Robin A. Costello
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Robin A. Costello has a total of 63 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Vincent A. Formica
Department of Biology Swarthmore College Swarthmore Pennsylvania USA
4 shared publications Cissy J. Ballen
Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849
3 shared publications- Cissy J. Ballen
Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA
3 shared publications - Edmund D. BrodieIII
Mountain Lake Biological Station and Department of Biology University of Virginia Charlottesville Virginia USA
3 shared publications - Emily P. Driessen
Department of Biological Sciences, Auburn University, Auburn, AL 36849, USA
3 shared publications - Phoebe A. Cook
Department of Biology, University of Virginia, Charlottesville, VA, USA
3 shared publications
Latest Publications
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
Students express minimal resistance to inclusive biology activities highlighting the diversity of scientists
While educators strive to foster inclusive learning environments, a commonly reported concern is the prospect of student resistance to inclusive course content. To investigate the extent of student resistance to inclusive activities, we conducted a post-hoc analysis of more than 6000 student responses to survey questionnaires from a nationwide study that evaluated data literacy activities implemented in undergraduate biology courses that featured scientist role models with counter-stereotypical identities. We found few instances of active student resistance to these inclusive activities. Most student responses (94%) displayed no clear resistance to the activities. Of the resistant responses, only 16 (0.25%) were clearly resistant to the inclusive content within the data literacy activities. This study is the first to attempt to quantify student resistance to inclusive activities featuring counter-stereotypical scientist role models and serves as a springboard for future exploration of student resistance.
- 1 April 2026
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
Students express minimal resistance to inclusive biology activities highlighting the diversity of scientists
While educators strive to foster inclusive learning environments, a commonly reported concern is the prospect of student resistance to inclusive course content. To investigate the extent of student resistance to inclusive activities, we conducted a post-hoc analysis of more than 6000 student responses to survey questionnaires from a nationwide study that evaluated data literacy activities implemented in undergraduate biology courses that featured scientist role models with counter-stereotypical identities. We found few instances of active student resistance to these inclusive activities. Most student responses (94%) displayed no clear resistance to the activities. Of the resistant responses, only 16 (0.25%) were clearly resistant to the inclusive content within the data literacy activities. This study is the first to attempt to quantify student resistance to inclusive activities featuring counter-stereotypical scientist role models and serves as a springboard for future exploration of student resistance.
- 1 June 2025
- Published by American Society for Cell Biology (ASCB) in CBE—Life Sciences Education
- Vol. 24 (2) , es1
Highlighting Counterstereotypical Scientists in Undergraduate Life Science Courses
In this essay, we review how counter-stereotypical scientists have been featured in life science courses and discuss the benefits and costs of developing and interacting with these materials from the perspectives of three groups: students, instructors, and the featured scientists.
- 1 June 2025
- Published by American Society for Cell Biology (ASCB) in CBE—Life Sciences Education
- Vol. 24 (2) , es1
Highlighting Counterstereotypical Scientists in Undergraduate Life Science Courses
In this essay, we review how counter-stereotypical scientists have been featured in life science courses and discuss the benefits and costs of developing and interacting with these materials from the perspectives of three groups: students, instructors, and the featured scientists.
- Open Access
- 12 February 2025
- Published by Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) Library in Nordic Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 43-65
STEM students prefer assessment practices known to reduce the impact of test anxiety
Undergraduate introductory STEM courses often rely on few, high-stakes exams to assess student learning. This assessment strategy engenders high test anxiety and negatively impacts academic performance. We know little about how students want to be assessed—particularly those who experience high test anxiety. Applying a humanist learning framework, we asked students at a university in Norway to envision their ideal assessment practice. Our analyses affirm that test anxious students performed worse in their STEM courses, and students with marginalized identities in STEM were more test anxious. Additionally, we found that students overwhelmingly want more assessments. We also found that first-generation students, a student group rarely studied in Norway, want different types of assessments to replace high-stakes exams. In sum, student preferences aligned with assessment practices known to reduce the impact of test anxiety. Our results support calls for creating STEM environments where student voices are valued.
- 12 February 2025
- Published by Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU) Library in Nordic Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 43-65
Open AccessSTEM students prefer assessment practices known to reduce the impact of test anxiety
Undergraduate introductory STEM courses often rely on few, high-stakes exams to assess student learning. This assessment strategy engenders high test anxiety and negatively impacts academic performance. We know little about how students want to be assessed—particularly those who experience high test anxiety. Applying a humanist learning framework, we asked students at a university in Norway to envision their ideal assessment practice. Our analyses affirm that test anxious students performed worse in their STEM courses, and students with marginalized identities in STEM were more test anxious. Additionally, we found that students overwhelmingly want more assessments. We also found that first-generation students, a student group rarely studied in Norway, want different types of assessments to replace high-stakes exams. In sum, student preferences aligned with assessment practices known to reduce the impact of test anxiety. Our results support calls for creating STEM environments where student voices are valued.
