DZDanhua Zhou

Danhua Zhou

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Danhua Zhou has a total of 13 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    What is Effective Teaching of Scientific Thinking: Meta-Analysis Based on Research on Science Curriculum Reform Over the Past 25 Years

    by Danhua Zhou, Lihui Sun

    Over the past quarter-century of science curriculum reform, the goal of cultivating students’ scientific thinking has gained significant prominence. This study aims to elucidate the essence of science curriculum reform and to explore the effectiveness and boundary conditions of scientific thinking teaching. First, it reviewed the historical evolution of scientific thinking as a central curricular objective. Second, drawing on the “transformative” perspective of the Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) framework, it constructed a teaching design model to deconstruct the teaching structure oriented toward developing students’ scientific thinking. This model established a basis for investigating effective boundary conditions across five dimensions: Scientific Teaching Strategies, Support for Learning Design, Style of Classroom Interaction, Categories of Scientific Knowledge, and Level of Technical Interaction. Third, through a meta-analysis of 98 studies involving 13,538 K-12 students, 103 effect sizes were synthesized. The overall effect analysis revealed a statistically significant positive impact of scientific thinking teaching (Hedges’ g = 0.784). Finally, subgroup analyses identified key effective boundary conditions: student engagement in inquiry-based practical activities and experiential perception as the core of scientific thinking instruction; technology serving as an interactive “environment” that facilitates the generation of scientific thinking; interdisciplinary thematic integration as a mainstream form of science knowledge organization; student-centered teaching as a holistic, life-relevant activity; and shared teacher–student guidance coupled with participatory learning support to foster scientific thinking better. This study offers preliminary practical insights and research suggestions for educators and practitioners in the field.


  • K‐12 teachers' programming attitudes among different disciplines: Analysis of influential factors

    by Lihui Sun, Danhua Zhou

    Background: Integrating programming in K‐12 curriculum has become a global consensus. Teachers are central figures in programming instruction. But the majority of current research focuses on teachers' external teaching behaviours and less on teachers' attitudes towards programming.Objectives: The purpose of this study is to validate the K‐12 in‐service Teacher Programming Attitudes Scale (TPAS), to analyse teachers' programming attitudes and their differences in personal, teaching, and environmental factors, and further explore the predictive relationship.Methods: The sample is 888 K‐12 teachers from China. First, exploratory factor analysis (EFA) and confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) were adopted to validate the availability and reliability of TPAS; Second, independent sample t‐test and one‐way Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) were adopted to explain the differences. Finally, correlation analysis and linear regression analysis were adopted to verify the correlation and prediction relationship.Results and Conclusion: TPAS possess good reliability and validity (χ2/df = 2.488, RMSEA = 0.055, CFI = 0.943, TLI = 0.935, and IFI = 0.943). Further analysis found that, first of all, male teachers possess more positive programming attitudes than female teachers; second, young teachers who are under 30 and the length of teaching under 5 years possess more positive programming attitudes; thirdly, in addition to Information and Communication Technology teachers, primary science teachers also possess high programming attitudes, followed by teachers of Humanities and Arts, reflecting the potential of teaching programming in integrated subjects and the humanities. Finally, primary school teachers possess the best programming attitudes. With the growth of grade, teachers' enthusiasm for programming has gradually decreased. Additionally, discipline, grade and gender factors were considered to predict K‐12 teachers' programming attitudes.Implications: The results of this study contribute to integrating programming teaching of teachers and promoting programming education in K‐12 classrooms.


  • “Learn to Argue” and “Argue to Learn”: meta-analysis of effective instructional design for online scientific argumentation activities

    by Danhua Zhou

    Online scientific argumentation activities have significant value for students’ cognitive ability. The purpose of this study was to solve the issues of online scientific argumentation. Firstly, the influences of online scientific argumentation were classified into “Learn to Argue” and “Argue to Learn” abilities. And then the technological empowerment scientific argumentation teaching model was constructed. Second, a total of 5415 students’ data from 46 studies were captured. It is proved that online argumentation activities have an upper-middle positive effect on students’ “Learn to Argue” (Hedges’ g = 0.603, P = 0.000) and “Argue to Learn” (Hedges’ g = 0.596, P = 0.000) abilities. Finally, the results of moderator analysis showed that the natural science issues have the greatest effect. Compared with higher education, online scientific argumentation is of greater value in K-12 classroom. Moreover, the CRE framework has been proved to have greater application potential. Virtual reality game platform and game based learning can more effectively promote students’ “Learn to Argue” and “Argue to Learn” abilities. Besides, intelligent evaluation based on machine learning has been proved to be a significant way to evaluate students’ argumentation abilities. Based on this, this study made discussion to provide valuable reference for practitioners and researchers.


