Christopher Paul Donahue
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Christopher Paul Donahue has a total of 43 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Kevin Hammonds
Department of Civil Engineering, Montana State University, Bozeman, MT, USA
17 shared publications - S. McKenzie Skiles
University of Utah
12 shared publications - Evan Schehrer
Department of Civil Engineering, Montana State University, Bozeman, MT, USA
11 shared publications - James W. Dillon
Department of Civil Engineering, Montana State University, Bozeman, MT, USA
11 shared publications Hans-Peter Marshall
Department of Geosciences, Boise State University, Boise, ID, USA
6 shared publications- Ian E. McDowell
Graduate Program of Hydrologic Sciences, University of Nevada, Reno, Reno, NV, USA
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 8 June 2026
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS ES&T Air
- Vol. 3 (7) , 1704-1716
Quantification Error Model for Aerial LiDAR Methane Emission Rate Estimates
- 8 June 2026
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in ACS ES&T Air
- Vol. 3 (7) , 1704-1716
Open AccessQuantification Error Model for Aerial LiDAR Methane Emission Rate Estimates
- Open Access
- 5 May 2026
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 60 (19) , 13968-13979
Aerial LiDAR-Based, Source-Resolved Methane Emissions Inventory: Permian Basin Case Study for Benchmarking U.S. Emissions
Reducing methane emissions can slow near-term warming, yet building accurate inventories to inform mitigation efforts and track progress toward reduction targets remains challenging. We present a 2024 source-resolved methane inventory for the Permian Basin, built from quarterly aerial LiDAR scans. We combined public infrastructure records with machine learning identification of non-producing sites to define the facility population and generate sampling plans and then deployed Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR to scan 51,785 sites across four quarters. Sources were localized within 2 m and attributed to equipment acquired by aerial photography during scans. We detail a Monte Carlo framework that propagates quantification, extrapolation, sampling, and detection sensitivity uncertainty and weights spatial extrapolation by observed equipment counts, avoiding bias from over- or under-sampling of large facilities. The workflow yields a source-resolved inventory down to 0.4 kg/h with quarterly temporal resolution. Total annual basin emissions were 5,133 kt CH4 after adding gathering pipelines and subthreshold emissions from prior studies. Emissions were seasonal, with the winter up to 17% higher than the summer. The basin-wide methane loss rate was 3.13%. Texas emitted 4,038 kt CH4 with a 3.6% loss rate, while New Mexico emitted 1,095 kt CH4 with a 2.1% loss rate. At the operator level, most large operators outperformed the basin average intensity by a wide margin.
- 5 May 2026
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 60 (19) , 13968-13979
Open AccessAerial LiDAR-Based, Source-Resolved Methane Emissions Inventory: Permian Basin Case Study for Benchmarking U.S. Emissions
Reducing methane emissions can slow near-term warming, yet building accurate inventories to inform mitigation efforts and track progress toward reduction targets remains challenging. We present a 2024 source-resolved methane inventory for the Permian Basin, built from quarterly aerial LiDAR scans. We combined public infrastructure records with machine learning identification of non-producing sites to define the facility population and generate sampling plans and then deployed Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR to scan 51,785 sites across four quarters. Sources were localized within 2 m and attributed to equipment acquired by aerial photography during scans. We detail a Monte Carlo framework that propagates quantification, extrapolation, sampling, and detection sensitivity uncertainty and weights spatial extrapolation by observed equipment counts, avoiding bias from over- or under-sampling of large facilities. The workflow yields a source-resolved inventory down to 0.4 kg/h with quarterly temporal resolution. Total annual basin emissions were 5,133 kt CH4 after adding gathering pipelines and subthreshold emissions from prior studies. Emissions were seasonal, with the winter up to 17% higher than the summer. The basin-wide methane loss rate was 3.13%. Texas emitted 4,038 kt CH4 with a 3.6% loss rate, while New Mexico emitted 1,095 kt CH4 with a 2.1% loss rate. At the operator level, most large operators outperformed the basin average intensity by a wide margin.
