Tapdyg Khafizovich Kerimov
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Tapdyg Khafizovich Kerimov has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Aleksandr Vladimirovich Pertsev
Уральский федеральный университет, Екатеринбург
1 shared publication - D. A. Tomiltseva
Ural Federal University, Yekaterinburg, Russia
1 shared publication - Igor V. Krasavin1 shared publication
Ural Federal University
1 shared publicationUral Federal University named after first President of Russia B. N. Yeltsin
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Non Profit Partnership Polis (Political Studies) in Полис. Политические исследования
- Vol. 1 (1) , 39-53
Politicization of social ontology and its paradoxes
The article reveals the historical and theoretical prerequisites for the ontological turn in political theory and the establishment of postfoundationalism, and develops a critical analysis of its inherent paradoxes and difficulties. The ontological turn in political theory became widely known in the first decades of the 21st century. The article argues that postfoundationalism represents a reaction to the dominance of foundationalism in the social sciences, according to which politics is reduced to a subsystem of society, and the ontology of politics is reduced to the regional field of social ontology. The need to overcome foundationalism and its consequences is determined by the formation of a postfoundational political ontology of society. The latter accepts as the main principle of interpretation the position about the contingency of the foundation of society and politics and, as a consequence, about the politicization of social ontology. It is shown that an attempt to shift the meaning of political ontology encounters some difficulties. Firstly, postfoundationalism, which posits the contingency of the foundation of society and politics, falls into contradiction and reveals its dependenceon foundationalism. Secondly, the provision of contingency does not entail ethical-normative principles prescribing specific forms of politics. Thirdly, postfoundationalism entails the loss of prospects for individual positions and projects of people, the possibility of their connection with strategic issues of social development. The general thesis of the article is that renewal ontology in postfoundationalism requires historicizing the interpretation of the social and political, turning to the institutional and normative mechanisms of both the representation and the formation of political subjectivity. The argumentation of this thesis is carried out in three stages, which predetermined the structure of the article. The first part discusses the ontological turn in political theory and the motives for constructing postfoundationalism. The second part substantiates the basic principles of postfoundational political ontology. The third part explains the paradoxes of postfoundationalism and analyses their consequences.
- 29 January 2025
- Published by Non Profit Partnership Polis (Political Studies) in Полис. Политические исследования
- Vol. 1 (1) , 39-53
Politicization of social ontology and its paradoxes
The article reveals the historical and theoretical prerequisites for the ontological turn in political theory and the establishment of postfoundationalism, and develops a critical analysis of its inherent paradoxes and difficulties. The ontological turn in political theory became widely known in the first decades of the 21st century. The article argues that postfoundationalism represents a reaction to the dominance of foundationalism in the social sciences, according to which politics is reduced to a subsystem of society, and the ontology of politics is reduced to the regional field of social ontology. The need to overcome foundationalism and its consequences is determined by the formation of a postfoundational political ontology of society. The latter accepts as the main principle of interpretation the position about the contingency of the foundation of society and politics and, as a consequence, about the politicization of social ontology. It is shown that an attempt to shift the meaning of political ontology encounters some difficulties. Firstly, postfoundationalism, which posits the contingency of the foundation of society and politics, falls into contradiction and reveals its dependenceon foundationalism. Secondly, the provision of contingency does not entail ethical-normative principles prescribing specific forms of politics. Thirdly, postfoundationalism entails the loss of prospects for individual positions and projects of people, the possibility of their connection with strategic issues of social development. The general thesis of the article is that renewal ontology in postfoundationalism requires historicizing the interpretation of the social and political, turning to the institutional and normative mechanisms of both the representation and the formation of political subjectivity. The argumentation of this thesis is carried out in three stages, which predetermined the structure of the article. The first part discusses the ontological turn in political theory and the motives for constructing postfoundationalism. The second part substantiates the basic principles of postfoundational political ontology. The third part explains the paradoxes of postfoundationalism and analyses their consequences.
- Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Liberal Arts University in Bulletin of Liberal Arts University
- Vol. 12 (2) , 108-119
Complexity – General, Limited and Organized: Problem, Methodology and Basic Concepts
This paper will provide an overview of the problem of complexity, highlight the main phenomena and propose concepts that describe it. We shall present the essence of the problem of complexity, which consists in the ambiguity of the relations of the singular and the multiple, the external and the internal, the subject and the object. For this purpose, methodological principles of complexity are emphasized: the distinction between general and limited complexity; critical modeling of complexity relations. Then the signs of complexity are indicated: heterogeneity, exteriority, emergence, evolutionary nature, mimeticity. Complex relationships correspond to those phenomena that are accepted as a fact, but are not fully explained deterministically. It will be shown why, despite the high interest in the problem, a general theory of complexity has not been created and how this is ontologically related to the definition of the problem itself.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Liberal Arts University in Bulletin of Liberal Arts University
- Vol. 12 (2) , 108-119
Open AccessComplexity – General, Limited and Organized: Problem, Methodology and Basic Concepts
This paper will provide an overview of the problem of complexity, highlight the main phenomena and propose concepts that describe it. We shall present the essence of the problem of complexity, which consists in the ambiguity of the relations of the singular and the multiple, the external and the internal, the subject and the object. For this purpose, methodological principles of complexity are emphasized: the distinction between general and limited complexity; critical modeling of complexity relations. Then the signs of complexity are indicated: heterogeneity, exteriority, emergence, evolutionary nature, mimeticity. Complex relationships correspond to those phenomena that are accepted as a fact, but are not fully explained deterministically. It will be shown why, despite the high interest in the problem, a general theory of complexity has not been created and how this is ontologically related to the definition of the problem itself.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Irkutsk State University in The Bulletin of Irkutsk State University. Series Political Science and Religion Studies
- Vol. 50, 26-39
The Moral City: The Return of the Political
The concept of the post-political in social sciences is used as a critical tool to describe the form of neutralization of the distinction between politics and the political and the processes of depoliticization associated with it. Depoliticization processes displace the political from public space and integrate it into techno-managerial structures and mechanisms. The article explores the dynamics of depoliticization, the contours and characteristics of the supposed “retreat of the political,” and the modalities and possibilities for the emerging “return of the political”. The main idea of the article is that the idea of the “moral city” reveals a number of new ways of re-centring the political and the conditions for preventing the risks of post-politicization under the sign of mutual respect, equality and solidarity. Thus, the new forms of coexistence are opening up. This idea is argued in three parts of the article. The first part examines the concept of the post-political city as a space of technomanagerial dispositifs, devoid of specific political demands. The second part reveals conceptual approaches to the description of the moral city, and the third part provides examples of recommendations for organizing interactions between significant actors in the moral city.
- 1 January 2024
- Published by Irkutsk State University in The Bulletin of Irkutsk State University. Series Political Science and Religion Studies
- Vol. 50, 26-39
The Moral City: The Return of the Political
The concept of the post-political in social sciences is used as a critical tool to describe the form of neutralization of the distinction between politics and the political and the processes of depoliticization associated with it. Depoliticization processes displace the political from public space and integrate it into techno-managerial structures and mechanisms. The article explores the dynamics of depoliticization, the contours and characteristics of the supposed “retreat of the political,” and the modalities and possibilities for the emerging “return of the political”. The main idea of the article is that the idea of the “moral city” reveals a number of new ways of re-centring the political and the conditions for preventing the risks of post-politicization under the sign of mutual respect, equality and solidarity. Thus, the new forms of coexistence are opening up. This idea is argued in three parts of the article. The first part examines the concept of the post-political city as a space of technomanagerial dispositifs, devoid of specific political demands. The second part reveals conceptual approaches to the description of the moral city, and the third part provides examples of recommendations for organizing interactions between significant actors in the moral city.
- Open Access
- 30 June 2023
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Philosophy. Journal of the Higher School of Economics
- Vol. 7 (2) , 60-85
Упорство критики и тупики посткритики
Изменение критической практики в гуманитарных науках в начале XXI в. можно содержательно охарактеризовать как «посткритический поворот», который во всем своем многообразии и напряженности реализуется на пересечении двух процессов. С одной стороны, это процесс истощения традиционной критики, погруженной в герменевтику подозрения, т.е. в идеологический и симптоматический способ разоблачения, трансформировавшийся со временем в параноидальный релятивизм. С другой стороны, формирование диспозитива постистины, который обесценивает истину как критерий и средство коммуникации и тем самым растворяет критику в скептическом фанатизме, релятивизме и даже нигилизме. В статье раскрываются теоретические предпосылки и мотивы «посткритического поворота» в гуманитарных науках, основные принципы посткритики, трудности, с которыми она сталкивается в процессе обновления традиционной критики. Общий аргумент статьи состоит в том, что, несмотря на некоторые обоснованные заявления посткритики, призывами к позитивности и примирению она рискует исключить критические точки зрения, так же как лиминальные и радикальные способы политизации вещей. В свете современной проблематизации истины, фактичности и объективности отношение между критикой и посткритикой следует воспринимать не через противопоставление негативности и позитивности, а скорее через взаимодействие, диалог методологий. Посткритика в этом контексте будет означать дифференциацию и плюрализацию критики, выработку путей взаимодействия множественных форм критики. Статья начинается с определения теоретических предпосылок и мотивов истощения критики. Во второй части статьи проясняется посткритическая идея обновления критики. Наконец, в заключительной части рассматриваются трудности, с которыми сталкивается посткритика и которые серьезно осложняют предпринятую ею попытку обновления критики.
