Zengting Liu
Research Subjects
Zengting Liu has a total of 61 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Johannes Heise
Vereinigte Informationssysteme Tierhaltung w.V. (vit), 27283 Verden, Germany
8 shared publications - Jens Tetens
Department of Animal Sciences, Georg-August-University, Burckhardtweg 2, 37077, Göttingen, Germany
7 shared publications - Jörn Bennewitz
Institute of Animal Science, University of Hohenheim, Stuttgart, Germany
6 shared publications - Ana-Marija Križanac
Department of Animal Sciences, University of Göttingen, 37077 Göttingen, Germany; Center for Integrated Breeding Research, Department of Animal Sciences, University of Göttingen, 37075 Göttingen, Germany
5 shared publications - Clemens Falker-Gieske
Department of Animal Sciences, Georg-August-University, Burckhardtweg 2, 37077, Göttingen, Germany
5 shared publications F. Reinhardt
VIT w.V., Heinrich-Schröder-Weg 1, D-27283 Verden, Germany
5 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 109 (4) , 4236-4247
Derivation of a breeding value for persistency in German dairy cattle focusing on performance in extended lactations
Persistency in production traits provides an opportunity to extend the lactation period. Enhanced lactation periods significantly over 305 d have potential benefits for fertility, animal health, farm management, and economic outcomes. However, the random regression test-day model, which is currently used in Germany, only covers d 5 to 305 of lactation. This study focuses on increasing the genetic capacity for persistency in Holstein breeding animals for use in extended lactations. The solutions of the second-order Legendre polynomial for the animal effect were obtained using the standard EBV routine in Germany. The breeding value estimation involved 19 million phenotypic lactation records resulting in EBVs for 17 million females and 200,000 males. In a next step, these regression coefficients were used to define genetic slopes for various lactation intervals between d 9 and 245 and 305 after calving (bg;x,305). The resulting dataset was combined with 955,345 Holstein cows with lactations extending to at least 400 DIM and having a calving interval of at least 550 d. For these cows, phenotypic slopes for each production trait and lactation between d 150 and 400 (bp;150,400) were estimated. The combined dataset was subdivided into quartiles based on the genetic slopes (bg;x,305) Finally, the DIM interval that best discriminated the phenotypic slopes (bp;150,400) of cows according to top and bottom quartiles was used to determine the most appropriate breeding value for persistency. The interval between 150 and 305 DIM proved to be the most informative for predicting bp;150,400 across all production traits. The final persistency index, called EBV persistency, combines the genetic slopes of protein and fat yield (kg) over the first 3 lactations with equal weighting, and it merges protein and fat persistency into a single index with a 2:1 weighting, reflecting the economic priorities of German breeding organizations. This EBV was officially introduced to the German Holstein breed in April 2023. The genetic basis of the EBV persistency, analyzed using the index theory, shows an estimated cumulative heritability of 0.34. Genomic EBV persistency shows negligible Pearson correlations with most traits in the total merit index. Only slight positive correlations are observed for the milk production index (0.24) and the longevity index (0.18). The new defined trait describes the genetic ability of animals for persistency in production traits, also in extended lactations.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 109 (4) , 4236-4247
Open AccessDerivation of a breeding value for persistency in German dairy cattle focusing on performance in extended lactations
Persistency in production traits provides an opportunity to extend the lactation period. Enhanced lactation periods significantly over 305 d have potential benefits for fertility, animal health, farm management, and economic outcomes. However, the random regression test-day model, which is currently used in Germany, only covers d 5 to 305 of lactation. This study focuses on increasing the genetic capacity for persistency in Holstein breeding animals for use in extended lactations. The solutions of the second-order Legendre polynomial for the animal effect were obtained using the standard EBV routine in Germany. The breeding value estimation involved 19 million phenotypic lactation records resulting in EBVs for 17 million females and 200,000 males. In a next step, these regression coefficients were used to define genetic slopes for various lactation intervals between d 9 and 245 and 305 after calving (bg;x,305). The resulting dataset was combined with 955,345 Holstein cows with lactations extending to at least 400 DIM and having a calving interval of at least 550 d. For these cows, phenotypic slopes for each production trait and lactation between d 150 and 400 (bp;150,400) were estimated. The combined dataset was subdivided into quartiles based on the genetic slopes (bg;x,305) Finally, the DIM interval that best discriminated the phenotypic slopes (bp;150,400) of cows according to top and bottom quartiles was used to determine the most appropriate breeding value for persistency. The interval between 150 and 305 DIM proved to be the most informative for predicting bp;150,400 across all production traits. The final persistency index, called EBV persistency, combines the genetic slopes of protein and fat yield (kg) over the first 3 lactations with equal weighting, and it merges protein and fat persistency into a single index with a 2:1 weighting, reflecting the economic priorities of German breeding organizations. This EBV was officially introduced to the German Holstein breed in April 2023. The genetic basis of the EBV persistency, analyzed using the index theory, shows an estimated cumulative heritability of 0.34. Genomic EBV persistency shows negligible Pearson correlations with most traits in the total merit index. Only slight positive correlations are observed for the milk production index (0.24) and the longevity index (0.18). The new defined trait describes the genetic ability of animals for persistency in production traits, also in extended lactations.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 109 (2) , 1680-1699
