaged and integral plasma quantities. Additionally, the uncertainty of the category of negative triangularity plasmas and alternative divertor configuration plasmas were evaluated.
- 1 August 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 68 (8) , 085044
Open AccessUncertainties of magnetic equilibrium reconstructions
Uncertainties of quantities of magnetic equilibrium reconstructions are essential for the validation and quantification of estimated plasma parameters and their uncertainties. The uncertainties of a few equilibrium quantities can be evaluated analytically. A Monte-Carlo method is proposed to estimate the uncertainty of any equilibrium quantity. The Monte-Carlo method was verified using analytic formulas for the uncertainty of some equilibrium quantities and applied to various scalar, profile, flux-surface averaged and integral plasma quantities. Additionally, the uncertainty of the category of negative triangularity plasmas and alternative divertor configuration plasmas were evaluated.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 68 (8) , 085033
Challenges of locked mode avoidance in the low-ν* ITER baseline scenario plasmas in ASDEX upgrade
In AUG, the requirement to explore the low-ν* regime within the same ITER baseline scenario parameters, i.e. a Greenwald fraction of ∼0.85, q 95 ≈ 3, β N ≈ 1.8, and H 98 ≈ 1, has been addressed by inducing density pump-out through n = 2 magnetic field perturbations. This approach required additionally relaxing the high- δ plasma shape to δ ≈ 0.1 to enable sufficiently strong density pump-out. However, at low density also the generation of locked modes was observed which deteriorates the plasma performance. Several strategies were therefore tested, including model-based error field correction combined with different heating schemes, as well as a core–edge decoupling metric derived from the general perturbed equilibrium code. Nevertheless, these attempts were unsuccessful, largely because the gap between the onset of density pump-out and the excitation of the core mode is very small.
- 1 August 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 68 (8) , 085033
Open AccessChallenges of locked mode avoidance in the low-ν* ITER baseline scenario plasmas in ASDEX upgrade
In AUG, the requirement to explore the low-ν* regime within the same ITER baseline scenario parameters, i.e. a Greenwald fraction of ∼0.85, q 95 ≈ 3, β N ≈ 1.8, and H 98 ≈ 1, has been addressed by inducing density pump-out through n = 2 magnetic field perturbations. This approach required additionally relaxing the high- δ plasma shape to δ ≈ 0.1 to enable sufficiently strong density pump-out. However, at low density also the generation of locked modes was observed which deteriorates the plasma performance. Several strategies were therefore tested, including model-based error field correction combined with different heating schemes, as well as a core–edge decoupling metric derived from the general perturbed equilibrium code. Nevertheless, these attempts were unsuccessful, largely because the gap between the onset of density pump-out and the excitation of the core mode is very small.
- Open Access
- 4 May 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 68 (5)
Hybrid kinetic-MHD model of RMP interaction with tokamak plasmas
We present a hybrid kinetic–MHD approach realized within the code MEPHIT for the linear modelling of the interaction of resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) with tokamak plasmas. The model uses an iterative approach where the solution of Ampère’s law in realistic device geometry is combined with the computation of plasma response currents to a given magnetic perturbation. The latter computation employs the ideal MHD model in most of the plasma volume, and a 1D collisional kinetic model in the resonant layers centered around rational flux surfaces. Within a 1D kinetic model, a straight inhomogeneous plasma cylinder geometry is assumed, and the finite Larmor radius expansion of plasma response current and charge densities up to second order is employed. The hybrid kinetic–MHD model is applied to RMPs in ASDEX Upgrade experiments on edge-localized mode suppression and compared to the results of the code GPEC used in the ideal MHD limit. In particular, the new hybrid model allows to estimate the size of an RMP-induced magnetic island well in the case that the electron shielding current is nearly eliminated by quasilinear effects due to the electron fluid resonance. Moreover, the hybrid approach developed here easily permits further incorporation of more detailed and accurate kinetic models of the resonant layer.
