SBShilpi Bhunia

Shilpi Bhunia

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Shilpi Bhunia has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Multiple shocks generated by the 2024 May 14 coronal mass ejection

    by Mohamed Nedal, Catherine Cuddy, David M. Long, Shilpi Bhunia, Pietro Zucca, Peter T. Gallagher

    Context. A series of powerful solar flares and coronal mass ejections (CMEs) occurred between 10 and 14 May 2024. As these eruptions propagated through the corona, they generated multiple solar type II radio bursts, indicating the presence of shock waves. Aims. This study characterises a series of type II radio bursts associated with a CME that occurred on 14 May, focusing on the coronal conditions during the event and identifying the likely location of the shocks where the radio bursts are generated. Methods. The CME was tracked using a combination of white light and extreme ultraviolet observations of the solar corona taken by three instruments: the Geostationary Operational Environmental Satellite (GOES) Solar Ultraviolet Imager (SUVI) and two coronagraphs of the Solar and Heliospheric Observatory (SOHO) Large Angle and Spectrometric Coronagraph (LASCO), together with ground-based radio observations between 10−240 MHz from the Irish Low–Frequency Array (I−LOFAR). The radial distances of the radio sources were examined using a series of density models, with both potential field source surface and magnetohydrodynamic models used to examine the coronal plasma conditions. Results. Four type II bursts were identified in the I−LOFAR radio dynamic spectrum over ∼15 minutes, exhibiting features such as band splitting, herringbones, and fragmentation. The shocks were found to have speeds ranging between ∼443−2075 km s −1 , with drift rates of ∼−361 to −78 kHz s −1 . The shocks were found to have a M A ≈ 3.21 − 3.57. indicating that they were super–Alfvénic. The first type II burst was triggered ∼18 minutes after the CME launch, with each burst appearing to have been generated at a different height in the corona. Analysis of the derived kinematics and modelling results suggests that the type II bursts were likely produced at the shoulders of the CME near the flanks, where open magnetic field lines and relatively low Alfvén speeds facilitated shock formation. Conclusions. This multi-instrument study shows that multiple type II bursts from a single CME originated at different coronal heights, with modelling indicating their generation near the CME flanks where low Alfvén speeds and open magnetic field lines facilitated shock formation. The findings highlight the role of coronal conditions, particularly the magnetic field configuration and the Alfvén speed distribution, in determining the heights and locations where these bursts originate. Our results reinforce the importance of continuous, multi-wavelength observations for understanding shock dynamics and improving constraints on coronal models.


  • Open Access

    Electron beam propagation and radio-wave scattering in the inner heliosphere using five spacecraft

    by L. A. Cañizares, S. T. Badman, N. Chrysaphi, S. Bhunia, B. Sánchez-Cano, S. A. Maloney, P. T. Gallagher

    Context. Solar energetic particles such as electrons can be accelerated to mildly relativistic velocities in the solar corona. These electrons travel through the turbulent corona, generating radio waves, which are then severely affected by scattering. Aims. The physical interpretation of the discrepancies between the actual and observed radio sources is still subject to debate. We used radio emission observed by an unprecedented total of five spacecraft to track the path of radio sources from the low corona to the inner heliosphere (15–75 R⊙ or 0.07–0.35 au generated during a solar event on 4 December 2021. Methods. We used the Bayesian multilateration technique known as BELLA to track the apparent path of radio sources observed by Parker Solar Probe, STEREO A, Wind, Solar Orbiter, and Mars Express. To validate the accuracy of the tracked path, we used Nançay Radioheliograph interferometric imaging at 150 MHz, which was found to agree with the estimated footpoints predicted by BELLA. We further validated our results using ACE in situ measurements. Results. We find that the apparent radio sources followed the path of an Archimedean Parker spiral, with an associated solar wind velocity of approximately 493 km s−1 (consistent with the corresponding speed observed at 1 au at the relevant longitude), and connected to the solar surface at 75° longitude east. Finally, we made quantitative estimates of the scattering of radio waves, which we found to be in good agreement with contemporary models of scattering in which the radio waves primarily propagate along the local Parker spiral. Conclusions. This work shows conclusive evidence that the cause of the widely observed ‘higher-than-expected’ electron densities at interplanetary distances is due to radio-wave scattering, and provides a more detailed understanding of the propagation of radio waves emitted near the local plasma frequency in turbulent astrophysical plasmas.