- Open Access
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Benchmarking Methane Emissions Across Major U.S. Oil and Gas Basins Using Aerial Gas Mapping LiDAR
With increasing accessibility of methane emission monitoring technology and advancements in emission modeling, numerous approaches have been developed to create measurement-based emission inventories. Yet inventories often leave emissions unaccounted for due to limited detection sensitivity, limited temporal sampling, or unscalable spatial deployment. We present a framework for building measurement-based methane inventories using Bridger Photonics Gas Mapping LiDAR (GML), a high-resolution, source-resolved aerial technology with a 90% probability of detection at 1 kg h⁻¹. We apply this framework in 2024 across major U.S. oil and gas basins including the Permian, Bakken, Appalachia, Haynesville, and Denver-Julesburg. The framework produces basin-scale methane inventories, attributed to the facility- and equipment-levels, along with methane intensity benchmarks derived from basin-representative sampling designs. Multiple survey deployments are used to characterize temporal variability and sub-basin results provide operator and supply-chain relevant benchmarks that support prioritization of LDAR campaigns and emissions reporting. Inventory methods integrate 1) the GML quantification error model that accurately accounts for uncertainty and bias of emissions estimates, and 2) the GML probability of detection model that estimates missed emissions in the partial detection region of the sensor (0.4-3 kg/h). We describe how representative sampling plans are constructed using U.S. energy infrastructure databases, and how emissions are extrapolated across heterogeneous facility populations with varying equipment and operational characteristics. In regions where public energy infrastructure data are sparse, operators can provide facility and equipment datasets to support sampling and inventory development, which often yield the highest quality results. Applying a single workflow across basins provides comparable, policy-relevant benchmarks for U.S. methane emissions and intensities. Ongoing work addresses remaining limitations, including diurnal variability and quantification uncertainty driven by regional wind models. The framework is transferable to international basins where comparable infrastructure data are available, enabling transparent, scalable, and globally comparable measurement-based methane inventories.
- 14 March 2026
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessBenchmarking Methane Emissions Across Major U.S. Oil and Gas Basins Using Aerial Gas Mapping LiDAR
With increasing accessibility of methane emission monitoring technology and advancements in emission modeling, numerous approaches have been developed to create measurement-based emission inventories. Yet inventories often leave emissions unaccounted for due to limited detection sensitivity, limited temporal sampling, or unscalable spatial deployment. We present a framework for building measurement-based methane inventories using Bridger Photonics Gas Mapping LiDAR (GML), a high-resolution, source-resolved aerial technology with a 90% probability of detection at 1 kg h⁻¹. We apply this framework in 2024 across major U.S. oil and gas basins including the Permian, Bakken, Appalachia, Haynesville, and Denver-Julesburg. The framework produces basin-scale methane inventories, attributed to the facility- and equipment-levels, along with methane intensity benchmarks derived from basin-representative sampling designs. Multiple survey deployments are used to characterize temporal variability and sub-basin results provide operator and supply-chain relevant benchmarks that support prioritization of LDAR campaigns and emissions reporting. Inventory methods integrate 1) the GML quantification error model that accurately accounts for uncertainty and bias of emissions estimates, and 2) the GML probability of detection model that estimates missed emissions in the partial detection region of the sensor (0.4-3 kg/h). We describe how representative sampling plans are constructed using U.S. energy infrastructure databases, and how emissions are extrapolated across heterogeneous facility populations with varying equipment and operational characteristics. In regions where public energy infrastructure data are sparse, operators can provide facility and equipment datasets to support sampling and inventory development, which often yield the highest quality results. Applying a single workflow across basins provides comparable, policy-relevant benchmarks for U.S. methane emissions and intensities. Ongoing work addresses remaining limitations, including diurnal variability and quantification uncertainty driven by regional wind models. The framework is transferable to international basins where comparable infrastructure data are available, enabling transparent, scalable, and globally comparable measurement-based methane inventories.