- Open Access
- 22 January 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2039) , 20240879
More than a token photo: humanizing scientists enhances student engagement
Despite broad consensus that highlighting counter-stereotypical scientist role models in educational materials promotes equity and success, the specific elements that make these materials effective remain untested. Are pictures of counter-stereotypical scientists enough to communicate to students that scientists come from a variety of backgrounds, or is additional information required? To parse the effects of including visual depictions and humanizing information about scientists featured in biology course materials, we distributed three randomized versions of assignments over several academic terms across 36 undergraduate institutions ( n > 3700 students). We found that including humanizing information about scientists was key to increasing student engagement with the biology course materials. The positive effect of humanizing information was especially important for students who related to the scientists. Structural equation modelling revealed the extent to which students related to scientists mediated the positive effect of humanizing descriptions on student engagement. Furthermore, our results were strongest among students who shared one or more excluded identity(s) with the featured scientists. Our findings underscore the importance of providing students with examples of humanized and relatable scientists in classrooms, rather than simply adding a photo to increase representation.
- 22 January 2025
- Published by The Royal Society in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
- Vol. 292 (2039) , 20240879
Open AccessMore than a token photo: humanizing scientists enhances student engagement
Despite broad consensus that highlighting counter-stereotypical scientist role models in educational materials promotes equity and success, the specific elements that make these materials effective remain untested. Are pictures of counter-stereotypical scientists enough to communicate to students that scientists come from a variety of backgrounds, or is additional information required? To parse the effects of including visual depictions and humanizing information about scientists featured in biology course materials, we distributed three randomized versions of assignments over several academic terms across 36 undergraduate institutions ( n > 3700 students). We found that including humanizing information about scientists was key to increasing student engagement with the biology course materials. The positive effect of humanizing information was especially important for students who related to the scientists. Structural equation modelling revealed the extent to which students related to scientists mediated the positive effect of humanizing descriptions on student engagement. Furthermore, our results were strongest among students who shared one or more excluded identity(s) with the featured scientists. Our findings underscore the importance of providing students with examples of humanized and relatable scientists in classrooms, rather than simply adding a photo to increase representation.
- 28 October 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 379 (1916) , 20230331
Population age structure shapes selection on social behaviour in a long-lived insect
Social traits are expected to experience highly context-dependent selection, but we know little about the contextual factors that shape selection on social behaviours. We hypothesized that the fitness consequences of social interactions will depend on the age of social partners, and therefore that population age structure will shape evolutionary pressures on sociality. Here, we investigate the consequences of age variation at multiple levels of social organization for both individual fitness and sexual selection on social network traits. We experimentally manipulated the age composition of populations of the forked fungus beetle Bolitotherus cornutus , creating 12 replicate populations with either young or old age structures. We found that fitness is associated with variance in age at three different levels of organization: the individual, interacting social partners, and the population. Older individuals have higher reproductive success, males pay a fitness cost when they interact with old males and females achieve lower fitness in older populations. In addition to influencing fitness, population age structure also altered the selection acting on social network position in females. Female sociality is under positive selection only in old populations. Our results highlight age structure as an understudied demographic variable shaping the landscape of selection on social behaviour. This article is part of the discussion meeting issue ‘Understanding age and society using natural populations’.
- 28 October 2024
- Published by The Royal Society in Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
- Vol. 379 (1916) , 20230331
Population age structure shapes selection on social behaviour in a long-lived insect
Social traits are expected to experience highly context-dependent selection, but we know little about the contextual factors that shape selection on social behaviours. We hypothesized that the fitness consequences of social interactions will depend on the age of social partners, and therefore that population age structure will shape evolutionary pressures on sociality. Here, we investigate the consequences of age variation at multiple levels of social organization for both individual fitness and sexual selection on social network traits. We experimentally manipulated the age composition of populations of the forked fungus beetle Bolitotherus cornutus , creating 12 replicate populations with either young or old age structures. We found that fitness is associated with variance in age at three different levels of organization: the individual, interacting social partners, and the population. Older individuals have higher reproductive success, males pay a fitness cost when they interact with old males and females achieve lower fitness in older populations. In addition to influencing fitness, population age structure also altered the selection acting on social network position in females. Female sociality is under positive selection only in old populations. Our results highlight age structure as an understudied demographic variable shaping the landscape of selection on social behaviour. This article is part of the discussion meeting issue ‘Understanding age and society using natural populations’.