A large-scale multitrait meta-analysis of 11 health and 22 conformation traits in German Holstein cows
In dairy cattle farming, many traits are included in the breeding goal simultaneously to maximize economic value. The phenomenon of genetic correlations can both enhance and hinder the response to selection and has to be taken into account in multitrait selection schemes. To investigate the genetic architecture of traits included in the balanced breeding goal in Germany, multitrait meta-analyses of 11 health and 22 conformation traits in 100,809 to 180,217 German Holstein cows were conducted, followed by the estimation of global genetic correlations between each pair of traits. Multitrait meta-analyses identified a total of 58,454 genome-wide significant variants across 11 health and 22 conformation traits. The variants in high linkage disequilibrium were pruned and functionally annotated using external functional and evolutionary information, specifically Functional-And-Evolutionary Trait Heritability scores, thereby prioritizing the variants with the highest potential to affect the traits. Variants were found in both known and novel regions for the traits studied, leading to a list of novel, shared candidate markers that can be incorporated into multitrait genomic predictions to increase their reliability.
- 1 February 2026
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 109 (2) , 1680-1699
Open AccessA large-scale multitrait meta-analysis of 11 health and 22 conformation traits in German Holstein cows
In dairy cattle farming, many traits are included in the breeding goal simultaneously to maximize economic value. The phenomenon of genetic correlations can both enhance and hinder the response to selection and has to be taken into account in multitrait selection schemes. To investigate the genetic architecture of traits included in the balanced breeding goal in Germany, multitrait meta-analyses of 11 health and 22 conformation traits in 100,809 to 180,217 German Holstein cows were conducted, followed by the estimation of global genetic correlations between each pair of traits. Multitrait meta-analyses identified a total of 58,454 genome-wide significant variants across 11 health and 22 conformation traits. The variants in high linkage disequilibrium were pruned and functionally annotated using external functional and evolutionary information, specifically Functional-And-Evolutionary Trait Heritability scores, thereby prioritizing the variants with the highest potential to affect the traits. Variants were found in both known and novel regions for the traits studied, leading to a list of novel, shared candidate markers that can be incorporated into multitrait genomic predictions to increase their reliability.
- Open Access
- 1 July 2025
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 108 (7) , 7310-7328
Sequence-based genome-wide association study and fine-mapping in German Holstein reveal new quantitative trait loci for health traits
We conducted a large GWAS of 11 health traits belonging to 3 trait complexes: (1) metabolic diseases, (2) infectious and noninfectious feet and claw disorders, and (3) udder-related traits in 100,809 to 180,217 German Holstein cows to investigate the genetic architecture and underlying biological mechanisms behind these complex traits. The GWAS identified 12,306 genome-wide significant variants across 10 traits. The new association signals were inspected with a Bayesian fine-mapping approach, leading to the discovery of 159 novel variants with high potential for causality. Variants were in known and novel regions for the traits studied, leading to a list of 53 novel candidate genes. Our study represents the largest whole-genome sequence GWAS for health traits so far, hence ensuring the power to detect meaningful variants, especially when enhanced with fine-mapping.
- 1 July 2025
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 108 (7) , 7310-7328
Open AccessSequence-based genome-wide association study and fine-mapping in German Holstein reveal new quantitative trait loci for health traits
We conducted a large GWAS of 11 health traits belonging to 3 trait complexes: (1) metabolic diseases, (2) infectious and noninfectious feet and claw disorders, and (3) udder-related traits in 100,809 to 180,217 German Holstein cows to investigate the genetic architecture and underlying biological mechanisms behind these complex traits. The GWAS identified 12,306 genome-wide significant variants across 10 traits. The new association signals were inspected with a Bayesian fine-mapping approach, leading to the discovery of 159 novel variants with high potential for causality. Variants were in known and novel regions for the traits studied, leading to a list of 53 novel candidate genes. Our study represents the largest whole-genome sequence GWAS for health traits so far, hence ensuring the power to detect meaningful variants, especially when enhanced with fine-mapping.
