LSLiliia Shestak

Liliia Shestak

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Liliia Shestak has a total of 9 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • CERTAIN ISSUES OF ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSIBILITY FOR MILITARY ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES

    by N. Rybalka, L. Shestak, Chernihiv Penitentiary Academy Of Ukraine

    The article examines the issues of legal regulation of administrative responsibility for military personnel in Ukraine, particularly the innovations introduced in Chapter 13-B of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses (CUAO). The relevance of the topic is determined by legislative changes in response to contemporary challenges, especially during russia’s armed aggression against Ukraine. The authors analyze the problems arising in the process of holding military personnel administratively liable, including the uncertainty of the subject in relation to the offenses, difficulties in qualifying actions, and the insufficient clarity of legislative norms. The article identifies three groups of norms that regulate the administrative responsibility of military personnel, namely general principles, types of administrative offenses, and special provisions. The authors highlight issues related to the application of the law. Specifically, descriptions of military offenses are found not only in Chapter 13-B of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses (CUAO), but also in other chapters of the Code. The issue of the subject composition of many offenses remains unresolved, as the status of reservists, individuals undergoing alternative service, and those serving in territorial defense units is undefined. There are also difficulties in qualifying the relevant offenses, given the inconsistency of the terms “special period” and “martial law.” Furthermore, the majority of the types of administrative offenses specified in Chapter 13-B of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses (CUAO) can only be identified by leaders (commanders) of military units. This means that many of these offenses remain latent and do not lead to the imposition of any sanctions. The authors conclude that the regulation of administrative responsibility for military offenses is improper, requiring urgent resolution to enhance discipline and the rule of law in the Armed Forces of Ukraine. Key words: administrative responsibility, military personnel, reservist, liable for military service, sanctions, punishment, violation of rules.

  • SPECIFIC ISSUES OF ADMINISTRATIVE LIABILITY FOR ILLEGAL TRANSFER OF PROHIBITED ITEMS TO INDIVIDUALS HELD IN PRE-TRIAL DETENTION CENTERS AND CORRECTIONAL INSTITUTIONS (ARTICLE 188 OF THE СODE OF UKRAINE ON ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES)

    by Chernihiv Penitentiary Academy Of Ukraine, L. Shestak

    The article addresses the need for amendments and supplements to Article 188 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses, which stipulates administrative liability for the illegal transfer of prohibited items to individuals in pre-trial detention centers and correctional institutions. The author proposes a more detailed definition of the list of prohibited items, differentiation of administrative liability under this norm, and the application of stricter sanctions against employees of correctional institutions, as well as the removal of warnings from the sanctions. Additionally, it is suggested to supplement this norm with provisions that would strengthen responsibility for repeated offenses within a year or for committing unlawful acts during martial law. Ensuring the effectiveness of the practical application of this norm requires increasing the amount of fines and adding to the list of penalties a prohibition on holding certain positions or engaging in specific types of activities. The type and severity of punishment should depend on the quantity, quality, and type of prohibited items that were illegally transferred into places of incarceration. The author also suggests including a note to Article 188 of the Code that refers to the regulatory act defining the list of items prohibited for transfer into places of incarceration. Furthermore, it is appropriate to establish a system of measures aimed at detecting and proving facts of illegal transfer of prohibited items to the relevant institutions. The author presents their own version of the content of Article 188 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses. Keywords: administrative liability, administrative offense, illegal transfer, prohibited items, subject, correctional institution, places of incarceration, detention centre.

  • ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF USING MEDIATION IN CASES OF ADMINISTRATIVE OFFENSES

    by Chernihiv Penitentiary Academy Of Ukraine, S. Nishchymna, L. Shestak

    The article explores the problems of legal regulation of the use of mediation as an alternative to judicial consideration of cases of administrative offenses. The advantages of mediation are considered, including regulation at the legislative level, effectiveness in European countries, the absence of shortcomings of judicial review, equality of parties, the possibility of agreeing on the terms of implementation of agreements, the absence of judicial and other costs, and the preservation of partnership relations between the parties. The authors also identified categories of cases in which the use of mediation is complicated or inadmissible (corruption offenses, offenses that harm state interests, the interests of minors, environmental offenses). The authors propose criteria for determining administrative cases, the consideration of which in the order of application of mediation is possible (petty hooliganism, violation of the rules of keeping animals, traffic accidents). The authors defend the position on the importance of voluntary participation in mediation and the inadmissibility of the use of coercion, since this condition negates the expediency of the use of mediation and its legal consequences. The article also considers the shortcomings of mediation, such as the possibility of delaying the process and the lack of procedural guarantees for the implementation of agreements. It is proposed to supplement Article 38 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses with Part 9, which provides for the suspension of the terms of imposing an administrative penalty for the duration of mediation and ensures the implementation of agreements through a court decision. The problem of an insufficient number of qualified mediators and the need to create an open register of mediators are emphasized. Amendments to Article 249 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses are proposed to ensure the confidentiality of mediation. The conclusion is made about the need to define categories of cases where mediation is impossible, to establish legislative frameworks for authorities, to ensure the implementation of agreements and to suspend the terms of imposing penalties for the duration of mediation. Keywords: administrative offense, administrative proceedings, mediation, mediator, confidentiality.

  • ADMINISTRATIVE LIABILITY FOR VIOLATION OF ADMINISTRATIVE SUPERVISION RULES

    by Chernihiv Penitentiary Academy Of Ukraine, L. Shestak

    The article examines current issues of administrative liability for violations of administrative supervision rules in Ukraine. The author analyzes problems related to the ineffectiveness of the existing legal regulation. In particular, it is noted that virtually every provision of Article 187 of the Code requires clarification. The author points out the ineffectiveness of the fines prescribed by this norm, as their amount is very low and has not been revised for almost 10 years. The position is advocated for the appropriateness of supplementing sanctions with types of punishment such as community service and socially useful work. Given that individuals under administrative supervision are subject to certain restrictions, the necessity of defining the specifics of the implementation of such restrictions in conditions of martial law and state of emergency is also proven. The author indicates the impracticality of applying administrative supervision to individuals sentenced to life imprisonment. Most characteristics of administrative supervision (temporariness, release from places of deprivation of liberty, etc.) are not typical for these subjects. Accordingly, administrative supervision over such individuals cannot be established. When addressing the issue of applying measures of administrative liability under Article 187 of the Code, it is important to establish the causes and motives for violations of administrative supervision rules and to ensure that they did not arise as a result of unforeseen circumstances or other emergencies. Ways to improve administrative liability for violations of administrative supervision rules are proposed. In particular, it is necessary to align the provisions of Part 1 of Article 187 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses with the provisions of Article 10 of the Law of Ukraine “On Administrative Supervision of Persons Released from Places of Deprivation of Liberty” to foresee the possibility of holding individuals administratively liable for all manifestations of violations of restrictions on the actions of those under supervision. It is also advisable to increase the amount of fines and introduce alternative types of punishment. Keywords: administrative supervision, administrative responsibility, punishment, sanction, fine, violation of rules.

  • INDIVIDUAL PROBLEMS OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE AND LEGAL QUALIFICATION OF OFFENSES RELATED TO CORRUPTION

    by Chernihiv Penitentiary Academy Of Ukraine, V. Puzyrnyi, L. Shestak

    The article analyzes the problems that arise in the process of administrative and legal qualification of offenses related to corruption, the responsibility for which is established by the provisions of Chapter 13-A of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses. The authors defend the idea that the correct and complete qualification can be carried out only when the presence of all the elements of the misdemeanor is proven, the circumstances that mitigate and/or aggravate the responsibility are determined, and the presence of optional elements of an administrative offense of the objective or subjective side is proven, the absence of circumstances that exempt from administrative responsibility or may indicate the insignificance of the act is proven. The authors outline a range of problems, the presence of which complicates the process of legal qualification. These include: the lack of a clear formulation of the objective side of an administrative offense related to corruption; the presence of a large number of notes to the norms of chapter 13-A, which define the subjects of specific administrative offenses or contain definitions that determine the specifics of the manifestation of the objective side of the act; lack of clear wording of the composition of administrative offenses related to corruption and their distinction from corruption manifestations that are not prosecuted in an administrative manner; the difficulty of applying the sign of repeated offense commission related to corruption; unresolved issue of the expediency of applying the provisions of Art. 22 of the Code of Administrative Offenses “Possibility of exemption from administrative liability in case of minor offense”; the difficulty of proving the presence of selfish and other motives in those cases where their obligation is presumed. The authors come to the conclusion that the quality of legal qualifications determines the correctness of the legal assessment of a specific administrative offense and allows the application of a fair punishment that would correspond to the severity of the offense and the damage that was or could be caused by a corrupt administrative act. Key words: administrative offense, administrative-legal qualification, responsibility, offense related to corruption, qualification problems.