- Open Access
- 17 October 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (10) , e0312243
“It let me merge my love of teaching with research”: A qualitative investigation of the career pathways of biology education researchers
Discipline-based education research—a field of research that investigates teaching and learning within STEM disciplines—has emerged over the last few decades to improve the quality of STEM education worldwide. Simple qualitative questions concerning the career backgrounds and motivations of the individuals who conduct this research have yet to be explored. Here, we surveyed and interviewed discipline-based education researchers about their career trajectories and motivations to pursue this field of research. We focused specifically on recruiting biology education research faculty members at colleges and universities. We used the Social Influence Model and Social Cognitive Career Theory to develop and analyze survey and semi-structured interview questions. Findings revealed participant career paths all began with disciplinary undergraduate and graduate-level biology education. We noticed participants began conducting biology education research due to their values and personal interests, while additionally being swayed by contextual factors. Specifically, participants valued biology education research because it allowed them to make a difference in the world and provided them with a community open to change and collaboration. Biology education research allowed them to explore their interests in teaching and evidence-based approaches to education. These values and interests were impacted by contextual factors, including discoveries of opportunities, positive (or negative) experiences with mentorship, exposure to evidence-based teaching literature, considerations of salary and job security, and experiences with gender-based discrimination. Our results underscore the importance of harnessing individual values and interests—especially those centered on evidence-based teaching practices and making a difference in the world—while fostering a positive and supportive academic environment. This research reveals pathways toward discipline-based education research careers. Additionally, this research can inform the development of graduate programs and funding opportunities.
- 17 October 2024
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 19 (10) , e0312243
Open Access“It let me merge my love of teaching with research”: A qualitative investigation of the career pathways of biology education researchers
Discipline-based education research—a field of research that investigates teaching and learning within STEM disciplines—has emerged over the last few decades to improve the quality of STEM education worldwide. Simple qualitative questions concerning the career backgrounds and motivations of the individuals who conduct this research have yet to be explored. Here, we surveyed and interviewed discipline-based education researchers about their career trajectories and motivations to pursue this field of research. We focused specifically on recruiting biology education research faculty members at colleges and universities. We used the Social Influence Model and Social Cognitive Career Theory to develop and analyze survey and semi-structured interview questions. Findings revealed participant career paths all began with disciplinary undergraduate and graduate-level biology education. We noticed participants began conducting biology education research due to their values and personal interests, while additionally being swayed by contextual factors. Specifically, participants valued biology education research because it allowed them to make a difference in the world and provided them with a community open to change and collaboration. Biology education research allowed them to explore their interests in teaching and evidence-based approaches to education. These values and interests were impacted by contextual factors, including discoveries of opportunities, positive (or negative) experiences with mentorship, exposure to evidence-based teaching literature, considerations of salary and job security, and experiences with gender-based discrimination. Our results underscore the importance of harnessing individual values and interests—especially those centered on evidence-based teaching practices and making a difference in the world—while fostering a positive and supportive academic environment. This research reveals pathways toward discipline-based education research careers. Additionally, this research can inform the development of graduate programs and funding opportunities.
- Open Access
More than a token photo: humanizing scientists enhances student engagement
Highlighting scientists from historically excluded groups in educational materials increases student engagement in STEM. However, which specific elements of these educational materials maximize their impact remains untested, leaving educators guessing how to best highlight counter-stereotypical scientists in their classrooms. We tested the effects of including visual and humanizing descriptions of scientists featured in quantitative biology activities on over 3,700 students across 36 undergraduate institutions. We found that including humanizing information about counter-stereotypical scientists increased the extent to which students related to those scientists, which in turn translated to higher student engagement. Students who shared one or more excluded identity(s) with the featured scientists related most strongly. Our findings demonstrate the importance of humanizing counter-stereotypical scientists in classrooms, beyond simply adding a photo to increase representation.
Open AccessMore than a token photo: humanizing scientists enhances student engagement
Highlighting scientists from historically excluded groups in educational materials increases student engagement in STEM. However, which specific elements of these educational materials maximize their impact remains untested, leaving educators guessing how to best highlight counter-stereotypical scientists in their classrooms. We tested the effects of including visual and humanizing descriptions of scientists featured in quantitative biology activities on over 3,700 students across 36 undergraduate institutions. We found that including humanizing information about counter-stereotypical scientists increased the extent to which students related to those scientists, which in turn translated to higher student engagement. Students who shared one or more excluded identity(s) with the featured scientists related most strongly. Our findings demonstrate the importance of humanizing counter-stereotypical scientists in classrooms, beyond simply adding a photo to increase representation.