- Open Access
- 1 June 2025
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 108 (6) , 6161-6173
Genetics of twin birth rate in German Holstein and options for breeding
Twinning in dairy cattle poses substantial risks for both cows and calves, including increased rates of calving difficulties, stillbirths, postpartum complications, and negative effects on calf viability and growth. These challenges lead to substantial economic losses and raise serious concerns for animal health and welfare. Consequently, selecting against twin births in German Holstein cattle could be beneficial. In this study, we analyzed the trait twin birth by estimating variance components and genetic correlations with other traits using population-wide data from German Holstein cattle. Breeding values were calculated using a single-step SNP BLUP model, treating twin births as 2 genetically correlated traits: (1) in first parity, and (2) in second and later parities. Heritability was estimated at 0.008 (± 0.0004) for the first parity and 0.026 (± 0.0008) for later parities. Genetic correlations with milk traits were close to zero, slightly positive with fertility, and slightly negative with longevity. The highest genetic correlation of 0.326 (± 0.0229) was observed for stillbirth rate. Comparison of breeding values with daughter phenotypes revealed substantial variability among bulls, whose genetic potential was expressed in varying twin birth rates among their daughters. It is therefore possible to lower twin birth rate through breeding. The estimation of the phenotypic impact of twin births on milk, longevity, calving ease, stillbirth, and health traits highlights the potential to breed against twin births to improve economics, herd performance and animal welfare.
- 1 June 2025
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 108 (6) , 6161-6173
Open AccessGenetics of twin birth rate in German Holstein and options for breeding
Twinning in dairy cattle poses substantial risks for both cows and calves, including increased rates of calving difficulties, stillbirths, postpartum complications, and negative effects on calf viability and growth. These challenges lead to substantial economic losses and raise serious concerns for animal health and welfare. Consequently, selecting against twin births in German Holstein cattle could be beneficial. In this study, we analyzed the trait twin birth by estimating variance components and genetic correlations with other traits using population-wide data from German Holstein cattle. Breeding values were calculated using a single-step SNP BLUP model, treating twin births as 2 genetically correlated traits: (1) in first parity, and (2) in second and later parities. Heritability was estimated at 0.008 (± 0.0004) for the first parity and 0.026 (± 0.0008) for later parities. Genetic correlations with milk traits were close to zero, slightly positive with fertility, and slightly negative with longevity. The highest genetic correlation of 0.326 (± 0.0229) was observed for stillbirth rate. Comparison of breeding values with daughter phenotypes revealed substantial variability among bulls, whose genetic potential was expressed in varying twin birth rates among their daughters. It is therefore possible to lower twin birth rate through breeding. The estimation of the phenotypic impact of twin births on milk, longevity, calving ease, stillbirth, and health traits highlights the potential to breed against twin births to improve economics, herd performance and animal welfare.
- Open Access
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Genetics Selection Evolution
- Vol. 57 (1) , 1-18
Mendelian randomisation to uncover causal associations between conformation, metabolism, and production as potential exposure to reproduction in German Holstein dairy cattle
Background: Reproduction is vital to welfare, health, and economics in animal husbandry and breeding. Health and reproduction are increasingly being considered because of the observed genetic correlations between reproduction, health, conformation, and performance traits in dairy cattle. Understanding the detailed genetic architecture underlying these traits would represent a major step in comprehending their interplay. Identifying known, putative or novel associations in genomics could improve animal health, welfare, and performance while allowing further adjustments in animal breeding. Results: We conducted genome-wide association studies for 25 different traits belonging to four different complexes, namely reproduction (n = 13), conformation (n = 6), production (n = 3), and metabolism (n = 3), using a cohort of over 235,000 dairy cows. As a result, we identified genome-wide significant signals for all the studied traits. The obtained summary statistics collected served as the input for a Mendelian randomisation approach (GSMR) to infer causal associations between putative exposure and reproduction traits. The study considered conformation, production, and metabolism as exposure and reproduction as outcome. A range of 139 to 252 genome-wide significant SNPs per combination were identified as instrumental variables (IVs). Out of 156 trait combinations, 135 demonstrated statistically significant effects, thereby enabling the identification of the responsible IVs. Combinations of traits related to metabolism (38 out of 39), conformation (68 out of 78), or production (29 out of 39) were found to have significant effects on reproduction. These relationships were partially non-linear. Moreover, a separate variance component estimation supported these findings, strongly correlating with the GSMR results and offering suggestions for improvement. Downstream analyses of selected representative traits per complex resulted in identifying and investigating potential physiological mechanisms. Notably, we identified both trait-specific SNPs and genes that appeared to influence specific traits per complex, as well as more general SNPs that were common between exposure and outcome traits. Conclusions: Our study confirms the known genetic associations between reproduction traits and the three complexes tested. It provides new insights into causality, indicating a non-linear relationship between conformation and reproduction. In addition, the downstream analyses have identified several clustered genes that may mediate this association.