  • Open Access

    Bursty acceleration and 3D trajectories of electrons in a solar flare

    by Shilpi Bhunia, Laura A. Hayes, Karl Ludwig Klein, Nicole Vilmer, Shane A. Maloney, Peter T. Gallagher

    Context. During a solar flare, electrons are accelerated to non-thermal energies as a result of magnetic reconnection. These electrons then propagate upwards and downwards from the energy release site along magnetic field lines and produce radio and X-ray emission. Aims. On 11 November 2022, an M5.1 solar flare was observed by the Spectrometer/Telescope for Imaging X-rays (STIX) on board Solar Orbiter together with various ground- and space-based radio instruments. The flare was associated with several fine hard X-ray (HXR) structures and a complex set of metric radio bursts (type III, J, and narrowband). By studying the evolution of X-ray, extreme ultraviolet, and radio sources, we aim to study the trajectories of the flare-accelerated electrons in the lower solar atmosphere and low corona. Methods. We used observations from the STIX on board Solar Orbiter to study the evolution of X-ray sources. Using radio imaging from the Nançay Radio heliograph (NRH) and the Newkirk density model, we constructed 3D trajectories of 14 radio bursts. Results. Imaging of the HXR fine structures shows several sources at different times. The STIX and NRH imaging shows correlated changes in the location of the HXR and radio source at the highest frequency during the most intense impulsive period. Imaging and 3D trajectories of all the bursts show that electrons are getting accelerated at different locations and along several distinct field lines. Some of the trajectories from the same origin show expansion on the order of 4 over a height of ∼110 Mm. The longitude and latitude extent of the trajectories are ∼30″ and ∼152″. Conclusions. We find that the electrons producing HXR and radio emission have similar acceleration origins. Importantly, our study supports the scenario that the flare acceleration process is temporally and spatially fragmentary, and during each of these small-scale processes, the electron beams are injected into a very fibrous environment and produce complex HXR and radio emission.


  • Open Access

    Bursty acceleration and 3D trajectories of electrons in a solar flare

    by Shilpi Bhunia, Laura A. Hayes, Karl Ludwig Klein, Nicole Vilmer, Shane A. Maloney, Peter T. Gallagher

    During a solar flare, electrons are accelerated to non-thermal energies as a result of magnetic reconnection. These electrons then propagate upwards and downwards from the energy release site along magnetic field lines and produce radio and X-ray emission. On 11 November 2022, an M5.1 solar flare was observed by the Spectrometer/Telescope for Imaging X-rays (STIX) on board Solar Orbiter together with various ground- and space-based radio instruments. The flare was associated with several fine hard X-ray (HXR) structures and a complex set of metric radio bursts (type III, J, and narrowband). By studying the evolution of X-ray, extreme ultraviolet, and radio sources, we aim to study the trajectories of the flare-accelerated electrons in the lower solar atmosphere and low corona. We used observations from the STIX on board Solar Orbiter to study the evolution of X-ray sources. Using radio imaging from the Nançay Radio heliograph (NRH) and the Newkirk density model, we constructed 3D trajectories of 14 radio bursts. Imaging of the HXR fine structures shows several sources at different times. The STIX and NRH imaging shows correlated changes in the location of the HXR and radio source at the highest frequency during the most intense impulsive period. Imaging and 3D trajectories of all the bursts show that electrons are getting accelerated at different locations and along several distinct field lines. The longitude and latitude extent of the trajectories are ~30 arcsec and ~ 152 arcsec. We find that the electrons producing HXR and radio emission have similar acceleration origins. Importantly, our study supports the scenario that the flare acceleration process is temporally and spatially fragmentary, and during each of these small-scale processes, the electron beams are injected into a very fibrous environment and produce complex HXR and radio emission.