- Open Access
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-18
Pathways of opportunity in STEM: comparative investigation of degree attainment across different demographic groups at a large research institution
Background: We used an opportunity gap framework to analyze the pathways through which students enter into and depart from science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) degrees in an R1 higher education institution and to better understand the demographic disparities in STEM degree attainment. Results: We found disparities in 6-year STEM graduation rates on the basis of gender, race/ethnicity, and parental education level. Using mediation analysis, we showed that the gender disparity in STEM degree attainment was explained by disparities in aspiration: a gender disparity in students’ intent to pursue STEM at the beginning of college; women were less likely to graduate with STEM degrees because they were less likely to intend to pursue STEM degrees. However, disparities in STEM degree attainment across race/ethnicities and parental education level were largely explained by disparities in attrition: persons excluded because of their ethnicity or race (PEERs) and first generation students were less likely to graduate with STEM degrees due to fewer academic opportunities provided prior to college (estimated using college entrance exams scores) and more academic challenges during college as captured by first year GPAs. Conclusions: Our results reinforce the idea that patterns of departure from STEM pathways differ among marginalized groups. To promote and retain students in STEM, it is critical that we understand these differing patterns and consider structural efforts to support students at different stages in their education.
- 28 June 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of STEM Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 1-18
Open AccessPathways of opportunity in STEM: comparative investigation of degree attainment across different demographic groups at a large research institution
Background: We used an opportunity gap framework to analyze the pathways through which students enter into and depart from science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) degrees in an R1 higher education institution and to better understand the demographic disparities in STEM degree attainment. Results: We found disparities in 6-year STEM graduation rates on the basis of gender, race/ethnicity, and parental education level. Using mediation analysis, we showed that the gender disparity in STEM degree attainment was explained by disparities in aspiration: a gender disparity in students’ intent to pursue STEM at the beginning of college; women were less likely to graduate with STEM degrees because they were less likely to intend to pursue STEM degrees. However, disparities in STEM degree attainment across race/ethnicities and parental education level were largely explained by disparities in attrition: persons excluded because of their ethnicity or race (PEERs) and first generation students were less likely to graduate with STEM degrees due to fewer academic opportunities provided prior to college (estimated using college entrance exams scores) and more academic challenges during college as captured by first year GPAs. Conclusions: Our results reinforce the idea that patterns of departure from STEM pathways differ among marginalized groups. To promote and retain students in STEM, it is critical that we understand these differing patterns and consider structural efforts to support students at different stages in their education.
- 4 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research in Science Education
- Vol. 54 (1) , 13-26
Re-envisioning Biology Curricula to Include Ideological Awareness
- 4 February 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research in Science Education
- Vol. 54 (1) , 13-26
Re-envisioning Biology Curricula to Include Ideological Awareness
- 8 December 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 77 (1) , 289-303
Multilevel selection on social network traits differs between sexes in experimental populations of forked fungus beetles
Both individual and group behavior can influence individual fitness, but multilevel selection is rarely quantified on social behaviors. Social networks provide a unique opportunity to study multilevel selection on social behaviors, as they describe complex social traits and patterns of interaction at both the individual and group levels. In this study, we used contextual analysis to measure the consequences of both individual network position and group network structure on individual fitness in experimental populations of forked fungus beetles (Bolitotherus cornutus) with two different resource distributions. We found that males with high individual connectivity (strength) and centrality (betweenness) had higher mating success. However, group network structure did not influence their mating success. Conversely, we found that individual network position had no effect on female reproductive success but that females in populations with many social interactions experienced lower reproductive success. The strength of individual-level selection in males and group-level selection in females intensified when resources were clumped together, showing that habitat structure influences multilevel selection. Individual and emergent group social behavior both influence variation in components of individual fitness, but impact the male mating success and female reproductive success differently, setting up intersexual conflicts over patterns of social interactions at multiple levels.
- 8 December 2022
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Evolution
- Vol. 77 (1) , 289-303
Multilevel selection on social network traits differs between sexes in experimental populations of forked fungus beetles
Both individual and group behavior can influence individual fitness, but multilevel selection is rarely quantified on social behaviors. Social networks provide a unique opportunity to study multilevel selection on social behaviors, as they describe complex social traits and patterns of interaction at both the individual and group levels. In this study, we used contextual analysis to measure the consequences of both individual network position and group network structure on individual fitness in experimental populations of forked fungus beetles (Bolitotherus cornutus) with two different resource distributions. We found that males with high individual connectivity (strength) and centrality (betweenness) had higher mating success. However, group network structure did not influence their mating success. Conversely, we found that individual network position had no effect on female reproductive success but that females in populations with many social interactions experienced lower reproductive success. The strength of individual-level selection in males and group-level selection in females intensified when resources were clumped together, showing that habitat structure influences multilevel selection. Individual and emergent group social behavior both influence variation in components of individual fitness, but impact the male mating success and female reproductive success differently, setting up intersexual conflicts over patterns of social interactions at multiple levels.