  • Measuring development of young students’ coding ability through a graphical teaching intervention: further explanation of the effect of coding experience and coding interest

    by Lihui Sun, Zhen Guo, Danhua Zhou

    Coding ability has become an essential digital skill for young children. The graphical programming environment is valuable carrier for cultivating children’s coding ability. The purpose of this study is to develop a coding ability test for children, to conduct a graphic coding intervention, and to further explore the impact of multiple factors on children’s coding ability in ScratchJr intervention. First, the coding ability test for ScratchJr environment was developed based on Item Response Theory to measure kindergarten students’ coding ability. The result showed that there are good reliability, content, and structural validity of the test question. Secondly, we conducted a 12-week ScratchJr coding activity teaching experiment on 162 kindergarten students. The analysis of the treated group and the control group showed that coding activity teaching can effectively improve the students’ coding ability. Finally, this study analyzed the differences in children’s coding ability in coding interest, and coding experience. The results showed that the coding ability was affected by coding experience and coding interest. More interestingly, it was found partial mediation effect among coding ability, coding experience and coding interest. Moreover, ScratchJr coding intervention can influence the direct effect of coding experience on coding ability by improving children’s coding interest.


  • Analysis of Physics Textbook Content

    by Xiaomei Yan, Yuze He, Jingying Wang, Xiying Li, Xiaomei Ping, Danhua Zhou

    The content of physics textbooks has always been an important part of physics education research. This chapter systematically reviewed the empirical studies on the contents of physics textbooks from the 1940s to 2022. The brief history and development of research was outlined, and representative research was identified. This chapter reviewed the contents from conceptual, epistemic and cultural levels and the representations of contents in physics textbooks. This chapter also investigates how different content analysis methods contribute to the issues of physics textbooks within the science education community from the methodology perspective. The findings show the researchers' continuous efforts on improving the validity of concepts and readability of texts, growing attentions on nature of science, argumentation and equal issues of hot topics in science educational research. The implications for future research are provided, including the use of new technologies to examine the content of physics textbooks.

  • Effective instruction conditions for educational robotics to develop programming ability of K‐12 students: A meta‐analysis

    by Lihui Sun, Danhua Zhou

    Background: As one of the mainstream forms of programming education, educational robotics (ER) have been a crucial way to develop K‐12 students' programming ability.Objectives: The purpose of this study is to clarify the content of programming ability, to verify the effectiveness of ER as a teaching method to improve students' programming abilities and the conditions for more effective instructional design.Methods: The method of meta‐analysis was adopted to conduct this study. 4180 K‐12 students from 36 studies with a total of 85 effect sizes were captured. Based on the contents of included literature, an ER programming ability model was put forward, which was composed of essential ability and generative ability. The meta‐analysis of essential ability (N = 22) and generative ability (N = 64) was carried out respectively.Results and conclusion: The results showed that ER activity has a positive effect on the essential ability (Hedges' g = 0.539 CI [0.327, 0.752], p < 0.001) and generative ability (Hedges' g = 0.535 CI [0.426, 0.643], p < 0.001). Additionally, the results of moderator analysis showed that utilizing ER to solve mathematics problems is able to more effectively develop students' essential ability, while the STEM interdisciplinary ER instruction had the largest effect on generative ability. Simultaneously, the individual programming form is conducive to students' essential ability, while the generative ability is significantly affected by the cooperative programming form. No matter for the evaluation of essential ability or generative ability, ER had the greatest effect on kindergarten children' programming ability. Moreover, the intervention duration ranging from 1 to 5 weeks, the samples size less than 50 and the choice of measurement scale can effectively improve students' programming ability.Implications: This research enriched the theoretical basis of programming ability, and provided reference and guidance for K‐12 programming teaching practitioners and researchers in ER teaching design and practise.


  • Evaluation and developmental suggestions on undergraduates’ computational thinking: a theoretical framework guided by Marzano’s new taxonomy

    by Lihui Sun, Linlin Hu, Danhua Zhou, Weipeng Yang

    As a core competence in 21st century, computational thinking (CT) is of great significance for undergraduates. However, there are few researches on the CT evaluation about undergraduates, and nor do a theoretical framework. Additionally, it is not clear what factors may affect their CT development. Therefore, according to Marzano's new taxonomy of educational objectives, this study constructed a theoretical framework for the CT evaluation, which included the field of the CT knowledge and the CT system. Then a Computational thinking scale (CTS) among 737 undergraduates was verified. CTS was adopted to evaluate undergraduates’ CT skills, and the factors that may affect their CT skills are discussed according to the framework. The results showed that: (1) the CTS had sufficient reliability and validity among the sample undergraduates; (2) the CT skills of the sample undergraduates were in the middle and upper level (M = 15.71, SD = 2.18); (3) personal factors (gender and major) and contextual factors (educational environment and school support) are related to undergraduates’ CT skills. Several suggestions and countermeasures were put forward for the undergraduates’ CT cultivation on the framework, which will provide a reference for CT in undergraduate education.