Ivan J. Cohen

Response to immunotherapy across multiple cancer types is approximately 25%, with some tumor types showing increased response rates compared to others (i.e. response rates in melanoma and non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) are typically 30-60%). Patients whose tumors are resistant to immunotherapy often lack high levels of pre-existing inflammation in the tumor microenvironment. Increased tumor glycolysis, acting through glucose deprivation and lactic acid accumulation, has been shown to have pleiotropic immune suppressive effects using in-vitro and in-vivo models of disease. To determine whether the immune suppressive effect of tumor glycolysis is observed across human solid tumors, we analyzed glycolytic and immune gene expression patterns in multiple solid malignancies. We found that increased expression of a glycolytic signature was associated with decreased immune infiltration and a more aggressive disease across multiple tumor types. Radiologic and pathologic analysis of untreated estrogen receptor (ER)-negative breast cancers corroborated these observations, and demonstrated that protein expression of glycolytic enzymes correlates positively with glucose uptake and negatively with infiltration of CD3⁺ and CD8⁺ lymphocytes. This study reveals an inverse relationship between tumor glycolysis and immune infiltration in a large cohort of multiple solid tumor types.

The effects of the LDH-A depletion via shRNA knockdown on three murine glioma cell lines and corresponding intracranial (i.c.) tumors were studied and compared to pharmacologic (GNE-R-140) inhibition of the LDH enzyme complex, and to shRNA scrambled control (NC) cell lines. The effects of genetic-shRNA LDH-A knockdown and LDH drug-targeted inhibition (GNE-R-140) on tumor-cell metabolism, tumor growth, and animal survival were similar. LDH-A KD and GNE-R-140 unexpectedly increased the aggressiveness of GL261 intracranial gliomas, but not CT2A and ALTS1C1 i.c. gliomas. Furthermore, the bioenergetic profiles (ECAR and OCR) of GL261 NC and LDH-A KD cells under different nutrient limitations showed that (a) exogenous pyruvate is not a major carbon source for metabolism through the TCA cycle of native GL261 cells; and (b) the unique upregulation of LDH-B that occurs in GL261 LDH-A KD cells results in these cells being better able to: (i) metabolize lactate as a primary carbon source through the TCA cycle, (ii) be a net consumer of lactate, and (iii) showed a significant increase in the proliferation rate following the addition of 10 mM lactate to the glucose-free media (only seen in GL261 KD cells). Our study suggests that inhibition of LDH-A/glycolysis may not be a general strategy to inhibit the i.c. growth of all gliomas, since the level of LDH-A expression and its interplay with LDH-B can lead to complex metabolic interactions between tumor cells and their environment. Metabolic-inhibition treatment strategies need to be carefully assessed, since the inhibition of glycolysis (e.g., inhibition of LDH-A) may lead to the unexpected development and activation of alternative metabolic pathways (e.g., upregulation of lipid metabolism and fatty-acid oxidation pathways), resulting in enhanced tumor-cell survival in a nutrient-limited environment and leading to increased tumor aggressiveness.

Three murine glioma cell lines (GL261, CT2A, and ALTS1C1) were modified to downregulate the expression of the murine LDH-A gene using shRNA, and compared to shRNA scrambled control (NC) cell lines. Differences in the expression of LDH-A and LDH-B mRNA, protein and enzymatic activity, as well as their LDH isoenzyme profiles, were observed in the six cell lines, and confirmed successful LDH-A KD. LDH-A KD (knock-down) resulted in metabolic changes in cells with a reduction in glycolysis (GlycoPER) and an increase in basal respiratory rate (mitoOCR). GL261 cells had a more limited ATP production capacity compared to CT2A and ALTS1C1 cells. An analysis of mRNA expression data indicated that: (i) GL261 LDH-A KD cells may have an improved ability to metabolize lactate into the TCA cycle; and (ii) that GL261 LDH-A KD cells can upregulate lipid metabolism/fatty acid oxidation pathways, whereas the other glioma cell lines do not have this capacity. These two observations suggest that GL261 LDH-A KD cells can develop/activate alternative metabolic pathways for enhanced survival in a nutrient-limited environment, and that specific nutrient limitations have a variable impact on tumor cell metabolism and proliferation. The phenotypic effects of LDH-A KD were compared to those in control (NC) cells and tumors. LDH-A KD prolonged the doubling time of GL261 cells in culture and prevented the formation of subcutaneous flank tumors in immune-competent C57BL/6 mice, whereas GL261 NC tumors had a prolonged growth delay in C57BL/6 mice. In nude mice, both LDH-A KD and NC GL261 tumors grew rapidly (more rapidly than GL261 NC tumors in C57BL/6 mice), demonstrating the impact of an intact immune system on GL261 tumor growth. No differences between NC and KD cell proliferation (in vitro) or tumor growth in C57BL/6 mice (doubling time) were observed for CT2A and ALTS1C1 cells and tumors, despite the small changes to their LDH isoenzyme profiles. These results suggest that GL261 glioma cells (but not CT2A and ALTS1C1 cells) are pre-programmed to have the capacity for activating different metabolic pathways with higher TCA cycle activity, and that this capacity is enhanced by LDH-A depletion. We observed that the combined impact of LDH-A depletion and the immune system had a significant impact on the growth of subcutaneous-located GL261 tumors.