  • Open Access

    Electron Beam Propagation and Radio-Wave Scattering in the Inner Heliosphere using Five Spacecraft

    by Luis Alberto Cañizares, Sam T. Badman, Nicolina Chrysaphi, Shilpi Bhunia, Beatriz Sánchez-Cano, Shane A. Maloney, Peter T. Gallagher

    Solar energetic particles such as electrons can be accelerated to mildly-relativistic velocities in the solar corona. These electrons travel through the turbulent corona generating radio waves, which are then severely affected by scattering. The physical interpretation of the discrepancies between the actual and observed radio sources is still subject to debate. Here, we use radio emission observed by an unprecedented total of five spacecraft, to track the path of radio sources from the low corona to the inner heliosphere (15-75 R$_{\odot}$) generated during a solar event on 4 December 2021. In this study we use the Bayesian multilateration technique known as BELLA to track the apparent path of radio sources observed by Parker Solar Probe, STEREO A, Wind, Solar Orbiter and Mars Express. To validate the accuracy of the tracked path, we used Nançay Radioheliograph interferometric imaging at 150 MHz, which was found to agree with the estimated footpoints predicted by BELLA. We also further validated our results using ACE in-situ measurements. We found that the apparent radio sources followed the path of a Parker Spiral, with an associated solar wind velocity of approximately 493 km s-1 (consistent with the corresponding speed observed at 1 au at the relevant longitude) and connected to 75$^\circ$ longitude East at the solar surface. Finally, we made quantitative estimates of the scattering of radio waves that were found to be in good agreement with contemporary models of scattering. This work shows conclusive evidence that the disputed cause of the widely observed `higher than expected' electron densities at interplanetary distances is due to radio wave scattering, and provides a more detailed understanding of the propagation of radio waves emitted near the local plasma frequency in turbulent plasmas.

  • Open Access

    Localising Signatures of Particle Acceleration During Solar Flare in Low Solar Atmosphere Using Combined EUV, X-ray and Radio Observations

    by Shilpi Bhunia, Laura Hayes, Karl Ludwig Klein, Peter T. Gallgaher, Shane Maloney, Nicole Vilmer

    It is well known that flare-accelerated electrons can produce hard X-ray (HXR) emission and Type-III radio bursts. The HXR emission is produced by the accelerated electrons propagating towards the chromosphere where they deposit their energy. In contrast, Type-III radio bursts are produced by the accelerated electron beams traveling toward the outer solar atmosphere. Hence a temporal correlation between these two kinds of emission may imply a common origin of the accelerated electrons providing insight into the acceleration process, and allowing us to connect electrons at the Sun to those in the heliosphere On 2022-Nov-11 11:30 - 12:00 UT, the Spectrometer Telescope for Imaging X-rays (STIX) on Solar Orbiter observed a highly energetic flare event with an excellent time resolution of 0.5 s. Simultaneously there were observations of multiple coronal and interplanetary Type-III radio bursts from several instruments such as WIND/WAVES, I-LOFAR, and ORFEES spanning the frequency range from 1 - 1000 MHz.We find an excellent temporal correlation between the X-ray and radio time series. We do multiwavelength imaging analysis using AIA, STIX, and NRH to locate the acceleration origin and track the electron beams during the eruption.