- 25 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Genetics Selection Evolution
- Vol. 57 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessMendelian randomisation to uncover causal associations between conformation, metabolism, and production as potential exposure to reproduction in German Holstein dairy cattle
Background: Reproduction is vital to welfare, health, and economics in animal husbandry and breeding. Health and reproduction are increasingly being considered because of the observed genetic correlations between reproduction, health, conformation, and performance traits in dairy cattle. Understanding the detailed genetic architecture underlying these traits would represent a major step in comprehending their interplay. Identifying known, putative or novel associations in genomics could improve animal health, welfare, and performance while allowing further adjustments in animal breeding. Results: We conducted genome-wide association studies for 25 different traits belonging to four different complexes, namely reproduction (n = 13), conformation (n = 6), production (n = 3), and metabolism (n = 3), using a cohort of over 235,000 dairy cows. As a result, we identified genome-wide significant signals for all the studied traits. The obtained summary statistics collected served as the input for a Mendelian randomisation approach (GSMR) to infer causal associations between putative exposure and reproduction traits. The study considered conformation, production, and metabolism as exposure and reproduction as outcome. A range of 139 to 252 genome-wide significant SNPs per combination were identified as instrumental variables (IVs). Out of 156 trait combinations, 135 demonstrated statistically significant effects, thereby enabling the identification of the responsible IVs. Combinations of traits related to metabolism (38 out of 39), conformation (68 out of 78), or production (29 out of 39) were found to have significant effects on reproduction. These relationships were partially non-linear. Moreover, a separate variance component estimation supported these findings, strongly correlating with the GSMR results and offering suggestions for improvement. Downstream analyses of selected representative traits per complex resulted in identifying and investigating potential physiological mechanisms. Notably, we identified both trait-specific SNPs and genes that appeared to influence specific traits per complex, as well as more general SNPs that were common between exposure and outcome traits. Conclusions: Our study confirms the known genetic associations between reproduction traits and the three complexes tested. It provides new insights into causality, indicating a non-linear relationship between conformation and reproduction. In addition, the downstream analyses have identified several clustered genes that may mediate this association.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 4 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Genetics Selection Evolution
- Vol. 57 (1) , 1-20
Sequence-based GWAS in 180,000 German Holstein cattle reveals new candidate variants for milk production traits
Background: Milk production traits are complex and influenced by many genetic and environmental factors. Although extensive research has been performed for these traits, with many associations unveiled thus far, due to their crucial economic importance, complex genetic architecture, and the fact that causal variants in cattle are still scarce, there is a need for a better understanding of their genetic background. In this study, we aimed to identify new candidate loci associated with milk production traits in German Holstein cattle, the most important dairy breed in Germany and worldwide. For that purpose, 180,217 cattle were imputed to the sequence level and large-scale genome-wide association study (GWAS) followed by fine-mapping and evolutionary and functional annotation were carried out to identify and prioritize new association signals. Results: Using the imputed sequence data of a large cattle dataset, we identified 50,876 significant variants, confirming many known and identifying previously unreported candidate variants for milk (MY), fat (FY), and protein yield (PY). Genome-wide significant signals were fine-mapped with the Bayesian approach that determines the credible variant sets and generates the probability of causality for each signal. The variants with the highest probabilities of being causal were further classified using external information about the function and evolution, making the prioritization for subsequent validation experiments easier. The top potential causal variants determined with fine-mapping explained a large percentage of genetic variance compared to random ones; 178 variants explained 11.5%, 104 explained 7.7%, and 68 variants explained 3.9% of the variance for MY, FY, and PY, respectively, demonstrating the potential for causality. Conclusions: Our findings proved the power of large samples and sequence-based GWAS in detecting new association signals. In order to fully exploit the power of GWAS, one should aim at very large samples combined with whole-genome sequence data. These can also come with both computational and time burdens, as presented in our study. Although milk production traits in cattle are comprehensively investigated, the genetic background of these traits is still not fully understood, with the potential for many new associations to be revealed, as shown. With constantly growing sample sizes, we expect more insights into the genetic architecture of milk production traits in the future.