- 4 May 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 68 (5)
Open AccessHybrid kinetic-MHD model of RMP interaction with tokamak plasmas
We present a hybrid kinetic–MHD approach realized within the code MEPHIT for the linear modelling of the interaction of resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) with tokamak plasmas. The model uses an iterative approach where the solution of Ampère’s law in realistic device geometry is combined with the computation of plasma response currents to a given magnetic perturbation. The latter computation employs the ideal MHD model in most of the plasma volume, and a 1D collisional kinetic model in the resonant layers centered around rational flux surfaces. Within a 1D kinetic model, a straight inhomogeneous plasma cylinder geometry is assumed, and the finite Larmor radius expansion of plasma response current and charge densities up to second order is employed. The hybrid kinetic–MHD model is applied to RMPs in ASDEX Upgrade experiments on edge-localized mode suppression and compared to the results of the code GPEC used in the ideal MHD limit. In particular, the new hybrid model allows to estimate the size of an RMP-induced magnetic island well in the case that the electron shielding current is nearly eliminated by quasilinear effects due to the electron fluid resonance. Moreover, the hybrid approach developed here easily permits further incorporation of more detailed and accurate kinetic models of the resonant layer.
- Open Access
- 12 August 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 65 (9) , 093002
Introduction and overview: Chapter 1 of the special issue: on the path to tokamak burning plasma operation
The International Tokamak Physics Activity (ITPA) has developed a comprehensive overview of the results of its coordinated R&D activities in fusion physics and diagnostics implemented during the past two decades with the aim of developing an improved physics basis for the operation of tokamak burning plasma experiments. Here, an introduction is presented to key concepts in the physics of burning plasmas in tokamaks, together with an overview of the scope of the principal areas of physics R&D pursued by the ITPA Topical Physics Groups in which the critical issues, major areas of progress and most significant recent results are highlighted. This paper introduces the following collection of articles, which encompass detailed presentations of the progress achieved by the Topical Groups in preparing the physics basis for the operation of tokamak burning plasma experiments expected to come into operation in the 2030s.
- 12 August 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 65 (9) , 093002
Open AccessIntroduction and overview: Chapter 1 of the special issue: on the path to tokamak burning plasma operation
The International Tokamak Physics Activity (ITPA) has developed a comprehensive overview of the results of its coordinated R&D activities in fusion physics and diagnostics implemented during the past two decades with the aim of developing an improved physics basis for the operation of tokamak burning plasma experiments. Here, an introduction is presented to key concepts in the physics of burning plasmas in tokamaks, together with an overview of the scope of the principal areas of physics R&D pursued by the ITPA Topical Physics Groups in which the critical issues, major areas of progress and most significant recent results are highlighted. This paper introduces the following collection of articles, which encompass detailed presentations of the progress achieved by the Topical Groups in preparing the physics basis for the operation of tokamak burning plasma experiments expected to come into operation in the 2030s.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 29 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 65 (5) , 053001
Progress in pedestal and edge physics: Chapter 3 of the special issue: on the path to tokamak burning plasma operation
This paper describes the extensive progress that has been made in the understanding of tokamak pedestal physics since the 2007 publication of ‘Progress in the ITER Physics Basis’ (Ikeda 2007 Nucl. Fusion 47 E01–S500). It serves as Chapter 3 of the 2025 Nuclear Fusion Special Issue titled ‘On the Path to Tokamak Burning Plasma Operation’ (Campbell et al 2025 Nucl. Fusion). This review was compiled by the pedestal and edge physics (PEP) community affiliated with the International Tokamak Physics Activity organization. It attempts to collect in one place citations to the majority of published literature on the pedestal physics topics that will be most important for the operation of a future power producing burning plasma tokamak. These include citations to publications describing the physics of the pedestal plasmas in many operating tokamaks worldwide and the pedestal physics projections for several near-term future devices including ITER. Descriptions of experimental results, interpretive modeling and predictive extrapolations are integrated together and comprehensive references are provided. This review is organized around four primary technical sections, viz.: pedestal structure, edge localized mode (ELM) characteristics, ELM control and regimes without large ELMs. Key results from many of the references are described briefly and set into the tokamak burning plasma power plant context. In addition, different perspectives on pedestal physics topics that are currently under debate within the community are also described, to provide guidance on needs for future research. Finally, attempts are made to describe conclusions from all of this progress consistent with discussions by the pedestal physics community at this time. The goal of this review is to provide a useful reference document for pedestal physics researchers going forward toward operation of a burning tokamak fusion plasma.