  • Open Access

    Erratum: “Robust Absolute Solar Flux Density Calibration for the Murchison Widefield Array” (2022, ApJ, 927, 17)

    by Devojyoti Kansabanik, Surajit Mondal, Divya Oberoi, Ayan Biswas, Shilpi Bhunia

  • Open Access

    Detailed look at the temporal correlation between hard X-ray flare and type III radio bursts

    by Shilpi Bhunia, Laura Hayes, Shane Maloney, Peter Gallagher

    It is well known that flare-accelerated electrons can produce both hard X-ray (HXR) emission and Type-III radio bursts. The HXR emission is produced by the accelerated electrons propagating towards the chromosphere where they deposit their energy while Type-III radio bursts are produced by the accelerated electron beams traveling towards the outer solar atmosphere. Hence a temporal correlation between these two kinds of emission may imply a common origin of the accelerated electrons providing insight into the acceleration process, and allows us to connect electrons at the Sun to those in the heliosphere. On 2022-Nov-11 11:30 - 12:00 UT, the Spectrometer Telescope for Imaging X-rays (STIX) on Solar Orbiter observed a highly energetic flare event with an excellent time resolution of 0.5 s. Simultaneously there were observations of multiple coronal and interplanetary Type-III radio bursts from several instruments such as I-LOFAR, WIND/WAVES, NDA and ORFEES. I-LOFAR provides high-sensitivity imaging spectroscopy in the range of ~10-240 MHz with a time resolution of 1.31 ms and a frequency resolution of 195 kHz. We examine the temporal correlation between the X-ray and radio time series and discuss the relationship between the two and what it implies about the origin of the electron populations producing these two kinds of radiation.

  • Open Access

    Imaging-spectroscopy of a band-split type II solar radio burst with the Murchison Widefield Array

    by Shilpi Bhunia, Eoin P. Carley, Divya Oberoi, Peter T. Gallagher

    Type II solar radio bursts are caused by magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) shocks driven by solar eruptive events such as coronal mass ejections (CMEs). Often, both fundamental and harmonic bands of type II bursts are split into sub-bands, which are generally believed to be coming from upstream and downstream regions of the shock; however, this explanation remains unconfirmed. Here, we present combined results from imaging analyses of type II radio burst band splitting and other fine structures observed by the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) and extreme ultraviolet observations from Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO)/Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) on 28 September 2014. The MWA provides imaging-spectroscopy in the range 80−300 MHz with a time resolution of 0.5 s and frequency resolution of 40 kHz. Our analysis shows that the burst was caused by a piston-driven shock with a driver speed of ∼112 km s−1 and shock speed of ∼580 km s−1. We provide rare evidence that band splitting is caused by emission from multiple parts of the shock (as opposed to the upstream–downstream hypothesis). We also examine the small-scale motion of type II fine structure radio sources in MWA images, and suggest that this motion may arise because of radio propagation effects from coronal turbulence, and is not due to the physical motion of the shock location. We present a novel technique that uses imaging spectroscopy to directly determine the effective length scale of turbulent density perturbations, which is found to be 1−2 Mm. The study of the systematic and small-scale motion of fine structures may therefore provide a measure of turbulence in different regions of the shock and corona.


  • Open Access

    Robust Absolute Solar Flux Density Calibration for the Murchison Widefield Array

    by Devojyoti Kansabanik, Surajit Mondal, Divya Oberoi, Ayan Biswas, Shilpi Bhunia

    Sensitive radio instruments are optimized for observing faint astronomical sources, and usually need to attenuate the received signal when observing the Sun. There are only a handful of flux density calibrators that can comfortably be observed with the same attenuation setup as the Sun. Additionally, for wide field-of-view (FoV) instruments like the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) calibrator observations are generally done when the Sun is below the horizon, to avoid the contamination from solar emissions. These considerations imply that the usual radio interferometric approach to flux density calibration is not applicable for solar imaging. A novel technique, relying on a good sky model and detailed characterization of the MWA hardware, was developed for solar flux density calibration for MWA. Though successful, this technique is not general enough to be extended to the data from the extended configuration of the MWA Phase II. Here, we present a robust flux density calibration method for solar observations with MWA independent of the array configuration. We use different approaches—the serendipitous presence of strong sources; detection of numerous background sources using high dynamic range images in the FoV along with the Sun; and observations of strong flux density calibrators with and without the additional attenuation used for solar observations—to obtain the flux scaling parameters required for the flux density calibration. Using the present method, we have achieved an absolute flux density uncertainty ∼10% for solar observations even in the absence of dedicated calibrator observations.