- 4 February 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Genetics Selection Evolution
- Vol. 57 (1) , 1-20
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessSequence-based GWAS in 180,000 German Holstein cattle reveals new candidate variants for milk production traits
Background: Milk production traits are complex and influenced by many genetic and environmental factors. Although extensive research has been performed for these traits, with many associations unveiled thus far, due to their crucial economic importance, complex genetic architecture, and the fact that causal variants in cattle are still scarce, there is a need for a better understanding of their genetic background. In this study, we aimed to identify new candidate loci associated with milk production traits in German Holstein cattle, the most important dairy breed in Germany and worldwide. For that purpose, 180,217 cattle were imputed to the sequence level and large-scale genome-wide association study (GWAS) followed by fine-mapping and evolutionary and functional annotation were carried out to identify and prioritize new association signals. Results: Using the imputed sequence data of a large cattle dataset, we identified 50,876 significant variants, confirming many known and identifying previously unreported candidate variants for milk (MY), fat (FY), and protein yield (PY). Genome-wide significant signals were fine-mapped with the Bayesian approach that determines the credible variant sets and generates the probability of causality for each signal. The variants with the highest probabilities of being causal were further classified using external information about the function and evolution, making the prioritization for subsequent validation experiments easier. The top potential causal variants determined with fine-mapping explained a large percentage of genetic variance compared to random ones; 178 variants explained 11.5%, 104 explained 7.7%, and 68 variants explained 3.9% of the variance for MY, FY, and PY, respectively, demonstrating the potential for causality. Conclusions: Our findings proved the power of large samples and sequence-based GWAS in detecting new association signals. In order to fully exploit the power of GWAS, one should aim at very large samples combined with whole-genome sequence data. These can also come with both computational and time burdens, as presented in our study. Although milk production traits in cattle are comprehensively investigated, the genetic background of these traits is still not fully understood, with the potential for many new associations to be revealed, as shown. With constantly growing sample sizes, we expect more insights into the genetic architecture of milk production traits in the future.
- Open Access
- 19 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Genomics
- Vol. 25 (1) , 880
Genetic and genomic analysis of reproduction traits in holstein cattle using SNP chip data and imputed sequence level genotypes
Background: Reproductive performance plays an important role in animal welfare, health and profitability in animal husbandry and breeding. It is well established that there is a negative correlation between performance and reproduction in dairy cattle. This relationship is being increasingly considered in breeding programs. By elucidating the genetic architecture of underlying reproduction traits, it will be possible to make a more detailed contribution to this. Our study followed two approaches to elucidate this area; in a first part, variance components were estimated for 14 different calving and fertility traits, and then genome-wide association studies were performed for 13 reproduction traits on imputed sequence-level genotypes with subsequent enrichment analyses. Results: Variance components analyses showed a low to moderate heritability (h 2 ) for the traits analysed, ranging from 0.014 for endometritis up to 0.271 for stillbirth, indicating variable degrees of variation within the reproduction traits. For genome-wide association studies, we were able to detect genome-wide significant association signals for nine out of 13 analysed traits after Bonferroni correction on chromosome 6, 18 and the X chromosome. In total, we detected over 2700 associated SNPs encircling more than 90 different genes using the imputed whole-genome sequence data. Functional associations were reviewed so far known and potential candidate regions in the proximity of reproduction events were hypothesised. Conclusion: Our results confirm previous findings of other authors in a comprehensive cohort including 13 different traits at the same time. Additionally, we identified new candidate genes involved in dairy cattle reproduction and made initial suggestions regarding their potential impact, with special regard to the X chromosome as a putative information source for further research. This work can make a contribution to reveal the genetic architecture of reproduction traits in context of trait specific interactions.