- 29 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 65 (5) , 053001
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessProgress in pedestal and edge physics: Chapter 3 of the special issue: on the path to tokamak burning plasma operation
This paper describes the extensive progress that has been made in the understanding of tokamak pedestal physics since the 2007 publication of ‘Progress in the ITER Physics Basis’ (Ikeda 2007 Nucl. Fusion 47 E01–S500). It serves as Chapter 3 of the 2025 Nuclear Fusion Special Issue titled ‘On the Path to Tokamak Burning Plasma Operation’ (Campbell et al 2025 Nucl. Fusion). This review was compiled by the pedestal and edge physics (PEP) community affiliated with the International Tokamak Physics Activity organization. It attempts to collect in one place citations to the majority of published literature on the pedestal physics topics that will be most important for the operation of a future power producing burning plasma tokamak. These include citations to publications describing the physics of the pedestal plasmas in many operating tokamaks worldwide and the pedestal physics projections for several near-term future devices including ITER. Descriptions of experimental results, interpretive modeling and predictive extrapolations are integrated together and comprehensive references are provided. This review is organized around four primary technical sections, viz.: pedestal structure, edge localized mode (ELM) characteristics, ELM control and regimes without large ELMs. Key results from many of the references are described briefly and set into the tokamak burning plasma power plant context. In addition, different perspectives on pedestal physics topics that are currently under debate within the community are also described, to provide guidance on needs for future research. Finally, attempts are made to describe conclusions from all of this progress consistent with discussions by the pedestal physics community at this time. The goal of this review is to provide a useful reference document for pedestal physics researchers going forward toward operation of a burning tokamak fusion plasma.
- Open Access
- 16 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 67 (5) , 055009
A 3D finite element model simulating tearing modes and their measurements in ASDEX Upgrade
Tearing modes (TM) are a significant challenge for the operation of large tokamak devices as they cause confinement degradation, can lead to a disruption and are part of the disruption process itself. Detecting and characterising tearing modes is basis for both, improved understanding of their evolution as well as adequate countermeasures. The most harmful tearing mode has the toroidal mode number n = 1, which, due to toroidal coupling, usually consists of different helicities, referred to as poloidal harmonics. Determining the poloidal harmonics requires modelling the magnetic measurements with different challenges for rotating and locked modes. Rotating modes produce frequency-dependent shielding currents in conducting structures that modify the perturbation field. Locked modes require pick-up coils measuring mainly the radial perturbation field component B r , of which there are far fewer than Mirnov coils in ASDEX Upgrade. The agreement between B r coils and Mirnov coils in a model description can be validated in the low frequency range, where all coils observe the modes and shielding currents are important. We employ a three-dimensional finite element method model to calculate the expected magnetic measurements of the perturbation field produced by an n = 1 tearing mode with a single helicity and frequency. The TMs are represented by helical perturbation currents at the corresponding resonant surfaces while the rest of the plasma is treated as vacuum. We show that, besides the vacuum vessel and the passive stabilisation loop, it is crucial to include other in-vessel components of ASDEX Upgrade. The poloidal composition of an n = 1 TM is determined by the linear superposition of modelled TMs with single helicities that best matches the measurements by a poloidal array of Mirnov coils. The resulting amplitudes and phases of the poloidal harmonics give simulated measurements that are found to be in agreement with their measured values for all coil types.
