JMJil Molenaar

Jil Molenaar

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Jil Molenaar has a total of 34 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Between caring and counting : maternal and newborn health data from Tanzanian maternity wards to global indicators

    by Jil Molenaar

    The measurement agenda in maternal and newborn health (MNH) has expanded from mortality rates, to service coverage, to quality of care. Routine health information systems (RHIS) in low- and middle-income countries are being strengthened, promising more timely, granular data than surveys. MNH data are produced through an assembly line of human decisions, reflecting and shaping how care is provided and accounted for. This thesis examines how global MNH measurement priorities translate into practice in Tanzania and internationally. The thesis comprises five papers across three streams of inquiry: a qualitative systematic review (Paper 1) of how MNH data requirements are experienced in low- and lower-middle-income countries; qualitative fieldwork in Tanzania (Papers 2-4), comprising ethnographic observations and 29 interviews with healthcare workers, hospital leadership, and district/regional managers in Mtwara region, plus 17 follow-up interviews with regional and national stakeholders; and an international stream (Paper 5) of observations and 24 interviews on how global actors understand indicator standardisation and prioritisation. The systematic review (Paper 1) found MNH data collection and use shaped by 'system hardware' and 'system software' conditions, with misalignment fostering fear, blame, and manipulation. A study of a perinatal eRegistry in two Tanzanian hospitals (Paper 2) linked data practices to systemic constraints and to data ownership: workers' sense of responsibility for the data they produced. An analysis of power dynamics (Paper 3) distinguished top-down authoritative power, exercised via targets and reporting, from bottom-up discretionary power, as HCWs manipulated data to protect themselves and colleagues. Across Tanzanian health system levels (Paper 4), routine data offered only a 'partial picture' of quality of care, capturing care processes and patient experience to a limited extent. At the international level (Paper 5), an appetite for comprehensive measurement and upward accountability drove indicator proliferation and limited local relevance. Interviewees proposed indicator menus tailored to country priorities as a step toward flexibility. This thesis shows that MNH data can drive prioritisation, support clinical decision-making, and motivate HCWs, but that this potential is undermined when information systems are designed to extract data upward rather than serve those closest to care. The thesis points toward subsidiarity as a guiding principle for reorientation: knowledge should be generated and held by those closest to the phenomenon it concerns. For RHIS, this means treating health facilities as primary units, investing in non-standardisable, place-based measurement, and embedding feedback loops, with no data collection without equivalent investment in its use.

  • Open Access

    Indicator menus: Intentional reorientation in global maternal and neonatal health measurement

    by Jil Molenaar, Aliki Christou, Lenka Beňová, Andrea B. Pembe, Isabelle L. Lange, Josefien van Olmen

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    The richness of urban health realities lost in measurement monocultures

    by Jil Molenaar, Lenka Beňová, Seye Abimbola, Onikepe Owolabi, Grégoire Lurton, Peter M Macharia


  • Open Access

    Partial pictures: what routine health data can and cannot tell us about the quality of maternal and neonatal health services in Tanzania

    by Jil Molenaar, Amani Kikula, Zamoyoni Julius, Claudia Hanson, Josefien van Olmen, Andrea Barnabas Pembe, Lenka Beňová

    Measurement of contact coverage of maternal and newborn health services may overestimate the benefits of the care that is provided, because the quality of care is not captured. It is therefore important to better understand the opportunities and challenges of capturing elements of care quality in routine health information systems (RHIS). This study explored healthcare workers’ (HCWs), health sector managers’ and policymakers’ perspectives on the value and limits of routine health data to understand the quality of maternal and neonatal health services in Tanzania. We conducted qualitative research during two periods to capture perspectives across facility, district, regional and national levels. In Mtwara region in 2023, we conducted ethnographic observations at two hospital labour wards and 29 in-depth interviews with healthcare workers, hospital leaders, and district/regional managers. In 2025, we carried out 17 additional interviews with regional managers in Mtwara and with key national-level stakeholders. Our findings demonstrate that Tanzania’s RHIS provides a valuable but partial picture of quality of care for maternal and neonatal health services. Care processes—including both provision and experience of care—are captured only to a limited extent. Using boundary object theory, we highlight how the same health information must serve diverse stakeholder needs. While there are opportunities to integrate more quality-of-care indicators, standardized RHIS cannot be expected to comprehensively capture the multifaceted nature of care quality. For quality measurement to support meaningful local health service improvement, a flexible, bottom-up approach is essential. However, the current emphasis on top-down oversight acts as a barrier for local-level data use. Relevant and feasible measurement of the quality of facility-based care requires a fundamental shift in current RHIS priorities—from systems that extract data for those ‘up there’ to platforms that also create value for those who provide care.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Beyond the Demographic and Health Survey: on the past and future of population health surveillance

    by John Nott, Blessings Kaunda-Khangamwa, Don P Mathanga, Jil Molenaar, Bertrand Taithe, Chimwemwe Phiri, Jesman Chintsanya, Alister Munthali