- 19 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in BMC Genomics
- Vol. 25 (1) , 880
Open AccessGenetic and genomic analysis of reproduction traits in holstein cattle using SNP chip data and imputed sequence level genotypes
Background: Reproductive performance plays an important role in animal welfare, health and profitability in animal husbandry and breeding. It is well established that there is a negative correlation between performance and reproduction in dairy cattle. This relationship is being increasingly considered in breeding programs. By elucidating the genetic architecture of underlying reproduction traits, it will be possible to make a more detailed contribution to this. Our study followed two approaches to elucidate this area; in a first part, variance components were estimated for 14 different calving and fertility traits, and then genome-wide association studies were performed for 13 reproduction traits on imputed sequence-level genotypes with subsequent enrichment analyses. Results: Variance components analyses showed a low to moderate heritability (h 2 ) for the traits analysed, ranging from 0.014 for endometritis up to 0.271 for stillbirth, indicating variable degrees of variation within the reproduction traits. For genome-wide association studies, we were able to detect genome-wide significant association signals for nine out of 13 analysed traits after Bonferroni correction on chromosome 6, 18 and the X chromosome. In total, we detected over 2700 associated SNPs encircling more than 90 different genes using the imputed whole-genome sequence data. Functional associations were reviewed so far known and potential candidate regions in the proximity of reproduction events were hypothesised. Conclusion: Our results confirm previous findings of other authors in a comprehensive cohort including 13 different traits at the same time. Additionally, we identified new candidate genes involved in dairy cattle reproduction and made initial suggestions regarding their potential impact, with special regard to the X chromosome as a putative information source for further research. This work can make a contribution to reveal the genetic architecture of reproduction traits in context of trait specific interactions.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 107 (1) , 423-437
The marker effects of a single-step random regression model for 4 test-day traits in German Holsteins
The single-step genomic model has become the golden standard for routine evaluation in livestock species, such as Holstein dairy cattle. The single-step genomic model with direct estimation of marker effects has been proven to be efficient in accurately accounting for millions of genotype records. For diverse applications including frequent genomic evaluation updates on a weekly basis, estimates of the marker effects from the single-step evaluations play a central role in genomic prediction. In this study we focused on exploring the marker effect estimates from the single-step evaluation. Phenotypic, genotypic, and pedigree data were taken from the official evaluation for German dairy breeds in April 2021. A multilactation random regression test -day model was applied to more than 242 million test -day records separately for 4 traits: milk, fat, and protein yields, and somatic cell scores (SCS). Approximately one million genotyped Holstein animals were considered in the single-step genomic evaluations including -21 million animals in pedigree. Deregressed multiple across -country breeding values of Holstein bulls having daughters outside Germany were integrated into the national test -day data to increase the reliability of genomic breeding values. To assess the stability and bias of the marker effects of the single-step model, test -day records of the last 4 yr were deleted, and the integrated bulls born in the last 4 yr were truncated from the complete phenotypic dataset. Estimates of the marker effects were shown to be highly correlated, with correlations -0.9, between the full and truncated evaluations. Regression slope values of the marker -effect estimates from the full on the truncated evaluations were all close to their expected value, being -1.03. Calculated using random regression coefficients of the marker effect estimates, drastically different shapes of the genetic lactation curve were seen for 2 markers on chromosome 14 for the 4 test -day traits. The contribution of individual chromosomes to the total additive genetic variances seemed to follow the polygenic inheritance mode for protein yield and SCS. However, chromosome 14 was found to make an exceptionally large contribution to the total additive genetic variance for milk and fat yields because of markers near the major gene DGAT1. For the first lactation test -day traits, we obtained -0 correlations of chromosomal direct genomic values between any pair of the chromosomes; no spurious correlations were found in our analysis, thanks to the large reference population. For trait milk yield, chromosomal direct genomic values appeared to have a large variation in the between -lactation correlations among the chromosomes, especially between first and second or third lactations. The optimal features of the random regression test -day model and the single-step marker model allowed us to track the differences in the shapes of genetic lactation curves down to the individual markers. Furthermore, the single-step random regression test -day model enabled us to better understand the inheritance mode of the yield traits and SCS (e.g., variable chromosomal contributions to the total additive genetic variance and to the genetic correlations between lactations).
- 1 January 2024
- Published by American Dairy Science Association in Journal of Dairy Science
- Vol. 107 (1) , 423-437
Open AccessThe marker effects of a single-step random regression model for 4 test-day traits in German Holsteins
The single-step genomic model has become the golden standard for routine evaluation in livestock species, such as Holstein dairy cattle. The single-step genomic model with direct estimation of marker effects has been proven to be efficient in accurately accounting for millions of genotype records. For diverse applications including frequent genomic evaluation updates on a weekly basis, estimates of the marker effects from the single-step evaluations play a central role in genomic prediction. In this study we focused on exploring the marker effect estimates from the single-step evaluation. Phenotypic, genotypic, and pedigree data were taken from the official evaluation for German dairy breeds in April 2021. A multilactation random regression test -day model was applied to more than 242 million test -day records separately for 4 traits: milk, fat, and protein yields, and somatic cell scores (SCS). Approximately one million genotyped Holstein animals were considered in the single-step genomic evaluations including -21 million animals in pedigree. Deregressed multiple across -country breeding values of Holstein bulls having daughters outside Germany were integrated into the national test -day data to increase the reliability of genomic breeding values. To assess the stability and bias of the marker effects of the single-step model, test -day records of the last 4 yr were deleted, and the integrated bulls born in the last 4 yr were truncated from the complete phenotypic dataset. Estimates of the marker effects were shown to be highly correlated, with correlations -0.9, between the full and truncated evaluations. Regression slope values of the marker -effect estimates from the full on the truncated evaluations were all close to their expected value, being -1.03. Calculated using random regression coefficients of the marker effect estimates, drastically different shapes of the genetic lactation curve were seen for 2 markers on chromosome 14 for the 4 test -day traits. The contribution of individual chromosomes to the total additive genetic variances seemed to follow the polygenic inheritance mode for protein yield and SCS. However, chromosome 14 was found to make an exceptionally large contribution to the total additive genetic variance for milk and fat yields because of markers near the major gene DGAT1. For the first lactation test -day traits, we obtained -0 correlations of chromosomal direct genomic values between any pair of the chromosomes; no spurious correlations were found in our analysis, thanks to the large reference population. For trait milk yield, chromosomal direct genomic values appeared to have a large variation in the between -lactation correlations among the chromosomes, especially between first and second or third lactations. The optimal features of the random regression test -day model and the single-step marker model allowed us to track the differences in the shapes of genetic lactation curves down to the individual markers. Furthermore, the single-step random regression test -day model enabled us to better understand the inheritance mode of the yield traits and SCS (e.g., variable chromosomal contributions to the total additive genetic variance and to the genetic correlations between lactations).
