CPClaire-France Picard

Claire-France Picard

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Claire-France Picard has a total of 7 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Secret professional deviance: the case of the independence rule

    by Claire-France Picard, Cynthia Courtois, Sylvain Durocher, Angélique Malo

    Purpose: This paper examines how rank-and-file practitioners react to and negotiate uniformized professional standards imposed by the elites of their profession in order to embody their professional ideal.Design/methodology/approach: We explore this topic through the specific case of the Canadian independence rule. We mobilize Freidson’s and Becker’s conceptual tools to make sense of our data, generated through 55 interviews with rank-and-file practitioners.Findings: We found that most rank-and-file practitioners override the (spirit of the) independence rule and engage in a process of secret deviance to pursue their professional ideal of accompanying their client in their business. Specifically, our analysis underlines how they find pleasure in fulfilling their professional ideal, seek to protect the secrecy that allows them to pursue this ideal while avoiding sanctions, and convince themselves of the morality of breaking the (spirit of the) rule in order to embody their conception of professionalism.Research limitations/implications: Our analysis expands fieldwork on rank-and-file practitioners by offering an analysis of struggles they experienced in their daily practice and by bringing to light their path to secret “professional” deviance.Practical implications: Our study points to the necessity for better consideration of the realities of professional segments when developing rules or standards.Originality/value: Our study develops a distinctive conceptual construct – the professionalism conception gap – to explain how secret “professional” deviance can unfold within a profession. This construct could be mobilized to further understand the divergences that can exist within broader professional spheres.

  • Auditors' sensemaking of other comprehensive income through metaphors

    by Sylvain Durocher, Claire-France Picard, Léa Dugal

    Purpose: This paper aims to examine how auditors make sense of the ill-theorized and contentious notion of other comprehensive income (OCI), specifically by uncovering their use of metaphors to make OCI plausible and intelligible.Design/methodology/approach: This interpretative paper draws on a collection of 21 interviews with experienced auditors. The analysis first uncovers metaphors that naturally surface within the talk and sensemaking of auditors about OCI (elicited metaphors). The authors then encapsulate these elicited metaphors into second-order constructs (projected metaphors) to synthesize and further explain auditors’ practical sensemaking.Findings: Auditors conceive OCI as a “safety” that ensures the well-functioning of fair value accounting, metaphorically qualifying this notion as a “necessary evil”, a “passage obligé”, and a “parking lot” resolving fair value-related issues and aberrations. Auditors also metaphorize OCI as a “purifier” that allows “polluted”, “noisy”, and “unloved” items to be “parked” outside net income.Practical implications: The study’s findings further the understanding of auditors’ tendency to remain uncritical throughout their sensemaking process. Making sense of professional standards of practice through metaphors indubitably involves shadowing and silencing other worldviews.Originality/value: This paper extends knowledge of auditors’ sensemaking, specifically showing how auditors easily make sense of complex notions even in the absence of conceptual grounds. This study also highlights that metaphors are a powerful sensemaking device that auditors mobilize to render complex notions intelligible and mitigate IFRS inconsistencies.


  • Non-accountants and Accounting: On the Emancipatory Mobilization of Accounting by Sustainability Managers

    by Michelle Rodrigue, Claire-France Picard

    Our study explores emancipatory manifestations of accounting through the experiences of sustainability managers. Specifically, drawing primarily on interviews with sustainability managers working in Canadian companies, it aims to better understand how they mobilize conventional accounting in their day-to-day activities in pursuit of socio-environmental progress. Informed by the pragmatist perspective on emancipation (Gallhofer & Haslam, 2003 Gallhofer, S. , & Haslam, J. (2003). Accounting and emancipation: Some critical interventions. Routledge. [Google Scholar] , 2019 Gallhofer, S. , & Haslam, J. (2019). Some reflections on the construct of emancipatory accounting: Shifting meaning and the possibilities of a new pragmatism. Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 63, 101975. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpa.2017.01.004 [Crossref], [Web of Science ®] , [Google Scholar] ), our analysis first reveals the global context in which our interviewees evolve and the aura of accounting therein. It then details how three local contextual dynamics shape the form, content, and usage of conventional accounting, making some accounting manifestations more emancipatory than others. Working in organizations receptive to sustainability initiatives, piloted by a small, resource-constrained department, seems to lead sustainability managers to generate more emancipatory progress in and through multiple forms, contents, and usages of accounting. The legitimacy of the sustainability department and the level of uncertainty experienced also play roles in the extent of progress reached. Through an empirical investigation, we contribute to a better understanding of accounting particularities shaping sustainability progress within organizations. Our study also offers valuable insights into the ways ‘non-accountants’ use accounting, therefore contributing to an understanding of how ‘peripheral’ business actors mobilize accounting to advance their sustainability agenda.


  • Desingularization and Dequalification: A Foray Into Ranking Production and Utilization Processes

    by Claire-France Picard, Sylvain Durocher, Yves Gendron

    Although some authors highlight the benefits of journal rankings, previous research is often highly critical of them, insinuating that they can lead to desingularization of academic journals (i.e. their impoverishment and standardization) and dequalification of researchers (i.e. a weakening of researchers’ ability to evaluate academic research). However, as very few authors have empirically assessed these presumptions, we aim to address this gap in the literature. Based on Lucien Karpik’s notions of singularities, judgment devices, forms of involvement, and emulation and rivalry, we assess whether the processes surrounding the production and use of journal rankings might lead to desingularization and dequalification. Our findings support previous research by highlighting that processes where passivity and heteronomy (i.e. lack of autonomy) prevail are conducive to desingularization, rivalry and dequalification. Our findings, however, introduce some nuances into the debate by underscoring instances where emulation logic is employed instead of mere rivalry logic, and where substantial judgment devices and active involvement are mobilized in the production and use of rankings, thereby somewhat alleviating the spread of desingularization and dequalification. Ultimately, our study raises questions that point to a need for serious collective reflection within the academic community on the processes by which published research is evaluated.