- 16 April 2025
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 67 (5) , 055009
Open AccessA 3D finite element model simulating tearing modes and their measurements in ASDEX Upgrade
Tearing modes (TM) are a significant challenge for the operation of large tokamak devices as they cause confinement degradation, can lead to a disruption and are part of the disruption process itself. Detecting and characterising tearing modes is basis for both, improved understanding of their evolution as well as adequate countermeasures. The most harmful tearing mode has the toroidal mode number n = 1, which, due to toroidal coupling, usually consists of different helicities, referred to as poloidal harmonics. Determining the poloidal harmonics requires modelling the magnetic measurements with different challenges for rotating and locked modes. Rotating modes produce frequency-dependent shielding currents in conducting structures that modify the perturbation field. Locked modes require pick-up coils measuring mainly the radial perturbation field component B r , of which there are far fewer than Mirnov coils in ASDEX Upgrade. The agreement between B r coils and Mirnov coils in a model description can be validated in the low frequency range, where all coils observe the modes and shielding currents are important. We employ a three-dimensional finite element method model to calculate the expected magnetic measurements of the perturbation field produced by an n = 1 tearing mode with a single helicity and frequency. The TMs are represented by helical perturbation currents at the corresponding resonant surfaces while the rest of the plasma is treated as vacuum. We show that, besides the vacuum vessel and the passive stabilisation loop, it is crucial to include other in-vessel components of ASDEX Upgrade. The poloidal composition of an n = 1 TM is determined by the linear superposition of modelled TMs with single helicities that best matches the measurements by a poloidal array of Mirnov coils. The resulting amplitudes and phases of the poloidal harmonics give simulated measurements that are found to be in agreement with their measured values for all coil types.
- Open Access
- 28 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Physics
- Vol. 20 (12) , 1980-1988
Observation of magnetic islands in tokamak plasmas during the suppression of edge-localized modes
In tokamaks, a leading platform for fusion energy, periodic filamentary plasma eruptions known as edge-localized modes occur in plasmas with high-energy confinement and steep pressure profiles at the plasma edge. These edge-localized modes could damage the tokamak wall but can be suppressed using small three-dimensional magnetic perturbations. Here we demonstrate that these magnetic perturbations can change the magnetic topology just inside the steep gradient region of the plasma edge. We identify signatures of a magnetic island, and their observation is linked to the suppression of edge-localized modes. We compare high-resolution measurements of perturbed magnetic surfaces with predictions from ideal magnetohydrodynamic theory where the magnetic topology is preserved. Although ideal magnetohydrodynamics adequately describes the measurements in plasmas exhibiting edge-localized modes, it proves insufficient for plasmas where these modes are suppressed. Nonlinear resistive magnetohydrodynamic modelling supports this observation. Our study experimentally confirms the predicted role of magnetic islands in inhibiting the occurrence of edge-localized modes. This will be beneficial for physics-based predictions in future fusion devices to control these modes.
- 28 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Nature Physics
- Vol. 20 (12) , 1980-1988
Open AccessObservation of magnetic islands in tokamak plasmas during the suppression of edge-localized modes
In tokamaks, a leading platform for fusion energy, periodic filamentary plasma eruptions known as edge-localized modes occur in plasmas with high-energy confinement and steep pressure profiles at the plasma edge. These edge-localized modes could damage the tokamak wall but can be suppressed using small three-dimensional magnetic perturbations. Here we demonstrate that these magnetic perturbations can change the magnetic topology just inside the steep gradient region of the plasma edge. We identify signatures of a magnetic island, and their observation is linked to the suppression of edge-localized modes. We compare high-resolution measurements of perturbed magnetic surfaces with predictions from ideal magnetohydrodynamic theory where the magnetic topology is preserved. Although ideal magnetohydrodynamics adequately describes the measurements in plasmas exhibiting edge-localized modes, it proves insufficient for plasmas where these modes are suppressed. Nonlinear resistive magnetohydrodynamic modelling supports this observation. Our study experimentally confirms the predicted role of magnetic islands in inhibiting the occurrence of edge-localized modes. This will be beneficial for physics-based predictions in future fusion devices to control these modes.