- Open Access
Sequence-based GWAS in 180 000 German Holstein cattle reveals new candidate genes for milk production traits
Background: The use of genome-wide association studies (GWAS) has led to the identification of numerous quantitative trait loci and candidate genes in dairy cattle. To obtain sufficient power of GWAS and to identify quantitative trait nucleotides, whole-genome sequence data is required. Sequence data facilitates the identification of potential causal variants; however, sequencing of whole genomes is still expensive for a large number of animals. Imputation is a quick and efficient way of obtaining sequence data from large datasets. Milk production traits are complex and influenced by many genetic and environmental factors. Although extensive research has been performed for these traits, with many associations unveiled thus far, due to their crucial economic importance, complex genetic architecture, and the fact that causative variants in cattle are still scarce, there is a need for a better understanding of their genetic background. In this study, we aimed to identify new candidate loci associated with milk production traits in German Holstein cattle, the most important dairy breed in Germany and worldwide. For that purpose, 252,285 cattle were imputed to the sequence level and large-scale GWAS was carried out to identify new association signals. Results: We confirmed many known and identified 30 previously unreported candidate genes for milk, fat, and protein yield. While all of the genes were functionally associated with the traits, some showed pleiotropic effects as well. Specifically, association with mammary gland development, fatty acid synthesis, metabolism of lipids, or milk production QTLs in other farm animals has been reported. Variants associated with these genes explained a large percentage of genetic variance, compared to random ones. Conclusions: Our findings proved the power of large samples and sequence-based GWAS in detecting new association signals. In order to fully exploit the power of GWAS, one should aim at very large samples combined with whole-genome sequence data. Although milk production traits in cattle are comprehensively researched, the genetic background of these traits is still not fully understood, with the potential for many new associations to be revealed, as shown in our study. With constantly growing sample sizes, we expect more insights into the genetic architecture of production traits in the future.
Open AccessSequence-based GWAS in 180 000 German Holstein cattle reveals new candidate genes for milk production traits
Background: The use of genome-wide association studies (GWAS) has led to the identification of numerous quantitative trait loci and candidate genes in dairy cattle. To obtain sufficient power of GWAS and to identify quantitative trait nucleotides, whole-genome sequence data is required. Sequence data facilitates the identification of potential causal variants; however, sequencing of whole genomes is still expensive for a large number of animals. Imputation is a quick and efficient way of obtaining sequence data from large datasets. Milk production traits are complex and influenced by many genetic and environmental factors. Although extensive research has been performed for these traits, with many associations unveiled thus far, due to their crucial economic importance, complex genetic architecture, and the fact that causative variants in cattle are still scarce, there is a need for a better understanding of their genetic background. In this study, we aimed to identify new candidate loci associated with milk production traits in German Holstein cattle, the most important dairy breed in Germany and worldwide. For that purpose, 252,285 cattle were imputed to the sequence level and large-scale GWAS was carried out to identify new association signals. Results: We confirmed many known and identified 30 previously unreported candidate genes for milk, fat, and protein yield. While all of the genes were functionally associated with the traits, some showed pleiotropic effects as well. Specifically, association with mammary gland development, fatty acid synthesis, metabolism of lipids, or milk production QTLs in other farm animals has been reported. Variants associated with these genes explained a large percentage of genetic variance, compared to random ones. Conclusions: Our findings proved the power of large samples and sequence-based GWAS in detecting new association signals. In order to fully exploit the power of GWAS, one should aim at very large samples combined with whole-genome sequence data. Although milk production traits in cattle are comprehensively researched, the genetic background of these traits is still not fully understood, with the potential for many new associations to be revealed, as shown in our study. With constantly growing sample sizes, we expect more insights into the genetic architecture of production traits in the future.