- Open Access
- 26 October 2025
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EarthArXiv
Aerial LiDAR Based, Source Resolved Methane Emissions Inventory: Permian Basin Case Study for Benchmarking U.S. Emissions
Reducing methane emissions is one of the quickest ways to slow near-term warming, yet building accurate inventories to track progress towards reduction targets remains challenging. We present a 2024 source-resolved methane inventory for the Permian Basin built from quarterly aerial LiDAR scans that supports benchmarking and provides a scalable framework for operator-level OGMP 2.0 reporting. We combined public infrastructure records with machine learning identification of non-producing sites to define the facility population and generate representative sampling plans, then deployed Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR to scan 51,770 sites across four quarters. Sources were localized to within 2 m and attributed to equipment identified in aerial photography acquired during the scans. The instruments achieved an average 90% probability of detection at 1.16 kg/h under campaign field conditions. We detail a Monte Carlo framework that propagates quantification, extrapolation, sampling, and detection sensitivity uncertainty and weights spatial extrapolation by observed equipment counts, avoiding bias from over or under sampling of large facilities. The workflow yields a facility inventory comprehensive of source-level emission rates down to 0.4 kg/h. After adding gathering pipeline and sub-0.4 kg/h emissions estimates from prior studies, the basin total was 5,133 kt CH₄ (95% CI: 4,070–6,337 kt). Seasonal variation in emissions was observed, with winter up to 17% higher than summer. Non-producing facilities contributed 38% of facility emissions, and tanks (31%) and compressors (28%) dominated equipment-level totals. The basin-wide methane loss rate was 3.13%. Texas emitted 4,038 kt CH₄ with a 3.60% loss rate, while New Mexico emitted 1,095 kt CH₄ with a 2.10% loss rate, placing New Mexico near its 2026 target of 2%. At the operator level, most large operators outperformed the basin average intensity by a wide margin, attributable to newer facilities, higher production, and active leak detection and repair programs indicating that facility design and operating practices are stronger drivers of emissions performance than geography, geology or regulatory environment.
- 26 October 2025
- Published by California Digital Library (CDL) in EarthArXiv
Open AccessAerial LiDAR Based, Source Resolved Methane Emissions Inventory: Permian Basin Case Study for Benchmarking U.S. Emissions
Reducing methane emissions is one of the quickest ways to slow near-term warming, yet building accurate inventories to track progress towards reduction targets remains challenging. We present a 2024 source-resolved methane inventory for the Permian Basin built from quarterly aerial LiDAR scans that supports benchmarking and provides a scalable framework for operator-level OGMP 2.0 reporting. We combined public infrastructure records with machine learning identification of non-producing sites to define the facility population and generate representative sampling plans, then deployed Bridger Photonics’ Gas Mapping LiDAR to scan 51,770 sites across four quarters. Sources were localized to within 2 m and attributed to equipment identified in aerial photography acquired during the scans. The instruments achieved an average 90% probability of detection at 1.16 kg/h under campaign field conditions. We detail a Monte Carlo framework that propagates quantification, extrapolation, sampling, and detection sensitivity uncertainty and weights spatial extrapolation by observed equipment counts, avoiding bias from over or under sampling of large facilities. The workflow yields a facility inventory comprehensive of source-level emission rates down to 0.4 kg/h. After adding gathering pipeline and sub-0.4 kg/h emissions estimates from prior studies, the basin total was 5,133 kt CH₄ (95% CI: 4,070–6,337 kt). Seasonal variation in emissions was observed, with winter up to 17% higher than summer. Non-producing facilities contributed 38% of facility emissions, and tanks (31%) and compressors (28%) dominated equipment-level totals. The basin-wide methane loss rate was 3.13%. Texas emitted 4,038 kt CH₄ with a 3.60% loss rate, while New Mexico emitted 1,095 kt CH₄ with a 2.10% loss rate, placing New Mexico near its 2026 target of 2%. At the operator level, most large operators outperformed the basin average intensity by a wide margin, attributable to newer facilities, higher production, and active leak detection and repair programs indicating that facility design and operating practices are stronger drivers of emissions performance than geography, geology or regulatory environment.