- Open Access
- 21 August 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 66 (10) , 105003
First observation of RMP ELM mitigation on MAST Upgrade
The first experimental attempts at controlling edge localised modes (ELMs) via the application of resonant magnetic perturbations on the MAST Upgrade tokamak are reported. Using the linear MHD model MARS-F, the phase shift between the upper and lower coil rows ΔΦ was optimised for toroidal mode number n = 1 and n = 2 fields, to provide forward guidance to experiments. In low β N discharges, the application of n = 1 3D fields caused the ELM frequency f E L M to increase by over a factor 20 relative to the reference, and also induced a locked mode, which did not cause a plasma termination nor an H-L back transition. However when β N was raised, this induced locked mode caused plasma termination which precluded mitigation access. Initially, applying a numerically optimised n = 2 field had no effect. However applying a rigid toroidal shift to this field caused a locked mode disruption, demonstrating the presence of a substantial n = 2 error field. Coil current ramps were conducted with ΔΦ set at 6 different values, resulting in either locked mode disruptions or no effect, but mitigation with n = 2 fields was not established.
- 21 August 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Plasma Physics and Controlled Fusion
- Vol. 66 (10) , 105003
Open AccessFirst observation of RMP ELM mitigation on MAST Upgrade
The first experimental attempts at controlling edge localised modes (ELMs) via the application of resonant magnetic perturbations on the MAST Upgrade tokamak are reported. Using the linear MHD model MARS-F, the phase shift between the upper and lower coil rows ΔΦ was optimised for toroidal mode number n = 1 and n = 2 fields, to provide forward guidance to experiments. In low β N discharges, the application of n = 1 3D fields caused the ELM frequency f E L M to increase by over a factor 20 relative to the reference, and also induced a locked mode, which did not cause a plasma termination nor an H-L back transition. However when β N was raised, this induced locked mode caused plasma termination which precluded mitigation access. Initially, applying a numerically optimised n = 2 field had no effect. However applying a rigid toroidal shift to this field caused a locked mode disruption, demonstrating the presence of a substantial n = 2 error field. Coil current ramps were conducted with ΔΦ set at 6 different values, resulting in either locked mode disruptions or no effect, but mitigation with n = 2 fields was not established.
- Open Access
- 31 July 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 64 (9) , 096022
Helium plasma operations on ASDEX Upgrade and JET in support of the non-nuclear phases of ITER
For its initial operational phase, ITER has until recently considered using non-nuclear hydrogen (H) or helium (He) plasmas to keep nuclear activation at low levels. To this end, the Tokamak Exploitation Task Force of the EUROfusion Consortium carried out dedicated experimental campaigns in He on the ASDEX Upgrade (AUG) and JET tokamaks in 2022, with particular emphasis put on the ELMy H-mode operation and plasma-wall interaction processes as well as comparison to H or deuterium (D) plasmas. Both in pure He and mixed He + H plasmas, H-mode operation could be reached but more effort was needed to obtain a stable plasma scenario than in H or D. Even if the power threshold for the LH transition was lower in He, entering the type-I ELMy regime appeared to require equally much or even more heating power than in H. Suppression of ELMs by resonant magnetic perturbations was studied on AUG but was only possible in plasmas with a He content below 19%; the reason for this unexpected behaviour remains still unclear and various theoretical approaches are being pursued to properly understand the physics behind ELM suppression. The erosion rates of tungsten (W) plasma-facing components were an order of magnitude larger than what has been reported in hydrogenic plasmas, which can be attributed to the prominent role of He2+ions in the plasma. For the first time, the formation of nanoscale structures (W fuzz) was unambiguously demonstrated in H-mode He plasmas on AUG. However, no direct evidence of fuzz creation on JET was obtained despite the main conditions for its occurrence being met. The reason could be a delicate balance between W erosion by ELMs, competition between the growth and annealing of the fuzz, and coverage of the surface with co-deposits.