- Open Access
- 16 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics
- Vol. 140 (5) , 496-507
Single‐step SNPBLUP evaluation in six German beef cattle breeds
The implementation of genomic selection for six German beef cattle populations was evaluated. Although the multiple‐step implementation of genomic selection is the status quo in most national dairy cattle evaluations, the breeding structure of German beef cattle, coupled with the shortcoming and complexity of the multiple‐step method, makes single step a more attractive option to implement genomic selection in German beef cattle populations. Our objective was to develop a national beef cattle single‐step genomic evaluation in five economically important traits in six German beef cattle populations and investigate its impact on the accuracy and bias of genomic evaluations relative to the current pedigree‐based evaluation. Across the six breeds in our study, 461,929 phenotyped and 14,321 genotyped animals were evaluated with a multi‐trait single‐step model. To validate the single‐step model, phenotype data in the last 2 years were removed in a forward validation study. For the conventional and single‐step approaches, the genomic estimated breeding values of validation animals and other animals were compared between the truncated and the full evaluations. The correlation of the GEBVs between the full and truncated evaluations in the validation animals was slightly higher in the single‐step evaluation. The regression of the full GEBVs on truncated GEBVs was close to the optimal value of 1 for both the pedigree‐based and the single‐step evaluations. The SNP effect estimates from the truncated evaluation were highly correlated with those from the full evaluation, with values ranging from 0.79 to 0.94. The correlation of the SNP effect was influenced by the number of genotyped animals shared between the full and truncated evaluations. The regression coefficients of the SNP effect of the full evaluation on the truncated evaluation were all close to the expected value of 1, indicating unbiased estimates of the SNP markers for the production traits. The Manhattan plot of the SNP effect estimates identified chromosomal regions harbouring major genes for muscling and body weight in breeds of French origin. Based on the regression intercept and slope of the GEBVs of validation animals, the single‐step evaluation was neither inflated nor deflated across the six breeds. Overall, the single‐step model resulted in a more accurate and stable evaluation. However, due to the small number of genotyped individuals, the single‐step method only provided slightly better results when compared to the pedigree‐based method.
- 16 April 2023
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Animal Breeding and Genetics
- Vol. 140 (5) , 496-507
Open AccessSingle‐step SNPBLUP evaluation in six German beef cattle breeds
The implementation of genomic selection for six German beef cattle populations was evaluated. Although the multiple‐step implementation of genomic selection is the status quo in most national dairy cattle evaluations, the breeding structure of German beef cattle, coupled with the shortcoming and complexity of the multiple‐step method, makes single step a more attractive option to implement genomic selection in German beef cattle populations. Our objective was to develop a national beef cattle single‐step genomic evaluation in five economically important traits in six German beef cattle populations and investigate its impact on the accuracy and bias of genomic evaluations relative to the current pedigree‐based evaluation. Across the six breeds in our study, 461,929 phenotyped and 14,321 genotyped animals were evaluated with a multi‐trait single‐step model. To validate the single‐step model, phenotype data in the last 2 years were removed in a forward validation study. For the conventional and single‐step approaches, the genomic estimated breeding values of validation animals and other animals were compared between the truncated and the full evaluations. The correlation of the GEBVs between the full and truncated evaluations in the validation animals was slightly higher in the single‐step evaluation. The regression of the full GEBVs on truncated GEBVs was close to the optimal value of 1 for both the pedigree‐based and the single‐step evaluations. The SNP effect estimates from the truncated evaluation were highly correlated with those from the full evaluation, with values ranging from 0.79 to 0.94. The correlation of the SNP effect was influenced by the number of genotyped animals shared between the full and truncated evaluations. The regression coefficients of the SNP effect of the full evaluation on the truncated evaluation were all close to the expected value of 1, indicating unbiased estimates of the SNP markers for the production traits. The Manhattan plot of the SNP effect estimates identified chromosomal regions harbouring major genes for muscling and body weight in breeds of French origin. Based on the regression intercept and slope of the GEBVs of validation animals, the single‐step evaluation was neither inflated nor deflated across the six breeds. Overall, the single‐step model resulted in a more accurate and stable evaluation. However, due to the small number of genotyped individuals, the single‐step method only provided slightly better results when compared to the pedigree‐based method.