  • Open Access

    Individual issues of legal regulation of administrative liability for offenses that undermine the established order of governance

    by L. V. Shestak, O. V. Seletskyi

    The article addresses the issues of legal regulation of administrative liability for offenses that undermine the established order of governance. The authors analyze the peculiarities of normative fixation of administrative offenses provided for in Chapter 15 of the Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offenses and point out the inconsistency of certain provisions of the Code with modern conditions, including wartime. According to the authors, this fosters a sense of impunity among offenders and a sense of helplessness among law enforcement officials in the face of the «letter of the law.» Analyzing the features of administrative offenses that affect established management procedures allows drawing conclusions about the multitude of special subjects for violations within the named group, as well as the diversity of manifestations of the subjective aspect. This is associated with the creation of new institutions (Bureau of Economic Security, State Special Communications Service and Information Protection of Ukraine, among others), as well as the expediency of legal protection of relationships that have emerged relatively recently (such as personal data protection). Despite the importance of applying measures of administrative liability for violations affecting established management procedures, there are numerous shortcomings in the legal regulation of such liability. Among these shortcomings, the following should be highlighted: disproportionality of sanctions to the severity of the offense committed, obsolescence of certain provisions, impossibility of holding accountable individuals who are not citizens of Ukraine; a significant number of offense elements, the qualification of which requires studying special regulatory acts, impossibility of holding minors accountable on general grounds; lack of administrative liability for violations of curfew and failure to observe blackout measures during a state of war, and so on.


  • Open Access

    Theoretical and legal approaches regarding the administrative activities of the public authority in safeguarding rights of persons with disabilities

    by Vitalii Kondratenko, Kostyantun Fomichov, Liliia Bobrishova, Oleksii Seletskyi, Liliia Shestak

    The purpose of the scientific research was to examine the essence and content of the modern human-centered concept in the theoretical-applied interpretation of management activities of state authorities, in connection with the implementation and protection of fundamental rights and freedoms of persons with systemic disorders of body function. The following research methods were used in the scientific work: systematization, generalization; analysis and synthesis of the developed ideas. Definitely, it is substantiated that significant reform changes in the system of state authorities of Ukraine and changes in the direction of their activities somehow mean the creation of conditions for the construction of a democratic, social and legal state, as well as the guarantee of subjective rights, in particular of persons with disabilities. The conclusions argue the priority of the formation of administrative and legal doctrine, built on the basis of a humanistic ideology that permeates the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities in the daily life of society as a whole.

  • Open Access

    Problems of legislative payment regulation for the administrative services provision

    by L.V. Shestak, V.V. Prysiazhnyi

    The provision of administrative services is the responsibility of the state. Its proper execution promotes ensuring the realization of the rights and freedoms of citizens, the fulfilment of the powers of state bodies. However, not all administrative services can be provided free of charge. Some of them are paid. The issue of the grounds and conditions of payment for administrative services provided by the state is the subject of scientific research of this article. The authors review the draft law «On Administrative Fees», as well as the provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On Administrative Services» and conclude that it is inexpedient to increase the array of regulations. The authors propose to determine the range of persons who may be exempt from paying the administrative fee, point to the need to improve digital infrastructure and material security of the population; substantiate the expediency of determining the amount of payment for the cost of administrative services not in a fixed amount, but based on the size of variable indicators (minimum wage or subsistence level). The authors consider it expedient to determine the basis for determining the administrative fee, its components, conditions, and cases of collecting the increased administrative fee, periodicity, and grounds for changing its size within certain provisions of the Law of Ukraine «On Administrative Services» and not to adopt new regulations. After all, this Law is the basic document. Within its limits, it is appropriate to provide for the procedure for distribution and use of funds received by the subjects of provision, as payment for services rendered. Such a policy of financial interest will keep the quality of administrative services at the appropriate level and ensure their provision in the short term, which will strengthen the financial stability of the territory.