  • Open Access

    “We have theoretical knowledge, but these are not things we do regularly”: District hospital’s healthcare workers’ experiences and perceptions on gestational diabetes mellitus screening in Tanzania

    by Amani Kikula, Lenka Beňová, Jil Molenaar, Catherine Birabwa, Kaushik Ramaiya, José L. Peñalvo, Andrea B. Pembe, Nathanael Sirili

    Screening for gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) during antenatal care (ANC) is crucial for maternal and fetal health. It offers an opportunity for prevention, timely diagnosis, and treatment of cardiometabolic complications during pregnancy and over women’s and babies’ life course. We aimed to describe GDM screening service provision during ANC in two hospitals in Tanzania, focusing on gaps and opportunities for improving GDM screening services in hospitals. We employed a case-study design, with seven rounds of structured observation, two focus group discussions, and eight semi-structured in-depth interviews with healthcare workers (HCWs) from two primary healthcare level hospitals between January and April 2024. Observation notes, interviews, and discussions were audio recorded, transcribed, and analyzed using qualitative content analysis. We present our findings using three categories to describe the GDM screening services: 1) no GDM screening services were provided - screening for GDM was not conducted according to any existing national guidelines. 2) Reasons for unavailability of GDM screening services - there was inadequate support for GDM screening services at the hospitals: no continuous learning opportunities for HCWs on GDM screening, a shortage of screening supplies, and the hospitals did not prioritize GDM screening services. 3) Opportunities for improving GDM screening services - the inclusion of GDM in the structural and administrative agenda of the hospitals was deemed important to provide quality screening for GDM. There was a discrepancy between guidelines and actual GDM screening services at the hospitals studied. To provide GDM screening services per the available national guidelines, HCWs should be trained and supported with supplies for providing GDM screening services.


  • Open Access

    Getting the numbers right: Power, creativity and ‘good’ routine maternal and neonatal health data in Southern Tanzania

    by Jil Molenaar, Amani Kikula, Josefien van Olmen, Andrea Pembe, Lenka Beňová


  • Open Access

    Data for whom? Experiences and perceptions of a perinatal eRegistry in two hospitals in Mtwara region, Tanzania

    by Jil Molenaar, Amani Kikula, Yusufu Kionga, Hassan Tearish Berenge, Lenka Benova, Josefien van Olmen, Claudia Hanson, Muzdalifat Abeid, Andrea Barnabas Pembe

    Introduction Digital data systems have the potential to improve data quality and provide individual-level information to understand gaps in the quality of care. This study explored experiences and perceptions of a perinatal eRegistry in two hospitals in Mtwara region, Tanzania. Drawing from realist evaluation and systems thinking, we go beyond a descriptive account of stakeholders’ experiences and provide insight into key structural drivers and underlying social paradigms. Methods We carried out 6 weeks of focused ethnographic observations at the labour wards of the two hospitals and 29 semi-structured qualitative interviews with labour ward staff, as well as with administrative and managerial stakeholders at hospital, district and regional levels. Multi-stage reflexive thematic data analysis was carried out. Results We provide an in-depth account of the day-to-day functioning of the eRegistry in the two hospitals, including both aspects of positive change and key challenges with its integration into routine documentation duties. Experiences with and perceptions of the eRegistry were inextricably linked to broader systemic constraints relating to staffing, workload and infrastructure. A key underlying theme shaping the way people engaged with the eRegistry was the notion of data ownership: the presence or absence of a feeling of being responsible, involved and in control of data. Conclusion Some of the key systemic challenges in recording accurate, timely information about women and their babies are not solved by digital tools. Our findings also underline that when healthcare workers feel that data are not primarily for them, they document only for reporting purposes. The eRegistry increased a sense of data ownership among the nurse-midwives directly involved with data entry, but the potential for promoting and supporting data use feedback loops for improvement in care provision remained largely untapped. Our findings highlight the importance of local relevance and ownership in digitisation of routine health information systems.