- 30 June 2023
- Published by National Research University, Higher School of Economics (HSE) in Philosophy. Journal of the Higher School of Economics
- Vol. 7 (2) , 60-85
Open AccessУпорство критики и тупики посткритики
Изменение критической практики в гуманитарных науках в начале XXI в. можно содержательно охарактеризовать как «посткритический поворот», который во всем своем многообразии и напряженности реализуется на пересечении двух процессов. С одной стороны, это процесс истощения традиционной критики, погруженной в герменевтику подозрения, т.е. в идеологический и симптоматический способ разоблачения, трансформировавшийся со временем в параноидальный релятивизм. С другой стороны, формирование диспозитива постистины, который обесценивает истину как критерий и средство коммуникации и тем самым растворяет критику в скептическом фанатизме, релятивизме и даже нигилизме. В статье раскрываются теоретические предпосылки и мотивы «посткритического поворота» в гуманитарных науках, основные принципы посткритики, трудности, с которыми она сталкивается в процессе обновления традиционной критики. Общий аргумент статьи состоит в том, что, несмотря на некоторые обоснованные заявления посткритики, призывами к позитивности и примирению она рискует исключить критические точки зрения, так же как лиминальные и радикальные способы политизации вещей. В свете современной проблематизации истины, фактичности и объективности отношение между критикой и посткритикой следует воспринимать не через противопоставление негативности и позитивности, а скорее через взаимодействие, диалог методологий. Посткритика в этом контексте будет означать дифференциацию и плюрализацию критики, выработку путей взаимодействия множественных форм критики. Статья начинается с определения теоретических предпосылок и мотивов истощения критики. Во второй части статьи проясняется посткритическая идея обновления критики. Наконец, в заключительной части рассматриваются трудности, с которыми сталкивается посткритика и которые серьезно осложняют предпринятую ею попытку обновления критики.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Ural Federal University in Koinon
- Vol. 1 (1-2) , 46-61
Koinon: Being-in-common, Heterology, Post-fundamentalism
The problem of being-in-common remains a fundamental problem of philosophy, social sciences and humanities. The purpose of this article is to analyze the changes in the nature of this problem, the incentives and prospects for its formulation and solution in the late XX — early XXI centuries. Being-incommon is increasingly shifting to the focus of human existence, acquires a decisive existential significance, acts as public opinion, and as a political motivation, and as a paradigm for the social sciences and humanities. The article argues that full awareness of the role of philosophy in describing and explaining the forms of being-in-common presupposes the need for a radical reorientation of both traditional philosophical constructions and the methodology of social and humanitarian cognition. Three dimensions of this reorientation are highlighted. Firstly, this is the “new sociality”, the undecidability between “globalization” and “mondialization”, as well as the need to deconstruct the very possibility of accepting a global or phenomenal world. Secondly, it is ontoheterology, which outlines the ways of overcoming ontological fundamentalism, building an “ontology after ontotheology”. It exposes the understanding of being-in-common, the original sociality as groundless, anarchic, which arises as a direct correlate of the experience of groundlessness of existence, unrooted in any substance or common essence. Thirdly, this is postfundamentalism as a particular paradigm, style of thinking, postulating the transformation of the practices and techniques of thinking in response to the need to reposition the multiple real as immanent in thought itself. The article concludes that the three-dimensional “space” of comprehending being-in-common sets a certain direction of philosophical and socio-humanitarian research, hidden behind them general methodological tendencies, and the relationship of these tendencies with the nature of social practice.
- 1 January 2020
- Published by Ural Federal University in Koinon
- Vol. 1 (1-2) , 46-61
Koinon: Being-in-common, Heterology, Post-fundamentalism
The problem of being-in-common remains a fundamental problem of philosophy, social sciences and humanities. The purpose of this article is to analyze the changes in the nature of this problem, the incentives and prospects for its formulation and solution in the late XX — early XXI centuries. Being-incommon is increasingly shifting to the focus of human existence, acquires a decisive existential significance, acts as public opinion, and as a political motivation, and as a paradigm for the social sciences and humanities. The article argues that full awareness of the role of philosophy in describing and explaining the forms of being-in-common presupposes the need for a radical reorientation of both traditional philosophical constructions and the methodology of social and humanitarian cognition. Three dimensions of this reorientation are highlighted. Firstly, this is the “new sociality”, the undecidability between “globalization” and “mondialization”, as well as the need to deconstruct the very possibility of accepting a global or phenomenal world. Secondly, it is ontoheterology, which outlines the ways of overcoming ontological fundamentalism, building an “ontology after ontotheology”. It exposes the understanding of being-in-common, the original sociality as groundless, anarchic, which arises as a direct correlate of the experience of groundlessness of existence, unrooted in any substance or common essence. Thirdly, this is postfundamentalism as a particular paradigm, style of thinking, postulating the transformation of the practices and techniques of thinking in response to the need to reposition the multiple real as immanent in thought itself. The article concludes that the three-dimensional “space” of comprehending being-in-common sets a certain direction of philosophical and socio-humanitarian research, hidden behind them general methodological tendencies, and the relationship of these tendencies with the nature of social practice.