- Open Access
- 6 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 19 (8) , 2913-2933
Evaluating sensitivity of optical snow grain size retrievals to radiative transfer models, shape parameters, and inversion techniques
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability and Earth's energy budget toward future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt by means of optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage different retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors causes tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Toward enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine (1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape; (2) the best-performing radiative transfer model; and (3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation, with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6 %–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Toward a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9 %–26.2 %, depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improves, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- 6 August 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in The Cryosphere
- Vol. 19 (8) , 2913-2933
Open AccessEvaluating sensitivity of optical snow grain size retrievals to radiative transfer models, shape parameters, and inversion techniques
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability and Earth's energy budget toward future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt by means of optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage different retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors causes tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Toward enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine (1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape; (2) the best-performing radiative transfer model; and (3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation, with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6 %–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Toward a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9 %–26.2 %, depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improves, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- Open Access
- 8 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Reply on RC1
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- 8 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Open AccessReply on RC1
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- Open Access
- 8 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Reply on RC2
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- 8 February 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Open AccessReply on RC2
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- Open Access
- 14 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Comment on egusphere-2024-3141
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- 14 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3141
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- Open Access
- 2 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Comment on egusphere-2024-3141
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- 2 December 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-31
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-3141
The near-infrared (NIR) albedo of snow is controlled by optical snow grain size (ropt). Therefore, characterizing the spatial and temporal variability in ropt at the snow surface is critical for understanding melt timing and magnitude for water availability, and Earth’s energy budget towards future climates. While numerous studies have demonstrated estimates of ropt via optical instruments that span scales from in situ to satellites, they leverage differing retrieval techniques, radiative transfer models, and modeled snow grain shapes. Variation in these factors cause tremendous uncertainty in ropt retrievals, yet a thorough evaluation has yet to be conducted. To address this knowledge gap we conducted a laboratory bidirectional reflectance study, using NIR hyperspectral imaging (NIR-HSI) to retrieve grain size metrics for a wide variety of snow microstructures and evaluate them against micro-CT benchmarks. Towards enhanced ropt retrieval accuracy, we sought to determine 1) the optimal modeled snow grain shape, 2) the best-performing radiative transfer model, and 3) variability associated with retrieval techniques, spanning broadband, narrowband, multispectral, and hyperspectral approaches. Our results for optimizing grain shape parameters align with existing studies for the TARTES model, and we offer first recommendations for the SNICAR model. The retrieval technique also displayed considerable variation with the hyperspectral residual method performing best. Multispectral and single-band techniques were comparable to their hyperspectral counterparts at times, but this was attributed to the idealized laboratory conditions and high instrument signal-to-noise ratio. Following shape-optimization, the SNICAR and TARTES models produced the best results (median absolute error of 15.6–17.4 %, depending on technique), outperforming the AART model and the Random Mixture model. Towards a more direct comparison with albedo estimate error, we also evaluated the square root of ropt retrievals; median absolute error values ranged from 7.9–26.2 % depending on model and technique, with most pairings resulting in values < 15 %. Our results demonstrate that the accuracy of ropt retrievals is highly sensitive to the choice of retrieval technique, radiative transfer model, and grain shape parameters. To minimize error, each of these factors should be carefully selected in the context of the specific measurement. As NIR-HSI instruments and other NIR detectors become increasingly affordable and their resolution improve, the findings presented here provide guidance for improved ropt and snow albedo mapping across ground-based, aerial, and satellite platforms.
- Open Access
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in GIScience & Remote Sensing
- Vol. 61 (1)
Airborne lidar intensity correction for mapping snow cover extent and effective grain size in mountainous terrain
- 12 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in GIScience & Remote Sensing
- Vol. 61 (1)
Open AccessAirborne lidar intensity correction for mapping snow cover extent and effective grain size in mountainous terrain