- 31 July 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 64 (9) , 096022
Open AccessHelium plasma operations on ASDEX Upgrade and JET in support of the non-nuclear phases of ITER
For its initial operational phase, ITER has until recently considered using non-nuclear hydrogen (H) or helium (He) plasmas to keep nuclear activation at low levels. To this end, the Tokamak Exploitation Task Force of the EUROfusion Consortium carried out dedicated experimental campaigns in He on the ASDEX Upgrade (AUG) and JET tokamaks in 2022, with particular emphasis put on the ELMy H-mode operation and plasma-wall interaction processes as well as comparison to H or deuterium (D) plasmas. Both in pure He and mixed He + H plasmas, H-mode operation could be reached but more effort was needed to obtain a stable plasma scenario than in H or D. Even if the power threshold for the LH transition was lower in He, entering the type-I ELMy regime appeared to require equally much or even more heating power than in H. Suppression of ELMs by resonant magnetic perturbations was studied on AUG but was only possible in plasmas with a He content below 19%; the reason for this unexpected behaviour remains still unclear and various theoretical approaches are being pursued to properly understand the physics behind ELM suppression. The erosion rates of tungsten (W) plasma-facing components were an order of magnitude larger than what has been reported in hydrogenic plasmas, which can be attributed to the prominent role of He2+ions in the plasma. For the first time, the formation of nanoscale structures (W fuzz) was unambiguously demonstrated in H-mode He plasmas on AUG. However, no direct evidence of fuzz creation on JET was obtained despite the main conditions for its occurrence being met. The reason could be a delicate balance between W erosion by ELMs, competition between the growth and annealing of the fuzz, and coverage of the surface with co-deposits.
- Open Access
- 23 July 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 64 (9) , 096004
Plasma performance and operational space with an RMP-ELM suppressed edge
The operational space and global performance of plasmas with edge-localized modes (ELMs) suppressed by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are surveyed by comparing AUG, DIII-D, EAST, and KSTAR stationary operating points. RMP-ELM suppression is achieved over a range of plasma currents, toroidal fields, and RMP toroidal mode numbers. Consistent operational windows in edge safety factor are found across devices, while windows in plasma shaping parameters are distinct. Accessed pedestal parameters reveal a quantitatively similar pedestal-top density limit for RMP-ELM suppression in all devices of just over 3 × 10 19 m−3. This is surprising given the wide variance of many engineering parameters and edge collisionalities, and poses a challenge to extrapolation of the regime. Wide ranges in input power, confinement time, and stored energy are observed, with the achieved triple product found to scale like the product of current, field, and radius. Observed energy confinement scaling with engineering parameters for RMP-ELM suppressed plasmas are presented and compared with expectations from established H and L-mode scalings, including treatment of uncertainty analysis. Different scaling exponents for individual engineering parameters are found as compared to the established scalings. However, extrapolation to next-step tokamaks ITER and SPARC find overall consistency within uncertainties with the established scalings, finding no obvious performance penalty when extrapolating from the assembled multi-device RMP-ELM suppressed database. Overall this work identifies common physics for RMP-ELM suppression and highlights the need to pursue this no-ELM regime at higher magnetic field and different plasma physical size.
- 23 July 2024
- Published by IOP Publishing in Nuclear Fusion
- Vol. 64 (9) , 096004
Open AccessPlasma performance and operational space with an RMP-ELM suppressed edge
The operational space and global performance of plasmas with edge-localized modes (ELMs) suppressed by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are surveyed by comparing AUG, DIII-D, EAST, and KSTAR stationary operating points. RMP-ELM suppression is achieved over a range of plasma currents, toroidal fields, and RMP toroidal mode numbers. Consistent operational windows in edge safety factor are found across devices, while windows in plasma shaping parameters are distinct. Accessed pedestal parameters reveal a quantitatively similar pedestal-top density limit for RMP-ELM suppression in all devices of just over 3 × 10 19 m−3. This is surprising given the wide variance of many engineering parameters and edge collisionalities, and poses a challenge to extrapolation of the regime. Wide ranges in input power, confinement time, and stored energy are observed, with the achieved triple product found to scale like the product of current, field, and radius. Observed energy confinement scaling with engineering parameters for RMP-ELM suppressed plasmas are presented and compared with expectations from established H and L-mode scalings, including treatment of uncertainty analysis. Different scaling exponents for individual engineering parameters are found as compared to the established scalings. However, extrapolation to next-step tokamaks ITER and SPARC find overall consistency within uncertainties with the established scalings, finding no obvious performance penalty when extrapolating from the assembled multi-device RMP-ELM suppressed database. Overall this work identifies common physics for RMP-ELM suppression and highlights the need to pursue this no-ELM regime at higher magnetic field and different plasma physical size.